摘要
随着科技的迅猛发展,以团队形式进行创新已经在当今比较流行,作为企业创新主体的研发人员是企业创新的载体,更是企业实现企业目标、提升企业绩效的关键。创新已经成为当今发展的主题,对企业和社会的发展具有至关重要的作用。作为创新主体的研发团队,成员的差异性,使得研发团队能够有效运行很困难。在创新过程中研发团队的冲突问题引起了重视,合理引导和化解研发团队的冲突是企业创新的关键,正确处理好研发团队冲突问题,能够给企业带来更多的经济价值和社会价值。
鉴于此,本文以研发团队为研究对象,从研发团队冲突的角度着手,构建研发团队冲突发展模型,通过模型发现研发团队冲突的创新效应,并通过对136个研发团队的实证调查,运用SPSS13.0,探讨研发团队冲突与创新绩效的关系,从团队规模、团队成立时间等团队层面分析了对当事人彼此依赖程度、研发团队冲突、创新绩效的影响,得出结论如下:
1、在研发团队冲突的三个维度上,认知冲突对创新绩效各个维度的影响具有正向作用;情感冲突对创新绩效各个维度的影响具有负向作用;过程冲突与创新绩效各个维度的关系不显著;
2、当事人彼此依赖程度对认知冲突与创新绩效各个维度的关系具有调节作用;
3、团队规模、团队成立时间对研发团队冲突存在着差异。
With the rapid development of science and technology, it has been more popular today that innovation is carried out by team. As the main innovation subject, the R&D people is the key who achieve business goals and improve business performance. Innovation has become the theme of development and which have a crucial role to development of enterprises and society. Because of the difference of R&D people, it is difficult to operate R&D team effectively. The conflict of R&D team is attracted in the process of innovation. It is the key to business innovation that dealing with the conflict of R&D team reasonably. Handling the conflict of R&D team correctly can bring more economic value and social value to enterprise.
In this paper, I take R&D team for the research object. From the perspective of the conflict of R&D team. It is established the four-stage development model of the R&D team’s conflict. From the model, I find out the innovation. This study use 136 sample teams and SPSS13.0 tools to analyze the relationship between the conflict of R&D team and innovation performance, and the Dependence of the parties to each other、the conflict of R&D team、innovation performance in the team size and the time of team established. The following conclusions:
1、From the three dimensions of R&D team’s conflict, cognitive conflict has a positive effect to the various dimensions of innovation performance; emotional conflict has a negative effect to the various dimensions of innovation performance; process conflict has no effect to the various dimensions of innovation performance;
2、Dependence of the parties to each other has a regulatory role in the relationship between the cognitive conflict and the various dimensions of innovation performance;
3、The conflict of R&D team has difference in the team size and the time of team established.
引文
[1]Stephen P.Robbins.Organization Behavior:Prentice-Hall International of Teams.[M] Seventh Edition. Harvard Business School Concepts controversy, Applications.Inc.1997:347-373
[2]张德.组织行为学.第七版. [M]北京:高等教育出版社,2002:153-154
[3]Katzenbach J.R,Smith D.K.The discipline of teams.Harvard Business Review,1993:56-78
[4]陈劲.研发项目管理. [M]北京:机械工业出版社,2004:261-272
[5]龚晓光.研发人员行为激励模拟系统研究[D].华中科技大学博士学位论文,2004,3:3-9
[6]陈洁.基于KM视角的IT研发团队工作特征与创新绩效的关系[D] .浙江大学硕士学位论文,2007,4:2-4
[7]王瑛.基于心理契约的企业研发人员激励研究[D] .兰州理工大学硕士学位论文,2007,4:3-6
[8]王林祥.企业研发团队成员知识共享动机与行为及效果的关系研究[D].浙江工业大学硕士论文,2007,11:2-8
[9]程寒晶.企业研发团队薪酬体系探析[D].西南财经大学硕士学位论文,2007,4:1-3
[10]祝磊.企业研发团队薪酬体系研究[D].河海大学硕士学位论文,2007,1:4-6
[11]聂晖,黎志成,谢颂华.基于AHP法的软件企业研发团队能力评价模型[J].武汉理工大学学报(信息与管理工程版),2005,8:310-313
[12]郝登峰,刘梅.基于团队凝聚力结构的科研团队管理[J].科技管理研究,2005,11:87-89
[13]杨华,李永周.构建高新技术企业研发项目团队的激励体系[J].科技创业月刊,2007,10:111-112
[14]陈春花,杨映珊.基于团队运作模式的科研管理研究[J].科技进步与对策,2002,4:119-122
[15]Martin Hoegl,Luigi Proserpio.Team member proximity and teamwork in innovative projects [J].Research Policy,Volume 33,Issue 8,October 2004:1153-1165
[16]Susan L.Kichuk,Willi H. Wiesner.Work Teams : Selecting Members for Optimal Performance[J].Canadian Psychology,Volume39,Issues1-2, February-May 1998:23-32
[17]Ta-Cheng Hsiao.Capability development and management of R&D professionals in a developing context, Taiwan[J].Technovation, Volume 17,Issue 10,October 1997:569-581
[18]Schwenk, C.R. Conflict in organizational decision making:An exploratory study of its effects in for-profit and not-for-profit organizations.Management Science, 1990,36(4) ,436-448
[19]斯蒂芬?P?罗宾斯.组织行为学.(第七版). [M]北京:中国人民大学出版社,1997,386
[20]Jameson , J.k.Toward a comprehensive model for the assessment and management of intra-organizational conflict:Developing the framework.The International Journal of Conflict Management,1999,10(3) ,268-294
[21]徐凤姝.社会心理的认识与调试[M] .北京人民出版社,1989:202-205
[22]周晓虹.现代社会心理学[M].上海人民出版社,1996,317
[23]张克昕,张凤林.现代管理心理学——理论与运用. [M]航空工业出版社,1998,232
[24]黄培伦.组织行为学[M] .广州:华南理工大学出版社,2001,248
[25]胡君辰,杨永康.组织行为学[M] .复旦大学出版社.2004,341
[26]Wall , Jr.J.W , and Callister , R.R.Conflict and its management.Journal of Management ,1995,21(3) ,515-558.
[27]徐笑君,卢盛忠,郭斌.国有企业部门冲突研究[J].科技经济社会,1997:34-37
[28]张兰霞,刘杰.基于虚拟企业生命周期的冲突管理[J] .东北大学学报(社会科学版),2006
[29]Thomas,K.W.Conflict and conflict management [J] .Handbook of Industrial and Organizational Psychology. Palo Alto:Consulting Psychologists Press,1976,889-935
[30]Georg Simmel.Sociologist and European[M] .Lawrence.Published:New York: Barnes & Noble Books,1976:275-320
[31]Pondy,L.R.Reflections on organizational conflict[J].Journal of Organizational Change Management,1989,2(2):94-98
[32]Stephen P.Robbins.Organizational Behavior[M].Ninth Edition,Prentice Hall ,2001:32-105
[33]林雪莹.创业管对冲突对创业绩效影响研究[D].中山大学硕士论文,2008,6
[34]沈丽.个人知识与团队知识冲突及其绩效的关系研究[D].浙江大学硕士论文,2007,4
[35]潘晓云.基于个体、团队视角冲突与情绪的研究[D].复旦大学博士论文,2008,4
[36]叶畅东.基于员工的团队内冲突管理对其绩效影响研究[D].同济大学硕士论文,2006,3
[37]陈云.企业高层管理团队冲突研究[D].武汉理工大学博士论文,2008,3
[38]欧阳慧.上市公司高层管理团队治理绩效评价系统及其实证研究[D].湖南大学博士学位论文,2004,6:15-80
[39]樊富珉,张翔.人际冲突与冲突管理研究综述[J].中国矿业大学学报(社会科学版),2003,3:82-91
[40]葛宏亮,张宏国.基于AHP的企业动态联盟冲突量化及预测[J].信息技术,2006,30(3):67-69
[41]Amason,A.C.Distinguishing the effects of functional and dysfunctional conflict on strategic decision making:Resolving a paradox for top management teams[J].Academy of Management Journal,1996:123-148
[42]Ensley,M. D, Pearson,A.W. An exploratory comparison of the behavioral dynamics of top management teams in family and non-family and non-family new ventures:Cohesion,conflict,potency,and consensus[J].Entrepreneurship theory and practice,2005:267-287
[43]Peterson,R.S.Behfar,K.J.The dynamic relationship between performance feedback,trust,and conflict in groups:A longitudinal study[J].Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Process,2003:102-112
[44]Janssen O,Van Yperen NW.Employee’s goal orientations,the quality of leader-member exchange,and the outcomes of job performance and job satisfaction[J].Academy of Management Journal,2004:368-384
[45]韩翼,廖建桥,龙立荣.雇员工作绩效结构模型构建于实证研究[J].管理科学学报,2007,10(5):62-77
[46]高阳,胡明铭,徐姝.中部区域创新系统与创新绩效评价研究[J].湖南商学院学报,2006,4:44-49
[47]任胜钢,彭建华.基于DEA模型的中部区域创新绩效评价与比较研究[J].求索,2006,10:15-18
[48]吴亚桃.基于灰色系统理论的企业技术创新绩效评价[J].价值工程,2006,4:36-38
[49]夏伟怀,秦桂香,陈治亚.基于层次灰色模型的铁路技术创新绩效综合评价[J].铁路科学与工程学报,2006,10:82-86
[50]吉峰,周敏.区域创新网络主体间的联结机制与区域创新绩效的关系研究[J].科技导报,2006,5:82-85
[51]易伟明,刘满凤.区域创新系统创新绩效分析与评价[J].科技进步与对策,2005,3:119-121
[52]赵付民,邹珊刚.区域创新环境及对区域创新绩效的影响分析[J].统计与决策,2005,4:17-18
[53]石晓梅,胡珑瑛.高新区创新绩效测量度指标体系的研究[J].燕山大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2003,8:27-28
[54]官建成,刘顺忠.区域创新系统创新绩效的研究[J].中国管理科学,2002,2:210-214
[55]W.Nasierowski,F.J.Arcelus.On the efficiency of national innovation systems[J].Socio-Economic Planning Science,Volume 37,Issue 3,September 2003:215-234
[56]Giles Hirst and Leon Mann.How leaders influence the impact of affective event on team climate and performance in R&D teams[J].The Leadership Quarterly,Volume,13,Issue 5,October 2002:561-581
[57]West,M.A.Sparkling fountains or stagnant ponds:An integrative model of creativity and innovationimplementation in work groups.Applied Psychology:An International Review,2002b,51(3):355-424
[58]West,M.A,Hirst,G. Richter,A.,et al.Twelve steps to heaven:Successfully managing change through developing innovative teams.European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology,2004,13(2) :269-299
[59]Valle,S.,& Avella, L.Cross-functionality and leadership of the new product development teams.European Journal of Innovation Management,2003,6(1) :32-47
[60]Somech,A.The effects of leadership style and team process on performance and innovation in functionally heterogeneous teams.Journal of Management,2006,32(1) :132-157
[61]Lee,C.,& Chen,W.J.Cross-functionality and charged behavior of the new product development teams in Taiwan’s information technology industries.Technovation,2007,27(10) :605-615
[62]Curral, L .A. ,Forrester, R. H,Dawson,J. F.,et al. It’s what you do and the way that you do it:Team task ,team size, and innovation-related group process. European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology,2001,10(2) :187-204
[63]薛继东,李海.团队创新影响因素研究述评[J].外国经济与管理,2009,31(2):25-32
[64]Somech, A.The effects of leadership style and team process on performance and innovation in functionally heterogeneous teams.Journal of Management,2006,32(1) :132-157
[65]Amabile,T.M.,Conti,R.,Coon,H.,et al. Assessing the work environment for creativity. Academy of Management Journal,1996,39(5) :1154-1184
[66]West,M.A.,& Anderson,N.R. Innovation in top management teams. Journal of Applied Psychoogy,1996,81(6) :680-693
[67]Anderson,N.R.,& West,M.A. Measuring climate for work group innovation:Development and validation of the team climate inventory.Journal of Organizational Behavior,1998,19(3) :235-258
[68]Lewis,K. Measuring transactive memory systems in the field:Scale development and validation. Journal of Applied Psychology,2003,88(4) :587-604
[69]Akgun,A.E .,Byrne,J.C. ,Keskin, H.,et al. Knowledge networks in new product development projects:A transactive memory perspective.Information & Management,2005,42(8) :1105-1120
[70]Schmickl, C .,& Kieser, A. How much do specialists have to learn from each other when they jointly develop radical product innovations?Research Policy,2008,37(3) :473-491
[71]Hoegl ,M., Gibber ,M.,& Mazursky,D.Financial constraints in innovation projects: When is less more? Research Policy,2008,37(8) :1382-1391
[72]Hung ,C.C. Knowledge sharing and group cohesiveness on performance:An empirical study of technology R&D teams in Taiwan. Technovation.2009,29(11) :786-797
[73]George,J.M .Group affective tone(In M.A.West) ,Handbook of Work Group Psychology.Chichester : Wiley,1996 :77-94
[74]Frishammar, J., & Ake Horte ,S .Managing external information in manufacturing firms: The impact on innovation performance.Journal of Product Innovation Management,2005,22(3) :251-266
[75]Badrinarayanan,V.,& Arnett,D.B. Effective virtual new product development teams:An integrated framework. Journal of Business & Industrial Marketing,20082,3(4) :242-248
[76]Sundstrom,P.,& Zika-Viktorsson ,A. Organizing for innovation in a product development project :Combining innovative and result oriented ways of working-A case study.International Journal of Project Management,20092,7(8) :745-753
[77]De Dreu,C.K.W.When too little or too much hurts: Evidence for a curvilinear relationship between task conflict and innovation in teams.Journal of Management,2006,32(1) :83-107
[78]Tjosvold,D.,Tang,M.M.L.,& West,M. Reflexivity for team innovation in China:The contribution of goal interdependence. Group & Organization Management,2004,29(5) :540-559
[79]Cabrera A,and Cabrera E F. Knowledge-sharing dilemmas. Organization Studies,2002, 23(5) :687-710
[80]Bodtker A M ,and Jameson K J. Emotion in conflict formation and its transformatioin: application to organizational conflict management. International Journal of Conflict Management,2001,12:259-275
[81] Karen A .Jehn,Elizabeth A .Mannix.The dynamic nature of conflict:A longitudinal-l study of intra-group conflict and group performance. Academy of management. Journal,2001,11:231-254
[82]Mark Mortensen , Pamela J Hinds.Conflict and shared identity in geographically distributed team[J].International Journal of Conflict Mangement,2001,(12) :212-239
[83]Allen C.Amason. Distinguishing the effects of functional and dysfunctional conflict on strategic decision making:resolving a paradox for top management teams [J].Academy of management journal,1996,(39) :123-148
[84]Pirola-Merlo,A.&Mann ,L. The relationship between individual creativity and team creativity:Aggregating across people and time[J].Journal of Organizational Behavior,2004,25(2) :235-257
[85]杨志蓉.团队快速信任-互动行为与团队创造力研究[D] .浙江大学,2006