民营企业经理人角色压力对工作满意度影响的实证研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
经理人的压力是影响其工作满意度的重要因素之一,也是管理学界关注的重要问题之一。在众多压力源中,角色压力是中国经理人最主要的压力来源。国内外现有的研究对企业经理人角色压力的前因和后果进行了有益的解释,指出了角色压力与消极的工作状态有关。但是,对角色压力传导向消极工作态度的作用机制研究尚有待进一步完善。
     民营企业因其数量众多、规模偏小、管理体系不规范、外部融资困难等特征而面临更为激烈的市场竞争,其经理人角色压力尤为突出。针对民营企业经理人角色压力和工作状态之间关系的研究对于解释角色压力中介机制具有重要的理论建构意义,更有利于提高经理人的工作满意度。
     本文力图解决民营企业经理人角色压力是如何影响其工作满意度这一科学问题。文章主体分为四个部分。首先,通过文献综述,梳理了中国经理人及角色压力的研究现状,明确以民营企业的经理人和企业主为研究对象。其次,以角色情节理论和组织支持感理论为基础构建经理人角色压力与情绪、工作满意度和企业主对经理人角色压力认知关系的研究模型。再次,基于文献构建角色压力、情绪和工作满意度等基础变量,并检验其量表的信度和效度。组织问卷调查获取了92家民营企业数据。最后,从企业主和经理人双方的角度,分析经理人角色压力与工作满意度变量之间的相互关系,验证了情绪对于角色压力作用于工作满意度的过程的调节的中介影响。
     研究结果表明:(1)角色压力对经理人工作满意度具有显著负向影响;(2)基于情绪二元观点,情绪在经理人角色压力与工作满意度之间具有中介作用;(3)基于组织支持感理论,企业主对经理人角色压力的认知对经理人的角色压力和情绪具有调节作用;(4)基于角色赋予者和接收者双方的视角,情绪对于角色压力作用于工作满意度的过程具有调节的中介影响。
     基于以上结果,本文提出如下建议:(1)重视并采取措施缓解经理人的角色压力是解决经理人满意度问题的重要手段;(2)干预消极情绪、提升积极情绪是提高经理人满意度的有效方法;(3)应该关注企业主对经理人角色压力的认知;(4)让经理人拥有正能量是经理人应对角色负荷的关键;(5)经理人对自己角色清晰程度的认知更依赖自己的感受和判断。
Role stress is one of the important influence factors of job satisfaction ofmanagers,and also is the important problems of management research. Role stress isthe important sources of stress. Although many studies discover that role stress isrelated to negative working conditions, there is still room for improvement.
     The private enterprises are numerous, small scale and external financingdifficulties, which management system is not standard.Therefore the stress role ofthe managers is Serious. This research has theoretical significance in revealing themediation mechanism of role stress, the so called black box; and it is also ofsignificance in determining the effect boundary of role stress; it also providesguidance for achieving the management practice of mutual benefit and cooperationbetween private enterprise owners and managers in China.
     The science problem is the relationship between the stress role of mangers andthe job satisfactory.The research has four parts. Firstly, we combed through manyarticles for the current situation of the stess role of managers. Secondly, based onAffective Events Theory, and Organizational Support Theory, it construct atheoretical model.Thirdly, through the revision to the scale of role stress, affect,and job satisfactory based on the literature research it finally forms thequestionnaire.After the empirical investigation and study from92private enterprisesin China, results show that the questionnaire has good reliability and validity.Finally, it evaluates the mediation effect of positive and negative mood, and themoderating effect of enterprise owner’s perception of manager’s role stress on theabove mentioned relationship.
     The results are as follows:(1) Role stress will negatively affect managers’jobsatisfaction;(2) Mood (including positive and negative mood) mediate betweenrole stress and job satisfaction;(3)the relationship between role stress and mood ofmanager will be moderated by enterprise owner’s perception of manager’s role stress,(4) The higher enterprise owner thinks manager’s role stress is, the stronger the negative correlation between manager’s role stress and mood is; enterprise ownerthinks the higher manager’s role stress is, the stronger mood mediates therelationship between manager’s role stress and job satisfaction.
     Based on the results the main conclusions are as follows:(1) Organizationshould adopt various measures to cope with role stress to improve the jobsatisfactory;(2) One way to increase manager’s job satisfaction is to improve hispositive mood;(3) Pay close attention to the owner’s perception of manager’s rolestress;(4) One way to increase manager’s positive mood is to improve his stressload;(5) The perception of the work role to the managers themselves depend ontheir own feelings and judgment.
引文
Abdel-Halim A A. Personality and Task Moderators of Subordinate Responses to Perceived LeaderBehavior. Human Relations,1981,34(1):73-88.
    Alfred J.Kahn. Prognosis: anxiety. Society,1964,1(3):22.
    Anton C.The impact of role stress on workers’ behavior through job satisfaction and organizationalcommitment. International Journal of Psychology,2009,44(3):187-194.
    Barling J,Macintyre A T.Daily work role stressors, mood and emotional exhaustion. Work&Stress,1993,7(4):315-325.
    Baron R M,Kenny D A. The moderator-mediator variable distinction in social psychological research:Conceptual, strategic, and statistical consideration. Journal of Personality and SocialPsychology,1986,51(6):1173-1182.
    Baroudi J Impact of role variables on IS personnel work attitudes and intentions.MISQuarterly,1985,(9):341-357.
    Beal A L.Post-traumatic stress disorder in prisoners of war and combat veterans of the Dieppe Raid: A50-year follow-up. Canadian Journal of Psychiatry,2006,(4):177-184.
    Bhalla S,Jones B,Flynn D M.Role stress among Canadian white-collar workers. Work&Stress,1991,(4):289-299.
    Biddle M. New Directions. Expedition,1979,21(2):3.
    Brannan S K.B-Adrenergic receptor changes in learned helplessness may depend on stress and testparameters. Pharmacology, Biochemistry and Behavior,1995,51(2-3):553-556.
    Bravo M,Farid H.Object segmentation by top-down processes. Visual Cognition,2003,10(4):471-492.
    Chang E C,Sanna L Optimism, accumulated life stress, and psychological and physical adjustment: Is Italways adaptive to expect the best. Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology,2003,22(1):97-115.
    Chung O K,Ohm J B,Guo A M,et al.Free Lipids in Air-Classified High-Protein Fractions of Hard WinterWheat Flours and Their Effects on Breadmaking Quality1. Cereal chemistry,2002,79(6):774-778.
    Coelho F,Augusto M,Lages L F.Contextual factors and the creativity of frontline employees: The mediatingeffects of role stress and intrinsic motivation. Journal of Retailing,2011,87(1):31-45.
    Cordes C L,Dougherty T W.A review and an integration of research on job burnout. Academy ofmanagement review,1993,18(4):621-656.
    Coverman,S.Role overload, role conflict, and stress: Addressing consequences of multiple role demands.Social Forces,1989,67(4):965-982.
    Davis M H,Conklin L,Smith A,et al.Effect of perspective taking on the cognitive representation of persons:a merging of self and other. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,1996,70(4):713-726.
    De Ruyter K,Wetzels M G M.The impact of perceived listening behavior in voice-to-voice serviceencounters.Journal of Service Research,2000,2(3):276-28.
    Deluga R J,Winters J J.The impact of role ambiguity and conflict on resident assistants. Journal of CollegeStudent Development.1990,31(3):230-236.
    Dube S,Spicer T,Bryz-Gornia V,et al.A rapid and sensitive method of identification of HTLV-II subtypes.Journal of medical virology,1995,45(1):1-9.
    Edwards Chris,Lambert Rob.Changing Course.Accountancy,2007,140(1368):46-47.
    Eisenberger R,Huntington R,Hutchisom S,et al.Perceived Organizational Support.Journal of AppliedPsychology,1986,71(2):500~507.
    Elovainio M,Kivim ki M.The effects of personal need for structure and occupational identity in the rolestress process.The Journal of social psychology,2001,141(3):365-378.
    Fisher C D,Ashkanasy N M.The emerging role of emotions in work Life: An introduction. Journal ofOrganizational Behavior,2000,21(2):123-129.
    Fogarty T J.of Burnout in Accounting: Beyond the Role Stress Model. Behavioral Research inAccounting,2000,12:31-68.
    Forgas J P,Moylan S.After the movies transient mood and social judgments. Personality and SocialPsychology Bulletin,1987,13(4):467-477.
    Frey D,Stahlberg D,Fries A.Information seeking of high-and low-anxiety subjects after receiving positiveand negative self-relevant feedback. Journal of Personality,1986,54(4):694-703.
    Fridja N.Moods, emotion episodes, and emotions. Handbook of emotions,1993:381-404.
    Garrosa E,Moreno-Jiménez B,Rodríguez-Mu oz A,et al.Role stress and personal resources in nursing: Across-sectional study of burnout and engagement.International Journal of NursingStudies,2011,48(4):479-489.
    Ghorbani N,Watson P J,Morris R J.Personality, stress and mental health: evidence of relationships in asample of Iranian managers.Personality and Individual Differences,2000,28(4):647-657.
    Gila M.Acker,Dorothea Lawrence.Social Work and Managed Care Measuring Competence, Burnout, andRole Stress of Workers Providing Mental Health Services in a Managed Care Era.Journal of SocialWork,2009,9(3):269-283.
    Gil-Monte P R,Valcaárcel P,Zornoza A.Role stress: Burnout antecedent in nursing professionals.TheEuropean Work and Organizational Psychologist,1993,3(3):217-227.
    Grunberg L,Moore S,Greenberg E S.Work stress and problem alcohol behavior: a test of the spillovermodel.Journal of Organizational Behavior,1998,19(5):487-502.
    Hans Solli-S ther.Transplants’ Role Stress and Work Outcome in IT Outsourcing Relationships.IndustrialManagement&Data Systems,2011,111(2):227-245.
    Hansung Kim PhDMSW,Madeleine Stoner PhD.(2008).Burnout and turnover intention among socialworkers effects of role stress, job autonomy and social support.Administration in Social Work,32(3),5-25.
    Hartenian L S,Hadaway F J,Badovick G J.Antecedents and consequences of role perceptions: A pathanalytic approach.Journal of Applied Business Research (JABR),2011,10(2):40-50.
    Hoppock R.Job satisfaction.1935.
    House R J,Rizzo J R.Role conflict and ambiguity as critical variables in a model of organizationalbehavior.Organizational Behavior and Human Performance,1972,7(3):467-505.
    Hughes J.N.,Cavell T.A.,Prasad-Gaur A.A Positive View of Peer Acceptance in Aggressive Youth Risk forFuture Peer Acceptance. Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology,2001,39(3):239-252.
    Igou E,Bless H,Schwarz N.Making sense of standardized survey questions: The influence of referenceperiods and their repetition. Communication Monographs,2002,69(2):179-187.
    Iverson R D,Deery S J,Erwin P J.Absenteeism in the health services sector: A causal model and interventionstrategies.Managing absenteeism: Analysing and preventing labour absence,1995,18:257-294.
    Jackson S E,Schuler R S.A meta-analysis and conceptual critique of research on role ambiguity and roleconflict in work settings. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,1985,36(1):16-78.
    Jennifer Brown,Jennifer Grover. The role of moderating variables between stressor exposure and beingdistressed in a sample of serving police officers. Personality and Individual Differences,1998,24(2):181-185.
    Johlke M C,Duhan D F,Howell R D,et al.An integrated model of sales managers’ communicationpractices.Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science,2000,28(2):263-277.
    Johnson E J, Tversky A.Affect, generalization, and the perception of risk. Journal of Personality and SocialPsychology,1983,45(1):20-31.
    Jung H S,Yoon H H.Is the individual or the organization the cause of hotel employees’ stress? Alongitudinal study on differences in role stress between subjects. International Journal of HospitalityManagement,2013,33:494-499.
    Kahn R L,Wolfe D M,Quinn R P,et al.Organizational stress: Studies in role conflict and ambiguity.1964.
    Kim B C P,Murrmann S K,Lee G.Moderating effects of gender and organizational level between role stressand job satisfaction among hotel employee. International Journal of HospitalityManagement,2009,28:612-619.
    Kim H,Stoner M.Burnout and turnover intention among social workers: Effects of role stress, job autonomyand social support.Administration in Social Work,2008,32(3):5-25.
    King L A,Emmons R A.Conflict over emotional expression: psychological and physical correlates.Journalof personality and social psychology,1990,58(5):864-877.
    Kinicki A J,Vecchio R P.Influences on the quality of supervisor–subordinate relations: The role of time‐pressure, organizational commitment, and locus of control. Journal of OrganizationalBehavior,1994,15(1):75-82.
    Koeske G F,Kirk S A,Koeske R D.Coping with job stress: Which strategies work best?. Journal ofOccupational and Organizational Psychology,1993,66(4):319-335.
    LAGACE R R.Role-stress differences between salesmen and saleswomen: Effect on job satisfaction andperformance. Psychological Reports,1988,62(3):815-825.
    Lambert E G,Hogan N L,Tucker K A.Problems at work: Exploring the correlates of role stress amongcorrectional staff.The Prison Journal,2009,89(4):460-481.
    Lambert E G,Lynne Hogan N,Barton S M.The impact of job satisfaction on turnover intent: a test of astructural measurement model using a national sample of workers.The Social ScienceJournal,2001,38(2):233-250.
    Lanza di Scalea T,Matthews K A,Avis N E,et al.Role Stress, Role Reward, and Mental Health in aMultiethnic Sample of Midlife Women: Results from the Study of Women's Health Across the Nation(SWAN).Journal of Women's Health,2012,21(5):481-489.
    Lawler E E,Hall D T.Relationship of job characteristics to job involvement, satisfaction, and intrinsicmotivation.Journal of Applied psychology,1970,54(4):305.
    Leiter M P,Maslach C.The impact of interpersonal environment on burnout and organizationalcommitment.Journal of organizational behavior,1988,9(4):297-308.
    LeRouge C,Nelson A,Blanton J E.The impact of role stress fit and self-esteem on the job attitudes of ITprofessionals.Information&management,2006,43(8):928-938.
    Leung K,Huang K L,Su C H,et al.Curvilinear relationships between role stress and innovative performance:Moderating effects of perceived support for innovation.Journal of Occupational and OrganizationalPsychology,2011,84(4):741-758.
    Levinson H.Reciprocation: The relationship between man and organization. Administrative sciencequarterly,1965,9(4):370—390.
    Lewis L M,Dember W N,Schefft B K,et al.Can experimentally induced mood affect optimism andpessimism scores?.Current psychology,1995,14(1):29-41.
    Lindberg E, Wincent J.Goal Commitment and Performance; An Empirical Study Incorporating Role-StressLiterature to Reveal Functional and Dysfunctional Influences.Journal of Applied SocialPsychology,2011,41(11):2634–2655.
    Liou K T.Role stress and job stress among detention care workers.Criminal Justice andBehavior,1995,22(4):425-436.
    Long-Zeng Wu,Eliza Ching-Yick Tse,Pingping Fu,Ho Kwong Kwan,Jun Liu.The Impact of ServantLeadership on Hotel Employees.―Servant Behavior‖Cornell Hospitality Quarterly,2013,(4):1-13.
    Love K M,Tatman A W,Chapman B P.Role stress, interrole conflict, and job satisfaction among universityemployees: The creation and test of a model.Journal of employment counseling,2010,47(1):30-37.
    Lu J L.Organizational Role Stress Indices Affecting Burnout among Nurses.Journal of InternationalWomen's Studies,2008,9(3):63-78.
    Madera J M,Dawson M,Neal J A.Hotel managers’ perceived diversity climate and job satisfaction: Themediating effects of role ambiguity and conflict.International Journal of HospitalityManagement,2013,35:28-34.
    Madjar N,Oldham G R,Pratt M G.There's no place like home? The contributions of work and nonworkcreativity support to employees' creative performance.Academy of ManagementJournal,2002,45(4):757-767.
    Matthews R A,Bulger C A,Barnes-Farrell J L.Work social supports, role stressors, and work–family conflict:The moderating effect of age.Journal of Vocational Behavior,2010,76(1):78-90.
    McVicar A.Workplace stress in nursing: a literature review.Journal of advancednursing,2003,44(6):633-642.
    Mohr A T,Puck J F.Role Conflict, General Manager Job Satisfaction and Stress and the Performance ofIJVs.European Management Journal,2007,25(1):25-35.
    Moore J E.One road to turnover: An examination of work exhaustion in technology professionals.MisQuarterly,2000:141-168.
    Netemeyer R G,Johnston M W,Burton S.Analysis of role conflict and role ambiguity in a structuralequations framework.Journal of Applied Psychology,1990,75(2):148-157.
    Orpen C.The Effect of Urbanization on Sources of Job Satisfaction among Black Supervisors in SouthAfrica.The Journal of Social Psychology,1977,101(2):307-308.
    Piko B F.Burnout, role conflict, job satisfaction and psychosocial health among Hungarian health care staff:a questionnaire survey.International journal of nursing studies,2006,43(3):311-318.
    Porter L W,Lawler E E,Hackman J R.Behavior in organizations.1975.
    Rebele J E,Michaels R E.Independent auditors’ role stress: Antecedent, outcome, and moderatingvariables.Behavioral Research in Accounting,1990,2(1):124-153.
    Riahi S.Role stress amongst nurses at the workplace: concept analysis.Journal of nursingmanagement,2011,19(6):721-731.
    Rizzo J R,House R J,Lirtzman S I.Role conflict and ambiguity in complex organizations. Administrativescience quarterly,1970:150-163.
    Russell J A,Carroll J M.On the bipolarity of positive and negative affect.Psychologicalbulletin,1999,125(1):3-30.
    Sager J K.A structural model depicting salespeople’s job stress.Journal of the Academy of MarketingScience,1994,22(1):74-84.
    Savelsbergh C,Gevers J M P,van der Heijden B I J M,et al.Team Role Stress Relationships With TeamLearning and Performance in Project Teams.Group&Organization Management,2012,37(1):67-100.
    Schwarz N,Clore G L.Mood as information:20years later.Psychological Inquiry,2003,14(3-4):296-303.
    Singh B G.Involvement in Research Activities: An Explanation Based on Valence, Attitude, SubjectiveNorm and Perceived Control.Psychology&Developing Societies,1993,5(1):81-93.
    Sobel Kutash E S.A psychoanalytic approach to understanding form in abstract expressionist and minimalistpainting.The International Journal of Psychoanalysis,1982,9(2):167-177.
    Spector P E.Development of the work locus of control scale.Journal of occupationalpsychology,1988,61(4):335-340.
    Stouffer S A,Toby J.Role conflict and personality. American Journal of Sociology,1951.
    Strack F,Schwarz N,Gschneidinger E.Happiness and reminiscing: The role of time perspective, affect, andmode of thinking.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,1985,49(6):1460-1469.
    Tan D T Y,Singh R.Attitudes and attraction: A developmental study of the similarity-attraction anddissimilarity-repulsion hypotheses.Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin,1995,21:975-986.
    Thomas C H,Lankau M J.Preventing burnout: The effects of LMX and mentoring on socialization, rolestress, and burnout.Human Resource Management,2009,48(3):417-432.
    Tiegs R B,Tetrick L E,Fried Y.Growth need strength and context satisfactions as moderators of the relationsof the job characteristics model.Journal of Management,1992,18(3):575-593.
    Tubre T C,Collins J M.Jackson and Schuler (1985) revisited: A meta-analysis of the relationships betweenrole ambiguity, role conflict, and job performance.Journal of Management,2000,26(1):155-169.
    Um M Y,Harrison D F.Role stressors, burnout, mediators, and job satisfaction: A stress-strain-outcomemodel and an empirical test.Social Work Research,1998,22(2):100-115.
    Van Sell M,Brief A P,Schuler R S.Role conflict and role ambiguity: Integration of the literature anddirections for future research.Human Relations,1981,34(1):43-71.
    Vroom V H.ego-involement, job satisfaction, and job performance.personnel psychology,1962,15(2):159-177.
    Watson D,Clark L A,Tellegen A.Development and validation of brief measures of positive and negativeaffect: the PANAS scales.Journal of personality and social psychology,1988,54(6):1063-1070.
    Watts D J.The" new" science of networks.Annual review of sociology,2004:243-270.
    Weiss H M,Cropanzano R.Affective events theory: A theoretical discussion of the structure, causes andconsequences of affective experiences at work.Research in Organizational Behavior,1996,18:1-74.
    Wincent J, rtqvist D.A comprehensive model of entrepreneur role stress antecedents andconsequences.Journal of Business and Psychology,2009,24(2):225-243.
    Wilson M L.Abraham Lincoln: Sources and Style of Leadership (review).Civil WarHistory,1995,41(3):249-250.
    Zeffane R M.Understanding employee turnover: the need for a contingency approach.International journalof Manpower,1994,15(9):22-37.
    杜建刚,马婧,王鹏.负面情感事件对一线服务人员情绪、满意及承诺的影响以高交互服务行业为例.旅游学刊,2012,(8):60-67
    耿昕.领导授权赋能行为对员工创新行为的影响研究—基于创新自我效能感、情绪及团队创新气氛的视角:[博士学位论文].上海:上海交通大学,2011
    段锦云,傅强,田晓明,孔瑜.情感事件理论的内容、应用及研究展望.心理科学进展,2011,19(4):599-607
    韩志明,顾盼.行政责任制度设计的理论原则.广东行政学院学报,2006,6:12-23
    何轩,陈文婷,李新春.赋予股权还是泛家族化——家族企业职业经理人治理的实证研究.中国工业经济,2009,(5):109-119
    胡左浩,张睿,江明华.三种角色压力对寿险代理人工作满意度的影响研究.管理工程学报.2006,3:74-77
    黄昱方,赵曙明.经理人职能与职业化发展研究.南开管理评论,2006,9(3):34-37
    李庆九,陈忠卫.家族企业创业者与外来职业经理人之间的信任关系.科技与管理,2008,83-87
    何轩,陈文婷,李新春.赋予股权还是泛家族化——家族企业职业经理人治理的实证研究.中国工业经济,2009(5):109-119
    李跃.家族企业主与职业经理人之间的矛盾.科学学与科学技术管理,2006(2),165-166
    理查德怀斯曼(Richard Wiseman)(英).正能量.长沙:湖南文艺出版社,2012
    刘卫国.民营企业引入职业经理人的演化博弈分析.江苏商论,2012(9):119-122
    罗家德.社会网分析讲义.北京:社会科学文献出版社.2005
    孙泽厚,李冬梅.人力资源管理中的风险管理.中国人力资源开发,2002,(9):32-35
    王国顺,张红波.企业成长中的职业经理人引入:一个关系分析模型.系统工程,2008,26(5):23-28
    王宣喻,苟茜.私营企业如何整合职业经理人.中国人力资源开发,2007,(10):62-66
    王志刚等.关于中国员工个体特征对其公司满意度影响的实证研究.南开管理评论,2004,7:44-45
    威廉詹姆斯(美)心理学原理.北京:北京大学出版社,2013
    温忠麟,侯杰泰.结构方程模型检验:拟合指数与卡方准则.心理学报,2004,36(2):186-194
    许静艳,陈忠卫.家族企业职业经理人型继任模式选择因素分析.商业时代,2009(1),49-50
    袁声莉等.工作满意度实证研究.技术经济与管理研究,2002(6),34-35
    张辉,牛振邦.特质乐观和状态乐观对一线服务员工服务绩效的影响:基于“角色压力-倦怠-工作结果框架”.南开管理评论,2013(2),66-68
    张玉利,李华晶.企业家和职业经理人融合路径分析.南开管理评论,2005(8),44-49
    赵曙明.MBA教育与中国企业职业经理人培养.高等教育研究,2002(5),82-85
    周之轩,周鸿勇.家族企业职业经理人引进时机和背叛控制策略.统计与决策,2011(12),177-179

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700