摘要
国际有机农业运动联盟有机生产和加工基本标准(IBS)反映了当前有机农业生产和加工水平,是各国政府和民间认证机构制定有机产品标准的基础。欧盟具有目前世界上最成熟的有机产品标准及制度,也是有机产品的重要进口国和消费市场。然而,我国有机农业发展较晚,国内标准的部分内容仍不够成熟,因此国内有机产品并未得到欧盟国家认可,成为了国内有机产品出口创汇的阻力。本研究分析比较我国与欧盟有机产品标准和认证认可制度之间的差距,吸取其发展经验,为国内修订标准、完善制度提供参考依据,从而推动我国加入欧盟有机产品进口第三国名单的进程,促进我国有机农业及产品进一步规范化、市场化、国际化,增强我国有机产品在国际市场上的竞争力,保证我国有机农业健康持续发展。
本研究以近十年来国际有机农业运动联盟(IFOAM)发布的IBS为依据,探讨IBS发展的历史和趋势;并依照现行的IBS、中国和欧盟有机产品标准,以IBS为平台,对中国与欧盟有机产品标准进行比较研究(包括两者在作物生产、畜禽养殖、蜜蜂养殖、水产养殖等生产和加工标准要求的比较),探讨两者的异同以及相关原因,为我国有机产品标准的修订提供具体建议;以中国和欧盟的与有机农业相关的制度文件为依据,比较中国与欧盟有机认证认可制度的异同(主要从法律法规、监管体系、标识、认可程序、认证程序这五个方面进行比较),为我国有机认证认可制度的发展提供意见。主要研究结论如下:
1.IBS的发展方向:
IBS应该向范围更广,结构更协调统一,内容更具体定量的方向发展,否则将难以取得进一步的进展。
2.中国与欧盟有机产品标准在总体上存在着较大的差异:
1)标准性质不同:中国有机产品标准GB/T 19630是一种技术性标准,而欧盟有机产品标准则直接被规定为法规(Regulation),是技术标准与法规的结合体。
2)标准体系不同:GB/T 19630是按有机农业的产业链分为生产、加工、标识和销售、管理体系四个部分;欧盟有机产品标准是以标准(EC)834/2007为中心,其余标准为其实施细则或补充细则的形式构成。
3)标准结构不同:GB/T 19630中植物种植、食用菌栽培、畜禽养殖、蜜蜂和蜂产品是独立存在的,其地位是平等的,而欧盟有机产品标准把植物生产和食用菌栽培归入作物生产,把蜜蜂养殖和畜禽养殖归入动物养殖。
4)标准范围不同:GB/T 19630.2《有机加工》的适用范围包括食品和纺织品,而欧盟有机加工标准的适用范围不包括纺织品。
5)规范性引用文件的位置不同:GB/T 19630的每部分会集中列举与本标准有关的各个规范性引用文件,而欧盟有机产品标准的规范性引用文件则是分散在每页的尾注中。
6)定义不同:定义在数量和侧重角度上不同。3.中国与欧盟有机产品标准在内容上的异同点
中国和欧盟有机产品标准都是在IBS的基础上发展起来的有机产品标准,因此中国与欧盟在有机生产和加工的原则性要求上都与IBS保持一致,但在具体的生产和加工的细节性要求上有较大差异,分为如下三种情况:
1)中国有机产品标准要求而欧盟有机产品标准未作出要求的部分,如产地环境、缓冲带、栖息地、蜂蜜的提取和贮存;
2)欧盟有机产品标准要求而中国有机产品标准未作出要求的部分,如种子数据库、畜禽肥料限量、有机动物饲料清单、饲料加工添加剂清单、水草、贝类和酵母等专项标准;
3)两种有机产品标准都包含但存在分歧的部分,如人粪尿、转基因兽药、蜂王人工受精、各项外部投入品(包括肥料、植保产品、食品添加剂、食品加工助剂)。4.中国与欧盟的有机认证认可制度的异同点
1)在法律效应方面,中国将技术标准与行政法规相分离,而欧盟则将技术标准和行政法规合二为一
2)中国与欧盟的有机监管体系不同。中国的有机监管体系分为三层,欧盟的有机监管体系分为四层。
3)有机标识的要求上,欧盟各成员国认证的有机产品不使用各成员国的标识,而是统一采用欧盟有机标识。中国具有有机和有机转换两种标识,而欧盟不具有有机转换标识。对于有机配料少于95%的产品,中国与欧盟具有不同的标识条件和要求。
4)中国与欧盟的有机认可程序大致相同。
5)中国与欧盟的有机认证程序大致相同。
International Federation of Organic Agriculture Movements Basic Standard for Organic Production and Processing (IBS) reflects the current state of organic production and processing methods of organic farming. IBS provides a framework for certification bodies and standard setting organizations worldwide to develop their own certification standards. EU has the world's most sophisticated organic product standard and system. EU is a major importer and consumption market of organic products. While the development of organic farming in China is relatively late, and some parts of GB/T 19630 are not perfect, the Chinese organic products are not approved by the EU countries which made it more difficult to be exported abroad. This study analyzed and compared the gap of organic product standards, certification and accreditation systems between China and EU. Then China could learn from EU experiences in revising GB/T 19630 and improving its system. Ultimately China will be listed in the EU import third countries list, and Chinese exported products could be marketed in the EU as organic. The study could also promote China's organic agriculture and product future standardize, marketization, internationalization, and enhance China organic agricultural products in international market competition, and insure the health and sustainable development of organic fanning in China.
This study discussed the history and trend of IBS based on the versions that IFOAM issued over the past decade. The study compared China organic product standard with EU organic product standard on IBS platform based on their current versions in crop production, animal husbandry, bee keeping, aquaculture production, food processing. Then the study provided specific recommendations for the amendment of GB/T 19630 through the similarities and differences between the two and the reasons. The study also compared organic certification and accreditation system between China and EU based on their related documents in laws and regulations, supervision system, labeling, accreditation procedure, certification procedure. Then the study provided recommendations for the development of China organic certification and accreditation system through the similarities and differences between the two. The main conclusions are as follows.
1. The development direction of IBS:
IBS should be towards a way which leads to a broader ranger, more coherent structure and more quantitative content; otherwise it is difficult for IBS to achieve further progress.
2. There are many differences between China and EU organic certification standards in general:
1) Different in nature:GB/T 19630 is a technical standard, while the EU organic standards are regulations, which are the combination of technical standards and the legislation.
2) Different in component:GB/T 19630 had four parts which were production, processing, labeling and sales, management system according to the product chain of organic farming; while EU organic standards take Council Regulation (EC) 834/2007 as the center, other Commission Regulations as implementation detail rules and supplementary standards.
3) Different in structure:crop production, mushroom cultivation, livestock and poultry production, bees and bee products are at the same level in GB/T 19630, while in EU organic product standard plant cultivation and mushroom cultivation belonged to the crop production, and bee keeping and livestock and poultry production belonged to animal husbandry.
4) Different in coverage:GB/T 19630.2 "organic processing" applies to organic food and textiles, while the EU organic processing standards doesn't apply to textiles.
5) Different in the location of the normative references:The normative documents in GB/T 19630 were cited in the beginning, while in EU organic standards were scattered in the endnotes of each page.
6) Different in definition:Definitions are different in its number and focus.
3. The same and different points in the content of organic product standards between China and EU
Both China and EU organic standards are developed on the basis of IBS, so the principles and general requirements of them are all consistent with IBS, but the specific details requirements of the two are quite different as the following three conditions:
1) Requirements mentioned in China organic standard and not mentioned in EU organic standard, such as producing environment, buffer zones, habitat, honey extraction and storage;
2) Requirements mentioned in EU organic standard and not mentioned in China organic standard, such as seed database, livestock manure limit, list of organic animal feed and feed additives, special standards for seaweed, shellfish and yeast;
3) The conflict requirements between China and EU organic standards, such as the use of human waste, transgenic animal medicine, queen bee artificial insemination, the external inputs (including fertilizers, plant protection products, food additives and processing aids).
4. The same and different points in the organic certification and accreditation systems between China and EU
1) In legal effect, technical standards and administrative standards were separation in China, while they were combination in EU.
2) Different in regulatory systems:organic regulatory system in China was divided into three levels, in EU was divided into four levels.
3) Different in organic labeling:the EU organic products did not use national organic logo, and the EU Member States uniform application of EU organic logo, while China used its national logos. China had both the organic labeling and organic conversion labeling, while the EU did not have the organic conversion labeling. For the products with organic ingredients below 95%, China and EU had different conditions and requirements in labeling.
4) There is no appreciable difference in accreditation process between China and EU.
5) There is no appreciable difference in certification process between China and EU.
引文
[1]Helga W,Lukas K.全球有机农业2007年统计和发展趋势[M].刘开朗译.波恩:德国Medienhaus Plump,2007:53-58.
[2]Helga W, Lukas K. The world of organic agriculture. statistics and emerging Trends 2011 (Excerpta) [M]. Bonn:Medienhaus Plump,2011:26-33,62-66.
[3]高振宁,赵克强,肖兴基,等.有机农业与有机食品[M].北京:中国环境科学出版社,2009:1-4,54,70,107,211-214.
[4]聂凤英.中国欧盟农业合作战略[M].北京:中国农业科学技术出版社,2007:2-3.
[5]Eurostat Newsrelease. EU27 deficit in trade in goods with China of 170 Bn Euro in 2008. EU-China Summit. [2009-5-18].http://epp.eurostat.ec.europa.eu/cache/ITY_PUBLIC/6-18052009-BP/EN/6-18052009-BP-EN.PDF
[6]国家认证认可监督管理委员会.《有机产品》国家标准征求意见稿编制说明[z]
[7]IFOAM. Become a member of the International Federation of Organic Agriculture Movements (IFOAM). [2010-1-21].http://www.ifoam.org/about_ifoam/membership/index.html.
[8]IFOAM. The IFOAM Norms. [2009-6-20].http://www.ifoam.org/about_ifoam/standards/norms.html..
[9]IFOAM. Organic Agriculture Worldwide Directory of IFOAM Member Organizations & Associates 2009[M].Germany:Die Deutsche Bibliothek,2009:29-31.
[10]Davies G. Organic principles and research:What implications the new IFOAM principles of organic agriculture? What can organic fanning deliver? [C]//Atkinson C, Ball B, Davies D H K et al.Aspects of Applied Biology 79, What will organic farming deliver? Edinburgh:Heriot-Watt University, Association of Applied Biologists,2006:79-82.
[11]Saki I F. The evolution and status of organic principles in an international perspective[M]. OASE working paper. Aalborg University:UNI. Print,2006.
[12]郭华仁.有机农业标准及政策之研究[D].台湾:国立台湾大学,2007:19-20.
[13]王世琨.国内外有机产品标准的比较研究[D].哈尔滨:东北林业大学,2007:34.
[14]陈兵红.丽水有机茶现状及产业化发展的思考[J].安徽农业科学,2007,35(1):133-134,139.
[15]黄鸿翔,李书田,李向林,等.我国有机肥的现状与发展前景分析[J].土壤肥料,2006,(1):3-8.
[16]高铭.国际有机棉纺织品的发展[J].纺织导报,2007, (4):49-51.
[17]王辉,赵晨霞.我国有机葡萄酒的发展现状与前景展望[J].中国酿造,2007, (8):1-3.
[18]甘昶春,王英平,李红.生态型现代农业是新疆农业的发展方向[J].农业现代化研究,2009,30(4):401-405.
[19]温明振.有机农业发展研究[D].天津:天津大学,2006:108-110.
[20]闫湘,任天志.中国台湾有机农业发展概况[J].世界农业,2007,(5):32-34.
[21]孙连飞,程慧林,杨决平,等.不同栽培方式对不结球白菜产量的影响[J].上海农业学报,2008,(1):67-68.
[22]程慧林,孙连飞,和文龙,等.有机、SEQ、特别与常规栽培对8种蔬菜产量、品质影响的研究初报[J].浙江农业学报,2009,21(5):476-480.
[23]和文龙,程慧林,孙连飞,等.不同方式栽培蔬菜对有机肥力影响的研究初探[J].土壤通报,2010,41(4):850-854.
[24]许敏娟,和文龙.有机、特别及常规栽培体系对蔬菜品质的影响[J].江西农业学报,2009,21(7):68-70.
[25]陈玉珍.有机与常规蔬菜农场的比较研究——以上海地区设施栽培为例[D].南京:南京农业大学,2009:15-18.
[26]蔡莉莉,严少华,孙连飞,等.三种不同栽培方式下黄瓜产量和品质及土壤养分的研究[J].上海农业学报,2008,24(4):51-54.
[27]中国认证人员与培训机构国家认可委员会.国家有机产品认证检查员培训教材(试用)[M].北京:中国计量出版社,2005:127,205.
[28]高振宁,赵克强,肖兴基等.有机农业与有机食品[M].北京:中国环境科学出版社,2009,5:37-147.
[29]聂磊,蒋俊树.GB/T 19630-2005《有机产品》标准解析[J].中国标准化,2006,10:49-51.
[30]单吉堃.有机农业发展的制度分析[M].北京:中国农业大学出版社,2008.
[31]郝建强.中国有机食品发展现状、问题及对策分析[J].世界农业,2006,(7):1-4.
[32]单吉堃.从有机认证制度看中国有机农业发展[D].北京:中国社会科学院研究生院,2003:61-69.
[33]孟凡乔,吴文良.国内外有机农产品生产、贸易及标准管理体系[J].中国生态农业学报,2002,10(2):4-6.
[34]王宏燕.全球有机农业发展现状和我国有机农业发展对策[J].农业系统科学与综合研究,2003,19(3):223-229.
[35]Paull J.China's organic revolution[J].Journal of Organic Systems,2007,2(1):1-11.
[36]Paull J. Green Food in China[J]. Elementals:Journal of Bio-Dynamics Tasmania,2008, (91):48-53.
[37]Sternfeld E. Organic Food "Made in China"[R]. EU-China Civil Society Forum Hintergrundinformationen,2009:1-12.
[38]Wilbois K P. The European regulatory system. Organic fanning and production[J]. The Organic Standard,2001, (8):12-15.
[39]杨莲娜.欧盟有机农业的新发展及启示[J].世界农业,2007,(1):48-51.
[40]徐磊,张峭.欧盟有机水果消费分析及预测[J].世界农业,2007, (5):35-36.
[41]周恤宝,王文雅,欧阳喜辉.积极利用欧盟有机产品标准开展有机食品国际贸易[J].世界农业,2006,(6):4-6.
[42]刘波,冒乃和.德国有机农业发展的法律基础与扶持政策[J].世界农业,2003,(5):28-30.
[43]周清,邓健.欧盟各国有机农业支持政策比较研究[J].农机化研究,2008, (9):220-223.
[44]韩沛新,李显军,郭春敏,等.以意大利为例浅谈欧盟有机农业发展促进机制[J].世界农业,2005(4):12-15.
[45]白玉良,王丽华.美国有机产品标准7CFR 205和欧盟2092/91标准对比分析[J].检验检疫科学,2008,(1):60-62.
[46]Schulze H, Jahn G, Spiller A. Acceptance and motivational impact of the organic certification system[J].Zwischen Tradition und Globalisierung Wissenschaftstagung Okologischer Landbau, Universitat Hohenheim, Stuttgart, Deutschland,2007:20-23.
[47]Koesling M, Lφes A K, Flaten O, et al. Dropping organic certification-effects on organic fanning in Norway[Z] Cultivating the Future Based on Science:2nd Conference of the International Society of Organic Agriculture Research ISOFAR, Modena, Italy, June 18-20,2008.
[48]Berlach N.Organic agriculture certification as factor of proper development of Ukraine AIC[Z]. Organic agriculture certification as factor of proper development of Ukraine AIC.2009
[49]Zorn A, Renner H. Organic operators'satisfaction with their certification body-a survey in Germany[Z]. Cultivating the Future Based on Science:2nd Conference of the International Society of Organic Agriculture Research ISOFAR, Modena, Italy, June 18-20,2008.
[50]Huber B.Building Trust in Organic[J].The Organic Standard,2007,(75):17.
[51]Stephan D, Christian L, Tatjana S, et al. Certcost-economic analysis of certification systems for organic food and fanning at eu level[Z]. Cultivating the Future Based on Science:2nd Conference of the International Society of Organic Agriculture Research ISOFAR, Modena, Italy, June 18-20, 2008.
[52]Zorm A, Christian L, Stephan D. Economic concepts of organic certification.2009 CERTCOST Project no.207727.[2010-10-8]. http://www.certcost.org.
[53]Zorn A.Organic Fanning Certification-the Costs of Reducing Transaction Costs[C]//Josef H, Franz H, Theresia O W, et al. Neue Impulse in der Agrar- und Ernahrungswirtschaft?!-18. Jahrestagung der Osterreichischen Gesellschaft fur Agrarokonomie,Tagungsband 2008, OGA, Wien.
[54]Huber B. Adressing fraud[J]. The Organic Standard,2007, (74):12.
[55]Susanne P, Nicolas L, Stephan D, et al.Organic fanning policy in the European Union[C]//Hall DC, Moffitt LJ.Economics of Pesticides, Sustainable Food Production and Organic Food Markets, Elsevier,2002:169-194.
[56]Huber B, Neuendorff J. Organic Agriculture and Legal Framework[Z]. Second Round Table of the Eastern European Countries. Proceedings of Organic Agriculture and Legal Framework. Second Round Table of the Eastern European Countries, Kyiv, Ukraine, November 5&6,2008. Research Institute of Organic Agriculture FiBL, CH-Frick.
[57]Koesling M, Flaten O, Lien G. Factors influencing the conversion to organic farming in Norway[J]. International Journal of Agricultural Resources, Governance and Ecology (IJARGE), Special Issue on:"Continuity and Change in Organic Fanning-Philosophy, Practice and Policy" 7(1):78-95.
[58]Padel S.How do ethical values of organic agriculture relate to standards and current pratice?[C]// Zollitsch W, Winkler C, Waiblinger S, et al.Sustainable Food Production and Ethics.7th EurSAFE Congress, Vienna, Wageningen Academic Publishers,2007:13-15.
[59]Padel S, Nicholas P, Jasinska A, et al. Ethical concerns associated with organic food in Europe[DB/CD]. Cultivate the future. Proceedings of 16 IFOAM world congress.16th IFOAM Organic World Congress, Modena, June 16-20,2008.
[60]Noureddin D, Umberto M, Bernardo D G. Preliminary explorative research about ethical values and organic food consumption in Apulia region, South of Italy[Z].15th International BioL Prize, International forum:Ethics and olive production, Bari Italy, April 27th to 30th,2010.
[61]Otto S, Beate H, Katia Z et al. Analysis of EEC Regulation 2092/91 in relation to other national and international organic standards.2007. [2010-10-8]. http://www.organic-revision.org/pub/D_3_2_final%20report low.pdf
[62]Melby J L. ORGANIC REVISION-Research to support the revision of the EU Regulation on organic agriculture. European Organic Congress, Brussels, December 4-5,2007. [2010-10-8]. http://www.organic-revision.org
[63]Jespersen L M, Sorensen L S, Rebsdorf S O. Organic Rules and Certification[C]//Danish Organic Congress, Organic Rules and Certification.Odense,2009:17-18.
[64]Schmid O, Huber B, Ziegler K, et al. Analysis of differences between EU regulation 2092/91 related to other standards-Potentials for harmonization, simplification and regionalization[Z]. Zwischen Tradition und Globalisierung-9. Wissenschaftstagung Okologischer Landbau, Universitat Hohenheim, Stuttgart, Deutschland,20.-23.03.2007.
[65]Otto S, Beate H, Katia Z, et al. Analysis of differences between EU Regulation (EEC) 2092/91 in relation to other national and international standards[Z]. Cultivating the Future Based on Science. 2nd Conference of the International Society of Organic Agriculture Research (ISOFAR), in the Frame of the 16th IFOAM Organic World Congress, Modena, Italy, June 18-20,2008
[66]Padel S, Melby J L, Schmid O. Final project report:EEC 2092/91 (ORGANIC) Revision[z]. EEC 2092/91 (Organic Revision Project Report), Final report.2007.
[67]Schmidt H. Legal Aspects of the Regulations (EC) No.834/2007 and 889/2008[C]//Schmidt H. The New EU Regulation for Organic Food and Fanning:(EC)No.834/2007 BACKGROUND, ASSESSMENT, INTERPRETATION. Brussels:International Federation of Organic Agriculture Movements EU Group,2009:24-29.
[68]Plakolm G. The Implementing rules of the new organic agriculture regulation-few changes in production rules [C]//Plakolm G. The New EU Regulation for Organic Food and Fanning: (EC)No.834/2007 BACKGROUND, ASSESSMENT, INTERPRETATION. Brussels:International Federation of Organic Agriculture Movements EU Group,2009:29-31.
[69]Schmid O. Animal production[C]//Schmid O. The New EU Regulation for Organic Food and Farming:(EC)No.834/2007 BACKGROUND, ASSESSMENT, INTERPRETATION. Brussels: International Federation of Organic Agriculture Movements EU Group,2009:33-35.
[70]Huber B, Neuendorff J. The new import regulation; More reliability for imported organic products? [C]//Huber B, Neuendorff J. The New EU Regulation for Organic Food and Farming:(EC) No 834/2007 BACKGROUND, ASSESSMENT, INTERPRETATION. Brussels:International Federation of Organic Agriculture Movements EU Group,2009:41-44.
[71]Beck A. Introduction of a legal definition of organic yeas[C]//Beck A. The New EU Regulation for Organic Food and Farming:(EC) No.834/2007 BACKGROUND, ASSESSMENT, INTERPRETATION. Brussels:International Federation of Organic Agriculture Movements EU Group,2009:47-48.
[72]Micheloni C. OR WINE:a further step towards an EU regulation on organic wine-making [C]// Micheloni C. The New EU Regulation for Organic Food and Farming:(EC) No.834/2007 BACKGROUND, ASSESSMENT, INTERPRETATION. Brussels:International Federation of Organic Agriculture Movements EU Group,2009:52-54.
[73]Stamer A, Bergleiter S. Common Rules for Organic Aquaculture Production in the EU [C]//Stamer A, Bergleiter S. The New EU Regulation for Organic Food and Farming:(EC) No.834/2007 BACKGROUND, ASSESSMENT, INTERPRETATION. Brussels:International Federation of Organic Agriculture Movements EU Group,2009:48-52.
[74]Strassner C. Food service and catering in Europe and future perspectives for European regulation[C]//Strassner C.The New EU Regulation for Organic Food and Fanning:(EC) No. 834/2007 BACKGROUND, ASSESSMENT, INTERPRETATION. Brussels:International Federation of Organic Agriculture Movements EU Group,2009:54-59.
[75]Strassner C.Certifying out of home operators in Europe[Z]. European Forum for Certification. Summary of a Forum held at the BioFach Congress 2009. ICROFS, Tjele, Denmark.
[76]Strassner C, Mikkelsen Camilla. Certifying out of home operators in Europe[Z]. European Forum for Certification. Proceedings of European Forum for Certification at BioFach 2010, Nuremberg, Germany,20th February 2010. University of applied sciences, Munster, Germany and IFOAM EU group.
[77]Alonso N. Common rules for 'out of home' catering [J]. The Organic Standard,2010, (110):12-15.
[78]Paull J. The School Food Revolution:Public Food and the Challenge of Sustainable Development-Book Review [J] Journal of Organic Systems,2008,3 (2):59-60.
[79]吴大付,胡国安.有机农业[M].北京:中国农业科学技术出版社,2007:66.
[80]IFOAM. IFOAM General Assemblies and Scientific Conferences. [2009-6-18]. http://www.ifoam.org/about_ifoam/inside_ifoam/pdfs/History_Organic_World_Congresses.pdf.
[81]IFOAM. The principles of organic agriculture. [2006-6-28]. http://www.ifoam.org/about_ifoam/prin-ciples/index.html.
[82]IFOAM. IFOAM General Assembly 2008 In Action. [2009-3-18].www.ifoam.org.
[83]IFOAM. First revision draft of the 2002 IFOAM Basic Standards for Organic Production and Processing. [2009-6-18]. http://www.ifoam.org.
[84]Davies G. Organic principles and research:What implications the new IFOAM principles of organic agriculture [J]. Aspects of Applied Biology,2006:79-82.
[85]宋代军,黄嫚秋.隐患不割除风险必然易传播——动物源原料在饲料工业中应用存在的潜在
安全问题[J].中国动物保健,2008,(108):69-70.
[86]Standards Committee Commentary. IBS 2nd Revision Draft, January,2003 Introduction and Commentary. [2009-6-18]. http://www.ifoam.org.
[87]Commins K. Overview of current status of standards and conformity assessment systems[z] International Task Force on Harmonization and Equivalence in Organic Agriculture (ITF)Discussion Paper,2004:9,21.
[88]IFOAM. Commentary on the Preparation of the Final Draft IFOAM Benchmark for Standards. [2009-4-1]. http://www.ifoam.org.
[89]IFOAM. Questions and Answers on the IFOAM Benchmark for Standards. [2009-1-18]. http://www.ifoam.org.
[90]IFOAM. Committee Final Draft of the IFOAM Benchmark for Standards. [2008-2-14]. http://www.ifoam.org.
[91]佟倩,周泽江,和文龙.有机产品标准及认证认可体系的一致化研究[J].农产品质量与安全,2009,(3):41-44.
[92]佟倩.全球有机产品标准及认证认可制度的一致化和等效性研究[D].南京:南京农业大学,2009:38.
[93]科学技术部中国农村技术开发中心组.有机农业在中国[M].北京:中国农业科学技术出版社,2006:11,21,171-172,174-175.
[94]Blake F, Schluter M. History of the EU organic regulation and its recent revision[C]//Blake F, Schluter M.The New EU Regulation for Organic Food and Fanning:(EC) No.834/2007 BACKGROUND, ASSESSMENT, INTERPRETATION. Brussels:International Federation of Organic Agriculture Movements EU Group,2009:8-14.
[95]Food Standards Agency, Organic Food. Is organic food safer than other food?[2010-10-1]. http://www.food.gov.uk/foodindustry/farmingfood/organicfood/
[96]Latvia Talsi. Organic seed propagation:current status and problems in Europe[R]. Seminar Report. Environmental Friendly Food Production System:requirements for plant breeding and seed production.May 31-June 3,2005.
[97]Convergence plan for Council Directive 91/676/EEC concerning the protection of waters against pollution caused by nitrates from agricultural sources. [2010-4-20]. http://www.ecbsea.org/files//content/MoldovaNitrates_Directive_Convergence_Plan_en.doc_l.pdf.
[98]杨小科.国外的有机农业[M].北京:中国社会出版社,2006:91.
[99]高定石,陈东义,刘启.现代农业发展中关键技术与问题探讨[M].北京:中国农业科学技术出版社,2008:37-43.
[100]许香春,王朝云.国内外地膜覆盖栽培现状及展望[J].中国麻业,2006,28(1):6-10.
[101]黎先发.可降解地膜材料研究现状与进展[J].塑料,2004,33(1):76-81.
[102]吴强.淀粉类生物降解材料研究进展[J].甘肃科技,2002,(4):53.
[103]周文春.环保型麻纤维纸地膜的研究开发分析[J].中国麻业,2002,24(2):22-25.
[104]水利部农村水利司,中国灌溉排水发展中心.节水灌溉工程实用手册[M].北京:中国水利水电出版社,2005:7-9.
[105]张金霞,黄晨阳.无公害食用菌安全生产手册[M].北京:中国农业出版社,2008:3,5.
[106]Paull J. Wild Organics:A Frontier Shift from Agriculture to Wildculture [J]. Elementals-Journal of Bio-Dynamics Tasmania,2008, (90):14-19.
[107]刘更另,金维续.中国有机肥料[M].北京:农业出版社,1991:25.
[108]Leifert C, Ball K, Volakakis N, et al. Control of enteric pathogens in ready-to-eat vegetable crops in organic and'low input' production systems:a HACCP-based approach [J]. Journal of Applied Microbiology,2008,105:931-950.。
[109]任健,墨继光,张树斌.草地共管在滇西北退化草地治理中的经验[J].可持续农业,2010,4(1):9-12.
[110]李卫华.农场动物福利规范[M].北京:中国农业科学技术出版社,2009:4,15,71,148.
[111]Vaarst M, Roderick S, Lund V, et al. Animal health and welfare in organic agriculture[M]. Londen:CABI publishing,2003:165-167.
[112]Thomas D L, Waldron D F, Lowe G D, et al. Length of docked tail and the incidence of rectal prolapse in lambs[J]. Animal Science,2003,81:2725-2732.
[113]Luther J Causes, prevention and treatment of rectal prolapse in sheep[Z]. NDSU Extension Services September 2008. AS-1388.
[114]Kellems R O, Church D C.畜禽饲料与饲养学[M].姜成钢,张辉,译.北京:中国农业大学出版社,2006:362.
[115]Beauchemin K A, Krehbiel C R, Newbold C J. Chapter 7 Enzymes, bacterial direct-fed microbials and yeast:principles for use in ruminant nutrition[J]. Biology of Growing Animals,2006, (4): 251-284.
[116]张延龄,张晖.疫苗学[M].北京:科学出版社,2004:286.
[117]Rabinovich N R, McInnes P, Klein D L. Vaccine technologies:view to the future [J]. Science,1994,265:1401-1404.
[118]Nichols W W, Ledwith B J, Manam S V, et al. Potential DNA malaria vaccine:tissue distribution and safty studies in mice and rabbits [J]. Human Gene Therapy,1999,10(5):741-758.
[119]Kanellos T,Sylvest I D,Ambali A G, et al.The safty and longevity of DNA vaccines for fish [J].Immunology,1999,96(2):307-313.
[120]Bagarazzi M L, Boyer J D,Mgen K E, et al.Ssfty and immunogenicity of HIV-1 DNA constructs in chimpanzees [J].Vaccine,1998,16(19):1836-1841
[121]Robinson H L, Torres C A.DNA vaccine[J].Semin Immunol,1997,9(5):271-283.
[122]刘焕亮,黄樟翰.中国水产养殖学[M].北京:科学出版社,2008:128,129~135,267.
[123]王迪,吴军,窦寅,等.江苏水产养殖鱼类外来物种调查及其生物入侵风险初探[J].江西农业学报,2008,20(11):99-102.
[124]Conte F S. Stress and the welfare of cultured fish[J]. Applied Animal Behaviour Science,2004,86: 205-223.
[125]国家林业局.濒危东方白鹤扎堆菜子湖数量达166只.[2010-12-13]. http://www.forestry.gov.cn/portal/main/s/144/content-82690.html.
[126]於亚兵,杨志刚.虾青素在水产养殖中的成用[J].中国水产,2007(6):65-66.
[127]Jim S, Lily H S食品添加剂实用手册[M].姜竹茂,译.北京:中国农业出版社,2004:175,194,247,276.
[128]Speiser B, Blake F, Micheloni C, et al. Evaluating inputs for organic farming -a new system[M].Proposals of the ORGANIC INPUTS EVALUATION project. Frick,Switzerland,2005.
[129]单吉堃.认证制度的建构与有机农业发展[J].学习与探索,2004,(4):81-86.
[130]Commins K. Overview of current status of standards and conformity assessment systems[z], IOAS, 2004:9,21.
[131]韩沛新,李显军,郭春敏等.以意大利为例浅谈欧盟有机农业发展促进机制[J].世界农业,2005,(4):12-15.
[132]Gunnar Rundgren. Asia organic standards in the making-Selected article.[2011.2.10]. http://www.organicstandard.com/
[133]GOMA. First meeting of Asian Working Group held in Mumbai. [2011.2.10]. http://www.goma-organic.org/news-from-goma/