中法战争后两广边防善后与刘永福位置问题
|
摘要
中法战争后,入越作战清军陆续撤兵回界,筹办边防善后成为当务之急,如何妥当安置边员却令边省大吏颇感棘手。原本两广总督张之洞拟以苏元春、冯子材、唐景崧三人为核心构建战后两广边防体系,另以刘永福驻扎边界或边外牵制法军,无奈各员思虑不尽一致。刘永福的位置尤令清政府踌躇不定,最终只得匆匆将其内迁。张之洞兼顾两广的边防布局至此基本落空,遗留下的以督办大臣办理边防的局面,则成为战后二十年间粤越、桂越边务筹办的基本格局。
It was imperative to organize the border defense when the combat troops of the Qing government withdrew after the Sino-French war,but the resettlement officials had made frontier official prickly. Zhang Zhidong who was Governor-General of Guangdong and Guangxi originally planned to build the frontier defense system from Guangdong and Guangxi with the core of Su Yunchun,Feng Zicai and Tang Jingsong,but the various people though inconsistencies.In addition,Liu Yongfu had planned to be stationed at the border or outside to contain the French which was particularly dithering on the Qing government. The border arrangement of Zhang Zhidong failed to materialize in the end,but the pattern of the Sino-Vietnamese border affairs was formed.
It was imperative to organize the border defense when the combat troops of the Qing government withdrew after the Sino-French war,but the resettlement officials had made frontier official prickly. Zhang Zhidong who was Governor-General of Guangdong and Guangxi originally planned to build the frontier defense system from Guangdong and Guangxi with the core of Su Yunchun,Feng Zicai and Tang Jingsong,but the various people though inconsistencies.In addition,Liu Yongfu had planned to be stationed at the border or outside to contain the French which was particularly dithering on the Qing government. The border arrangement of Zhang Zhidong failed to materialize in the end,but the pattern of the Sino-Vietnamese border affairs was formed.
引文
[1]中国第一历史档案馆.清代军机处电报档汇编:第1册[Z].北京:中国人民大学出版社,2005:130.
[2]张文襄公(未刊)电稿[M].北京:全国图书馆缩微复制中心,2005.
[3]唐景崧.请缨日记[M]∥沈云龙.近代中国史料丛刊(正编):第5辑.台北:文海出版社,1971.
[4]苑书义,孙华峰,李秉新.张之洞全集[M].石家庄:河北人民出版社,1998.
[5]清实录:第57册[M].北京:中华书局,1987:106.
[6]郭廷以主编.中法越南交涉档:第5册[M].台北:精华印书馆股份有限公司,1962.
[7]中越勘界往来电稿[M]∥萧德浩,吴国强.邓承修勘界资料汇编.南宁:广西人民出版社,1990:18.
[8]吴剑杰.张之洞年谱长编(上卷)[M].上海:上海交通大学出版社,2009.
[9]故宫博物院档案馆.中法越南交涉资料[M]∥中国史学会.中法战争:第6册.上海:上海人民出版社,1957:436.
[10]李绍雄.广西边防[M].桂林:广西史地学社,1946:1.
[2]张文襄公(未刊)电稿[M].北京:全国图书馆缩微复制中心,2005.
[3]唐景崧.请缨日记[M]∥沈云龙.近代中国史料丛刊(正编):第5辑.台北:文海出版社,1971.
[4]苑书义,孙华峰,李秉新.张之洞全集[M].石家庄:河北人民出版社,1998.
[5]清实录:第57册[M].北京:中华书局,1987:106.
[6]郭廷以主编.中法越南交涉档:第5册[M].台北:精华印书馆股份有限公司,1962.
[7]中越勘界往来电稿[M]∥萧德浩,吴国强.邓承修勘界资料汇编.南宁:广西人民出版社,1990:18.
[8]吴剑杰.张之洞年谱长编(上卷)[M].上海:上海交通大学出版社,2009.
[9]故宫博物院档案馆.中法越南交涉资料[M]∥中国史学会.中法战争:第6册.上海:上海人民出版社,1957:436.
[10]李绍雄.广西边防[M].桂林:广西史地学社,1946:1.