家庭视角的流动人口城市定居意愿及其影响机制——基于中国8个城市的实证分析
详细信息    查看全文 | 推荐本文 |
  • 英文篇名:Urban Settlement Intention and Its Influencing Mechanism of Floating Population with Low Education Levels from Household Perspective:A Case Study of Eight Cities in China
  • 作者:陈宏胜 ; 王兴 ; 刘晔 ; 李志刚
  • 英文作者:Chen Hongsheng;Wang Xingping;Liu Ye;Li Zhigang;School of Architecture,Southeast University;School of Geography and Planning,Sun Yat-sen University;School of Urban Design,Wuhan University;
  • 关键词:家庭 ; 定居意愿 ; 流动人口 ; 城市化
  • 英文关键词:household;;settlement intention;;floating population;;urbanization
  • 中文刊名:RDDD
  • 英文刊名:Tropical Geography
  • 机构:东南大学建筑学院;中山大学地理科学与规划学院;武汉大学城市设计学院;
  • 出版日期:2018-12-18 17:08
  • 出版单位:热带地理
  • 年:2019
  • 期:v.39
  • 基金:国家自然科学基金(41422103、41771167);; 高密度人居环境生态与节能教育部重点实验室(同济大学)开放课题资助
  • 语种:中文;
  • 页:RDDD201901007
  • 页数:11
  • CN:01
  • ISSN:44-1209/N
  • 分类号:60-70
摘要
采用了8个具有代表性城市的抽样调查数据,基于家庭视角对流动人口家庭城市定居意愿及其影响因素进行研究。通过从长期居住打算、社会保障、社会认同、家庭迁移、户口迁移等方面构建家庭城市定居意愿指数(FSI),研究发现:武汉、无锡、苏州、西安的流动人口家庭城市定居意愿较高,上海处于中间水平,而泉州、长沙和咸阳的流动人口的家庭城市定居意愿较低。采用回归分析发现:不同城市流动人口定居意愿的影响因素存在一定差异,但家庭因素的影响具有一致性,呈现所在城市越有利于对其家庭成员的照顾和发展,流动人口家庭城市定居意愿则越强烈的特征。最后,提出创建"家庭友好型"的城乡发展新秩序,实现流动人口家庭城市定居和发展,提升人口城市化质量。
        In the 40 years since the reform and opening up, the urbanization rate of China's population has increased substantially, and the pattern of population mobility has also changed from individual mobility to family migration. However, most of the existing studies are based on individual dimensions to analyze the settlement willingness of China's floating population, and less from the family dimension. In the context of the pursuit of highly educated and highly skilled personnel in China's big cities, the family development of low-education migrants is easily overlooked. This paper uses sample survey data of eight representative cities to study the willingness of migrant families and their influencing factors based on family perspective. By constructing the Family Settlement Index(FSI) from long-term residential plan, social security, social identification, family migration, and household registration(hukou), this study found that migrant families in Wuhan, Wuxi, Suzhou, and Xi'an have higher willingness to settle in cities. Shanghai is at an intermediate level, while the floating population of Quanzhou, Changsha and Xianyang has a lower willingness to settle. Using regression analysis, it is found that the households' willingness to settle in the third-tier cities is significantly lower than that of the first-tier cities; the higher the per capita GDP and the proportion of tertiary industry in GDP, the higher the willingness of migrant families to settle. Among the urban social factors, if the city is convenient for migrants to take care of family members and children to obtain better education, the higher the willingness of migrant families to settle in cities. Consistent with existing research, the longer the residence time and the shorter the flow distance, the higher the willingness of the floating population to settle in the city. Among the rural factors, the amount of money returned to the hometown and the household expenses of the home have a negative effect on the willingness of the floating population to settle in the city. In short, there are some differences in the factors affecting the settlement willingness of migrants in different cities, but the influence of family factors is consistent, showing that the city is more conducive to the care and development of its family members, and the stronger the willingness of migrant families to settle in the city. Compared with the existing research that measures the willingness to settle by a single variable, this study comprehensively constructs the family settlement index of the floating population from the family perspective, and more accurately assesses the willingness of the floating population to settle in the city. In terms of analytical methods, this study used a multilevel regression analysis method to analyze the correlation between "city-family settlement" and explore the inter-city differences in the impact mechanism of floating population family settlement willingness. This study empirically explains the impact of China's urbanization process on the urbanization of vulnerable migrant families, and is of great significance for understanding the social effects of China's urbanization process. Finally, at the policy level, this paper proposes to create a "family-friendly" new urban-rural development order to achieve the settlement and development of migrant families, which is an important part of improving the quality of population urbanization.
引文
BIAN Y.2002.Chinese social stratification and social mobility.Annual Review of Sociology,28(1):91-116.
    陈浩,张京祥,陈宏胜.2015.新型城镇化视角下中国“土地红利”开发模式转型.经济地理,35(4):1-8.[Chen Hao,Zhang Jingxiang and Chen Hongsheng.2015.The Transformation of Land Dividend Under the Perspective of New Urbanization.Economic Geography,35(4):1-8.]
    陈宏胜,刘振东,李志刚.2015.中国大城市新移民社会融合研究.现代城市研究,(6):112-119.[Chen Hongsheng,Liu Zhendong and Li Zhigang.2015.Social Integration of Neo-Immigrants in Urban China:A case study of six large cities.Modern Urban Research,(6):112-119.]
    Chen H,Wang X,Chen G and Li zhigang.2018.Upward social mobility in China:Do cities and neighbourhoods matter?.Habitat International,82:94-103.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.habitatint.2018.10.003.
    陈宏胜,王兴平,贺志华.2015.城镇化的家庭转向:个体城镇化向家庭城镇化转变的实证研究.规划师,31(10):82-88.[Chen Hongsheng,Wang Xingping and He Zhihua.2015.From individual to familial urbanization:A positive study.Planners,31(10):82-88.]
    陈宏胜,王兴平,刘晔,李志刚.2017.“理性”与“感性”之间:上海流动人口迁居意愿研究.现代城市研究,(7):100-106.[Chen Hongsheng,Wang Xingping,Liu Ye and Li Zhigang.2017.Between Sensibility and Rationality:Study on Shanghai Migrants'Residential Mobility Intention.Modern Urban Research,(7):100-106.]
    陈宏胜,王兴平.2016.促进农村家庭城镇化的城乡规划转型探讨.现代城市研究,31(4):16-21.[Chen Hongsheng and Wang Xingpin.2016.Discussion on the urban-rural planning transformation in the background of promoting urbanization of rural households.Modern Urban Research,31(4):16-21.]
    陈宏胜,王兴平.2015.面向农民工家庭的城镇公共服务体系优化:农民工市民化的关键.规划师,31(3):11-16.[Chen Hongsheng and Wang Xingping.2015.Improving public service for rural migrant workers.Planners,31(3):11-16.]
    Cheng T and Selden M.1994.The origins and social consequences of China's hukou system.The China Quarterly,139:644-668.
    Ellis F.1998.Household strategies and rural livelihood diversification.Journal of Development Studies,35(1):1-38.
    范芝芬.2013.流动中国:迁移、国家和家庭.北京:社会科学文献出版社.[Fan Zhifen.2013.China on the move:Migration,the state,and the household.Beijing:Social Sciences Academic Press.]
    Fan C C,Sun M and Zheng S.2011.Migration and split households:a comparison of sole,couple,and family migrants in Beijing,China.Environment&Planning A,43(9):2164-2185.
    Fan C C and Wang W W.2008.The household as security:Strategies of rural-urban migrants in China.In:Nielsen,R.Smyth.Migration and social protection in China.New Jersey.NY:World Scientific,205-243.
    Fan C C.2003.Rural-urban migration and gender division of labor in transitional China.International Journal of Urban and Regional Research,27(1):24-47.
    冯长春,李天娇,曹广忠,沈昊婧.2017.家庭式迁移的流动人口住房状况.地理研究,36(4):633-646.[Feng Changchun,LI Tianjiao,Cao Guangzhong and Shen Haojing.2017.Housing outcomes of family migrants at the place of destination.Geographical Research,36(4):633-646.]
    符平,唐有财,江立华.2012.农民工的职业分割与向上流动.中国人口科学,(6):75-82.[Fu Ping,Tang Youcai and Jiang Lihua.2012.The Occupational Segregation and Upward Mobility of Migrant Workers.Chinese Journal of Population Science,(6):75-82.]
    Huang Y and Yi C.2015.Invisible migrant enclaves in Chinese cities:Underground living in Beijing,China.Urban Studies,52(15):2948-2973.
    侯慧丽.2016.城市公共服务的供给差异及其对人口流动的影响.中国人口科学,(1):118-125.[Hou Huili.2016.The Difference of Urban Public Service Supply and Its Influence on Population Movement.Chinese Journal of Population Science,(1):118-125.]
    Keung Wong D F,Li C Y and Song H X.2007.Rural migrant workers in urban China:living a marginalised life.International Journal of Social Welfare,16(1):32-40.
    李郇,殷江滨.2012.劳动力回流:小城镇发展的新动力.城市规划学刊,(2):47-53.[Li Xun and Yin Jiangbin.2012.Returning migrants:Anew impetus for small town development.Urban Planning Forum,(2):47-53.]
    李志刚.2012.中国大都市新移民的住房模式与影响机制.地理学报,67(2):189-200.[Li Zhigang.2012.Housing Conditions,Patterns and Mechanisms of Second Generation Migrants in Urban China:A Case Study of Six Large Cities.Acta Geographica Sinica,67(2):189-200.]
    梁土坤.2016.流动人口定居意愿影响因素分析.人口与社会,32(2):63-74.[Liang Tukun.2016.An analysis of influencing factors of settling willingness of floating population.Population and Society,32(2):63-74.]
    林李月,朱宇,许丽芳.2016.流动人口对流入地的环境感知及其对定居意愿的影响--基于福州市的调查.人文地理,(1):65-72.[Lin Liyue,Zhu Yu and Xu Lifang.2016.The environmental perceptionand its effect on settlement intention of the floating population:A case study of fuzhou city.Human Geography,(1):65-72.]
    刘成斌.2013.农民工流动方式与子女社会分化--对中国人口流动制度设计的反思.中国人口科学,(4):108-116.[Liu Chengbin.2013.The social mobility of China peasant-workers’children:Social differentiation patterns between the floating-along and the left-behind.Social Sciences in China,(4):108-116.]
    Liu Y and Shen J.2014.Jobs or Amenities?Location Choices of Interprovincial Skilled Migrants in China,2000-2005.Population,Space&Place,20(7):592-605.
    Liu Y and Shen J.2017.Modelling Skilled and Less-Skilled Interregional Migrations in China,2000-2005.Population,Space&Place,23(4):1-17.
    刘于琪,刘晔,李志刚.2014.中国城市新移民的定居意愿及其影响机制.地理科学,34(7):780-787.[Liu Yuqi,Liu Ye and LI Zhigang.2014.Settlement Intention of New Migrants in China’s Large Cities:Patterns and Determinants.Scientia Geographica Sinica,34(7):780-787.]
    罗震东,夏璐,耿磊.2016.家庭视角乡村人口城镇化迁居决策特征与机制--基于武汉的调研.城市规划,40(7):38-47.[Luo Zhendong,Xia Lu and Geng Lei.2016.Study on the characteristics and micromechanisms of rural residents’migration decision from the perspective of family:Based on the field survey in Wuhan.City Planning Review,40(7):38-47.]
    任远,乔楠.2010.城市流动人口社会融合的过程,测量及影响因素.人口研究,34(2):11-20.[Ren Yuan and Qiao Nan.2010.Social Integration for Migrants:Process,Measurement and Determinants.Population Research,34(2):11-20.]
    盛亦男.2014.中国的家庭化迁居模式.人口研究,38(3):41-54.[Sheng Yinan.2014.Family Migration Pattern in China.Population Research,38(3):41-54.]
    王桂新,胡健.2016.城市农民工社会保障与市民化意愿.社会科学文摘,37(1):45-55.[Wang Guixin and Hu Jian.Social Security and Urbanization Willingness of Urban Migrant Workers.Social Science Digest,37(1):45-55.]
    王瑞民,陶然.2016.“城市户口”还是土地保障:流动人口户籍改革意愿研究.人口与发展,22(4):19-28.[Wang Ruimin and Tao Ran.2016.Urban Hukou or Land Security:A Research on the Migrants’Intention of Hukou System Reform.Population and Development,22(4):19-28.]
    Wallace C.2002.Household Strategies:Their Conceptual Relevance and Analytical Scope in Social Research.Sociology,36(2):275-292.
    王兴平,谢亚,陈宏胜,夏菁.2018.新时期中国开发区流动人口集聚与再流动研究.城市规划学刊,(2):29-36.[Wang Xingping,Xie Ya,Chen Hongsheng and Xia Jing.2018.The Mobility of Floating Population in the Chinese Development Zones under the Background of the Transition of Economy.Urban Planning Forum,(2):29-36.]
    王兴平.2014.以家庭为基本单元的耦合式城镇化新型城镇化研究的新视角.现代城市研究,(12):88-94.[Wang Xingping.2014.Family based coupled urbanization:A new perspective of new urbanization research.Modern Urban Research,(12):88-94.]
    王兴平.2015.面向社会发展的城乡规划:规划转型的方向.城市规划,39(1):16-29.[Wang Xingping.2015.Social development-oriented urban and rural planning:The trend of planning transformation.City Planning Review,39(1):16-29.]
    王兴平.2016.城镇化进程中家庭离散化及其应对策略初探.城市规划,40(12):42-48.[Wang Xingping.2016.Study on the phenomenon of family abruption in chinese urbanization process and the coping method.City Planning Review,40(12):42-48.]
    夏璐.2015.分工与优先次序--家庭视角下的乡村人口城镇化微观解释.城市规划,39(10):66-74.[Xia Lu.2015.Labor division and expense priority:microcosmic explanation of rural population urbanization from the perspective of family.City Planning Review,39(10):66-74.]
    杨菊华,陈传波.2013.流动人口家庭化的现状与特点:流动过程特征分析.人口与发展,19(3):2-13.[Yang Juhua and Chen Chuanbo.2013.The process of familization of migration in CHina.Population and Development,19(3):2-13.]
    杨菊华.2015.人口流动与居住分离:经济理性抑或制度制约?.人口学刊,37(1):26-40.[Yang Juhua.2015.Migration and Living Apart in China:Economic Rationality Vs.Institutional Barriers?.Population Journal,37(1):26-40.]
    杨云彦,褚清华.2013.外出务工人员的职业流动、能力形成和社会融合.中国人口·资源与环境,23(1):75-80.[Yang Yunyan and Chu Qinghua.2013.Career Mobility,Ability Formation and Social Integration for Migrant Workers China.Population,Resources and Environment,23(1):75-80.]
    湛东升,张文忠,党云晓,戚伟,刘倩倩.2017.中国流动人口的城市宜居性感知及其对定居意愿的影响.地理科学进展,36(10):1250-1259.[Zhan Dongsheng,Zhang Wenzhong,Dang Yunxiao,Qi Wei,Liu Qianqian,Qi Wei and Liu Qianqian.2017.Urban Livability Perception of Migrants in China and Its Effects on Settlement Intention.Progress in Geography,36(10):1250-1259.]
    张文宏,雷开春.2008.城市新移民社会融合的结构、现状与影响因素分析.社会学研究,8(5):117-141,244-245.[Zhang Wenhong and Lei Kaichun.2008.Analysis on the Structure,Status Quoand Influencing Factors of Urban New Immigrants’Social Integration.Sociological Studies,8(5):117-141,244-245.]
    张一凡,王兴平,周军.2014.由“离散”向“耦合”的农村家庭城镇化路径探讨--基于如东县西部城镇的案例研究.现代城市研究,(12):101-109.[Zhang Yifan,Wang Xingping and Zhou Jun.2014.ADiscussion on an Urbanization Path from Aggregation to Dissociation of Rural Families:A Case Study of the Western Towns in Rudong.Modern Urban Research,(12):101-109.]
    张勇,冯健.2016.理性、流动与家庭--村民日常生活语境下的乡村性转型.人文地理,(6):49-57.[Zhang Yong,Feng Jian.2016.Rationality,mobilityand family:Transformation of rurality in villagers’daily lives.Human Geography,(6):49-57.]
    赵方,袁超文.2017.中国城市化发展--基于空间均衡模型的研究.经济学:季刊,16(4):1643-1668.[Zhao Fang and Yuan Chaowen.2017.The Development of Urbanization in China:A Study Based on Spatial Equilibrium Model.China Economic Quarterly,16(4):1643-1668.]
    赵延东,王奋宇.2002.城乡流动人口的经济地位获得及决定因素.中国人口科学,(4):8-15.[Zhao Yandong and Wang Fenyu.2002.Economic status and determinants of urban and rural migrants.Population Science of China,(4):8-15.]
    周兴,王芳.2014.城乡居民家庭代际收入流动的比较研究.人口学刊,36(2):64-73.[Zhou Xing and Wang Fang.2014.A comparative study of the intergenerational income mobility between the urban and rural China.Population Journal,36(2):64-73.]
    朱宇.2004.户籍制度改革与流动人口在流入地的居留意愿及其制约机制.南方人口,19(3):21-28.[Zhu Yu.2004.Households Registration System Reform and the Dwelling Willing of Floating Population in the Areas They Are Dwelling and Its Restrictive Mechanism.South China Population,19(3):21-28.]
    (1)流动人口动态监测调查介绍http://www.chinaldrk.org.cn/wjw/#/home。
    (2)笔者注:学界围绕农村土地制度改革而衍生的人口城市化政策有许多争论(陈浩等,2015)。