摘要
近年来狂犬病的发生呈逐年上升的趋势,原因是多方面的,但是免疫程序不科学、缺乏免疫监测和免疫质量得不到保证仍是主要的原因。因此,调查了解湖南省犬狂犬病的流行情况、开展狂犬病的监测、制订出科学的免疫程序、确保免疫质量和摸索出有效的防控措施是湖南省防控狂犬病亟待解决的问题。
对2003-2007年湖南犬饲养数量、免疫情况、疫情发生情况、疫情监测及疫情处置情况的调查表明,湖南近五年来犬狂犬病疫情较严重,疫点多,地域分布广,犬的常年存栏量和免疫数量均呈逐年上升趋势,但犬整体免疫率低,2007年湖南整体免疫率只有36.51%,与国际公认的70-75%常年免疫率形成免疫屏障的水平还相差很远。
对湖南部分地域的8个县(市)区的8个城区、乡镇和农村的健康犬抽样采集脑组织标本142份,应用RT-PCR和直接荧光抗体试验(FAT)检测,检测结果142份犬脑样中均不含狂犬病病毒。调查上述监测点及周边近三年狂犬病的免疫情况,免疫率均超过70%。表明湖南部分犬免疫工作较好的地区,通过加大群免疫密度,可以使犬狂犬病病毒携带率降低,这可能与形成免疫屏障有关。
对湖南长沙市区及其他部分市州的农村地区随机抽取的156份犬血清用ELISA检测狂犬病抗体,结果显示这些地区犬免疫后抗体阳转率较低,平均为32.05%,各县(区)犬狂犬病抗体阳性率存在一定差别,较低的犬狂犬病抗体阳性率可能是湖南省外观健康犬带毒的原因之一,与人间狂犬病发病率对比发现犬狂犬病抗体阳性率与疫苗种类等情况,得出犬免疫后抗体阳性合格率城区比农村高、1岁以上的犬比1岁以内犬高、进口单联苗比国产单联苗及多联苗高。这些结果可能与疫苗的质量、免疫操作、免疫程序有关。
控制狂犬病的基本策略是控制动物狂犬病。因此,加强湖南的动物狂犬病免疫工作,特别是加大犬的免疫覆盖率,同时对家犬进行狂犬病抗体监测,对指导犬狂犬病免疫的制订狂犬病防控措施有重要意义。掌握湖南狂犬病的流行特点,为狂犬病的防制提供更为准确的动物流行病学资料,为制订狂犬病综合防制措施提供科学依据。
There were many factors for the trend that the incidence of rabies increased year after year, mainly, unscientific vaccination program, lack of immunization surveillance and lack of guarantees for the quality of vaccine products. It was urgent need to solved the problem such as investigating the prevalence of canine rabies, surveying the hunan rabies, working out scientific immunization procedures, ensuring the quality of vaccination and exploring effective ways to prevent and control rabies in Hunan Province.
According to the investigation results that the number of dog raising, immunization, the occurrence of the epidemic, the epidemic surveillance and disposition during the year 2003 to 2007 in Hunan Province, the epidemic situation of canine rabies is much more serious and distributed in wide geographical areas. The population quantity of dogs all the year round and the number of immuned dogs were gradually increased in the past five years, but the low coverage in dogs as a whole in Hunan Province in 2007 was only 36.51%, much lower than internationally recognized 70%-75% to form the immune barrier.
In order to investigate the virus carrying state and test antibody level of vaccinated dogs in Hunan, 142 healthy looking dog brain tissue samples were tested from eight counties (cities) in eight urban and rural districts in Hunan. The RT-PCR and direct fluorescent antibody test (FAT) results showed that there no rabies virus was found in the 142 dog brain samples. Investigation for rabies immunization of the above surveillance areas and the surrounding areas, the average coverage was higher than 70%.the number of carrying state dogs could be decreased in the areas where good vaccination program was undertaken. It was shown that the raising coverage of the dog population may resulted in the formation of immunological barrier.
For the ELISA test of rabies antibody on the 156 dogs, the sera were randomly collected from some urban and rural areas of Changsha, Hunan Province, and the result shown that firstly, the seroconversion was low after vaccination in some areas in Hunan Province, only 32.05% in average. Secondly, there were certain differences in canine positive antibody rate among the counties (districts). Thirdly, the lower antibody positive rate in canine may be one of the reasons that the healthy looking dogs carry virus in Hunan Province. Fourthly, compared with the rabies incidence of hunan, a negative correlation between the dog antibody positive rate and hunan rabies incidence rate was found. Comparing different regions, age groups, sexes,the vaccines used and so on, it was found that more vaccinated dogs showed acceptable antibody titer in urban areas than in rural areas, dogs at age of 1 year old or above showed higher antibody titer than dogs younger than 1 year old, imported mono vaccine or combined vaccine gave better antibody titer than domestic products, These results might be related to the quality of vaccines, immunization operations, and immunization programs.
Controlling animal rabies was the basic strategy to control the hunan rabies, Thus it is important to strengthen the animal immunization work in Hunan province, especially maintain high coverage in dogs, carry on surveillance of rabies immune antibody to the domestic dogs for setting up rabies vaccination program and for the guidance of rabies prevention and control. It is more suitable for large-scale antibody surveillance in order to understand the epidemiology of the rabies and provide exact and scientific epidemiological data for drawing comprehensive control measures.
引文
[1]殷震,刘景华主编.动物病毒学[M].第二版,北京:科学出版社,1997,777-795
[2]Waterson A P.Introductiontothehistory of virologs,[M].Cambridge Univ.Press,1978,1(3):53-59
[3]Harrison T R.Viral infection of Humans[M].New York:Plenum Medical Company,1989:509-524
[4]李伟,张曼夫,王树蕙.狂犬病分子流行病学的研究进展[J].中国兽医杂志,1999,5(25):48-49
[5]Elizabeth M B,Lorraine M M,Paul L,et al.Molecular methods to distinguish between classical rabies and the rabies-related European bat lyssaviruses[J].Journal of Virological Methods,2000,87:123-131
[6]林放涛.狂犬病学[M].福州.福建科学技术出版社,1992,3-21
[7]William H W,Tovi K L,,Bernhard D,et al.The molecularbiology of rabies viruses.Reviews of infectious diseases[J],1998,4(10):777-784
[8]Harufusa,Toriumi,Akihiko K.Association of rabies virus nominal phosphoprotein(P) with Virul nucleocapsid(CN) is enhanced by phosphorylation of the Viral nucleoprotein(N)[J].Microbiol,Immunol,48(5):399-404
[9]Xianfu Wu,Xiaoming Gong,Heather D,Foley,Matthias J.Schnell,and Zhen F.Fu.Both viral transcription and replication are reduced when rabies virus nucleoprotein is not phosphorylated[J].Journal of Virology,2002,4153-4161
[10]Jacob Y,Real E,Tordo N.Functional interaction map of lyssavirus phosphoprotein identification of the minimal transcription domain[J].J Virol,2001,75(20):9613-9622
[11]唐青,杨为松.狂犬病毒分子生物学及遗传变异性研究进展[J].中国人兽共患病杂志1999,15(2):77-81
[12]Reid-sanden.F,Sumner J,Smith J.Fekadu M.Rabies Diagnostic Reagents Prepared from a rabies N gene recombinant expressed in baculovirus[J].Clin Microbiology,1990,858-863
[13]Poch D,Blumberg BM.Sequence comparison of five polymerases(L protein) of unsegmented negative-strand RNA virus[J].J Gen.Virol,1990,71:1153-1157
[14]张建明,严延生.狂犬病病毒的基因分型及其分子流行病学研究进展[J].中国人兽共患病学报,2006,22(3):271
[15]Tordo H,Poch A,Ermine,et al.Primary structure of leader RNA and nucleoprotein genes of zhe rabies genome:segmented homology with VSV[J].Nucleic Acids Res,1986,14:2671-1683
[16]Bourhy H,Kissi B,Tordo N.Molecular diversity of the Lyssavirus genus[J].Virology,1993,194(1):79-81
[17]Skerratt LF,Speare R,Berger L,et al.Lyssaviral infection and lead poisoning in black flying foxes from Queensland[J].J Wildl Dis,1998,34(2):355-361
[18]de Mattos CA,de Mattos CC,Rupprecht CE.Rhabdoviruese.In:Kinpe DM Howley PM.Fields Virology 4th ed[M].Voll.Philadephia:Lipponcott Williams & Wilkins,2001:1245-1257
[19]WHO.World survey of rabies No 35 for the year 1999
[20]Vos A.Oral vaccination against rabies and the behavioural ecology of the red fox (Vulpesvulpes)[J].J Vet Med B Infect Dis Vet Public Health,2003,50(10):83-477
[21]Gremillion-SmithC,Woolf A.Epizootiology of skunk rabies in North America[J].J Wildl Dis,1988,24(4):6-20.
[22]Nadin-Davis S A,Muldoon F,Wandeler AI.A molecular epidemiological analysis of the incursion of the raccoon strain of rabies virus into Canada[J].Epidemiol Infect,2005,5:1-14.
[23]朱凤才,祖荣强,吴扬生,等.江苏省1990-2000年狂犬病流行情况及防制对策分析[J].中华流行病学杂志,2001,22(1):14-16
[24]陈阳,李功忠,黄秀蒙,等.病区和非病区犬感染狂犬病毒调查[J].中国人畜共患病杂志,1993,9(5):17
[25]王炜红,李滨香,佟继红,等.狂犬病暴露后隐性感染的研究[J].中国人畜共患病杂志,1998,14(2):70
[26]杨守平,刑教杰.与“健康犬”密切接触致狂犬病一例[J].中国传染病杂志,1995,13(2):72
[27]蔡宝祥.我国狂犬病研究进展[J].畜牧与兽医,1994,26(25):226-233
[28]褚菊仁.对我国流行原因的思考[J].中国人畜共患病杂志,1989,5(6):37
[29]唐宜栓,姜玉亭,蔡素洁.外观健康犬狂犬病毒感染分布调查[J].预防医学文献信息,1997,3(1):26
[30]靳风鸣,王孟千.狂犬病[J].黑龙江省卫生防疫站,1995,94-104
[31]杨家增.关于狂犬病传播问题的探讨[J].中国兽医杂志,1992,18(3):28-31
[32]唐婕,李六金,陈铁桥.狂犬病研究动态[J].动物医学进展,2006,27(7):100-104
[33]Smith JS,Orciari LA,Yager HD,et al.Epidemiological and historical relationship among 87 rabies virus isolates as detemined by limited sequence analysis[J].J Infect Dis,1992,160:296-307
[34]Davis PL,Bourhy H,Holmes EC.The evolutionary history and dynamics of bat rabies virus.Infect Genet Evol,2006,6(6):464-473
[35]Warner CK,Schurr TG,Fekadu M.Molecular characterization of carrier rabies isolates[J].Virus Res,1996,41(2):133-140
[36]钱爱东,侯世宽,张茂林等,1996.狂犬病病毒糖蛋白基因主要功能区的克隆和序列比较分析.中国兽医学报,16(6):554-560.
[37]古漓,王树声,CA De Mattos,等.广西狂犬病病毒街毒株的分子流行病学分析[J]中华实验和临床病毒学杂志,2001,15(4):335-338
[38]徐葛林,Li Ku,吴杰,等.中国19个狂犬病病毒街毒株N基因的序列分析[J].病毒学报,2002,18(1):48
[39]扈荣良,狂犬病理论、技术与防治[M],北京:科学出版社,2007:19-29.
[40]World Health Organization.Strategies for zhe control and elimination of rabies in Aisa[M].Geneva:Switzerland,2001:2
[41]谢世宏.狂犬病防控守册[M].四川:科学技术出版社,2003:19
[42]Pastoret PP,Brochier B.Epidemiology and control of fox rabies in Europe[J].Vaccine,1999,17(13-14):1750
[43]McColl KA,Tordo N,Aguilar Setien AA.Bat lyssavirus infections[J].Rev Sei Tech,2000,19(1):177
[44]俞永新.狂犬病和狂犬病疫苗[M].北京:中国医药出版社,2001:127-142
[45]胡静,王志高.江苏省狂犬病40年流行特征分析[J].现代预防医学,1997,24(3):315-316
[46]唐青,赵秀芹,陶晓霞.中国人间狂犬病流行近况分析[J].中华流行病学杂志,2001,22(1):8-10
[47]俞永新.人和动物狂犬病防治措施研究进展[J].中国人兽共患病杂志,1998,14(4):56-60
[48]张永振,肖东楼,孙玉辉,等.中国1984-2002年狂犬病流行情况及防制对策[J].中华流行病学杂志,2003,24(10):883-886
[49]郭绶衡,李俊华.湖南省50年来人间狂犬病流行趋势分析[J].中国热带医学,2002,2(1):94-96
[50]肖奇友,王祥迪,康肃邦,等.湖南省近十年狂犬病流行情况分析[J].中华流行病学杂志,2005,6(26):428-430
[51]许真,唐青,宋淼,等.2005年中国人间狂犬病流行特征及分析[J].疾病监测,2006,21(7):361
[52]王晓春.湖南狂犬病流行病学调查分析[J].中国动物检疫,2006,6(23):45-46
[53]中国人民解放军兽医大学.人兽共患病学(上册)[M].1993.21-45.
[47]俞永新.人和动物狂犬病防制研究进展[J].中国人兽共患病杂志,1998,14(4):56-60.
[54]侯世宽,岳军明,张茂林,等.动物狂犬病口服疫苗株的筛选、鉴定及实验免疫研究[J].中国人兽共患病杂志,1995,12(6):347-351.
[55]周桂兰,祝俊杰,赵景义,等.国产狂犬病疫苗免疫抗体监测试验报告[J].当代畜牧,2004,6:36-37.
[56]熊毅,刘棋,朱伟,等.广西狂犬病分子流行病学的研究[A].全国人畜共患病学术研讨会论文集[C].2006.102-105.
[57]TeshomeMebatsion.ExtensiveAttenuation of RabiesVirus by Sim2ultaneouslyModifying the Dynein Light Chain Binding Site in the PProtein and Rep lacingArg333 in the G Protein[J].J Virol,2001,75(23):11496-11502.
[58]张德礼.狂犬病疫苗的研究动向[J].中国畜禽传染病,1994,6:52-55.
[59]Follmann EH,RitterDG,Baer GM,et al.Oral Rabies Vaccinationof Arctic Foxes(A lopex lagopus) with an Attenuated Vaccine[J].Vaccine,1992,10(5):305-308.
[60]董关木.狂犬病的防治、疫苗和抗血清的安全性探讨[A].全国人畜共患病学术研讨会论文集[C].2006.108-111.
[61]刘宝全.兽医生物制品学[M].北京:中国农业出版社,1997.239-242.
[62]DavidW,Dreesen.A global Review of Rabies Vaccines for Hu2man Use[J].Vaccine,Supp 1.1997,15:2-6.
[63]俞永新.狂犬病和狂犬病疫苗[M].北京:中国医药科技出版社,2001.163.
[64]Kondo A,Takashima Y,Suzuki M.Inactivated rabies vaccineof chick embryo cell culture origin,In Symposia series inimmunobiological standardization,1974,21:182-189.
[65]Widtor TJ,Sokol F,Koprowski H.Immunogenicity of concentratedand purified rabies vaccine of tissue culture origin[J].Proc Soc Exp Biol Med,1969,131:799-805.
[66]Fournier P,Montagnon B,Vincent - Falquet JC,et al.A newvaccine produced from rabies virns cultivated on Vero cells.In:Vodopija et al eds.Improvements in rabies post-exposuretreatment[J].Zagreb Institute of Public Health,1985,115 121.
[67]Lin FT,Zeng FZ,Lu LM,et al.The primary hamster kidneycell rabies vaccine:adaption of viral strain,production ofvaccine,and postexposure treatment[J].J Infect Dis,1983,147(3):467-473.
[68]陆隆沫,俞永新,梁名奕,等.地鼠肾组织培养狂犬病灭活疫苗健康人群接种反应观察和血清抗体测定[J].病毒学集刊,1982,281-86.
[69]Lin Fangtao.The protective effect of the large-scale use of PHKC rabies vaccine in human in China[J].Bullletin WHO.1990,68(4):44-454.
[70]董关木,刘增顺,郑海发,等.精制地鼠肾细胞狂犬病疫苗的效果观察[J].中国生物制品学杂志,1999,12(3):181-183
[71]严子林,韩秀娟,纪元吉,等.狂犬病在小鼠和人二倍体细体细胞上传代和适应[J].中国微生物和免疫学杂志,1983,3(5):305-307.
[72]肖泽帅,阎长青,俞永新.狂犬固定病毒人二倍体细体细胞适应株生物学性质的研究[J].中华微生物学和免疫学,1981,1(4):245-250.
[73]乐威,何春辉,夏智,等.人用狂犬病纯化疫苗(Vero细胞)临床观察及免疫学效果研究[J].中国人兽共患病杂志,2002,18(1):62-64.
[74]刘增顺,郑海发,董关木.国产新型人用狂犬病疫苗临床观察及免疫学效果评价[J].中华流行病学杂志,2001,22(1):20-22.
[75]张玉慧,高春润,潘广或,等.狂犬病病毒CTN株不同代次在Vero细胞培养的病毒滴度和免疫原性的比较[J].中国生物制品学杂志,1998,2:90-92.
[76]Kieny MP,Lathe R,Orillien R,et al.Expression of rabiesvirus glycoprotein from a recombinant vaccinia virus[J].Nature(London),1984,312:163.
[77]Hanlon CA,Niezgoda M,Hamir AN,et al.First North Americanfield release of a vaccinia-rabies glycoprotein recombinant virus[J].J Wild Dis.1998,34(2):228.
[78]Roscoe DE,Hoste WC,Sorhage FE,et al.Efficacy of an oralvaccinia-rabies glycoprotein recombinant vaccine in controlling epidemic raccoon rabies in NewJersey[J].J Wild Dis,1998,34(4):752.
[79]Oslon CA,Wemer PA.Oral rabies vaccine contact bY raccoonsand nontarget species in a field trial in Floride[J].JWild Dis,1999,35(4):687.
[80]李萍,胡巧玲,孙朝晖,等.表达狂犬病毒糖蛋白的非复制型重组痘苗病毒的构建与鉴定[J].中华实验和临床病毒学杂志,1999,13(2):170.
[81]李萍(导师朱家鸿,阮力).非复制载体表达狂犬病毒糖蛋白和核蛋白的实验研究.博士论文,卫生部武汉生物制品研究所.1999.
[82]Wolff JA,Malone RW,Williama P,et al.Direct gene transferinto mouse muscle in vivo[J].Science,1990,247:1465.
[83]Xiang ZQ,Spitalnike SL,Tran M,et al.Vaccination with aplasmid vector carrying the rabies virus glycoprotein geneinduces protective immunity against rabies virus[J].Virology,1994,199:132.
[84]Le Blois H,Tufferean C,Blancou J,et al.Oral immunization offoxes with avirulent rabies virus mutants[J].Vet Microbiol,1990,23:159.
[85]林海祥,Perrin P.皮卡狂犬病疫苗的实验研究[J].中国生物制品学,1998,11(3):137-139.
[86]熊仲良,江禹,罗明,等.重庆地区2004年12月~2005年4月犬狂犬病流行毒 株的检测[J].中国人兽共患病学报,2006,22(1):85-88
[87]Smith J S.Manual of Clinical Microbiology[M].Washington,DC:American Society for Microbiology,1995,997-1003
[88]涂长春,我国狂犬病流行现状及原因[J],动物保健,2006.8:11-12
[89]张永振,熊成龙,邹洋,等.湖南省武岗市洞口县狂犬病流行病研究[J].中华流行病学杂志,2006,27(7):583-588
[90]刘浩,江禹,王莉莉等.湖南湘西地区外观健康犬携带狂犬病病毒的调查研究[J].中国动物检疫,2007,24(6)17-19
[91]陆家华,吴泰才.广西45年狂犬病疫情动态与防制效果分析[J].疾病监,1997,12(11):10-14
[92]沈悦,孙泉云,鞠龚讷,等.上海地区犬狂犬病毒抗体的血清学调查[J]上海畜牧兽医通讯,2004(1):19
[93]应小飞,母安雄,陈玉华,等.杭州地区养殖犬狂犬病的血清学调查[J].浙江畜牧兽医,2006(2):21
[94]艾智武,肖鼎昌.狂犬病毒抗原刺激小鼠的细胞免疫反应试验[J].中国人兽共患病杂志,2000,16(3):63
[95]Hooper D C,Morimoto K,Betle M,et al.Collaboration of antibody and inflammation in clearance ofrabies virus from zhe central system[J].J Virol,1998,72:3711-3719
[96]王明俊等.兽医生物制品学[M].北京:中国农业出版社,1996,683
[97]甘甲忠(导师邹思湘,刘棋).广西玉林市犬狂犬病流行病学调查与防控.硕士论文,南京农业大学.
[98]张险朋,周萍,郭霄峰等.广东省东莞市犬狂犬病的流行病学调查[J].中国兽医科学,2008,38(06):365-368.