摘要
大型医用设备是卫生资源的重要组成部分,是各级医疗机构开展医疗工作、提高医疗水平重要辅助手段,一定程度上代表着医疗机构的技术水平。随着我国经济社会和医疗科技水平的快速发展,大型医用设备大量引进,卫生行政管理机构制定配置规划的方法却相对滞后,区域内设备超负荷运转或重复购置,存在一定的医疗安全隐患,并造成了医疗资源的严重浪费。对大型医用设备配置的微观和宏观分析,合理优化配置大型医用设备成为现代医院管理的一个重要课题。
本课题以国家和地区大型医用设备的配置规划为参照,以大型医用设备的配置过程为主线,将大型医用设备的配置过程分为现状评价、需求预测、单个医疗机构的设备配置和区域设备配置四部分,对大型医用设备配置理论与方法进行分析研究,并结合乙类大型医用设备布局规划实例,将相关的理论研究成果与实际情况相比较进行验证,从而为大型医用设备的优化配置提供理论与方法支持。本文的主要研究工作和结论如下:
(1)分析了大型医用设备的控制机制。从国家和地区大型医用设备的相关管理政策入手,选定甲、乙两类大型医用设备中的乙类大型医用设备(以下简称大型医用设备或设备)为研究对象,按照国家对乙类大型医用设备规划制定权限,选定直辖市为研究区域,根据区域大型医用设备配置规划的指导思想,确定与区域经济、功能定位等协调的配置基本原则,明确了临床机构配置大型医用设备必须具备的基本条件,为下一步的研究明确了研究对象和研究主要方向。
(2)从设备配置的公平性、经济性、使用效率和配套性,对设备配置现状进行了综合评价。从公平的角度,依照公平理论和健康公平的理念,采用Lorenz曲线、基尼系数和Theil-L指数分析了大型医用设备配置的公平性;从经济学的角度,按照客观合理性、经济性和实用性的原则,根据设备折旧、成本、收益等指标,选用静态投资回收期、投资利润率、内部收益率、净现值的计算方法,分析了大型医用设备的经济现状;从设备使用效率的角度,依据年检查人次、日均检查人次、人均占机时间、年均开机天数和日均开机时间等设备使用统计数据,分析了大型医用设备使用效率现状。按照客观性、独立性、可比性等指标选取准则,以设备配置的公平、经济和使用效率、医院设施人员配套性为第一层指标,建立了大型医用设备配置评价指标体系,概述了层次分析法、模糊综合评价等常用评价方法的优缺点,根据评价指标体系中指标数量较多、多为定量指标的特点,采用主成分分析法对现状进行了综合评价,通过综合评价发现存在的问题,为下一步的设备配置提供参考。
(3)对区域大型医用设备的检查需求进行了预测。从地区社会经济和医院自身两个方面总结了大型医用设备检查的影响因素,介绍了需求预测的步骤、原则和常用方法,决定采用自回归分析法对各影响因素进行预测,运用影响因素的历史数据和预测结果,采用多元线性回归法进行了大型医用设备检查量的预测,同时采用指数平滑法进行了设备检查量的预测,为了增加预测的可信度,将两种方法预测结果的平均值作为最终的设备检查需求。参照相关研究中确定的乙类大型医用设备合理年检查人次,对大型医用设备的基底配置数量进行了粗略估计。
(4)从微观层面对单个医疗机构大型医用设备进行了优化配置研究。分析了患者排队检查的过程和排队系统的特征,确定了检查的排队规则,以某医院的MRI检查为例,根据不同部位检查时间统计数据得出了设备平均检查时间,分单个队列和两个队列两种情况,采用M/M/1模型和M/M/C模型,计算得出了不同排队方式下排队系统的指标,结果显示,单个队列的各个指标优于两个队列的情况,并运用SIMIO仿真工具进行了排队系统的仿真,验证了计算结果的可信性,讨论了不同到达率对排队系统指标的影响。简要探讨了成立MRI区域检治中心对排队系统的影响,证明成立检治中心能够提高设备的工作效率,缩短患者检查等待时间。
(5)从宏观角度建立了区域大型医用设备优化配置模型。以提高配置的公平性和覆盖人口最大化为目标,以配置的成本等为约束条件,建立了区域大型医用设备最大覆盖优化配置模型,采用主观赋权法将多目标优化问题转化为单目标优化问题来求解,并对模型中最短路径、患者选择该设备的概率、设备价格、检查需求和设备的最大覆盖距离参数的确定进行了探讨。以提高配置的公平性和设备效益,降低配置成本为目标,以基尼系数和设备使用效率以及建设时序为约束条件,建立了区域大型医用设备时序优化配置模型,并选用遗传算法求解该问题。
本文的主要创新点包括以下几点:
(1)综合设备配置的公平性、经济性、设备使用效率和相关配套条件四个方面,建立大型医用设备配置现状评价指标体系,为跟踪研究大型医用设备规划后的使用情况提供了方法。
(2)从微观层面,采用排队论的模型和模型,分析了单个医疗机构中设备的配置问题,得出了成立区域检治中心将降低患者检查的等待时间的结论,证明成立区域检治中心的必要性。
(3)从宏观层面,以提高配置的公平性和覆盖人口最大化为目标,建立了区域大型医用设备最大覆盖优化配置模型;以提高配置的公平性和设备效益,降低配置成本为目标,建立了区域大型医用设备时序优化配置模型,为大型医用设备的区域规划提供了方法。
Large medical equipment is a significant part of health resources, which is thematerial foundation and important auxiliary means at all levels of clinical institutions tocarry out medical work. It improves the level of medical treatment. With the developmentof our country Socioeconomic and medical science, a large number of large medicalequipment is introduced. However, the method of configuration planning which developedby health administrative agencies is lagging behind, and Decision-making with obviousblindness. The repeated purchase and low utilization rate of equipments result in a seriouswaste of medical resources in the region. Analysis large medical equipment configurationin the microscopic and the macroscopic, optimal allocate large medical equipment is animportant task in modern hospital management.
This paper takes large medical equipment configuration planning of the countries andareas as reference, and the large medical equipment configuration process as the main line.The large medical equipment configuration process is divided into four parts. They arecurrent situation evaluation, demand forecasting, single medical configuration and areaequipment configuration. The theory and method of configuration of large medicalequipment are analyzed. Combined with the example of B-large medical equipmentconfiguration planning, the results of theoretical research are verified with the actualsituation. Theory and method supports optimal configuration of large medical equipmentare provided. The main research work and conclusion are as follows:
(1)Control mechanism of large medical equipment is analyzed. From the relatedmanagement policies of the countries and regions of large medical equipment, SelectB-large medical equipment from A and B large medical equipment as the research object.In accordance with the state of B-large medical equipment planning permission, selectmunicipalities as the study area. According to the guiding ideology of the regionalconfiguration program of large medical equipment, identify the configuration principlesuch as coordination with region economy, function orientation, and so on. The basicconditions that clinical institution must have to configure large medical equipment areclear. Explicit object and research directions of study for future research.
(2)From angle of equipment configuration fairness, economy and efficiency, thecomprehensive evaluation of the equipment status is carried out. In accordance with thetheory of fairness and equity in health concept, Lorenz curve, Gini coefficient and Theil-Lindex are used to of analysis the large medical equipment fair situation from the view offairness; In accordance with the principle of objective rationality, economic and practical, according to the equipment depreciation, cost, income and other indicators, Methods ofstatic investment payback period, the profit rate of investment, net present value, internalrate of return are chose to analysis the current economic situation of large medicalequipment from the angle of economics; From the efficiency angle, the use efficiencysituation of the large medical equipment are analyzed, based on statistical data such asYear inspection trips, daily inspection trips, per capita of machine time, the annual boottime, the average starting time. In accordance index selection criteria of objectivity,independence, comparability, the evaluation index system of configuration of largemedical equipment is established, which first layer index including equity, economic,efficiency and supporting of hospital facilities and staff. The advantages and disadvantagesof the commonly used evaluation methods are overviewed. The number of evaluationindexes is much, and most of which are quantitative indicators. Principal componentanalysis is used to evaluate status. Problems are found out through the comprehensiveevaluation, which provide reference for the next step of configuration.
(3)The inspection requirements of large medical equipment in the region are predicted.The impact factor of large medical equipment inspection is summarized from two aspectswhich include the regional socio-economic and hospitals. The procedures, principles andcommon methods for demand prediction are introduced. Auto-regression analysis methodis chosen to predict each factor,The inspection amount of large medical equipment is predicted by multiple linearregression method which bases on the historical data and predict results. And exponentialsmoothing method is used to predict the amount of equipment checks. Regard the averageof predict results by two ways as final equipment inspection requirements in order toincrease the credibility of the prediction. A rough the number of the base configuration oflarge medical equipment is estimated which reference to reasonable check passengers of Blarge medical equipment one year in related studies.
(4) Optimal configuration of large medical equipment is researched frommicrocosmic aspect. The patients’ inspection process in line and queuing systemcharacteristics are analyzed. The rule of inspection queue is determined. The article takesMRI examination of a hospital as an example. The average inspection time is calculatedaccording to the check time of different position. The queue is divided into single queueand a two queue. The M/M/1model and M/M/Cmodel are used to calculate queuesystem indexes of different queue. The result shows that indexes of two queues aresuperior to single queue. Simulation tool of SIMIO is used to simulate queue system. The credibility of the results is validated. The effect of different arrival rates to queuing systemis discussed. The effect of queuing system to establish check and treat center of MRI in thearea is discussed briefly. The result demonstrates that the formation of check and treatcenter can improve efficiency of the equipment. Waiting time of patient examination isshorten.
(5)The model of optimal configuration of regional large medical equipment isestablished from the macro aspect. The maximum coverage optimization configurationmodel of regional large medical equipment is established. The goals of the model areimproving configuration fairness and maximizing covering population. The constraints ofthe model include the cost of configuration, and so on. The multi-objective optimizationproblem is transform into single objective optimization problem by subjective weightingmethod. The parameters of the model are discussed. They are the shortest path, theprobability of patients selecting the equipment, equipment prices, check of demand andequipment's maximum coverage distance. Timing optimization model of area large scalemedical equipment is established. The goals of the model are improving the fairness andefficiency of equipment, and reducing distribution cost. The constraints of the modelinclude Gini coefficient, the efficiency of the equipment and the construction of timing.Genetic algorithm is adopted to solve the problem.
The main innovations of this paper are as follows:
(1) Status evaluation index system of configuration of large medical equipmentestablished which integrates four aspects. They are equipment configuration fairness,economic, the use efficiency and related conditions. Method is provided for tracking thesituation of large scale medical equipment planning. It provides convenience to find out theproblems existing in the original planning.
(2)The equipment configuration in individual medical institutions is analyzed frommicrocosmic aspect, which using a M/M/1model and M/M/Cmodel in queuingtheory. The conclusion is drawn that the establishment of the regional check and treatcenter will reduce the waiting time of patient examination. It also proves that theestablishment of area check and treat central is necessity.
(3)The model of optimal configuration of regional large medical equipment isestablished from the macro aspect in order to improving configuration fairness andmaximizing covering population. Timing optimization model of area large scale medicalequipment is established in order to improving the fairness and efficiency of equipment,and reducing distribution cost. It offers the method for large medical equipment planning.
引文
[1]尹德卢.2005年北京市乙类大型医用设备配置现状[J].中国医学装备,2007,4(7):12-15
[2]卫规财发(2004)474号文.卫生部、国家发展和改革委员会、财政部,关于发布《大型医用设备配置与使用管理办法》的通知.卫生部公报,2005,1.
[3]《大型医用设备配置与使用管理办法》.卫生部、发改委和财政部,2000,12
[4]Renaldo N battista, et al. Lessons from the eight countries. Health policy.1994.30:287-421
[5]Bruce J. Hillman. Government health policy and the diffusion of new medicaldevices. Health Service Research.1986,21(5):681-711
[6]雷海潮.中外大型医用设备的配置和管理[J].中国卫生资源,2000,3(2):55-57
[7]BrueeA Boissofmault.MRI services in western NewYork.2003[R].2003.
[8]GeneH.Barett.Evolution and organization of a regional Gamma knif centerStereotaet Ffunet Neurosurg,1996:66(Suppl1):365-369
[8]杨才布.国外大型医用设备管理体制比较研究[J].中国卫生经济,2004,27(8):59-63
[9]石光.德国等九个发达国家区域卫生规划的经验与启示[J].卫生经济研究,2009,9:22-25
[10]俞启平.英、德两国卫生服务模式现状与借鉴[J].《国外医学》卫生经济分册,2007,24(4):145-151
[11] Pei TK, Wen CT. Determinants of computed tomography and magneticresonance imaging utilization in Taiwan[J].International Journal ofTechnology Assessment in Health Care,2005,21(1):81-88
[12]Vaknin S,Luxenburg O,Polliack G.CT and MRI imaging in Israel nationaltrends of utilization[J].2003.
[13]石光.英美两国卫生资源配置的制度经济学解释[J].《中国卫生经济》.2005,24(11):51-53
[14]方月明.日本磁共振仪(NRI)的现状和经济分析[J].国外医学卫生经济学分册,1994,11(2):79-81
[15]Gene H.Barnett.Evolution and organization of a regional Gamma knifecenter Stereotact Ffunct Neurosurg,1996,66(Suppl1):365-369
[16]吴松林.加拿大药品和医疗设备控制[J].国外医学,1997,14(1):11-13
[17] DomenighettiG, CasabiancaA. Health care economics, uncertainty andphysician-induced demand.Schweiz Med Wochenschr.1995,125(42):1969-1979
[18]雷海潮.国外大型医用设备配置和管理的方法与经验[J].国外医学,卫生经挤分册,2000,17(l):1-4
[19]何南婉.再谈“大型医用设备的配置与使用管理办法”[J].中国医学装备,2005,2(6):1-2
[20]李坤成.关于我国医疗卫生改革的思考和建议[J].医疗设备信息,2005,10:1-2
[21]阴海梅.浅谈医疗设备引进及使用过程中的科学化管理[J].中国卫生质量管理.2007,14(5):51-53
[22]陈博文,尹德卢等.大型医用设备配置规划方法探讨[J].中国医学装备,2007,4(6):8-11
[23]孟庆跃、严非.中国城市卫生服务公平与效率评价研究[M],济南:山东大学出版社,2005
[24]彭志丽,何洁仪.我国卫生资源配置的现状、存在问题及改革的重点难点分析[J].国际医药卫生导报,2005,19:21-23
[25]于京杰.医疗设备管理在医院管理中的地位和作用[J],中国医疗设备,2008,23(11):66-67
[26]徐月萍.大型医疗设备配置管理存在的问题及对策[J].常规医疗装备,2004,2:45-46
[27]中华人民共和国卫生部.关于暂缓装备伽玛刀、爱克斯刀的通知.卫计发(1995)第83号
[28]2009年全国卫生统计年鉴.中华人民共和国卫生部,2010
[29]叶慧.合理配置医疗资源有效控制医疗费用[J].中国医疗器械信息.2005.11(4):1-2
[30]崔宏建.认真实施区域卫生规划,加强大型医用设备管理[J].中国卫生经济,2001,6:46-47
[31]侯淑莲.唐山市大型医用设备配置情况研究[J].医疗卫生装备2003,1:31-33
[32]吴先泽.天津市CT、 MRI大型医用设备配置标准综述[J].中国医学装备,2007,4(12):11-13
[33]张晋华.大型医用设备配置现状及分析[J].基层医学论坛,2005,13:631
[34]雷海潮.中国大型医用设备宏观管理中的问题与对策研究[J].中国卫生经济,2004,23(3):54-55
[35]张鲁闽.医疗设备管理中的效益分析[J].医疗卫生装备,2006,5:39
[36]盛洪.现代制度经济学(上卷)[M].北京:北京大学出版社.2003
[37]刘激扬.公共卫生资源公平配置的伦理学研究[D].中南大学博士学位论文.2007
[38]王文科.公共卫生资源配置的政府决策与公平[J].中国医学伦理,2007,20(l):19-22
[39]侯淑莲.大型医用设备配置公平性研究方法分析[J].中国卫生统计,2004,21(3):178-179
[40]雷海潮.大型医用设备地理分布公平性的评估方法研究[J].卫生经济研究,2008,8:12-14
[41]刘杉.北京地区大型医用设备分布的公平性评估[J].医疗设备信息.2007,22(10):50-53
[42]李杰.东营市大型医用设备分布公平性研究[J].卫生经济研究,2003,10:23-24.
[43]A.D.Asante,A.B. Zwi,M.T Ho. Equity in resource allocation for health:A comparative study of the Ashanti and Northern Regions of Ghana[J].HealthPolicy,2006,78:135-148
[44]R.0Loughlin,Alan Kelly. Equity in resource allocation in the Irish healthservice a policy Delphi study[J]. Health Policy,2004,67:271-280
[45]杜仕林.医疗卫生资源配置法律制度研究[D].西南政法大型博士学位论文.2008
[46]李少红.大型医用设备引入的经济分析框架探讨[D].浙江大学硕士学位论文.2001
[47]马玲.大型医用设备购置的经济可行性分析[J].医疗卫生装备,2008,6:27-28
[48]张波.大型医用设备配置及其对医院收入影响[D].大连医科大学硕士学位论文.2010
[49]王丽姿.医院医疗设备运营经济评价的应用分析[J].医疗设备息,2007,6:63-65
[50]贾智霞.浅议大型医用设备购置的财务评价[J].江苏卫生事业管理,2001,22(4):78-80
[51]王忠明.百万元以上大型医疗设备成本效益分析研究[J].中华医院管理杂志,2005,21(2):77
[52]程天河.医院内部大型医疗设备效益审计探讨[J].医疗装备,2004,17(11):26-27
[53]Va1icenti RK. Waterman FM. Croce RJ.et al.Effieient CT simulation ofthefour-field teehnique for conformal radiotherapy of prostate careinoma. IntJ Radiat Oncol Biol Phys,1997,37:953-957.
[54]张鹭鹭,胡善联.区域内医院医疗资源配置效率研究[J].中华医院管理杂志,2000,16(5):270-272
[55]伏嘉宝.上海市某区二级综合性医院大型医疗设备配置和利用效率研究[J].复旦大学硕士学位论文.2010
[56]肖海汀.医院大型医用设备利用效率现况分析[J].中华医院管理杂志,2000,16(12):716-717
[57]雷海潮,毛阿燕.全国大型医用设备技术效率分析[J].医学装备,2002,1:17-20
[58]张军,关兵,周丹.大型医用设备利用效率及配置合理性分析[J].中国医疗设备.2008,23(7):67-69
[59]陈睦.医院设备利用率管理的探究[J].生物医学工程学进展[J].2009,30(3):169-171
[60]侯祖洪,秦俊等.湖北省CT机配置及使用现状调查分析汇报[J].公共卫生与预防医学,2008,19(l):90-91
[61]王骏,吴元赭.苏州地区大型医用影像设备配置综合评价[J].中华医院管理志,2009,24(7):74-76
[62]赵广宇,李捷玮,刘吉祥.我国大型医用设备配制现状及利用评价方法简介[J].医疗卫生装备,2003,12:41-43
[63]杨珺文.大型医用设备配置评价指标分析及建议[J].中国卫生质量管理,2011,18(2):75-78
[64]陶琳.大型医用设备配置合理性评价指标体系研究[J].中国医疗装备,2008,23(6):1-4
[65]马海燕.浙江三地城市居民社区卫生服务需求与利用评价[J].中国初级卫生保健,2007,21(1):25-28
[66]李贤相,洪倩.卫生综合评价方法研究进展[J].实用预防医学,2003,10(6):1035-1038
[67]飞思科技产品研发中心.神经网络理论与实现[M].北京:电子工业出版社,2005
[68]陈桃生,姚新胜,张若倩.基于主成分分析的公路货运站场布局评价[J].交通运输系统工程与信息,2006,6(3):125-131
[69]李陕生,罗智敏.大型医用设备的合理性探讨[J].公共卫生与预防医学,2006,2:92-94
[70]张玉珍,钱晓明.多种预测方法确定枢纽站场客运规模[J].公路营运,2004,8:17-21
[71]李陕生,周幼幼.大型医用设备配置规划中的限制性因素解析[J].卫生经济研究,2006(6):39-40
[72]颜丙约.四川省乙类大型医用设备配置数量影响因素研究[J].中国卫生事业管理.2001,4:224-229
[73]李功民.当前大型医用设备配置的风险性因子[J].公共卫生与预防医学,2006,17(6):97-98
[74]宁岩,任蒋.应用多元回归分析预测中国公共卫生补助的总量[J].中国卫生经济,2003,22(l):44
[75]朱勤忠,应向华.趋势预测法结合排队论在区域大型医疗设备配置规划中的应用[J].中国卫生资源,2007,10(5):226-228
[76]雷海潮.用于CT配置数量预测的滞后计量模型研究[J].中国卫生资源,2002,5(4):107-109
[77]苏芳.基于排队论的CT设备服务效率分析[D].山西医科大学硕士学位论文.2008
[78]Dickhaus CF,Burghart C,TemPanyC,et al. Wbrkflow modeling and analysisof Computer gnided prostate brachytherapy under MR imaging control. Sttd,Health Technol Inform.2004,98:72-74
[79]戴谷音,孙康平,韦文生.综合医院优化门诊流程的思路[J].中华医院管理杂志,2002,18:285-286
[80]周庆逸,梁万年.以病人为中心优化门诊流程[J].中华医院管理杂志,2004,20(8):491-493
[81]彭迎春,董斯彬,常文虎.运用排队论模型测量医院门诊流程效率[J].中华医院管理杂志,2005,21(12):806-809
[82]Bar-dayan,leiba,Weiss,et al.Wairting time is a major predictor of patientsatisfaction In a primary military clinic[J]. Mil-Med,2002,167(10):842-5
[83]郑静,凌莉,张福林等.门诊病人满意度的测量和评价[J].中华医院管理杂志.2004,20(6):372-374
[84]朱秀文,李令瑟,约翰.威特克等.医院急症病人医疗流程重构的研究[J].天津大学学报,2001,34(3):331-335
[85]程东梅,康雅斌,张清华.结合门诊医生站全面调整门诊就诊流程[J].中国医院,2002,6:46-48
[86]Norman D A. Designing waits that work [J]. MIT Sloan Management Review,2009,50(4):22-28.
[87]Lovejoy T C,Aravkin A Y,Schneider-Mizell C. Kalman queue: An adaptiveapproach to virtual queuing [J]. The UMAP Journal,2004,25(3);337-352.
[88]Kunniyur S,Srikant R. An adaptive virtual queue (AVQ) algorithm foractive queue management[J]. IEEE ACM Transactions on Networking,2004,(4):286-299
[89]SILVA F,SERRA D. Incorporating waiting time in competitive locationmodels[J]. Networks&Spatial Econ,2007,7(1):63-76.
[90]MARIANOV V,RIOS M,ICAZA M J. Facility location for market capture whenusers rank facilities by shorter travel and waiting times[J]. Eur JOperational Res,2008,35(2):327-338.
[91]Franx G J. A simple solution for the M/D/c waiting time distribution.Operations,2001,(29):221-229.
[92]SHAVANDI H,MAHLOOJI H. A fuzzy queuing location model with a geneticalgorithm for congested systems [J]. Appl Math&Computation,2006,181(1):440-456.
[93]张诗敏.按资源共享原则建立大型医用设备检治中心的可行性研究[D].四川大学硕士学位论文.2007
[94]苗春霞.成都市CT的配置和使用.四川大学硕士学位论文.2004
[95]William F, Sharpe. Budget and monitoring pension fund risk [J]. FinancialAnalysts Journal,2002,58(5):74-85
[96]Hogan K, Revelle C. Concept and application of backup coverage.Management Science,1986,32(11):1434-1444
[97]贾静.突发公共卫生事件的应急医疗设施选址问题的研究[D].北京交通大学博士学位论文.2007.
[98]BERMAN O, KRASS D,WANG J. Location service facilities to reduce lostdemand [J]. IIE Trans,2006,38(11):933-946.
[99]韩皓,王素玲.多级物流节点选址问题建模与求解[J].上海海事大学学报,2009,30(4):31-35.
[100]刘宝碇,赵瑞清,王纲.不确定规划及应用[M].北京:清华大学出版社,2003
[101]Marv in B, M andel.l Covering models for two-tiered emergency medicalservices systems [J]. Location Science,1998,128(6):355-368
[102]Guvenc Sah in. A review of hierarchical facility location models [J].Computers and Operations Research,2005(10):2310-2331.
[103]TA KA GI H, L EUN G K. Analysis of a discrete-time queueing system withtime-limited service [J]. QueueSyst,1994,18:183-197.
[104]Gross D, Harris CM. Fundamentals of queuing theory. New York Wiley,1998,150-161.
[105]Davis L. Handbook of Genetic Algorithm [M]. New York: Van NostrandReinhold,1991.
[106]Melin A, Granath J A. Patient focused healthcare: An important conceptfor provision and management of space and services to the healthcare sector[J]. Facilities,2004,22(11/12):284-289.
[107]Doerner K F, Gutjahr W J, Nolz P C. Multi-criteria location planning forpublic facilities in tsunami prone coastal areas [J]. OR Spectrum,2009,31(3):651-678.
[108]Ko zan E, Pr esto n P. Mathematical modelling of container transfers andstorage locations at seaport terminals[J]. OR Spectrum,2006,28(4):519-537.
[109]王宗军.集成式多目标权系数赋值方法[J].系统工程理论与实践,1996,8(2):12-19.
[110]杨桂元,郑亚豪.多目标决策问题及其求解方法研究[J].数学的实践与认识.2012,42(2):108-115
[111]Melin A, Granath J A. Patient focused healthcare: An important conceptfor provision and management of space and services to the healthcare sector[J]. Facilities,2004,22(11/12):284-289.
[112]蔡志强,孙树栋,司书宾,等.不确定环境下多阶段多目标决策模型[J].系统工程理论与实践,2010,30(9):1622-1629
[113]Lee A H I, Chen H H, Kang H Y. Multi-criteria decision making on strategicselection of wind farms[J]. Renewable Energy,2009,34:120-126Figureira J, Greco S, Ehrgott M. Muliple Criteria Decision Analysis: Stateof the ART Surveys[M]. London: Springer,2005.
[114]P.Z.Tan and B.Y.Kara.A hub covering model for cargo delivsysystems[J].Networks,2007,49(l):28-39
[115]李敏强,寇纪淞,林丹,李书全.遗传算法的基本理论与应用[M].北京:科学出版设,2002.
[116]雷英杰,张善文,李继武,周创明.MATLAB遗传算法工具箱及应用[M].西安:西安电子科技大学出版社,2005
[117]林伟鹏,闫整.医疗卫生体系改革与城市医疗卫生设施规划[J].城市规划,2006,4:47-50
[118]段茗玉,黄晓光.国产和进口大型医用设备采购价格比较研究[J].中国卫生经济,2011,30(2):67-68
[1]卫生部,国家发展和改革委员会,财政部.大型医用设备配置与使用管理办法[Z].2004.
[2]雷海潮.制定大型医用设备区域配置规划的方法学探讨[J].中国卫生事业管理,2000(2):74-77.
[3]韩荣芳,韩梅.应用CVP分析法配置大型医用设备[J].中国卫生经济,1998,6:44-45.
[4]贾智霞.浅议大型医用设备购置的财务评价[J].江苏卫生事业管理,2011,4:78-80.
[5]王骏,吴元赭.苏州地区大型医用影像设备配置综合评价[J].中华医院管理杂志,2009,24(7):74-76.
[6]陶晽.大型医用设备配置合理性评价指标体系研究[J].中国医疗设备,2008,23(6):1-4.
[7]刘杉.北京地区大型医用设备分布的公平性评估[J].医疗设备信息,2007(10):50-53.
[8]杨珺文,黄葭燕.大型医用设备配置评价指标分析及建议[J],中国卫生质量管理,2011,18(2):75-78.
[9]钱英,羊月祺.我国大型医用设备管理现状及发展趋势研究[J].医疗卫生装备,2011,32(7):115-118.
[10]陈英耀,董恒进,等.我国乙类大型医用设备配置、利用现状与政策建议[J].中国卫生资源,2012,15(1):42-45.
[11]颜丙约,谭玲,等.四川省乙类大型医用设备配置数量影响因素研究[J].中国卫生事业管理,2010,4:224-225.