国外休闲制约协商研究进展与评析
|
摘要
国外休闲制约协商研究兴起于20世纪90年代,是休闲制约研究的前沿领域。论文以"Web of Science核心合集"数据库中1985—2018年共计136篇文献为样本数据,借助CiteSpaceⅢ信息可视化软件的计量分析方法对英文文献进行全面回顾及展望。结果发现:国外休闲制约协商研究大致可分为萌芽(1993—1999年)、探索(2000—2010年)和快速发展(2011年至今) 3个阶段,早期以概念性、描述性研究为主,自21世纪起,以实证研究为主,且研究内容已从简单的描述性分类发展到多变量的检验性模型构建与验证;关注休闲制约协商研究的学者和机构主要来自北美等经济发达的国家和地区;研究方法以数理统计、模型构建与验证居多,注重定性与定量相结合;涉及的研究对象广泛,已从大众休闲者扩展到特殊疾病患者、残障人士、穆斯林妇女等社会特殊群体,且主要关注体育健身休闲、户外游憩和深度休闲等多种休闲活动类型。目前,非西方文化背景下休闲制约协商的跨文化研究是西方休闲研究的热点话题。国外休闲制约协商的研究成果及综合研究思路对中国休闲制约协商研究及实践探讨具有借鉴价值。
Foreign researches on negotiation of leisure constraints appeared in the 1990 s, and is now the frontier field of leisure constraints research. In this study, a total of 136 articles in the Web of Science database from1985 to 2018 were taken as sample data, and the bibliometric analysis tool of CiteSpace Ⅲ information visualization software was used to perform a comprehensive review of these articles. Based on the growth in the number of articles and the change of research hotspots, the foreign researches on negotiation of leisure constraints can be divided into three stages: embryonic stage(1993-1999), exploration stage(2000-2010), and rapid development stage(2011 till now). Scholars and institutions who focus on negotiation of leisure constraints mainly come from the United States and Canada, followed by Australia and South Korea. In the early stage, the studies were conceptual and descriptive, empirical research emerged since the 21 st century, and the research content has developed from simple descriptive classification to multivariate model building and validation. The researches involved a wide range of crowd, ranging from the general population to special social groups, such as people with special diseases, people with disabilities and Muslim women. The contents focus on the constraints and negotiations of physical activity, outdoor recreation and serious leisure. At present, cross-cultural research has become a hot topic in foreign leisure researches. These foreign researches are of great significance to the theoretical and practical work of China's leisure study.
Foreign researches on negotiation of leisure constraints appeared in the 1990 s, and is now the frontier field of leisure constraints research. In this study, a total of 136 articles in the Web of Science database from1985 to 2018 were taken as sample data, and the bibliometric analysis tool of CiteSpace Ⅲ information visualization software was used to perform a comprehensive review of these articles. Based on the growth in the number of articles and the change of research hotspots, the foreign researches on negotiation of leisure constraints can be divided into three stages: embryonic stage(1993-1999), exploration stage(2000-2010), and rapid development stage(2011 till now). Scholars and institutions who focus on negotiation of leisure constraints mainly come from the United States and Canada, followed by Australia and South Korea. In the early stage, the studies were conceptual and descriptive, empirical research emerged since the 21 st century, and the research content has developed from simple descriptive classification to multivariate model building and validation. The researches involved a wide range of crowd, ranging from the general population to special social groups, such as people with special diseases, people with disabilities and Muslim women. The contents focus on the constraints and negotiations of physical activity, outdoor recreation and serious leisure. At present, cross-cultural research has become a hot topic in foreign leisure researches. These foreign researches are of great significance to the theoretical and practical work of China's leisure study.
引文
侯剑华,胡志刚.2013.CiteSpace软件应用研究的回顾与展望[J].现代情报,33(4):99-103.[Hou J H,Hu Z G.2013.Review on the application of CiteSpace at home and abroad.Journal of Modern Information,33(4):99-103.]
林岚,施林颖.2012.国外休闲制约研究进展及启示[J].地理科学进展,31(10):1377-1389.[Lin L,Shi L Y.2012.Progress and enlightenments of foreign leisure constraints research.Progress in Geography,31(10):1377-1389.]
邱亚君.2009.休闲体育行为发展阶段动机和限制因素研究[J].体育科学,29(6):39-46,72.[Qiu Y J.Research on motivation and constraint of leisure sport behavior stage.China Sport science,29(6):39-46,72.]
邱亚君.2011.休闲体育行为变通策略的探索性研究[J].体育科学,31(7):8-16,42.[Qiu Y J.2011.Research on the negotiation strategies of the leisure sports activities.China Sports Science,31(7):8-16,42.]
施林颖,林岚,邱妍,等.2014.国外休闲制约研究的特征与展望:基于《Journal of Leisure Research》《Leisure Sciences》《Journal of Park and Recreation Administration》期刊[J].亚热带资源与环境学报,9(3):35-44,95.[Shi L Y,Lin L,Qiu Y,et al.2014.Characteristics and prospect of foreign leisure constraints research:Based on the literature analysis of Journal of Leisure Research,Leisure Sciences,and Journal of Park and Recreation Administration.Journal of Subtropical Resources and Environment,9(3):35-44,95.]
世界休闲组织.2006.《休闲宪章》[N/OL].安徽日报,2006-05-06[2018-03-04].http://news.sina.com.cn/o/2006-05-06/0342885304.[World Leisure Organization.2006.Leisure charter.2006-05-06[2018-03-04].http://news.sina.co m.cn/o/2006-05-06/0342885304.]
曾秀芹,石忠海,林绚晖.2016.冒险性户外运动的限制因素和协商策略研究[J].体育科学,36(12):85-93.[Zeng XQ,Shi Z H,Lin X H.2016.Study on the constraints and negotiations of adventurous recreation.China Sports Science,36(12):85-93.]
张淑萍.2015.国内外休闲制约研究述评[J].山东农业工程学院学报,32(4):65-67.[Zhang S P.2015.A summary of the research on leisure constraints at home and abroad.The Journal of Shandong Agricultural and Engineering University,32(4):65-67.]
周文婷,田海波,邱亚君.2017.马拉松跑者深度休闲限制变通策略的质性研究[J].武汉体育学院学报,51(11):80-84.[Zhou W T,Tian H B,Qiu Y J.2017.Qualitative research on serious leisure constraints negotiation strategies of Marathon runners.Journal of Wuhan Institute of Physical Education,51(11):80-84.]
朱志强,林岚,杨书,等.2016.国内红色旅游研究发展知识图谱:基于CiteSpace的计量分析[J].旅游论坛,9(6):32-39.[Zhu Z Q,Lin L,Yang S,et al.2016.The mapping knowledge domains about development of domestic red tourism research:Bibliometric analysis based on CiteSpace.Tourism Forum,9(6):32-39.]
Alexandris K,Funk D C,Pritchard M.2011.The impact of constrains on motivation,activity attachment,and skier intentions to continue[J].Journal of Leisure Research,43(1):56-79.
Alexandris K,Kouthouris C,Funk D C,et al.2013.The use of negotiation strategies among recreational participants with different involvement levels:The case of recreational swimmers[J].Leisure Studies,32(3):299-317.
Alexandris K,Du J,Funk D C,et al.2017.Leisure constraints and the psychological continuum model:A study among recreational mountain skiers[J].Leisure Studies,36(5):670-683.
Bandura A.1977.Self-efficacy:Toward a unifying theory of behavioral change[J].Psychological Review,84(2):191-215.
Bandura A.1997.Self-efficacy:The exercise of control[M].NY:Freeman.
Funk D C,Alexandris K,Ping Y.2009.Exploring the balance between motives and perceived constrains for major events:A case study of the 2008 Beijing Olympic Games[J].International Journal of Tourism Research,11(1):41-53.
Hubbard J R,Mannell R C.2001.Testing competing model of the leisure constraint negotiation progress in a corporate employee recreation setting[J].Leisure Sciences,23(3):145-163.
Jackson E L.1999.Comment on Hawkins et al."Leisure constraints:A replication and extension of construct development"[J].Leisure Sciences,21(3):195-199.
Jackson E L.2000.Will research on leisure constraints still be relevant in the twenty-first century[J].Journal of Leisure Research,32(1):62-68.
Jackson E L,Burrton T L.1999.Leisure studies:Prospects for the twenty-first centuty[M].State College,PA:Venture Publishing.
Jackson E L,Crawford D W,Godbey G.1993.Negotiation of leisure constraints[J].Leisure Sciences,15(1):1-11.
Jackson E L,RucksV C.1995.Negotiation of Leisure constraints by junior-high and high school students:An exploratory study[J].Journal of Leisure Research,27(1):85-105.
Jun J E,Kyle G T.2011a.Understanding the role of identity in the constraint negotiation process[J].Leisure Sciences,33(4):309-331.
Jun J E,Kyle G T.2011b.The effect of identity conflict/facilitation on the experience of constraints to leisure and constraint negotiation[J].Journal of Leisure Research,43(2):176-204
Kay T,Jackson G.1991.Leisure despite constraint:The impact of leisure constraints on leisure participation[J].Journal of Leisure Research,23(4):301-313.
Kloek M E,Peters K N,Sijtsma M E.2013.How Muslim women in the Netherlands negotiate discrimination during leisure activities[J].Leisure Science,35(5):405-421.
Koca C N,Henderson K A,Asci H A,et al.2009.Constraints to leisure-time physical activity and negotiation strategies in Turkish women[J].Journal of Leisure Research,41(2):225-251.
Lee S N,Scott D D.2009.The process of celebrity fan's constraint negotiation[J].Journal of Leisure Research,41(2):137-155.
Livengood J S,Stodolska M A.2004.The effects of discrimination and constraints negotiation on leisure behavior of American Muslims in the post-September 11 America[J].Journal of Leisure Research,36(2):183-208.
Loucks-Atkinson A,Mannell R C.2007.Role of self-efficacy in the constraints negotiation process:The case of individuals with fibromyalgia syndrome[J].Leisure Sciences,29(1):19-36.
Lyu S O,Oh C O,Lee H N.2013.The influence of extraversion on leisure constraints negotiation process:A case of Korean people with disabilities[J].Journal of Leisure Research,45(2):233-252.
Lyu S O,Oh C O.2014.Recreationists'constraints negotiation process for continual leisure engagement[J].Leisure Science,36(5):479-497.
Lyu S O,Oh C O.2015.Bridging the conceptual frameworks of constraints negotiation and serious leisure to understand leisure benefit realization[J].Leisure Science,37(2):176-193.
Lyu S O,Lee H N.2016.Latent demand for recreation participation and leisure constraints negotiation process evidence from Korean people with disabilities[J].Journal of Leisure Research,48(5):431-449.
Lyu S O.2017.Developmental process of internet gaming disorder among South Korean adolescents:Effects of family environment and recreation experience[J].Journal of Child and Family Studies,26(6):1527-1535.
Lyu S O,Lee H N.2018.How do golf tourists manage golfing constraints?A choice modeling approach[J].Journal of Hospitality&Tourism Research,42(2):295-318.
Nadirova N,Jackson E L.2000.Alternative criterion variables against which to assess the impacts of constraints to leisure[J].Journal of Leisure Research,32(4):396-405.
Ridinger L L,Funk D C,2012.Jordan J S.Marathons for the masses:exploring the role of negotiation-efficacy and involvement on running commitment[J].Journal of Leisure Research,44(2):155-178.
Scott D.1991.The problematic nature of participation in contract bridge:A qualitative study of group-related constraints[J].Leisure Sciences,13(4):321-336.
Shaw S M,Bonen A,Mccabe J F.1991.Do more constraints mean less leisure?Examining the relationship between constraints and participation[J].Journal of Leisure Research,23(4):286-300.
Son J S,Mowen A J,Kerstetter D L.2008.Testing alternative leisure constraint negotiation models:An extension of Hubbard and Mannell's study[J].Leisure Science,30(3):198-216.
Son J S,Mowen A J,Kerstetter D L.2011.Interactive social cognitive model of leisure-time physical activity in mid to late life[J].American Journal Health Behavior,35(1):60-70.
Son J S,Kerstetter D L,Mowen A J.2008.Do age and gender matter in the constraint negotiation of physically active leisure[J].Journal of Leisure Research,4(2):267-289.
Son J S,Kerstetter D L,Mowen A J,et al.2009.Global selfregulation and outcome expectations:Influences on constraint self-regulation and physical activity[J].Journal of Aging and Physical Activity,17(3):307-326.
Tian G,Schneider I D.2015.Measurement properties and cross-cultural equivalence of negotiation with outdoor recreation constraints[J].Journal of Leisure Research,47(1):125-153.
White D D.2008.A structural model of leisure constraints negotiation in outdoor recreation[J].Leisure Sciences,30(4):342-359.
Wilhelm S A,Schneider I E,Russell K C.2009.Leisure time physical activity of park visitors:Retesting constraint models in adoption and maintenance stages[J].Leisure Sciences,31(3):287-304.
林岚,施林颖.2012.国外休闲制约研究进展及启示[J].地理科学进展,31(10):1377-1389.[Lin L,Shi L Y.2012.Progress and enlightenments of foreign leisure constraints research.Progress in Geography,31(10):1377-1389.]
邱亚君.2009.休闲体育行为发展阶段动机和限制因素研究[J].体育科学,29(6):39-46,72.[Qiu Y J.Research on motivation and constraint of leisure sport behavior stage.China Sport science,29(6):39-46,72.]
邱亚君.2011.休闲体育行为变通策略的探索性研究[J].体育科学,31(7):8-16,42.[Qiu Y J.2011.Research on the negotiation strategies of the leisure sports activities.China Sports Science,31(7):8-16,42.]
施林颖,林岚,邱妍,等.2014.国外休闲制约研究的特征与展望:基于《Journal of Leisure Research》《Leisure Sciences》《Journal of Park and Recreation Administration》期刊[J].亚热带资源与环境学报,9(3):35-44,95.[Shi L Y,Lin L,Qiu Y,et al.2014.Characteristics and prospect of foreign leisure constraints research:Based on the literature analysis of Journal of Leisure Research,Leisure Sciences,and Journal of Park and Recreation Administration.Journal of Subtropical Resources and Environment,9(3):35-44,95.]
世界休闲组织.2006.《休闲宪章》[N/OL].安徽日报,2006-05-06[2018-03-04].http://news.sina.com.cn/o/2006-05-06/0342885304.[World Leisure Organization.2006.Leisure charter.2006-05-06[2018-03-04].http://news.sina.co m.cn/o/2006-05-06/0342885304.]
曾秀芹,石忠海,林绚晖.2016.冒险性户外运动的限制因素和协商策略研究[J].体育科学,36(12):85-93.[Zeng XQ,Shi Z H,Lin X H.2016.Study on the constraints and negotiations of adventurous recreation.China Sports Science,36(12):85-93.]
张淑萍.2015.国内外休闲制约研究述评[J].山东农业工程学院学报,32(4):65-67.[Zhang S P.2015.A summary of the research on leisure constraints at home and abroad.The Journal of Shandong Agricultural and Engineering University,32(4):65-67.]
周文婷,田海波,邱亚君.2017.马拉松跑者深度休闲限制变通策略的质性研究[J].武汉体育学院学报,51(11):80-84.[Zhou W T,Tian H B,Qiu Y J.2017.Qualitative research on serious leisure constraints negotiation strategies of Marathon runners.Journal of Wuhan Institute of Physical Education,51(11):80-84.]
朱志强,林岚,杨书,等.2016.国内红色旅游研究发展知识图谱:基于CiteSpace的计量分析[J].旅游论坛,9(6):32-39.[Zhu Z Q,Lin L,Yang S,et al.2016.The mapping knowledge domains about development of domestic red tourism research:Bibliometric analysis based on CiteSpace.Tourism Forum,9(6):32-39.]
Alexandris K,Funk D C,Pritchard M.2011.The impact of constrains on motivation,activity attachment,and skier intentions to continue[J].Journal of Leisure Research,43(1):56-79.
Alexandris K,Kouthouris C,Funk D C,et al.2013.The use of negotiation strategies among recreational participants with different involvement levels:The case of recreational swimmers[J].Leisure Studies,32(3):299-317.
Alexandris K,Du J,Funk D C,et al.2017.Leisure constraints and the psychological continuum model:A study among recreational mountain skiers[J].Leisure Studies,36(5):670-683.
Bandura A.1977.Self-efficacy:Toward a unifying theory of behavioral change[J].Psychological Review,84(2):191-215.
Bandura A.1997.Self-efficacy:The exercise of control[M].NY:Freeman.
Funk D C,Alexandris K,Ping Y.2009.Exploring the balance between motives and perceived constrains for major events:A case study of the 2008 Beijing Olympic Games[J].International Journal of Tourism Research,11(1):41-53.
Hubbard J R,Mannell R C.2001.Testing competing model of the leisure constraint negotiation progress in a corporate employee recreation setting[J].Leisure Sciences,23(3):145-163.
Jackson E L.1999.Comment on Hawkins et al."Leisure constraints:A replication and extension of construct development"[J].Leisure Sciences,21(3):195-199.
Jackson E L.2000.Will research on leisure constraints still be relevant in the twenty-first century[J].Journal of Leisure Research,32(1):62-68.
Jackson E L,Burrton T L.1999.Leisure studies:Prospects for the twenty-first centuty[M].State College,PA:Venture Publishing.
Jackson E L,Crawford D W,Godbey G.1993.Negotiation of leisure constraints[J].Leisure Sciences,15(1):1-11.
Jackson E L,RucksV C.1995.Negotiation of Leisure constraints by junior-high and high school students:An exploratory study[J].Journal of Leisure Research,27(1):85-105.
Jun J E,Kyle G T.2011a.Understanding the role of identity in the constraint negotiation process[J].Leisure Sciences,33(4):309-331.
Jun J E,Kyle G T.2011b.The effect of identity conflict/facilitation on the experience of constraints to leisure and constraint negotiation[J].Journal of Leisure Research,43(2):176-204
Kay T,Jackson G.1991.Leisure despite constraint:The impact of leisure constraints on leisure participation[J].Journal of Leisure Research,23(4):301-313.
Kloek M E,Peters K N,Sijtsma M E.2013.How Muslim women in the Netherlands negotiate discrimination during leisure activities[J].Leisure Science,35(5):405-421.
Koca C N,Henderson K A,Asci H A,et al.2009.Constraints to leisure-time physical activity and negotiation strategies in Turkish women[J].Journal of Leisure Research,41(2):225-251.
Lee S N,Scott D D.2009.The process of celebrity fan's constraint negotiation[J].Journal of Leisure Research,41(2):137-155.
Livengood J S,Stodolska M A.2004.The effects of discrimination and constraints negotiation on leisure behavior of American Muslims in the post-September 11 America[J].Journal of Leisure Research,36(2):183-208.
Loucks-Atkinson A,Mannell R C.2007.Role of self-efficacy in the constraints negotiation process:The case of individuals with fibromyalgia syndrome[J].Leisure Sciences,29(1):19-36.
Lyu S O,Oh C O,Lee H N.2013.The influence of extraversion on leisure constraints negotiation process:A case of Korean people with disabilities[J].Journal of Leisure Research,45(2):233-252.
Lyu S O,Oh C O.2014.Recreationists'constraints negotiation process for continual leisure engagement[J].Leisure Science,36(5):479-497.
Lyu S O,Oh C O.2015.Bridging the conceptual frameworks of constraints negotiation and serious leisure to understand leisure benefit realization[J].Leisure Science,37(2):176-193.
Lyu S O,Lee H N.2016.Latent demand for recreation participation and leisure constraints negotiation process evidence from Korean people with disabilities[J].Journal of Leisure Research,48(5):431-449.
Lyu S O.2017.Developmental process of internet gaming disorder among South Korean adolescents:Effects of family environment and recreation experience[J].Journal of Child and Family Studies,26(6):1527-1535.
Lyu S O,Lee H N.2018.How do golf tourists manage golfing constraints?A choice modeling approach[J].Journal of Hospitality&Tourism Research,42(2):295-318.
Nadirova N,Jackson E L.2000.Alternative criterion variables against which to assess the impacts of constraints to leisure[J].Journal of Leisure Research,32(4):396-405.
Ridinger L L,Funk D C,2012.Jordan J S.Marathons for the masses:exploring the role of negotiation-efficacy and involvement on running commitment[J].Journal of Leisure Research,44(2):155-178.
Scott D.1991.The problematic nature of participation in contract bridge:A qualitative study of group-related constraints[J].Leisure Sciences,13(4):321-336.
Shaw S M,Bonen A,Mccabe J F.1991.Do more constraints mean less leisure?Examining the relationship between constraints and participation[J].Journal of Leisure Research,23(4):286-300.
Son J S,Mowen A J,Kerstetter D L.2008.Testing alternative leisure constraint negotiation models:An extension of Hubbard and Mannell's study[J].Leisure Science,30(3):198-216.
Son J S,Mowen A J,Kerstetter D L.2011.Interactive social cognitive model of leisure-time physical activity in mid to late life[J].American Journal Health Behavior,35(1):60-70.
Son J S,Kerstetter D L,Mowen A J.2008.Do age and gender matter in the constraint negotiation of physically active leisure[J].Journal of Leisure Research,4(2):267-289.
Son J S,Kerstetter D L,Mowen A J,et al.2009.Global selfregulation and outcome expectations:Influences on constraint self-regulation and physical activity[J].Journal of Aging and Physical Activity,17(3):307-326.
Tian G,Schneider I D.2015.Measurement properties and cross-cultural equivalence of negotiation with outdoor recreation constraints[J].Journal of Leisure Research,47(1):125-153.
White D D.2008.A structural model of leisure constraints negotiation in outdoor recreation[J].Leisure Sciences,30(4):342-359.
Wilhelm S A,Schneider I E,Russell K C.2009.Leisure time physical activity of park visitors:Retesting constraint models in adoption and maintenance stages[J].Leisure Sciences,31(3):287-304.