摘要
20世纪90年代后,生态旅游在世界范围内得到了迅速的发展,有关生态旅游的研究也成为热点。但目前很多有关生态旅游的理论研究尚未成熟,理论与实际联系较弱,所以有必要加强对生态旅游规划设计、管理、评价等方面的研究,以探讨实现生态旅游可持续发展的科学依据。
本文选择浙江省临安市作为研究对象,采用GIS技术手段和APPA(Appreciative Participatory Planning and Action)与PRA(Participatory Rural Appraise)相结合的手段进行数据的采集和资料的收集,并进行了游客调查、专家咨询调查,并对几家旅行社负责人、生态旅游开发商、导游及农户代表进行半结构式访谈和小组访谈。
针对临安市生态旅游的发展特点主要就以下四个内容进行研究:1)临安市生态旅游发展现状以及发展潜力分析;2)利用GIS技术对临安市的生态旅游资源进行规划,确定临安市的潜在的一、二级生态旅游区;3)以太湖源镇的白沙村和大峡谷镇的上坪村为例,研究当地生态旅游发展中居民参与问题;4)以上坪村为例,进行社区生态旅游CBET(Community-based Eco-tourism)发展的规划设计。主要研究结论如下:
1)临安市生态旅游的成功发展得益于临安市良好的生态环境、非木质林产品以及相关生态产业的综合发展和临安市强有力的政策支持。
2)限制临安市生态旅游健康发展的因子中最突出的是缺乏长远、整体的发展战略规划和社区居民参与不足问题。同时还存在景区雷同且开发速度过快、不良竞争、土地利用冲突、缺乏生态旅游市场的监控体系、森林补偿金不足、景区服务项目雷同、环境保护教育力度弱、利益冲突以及导游业务水平限制等问题,并就以上问题提出了6方面的发展对策。
3)通过对临安市土地利用的景观格局分析认为临安市具备发展生态旅游的基本条件。确定了临安市旅游资源的基本特征为自然性,提出了适合于当地的生态旅游定义及其6个属性和6个用于确定临安市潜在生态旅游单元的指标。通过旅游影响力的缓冲区分析和叠加分析,最终确定临安市2个级别的潜在生态旅游区。
4)目前临安市生态旅游发展中主要存在以白沙村与上坪村为代表的两种发展模式,跨越式和渐进式。两个村的发展模式存在的共同问题是“社区参与问题”。主要表现在居民的参与规模、参与项目类型、当地社区参与管理的水平、居民参与决策的意识和程度、相关受益方的关系、信息共享与培训机会以及参与方式与参与水平等7个方面。
5)改变临安市目前居民的参与方式和提高居民的参与水平势在必行,也是解决社区参与的关键。居民应该通过发展合理的参与规模、改善目前的参与形式,并加强培训以提高自身的能力、水平、参与意识以及在生态旅游活动中的专业技能,在主观上积极创造参与条件。参与的外部条件的创造则需要当地的旅游管理部门和旅游开发商建立旅游论坛,为社区参与提供机会。
6)发展CBET可以提高当地社区在旅游活动中的参与水平。与临安市上坪村具有相似条件的社区均可以考虑发展CBET。但是要发展CBET并确保其成功,除了APPA的运用外,当地政府或者NGO在社区开展CBET初期应该提供一定帮助,以帮助社区旅游组织逐步实现自立。
Eco-tourism developed rapidly since 1990s that resulted in the special focus on eco-tourism research. Certain theories have been identified from many researches, but programming and management of the eco-tourism still needed to be emphasized so as to fulfill the object of sustainable development.
Therefore, this research focuses on 4 aspects as follows: 1) Analyzing current status and potential prospects of eco-tourism development of Lin'an 2) GIS application in identifying the potential Eco-tourism units for Lin'an; 3) A case study on local communities involvement in eco-tourism development in Baisha and Shangping villages; 4) Design for CBET development in Shangping village. Data were collected and proceeded by conducting the methods of PRA, APPA(Appreciative Participatory Planning and Action) and GIS technique. Questionnaire, semi-structure interview and group meeting were adopted to collect information from tourists, tour operators, tour guides, villages and expert.
It's revealed that
(1) The major success factors of eco-tourism development in Lin'an are well-protected natural environment, integrated development of Non-timber Forest Products and other ecological industries as well as powerful local political support.
(2) Lack of a long-term and integrated development strategy and insufficient involvement of local communities are two major containing elements of Lin'an eco-tourism development. It causes extremely-rapid exploitation of scenery spots, homogenous eco-tourism sites and service items, harmful competition, land-used conflicts, short of eco-tourism market monitoring system, insufficient compensation for forest resources, deficiency of environmental education to public, interest conflict between stakeholders and so on.
(3) It's proved to be a successful decision to develop eco-tourism in Lin'an after analyzing the spatial pattern of landscape. Then, naturalness was determined as the character of ecotourism attraction in Lin'an. An definition of ecotourism that meet Lin'an and its 6 attributes and criteria were determined respectively. At the
end, with the overlay of the 6 attributes of coverage, 2 types of potential eco-tourism unit coverage were identified.
(4) At present, gradually-advance and span-progress are 2 major eco-tourism development models in Lin'an. These two development models have the common issue on insufficient community involvement that as follows: participation scale; Program involved; Management ability; Awareness and degree of participation; Relation between stakeholders; Information sharing & training opportunities; Participatory type.
(5) It's urgent to change the participatory form and improve the involved level of the local communities in eco-tourism development in Lin'an. The local communities member should create a circumstance to get more involvement by extending involve scale, improving the involve patter, enhancing the personal ability and participatory consciousness. At the same time, local tourism authorities and tour operators should establish forum to let local communities involve.
(6) It's recommend to develop CBET for those communities that own resources as similar as Shangping village's by considering the function of CBET on increasing the participatory level. In order to ensure the success of CBET, at the begging phase, the local government and NGO should give some support to speed the community to self-sufficient. APPA application is another important factor.
引文
1. 爱德华·英斯基普. 1997旅游业的发展与规划. 全国旅游规划培训班领导讲话及讲授提纲, 国家旅游局计统司
2. 陈才. 2000 生态美与生态旅游. 生态经济, No.2
3. 陈鑫峰. 2000 京西山区森林景观评价和风景游憩林营建研究--兼论太行山区的森林游憩业建设. 北京: 北京林业大学博士学位论文
4. 陈忠晓, 彭建. 2001 生态旅游的内涵辨析. 桂林旅游高等专科学校学报, Vol. 12, No. 1
5. 陈忠晓, 王仰麟. 1999 生态旅游刍议. 地理学与国土研究, Vol. 15, No. 4
6. 程伟民, 谢炳庚, 李晓青, 杨友孝. 1994 海南省旅游读评价及其开发研究. 自然资源学报, Vol. 9, No. 2
7. 程渭山. 2002 浙江森林旅游. 北京: 中国林业出版社
8. 程占红, 张金屯. 2000 天龙山旅游开发对植被的影响. 地理科学, Vol. 20, No. 2
9. 程占红, 张金屯. 2001 生态旅游的兴起和研究进展. 经济地理, Vol. 21, No. 1
10. 崔凤军. 1998旅游环境研究的几个前沿问题. 旅游学刊, No. 5
11. 崔国发, 李俊清, 蒋兆刚, 王冬青等. 2000 北京喇叭沟门自然保护区生态旅游开发问题探讨. 北京林业大学学报, Vol.22, No.4
12. 崔书红, 王捷. 1999 生态旅游的概念及其在我国的实践 环境保护. No. 9
13. 但新球, 周光辉, 蔡时钧. 1996 森林游憩对环境与景观生态系统的影响. 中南林业调查规划, Vol. 15, No. 1
14. 邓金阳, 陈德东, 李世东. 1996 森林生态旅游的生态影响――兼论建立定位站的必要性. 农村生态环境, Vol. 12, No. 1
15. 邓金阳, 吴云华, 金龙. 2000 张家界国家森林公园游憩冲击的调查评估. 中南林学院学报, Vol. 20, No. 1
16. 董良飞, 张志杰, 杨楚屏. 2000 浅谈我国旅游环境的开发与可持续发展. 环境与开发, Vol. 15, No. 3
17. 多伦多旅游办事处编译. 2002年世界生态旅游峰会魁北克声明. 旅游调研, No. 8
18. 樊红. 1999 ARC/INFO应用与开发技术 武汉测绘科技大学出版社
19. 樊文华, 李海金, 池宝亮, 马步洲. 1999 五台山生态旅游资源特点及开发利用. 生态经济. 生态经济, No.4
20. 高红波. 2002 饮用水源头岂容污染——里畈水库一个月内清除垃圾7吨. 临安: 临安日报, 第七版, 本地要闻版, 5月22日
21. 龚雪辉. 1998 生态旅游岂能破坏生态. 光明日报, 5月23日
22. 管东生, 林卫强, 陈玉娟. 1999 旅游干扰对白云山土壤和植被的影响. 环境科学, Vol. 20, No. 6
23. 管东生, 钟晓燕, 郑淑颖. 2001 广州地区森林景观多样性分析. 生态学杂志, Vol. 20, No. 4
24. 郭来喜, 吴必虎, 刘峰, 范业正. 2000 中国旅游资源分类系统与类型评价. 地理学报, Vol. 55, No.3
25. 郭来喜. 1997 中国生态旅游-可持续旅游的基石. 地理科学进展, Vol. 16, No. 4
26. 郭舒. 2002 生态旅游概念泛化思考. 旅游学刊, Vol. 17, No 1
27. 何艺玲. 2002a如何发展社区生态旅游?——泰国Huay Hee (HH)村社区生态旅游CBET (Community-based Eco-tourism)的经验. 旅游学刊, Vol. 17, No 6
28. 何艺玲. 2002b 发展社区生态旅游,促进资源保护与经济发展. 国际示范林建设国际研讨会会议论文. 浙江临安
29. 胡延杰. 2001山区林业可持续发展社区机制的研究——湖北鹤峰社区林业项目案例研究. 北京: 北京林业大学博士学位论文
30. 黄芳. 2002 传统居民旅游开发中居民参与问题思考. 旅游学刊, Vol. 17, No 4
31. 江海波. 2001 AHP法在梅州旅游资源定量评价中的运用. 地理学与国土研究, Vol. 17, No. 2
32. 蒋明康, 吴小敏. 2000 自然保护区生态旅游开发与管理对策研究. 农村生态环境, Vol. 16, No. 3
33. 蒋文举, 朱联锡, 李静. 1996 旅游对峨眉山生态环境的影响及保护对策. 环境科学, Vol. 17, No. 3
34. 康云海, 宁萍. 1997论发展生态旅游的理论基础. 生态经济, No. 6,
35. 孔红梅, 齐东, 卢琦. 1995生态旅游规划. 世界林业研究, Vol.8, No.2
36. 《拉英汉中国植物名录》编委会编. 2001拉英汉中国植物名录. 中国林业出版社
37. 李春茂, 明庆忠, 胡笃冰. 2000 生态旅游环境容量的确定与量测. 林业建设, No.5
38. 李东和, 张结魁. 1999论生态旅游的兴起及其概念实质. 地理学与国土研究, Vol,15, No.2
39. 李敏. 2002 自然保护区生态旅游景观规划研究 --以目平湖湿地自然保护区为例. 旅游学刊, Vol.17, No. 5
40. 李明阳. 1999 浙江临安森林景观格局变化的研究. 南京林业大学学报, Vol.23, No. 3
41. 李芮. 2002别把不文明丢在国外--泰国旅游区张贴出用汉语写的警示布告. 北京:北京青年报, 第1版:要闻. 1月15日
42. 李维长. 2000 兴生态旅游 促社区发展, 北京:中国环境科学出版社
43. 李玉珍. 1998 浙江省临安市临目乡可持续发展研究. 北京: 中国林业科学研究院 硕士学位论文
44. 李云梅. 2000景观多样性与景区旅游价值—浙江仙居风景名胜区景观格局分析. 生态经济, No.10
45. 李贞, 保继刚,覃朝峰. 1996 旅游开发对丹霞山植被的影响研究. 旅游开发研究-原理-方法-实践, 保继刚等著. 北京: 科学出版社, 151-158
46. 林媚珍. 1999 广州流溪河国家森林公园生态旅游初探. 生态科学, Vol.18, No.3
47. 林卫强, 管东生. 2000 生态旅游和旅游环境影响评价. 重庆环境科学, Vol. 22, No. 1
48. 临安日报社. 2002 浮玉文丛: 临安名胜散文文选
49. 临安市地方志编纂委员会. 1999, 2000, 2001, 2002临安年鉴
50. 临安市统计局编. 1999 临安五十年-建国以来临安经济和社会发展辉煌业绩
51. 临安市统计局编. 1999, 2000, 2001, 2002 临安统计年鉴
52. 临安示范林秘书处. 2002 生态旅游可持续发展指南. 临安示范林系列丛书
53. 刘爱民, 刘代泉. 2000旅游资源开发与规划. 北京: 旅游教育出版社
54. 刘鸿雁. 1994旅游生态学-生态学应用的一个新领域. 生态学杂志, Vol. 13, No. 5,
55. 刘家明, 杨新军. 1999 生态旅游地可持续旅游发展规划初探. 自然资源学报, Vol. 14, No. 1
56. 刘家明. 1998 生态旅游及其规划的研究进展. 应用生态学报, Vol.9, No.3
57. 刘纬华. 2000 关于社区参与旅游发展的若干理论思考. 旅游学刊, Vol.15, No.1
58. 刘晓冰, 保继刚. 1996 旅游开发的环境影响研究进展. 地理研究, Vol.15, No. 4
59. 刘玉清 2000 生态美的特征和价值. 生态经济 No.10
60. 刘忠伟, 王仰麟, 陈忠晓. 2001 景观生态学与生态旅游规划管理. 地理研究, Vol.20 No. 2
61. 楼涛. 2001 从小山村走向大世界——临目乡白沙村社会经济调查报告. "论农民增加收入的成功之道"学术研讨会暨中国农业经济学会2001年会交流材料
62. 吕永龙. 1998 生态旅游的发展与规划. 自然资源学报, Vol.13, No.1
63. 罗明义. 2002 生态旅游可持续发展—亚太地区部长会议评述. 旅游学刊, Vol.17, No.3
64. 马乃喜. 1997 自然保护区开展旅游应该注意哪些问题—答读者问. 中国生物圈保护区, No.1
65. 明庆忠. 2001 试论生态旅游环境问题的类型及其产生原因. 云南师范大学学报, Vol.21, No.2
66. 倪强. 1999 近年来国内关于生态旅游研究综述. 旅游学刊, Vol.14, No.3
67. 聂献忠, 张捷, 吕菽菲, 汤家法. 1998 九寨沟国内旅游者行为特征初步研究及其意义. 自然资源学报, Vol.13, No.3
68. 牛亚菲. 1999可持续生态旅游及实施方案. 地理研究, Vol.18, No.2
69. 秦杰, 邹声文. 2003 中国林业信息网. 3月14日 林业新闻, 源自北京:新华网. 2月18日. http//:www.lknet.forewtry.ac.cn
70. 沈月琴, 姜春前, 吴伟光, 刘微, 夏玉云. 2002参与性方法在示范林项目中运用的案例研究. 社会林业, No. 4
71. 石强. 2000 旅游开发利用对张家界国家森林公园自然生态环境的影响及对策研究. 北京: 北京林业大学博士学位论文
72. 世界旅游组织. 1997 旅游规划的理论规范 旅游规划工资纲要. 北京: 旅游教育出版社, 559-564
73. 舒伯阳, 张立明. 2001 生态旅游区的景观生态化设计, 湖南大学学报(自然科学版), Vol.23, No.1
74. 苏文才, 孙文昌. 1997 旅游资源学, 北京: 高等教育出版社
75. 孙玉军, 王如松. 2000 生态旅游景区环境容量研究. 应用生态学报, Vol. 11, No. 4
76. 唐顺铁. 1998旅游目的地的社区化及社区旅游研究. 地理研究,Vol.17, No.2
77. 铁铮. 2003 我国国家级自然保护区达到197个. 北京: 北京晚报 第10版 北京新闻/科教 5月22日
78. 万绪才, 朱应皋, 丁敏. 2002 国外生态旅游研究进展. 旅游学刊, Vol. 17,No.2
79. 王献溥. 1995 关于生态旅游与保护区的发展. 中国生物圈保护, No.2
80. 王祖良, 丁丽霞, 傅起升. 2002 天目山自然保护区的景观分析. 四川林勘设计, No.3
81. 韦新良, 桂祖云, 方躬勇, 方健. 2000 灵峰山风景资源的生态特性与生态旅游发展. 浙江林学院学报, Vol.17, No.2
82. 韦新良. 2002 生态旅游效益及其环境影响计量评价研究报告. Progress report of RMFP in China, GCP/RAS/177/JAP Volum Ⅱ. Compiled by He Yiling & Liu Dedi., China Model Forest Network Secretariat
83. 温远光, 蒋海平. 1996 论森林环境建设与生态旅游业的持续发展. 生态经济, No. 6,
84. 文彤. 2002 家庭旅馆业的发展--以桂林龙脊梯田风景区为例. 旅游学刊, Vol.17, No. 1
85. 邬建国. 2000景观生态学—格局、过程、尺度与等级. 北京: 高等教育出版社
86. 吴必虎. 1999 地方旅游开发与管理. 北京: 科学出版社
87. 吴兆录, 闫海忠. 1998 乡村生态旅游,自然保护区土地利用模式的走向. 中国生物圈保护区, No. 2,
88. 徐期勇, 艾南山, 李立华. 2000 生态学原理在生态旅游中的应用研究. 环境保护, No. 3
89. 许璨. 1999 社区林业. 北京: 中国林业出版社
90. 杨桂华, 钟林生, 明庆忠. 2000生态旅游, 北京: 高等教育出版社与施普格林出版社
91. 杨桂华. 1999 论生态旅游资源. 思想战线(云南大学人文社会科学学报), Vol.25, No.6
92. 叶敬忠, 刘金龙, 林志斌. 2001 参与. 组织. 发展-参与式林业的理论、研究与实践. 北京:中国林业出版社
93. 曾宗永. 2000 生态旅游的非持续性. 生态与自然保护, No.6
94. 张广瑞. 1999 生态旅游的理论与实践. 旅游学刊, Vol.14, No. 1,
95. 张建萍. 2001 生态旅游理论与实践. 北京: 中国旅游出版社
96. 张金泉. 1999 广东省森林生态旅游与可持续发展. 生态科学, Vol.18, No.3
97. 张延毅, 董观志. 1997 生态旅游及其可持续发展对策. 经济地理, Vol.17, No.2
98. 张瑛. 2000 略论生态旅游与环境保护. 云南环境科学, Vol.19, No.4
99. 赵新明. 2002 生态旅游的基础性研究. 旅游学刊, Vol.17, No.3
100. 浙江大学旅游研究所, 临安市风景旅游局. 2001 临安市旅游产业“十五”总体规划(2001-2015)
101. 中共杭州市委宣传部, 杭州旅游西进领导小组办公室编. 2001 游在杭州 旅游西进-新闻采访报道
102. 中国科学院植物研究所编. 1996 新编拉英汉植物名称. 航空工业出版社
103. 中国绿色时报. 2002 我国国家森林公园新增59处. 2002-12-25
104. 钟林生, 肖笃宁, 赵士洞. 2002 乌苏里江国家森林公园生态旅游适宜度评价. 自然资源学报, Vol.17, No.1
105. 钟林生, 肖笃宁. 2000 生态旅游及其规划与管理研究综述. 生态学报, Vol.20, No.5
106. Allwn, J. S., Lu, K. S & Potts, T. D. 1999 A GIS-based analysisi and prediction of parcel land-use change in a costal tourism destination area. presented at the 1999 world congress on coastal and marine tourism Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada
107. Amanda, S. 2000 "Because It Is Ours": Community-based Ecotourism in the Peruvian Amazon.
108. Beyond the Green Horizon, Tourism Concern and WWF UK, Surrey.
109. Boo, E. 1990 Ecotourism: The Potentials and pitfalls, Vols. 1 and 2. Washiingtin, D. C.: World Wildlife Fund
110. Boyd, S. W., Butler, R. W. & Haider, W. et. 1994 Identifying areas for ecoturism in northern Ontario: application if a geographical information system methodology. Journal of applied recreation research Vol, 19
111. Boyd, S. W., Butler, R. W. 1996 Seeing the forest from the trees: Using geographical information systems to identify potential ecotourism sites in northern Ontario, Canada. In:; Harrison, L., C. and Husbands, W., eds Practicing responsible development, New York: John Wiley: pp.380-403
112. Buckley, R. 1994 A framework for ecotourism. Annuals of tourism research, Vol.21, No.3
113. Campbell, L. M. 1999 Ecourism in Rural developing Communities. Annals of Tourism Research, 3: 534-553
114. Cater, E. 1992 Profits from Paradise. (Ecotourism). Geographical Magazine, Vol 64, p16. G1.G343
115. Cater, E. 1994 Introduction. In Cater, E., Lowman, G.(Eds.).Ecotourism: A sustainable Option?, Wiley, Washington, DC,pp:75-85
116. Ceballos-Lascurain, H. 1987 The Future of Ecotourism. Mexico Journal (January):13-14
117. Cochrane, J. 1998 "CBMT: Community Participation." Contribution to Community- Based Mountain Tourism Electronic Conference, Mountain Forum.
118. De, kadt. 1990 Making the Alternative Sustainable: Lessons from Development for Tourism. IDS Discussion Paper 272, Institute of Development Studies, Brighton, January
119. Drake, S. P. 1991 Local participation in ecotourism projects. In Whelan, T. (el) Nature Tourism: Managing for the environment. Island press, 132-163
120. Durst, P. B and C. D, Lngram.1988 Nature-oriented tourism promotion by developing countries. Tourism Management, Vol.9, No. 1
Edwards, S. N., McLaughlin, W. J. & Ham, S. H. 1999 Volume I Executive summary
121. The definitions-based ecotourism model ecotourism policy comparison Comparative study of ecotourism policy in the Zmerica-1998 inter-sectoral unit for tourism organization of American states
122. Fennell, D. A. 1999 Ecotourism: An Introduction. New York: USA
123. Forster, R. R. 1973 Planning for man and nature in national park. Morges, Switzerland: International Union of Conservation of Nature and Natural Resources
124. Gayman. 1999 H Five Parameters of ecotourism, The ecotourism equation: measuring the impacts. Yale F&Es bulletin
125. Gunn, C. A. 1994 Tourism planning: Basics, concepts, cases (3rd ed.). Washington, D.C.: Taylor & Francis.
126. Hubert, G., et al. 2001 Landscape as framework for Integrating Local Subsistance and Ecotourism: A Case Study Zimbabwe. Landscape and Urban Planning 53: 173-182
127. Jim, C. Y. 2000 Environmental changes associated with mass urban tourism and nature tourism development in Hongkong. The environmentlist, Vol.20: 223-247
128. Joppe, M. 1996 Sustainable Community Tourism Development Revisited. Tourism Management, 17
129. Lash, Gail. 1997 "What is Community-Based Ecotourism." In Jeffrey Bornemeier, Michael Victor and Patrick Durst (eds.) Ecotourism for Forest Conservation and Community Development: Proceedings of an International Seminar, held in Chiang Mai, Thailand, 28-31 January, 1997. FAO/RAP Publication: 1997/26; RECOFTC report No. 15. Bangkok, Thailand.
130. Lead Associate. Cohort Ⅱ 1999 Ecotourism in China - A case from Jiuzhaigou, Sichuan Province of China http://www.lead.org.cn/Data/Case/en/jiuzhg.html
131. Lesslie, R. G., and S. C. Taylor. 1985 The wilderness continuum concept and its implications for Australian wilderness preservation policy. Biological Conservation, Vol.32: 309-333
132. Lesslie, R. G., B. G. Mackey, and K. M. Preece. 1988 A computer-based method of eilderness evaluation. Environmental Conservation, Vol.15, No. 3
133. Lesslie, R. G., S. C. Taylor, and M. Maslen. 1993 National wilderness inventory: Handbook of principles, Procedures and usage. University of Adelaide, Department of Geography
134. Leuing, Y-F. 2001 The role of recreation ecology in sustainable tourism and ecotourism. In McCool, S. F. and Modisey, N. eds. Tourism, recreation and sustainability, liking culture and the environment. CABI publishing, Oxon, Englang, pp.21-39
135. Lindber K., Hawkins D. 1993 Ecourism: A Guide for Planners and Manager. North Bennington: The Ecotourism Society
136. Martha, H. 1999 Ecotourism and sustainable development. Who Owns Paradise? Washington D C: Island Press
Mcadam, D. 1999 The value and scope of Geographical information systems in tourism
137. management. Journal of sustainable tourism. Vol. 7 No.1
138. Morales, N. and Masberg, B. A., 1999 A case analysis of strategies in ecotourism development, Aquatic ecosystem health and management, No. 2: 289-300
139. Morales, T. 1998 "CBMT: A Case of Community-Based Tourism in Oaxaca." Contribution to Community-Based Mountain Tourism Electronic Conference, Mountain Forum.
140. Nieuwkamp, L. B. W, 1996 Zone Modeling in Ecotourism. Proceeding of International Seminar on Ecotourism Programming and Development
141. Pitamber, S. 1998 "CBMT: Community in Community-Based Tourism." Contribution to Community-Based Mountain Tourism Electronic Conference, Mountain Forum.
142. Pretty, J., Gujit, I., Scoones, I., Thompson, J. 1995 A trainer's guide for participatory learning and action. Sustainable agriculture progromme, international institute for environment and development, 3 endsleigh Street, London WCIH ODD, UK
143. Regina, S. 1999 Ecotourism and the Empowerment of Local Communities. Tourism Management. Vol.20: 245-249
144. Ross, S. and Wall, G. 1999 Ecotourism: Towards Congruence between Theory and Practice Tourism Management, Vol. 20: 123-132
145. Sapna, M., Laxmi, R. 2000 The impacts of tourism on the environment of Mussoorie, Garhwal Himlaya, India The environmentalist 20
146. Scheyens, R. 1999 Case study: ecotourism and the empowerment of local communities. Tourism Management, Vol.20(2)
147. Shackley, M. 1996 Visitor management into the 21st Century. Tourism Management, Vol. 17, No.5
148. Srefan, G. 1999 Ecotourism: A Means to safeguard biodiversity and ecosystem function?. Ecological economics, Vol.29: 303-320
149. Sudhiani, P. 2000 Understanding Local Community Participation in Ecotourism Development: A critical Analysis of Selected Published Literature.
150. Sven, W. 2000 Ecotourism and Economic Incentive-an Empirical Approach. Ecological Economics. Vol.32: 465-479
151. Taylor, G. 1995 The Community approach: Does it really work?. Tourism Management, Vol. 16, No.7
152. The Eco-tourism Society. 1993 Eco-tourism: A guide for planners and managers. N Bennington, USA
153. TMI. 2000 Community Based tourism for conservation and development. A resource Kit, The Mountain Institute with Assistance from the Regional Community Forestry Training Center
Van der Knaap, W. G. M. 1999 Research report: GIS-oriented analysis of tourist time-space patterns to support sustainable tourism development. Tourism Geographies,
154. Vol. 1, No.1
155. Vaske, J. J, Donnelly, M. P., Whittaker Doug Tourism, national parks and impact management in Butler, R. W. & Boyd, S. W. 2000 Touriam and National parks: Issues and implications. Chichester, UK: John Wiley & Sons, pp. 203-222
156. Wall, G and Ross, S., 1999 Ecoturism: towards congruence between theory and practice, Tourism management, Vol. 20: 123-132
157. Wang Anguo. 2002 The development of Lin'an ecotourism. Training materials of training workshop on the best practice and Model Forest development of Lin'an
158. Wight, P., 1994 Environmentally responsible marketing of tourism. In: Cater, E., Lowman, G, G. (Gds.). Ecoturism : A sustainable option? Wiley, New York, pp. 39-56
159. WWF international. 2001 Guideline for community-based ecotourism development