Cofactor regeneration; i.e., regiospecific conversion of NAD
+ to 1,4-NADH, has been extensively studied and isa crucial component in the eventual use of 1,4-NADH in a variety of bioorganic synthesis processes involvingthe formation of chiral organic compounds. We have studied the reduction of a model NAD
+ compound,1-benzylnicotinamide triflate,
1a, using [Cp*Rh(bpy)(H
2O)]
2+,
2 (Cp* =
5-C
5Me
5, bpy = 2,2'-bipyridyl), as thecatalyst precursor and sodium formate (HCO
2Na) as the hydride source in 1:1 H
2O/THF and have found exclusive1-benzyl-1,4-dihydronicotinamide regioselectivity, as was observed previously for natural NAD
+ that provided1,4-NADH (see: Steckhan et al.
Organometallics 1991,
10, 1568). Moreover, a variety of 3-substituted derivativesof 1-benzylpyridinium triflate, in addition to the -C(O)NH
2 group (
1a), were also studied to ascertain that this3-functionality (e.g., -C(O)NHCH
3, -C(S)NH
2, -C(O)CH
3, -C(O)OCH
3, and -CN,
1b,d-g) coordinates to a[Cp*Rh(bpy)H]
+ complex to direct the concerted, regioselective transfer of the hydride group from the rhodiumto the 4-ring position of the NAD
+ model; all coordinating 3-substituents had relative rates in the 0.9-1.3 rangewith substrate
1a set to 1.0. If in fact the 3-substituent presented a steric effect [-C(O)NH(CH
2CH
3)
2,
1c] or wasa nonbinding group (-CH
3,
1h; -H,
1i), no catalytic hydride transfer was observed even with the more electrophilic2 and 6 ring positions being readily available, which further implicated the crucial coordination of the NAD
+model to the Cp*Rh metal ion center. We also found that the 1-benzyl substituent on the nitrogen atom exerteda substantial electron-withdrawing effect, in comparison to the electron-donating 1-methyl substituent, and favorablyaffected the rate of the regioselective reduction (rate enhancement of 1-benzyl/1-methyl = 2.0). The kinetics ofthe regioselective reduction of
1a were studied to show that the initial rate of reduction,
ri, is affected by theconcentrations of the substrate,
1a, precatalyst,
2, and the hydride source, HCO
2Na, in 1:1 H
2O/THF: d[1-benzyl-1,4-dihydronicotnamide]/d
t =
kcat[
1a][
2][HCO
2Na]. Furthermore, we wish to demonstrate that a previouslysynthesized aqueous NAD
+ model,
-nicotinamide ribose-5'-methyl phosphate,
3, shows a similar regioselectivityfor the 1,4-NADH analogue, while the initial rate (
ri) for the regioselective reduction of
3 and NAD
+ itself wasfound to be comparable in water but faster by a factor of ~3 in comparison to
1a in 1:1 H
2O/THF; the solvent,THF, appeared to inhibit the rate of reduction in
1a by presumably competing with the substrate
1a for theCp*Rh metal ion center. However, in H
2O, the initial kinetic rate for substrate
3 was not affected by its concentrationand implies that, in H
2O, [Cp*Rh(bpy)H]
+ formation is rate determining. We assume that binding of
3 and NAD
+to the Cp*Rh metal ion center is also a pertinent step for 1,4-dihydro product formation, the experimental rateexpression in H
2O being d[1,4-dihydro-
-nicotinamide ribose-5'-methyl phosphate]/d
t =
kcat[
2][HCO
2Na]. Whatwe have discovered, for the first time, is evidence that the regioselective reduction of NAD
+ to 1,4-NADH by[Cp*Rh(bpy)H]
+ is a consequence of the amide's ability to coordinate to the Cp*Rh metal center, therebyconstricting the kinetically favorable six-membered ring transition state for plausible concerted hydride transfer/insertion to C4 to regioselectively provide the 1,4-NADH derivative; [Cp*Rh(bpy)H]
+ can be categorized as abiomimetic enzymatic hydride via its ability to bind and regioselectively transfer hydride to C4, exclusively.Clearly, the pyrophosphate and adenosine groups associated with the structure of NAD
+ are not essential in therate of hydride transfer to C4, with NAD
+ model
3 having a similar initial rate (
ri) of reduction as NAD
+ itselfin water. Finally, a catalytic cycle will be proposed to account for our overall observations.