城市能源代谢生态网络分析研究进展
|
摘要
运用生态网络分析方法研究城市能源代谢可以打破以往研究中的"黑箱模式",有助于考察城市内部能源的代谢过程和代谢路径。对研究城市能源代谢的一般方法进行了分析和对比,发现在探究城市能源代谢方面,生态网络分析相较于其他方法更具优越性;因此,全面整理和阐述了生态网络分析方法的主要内容,并系统综述了该方法在城市能源代谢中的应用。在此基础之上,指出在未来城市能源代谢的生态网络分析中应从研究尺度、上升性分析和环境元分析的结合应用以及增加不同模型精细度的对比研究3个方面做出改进。
Ecological network analysis can eliminate the "black box" problem in research on urban energy systems by examining the metabolic processes and pathways within these systems. This study analyzed and compared the general methods for analyzing urban energy metabolism and found that ecological network analysis was superior to other methods. We comprehensively summarized the main components of the ecological network analysis and systematically reviewed the application of this method to urban energy metabolism. Based on this analysis, we concluded that, in the future, ecological network analyses of urban energy metabolism could be improved in the following aspects:(1) expand the research scale;(2) strengthen the combination of ascendency analysis and network environ analysis;(3) compare the precision of different models.
Ecological network analysis can eliminate the "black box" problem in research on urban energy systems by examining the metabolic processes and pathways within these systems. This study analyzed and compared the general methods for analyzing urban energy metabolism and found that ecological network analysis was superior to other methods. We comprehensively summarized the main components of the ecological network analysis and systematically reviewed the application of this method to urban energy metabolism. Based on this analysis, we concluded that, in the future, ecological network analyses of urban energy metabolism could be improved in the following aspects:(1) expand the research scale;(2) strengthen the combination of ascendency analysis and network environ analysis;(3) compare the precision of different models.
引文
[1] 赵颜创,赵小锋,林剑艺,崔胜辉.厦门市城市能源代谢综合分析方法及应用.生态科学,2016,35(5):110- 116.
[2] Su M R,Fath B D,Yang Z F.Urban ecosystem health assessment:a review.Science of the Total Environment,2010,408(12):2425- 2434.
[3] Jones N F,Pejchar L,Kiesecker J M.The energy footprint:how oil,natural gas,and wind energy affect land for biodiversity and the flow of ecosystem services.Bioscience,2015,65(3):290- 301.
[4] Su M R,Zhang Y,Liu G Y,Xu L Y,Zhang L X,Yang Z F.Urban ecosystem health assessment:perspectives and Chinese practice.International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health,2013,10(11):5874- 5885.
[5] Zeng H,Ellis C S,Lebeck A R,Vahdat A.ECOSystem:managing energy as a first class operating system resource.ACM Sigops Operating Systems Review,2002,36(5):123- 132.
[6] Wolman A.The metabolism of cities.Scientific American,1965,213:179- 190.
[7] Newman P W G.Sustainability and cities:extending the metabolism model.Landscape and Urban Planning,1999,44(4):219- 226.
[8] Warren-Rhodes K,Koenig A.Escalating trends in the urban metabolism of Hong Kong:1971- 1997.Ambio,2001,30(7):429- 438.
[9] Kennedy C,Cuddihy J,Engel-Yan J.The changing metabolism of cities.Journal of Industrial Ecology,2007,11(2):43- 59.
[10] Huang H P,Bi J,Li X M,Zhang B,Yang J.Material flow analysis (MFA) of an eco-economic system:a case study of Wujin District,Changzhou,China.Frontiers of Biology in China,2008,3(3):367- 374.
[11] 宋涛,蔡建明,杜姗姗,倪攀,丁悦.基于能值分析的北京城市新陈代谢研究.干旱区资源与环境,2015,29(1):37- 42.
[12] Zhang Y,Zheng H M,Fath B D,Liu H,Yang Z F,Liu G Y,Su M R.Ecological network analysis of an urban metabolic system based on input-output tables:model development and case study for Beijing.Science of the Total Environment,2014,468- 469:642- 653.
[13] Zhang Y,Liu H,Fath B D.Synergism analysis of an urban metabolic system:Model development and a case study for Beijing,China.Ecological Modelling,2014,272:188- 197.
[14] Yang Z F,Zhang Y,Li S S,Liu H,Zheng H M,Zhang J Y,Su M R,Liu G Y.Characterizing urban metabolic systems with an ecological hierarchy method,Beijing,China.Landscape and Urban Planning,2014,121:19- 33.
[15] 王红娟.张掖市城市代谢机理及优化调控研究[D].兰州:兰州大学,2012:57.
[16] 黄永斌,董锁成,李泽红.基于能值分析的资源型城市新陈代谢水平评价——以石嘴山市为例.资源科学,2015,37(8):1621- 1628.
[17] 刘耕源,杨志峰,陈彬,徐琳瑜,张妍.基于生态网络的城市代谢结构模拟研究——以大连市为例.生态学报,2013,33(18):5926- 5934.
[18] 李晓英.基于城市代谢分析的大连可持续发展对策.环境保护,2016,44(19):56- 58.
[19] 徐福军,马俊杰.基于物质流分析的区域循环经济评价指标体系构建——以陕西省榆林市为例.地下水,2011,33(1):158- 159,167- 167.
[20] 李爽,张国臣,王丽艳.基于生态足迹和物质流的可持续性分析与评价——以石家庄市为例.水土保持研究,2013,20(5):226- 231.
[21] Zhang Y,Xia L L,Xiang W N.Analyzing spatial patterns of urban carbon metabolism:a case study in Beijing,China.Landscape and Urban Planning,2014,130:184- 200.
[22] 夏楚瑜,李艳,叶艳妹,史舟,刘婧鸣,李效顺.基于生态网络效用的城市碳代谢空间分析——以杭州为例.生态学报,2018,38(1):73- 85.
[23] Yellishetty M,Mudd G M.Substance flow analysis of steel and long term sustainability of iron ore resources in Australia,Brazil,China and India.Journal of Cleaner Production,2014,84:400- 410.
[24] Zhang Y,Zheng H M,Yang Z F,Liu G Y,Su M R.Analysis of the industrial metabolic processes for sulfur in the Lubei (Shandong Province,China) eco-industrial park.Journal of Cleaner Production,2015,96:126- 138.
[25] Min Y,Jin X G,Chang J,Peng C H,Gu B J,Ge Y,Zhong Y.Weak indirect effects inherent to nitrogen biogeochemical cycling within anthropogenic ecosystems:a network environ analysis.Ecological Modelling,2011,222(17):3277- 3284.
[26] Bai L,Qiao Q,Li Y P,Xie M H,Wan S,Zhong Q D.Substance flow analysis of production process:a case study of a lead smelting process.Journal of Cleaner Production,2015,104:502- 512.
[27] Sakamornsnguan K,Kretschmann J.Substance flow analysis and mineral policy:the case of potash in Thailand.The Extractive Industries and Society,2016,3(2):383- 394.
[28] Ding N,Yang J X,Liu J R.Substance flow analysis of aluminum industry in mainland China.Journal of Cleaner Production,2016,133:1167- 1180.
[29] Zhang Y,Yang Z F,Fath B D.Ecological network analysis of an urban water metabolic system:model development,and a case study for Beijing.Science of the Total Environment,2010,408(20):4702- 4711.
[30] Li Y,Yang Z F.Network structure analysis for environmental flow toward sustainable water use.Procedia Environmental Sciences,2010,2:1737- 1744.
[31] Fang D L,Chen B.Ecological network analysis for a virtual water network.Environmental Science & Technology,2015,49(11):6722- 6730.
[32] Chen S Q,Chen B.Urban energy-water nexus:a network perspective.Applied Energy,2016,184:905- 914.
[33] 黄初龙,于昌平,高兵,黄云凤.厦门市资源水与虚拟水耦合代谢效率评价.生态学报,2016,36(22):7267- 7278.
[34] Zhang Y,Li Y X,Zheng H M.Ecological network analysis of energy metabolism in the Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei (Jing-Jin-Ji) urban agglomeration.Ecological Modelling,2017,351:51- 62.
[35] Zheng S S,Shi L.Energy metabolism network based on ecological network analysis:a case study of Shandong province.Advances in Environmental Protection,2016,6(6):159- 170.
[36] Wang S G,Chen B.Energy-water nexus of urban agglomeration based on multiregional input-output tables and ecological network analysis:a case study of the Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei region.Applied Energy,2016,178:773- 783.
[37] Zheng H M,Wang X J,Li M J,Zhang Y,Fan Y C.Interregional trade among regions of urban energy metabolism:a case study between Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei and others in China.Resources,Conservation and Recycling,2018,132:339- 351.
[38] Facchini A,Kennedy C,Stewart I,Mele R.The energy metabolism of megacities.Applied Energy,2017,186(2):86- 95.
[39] 黄和平,王丽影.基于能源代谢分析的南昌市能源消费碳排放综合生态效率研究.生态学报,2017,37(12):4191- 4197.
[40] 宋涛,蔡建明,倪攀,杜姗姗,丁悦.城市新陈代谢研究综述及展望.地理科学进展,2013,32(11):1650- 1661.
[41] Liu G Y,Yang Z F,Chen B,Zhang Y.Ecological network determination of sectoral linkages,utility relations and structural characteristics on urban ecological economic system.Ecological Modelling,2011,222(15):2825- 2834.
[42] Amatya V B,Chandrashekar M,Robinson J B.Residential sector energy-supply-demand analysis:a modelling approach for developing countries and fuelwood-supply sustainability in Nepal.Energy,1993,18(4):341- 354.
[43] Howorth C,O′Keefe P,Convery I.Energy utilisation in peri-urban areas:issues of demand.Energy for Sustainable Development,1997,3(5):16- 25.
[44] Brownsword R A,Fleming P D,Powell J C,Pearsall N.Sustainable cities-modelling urban energy supply and demand.Applied Energy,2005,82(2):167- 180.
[45] Pachauri S.An analysis of cross-sectional variations in total household energy requirements in India using micro survey data.Energy Policy,2004,32(15):1723- 1735.
[46] Crompton P,Wu Y R.Energy consumption in China:past trends and future directions.Energy Economics,2005,27(1):195- 208.
[47] Kadian R,Dahiya R P,Garg H P.Energy-related emissions and mitigation opportunities from the household sector in Delhi.Energy Policy,2007,35(12):6195- 6211.
[48] Farreny R,Gabarrell X,Rieradevall J.Energy intensity and greenhouse gas emission of a purchase in the retail park service sector:an integrative approach.Energy Policy,2008,36(6):1957- 1968.
[49] Dhakal S.Urban energy use and carbon emissions from cities in China and policy implications.Energy Policy,2009,37(11):4208- 4219.
[50] Ma C B.Account for sector heterogeneity in China′s energy consumption:sector price indices vs.GDP deflator.Energy Economics,2010,32(1):24- 29.
[51] Bensel T G,Remedio E M.Residential energy use patterns in Cebu City,Philippines.Energy,1995,20(3):173- 187.
[52] Alabe M.Household energy consumption patterns in northern Nigeria.Energy for Sustainable Development,1996,2(5):42- 45.
[53] Templet P H.Energy,diversity and development in economic systems;An empirical analysis.Ecological Economics,2004,30(2):223- 233.
[54] Xu Z M,Cheng G D,Chen D J,Templet P H.Economic diversity,development capacity and sustainable development of China.Ecological Economics,2002,40(3):369- 378.
[55] Shivakumar K,Narasimhan S.A robust and efficient NLP formulation using graph theoretic principles for synthesis of heat exchanger networks.Computers & Chemical Engineering,2002,26(11):1517- 1532.
[56] Grekas D N,Frangopoulos C A.Automatic synthesis of mathematical models using graph theory for optimisation of thermal energy systems.Energy Conversion and Management,2007,48(11):2818- 2826.
[57] 张雷.经济发展对碳排放的影响.地理学报,2003,58(4):629- 637.
[58] Newcombe K,Kalma J D,Aston A R.The metabolism of a city:the case of Hong Kong.Ambio,1978,7(1):3- 15.
[59] Korhonen J.Four ecosystem principles for an industrial ecosystem.Journal of Cleaner Production,2001,9(3):253- 259.
[60] Korhonen J.A material and energy flow model for co-production of heat and power.Journal of Cleaner Production,2002,10(6):537- 544.
[61] Korhonen J,Sn?kin J P.Analysing the evolution of industrial ecosystems:concepts and application.Ecological Economics,2005,52(2):169- 186.
[62] Liang S,Wang C,Zhang T Z.An improved input-output model for energy analysis:a case study of Suzhou.Ecological Economics,2010,69(9):1805- 1813.
[63] Browne D,O′Regan B,Moles R.Comparison of energy flow accounting,energy flow metabolism ratio analysis and ecological footprinting as tools for measuring urban sustainability:a case-study of an Irish city-region.Ecological Economics,2012,83:97- 107.
[64] Baynes T M,Bai X M.Reconstructing the energy history of a city.Journal of Industrial Ecology,2012,16(6):862- 874.
[65] Yang D W,Kao W T M,Zhang G Q,Zhang N Y.Evaluating spatiotemporal differences and sustainability of Xiamen urban metabolism using emergy synthesis.Ecological Modelling,2014,272:40- 48.
[66] Garcia-Montiel D C,Verdejo-Ortiz J C,Santiago-Bartolomei R,Vila-Ruiz C P,Santiago L,Melendez-Ackerman E.Food sources and accessibility and waste disposal patterns across an urban tropical watershed:implications for the flow of materials and energy.Ecology and Society,2014,19(1):37.
[67] 刘华军,刘传明,孙亚男.中国能源消费的空间关联网络结构特征及其效应研究.中国工业经济,2015,(5):83- 95.
[68] 姜巍,高卫东,熊天琦.中国能源产业网络结构特征分析.干旱区资源与环境,2015,29(8):196- 202.
[69] Chen S Q,Chen B.Urban energy consumption:different insights from energy flow analysis,input-output analysis and ecological network analysis.Applied Energy,2015,138:99- 107.
[70] Zhang Y,Zheng H M,Fath B D.Analysis of the energy metabolism of urban socioeconomic sectors and the associated carbon footprints:model development and a case study for Beijing.Energy Policy,2014,73:540- 551.
[71] Haberl H.Human appropriation of net primary production as an environmental indicator:implications for sustainable development.Ambio,1997,26(3):143- 146.
[72] Haberl H.The energetic metabolism of societies part I:accounting concepts.Journal of Industrial Ecology,2001,5(1):11- 33.
[73] Patten B C,Bosserman R W,Finn J T,Cale W G.Propagation of cause in ecosystems//Patten B C,ed.Systems Analysis and Simulation in Ecology.New York:Academic Press,1976:457- 579.
[74] Leontief W W.The structure of the U.S.economy.Scientific American,1965,212(4):25- 35.
[75] Leontief W W.Input-output Economics.Oxford:Oxford University Press,1966:15- 21.
[76] Schramski J R,Kazanci C,Tollner E W.Network environ theory,simulation,and EcoNet? 2.0.Environmental Modelling & Software,2011,26(4):419- 428.
[77] Fath B D.Network mutualism:positive community-level relations in ecosystems.Ecological Modelling,2007,208(1):56- 67.
[78] Finn J T.Measures of ecosystem structure and function derived from analysis of flows.Journal of Theoretical Biology,1976,56(2):363- 380.
[79] Baird D,Fath B D,Ulanowicz R E,Asmus H,Asmus R.On the consequences of aggregation and balancing of networks on system properties derived from ecological network analysis.Ecological Modelling,2009,220(23):3465- 3471.
[80] Dame J K,Christian R R.Evaluation of ecological network analysis:validation of output.Ecological Modelling,2008,210(3):327- 338.
[81] Borrett S R,Fath B D,Patten B C.Functional integration of ecological networks through pathway proliferation.Journal of Theoretical Biology,2007,245(1):98- 111.
[82] Jordán F,Okey T A,Bauer B,Libralato S.Identifying important species:linking structure and function in ecological networks.Ecological Modelling,2008,216(1):75- 80.
[83] Gattie D K,Schramski J R,Bata S A.Analysis of microdynamic environ flows in an ecological network.Ecological Engineering,2006,28(3):187- 204.
[84] Bodini A,Bondavalli C.Towards a sustainable use of water resources:a whole-ecosystem approach using network analysis.International Journal of Environment and Pollution,2002,18(5):463- 485.
[85] Li S S,Zhang Y,Yang Z F,Liu H,Zhang J Y.Ecological relationship analysis of the urban metabolic system of Beijing,China.Environmental Pollution,2012,170:169- 176.
[86] 胡科,刘晓磊,魏希文,Reshmita N,崔雪锋.应用生态网络分析方法评价中国经济系统的可持续性.生态学报,2016,36(24):7942- 7950.
[87] Bodini A,Bondavalli C,Allesina S.Cities as ecosystems:growth,development and implications for sustainability.Ecological Modelling,2012,245:185- 198.
[88] Zhang Y,Li Y G,Liu G Y,Hao Y.CO2 metabolic flow analysis in global trade based on ecological network analysis.Journal of Cleaner Production,2018,170:34- 41.
[89] Xia L L,Liu Y,Wang X J,Tian X,Wu Q,Zhang Y,Liu G Y,Hao Y.Spatial analysis of the ecological relationships of urban carbon metabolism based on an 18 nodes network model.Journal of Cleaner Production,2018,170:61- 69.
[90] 张妍,郑宏媚,陆韩静.城市生态网络分析研究进展.生态学报,2017,37(12):4258- 4267.
[91] Lu W W,Su M R,Zhang Y,Yang Z F,Chen B,Liu G Y.Assessment of energy security in China based on ecological network analysis:a perspective from the security of crude oil supply.Energy Policy,2014,74:406- 413.
[92] Xia L L,Fath B D,Scharler U M,Zhang Y.Spatial variation in the ecological relationships among the components of Beijing′s carbon metabolic system.Science of the Total Environment,2016,544:103- 113.
[93] Bodini A.Building a systemic environmental monitoring and indicators for sustainability:what has the ecological network approach to offer?Ecological Indicators,2012,15(1):140- 148.
[94] Mao X F,Yang Z F,Chen B,Chen H.Examination of wetlands system using ecological network analysis:a case study of Baiyangdian Basin,China.Procedia Environmental Sciences,2010,2:427- 439.
[95] Li Y,Chen B,Yang Z F.Ecological network analysis for water use systems—A case study of the Yellow River Basin.Ecological Modelling,2009,220(22):3163- 3173.
[96] Niquil N,Chaumillon E,Johnson G A,Bertin X,Grami B,David V,Bacher C,Asmus H,Baird D,Asmus R.The effect of physical drivers on ecosystem indices derived from ecological network analysis:comparison across estuarine ecosystems.Estuarine,Coastal and Shelf Science,2012,108:132- 143.
[97] Ravalde T,Keirstead J.Comparing performance metrics for multi-resource systems:the case of urban metabolism.Journal of Cleaner Production,2017,163(S1):S241-S253.
[98] Fath B D,Patten B C.Review of the foundations of network environ analysis.Ecosystems,1999,2(2):167- 179.
[99] Small G E,Sterner R W,Finlay J C.An ecological network analysis of nitrogen cycling in the Laurentian great lakes.Ecological Modelling,2014,293:150- 160.
[100] Zhang Y,Zheng H M,Fath B D.Ecological network analysis of an industrial symbiosis system:a case study of the Shandong Lubei eco-industrial park.Ecological Modelling,2015,306:174- 184.
[101] Chen S Q,Chen B.Network environ perspective for urban metabolism and carbon emissions:a case study of Vienna,Austria.Environmental Science & Technology,2012,46(8):4498- 4506.
[102] Zhang Y,Zheng H M,Yang Z F,Su M R,Liu G Y,Li Y X.Multi-regional input-output model and ecological network analysis for regional embodied energy accounting in China.Energy Policy,2015,86:651- 663.
[103] Zhang Y,Zheng H M,Yang Z F,Li Y X,Liu G Y,Su M R,Yin X N.Urban energy flow processes in the Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei (Jing-Jin-Ji) urban agglomeration:combining multi-regional input-output tables with ecological network analysis.Journal of Cleaner Production,2016,114:243- 256.
[104] Ravalde T,Keirstead J.Comparing performance metrics for multi-resource systems:the case of urban metabolism.Journal of Cleaner Production,2017,163(S1):S241-S253.
[105] Zhang Y,Xia L L,Fath B D,Yang Z F,Yin X N,Su M R,Liu G Y,Li Y X.Development of a spatially explicit network model of urban metabolism and analysis of the distribution of ecological relationships:case study of Beijing,China.Journal of Cleaner Production,2016,112(5):4304- 4317.
[106] Zhang Y,Yang Z F,Fath B D,Li S S.Ecological network analysis of an urban energy metabolic system:model development,and a case study of four Chinese cities.Ecological Modelling,2010,221(16):1865- 1879.
[107] Zhang Y,Zhang J Y,Yang Z F.Network relationship analysis of urban energy metabolic system.Procedia Environmental Sciences,2010,2:1407- 1412.
[108] Zhang Y,Li S S,Fath B D,Yang Z F,Yang N J.Analysis of an urban energy metabolic system:comparison of simple and complex model results.Ecological Modelling,2011,223(1):14- 19.
[109] Zhang Y,Zheng H M,Yang Z F,Li J J,Yin X N,Liu G Y,Su M R.Analysis of urban energy consumption in carbon metabolic processes and its structural attributes:a case study for Beijing.Journal of Cleaner Production,2015,103:884- 897.
[110] 彭焜,朱鹤,王赛鸽,陈斌,魏文栋,李佳硕.基于系统投入产出和生态网络分析的能源-水耦合关系与协同管理研究——以湖北省为例.自然资源学报,2018,33(9):1514- 1528.
[111] Lu Y,Chen B,Hayat T,Alsaedi A.Communal carbon metabolism:methodology and case study.Journal of Cleaner Production,2017,163(S1):S315-S321.
[2] Su M R,Fath B D,Yang Z F.Urban ecosystem health assessment:a review.Science of the Total Environment,2010,408(12):2425- 2434.
[3] Jones N F,Pejchar L,Kiesecker J M.The energy footprint:how oil,natural gas,and wind energy affect land for biodiversity and the flow of ecosystem services.Bioscience,2015,65(3):290- 301.
[4] Su M R,Zhang Y,Liu G Y,Xu L Y,Zhang L X,Yang Z F.Urban ecosystem health assessment:perspectives and Chinese practice.International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health,2013,10(11):5874- 5885.
[5] Zeng H,Ellis C S,Lebeck A R,Vahdat A.ECOSystem:managing energy as a first class operating system resource.ACM Sigops Operating Systems Review,2002,36(5):123- 132.
[6] Wolman A.The metabolism of cities.Scientific American,1965,213:179- 190.
[7] Newman P W G.Sustainability and cities:extending the metabolism model.Landscape and Urban Planning,1999,44(4):219- 226.
[8] Warren-Rhodes K,Koenig A.Escalating trends in the urban metabolism of Hong Kong:1971- 1997.Ambio,2001,30(7):429- 438.
[9] Kennedy C,Cuddihy J,Engel-Yan J.The changing metabolism of cities.Journal of Industrial Ecology,2007,11(2):43- 59.
[10] Huang H P,Bi J,Li X M,Zhang B,Yang J.Material flow analysis (MFA) of an eco-economic system:a case study of Wujin District,Changzhou,China.Frontiers of Biology in China,2008,3(3):367- 374.
[11] 宋涛,蔡建明,杜姗姗,倪攀,丁悦.基于能值分析的北京城市新陈代谢研究.干旱区资源与环境,2015,29(1):37- 42.
[12] Zhang Y,Zheng H M,Fath B D,Liu H,Yang Z F,Liu G Y,Su M R.Ecological network analysis of an urban metabolic system based on input-output tables:model development and case study for Beijing.Science of the Total Environment,2014,468- 469:642- 653.
[13] Zhang Y,Liu H,Fath B D.Synergism analysis of an urban metabolic system:Model development and a case study for Beijing,China.Ecological Modelling,2014,272:188- 197.
[14] Yang Z F,Zhang Y,Li S S,Liu H,Zheng H M,Zhang J Y,Su M R,Liu G Y.Characterizing urban metabolic systems with an ecological hierarchy method,Beijing,China.Landscape and Urban Planning,2014,121:19- 33.
[15] 王红娟.张掖市城市代谢机理及优化调控研究[D].兰州:兰州大学,2012:57.
[16] 黄永斌,董锁成,李泽红.基于能值分析的资源型城市新陈代谢水平评价——以石嘴山市为例.资源科学,2015,37(8):1621- 1628.
[17] 刘耕源,杨志峰,陈彬,徐琳瑜,张妍.基于生态网络的城市代谢结构模拟研究——以大连市为例.生态学报,2013,33(18):5926- 5934.
[18] 李晓英.基于城市代谢分析的大连可持续发展对策.环境保护,2016,44(19):56- 58.
[19] 徐福军,马俊杰.基于物质流分析的区域循环经济评价指标体系构建——以陕西省榆林市为例.地下水,2011,33(1):158- 159,167- 167.
[20] 李爽,张国臣,王丽艳.基于生态足迹和物质流的可持续性分析与评价——以石家庄市为例.水土保持研究,2013,20(5):226- 231.
[21] Zhang Y,Xia L L,Xiang W N.Analyzing spatial patterns of urban carbon metabolism:a case study in Beijing,China.Landscape and Urban Planning,2014,130:184- 200.
[22] 夏楚瑜,李艳,叶艳妹,史舟,刘婧鸣,李效顺.基于生态网络效用的城市碳代谢空间分析——以杭州为例.生态学报,2018,38(1):73- 85.
[23] Yellishetty M,Mudd G M.Substance flow analysis of steel and long term sustainability of iron ore resources in Australia,Brazil,China and India.Journal of Cleaner Production,2014,84:400- 410.
[24] Zhang Y,Zheng H M,Yang Z F,Liu G Y,Su M R.Analysis of the industrial metabolic processes for sulfur in the Lubei (Shandong Province,China) eco-industrial park.Journal of Cleaner Production,2015,96:126- 138.
[25] Min Y,Jin X G,Chang J,Peng C H,Gu B J,Ge Y,Zhong Y.Weak indirect effects inherent to nitrogen biogeochemical cycling within anthropogenic ecosystems:a network environ analysis.Ecological Modelling,2011,222(17):3277- 3284.
[26] Bai L,Qiao Q,Li Y P,Xie M H,Wan S,Zhong Q D.Substance flow analysis of production process:a case study of a lead smelting process.Journal of Cleaner Production,2015,104:502- 512.
[27] Sakamornsnguan K,Kretschmann J.Substance flow analysis and mineral policy:the case of potash in Thailand.The Extractive Industries and Society,2016,3(2):383- 394.
[28] Ding N,Yang J X,Liu J R.Substance flow analysis of aluminum industry in mainland China.Journal of Cleaner Production,2016,133:1167- 1180.
[29] Zhang Y,Yang Z F,Fath B D.Ecological network analysis of an urban water metabolic system:model development,and a case study for Beijing.Science of the Total Environment,2010,408(20):4702- 4711.
[30] Li Y,Yang Z F.Network structure analysis for environmental flow toward sustainable water use.Procedia Environmental Sciences,2010,2:1737- 1744.
[31] Fang D L,Chen B.Ecological network analysis for a virtual water network.Environmental Science & Technology,2015,49(11):6722- 6730.
[32] Chen S Q,Chen B.Urban energy-water nexus:a network perspective.Applied Energy,2016,184:905- 914.
[33] 黄初龙,于昌平,高兵,黄云凤.厦门市资源水与虚拟水耦合代谢效率评价.生态学报,2016,36(22):7267- 7278.
[34] Zhang Y,Li Y X,Zheng H M.Ecological network analysis of energy metabolism in the Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei (Jing-Jin-Ji) urban agglomeration.Ecological Modelling,2017,351:51- 62.
[35] Zheng S S,Shi L.Energy metabolism network based on ecological network analysis:a case study of Shandong province.Advances in Environmental Protection,2016,6(6):159- 170.
[36] Wang S G,Chen B.Energy-water nexus of urban agglomeration based on multiregional input-output tables and ecological network analysis:a case study of the Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei region.Applied Energy,2016,178:773- 783.
[37] Zheng H M,Wang X J,Li M J,Zhang Y,Fan Y C.Interregional trade among regions of urban energy metabolism:a case study between Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei and others in China.Resources,Conservation and Recycling,2018,132:339- 351.
[38] Facchini A,Kennedy C,Stewart I,Mele R.The energy metabolism of megacities.Applied Energy,2017,186(2):86- 95.
[39] 黄和平,王丽影.基于能源代谢分析的南昌市能源消费碳排放综合生态效率研究.生态学报,2017,37(12):4191- 4197.
[40] 宋涛,蔡建明,倪攀,杜姗姗,丁悦.城市新陈代谢研究综述及展望.地理科学进展,2013,32(11):1650- 1661.
[41] Liu G Y,Yang Z F,Chen B,Zhang Y.Ecological network determination of sectoral linkages,utility relations and structural characteristics on urban ecological economic system.Ecological Modelling,2011,222(15):2825- 2834.
[42] Amatya V B,Chandrashekar M,Robinson J B.Residential sector energy-supply-demand analysis:a modelling approach for developing countries and fuelwood-supply sustainability in Nepal.Energy,1993,18(4):341- 354.
[43] Howorth C,O′Keefe P,Convery I.Energy utilisation in peri-urban areas:issues of demand.Energy for Sustainable Development,1997,3(5):16- 25.
[44] Brownsword R A,Fleming P D,Powell J C,Pearsall N.Sustainable cities-modelling urban energy supply and demand.Applied Energy,2005,82(2):167- 180.
[45] Pachauri S.An analysis of cross-sectional variations in total household energy requirements in India using micro survey data.Energy Policy,2004,32(15):1723- 1735.
[46] Crompton P,Wu Y R.Energy consumption in China:past trends and future directions.Energy Economics,2005,27(1):195- 208.
[47] Kadian R,Dahiya R P,Garg H P.Energy-related emissions and mitigation opportunities from the household sector in Delhi.Energy Policy,2007,35(12):6195- 6211.
[48] Farreny R,Gabarrell X,Rieradevall J.Energy intensity and greenhouse gas emission of a purchase in the retail park service sector:an integrative approach.Energy Policy,2008,36(6):1957- 1968.
[49] Dhakal S.Urban energy use and carbon emissions from cities in China and policy implications.Energy Policy,2009,37(11):4208- 4219.
[50] Ma C B.Account for sector heterogeneity in China′s energy consumption:sector price indices vs.GDP deflator.Energy Economics,2010,32(1):24- 29.
[51] Bensel T G,Remedio E M.Residential energy use patterns in Cebu City,Philippines.Energy,1995,20(3):173- 187.
[52] Alabe M.Household energy consumption patterns in northern Nigeria.Energy for Sustainable Development,1996,2(5):42- 45.
[53] Templet P H.Energy,diversity and development in economic systems;An empirical analysis.Ecological Economics,2004,30(2):223- 233.
[54] Xu Z M,Cheng G D,Chen D J,Templet P H.Economic diversity,development capacity and sustainable development of China.Ecological Economics,2002,40(3):369- 378.
[55] Shivakumar K,Narasimhan S.A robust and efficient NLP formulation using graph theoretic principles for synthesis of heat exchanger networks.Computers & Chemical Engineering,2002,26(11):1517- 1532.
[56] Grekas D N,Frangopoulos C A.Automatic synthesis of mathematical models using graph theory for optimisation of thermal energy systems.Energy Conversion and Management,2007,48(11):2818- 2826.
[57] 张雷.经济发展对碳排放的影响.地理学报,2003,58(4):629- 637.
[58] Newcombe K,Kalma J D,Aston A R.The metabolism of a city:the case of Hong Kong.Ambio,1978,7(1):3- 15.
[59] Korhonen J.Four ecosystem principles for an industrial ecosystem.Journal of Cleaner Production,2001,9(3):253- 259.
[60] Korhonen J.A material and energy flow model for co-production of heat and power.Journal of Cleaner Production,2002,10(6):537- 544.
[61] Korhonen J,Sn?kin J P.Analysing the evolution of industrial ecosystems:concepts and application.Ecological Economics,2005,52(2):169- 186.
[62] Liang S,Wang C,Zhang T Z.An improved input-output model for energy analysis:a case study of Suzhou.Ecological Economics,2010,69(9):1805- 1813.
[63] Browne D,O′Regan B,Moles R.Comparison of energy flow accounting,energy flow metabolism ratio analysis and ecological footprinting as tools for measuring urban sustainability:a case-study of an Irish city-region.Ecological Economics,2012,83:97- 107.
[64] Baynes T M,Bai X M.Reconstructing the energy history of a city.Journal of Industrial Ecology,2012,16(6):862- 874.
[65] Yang D W,Kao W T M,Zhang G Q,Zhang N Y.Evaluating spatiotemporal differences and sustainability of Xiamen urban metabolism using emergy synthesis.Ecological Modelling,2014,272:40- 48.
[66] Garcia-Montiel D C,Verdejo-Ortiz J C,Santiago-Bartolomei R,Vila-Ruiz C P,Santiago L,Melendez-Ackerman E.Food sources and accessibility and waste disposal patterns across an urban tropical watershed:implications for the flow of materials and energy.Ecology and Society,2014,19(1):37.
[67] 刘华军,刘传明,孙亚男.中国能源消费的空间关联网络结构特征及其效应研究.中国工业经济,2015,(5):83- 95.
[68] 姜巍,高卫东,熊天琦.中国能源产业网络结构特征分析.干旱区资源与环境,2015,29(8):196- 202.
[69] Chen S Q,Chen B.Urban energy consumption:different insights from energy flow analysis,input-output analysis and ecological network analysis.Applied Energy,2015,138:99- 107.
[70] Zhang Y,Zheng H M,Fath B D.Analysis of the energy metabolism of urban socioeconomic sectors and the associated carbon footprints:model development and a case study for Beijing.Energy Policy,2014,73:540- 551.
[71] Haberl H.Human appropriation of net primary production as an environmental indicator:implications for sustainable development.Ambio,1997,26(3):143- 146.
[72] Haberl H.The energetic metabolism of societies part I:accounting concepts.Journal of Industrial Ecology,2001,5(1):11- 33.
[73] Patten B C,Bosserman R W,Finn J T,Cale W G.Propagation of cause in ecosystems//Patten B C,ed.Systems Analysis and Simulation in Ecology.New York:Academic Press,1976:457- 579.
[74] Leontief W W.The structure of the U.S.economy.Scientific American,1965,212(4):25- 35.
[75] Leontief W W.Input-output Economics.Oxford:Oxford University Press,1966:15- 21.
[76] Schramski J R,Kazanci C,Tollner E W.Network environ theory,simulation,and EcoNet? 2.0.Environmental Modelling & Software,2011,26(4):419- 428.
[77] Fath B D.Network mutualism:positive community-level relations in ecosystems.Ecological Modelling,2007,208(1):56- 67.
[78] Finn J T.Measures of ecosystem structure and function derived from analysis of flows.Journal of Theoretical Biology,1976,56(2):363- 380.
[79] Baird D,Fath B D,Ulanowicz R E,Asmus H,Asmus R.On the consequences of aggregation and balancing of networks on system properties derived from ecological network analysis.Ecological Modelling,2009,220(23):3465- 3471.
[80] Dame J K,Christian R R.Evaluation of ecological network analysis:validation of output.Ecological Modelling,2008,210(3):327- 338.
[81] Borrett S R,Fath B D,Patten B C.Functional integration of ecological networks through pathway proliferation.Journal of Theoretical Biology,2007,245(1):98- 111.
[82] Jordán F,Okey T A,Bauer B,Libralato S.Identifying important species:linking structure and function in ecological networks.Ecological Modelling,2008,216(1):75- 80.
[83] Gattie D K,Schramski J R,Bata S A.Analysis of microdynamic environ flows in an ecological network.Ecological Engineering,2006,28(3):187- 204.
[84] Bodini A,Bondavalli C.Towards a sustainable use of water resources:a whole-ecosystem approach using network analysis.International Journal of Environment and Pollution,2002,18(5):463- 485.
[85] Li S S,Zhang Y,Yang Z F,Liu H,Zhang J Y.Ecological relationship analysis of the urban metabolic system of Beijing,China.Environmental Pollution,2012,170:169- 176.
[86] 胡科,刘晓磊,魏希文,Reshmita N,崔雪锋.应用生态网络分析方法评价中国经济系统的可持续性.生态学报,2016,36(24):7942- 7950.
[87] Bodini A,Bondavalli C,Allesina S.Cities as ecosystems:growth,development and implications for sustainability.Ecological Modelling,2012,245:185- 198.
[88] Zhang Y,Li Y G,Liu G Y,Hao Y.CO2 metabolic flow analysis in global trade based on ecological network analysis.Journal of Cleaner Production,2018,170:34- 41.
[89] Xia L L,Liu Y,Wang X J,Tian X,Wu Q,Zhang Y,Liu G Y,Hao Y.Spatial analysis of the ecological relationships of urban carbon metabolism based on an 18 nodes network model.Journal of Cleaner Production,2018,170:61- 69.
[90] 张妍,郑宏媚,陆韩静.城市生态网络分析研究进展.生态学报,2017,37(12):4258- 4267.
[91] Lu W W,Su M R,Zhang Y,Yang Z F,Chen B,Liu G Y.Assessment of energy security in China based on ecological network analysis:a perspective from the security of crude oil supply.Energy Policy,2014,74:406- 413.
[92] Xia L L,Fath B D,Scharler U M,Zhang Y.Spatial variation in the ecological relationships among the components of Beijing′s carbon metabolic system.Science of the Total Environment,2016,544:103- 113.
[93] Bodini A.Building a systemic environmental monitoring and indicators for sustainability:what has the ecological network approach to offer?Ecological Indicators,2012,15(1):140- 148.
[94] Mao X F,Yang Z F,Chen B,Chen H.Examination of wetlands system using ecological network analysis:a case study of Baiyangdian Basin,China.Procedia Environmental Sciences,2010,2:427- 439.
[95] Li Y,Chen B,Yang Z F.Ecological network analysis for water use systems—A case study of the Yellow River Basin.Ecological Modelling,2009,220(22):3163- 3173.
[96] Niquil N,Chaumillon E,Johnson G A,Bertin X,Grami B,David V,Bacher C,Asmus H,Baird D,Asmus R.The effect of physical drivers on ecosystem indices derived from ecological network analysis:comparison across estuarine ecosystems.Estuarine,Coastal and Shelf Science,2012,108:132- 143.
[97] Ravalde T,Keirstead J.Comparing performance metrics for multi-resource systems:the case of urban metabolism.Journal of Cleaner Production,2017,163(S1):S241-S253.
[98] Fath B D,Patten B C.Review of the foundations of network environ analysis.Ecosystems,1999,2(2):167- 179.
[99] Small G E,Sterner R W,Finlay J C.An ecological network analysis of nitrogen cycling in the Laurentian great lakes.Ecological Modelling,2014,293:150- 160.
[100] Zhang Y,Zheng H M,Fath B D.Ecological network analysis of an industrial symbiosis system:a case study of the Shandong Lubei eco-industrial park.Ecological Modelling,2015,306:174- 184.
[101] Chen S Q,Chen B.Network environ perspective for urban metabolism and carbon emissions:a case study of Vienna,Austria.Environmental Science & Technology,2012,46(8):4498- 4506.
[102] Zhang Y,Zheng H M,Yang Z F,Su M R,Liu G Y,Li Y X.Multi-regional input-output model and ecological network analysis for regional embodied energy accounting in China.Energy Policy,2015,86:651- 663.
[103] Zhang Y,Zheng H M,Yang Z F,Li Y X,Liu G Y,Su M R,Yin X N.Urban energy flow processes in the Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei (Jing-Jin-Ji) urban agglomeration:combining multi-regional input-output tables with ecological network analysis.Journal of Cleaner Production,2016,114:243- 256.
[104] Ravalde T,Keirstead J.Comparing performance metrics for multi-resource systems:the case of urban metabolism.Journal of Cleaner Production,2017,163(S1):S241-S253.
[105] Zhang Y,Xia L L,Fath B D,Yang Z F,Yin X N,Su M R,Liu G Y,Li Y X.Development of a spatially explicit network model of urban metabolism and analysis of the distribution of ecological relationships:case study of Beijing,China.Journal of Cleaner Production,2016,112(5):4304- 4317.
[106] Zhang Y,Yang Z F,Fath B D,Li S S.Ecological network analysis of an urban energy metabolic system:model development,and a case study of four Chinese cities.Ecological Modelling,2010,221(16):1865- 1879.
[107] Zhang Y,Zhang J Y,Yang Z F.Network relationship analysis of urban energy metabolic system.Procedia Environmental Sciences,2010,2:1407- 1412.
[108] Zhang Y,Li S S,Fath B D,Yang Z F,Yang N J.Analysis of an urban energy metabolic system:comparison of simple and complex model results.Ecological Modelling,2011,223(1):14- 19.
[109] Zhang Y,Zheng H M,Yang Z F,Li J J,Yin X N,Liu G Y,Su M R.Analysis of urban energy consumption in carbon metabolic processes and its structural attributes:a case study for Beijing.Journal of Cleaner Production,2015,103:884- 897.
[110] 彭焜,朱鹤,王赛鸽,陈斌,魏文栋,李佳硕.基于系统投入产出和生态网络分析的能源-水耦合关系与协同管理研究——以湖北省为例.自然资源学报,2018,33(9):1514- 1528.
[111] Lu Y,Chen B,Hayat T,Alsaedi A.Communal carbon metabolism:methodology and case study.Journal of Cleaner Production,2017,163(S1):S315-S321.