摘要
本文实证研究了中国对非洲直接投资和中国与非洲双边贸易的关系,并且分析了前两者对非洲经济增长的影响。我们使用了来自于被选定作为样本非洲东道国的数据集,并采用了STATA软件对数据进行静态和动态面板数据分析。我们先评估了中国对非洲直接投资(FDI)流量和中国对非洲的进、出口之间的关系,然后我们又研究了前三者同时对东道国的GDP增长,实际人均GDP增长以及对东道国就业的共同作用。为此,本文的结构围绕着四个主轴。首先,在研究中国对非洲直接投资的影响因素时把中国对非洲的出口、中国从非洲的进口,中国承包商在非洲的营业额,中-非合作论坛平台和东道国的自然资源禀赋作为重点考虑和观察的因素。实证结果显示所有这些解释变量都对中国对非洲直接投资流量有着显著的积极影响,除中国对非洲的出口额以外。其次,我们研究了中国对非洲出口贸易的决定因素。在此过程中我们重点考虑了中国对非洲直接投资年度流量,中国在东道国签约项目的年度总金额,中国在与东道国进行劳动合作的年度收益总额,中国制造业年度增值比率以及在中国给以私营部门的年度贷款便捷等因素。得出来的结果是中国对非洲直接投资流量积极影响了中国对非洲的出口贸易。与此同时除了在中国给以私营部门的年度贷款便捷这个变量以外,其他上述的因素都对中国向非洲的出口都有着显著的正面影响。此外,在已包括其它控制变量的情况下,我们估计了中国对非洲直接投资流量和非洲东道国的自然资源禀赋对中国从非洲进口的作用。我们发现,中国对非洲直接投资和东道国的自然资源禀赋一直在积极共同的影响着中国从非洲的进口。中国对非洲的直接投资与中-非贸易存在互补性关系,这些对非洲直接投资大多有垂直、上游寻求资源或下游服务出口的性质。第三,我们研究了中国对非洲直接投资流量、中国对非洲的出口和中国从非洲的进口等三个要素对非洲东道国经济增长的影响,通过前三者其对GDP增长和实际人均GDP的增长。实证分析结果表明自2003年以来非洲国家明显上升的GDP增长率有一部分是受了与中国经济往来的良好影响。此外,结合中国对非洲直接投资,中国从非洲的进口总额对非洲东道国的实际人均GDP也有积极的影响。然而中国对非洲的出口反而对非洲东道国实际人均GDP增长有着负面因素。最后,我们发现中国对非洲直接投资和中国从东道国的进口同时对东道国当地就业有积极影响的作用。相反,非洲东道国自然资源禀赋对当地就业有阻碍作用,同时中国对非洲的出口对非洲国家就业没有显著的影响。
This thesis empirically examines the linkages between China’s FDI inflows in Africa and China-Africa bilateral trade; as well as the joint impacts of the above factors on economic growth andemployment in Africa. Using datasets from a selection of African countries over1990-2012, weemployed both the static and the dynamic panel techniques in STATA first to evaluate the nexusbetween China’s Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) inflows in Africa and China’s exports andimports trade with Africa. Next, we examined their joint effects as determinants of hostcountries’ GDP growth, real per capita GDP growth as well as on host countries’ employment.To do this, we structured the study around four major axes. First, we engaged in a prior empiricalreview of determinants of China’s FDI inflows in Africa, focussing on the effects of China’sexports to and imports from Africa, turnover of China’s economic cooperation with Africa, theFOCAC platform and host countries’ endowments in natural resources. All those variables showa significantly positive effect on China’s FDI inflows in Africa, except for China’s exports toAfrica. Secondly, we examined the determinants of China’s exports to Africa laying an emphasison China’s FDI inflows, total amount of China’s contracted projects in host countries, totalamount of China’s labour cooperation with host countries, growth of value added in themanufacturing sector in China as well as credit facilities available for private sector in China. Wefound that China’s FDI flows into Africa have a positive effect on China’s exports to Africa,jointly with positive effects from other factors cited above; except for credit facilities to privatesector in China. Moreover, among other control variables, we estimated the roles of China’s FDIinflows in Africa and host countries natural resources endowments as determinants of China’simports from Africa. We found that China’s FDI inflows in Africa and host countries’ naturalresources endowments have been active drivers for China’s imports from Africa. There is strongevidence of complementarities between China’s FDI and trade with Africa, these vertical FDImostly have an upstream resource-seeking or downstream export-servicing orientation. Thirdly,we examined the roles of China’s FDI inflows in Africa, together with China’s exports to Africaand China’s imports from Africa on economic growth in host countries through their jointimpacts on GDP growth and real per capita GDP growth. We found that part of observedincrease in African countries GDP growth since2003is due to China’s occurrence as a player onthe African economic stage. Besides, combined with China’s FDI inflows in Africa, China’simports from Africa have been positively affecting real per capita GDP in Africa, while China’sexports to Africa on the contrary proved to be a negative factor for real per capita GDP growth.Finally, we found strongly positive joint effects of both China’s FDI and China’s imports fromAfrica on employment in host countries. On the contrary, natural resources endowments have ahindering effect on employment in Africa while exports from China have no impact onemployment in Africa.
引文
1UNCTAD defines FDI as an investment involving a long-term relationship and reflecting a lasting interest and control by a firmin an enterprise resident in a foreign country (UNCTAD,2005). FDI normally has three components:(i) equity capital (thepurchase of shares in the foreign enterprise);(ii) reinvested earnings (those earnings not distributed as dividends by foreignaffiliates or remitted to the investor enterprise) and (iii) intra-company loans or debt transactions (borrowing and lending betweenparent and foreign affiliate enterprises)(UNCTAD,2005).International Monetary Fund (International Financial Statistics and Balance of Payments databases) defines Foreign directinvestment as the net inflows of investment to acquire a lasting management interest (10percent or more of voting stock) in anenterprise operating in an economy other than that of the investor. It is the sum of equity capital, reinvestment of earnings, otherlong-term capital, and short-term capital as shown in the balance of payments.
2In this study, the term China refers to the People’s Republic of China (PRC), for data collection and convenience issues. Thus,no consideration is made of Taiwan, Hong Kong and Macau special autonomous regions.
3World Investment Report2013: Global Value Chains: Investment and Trade for Development; primary Source: UNCTAD FDI‐TNC‐GVCInformation System, FDI database (www.unctad.org/fdistatistics).
4China’s Statistical Yearbook2013. National Bureau of Statistics of the Peoples’ Republic of China.(http://www.stats.gov.cn/tjsj/ndsj/2013/indexeh.htm)
5See: People Daily, January15,1983; Or Beijing Review,24January1983:1. The11African countries are Algeria, CongoBrazzaville, Egypt, Gabon, Guinea, Kenya, Morocco, Tanzania, Zaire, Zambia and Zimbabwe. See People Daily, January15,1983;Or Beijing Review,24January1983:1
6Gu, Jing (2009),“China’s Private Enterprises in Africa and the Implications for African Development,” European Journal ofDevelopment Research,21(4), pp.570‐587.
7Will sometimes be referred to in short as COFDI or as China’s OFDI
8Annual data on China's outward Direct Investments to Europe for years2003‐2005and2009present some irregularitiesacross the English and the Chinese versions and different publications of the Statistical Bulletin of China's Outward DirectInvestments and have been slightly adjusted by the author
9annual data on China's outward Direct Investments to Europe for years2003‐2005and2009present some irregularitiesacross the English and the Chinese versions and different publications of the Statistical Bulletin of China's Outward DirectInvestments and have been slightly adjusted by the author
10Lim,D.(1983)“fiscal incentives and direct investment in less developed countries”. Journal of Development Studies19(2):207‐212.
11Brazil, Russia Federation, India and China
12‐Brainard, S. Lael (1997)“An Empirical Assessment of the Proximity‐Concentration Trade‐Off between Multinational Salesand Trade”. The American Economic Review87(4),520–544;‐Helpman, Elhanan, Marc J. Melitz, and Stephen R. Yeaple (2004)“Export versus FDI with Heterogeneous Firms”. AmericanEconomic Review94(1),300–316;‐Horstmann, Ignatius J., and James R. Markusen (1992)“Endogenous Market Structures in International Trade”(natura facitsaltum).’ Journal of International Economics32(1‐2),109–129;‐Markusen, James R., and Anthony Venables (2000)“The Theory of Endowment, Intra‐Industry and Multi‐national Trade”.Journal of International Economics52(2),209–234;‐Ramondo, Natalia, Veronica Rappoport, and Kim J. Ruhl (2013)“The Proximity‐Concentration Tradeoff under Uncertainty”.Unpublished Manuscript
13Sub‐Saharan Africa
14De Mello (1997)
15Calvo, et al (1996)
16Yan, Zhou (May28,2010)."CAD Fund to boost footprint in Africa". China Daily. http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/bizchina/2010‐05/28/content_9903203.htm.
17Barney Jopson, Jamil Anderlini (Nov.9,2009)."China pledges$10billion in low‐cost loans to Africa". The Washington Post.http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp‐dyn/content/article/2009/11/08/AR2009110818002.html.
18The author has been working as an intern in a Chinese state‐owned infrastructure construction company since2009.
19Transparency, accountability, and corruption in the public sector assess the extent to which the executive can be heldaccountable for its use of funds and for the results of its actions by the electorate and by the legislature and judiciary, and theextent to which public employees within the executive are required to account for administrative decisions, use of resources,and results obtained. The three main dimensions assessed here are the accountability of the executive to oversight institutionsand of public employees for their performance, access of civil society to information on public affairs, and state capture bynarrow vested interests. See http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/IQ.CPA.TRAN.XQ/countries?display=default.
20See section2.2.1(b) in chapter2above.
21The lower the risk point total, the higher the risk of corruption, and the higher the risk point total the lower the risk. Seehttp://www.prsgroup.com/ICRG_Methodology.aspx
22The lower the risk point total, the higher the risk of corruption, and the higher the risk point total the lower the risk. Seehttp://www.prsgroup.com/ICRG_Methodology.aspx
23The lower the risk point total, the higher the risk of corruption, and the higher the risk point total the lower the risk. Seehttp://www.prsgroup.com/ICRG_Methodology.aspx
24The lower the risk point total, the higher the risk of corruption, and the higher the risk point total the lower the risk. Seehttp://www.prsgroup.com/ICRG_Methodology.aspx
[1] Ani, I.D.&Jovan evi, R.(2004). Foreign Direct Investment in the Trade Sector in Croatia.Faculty of Economics and Business, Maribor, Review Papers1:2,59-67.
[2] Anyanwu, J. C.(2012). Why Does Foreign Direct Investment Go Where It Goes?: NewEvidence From African Countries. Annals of Economics and Finance13:2,433-470.
[3] Aristotelous, K.&Fountas, S.(1996). An Empirical Analysis of Inward Foreign DirectInvestment Flows in the EU with emphasis on the Market Enlargement Hypothesis. Journalof Common Market Studies,33:4,571-583.
[4] Aroca, P.&Maloney, W. F..(2005). Migration, Trade, and Foreign Direct Investment inMexico. The World Bank Economic Review,19:3,449–472.
[5] Asheghian, P.(2004). Determinants of Economic Growth in the United States: The Role ofForeign Direct Investment. The International Trade Journal,18:1,63-83.
[6] Asiedu, E.(2004). The Determinants of Employment of Affiliates of US MultinationalEnterprises in Africa. Development Policy Review,22:4:371-379.
[7] Asiedu, E.(2006). Foreign Direct Investment in Africa: The Role of Natural Resources,Market Size, Government Policy, Institutions and Political Instability. United NationsUniversity.63-77.
[8] AZAM, M.(2010). Economic Determinants of Foreign Direct Investment in Armenia,Kyrgyz Republic and Turkmenistan: Theory and Evidence. Eurasian Journal of Businessand Economics,3(6),27-40.
[9] Batten, J.A.&Vinh Vo, X.(2009). An analysis of the relationship between foreign directinvestment and economic growth. Applied Economics,41,1621–1641.
[10] Bellak, C., Leibrecht, M.&Damijan, J. P.(2009). Infrastructure Endowment and CorporateIncome Taxes as Determinants of Foreign Direct Investment in Central and EasternEuropean Countries. The World Economy,267-290.
[11] Bénassy-Quéré, A., Coupet, M.&Thierry Mayer.(2007). Institutional Determinants ofForeign Direct Investment. The World Economy,764-782.
[12] Bhavan,T., Xu, C.&Zhong, C.(2011) Determinants and Growth Effect of FDI in SouthAsian Economies: Evidence from a Panel Data Analysis. International Business Research,4:1,43-50.
[13] Brock, G.(2009). Growth and Foreign Direct Investment in American States,1977–2001.Review of Urban and Regional Development Studies,21:2/3,110-123.
[14] Buckley, P. J.&Clegg, Jeremy and Cross, Adam R. and Liu, Xin and Voss, Hinrich andZheng, Ping (2007) The determinants of Chinese outward foreign direct investment. Journalof International Business Studies,38(4). pp.499-518
[15] Busse, M.&Groizard, J. L..(2008). Foreign Direct Investment, Regulations and Growth.The World Economy,…:…,861-886.
[16] CAMPOS, N. F.&KINOSHITA, Y.(2002). Foreign Direct Investment as TechnologyTransferred: Some Panel Evidence From the Transition Economies. The Manchester School,70:3,398-419.
[17] Chaitanya, K., Vadlamannatia, Tamazianb, A.&Iralac, L. R..(2009). Determinants offoreign direct investment and volatility in South East Asian economies. Journal of the AsiaPacific Economy,14:3,246–261.
[18] Chang, Shu-Chen (2006). The dynamic interactions among foreign direct investment,economic growth, exports and unemployment: evidence from Taiwan. Econ Change (2005)38:235-256.
[19] Cheung, Yin-Wong.&Qian, Xingwang.(2009). Empirics of China’s Outward DirectInvestment. Pacific Economic Review,14:3,312–341.
[20] CHOONG, CHEE-KEONG&LAM, S.Y.(2010). The Determinants of Foreign DirectInvestment in Malaysia: A Revisit. Global Economic Review,39:2,175-195.
[21] CHEW GING LEE.(2010). Outward Foreign Direct Investment and Economic Growth:Evidence from Japan. Global Economic Review,39:3,317-326.
[22] Crotti, S., Cavoli, T.&Wilson, J.K.(2010). The impact of trade and investment agreementson australia’s inward fdi flows. Australian Economic Papers,259-275.
[23] Davies, R. B., Ionascu, D.&HelgaKristjánsdóttir.(2008). Estimating the Impact of Time-Invariant Variables on FDI with Fixed Effects. Review of World Economics,144:3,381-407.
[24] De Vita, G.&Kyaw, K.S.(2009). Growth effects of FDI and portfolio investment flows todeveloping countries: a disaggregated analysis by income levels. Applied Economics Letters,16,277–283.
[25] EGGER, P.&PFAFFERMAYR, M.(2004). Distance, Trade And FdI: A Hausman-TaylorSUR Approach, Journal of Applied Econometrics,19,227-246.
[26] Egger, P.&Pfaffermayr, M.(2005). Trade, Multinational Sales, and FDI in a Three-factorModel. Review of International Economics,13:4,659–675.
[27] Elu, J.U.&Price, G. N.(2010). Does China Transfer Productivity Enhancing Technology toSub-Saharan Africa? Evidence from Manufacturing Firms. African Development Review,22:1,587–598.
[28] Fantessi, A. A&Kiprop, S. K.(2012). The impact of Chinese foreign direct investment inAfrica on Sino-Africa bilateral trade” African. Journal of Business Management,6:1,….-….
[29] Federico, S.&Minerva, G.A.(2008). Outward FDI and Local Employment Growth in Italy.Review of World Economics,144:2,295-324.
[30] Ford, T. C., Rork, J.C.&Elmslie, B.T.(2008). Foreign Direct Investment, EconomicGrowth, and the Human Capital Threshold: Evidence from US States. Review ofInternational Economics,16:1,96–113.
[31] Fortanier, F.(2007). Foreign direct investment and host country economic growth: Does theinvestor’s country of origin play a role?. Transnational Corporations,16:2,41-76.
[32] FUNG, K. C., HERRERO, A. G., IIZAKA, H.&SIU, A.(2005). Hard Or Soft?Institutional Reforms and Infrastructure Spending as Determinants of Foreign DirectInvestment in China. The Japanese Economic Review,56:4,408-416.
[33] FU, Xiao-lan.(2007). Trade-cum-FDI, Human Capital Inequality and Regional Disparitiesin China: the Singer Perspective. Econ Change,40,137–155.
[34] FU Xiao-lan.(2008). Foreign Direct Investment, Absorptive Capacity and RegionalInnovation Capabilities: Evidence from China. Oxford Development Studies,36:1,89-110.
[35] Gao, Ting.(2002). The impact of foreign trade and investment reform on industry location:the case of China. The Journal of International Trade&Economic Development,11:4,367–386.
[36] Ghosh, M.&Wang, Wei-min.(2009). Does FDI Accelerate Economic Growth? The OECDExperience Based on Panel Data Estimates for the Period1980-2004. Global EconomyJournal,9:4, Art.1.
[37] Gyimah-Brempong, K.(2002). Corruption, economic growth, and income inequality inAfrica. Economics of Governance,3,183–209.
[38] Hailu, Z.A.(2010). Impact of Foreign Direct Investment on Trade of African Countries.International Journal of Economics and Finance,2:3,122-133.
[39] Hejazi, W.&Safarian A. E.(2001). The Complementarity Between U.S. Foreign DirectInvestment Stock and Trade. Atlantic Economic Journal,29:4,420-437.
[40] Hermes, N.&Lensink, R.(2003). Foreign Direct Investment, Financial Development andEconomic Growth. The Journal of Development Studies,40:1,142-163.
[41] IRAM, S.&NISHAT, V.(2009). Sector Level Analysis of FDI-Growth Nexus: A CaseStudy of Pakistan. The Pakistan Development Review,48:4Part II,875-882.
[42] JANICKI, H.P.&WUNNAVA, P.V.(2004). Determinants of foreign direct investment:empirical evidence from EU accession candidates. Applied Economics,2004,36,505–509.
[43] Jung Soo Seo and Chung-Sok Suh.(2006). An Analysis of Home Country Trade Effects ofOutward Foreign Direct Investment: The Korean Experience with ASEAN,1987–2002.ASEAN Economic Bulletin,23:2,160–70.
[44] Jung Wan Lee, Gulzada S. Baimukhamedova, Akhmetova, S.(2009). The Effects ofForeign Direct Investment on Economic Growth of a Developing Country: FromKazakhstan. Proceedings of the Academy for Economics and Economic Education,12:2,22-27.
[45] Kaplinsky, R.&Morris, M.(2009). Chinese FDI in Sub Saharan Africa: Engaging WithLarge Dragons.To be published in European Journal of Development Research Special Issue,24:1.
[46] KERSAN-KABI, I.&ORLI, E.(2007). Determinants of Fdi Inflows In CEE AndWestern Balkan Countries (Is Accession To The EU Important For Attracting Fdi?).Economic and Business Review,9:4,333–350.
[47] Khawar, M.(2005). Foreign Direct Investment and Economic Growth: A Cross-CountryAnalysis. Global Economy Journal,5:1, Art.8.
[48] Kimino, S., Saal, D.S.&Driffield, N.(2007). Macro Determinants of FDI Inflows to Japan:An Analysis of Source Country Characteristics. The World Economy,446-469.
[49] Kim, W.S., Lyn, E., Zychowicz, E.(2003). Is the Source of FDI Important to EmergingMarket Economies? Evidence from Japanese and U.S. FDI. Multinational Finance Journal,7:3&4,107-130.
[50] KOHPAIBOON, A.(2003). Foreign Trade Regimes and the FDI–Growth Nexus: A CaseStudy of Thailand. The Journal of Development Studies,40:2,55–69.
[51] Kotrajaras, P., Tubtimtong, B.&Wiboonchutikula,P.(2011). Does FDI Enhance EconomicGrowth?. ASEAN Economic Bulletin,28:2,183–202
[52] Leichenko, R.M.&Erickson, R. A.(1997).Foreign Direct Investment and State ExportPerformance.Journal of Regional Science,37:2,307-329.
[53] Leibrecht, M.&Scharler, J.(2009). How important is employment protection legislation forForeign Direct Investment flows in Central and Eastern European countries?. Economics ofTransition Volume17(2)2009,275–295.
[54] LIANG-Yan.(2007). FDI, Competitive Menace, and the Evolution of Labor Practices inChina. The Chinese Economy,40:5,21–51.
[55] LIU, YI&PEARSON, C.(2010). An Empirical Study of the Determinants of ForeignInvestment in China: A Western Australian Perspective. Journal of Asia-Pacific Business,11:99–120.
[56] LUIZ R. DE MELLO, JR and KIICHIRO FUKASAKU.(2000). Trade and Foreign DirectInvestment in Latin America and Southeast Asia: Temporal Causality Analysis. Journal ofInternational Development,12,903-924.
[57] Majeed, M.T.&Ahmad, E.(2009).An analysis of Host Country Characteristics thatDetermine FDI in developing Countries: Recent Penel Data Evidence. The Lahore Journalof Economics,14:2,71-96.
[58] Manh Vu Le&Suruga, T.(2005). Foreign direct investment, public expenditure andeconomic growth: the empirical evidence for the period1970–2001. Applied EconomicsLetters,12,45-49.
[59] Min, B. S.(2003). FDI and Trade Links in The Case Of Malaysia. Journal of the AsiaPacific Economy,8:2,229–250.
[60] NAUDE, W. A.(2004). The Effects Of Policy, Institutions and Geography On EconomicGrowth in Africa: An Econometric Study Based on Cross-Section and Panel Data. Journalof International Development,16,821–849.
[61] Mullen, J. K.&Williams, M.(2005). Foreign Direct Investment and Regional EconomicPerformance. KYKLOS,58:2,265–282.
[62] Naudé, W. A.&Krugell, W. F.(2007). Investigating geography and institutions asdeterminants of foreign direct investment in Africa using panel data. Applied Economics,39,1223–1233.
[63] Ndikumana, L.&Verick, S.(2008). The Linkages Between FDI and Domestic Investment:Unravelling the Developmental Impact of Foreign Investment in Sub-Saharan Africa.Development Policy Review,26:6,713-726.
[64] Obwona, M.B.(2001). Determinants of FDI and their impact on Economic Growth inUganda. Economic Research Centre, African Development Bank,46-81.
[65] Oladipo, O. S.(2010). Foreign Direct Investment (Fdi): Determinants and Growth Effects ina Small Open Economy. The International Journal of Business and Finance Research,4:4,75-88.
[66] Ramasamy, B.&Yeung, M.(2010). The Determinants of Foreign Direct Investment inServices. The World Economy,573-596.
[67] Ranjan, V.&Agrawal, G.(2011). FDI Inflow Determinants in BRIC countries: A PanelData Analysis. International Business Research,4:4,255-263.
[68] Renard, M.F.(2011), China’s Trade and FDI in Africa, Series N°126, African DevelopmentBank, Tunis, Tunisia.
[69] RIZVI, S. Z.A.&NISHAT, M.(2009). The Impact of Foreign Direct Investment onEmployment Opportunities: Panel Data Analysis: Empirical Evidence from Pakistan, Indiaand China. The Pakistan Development Review,48:4Part II,841-851.
[70] Rodr iguez, X. A.&Pallas, J.(2008). Determinants of foreign direct investment in Spain.Applied Economics,40,2443–2450.
[71] Roy, A. G.&Berg, H. F. V.(2006). Foreign Direct Investment and Economic Growth: ATime-Series Approach. Global Economy Journal,6:1, Art.7.
[72] SCHIFF, M.&WANG, Yan-ling.(2006). North-South and South-South Trade-RelatedTechnology Diffusion: How Important Are They in Improving TFP Growth?. Journal ofDevelopment Studies,44:1,49–59.
[73] Sha.q Dhanani&Syed Asif Hasnain.(2002). The Impact of Foreign Direct Investment OnIndonesia’s Manufacturing Sector. Journal of the Asia Pacific Economy7:1,61–94.
[74] SINGH, D. R., MCDAVID, H., BIRCH, A.&WRIGHT, A.(2008). Social and EconomicStudies,57:3&4,79—104.
[75] KUFLIC, L.&BOTRIC V.(2006). Foreign Direct Investment in Southeast EuropeanCountries The Role of the Service Sector. Eastern European Economics,44:5,72–90.
[76] Sun, Haishun.(1999) Impact of FDI on the Foreign Trade of China. Journal of the AsiaPacific Economy,4:2,317-339.
[77] Sun, Hai-shun.(2001). Foreign Direct Investment and Regional Export Performance inChina. Journal of Regional Science,41:2,317-336.
[78] Sukar, A., Ahmed, S.&Hassan, S. The Effects of Foreign Direct Investment on EconomicGrowth: The Case of Subsahara Africa. Southwestern Economic Review,…:…61-74.
[79] Tadesse, B.&Ryan, M.(2004). Host market characteristics, FDI, and the FDI–traderelationship. Journal of International Trade&Economic Development,13:2199–229.
[80] Takechi, K.(2010). What is Driving the Manufacturing FDI Wave in Asia?. Review ofDevelopment Economics,15:1,33–47.
[81] Tang, S., Selvanathan, E. A.&Selvanathan, S.(2008). Foreign Direct Investment,Domestic Investment and Economic Growth in China: A Time Series Analysis. The WorldEconomy,…:…,1292-1309.
[82] Todo, Y.(2011). Quantitative Evaluation of the Determinants of Export and FDI: Firm-levelEvidence from Japan. The World Economy,355-381.
[83] Vadlamannati, K. C.&Tamazian, A.(2009). Growth effects of FDI in80developingeconomies: the role of policy reforms and institutional constraints. Journal of EconomicPolicy Reform,12:4,299–322.
[84] Vogiatzoglou, K.(2007). Vertical Specialization and New Determinants of FDI: Evidencefrom South and East Asia. Global Economic Review,36:3,245-266.
[85] Vogiatzoglou,K.(2008). The Triad in Southeast Asia What Determines U.S., EU andJapanese FDI within AFTA?. ASEAN Economic Bulletin,2:2,40-60
[86] WALDKIRCH, A., NUNNENKAMP, P.&BREMONT, J.E.A.(2009). EmploymentEffects of FDI in Mexico’s Non-Maquiladora Manufacturing. Journal of DevelopmentStudies,45:7,1165–1183.
[87] Wang, Cheng-gang., Wei, Y.Q.&Liu, X.M.(2010) Determinants of Bilateral Trade Flowsin OECD Countries: Evidence from Gravity Panel Data Models. The World Economy,894-915.
[88] Wang, Miao.(2009). Manufacturing FDI and economic growth: evidence from Asianeconomies. Applied Economics,41,991–1002.
[89] Wang, Miao&Wong, M. C. S.(2011). FDI, Education, and Economic Growth: QualityMatters. Atlantic Economic Journal,39,103–115.
[90] WERESA, M.(2001). The Impact of Foreign Direct Investment on Poland’s Trade with theEuropean Union. Post-Communist Economies,13:1,71-83.
[91] Wijeweera,A.,Villano,R., Dollery, B.(…). Journal of Developing Areas,…:…,143-158.
[92] Yen Li Chee.(2010). The Impact of FDI and Financial Sector Development on EconomicGrowth: Empirical Evidence from Asia and Oceania. International Journal of Economicsand Finance,2:2,107-119.
[93] Zhao, Zhongxiu&Zhang, K. H.(2010). FDI and Industrial Productivity in China: Evidencefrom Panel Data in2001–06. Review of Development Economics,14:3,656–665.
[1] CHEN, En.&WANG, Fang-fang.(2011). China's Outward Foreign Direct Investment: AnEmpirical Test Based on International Panel-Data (2007-2009). Journal Of BusinessEconomics,8:238,43-50/陈恩、王方方.(2011).中国对外直接投资影响因素的实证分析—基于2007-2009年国际面板数据的考察.商业经济与管理,第8期总第238期,第43-50页
[2] CUI Jia-yu/崔家玉.(2010).中国对外直接投资的动因.大连海事大学学报(社会科学版).第9卷第3期.第12-14页.
[3] KAN, Da-xue&LUO, Liang-wen.(2010). An Empirical Study on the Influence of ForeignTrade and FDI on Human Capital Efficiency in China Based on Provincial Panel Data.International Economics and trade research,26:6,61-65./阚大学、罗良文.对外贸易及FDI对我国人力资本效率的影响—基于省级面板数据.国际经贸探索,第26卷第6期,第61-65页.
[4] LIU, Hong.&WANG, Duan-yong.(2010). China's Outward FDI of2008~2009: The StatusQuo and Characteristics. International Economics and trade research,26:12,63-68./刘宏、汪段泳.(2010).中国对外直接投资现状与特点研究:2008~2009.国际经贸探索,第26卷第12期,第63-68页.
[5] LI-Xuan.(2011). Effect of China-ASEAN Free Trade Area on China’s FDI.…,…:…,41-47./李轩.中国-东盟自由贸易区建设对中国FDI的影响效应.《国际贸易问题》第4期,第41-47页.
[6] MA, Ling-yuan.(2008). The Effects of FDI on International Trade: the Evidence from China.Journal of Zhongnan University of Economics and Law,170:5,37-42./马凌远.FDI对国际贸易的影响:来自中国的证据.中南财经政法大学学报,2008年第5期双月刊总第170期,第37-42页.
[7] MO-Sha,LIU Fang.(2008). Study of the relationship between Chinese Direct Investmentand Trade to Africa Based on Panel Data Model. International Economics and traderesearch,8:24,46-50./莫莎、刘芳.中国对非洲直接投资与贸易的关系研究—基于面板数据的实证分析.国际经贸探索,第24卷第8期,第46-50页.
[8] WEI, Jun-liang.&CHEN, Ligao./韦军亮、陈漓高(2009)政治风险对中国对外直接投资的影响—基于动态面板模型的实证研究.经济评论,第4期第106-113页.
[9] WEN Huai-de&TAN Jing-rong.(2010). Impact of Trade, FDI on Employment in China:Based on Panel Data of Eastern, Middle, and Western Districts after or before Access toWTO.…,…:…,102-109./温怀德、谭晶荣.中国对外贸易、FDI对就业影响的实证研究.—基于加入世贸组织前后东、中、西部数据的比较.《国际贸易问题》2010年第8期,第102-109页.
[10] WU, Yaqing./虞亚庆.(2010).中国对外直接投资行为影响因素的实证分析.国际贸易与国际投资,…:…,第11-15页.
[11] XU, Xiao-long/□文、许小龙.(2008).中国对外直接投资影响因素实证研究.《合作经济与科技》总第359期,第76-77页.
[12] Yao, Gui-mei.(2009). A General Assessment on China’s Direct Investment in Africa. WestAsia And Africa,7,48-54./姚桂梅.中国在非洲直接投资的总体评估.西亚非洲,第7期,第48-54页.
[13] Zhang, H., Yuan, J., Kong, Y.(2010). A Study on the Linkage between China’s ODA andFDI to Africa. World Economy Study,201:11,69-74/张汉林、袁佳、孔洋.中国对非洲ODA与FDI关联度研究.区域与国别经济.《世界经济研究》:第11期,第69-74页.
[14] Zhang, Han-lin,Yua-Jia&Kong-Yan (2010). A Study on the Linkage between China’sODA and FDI to Africa. World Economy Study,201:11,69-74/张汉林、袁佳、孔洋.中国对非洲ODA与FDI关联度研究.区域与国别经济.《世界经济研究》:第11期,第69-74页.
[15] ZHANG, Xiaofen.(2010). Analysis of the Motives of China’s Outward FDI Flow intoAfrica: A Case Study of North African Countries. Journal of Shanghai Normal University(Philosophy&Social Sciences Edition),39:5,97-103/张小峰(2010).中国对北非国家投资现状、动因及策略选择.上海师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版).第39卷第5期,第97-103页
[16] ZHAO, Beiwen.(2009). FDI’s Macroeconomic Effect in Transitional Countries: AComparison among Russia, Eight Eastern&Central European Countries and China. WorldEconomy Study,186:8,50-88./赵蓓文.(2009).转型国家外国直接投资的宏观经济效应─关于俄罗斯、中东欧八国和中国的比较.《世界经济研究》2009年第8期.第50-88页.