企业综合经营绩效体系的框架研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
绩效管理将是中国企业培育世界级竞争力最为重要的管理制度体系,建立、实施并不断完善企业的绩效管理体系成为摆在每一位CEO案头最紧迫的任务之一。
    本文研究的企业综合经营绩效管理体系是一种长期的、可持续发展的评价制度,有助于衡量、培植和提升企业的核心能力;它是一个具有创新能力和自我革新能力的战略管理与规划的平台。本文以规范研究、定性研究为主,以实证研究、定量研究为辅。首先对国内外绩效管理的现状及绩效管理的一般框架模型进行深入研究,引入平衡计分卡理论中四个维度的原理,结合绩效管理工作实践中产生的主要问题,通过对分属于不同维度理论业绩指标的建立、改进和拓展,构建了企业综合经营绩效的体系框架。
    通过对两种理论的深入研究发现:从横向看,将绩效管理的一般框架模型贯穿于平衡计分卡的一个维度,可以较好地完成对这一方面的业绩管理,而且使大量的短期内日常经营管理工作受控于企业长期的战略规划和战略管理;与此同时,从纵向看,将平衡计分卡的四个维度应用于绩效管理的某一阶段,可以使某一经营决策(或活动)均受控于四个不同且符合战略规划和战略管理的维度。
    首先通过对平衡计分卡四个维度的业绩动因、因果关系的研究,建立起企业综合经营绩效体系的实施框架模型;其次将管理会计中成本习性的理论引入后,改进了杜邦财务评价系统,同时将经资本资产定价理论修正后经济附加值模型作为财务维度的业绩指标,更为有效地优化了财务业绩指标;第三对内部经营过程维度三个方面价值链的分析,将戴明循环原理应用于目标成本法及作业成本法,并将绩效管理的一般原理——关键因素、业绩指标与方法、单个业绩目标及工作策略贯穿于目标成本法与作业成本法的始终,完善了内部经营过程维度的业绩管理;第四引入顾客价值、顾客资产的概念,分析并归纳客户维度的核心结果业绩指标,包括非财务指标时间、质量等;第五通过运用员工资产、共同心理契约的两种原理,建立以员工满意度、员工保持率及员工生产率为主的学习与成长维度的核心员工指标组体系;最后,结合行为科学的理论,对企业综合经营绩效框架体系的激励与补偿系统进行了规范性设计,完成了企业绩效管理的PDCA的闭循环。
    这样,企业的绩效管理就构造成为战略性的综合绩效管理的体系。它可以使
    
    企业信息负担降到最少,为企业战略管理提供强有力的支持,同时注重团队合作 ,防止企业管理机能失调,提高企业激励作用 ,扩大员工的参与意识,有效地提高了企业整体的管理效率。
Performance management will be the most important system by which Chinese enterprises cultivate the first-rate competition abilities all over the world. To establish, carry out and better the system of performance management has become the imperative task before each CEO in China.
    The comprehensive performance management in firms that hereby studied by the article is a long-term, sustainable evaluating system. It can be conducive to measure, cultivate and improve the core abilities in firms, and it is also a platform for strategy management and planning of the abilities of renovation and self-revolution.
    The article's research methods focus mainly on standardizing research and qualitative research with the help of quantitative research. Firstly, it has made a further research on the status quo and the general frameworks of the domestic and the overseas performance management; then introduced the four-dimension principles in the Balanced Scorecard theory and according to the main problems in the performance management practices, set up the framework of comprehensive operating performance system in firms by establishing, bettering and developing the performance indices belonged to different dimension theories respectively.
    Such findings are reached according to the further research on the two theories as follows: the common framework running through one dimension of the Balanced Scorecard will complete the performance management in some aspect more perfectly and make the number of routine operating management in short term be in the control of the enterprise long-term strategy management and planning, and at the same time, applying the four dimension of the Balanced Scorecard to some stage of the common performance management will also make a operating decision be in the control of all the four different dimensions which are suitable for the long-term strategy management and planning.
    Firstly, with the research on the cause-and-effect of the four dimensions of the Balanced Scorecard has the model of implementing the comprehensive operating framework been set up; secondly, the financial performance indices have been optimized after introducing the theories of cost characters in Management Accounting as well as the Du Pont financially evaluating system was improved and at the same time, the model of Economic Value Added was amended by the Capital Asset Pricing
    
    theory to be the indices of the financial dimension; thirdly, analyzed the value chain on the three aspects on the process of inside operation, and applied the Deming's Theory to the Target Costing & Activity-Based Costing theories, and made the general principles of performance management i.e. key factors, performance indices and methods, single performance target and working strategy running through the all course of target cost's theories, improved the performance management of the inside operating dimension; fourthly, introducing the concept of value and assets of consumers, and analyzing and generalizing the indices of core outcome performance of the dimension of consumers including the time and quality of non-financial indices etc.; fifthly, set up the core employees' indices system of the studying and growing dimension of the satisfaction and preserve and productivity by utilizing the two principles of employees' assets and common psy-treaty, and finally in accordance with the behaviour science, made a standard design on the system of comprehensive operating performance framework and the compensation system.
    Then the performance management hereto has become the strategy comprehensive performance management system. It can reduce the burden of information to the lest, and provide the firms' strategy management with a forceful support, and stress on team-work spirit, and prevent the discordance of the management system. It also can improve the stimulating system and enlarge the employees' participating ideas and improve the overall management effectiveness to a large extant.
引文
[1] 余景选,陈宝忠,上海财经大学会计学院,《企业业绩衡量中平衡计分卡应用初探》,上海,上海会计,2001年第10期,pp.51;
    [2] 林文雄,吴安妮:《中国管理会计实务调查报告》,《会计研究》,1998年,第8期;
    [3] 杜拉克,吴军译,《有效的管理者》,求实出版社,1985年版;
    [4] 杜拉克,《科学管理法的时代意义》,收入《迈向经济的新纪元》,台湾志文出版社,1986年;
    [5] Robert S. Kaplan & David P. Norton, The Advanced Management Accounting,The third edition, Cambridge: Harvard Business School Press, 1996;
    [6] 余绪缨,胡玉明,《管理会计学》,北京,中国人民大学出版社,1998年8月;
    [7] Mamagement Accounting Practice, vol. 3, of IMA/AAA Management Accounting Symposium series. Raprined with permission
    [8] 参见《ISO9000--质量标准体系(GB)》,2000版;2000年
    [9] http://www.amteam.org ,"AMT-企业资源管理研究中心网站",2002年;
    [10] 周惠中,《微观经济学》,上海,上海人民出版社,1997年,pp.196;
    [11] 罗伯特·S 卡普兰,安东尼·A 阿特金森著 吕长江译 高级管理会计 [M]大连:东北财经大学出版社,1999年;
    [12] 粟松,陈敏,《企业战略评估的新体系》,东北大学学报,2002年第2期,pp.66;
    [13] 颜志刚,《EVA综合计分卡》,经济师,2002年第5期,pp.255;
    [14] 曹文辉,《浅析平衡计分卡》,财会月刊,2001年第4期,pp.17;
    [15] R. D. Buzzell, The PIMS Principles: Linking Strategy to Performance, New York: Free Press, 1987, pp.6;
    [16] The Rise and Fall of Management Accounting , Boston: Harvard Business School Press, 1987, chap.2;
    [17] 高阳宗:杜邦财务系统的改进--兼论管理会计在我国企业中的运用,河北经贸大学学报,1999年4月,第2期;
    [18] A.D. Chandler Jr., "The Competitive Performance of U.S. Industrial Enterprises Since the Second World War," pp.16-18;
    [19] Solomons, Divisional Performance, chap.5.;
    [20] 周长青:论文《EVA业绩评价系统评述》,厦门大学,2002年;
    
    
    [21] 颜哲等:《经济管理基础》,经济与管理出版社,重庆,2002年;
    [22] 胡奕明,《ABC、ABM在我国企业的自发形成与发展》,上海财经大学会计学院,2002年;
    [23] C.Hart, The Power of Unconditional Service Guarantees, Harvard Business Review, July-
    August,1998, pp.54-62;
    [24] 史刁民,《完善公司治理与管理创新》,会计研究,2000年第4期,pp.10;
    [25] J.Heskett, E.Sasser, and C.Hart, Service Breakthoughs: Changing the Rules of the the Game, New York: free Press,1990;
    [26] 方慧,熊秩伟,江西财经大学,《试论现代管理会计观念的更新》,《会计之友》,1999年第5期;
    [27] 冯巧根,论文,"21世纪管理会计展望",2001年;
    [28] 顾迎新,《定量化目标管理》,经营与管理,2000年第10期;
    [29] F.F. Reichheld, The Loyalty Effect ,Boston: Harvard Business School Press, 1996; F.F. Reichheld, Learning from Customer Defections, Harvard Business Review ,March - April 1996, pp.89-91;
    [30] T.O. Jones and W.E. Sasser, "Why Satisfied Customers Defect," Harvard Business Review , November - December, 1995, pp.88-99.;
    [31] 石人瑾等,《管理会计》,上海三联书店出版社,1994年6月;
    [32] R.S. Kaplan, "In Defense of Activity - Based Cost Management," Management Accounting (November 1992), pp.62-63;
    [33] 胡玉明,暨南大学管理学院会计系,《21世纪管理会计主题的转变》,外国经济与管理,广州,2001年第1期, pp1-2;
    [34] 施恩,《职业的有效管理》,北京,三联书店,1992年6月版,pp.162-166;
    [35] D. McGregor, The Human Side of Enterprise, Mc Graw-Hill Book Co., 1960, pp.168-169;
    [36] F. Heraber, B. Mausner, and B. Snyderman: The Motivation to Work, John Wiley & Son, Inc., 1959
    [37] 余绪缨,《管理会计》,沈阳,辽宁人民出版社,1996年1月;
    [38] 财政部,2001年注册会计师全国统一考试指定辅导教材,《财务成本管理》,经济科学出版社,2001年3月,pp.589;
    [39] 胡君辰,郑绍濂,《人力资源开发与管理》,复旦大学出版社,1999年1月,pp26-27;
    [40] M. Ezzamel: Advanced Management Accounting: An Organizational Emphasis,pp5-6,Cassell Educational Limited,1987.
    [41] G..Siegel and H.ramanaukas-Marconi: Bahavioral accounting, pp128-131, South-Western Publishing Co. ,1989.
    
    
    [42] 弗舒斯特,《A战略:人与效益的关系》,上海科学技术出版社, 1989年1月, pp.56-58;
    [43] Alfelard, My Years with General Motors, New York, Doubleday, 1964, Chap.22;
    [44] 刘韬,论文《业绩工资能否提升业绩》,2002年7月;
    [45] 谢晓非,衣琳琳,论文《薪酬发放的激励效应--公开还是秘密》,2002年。