摘要
随着我国经济社会的深入发展,人民生活水平的提高,各种组织为了在竞争中保持和取得竞争优势,必须进行不断的发展和变革来适应各方面的变化发展的要求。对于医院来说,我国经济发展在近三十年来一直保持着一个较高的发展速度,在居民对医院服务提出更高的要求,而医院的总体组织结构等没有发生一定的变化,医院必须从内部进行组织变革。医院不但要加强内部管理,完善内部机制,提高医院的技术水平和服务水平,而且需要转变观念,借鉴现代企业管理变革理念,以求在市场竞争中生存和发展。
本文结合笔者对HZ医院项目的调研工作和资料,从对医院的中高层、医护人员、病人和当地居民的问卷和访谈资料的基础上,结合医院提供的资料对HZ医院的组织变革管理与组织绩效关系进行研究。在吸取了一般企业变革管理研究经验的基础上,通过建立SSC模型,从组织变革的组织战略变革、组织结构变革和组织文化变革等三个角度与组织绩效关系来研究,通过问卷数据进行实证分析。论证了组织战略变革、结构变革和文化变革三大因素积极的影响着医院的组织绩效。同时,通过研究医院近几年来的财务数据、问卷和内部相关资料,包括财务指标、市场占有率、人员数等角度论证了在变革的前后,从实际可以量化的数据来论证这种绩效的改进。全文从问卷的角度和实际可以量化角度来论证了医院组织变革对组织绩效改进的积极作用。
本文选择有代表性的HZ医院,对医院的组织变革与组织绩效的关系进行研究。通过研究笔者认为在医院管理下,吸取一般企业组织变革管理的经验对医院的组织绩效提升有着积极的影响。这些研究对医院的改革和发展具有一定的参考价值。
With the further development of China’s economy and the markedly improved people’s living standard, all organizations, in order to obtain and maintain their competitiveness, have to accommodate the requirements of change by constant development and reformation. China has enjoyed a high speed economic growth in the past 30 years. People have new demand of services on hospitals. When outer competition intensified, hospitals must carry on internal organization reform. Hospitals not only should enhance their management, complete internal mechanism, boost technological and service level, but also should reform their ideas, learn the methods of modern managerial reformation. Thus, they can survive from the fierce market competition.
On the basis of the questionnaires and interviews of the super ordinate in the hospital , doctors and nurses, patients and local residents, this paper combines the research on the project of HZ Hospital as well as the data from the hospital, the paper aims to study the management of HZ Hospital’s organizational reform and its organizational performance. On the basis of learning from the experience of reform management of current enterprises, the study was conducted from the relation between three angles of organizational tactic reform, organizational structure reform and organizational cultural reform with organizational performance. The empirical research proves that the three elements of organizational reform affect the organizational performance of the hospital indeed. On the basis of establishing SSC model, the paper demonstrates the positive effect through certain relevant questionnaires and data. Meanwhile, the paper demonstrates the differences between before and after reform by studying the financial data and relevant information of the hospital in the past few years, which includes financial index, market share, number of personnel, etc. The quantitative data proves the improvement of performance. The thesis proves the positive effect of the hospital’s organizational reform on the organizational performance from the angle of questionnaires and quantitative data.
The paper, which chooses the representative HZ Hospital as the object of organizational reform and organizational performance research, is aimed at studying the relation between the two. Through the research, the author believes that under the control of the hospital, assimilating the experience of organizational reform experience of current enterprises offers positive effect on the improvement of the organizational performance of the hospital. The study offers theoretical and practical guidance for the reform and development of the hospital.
引文
[1] Jeffrey A.Alexander. Managing Hospitals in turbulent times:do organizational changes improve hospital survival? [J]Health Services Research [EB/OL], [1999-10] , [2007-5-13] ,http://finderticles.com/p/articles/mi_m4149/is_4_34/ai_57796345/pg_1
[2] Eda P.Topliss,.Organizational Change as Illustrated by a Case-Study of a Geriatric Hospital[J],The British Journal of Sociology ,1974,25(3):356
[3]Robert.A.Rothman,Allen M.Schwartzbaum,John H.McGrath,Physicians and a Hospital Merger: Patterns of Resistance to Organizational Change[J],Journal of Health and Social Behavior,1971,12(1):46
[4]杨炯,徐卫国.现代企业组织变革趋势对医院组织变革的借鉴[J].中国医院管理,2002,22(10):2
[5]任真年.现代医院管理创新变革要变阻力为助力[J],中华适宜诊疗技术杂志,2004,22(4):44
[6]刘向红,李汉铃.我国公立非营利性医院组织变革过程中人力资本的柔性管理研究[J],中国海洋大学学报(社会科学版),2006,3:49
[7]詹姆斯·马奇和赫伯特.西蒙合著,邵冲译,.组织[M].北京:机械工业出版社,2008
[8]巴纳德著,曾琳,赵青译..组织与管理[M].北京:中国人民大学出版,2009
[9]卡斯特,罗森茨威客,李柱流等译..组织与管理:系统方法与权变方法[M].北京:中国社会科学出版社,1985
[9] Barles Stephen;Murphy Elizabeth;Randel Robert;Williams Kathy;Verschoor Curtis C;Murphy Elizabeth A,Best Corporate Citizens Have Better Financial Performance,Stategic Finance,Vol.83 Issue7,2002.06
[10]吴秉恩.组织行为学[M],台北:华泰书局,1986
[11] Carnall, C. A. Managing Change in Organizations[M], U.K. Prentice Hall, International Ltd. ,1990
[12]Strebel, P.(1992), Breakpoints: How Managers Exploit Radical Business Change. Boston, MA: Harvard Business School.
[13]卢瑞阳,组织行为:管理心理与心理导向,初版[M],台北:华泰书局,1993
[14]达夫特著.组织理论与设计[M],北京:清华大学出版社,1994
[15]科特著.刘祥亚译.变革之心[M]北京:机械工业出版,2003
[16]朱祖平.变革管理[M].北京:经济科学出版社,2001
[17]余凯成,组织行为学[M],大连:大连理工大学出版社,2001
[18]张阳、周海炜.现代企业管理一变革的观点[M].上海:复旦大学出版社,2001
[19]Recardo.R J. The What and How of Change Manage-ment[J].Manufacturing System, 1991,(5):52-58.
[20]许长田.变革狂潮初版[M]台北:五南出版社2004
[21]Townsend BW,Zutshi A,Bekersky I..Biodistribution of cholesterol-AmBisome following a singleintravenous administration to rats[J].Drug Metab Dispos, 2001,29(5):681-685.
[22] Hammer, Michael, James Champy著.杨幼兰译.改造企业:再生策略的蓝本[M].牛顿出版公司,1994
[23]萧琛.论中国经济改革:道路、转轨、接轨:从世界经济看中国[M].北京:北京大学出版社,1996.
[24]林奇著.文红、陈涛、杨晶译.公司战略[M](第四版)中国市场出版社,2009
[25] Frid R.David.李克宁译战略管理[M]北京:经济科学出版社,2001
[26]小詹姆斯·H·唐纳利、詹姆斯·L·吉布森、约翰·M·伊凡赛维奇著,司徒淳译:管理学基础,辽宁大学出版社,1988
[27]帕尔,默埃金,邓福德著.金永红,奚玉芹译组织变革管理[M].北京:中国人民大学出版社,2009
[28]张鼎昆突破[M]北京:机械工业出版社,2004
[29]蔡利忠,企业变革的阻力研究[D]浙江大学优秀硕士论文,2002
[30]齐振宏.企业组织变革的五大阻力透析.未来与发展.2004(03)50-52
[31]李作战.从组织变革的模式选择看组织变革的阻力及其克服.现代管理科学,2007(06)45-46
[32] Johnson,P.Fraser,Michiel R.Lenders.The Supply Organizational Structure Dilemma[J].Journal of Supply Chain Management,Summer:2001,(6).4-11
[33] Decanio, Catherine Dibble. Importance of Organizational Structure for the Adoption of Innovations[J]. Management Science, 2000,46(10):1285-1299. [10
[34]Mils,Peter K.,Gerardo R,Ungson.Reassesing the Limits of Structural Empo werment:Organizational Constitution and Trust as Controls[J].Academy of Management Review,2003,28(1)
[35]詹姆斯.S.科尔曼著.邓方译.社会理论的基础[M]北京:社会科学文献出版社,1999
[36]Donaldon,Lex.Organizational Portfolio Theory:Performance-Driven Organizational Change[J].Contemporary Economic Policy,2000,18(4).
[37]Seth Lloyd and Heinz Pagels,Complexity as Thermodynamic Depth,Ann. Physics. 188 (1988):186~213.
[38]成思危.复杂性科学探索[M].北京:民主与建设出版社,1999.
[39]埃德加·沙因.沙因组织心理学[M].中国人民大学出版社,2009.
[40]森茨韦克,卡斯特著.傅严等译.组织与管理--系统方法与权变方法[M].北京:社会科学文献出版社,2000
[41]哈罗德·J.莱维特(Harold J.Leavitt)著;方展画,刘纯译.现代管理心理学论组织中的个体、同事和团体[M].上海:翻译出版公司,1988.6
[42]彼得斯、沃特曼著.戴春平译.追求卓越[M]中央编译出版社,2003
[43]科特著.罗立彬译.变革[M]机械工业出版社,2005
[44]王凤彬.企业管理组织变革的理论与实践[M].北京:中国人民大学出版,1994.
[45]钱平凡..组织转型[M].杭州:浙江人民出版社. 1999
[46]芮明杰,钱平凡.再造流程[M].杭州:浙江人民出版社. 1997
[47]芮明杰,袁安照.管理重组[M].淅江人民出版社. 2000
[48]Mintzberg (1987), Five P’s for Strategy[J], California Management. Review, 30, 11-24.
[49]Boeker, W. (1989),“Strategic change: The effects of founding and history”[J], Academy of Management Journal, 32, pp.489-551.
[50]Alfred D. Chandler.1962.Strategy and structure - Chapters in the History of the Industrial Enterprise[M]. MIT Press; United States;
[51]Porter, M.E. 1980.Competitive Strategy[M].The Free Press, New York.
[52]Makino, Shige and Paul W. Beamish.1998.Performance and Survival of Joint Ventures with Non-Conventional Ownership Structures[J].Journal of International Business Studies, 29(4): 797-818.
[53]M.T. Hannan, J. Freeman .1984.Structural inertia and organizational change[J].American Sociological Review, 49 :149 - 164.
[54]Naisbitt. 1982.Megatrends[M].Grand Central Pub.
[55] Barney J B. 1991.Firm resources and sustained competitive advantage[J]. Journal of Management, 17(1):99-120
[56]Kilmann, R. H. 1982. Getting control of corporate culture[J]. Managing, 2:11-17.
[57]Tichy, J. 1982. Human resources management[M]. New York: McGraw-Hill.
[58]Hofstede, G.1986.Cultural differences in teaching and learning[J].International Journal of Intercultural Relations 10 (3):301-320
[59]W Brooke Turnstall.1983.Cultural Transition at AT&T[J].Sloan Management Review.25(03):15-26.
[60]Louis. 1983.The Environment of Marketing Channel Dyads:A Framework for Comparative Analysis[J].Journal of Marketing, 47(4):55 -67.
[61]Dyer.1984.Linking Human Resource and Business Strategies[J].Human Resource Planning, 7(2): 79-84.
[62] Zajac, Edward J., Kraatz, and Matthew S.1993.A Diametric Forces Model of Strategic Change: Assess the Antecedents and Consequences of Restructuring in The Higher Education Industry[J].Strategic Management Journal, 14: 83-102
[63] Haveman, H. 1992.Between a rock and a hard place:Organization change and performance under conditions of fundamental environmental transformation[J]. Administrative Science Quarterly. 37:48-75.
[64] Kim, E. & Mc Intosh, J. C..1996. The Faster, the Better?: An Empirical Study on the Speed of Strategic Change and Firm Survival and Performance[J].Journal of Applied Business Research, 12(2): 35-40.
[65] Kelly & Amburgey.1991.Organizational inertia and momentum: A dynamic model of strategic change[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 34:591-612
[66] Tushman, M.L. and E. Romanelli.1985.Organizational evolution: A metamorphosis model of convergence and reorientation[J].Research in Organizational Behavior, 7: 171-222.
[67] DeCanio, Stephen J., Catherine Dibble, and Keyvan Amir-Atefi.2000. The Importance of Organizational Structure for the Adoption of Innovations[J].Management Science, 46(10):1285-1299.
[68] Donaldson, Organizational portfolio theory: performance-driven organizational change[J], Contemporary Economic Policy 2000, 18(4):386-396
[69] Williamson, O.E. 1975.Markets and Hierarchies: Analysis and Antitrust Implications[M]. New York : Free Press.
[70] X. Lin, R. Germain.2003.Organizational structure, context, customer orientation, and performance: Lessons from Chinese state-owned enterprises[J].Strategic Management Journal, 24:1131 - 1151.
[71]吴声凤.2008.信息时代的企业组织结构变革[J].贵阳学院学报(自然科学版),3(01)
[72]孙公伟.2008.现代企业人力资本投资研究[J].商场现代化.21.
[73] Barney, J. B. 1986.Strategic factor markets: Expectations, luck and business strategy[J].Management Science,31:1231 - 1241.
[74] Denison, D. R., & Mishra, A. K. 1995. Toward a theory of organizational culture and effectiveness[J]. Organization Science, 6(2):204–223.
[75] Kanter, R. M. 1983.The Change Masters[M]. New York: Simon & Schuster.
[76]邓荣霖,吴欣,郑平. 2006.组织文化、组织结构与绩效:中国企业的实证研究[J].商业研究,22.
[77] Macpherson M.performance measurement in not-for-profit and public-sector organizations[J]Measuring Business Excellence,2001,5(2):13-17
[78]司徒达贤.非营利组织的经营管理[M].台北:天下远见,1999
[79]邓国胜.非营利组织评估体系研究[J].中国行政管理,2001(10):41-43
[80]刘宇喆.浅议非营利组织评估[J].科技创业. 2005(04)78-80
[81]吕键,王明晓.医疗机构《卓越绩效评价准则》实施指南[M].北京:化学工业出版社,2007
[82]王宇.企业外部环境驱动下的战略变化及其绩效的关联性研究[M]成都:西南财经大学出版社,2009
[83]沈波.企业信息资源配置对企业绩效影响的研究[M]北京:中国财政经济出版社,2009
[84] Said A AHassabelnaby,Wier B An empirical investigation of the performance consequences of nonfinancial measuers.[J]Jorunal of Managenment Accounting Research,2003(15):193-223
[85] Baker R D,Potter G,Srinivasan D.An empirical invertigation of an incertive plan that includes non-financial performance measures[J] Organization Science,2003(14):510-527
[86] Sittimalakorn W,Hart S.Market orientation versus quality orientation:sources of superior business performance.[J] Jurnal of Stategic Marketing 2004(12):243-253
[87] Riley Jr R A,Person T A ,Trompeter G.The value relevance of non-financial performance varia bles and accounting information:the case of the airline industry.Journal of Accounting and Public Policy,2003(22):231-254.
[88] Abdel-Maksoud A,Dugdale D,Luther R.Non-financial performance measurement in manrfacturing companies.The British Accounting Reciew,2005(37):261-297
[89] Sale M L,Inman R A.Survey-based comparison of performance and change in performance of firms using traditional manufacturing,JIT and TOC[J].International Journal of Pruduction Research,2003(41):829-844
[90] Jeremy Chery AG,Michael AM Patient Satisfaction Hospital Report 2001[J].Actue Care Technical Summary,2001 5-35
[91]张丽君,陈平雁,王景明.网络模式下住院病人满意度量表的研制[J].中华医院管理杂志,2005,21:442一445.
[92]郑静,凌莉,张福林等.门诊病人满意度的测量和评价[J].中华医院管理杂志,2004,20:372一373.