基于知识工作结构化的知识共享实证研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
随着信息的大量积累、新的知识处理技术的采用以及工作的日益复杂化,带来了知识工作研究的浪潮,人们把很多活动纳入一个独立的领域,即知识工作。
     知识员工,作为知识工作的载体,既是知识的传输者又是知识的创造者,因此,在现代社会,知识工作及知识员工的重要性已经凸显出来。随着相关技术的发展,许多企业注重数据库和信息管理手段的开发和应用,以便知识最大程度地得以储存、利用、分享,使知识工作的内容不断更新。在这个过程中,知识共享作为知识管理的重要手段和核心内容,能够使知识在一定范围内自由流动和使用,节约知识获取成本,以提高知识的生产率,并有利于知识的传播与创新。然而管理实践中发现,单纯依靠技术性渠道无法实现高效的知识共享,于是更多的企业与学者开始关注知识共享中的非技术因素。
     本文在知识工作、知识共享的相关理论基础上,从知识工作结构化的视角,对知识共享及其影响因素之间的关系进行了研究。同时将知识共享分为两个层面,客观层面为知识工作内容本身所决定的结构化特性,主观层面为知识员工的利他主义、功力主义、互惠主义、价值主义四个维度,并构建模型。通过问卷调研,收集的有效问卷来自上海6家公司的114名IT人员,利用统计软件SPSS11.0和结构方程(SEM) AMOS7.0进行数据分析与假设检验,结果发现:知识工作结构化、利他主义、功利主义、互惠主义对于知识共享均存在显著影响,价值主义对于知识共享不存在显著影响。知识工作结构化越高,其知识共享越容易;知识工作结构化越低,其知识共享越困难。利他主义、功利主义、互惠主义对知识共享都有一定的促进作用,价值主义虽然没有通过检验,但该论证对知识共享后续研究有一定的参考价值。此外,本文对利他主义、功利主义、互惠主义对于知识共享的直接效应、间接效应及总效应给予了分析,得出:除利他主义本身能够在一定程度上影响知识共享外,对于功利性的追求也会促使个体表现出利他倾向,并间接促进知识共享的发生,即利他主义的体现不再单纯归结为不以预期回报为目的,可能包含对于功利的潜在回报预期。以上结论对现有的知识共享理论进行了验证与补充,并为组织有效实现知识共享提供了思路和方法。因此,本文的研究成果在一定程度上丰富了知识管理理论,对知识共享的研究与拓展起到了一定的指导性作用。
Along with the information of accumulation, adoption of new knowledge processing technology and the complexity of work, which brings knowledge work research tide, people put a lot of activities into a separate field, namely knowledge work.
     Knowledge workers, as the carrier of knowledge work, both knowledge transmitter and creator, the importance of knowledge work and knowledge workers has become more and more obvious. With the development of related technologies, many enterprises focus on the development and application of database and information management methods, to the greatest extent to store, use, and share knowledge, which makes the content of knowledge work constantly update. In this process, the knowledge sharing as an important means and the core content of knowledge management, which can make knowledge to free flow and use in a certain range, save acquisition cost of knowledge, in order to improve the productivity of knowledge, and to facilitate the spread and innovation of knowledge. However, it is found that in management practice, knowledge sharing is unable to be carried out efficient by technical channels, so more enterprise and scholars begin to pay close attention to the non-technological factors of knowledge sharing. Based on the related theory of the knowledge work, knowledge sharing, from the innovation perspective of knowledge structure, studied the relationship between knowledge sharing and its influencing factors, knowledge sharing can be divided into two levels, the objective aspect is structured characteristics determined by the content of knowledge work itself, the subjective aspect is divided into four dimension:Altruism, Benthamism, Reciprocity and Valuism of knowledge workers, Which constructs hypothesis model. By questionnaire investigation, the valid questionnaires were collected from 114 IT staff of Shanghai six companies, used statistical software SPSS11.0 and structural equation modeling (SEM) AMOS7.0 for data analysis and hypothesis testing, the results showed that:Knowledge Work Structure, Altruism, Benthamism, and Reciprocity significantly influence knowledge sharing, Valuism doesn't significantly influence knowledge sharing. The higher of knowledge work structure, the knowledge sharing is easier; the lower of knowledge work structure, the knowledge sharing is more difficult. Altruism, Benthamism and Reciprocity have certain simulative effect on knowledge sharing. Although Valuism doesn't pass the test, the proof has certain reference value for subsequent research of knowledge sharing. In addition, In addition, the paper analyzes the direct effect, indirect effect and total effect between Altruism, Benthamism, Reciprocity and knowledge sharing, it is concluded that:to a certain extent, in addition to Altruism itself can influence the knowledge sharing, for the pursuit of Benthamism also can lead to individual to show the tendency of Altruism and indirectly promote the occurrence of knowledge sharing, the reflection of Altruism is not only attributed to no expectation of return for purpose, may contain potential reward expectations of Benthamism. These conclusions validate and supplement on the existing theory of knowledge sharing, and effective implementation of knowledge sharing for the organization to provide the ideas and methods These conclusions to existing knowledge sharing theory are verified with supplement, and provides ideas and methods for the organization to realize knowledge sharing effectively.Therefore, the results of this study to some extent have enriched the knowledge management theory, and have some guiding effect on the study of knowledge sharing and expansion.
引文
[1]Davenport T, Prusak L.Working knowledge:how organizations manage what they know [M].Boston:Harvard Business School Press,1998.
    [2]Zack, M.Developing a Knowledge Strategy [J]. California Management Review.1999:41(3),Spring.125-143.
    [3](美)梅尔·西尔伯曼著.高变华译.咨询师的工具箱[M].第1版,机械工业出版社,2002.12-48.
    [4]Alavi.M&D, Leidnet. Knowledge management and knowledge management systems:Conceptual foundations and research issues [J]. MISQ Review.2001,25(1).107-136.
    [5]李涛,王兵.我国知识工作者组织内知识共享问题的研究[J].南开管理评论2003(5):16-19.
    [6]王润良、郭秀敏、郑晓齐.知识管理的维度与策略[J]中国软科学,2001(6).
    [7]李华伟,董小英,左美云.知识管理的理论与实践[M].北京:华艺出版社,2002.89.
    [8]Clarke, P., Cooper, M.:Knowledge Management and Collaboration.
    [9]Nonaka, I. Takeuchi, H, The knowledge-creating company:How Japanese companies create the dynamics of. Innovation,1995
    [10]OECD.杨宏进,薛澜译.以知识为基础的经济[M].北京:机械工业出版社,1997(4):38.
    [11]彼得·F·德鲁克.知识工人是新资本家[J].国外社会科学文献,2002(1)
    [12]迈克尔·罗杰斯等,美国知识产[M].普林斯顿大学出版社,1986,转引自:[美]詹姆斯·科塔达,知识工作者的兴起[M].新华出版社1999,109-123.
    [13]Jennifer Waiming Yau, Defining Knowledge Work-A British and Hispanic [J].Cross-Cultural Study,2003.
    [14]Cortada James W., Rise of Knowledge Worker [J].Industrial Management, 1998(4)72-84
    [15]弗朗西斯·赫瑞比,管理知识员工[M],北京,机械工业出版社,2000
    [16]Druck P., Management:Tasks, Responsibilities and Practices [M].Happer and Row:New York, NY,1993,186
    [17]G. David et al., Conceptual Model for Research on knowledge work [J].MISRC Working Paper (10),1991
    [18]Thomas H. Davenport et al., Improving Knowledge work Processes [J].Sloan Management Review, summer,1996
    [19]彼得·德鲁克著,21世纪的管理挑战[M].北京,生活.读书.新知三联书店,2000,131-156
    [20]Helton, B. Ray. Achieving white collar white water performance by organizational alignment [J]. National Productivity Review,1991,227-244.
    [21]Strassmann, Paul A. Information Technology:Will it make the Difference for Management Productivity? [J]. American Productivity Center, May 1986(37),2-6
    [22]Collins, D.Knowledge work or working knowledge,Ambiguity and confusion in the analysis of the "knowledge age" [J]. Systemic Knowledge Management, 1998(3).
    [23]Kelloway, E.K. and Barling, J. Knowledge work as organizational behavior [J]. Management Review [J].2000(3),287-304.
    [24]戴昌钧,陈臻祎.程序性和规范性知识工作界定准则的探讨[J].华东经济管理,2002(2):54-58.
    [25]Thompson,P.,Warhurst,C. and Callaghan,G, Ignorant theory and knowledgeable workers interrogating the connections between knowledge, skills and services[J]Journal of Management Studies,Vol.38 No.38,923-43.
    [26]Davenport,T.,Can you boost knowledge work's impact on the bottom line [J]Management Update.Vol.7 No.11,3-5
    [27][加]亨利·明茨伯格著,思铭译.哈佛商业评论,精粹译丛-领导[M],中国人民大学出版社,哈佛商学院出版社,2004,1-36.
    [28]Joan.G. Turner.RN.Job analysis 1996:Infection control professional, Amer[J]. Infection Control,1999(2),145-157.
    [29]Lauren E.Mc Entire. Innovations in job analysis:Development and application of metrics to analyze job data[J].Human Resource Management Review,2006(3), 310-323.
    [30]张鹏程,廖建桥,杜旌,脑力劳动测量模型研究[J].科学学研究,2003(5),519-523.
    [31]李永建,李瑾坤,王蕾,知识作业的“动素”研究[J].工业工程,2006(5),49-52.
    [32]刘学方,王重鸣,唐宁玉等,家族企业接班人胜任力建模——一个实证研究[J].管理世界,2006(5),96-106.
    [33]邵祖峰,胡斌,章得宾,企业管理岗位职能变化过程定性模拟研究[J].工业工程与管理,2006(2),26-31.
    [34]Robert J. Harvey, Mark A. Wilson, There is an objective job analysis [J]. Organizational Behavior,2000.
    [35]Hanser,L.M., Traditional and Cognitive Job Analyses as Tools for Understanding the Skills Gap,Berkeley: National Center for Research in Vocational Education, University of California,1995.
    [36]Fine,S.A., Functional job analysis scales:Adeskaid.Milwaukee,WI:Ahthor,1989.
    [37]Robert J. Harvey. The common-metric questionnaire:Applications and current research. In S. Fine (Chair), Multipurpose job analysis:New Approaches supporting integrated human resource management. Symposium presented at the annual conference of the Society for Industrial and Organizational Psychology, SanFrancisco,1993.
    [38]McCormick E.J., Jeanneret P.R.,& Mecham R.C., "A study of job characteristics & job dimensions as based on the Position Analysis Questionnaire(PAQ)"[J]. AppliePsychology,1972(56),347-368
    [39]Bostorm, RP. Successful application of communication techniques to improve systems development process. [J]Information &Management,1989:(16)
    [40]Paul Hendriks. Why Share Knowledge? The influence of ICT on the motivation for knowledge sharing[J].knowledge and Process management,1999;6(2)
    [41]钟耕深,赵前.团队组织中知识共享的风险障碍与对策[J].山东社会科学,2005(7):116-119
    [42]刘冀生.企业知识管理战略.2003年中国知识管理理论与实践专家研讨会,2003
    [43]杨溢.企业内知识共享与知识创新的实现[J].情报科学,2003,21(10):1107-1109
    [44]闰芬,陈国权.实施大规模定制中组织知识共享研究[J].管理工程学报,2002,16(3):39-43
    [45]路琳.人际关系对组织内部知识共享行为的影响研究[J]科学学与科学技术管理,2006(4):116-121
    [46]Herzberg F. Work and the Nature of Management in London[M] Granada Publishing,1968
    [47]Hamel G. Competition for Competence and Inter - Partner Learning Within International Strategic Alliance[J]. Strategic Management,1991 (12):83-103.
    [48]Szulanski G Exploring internal stickiness:impediment s to the transfer of best practice within the firm[J].Strategic Management,1996 (17):27-43
    [49]Leenders RTAJ,Engelen JMLV, Kratzer J.Virtuality, Communication, and New Product Team Creativity:a Social Network Perspective[J]. Engineering and Technology Management,2003 (20):69-92
    [50]胡婉丽,汤树昆.基于研发过程的知识创造和知识转移[J].科学学与科学技术管理,2004(1):20-23
    [51]邓丹.研发团队的知识共享研究——从社会网络的角度[D]南京航空航天大学 硕士论文,2006
    [52]龙勇,李忠云.技能型战略联盟基于信任的知识获取和合作效应实证研究.[J]研究与发展管理,2006(5):36-43
    [53]邵俊.构建角色均衡团队的知识共享策略研究[D]南京航空航天大学硕士论文,
    2007
    [54]Cummings J L. Teng B S.Transferring R&D Knowledge:the Key Factors Affecting Knowledge Transfer Success [J]. Engineering and Technology Management,2003 (2):39-68
    [55]Zaheer A, McEvily B, Perrone V.Does Trust Matter? Exploring the Effect s of Inter organizational and Interpersonal Trust on Performance [J].Organization Science,1998 (2):141-159
    [56]Baum JAC, Ingram P.Survival - enhancing learning in the Manhattan hotel industry[J].Management Science,1998(44):996-1016
    [57]Szulanski G.The Process of Knowledge Transfer:A Diachronic Analysis of Stickiness[J].Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,2000 (1): 9-27
    [58]Andrews KM, Delahaye BL.Influence on Knowledge Processes in Organizational Learning:The psychosocial filter[J].Management Studies,2000 (37):797-810.
    [59]Levin DZ, Cross R.The Strength of Weak Ties you Can Trust:The Mediating Role of Trust in Effective Knowledge Transfer.[J].Management Science,2004 (11):1477-1490
    [60]郭强,施琴芬.企业隐性知识显性化的外部机理和技术模式[J]自然辩证法研究,2004(20):69-72
    [61]LIN Hsiu-Fen,et al. Evaluation of factors influencing knowledge sharing based on a fuzzy AHP approach [J]. Information Science,2009,35 (1):25-44.
    [62]HALL H, GOODYM1 KM, culture and compromise-interventions to promote knowledge sharing supported by technology in corporate environments [J]. Information Science,2007,33(2):181-188.
    [63]BLANKENSH IP SS, RUONA W E A. Exploring knowledge sharing in social structures-potential contributions to an overall knowledge management strategy [J]. Advances in Developing Human Resources,2009,11(3):290-306.
    [64]YANG Chyan,CHEN Liang-Chu. Can organizational knowledge capabilities affect knowledge sharing behavior [J]. Information Science,2007,33 (1):95-109.
    [65]SIEMSEN E, BALASUBRAMAN IAN S, ROTH A V. Incentives that induce task-related effort, helping, and knowledge sharing in workgroups [J]. Management Science,2007,53(10):1533-1550.
    [66]WILLEM A, BUELENSM. Knowledge sharing in public sector organizations [J]. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,2007 (17):5812-6061
    [67]WILLEMA,BUELENSM, SCARBROUGH H. The role of inter-unit coordination mechanisms in knowledge sharing [J].Information Science,2006,33 (6):539-561.
    [68]NEWELL S, et all Sharing knowledge across projects [J].Management Learning, 2006,37(2):167-185.
    [69]LIN Hsiu,Fen. Effects of extrinsic and intrinsic motivation on employee knowledge sharing intentions [J].Information Science,2007,33 (2):135-149.
    [70]QUIGLEYNR, et all A multilevel investigation of the motivational mechanisms underlying knowledge sharing and performance [J]. Organization Science,2007, 18(1):71-88.
    [71]SIEMSEN E, et all.The influence of psychological safety and confidence in knowledge on employee knowledge sharing [J]. Manufacturing & Service Operations Management,2009,11(3):4292-4471
    [72]ANTALA B, RICHEB'e N.A passion for giving, a passion for sharing [J]. Management Inquiry,2009,18(1).
    [73]MOORADIAN T, et all Who trusts? Personality、trust and knowledge sharing [J]. Management Learning,2006,37 (4):523-540.
    [74]ARD ICHV IL I A.Learning and knowledge sharing in virtual communities of Practice motivators, barriers, and enablers [J].Advances in Developing Human Resources,2008,10 (4):541-554.
    [75]VOELPEL S C, et.all. David against goliath? Group size and bystander effects in virtual knowledge sharing [J]. Human Relations,2008,61(2):271-295.
    [76]Kathryn M Bartol, Abhishek Srivastava. Encouraging Knowledge Sharing: The Role of Organizational Reward Systems[J].Leadership&Organizational Studies,2002,9(1):64-76
    [77]Sandra Jones. Employee Rights, Employee Responsibilities and Knowledge Sharing in Intelligent Organization [J].Employee Responsibilities and Right, 2002,14(2/3):69-78
    [78]Gee Woo Bock, Young-Gul Kim. Break the Myths of Rewards:An Exploratory Study of Attitudes about Knowledge Sharing. [J] Information Resources Management,2002,15(2):14-21
    [79]Constand, kielser,sproull.Whats mine is ours, or is it,A study of attitudes about Information sharing. [J]Information Systems Research,1994,5(4):400-421.
    [80]余光胜.企业发展的知识分析[M].上海财经大学出版社,2000.145-149
    [81]李涛,谢伟.基于信息技术的组织内知识共享动机的研究[J].情报科学,2004,23(6):275-280
    [82]冯天学,田金信.基于企业内知识转移与共享的激励模式研究[J].预测2005(5):9-13
    [83]潘颖雯,杨静,鄢飞.员工知识共享意愿激励机制概念模型的构建[J].西安工程大学学报:2008(12):779-784
    [84]陈永清.不完全信息条件下企业内部知识共享的演化博弈分析[J].科技管理研究2009(8):281-283
    [85]范道津,郭瑜桥.基于激励优化的企业知识共享机制研究[J].技术经济与管理研究,2008(4):39-41
    [86]冯帆,杨忠.组织激励与知识共享:员工心理需求的匹配效应[J]南京社会科学2009(5):44-51
    [87]张波.面向知识服务业的知识共享机制研究[J]电子科技大学(学报社科版),2006(1):61-63.
    [88]陈松青.企业的知识共享和激励机制[J].人力资源,2007(8):55-56.
    [89]戴小鹏,夏红球,刘意文.企业员工知识共享行为的激励分析探讨[J]农业图书情报学刊,2008(2):163-166.
    [90]孙红萍,王静一.社会资本和知识共享意向的作用机制:基于知识密集型企业的实证研究[J]科技进步与对策,2009(1):138-142.
    [91]诸葛剑平.知识密集型组织内实现知识共享的激励策略选择[J]科学学与科学技术管理,2008(5):86-89.
    [92]Kidd, A. (1994). The marks are on the knowledge worker. Proceedings of CHI. [N]ACM Press:Boston, MA.186-191.
    [93]OECD以知识为基础的经济[M]机械工业出版社,1997
    [94]彼得·F·德鲁克等知识管理[M]中国人民大学出版社,哈佛商学院出版社,1999,23-31
    [95]戴昌钧,国家自然科学基金项目(批准号70172030,2002-2004)研究报告,2005.3.
    [96][日]竹内弘高,野中郁次郎著,李盟译.知识创造的螺旋:知识管理理论与案例研究[M].知识产权出版社,2006,30-34.
    [97]杨丹,知识工作的结构分析及模型表征[J]南开管理评论,2007,57(6),86-92.
    [98]赵曙明冯芷艳刘洪.人力资源管理研究新进展[M].南京大学出版社.2002,72-74.
    [99]Leonard,D. Wellsprings of Knowledge:Building and Sustaining the Sources of Innovation.Boston.[J] Harvard Business School Press.1995,29-58.
    [100]Barnes,B. The Nature of Power. Cambridge[J].Polity Press.1988.55-94.
    [101]Hendriks. p. Why Share Knowledge? The Influence of ICT on Motivation for Knowledge Sharing[J].Knowledge and Process Management,1999
    [102]Nancy, M.D., Common Knowledge:How Companies thrive by sharing What they know[J].Long Range Planning,2001(34)
    [103]Davenport T, Prusak L. Working Knowledge:How Organization Manage What They Know[M]. Harvard Business School Press,1998.23-24.
    [104]川野中郁次郎.知识创新型组织[M].北京:中国人民大学出版社,1999.
    [105]Kaj U Koskinena,Pekka Pihlanto,HannuVanharanta. Tacit Knowledge Acquisition and Sharing in a Project Work Context [J]. Project Management, 2003, (21):281-290.
    [106]HANSEN M T, NOHR IA N,TIERNEY T. What's your strategy for managing Knowledge [J].Harvard Business Review,1999,77(2):106-116.
    [107]刘明杞,郭东强.IT企业内部知识共享的递阶模式浅析.科技管理研究[J].2008(3):219-221
    [108]HendriksP. Why Share Knowledge? The Motivation for Knowledge Sharing [J]. Knowledge and process Management,1999,6(2):91-100.
    [109]Nonaka,I,&Takeuchi,H. The knowledge Creating Company:How Japanese Companies create the dynamics of innovation [J].Harvard Business
    [110]Bandura,A Self-Efficacy Mechanism in Human Agency.[J] American Psychologist,37(2), February,1982.
    [111]Davenport, T.H., Successful Knowledge Management Projects. [J]Sloan Management Review,1998:443-457.
    [112]Taylor S. E.等著,谢晓非等译.社会心理学[M].北京:北京大学出版社,2005,487-488
    [113]Chennamaneni, A. Determinants of Knowledge Sharing Behaviors:Developing and Testing an Integrated Theoretical Model [D].The University of Texas at Arlington,2006.
    [114]Hoffman,M.L." Altruistic Behavior and the Parent-Child Relationship"[J]. Personality and Social Psychology,1975(31).
    [115]O'Dell, C. Grayson, J.C. If Only We Knew What We Know:The Transfer of Internal Knowledge and Best Practice [M].New York:The Free Press,1998
    [116]Bock, G. W., Kim, Y. G. Breaking the myths of rewards:An exploratory study of attitudes about knowledge sharing [J].Information Resource Management, 2002,15(2):14-21
    [117]斯蒂芬·罗宾斯.组织行为学[M].孙健敏,李原,译[M]北京:中国人民大学出版社,2006(10)
    [118]WAYNE SJ, SHORE LM, LIDEN R C. Perceived Organizational Support and Leader-member Exchange:A Social Exchange Perspective [J].Academy of Management,1997(40):82-111.
    [119]REZAI-RASHTI. Reciprocity and Knowledge Transfer:The Role of Social and Economic Factors[D]. Doctoral Dissertation, The University of Western Ontario, 2002:28.
    [120]Husted,K.,&Michailova,S.Diagnosing and fighting knowledge-sharing hostility.[J]Organizational Dynamics,2002,31(1),60-73.
    [121]Jens Gammelgaard. Why we are so hostile to sharing knowledge [J].EBF, issue 18, summer 2004.
    [122]刑以群,杨琪.如何进行有效的知识共享——一个整合的框架[J].经济论坛,2004年第11期.
    [123]Hedlund Gunnar.A Model of Knowledge Management and the N-Form Corporation J].StrategyManagemer,1994(15):73-90
    [124]McDermott,R.,O'Dell,C. Overcoming cultural barriers to sharing knowledge. [J]Knowledge Management,2001,5(1),76-85.
    [125]ZA'RRAGA C, BONACHE J. Assessing the team environment for knowledge sharing:An empirical analysis [J].Human Resource Management,2003,14 (7): 1227-1245.
    [126]BOCK GEE - WOO, LEE JAE - NAM, ZMUD R W, et al. Behavioral intention formation in knowledge sharing:Examining the roles of extrinsic motivators, social-psychological forces, and organizational climate [J]. M IS Quarterly,2005, 29(1):87-111.
    [127]周密,姚芳,姚小涛.员工知识共享、知识共享意愿与信任基础[J]软科学2006(87):109-113.
    [128]姜文.知识共享的障碍因素及其对策分析[J].科技管理究,2007(3):200-203.
    [129]Senge P. Sharing Knowledge[J]. Executive Excellence,1997,(11):15-27.
    [130]Bandura.A. Regulation of Cognitive Processes through Perceived Self-Efficacy [J].Development Psychology,25(5),1989,729-735.
    [131]Morrison, E.W., "Role Definitions and Organizational Citizenship Behavior: TheImportance of Employee's Perspective", Academy of Management Review, 1994,14(2),157-169.
    [132]AmabileT.M. Motivational synergy:Toward new conceptualizations of intrinsic and extrinsic motivation in the workplace [J].Human Resource Management Review,1993(3):185-201
    [133]Spreitzer, G.M., "Psychological empowerment in the workplace:dimensions, measurement, and validation", Academy of Management Journal,1995(5), 1442-1465.
    [134]Hargadon, A.B. Firms as knowledge brokers:lessons in pursuing continuous innovation [J] California Management Review,1998(3),209-297.
    [135]Hsiu-Fen Lin.Knowledge sharing and firm innovation capability:an empirical study[J].International Journal of Manpower,2007(28):315-332
    [136]薛薇SPSS统计分析方法及应用(第2版)[M].北京:电子工业出版社,2009.第一版
    [137]Kline. Principles and practice of structural equation modeling. Administrative Science Quarterly,1989,5(3):13-13
    [138]Aiken L.S.,&West S.G. Multiple regression:Testing and interpreting interactions. Newbury Park,1991,21-21
    [139]Bollen K.A. Structural equations with latent variables NY:John Wiley&Sons, 1991,18-19
    [140]Steiger J H.Structure model evaluation and modification:An interval estimation approach. Multivariate Behavioral Research,1990(25):173-180
    [141]易丹辉.结构方程模型方法与应用[M].中国人民大学出版社,2008(4),第一版
    [142]侯杰泰,温忠麟,成子娟.结构方程模型及其应用[M].教育科学出版社,2004(7),第一版
    [143]Bentler P.M. Comparative fit indexes in structural models. Psychological Bulletin,1990(107):238-246.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700