摘要
傍河水源地是我国北方地区重要的供水水源,其氨氮污染问题因人类活动及地表水污染影响而日益凸显。作为一种有效的地下水污染修复技术,渗透反应格栅(Permeable Reactive Barrier, PRB)以其无动力运行、环境影响小和维护成本低的特点得到越来越广泛的关注。然而,傍河区含水层高渗透性、氧化还原条件复杂的特点使得PRB的应用受到限制。本文针对傍河区地下水氨氮污染问题,研发了复合介质渗透反应格栅修复技术,实现对傍河区地下水氨氮污染的有效去除,并进行了示范工程应用。论文取得以下研究成果:
(1)针对傍河水源区含水层渗透性大的特点,本文开发了以吸附性高、颗粒粒径大、渗透性强的沸石作为PRB的反应介质,解决了傍河水源区PRB截获地下水流宽度小、反应滞留时间短的问题。研究区受污染含水层渗透系数K=60-80m/d,本文筛选的沸石粒径3-5mm,渗透系数K=700-800m/d,且对氨氮具有“快速吸附,缓慢平衡”特征,对氨氮最大饱和吸附量可达9.30mg/g。
(2)针对研究区地下水中不利于氨氮硝化反应的还原性环境问题,本文开发了以释氧材料和沸石为主的复合介质渗透反应格栅技术,通过改变地下水氧化还原环境,有效促进了氨氮的硝化反应。实验表明,以释氧材料和沸石作为PRB复合反应介质能够有效去除地下水中的氨氮;在氨氮浓度为10mg/L条件下,出水浓度小于0.5mg/L,去除率能够达到90%以上。相对于单纯以河砂或沸石为介质的PRB,释氧材料释放氧气促进微生物对氨氮的转化,实现了沸石再生,避免了氨氮解吸导致的二次污染。
(3)针对沈阳李官堡傍河水源区氨氮污染问题,本研究构建了地下水氨氮污染复合介质渗透反应格栅修复示范工程。监测数据表明PRB示范工程运行良好,地下水中氨氮浓度从2-10mg/L降至0.5mg/L以下,达到了氨氮的生活饮用水卫生标准。
本文开发的PRB,具有受含水层渗透性及氧化还原环境限制小的特点,能有效去除了傍河区地下水的氨氮污染,并成功地进行了技术示范,极大地拓展了PRB的适用范围,对于我国地下水污染修复技术的研究与应用具有重要推动作用。
Riverside source fields are important for water supply in northern China, wherethe ammonia pollution problems caused by human activity and surface waterpollution have become increasingly serious. As an effective groundwater pollutionremediation technology, Permeable Reactive Barrier (PRB) is getting more and moreattention for its non-power operation, less environmental impact and low maintenancefeatures. However, it is difficult for the PRB's application in riverside areacharacterized by high permeability, complex redox conditions. For the riversidegroundwater contanminated by ammonia, we have developed a composite mediumPermeable Reactive Barrier remediation techniques, to achieve effective removal ofammonia nitrogen in groundwater near the river. The technology has been appliedsuccessfully in a demonstration project. Main research results of this paper aredescribed in detail as following:
(1) For the high permeability characteristics of unconfined aquifer of riversidewater source area, we have developed a zeolite with high adsorption capacity, largeparticle size, high permeability as the reaction medium of the PRB, to solve theproblem of less intercept width of groundwater flow and shorter residence time ofcontaminant in the riverside PRB. The permeability coefficient (K) of contaminatedaquifer in the study area is60-80m/d. The zeolite particles screened in the study are3-5mm diameter, and with permeability of700-800m/d, which adsorb ammonia withthe "rapid adsorption, slow equilibrium" characteristic. The maximum amount ofsaturated ammonia adsorption is up to9.30mg/g.
(2) For reduction environmental of groundwater in the study area is notconducive to ammonia nitrification, we have has developed a Permeable ReactiveBarrier technology with release oxygen compound and zeolite as its compositemedium, which can effectively promote the nitrification of ammonia by changing thegroundwater redox environment. Experiments showed that the PRB with the oxygenrelease compound and zeolite materials as reaction medium can effectively removeammonia, with a decrease from10mg/L for influent concentrations to less than0.5 mg/L for effluent concentrations of. The removal efficency can reach90%. Relative tothe only river sand or zeolite as the medium, oxygen release compound can promotethe microbial reaction of ammonia by releasing oxygen, realize the regeneration ofzeolite, and avoid the secondary pollution caused by the desorption of ammonia.
(3) The study constructed a Permeable Reactive Barrier remediationdemonstration project with composite medium to resolve the problem of groundwatercontaminated by ammonia in Liguanpu water source in Shenyang. Monitoring datashow that PRB demonstration project along River worked well. The ammoniaconcentration in groundwater can be decreased from2-10mg/L to0.5mg/L or less,meeting the "Sanitary standard for drinking water".
The PRB developed in this paper, less affected by permeability of aquifer andredox environmental of groundwater, can effectively removes ammoniacontamination of groundwater near the river. The successful demonstration projectexpands the range of application of PRB technology, which will greatly promote theresearch and application of groundwater remediation technologies in China.
引文
Adzomani, A., J. Dong and Y. Jin (2003)."Laboratory Research into Permeable ReactiveBarriers for Groundwater Remediation." Journal of Geoscientific Research in NortheastAsia(01):93-98.
Arai, Y. and C. C. Fuller (2012)."Effects of sulfate ligand on uranyl carbonato surface specieson ferrihydrite surfaces." Journal of Colloid and Interface Science365(1):268-274.
Bortone, I., A. Di Nardo, M. Di Natale, A. Erto, D. Musmarra and G. Santonastaso (2013)."Remediation of an aquifer polluted with dissolved tetrachloroethylene by an array ofwells filled with activated carbon." Journal of Hazardous Materials.
Buss, S., A. Herbert, P. Morgan, S. Thornton and J. Smith (2004)."A review of ammoniumattenuation in soil and groundwater." Quarterly Journal of Engineering Geology andHydrogeology37(4):347-359.
Careghini, A., S. Saponaro and E. Sezenna (2013)."Biobarriers for groundwater treatment: areview." Water Science and Technology67(3):453-468.
Carpenter, S. R., N. F. Caraco, D. L. Correll, R. W. Howarth, A. N. Sharpley and V. H. Smith(1998)."NONPOINT POLLUTION OF SURFACE WATERS WITH PHOSPHORUSAND NITROGEN." Ecological Applications8(3):559-568.
Chen, L., F. Liu, Y. Liu, H. Dong and P. J. S. Colberg (2011)."Benzene and toluenebiodegradation down gradient of a zero-valent iron permeable reactive barrier." Journalof Hazardous Materials188(1–3):110-115.
Christensen, T. H., P. L. Bjerg, S. A. Banwart, R. Jakobsen, G. Heron and H.-J. Albrechtsen(2000)."Characterization of redox conditions in groundwater contaminant plumes."Journal of Contaminant Hydrology45(3-4):165-241.
Chung, Y. W., J. Kim and S.-H. Kong (2011). Three-Dimensional Groundwater FlowSimulation for the Design of Permeable Reactive Barriers, Singapore.
Cui, H. W., J. C. Sun, Y. X. Zhang, J. C. Wang, Y. Zhang, G. X. Huang, J. T. Liu, X. Chen, Y.J. Zhang, X. P. Xiang and J. H. Jing (2010). PRB Technology in Situ Remediation ofGroundwater Polluted by LandfillLeachate. Irvin, Sci Res Publ, Inc-Srp.
Demir, A., A. Gunay and E. Debik (2002)."Ammonium removal from aqueous solution byion-exchange using packed bed natural zeolite." Water SA28(3):329-335.
Eljamal, O., K. Sasaki and T. Hirajima (2011)."Numerical simulation for reactive solutetransport of arsenic in permeable reactive barrier column including zero-valent iron."Applied Mathematical Modelling35(10):5198-5207.
EPA, U. S.(2002)." Field Applications of In Situ Remediation Technologies: PermeableReactive Barriers." Office of Solid Waste and Emergency Response, TechnologyInnovation Office, Washington, DC,.
Erto, A., A. Lancia, I. Bortone, A. Di Nardo, M. Di Natale and D. Musmarra (2011)."Aprocedure to design a Permeable Adsorptive Barrier (PAB) for contaminatedgroundwater remediation." Journal of Environmental Management92(1):23-30.
Gavaskar, A. R.(1999)."Design and construction techniques for permeable reactive barriers."Journal of Hazardous Materials68(1-2):41-71.
Guerin, T. F., S. Horner, T. McGovern and B. Davey (2002)."An application of permeablereactive barrier technology to petroleum hydrocarbon contaminated groundwater." WaterResearch36(1):15-24.
Henderson, A. D. and A. H. Demond (2007)."Long-term performance of zero-valent ironpermeable reactive barriers: a critical review." Environmental Engineering Science24(4):401-423.
Hinkle, S. R., J. K. Bohlke, J. H. Duff, D. S. Morgan and R. J. Weick (2007)."Aquifer-scalecontrols on the distribution of nitrate and ammonium in ground water near La Pine,Oregon, USA." Journal of Hydrology333(2-4):486-503.
Hou, G., F. Liu, M. Liu, X. Kong, S. Li, L. Chen, P. J. Colberg, S. Jin and H. Chen (2014)."Performance of a permeable reactive barrier for in situ removal of ammoniumin groundwater."
Huang, H., X. Xiao, B. Yan and L. Yang (2010)."Ammonium removal from aqueoussolutions by using natural Chinese (Chende) zeolite as adsorbent." Journal of HazardousMaterials175(1–3):247-252.
Jeen, S.-W., R. W. Gillham and D. W. Blowes (2006)."Effects of carbonate precipitates onlong-term performance of granular iron for reductive dechlorination of TCE."ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE&TECHNOLOGY40(20):6432-6437.
Jeen, S.-W., R. W. Gillham and A. Przepiora (2011)."Predictions of long-term performance ofgranular iron permeable reactive barriers: Field-scale evaluation." JOURNAL OFCONTAMINANT HYDROLOGY123(1-2):50-64.
Jung, J.-Y., Y.-C. Chung, H.-S. Shin and D.-H. Son (2004)."Enhanced ammonia nitrogenremoval using consistent biological regeneration and ammonium exchange of zeolite inmodified SBR process." Water Research38(2):347-354.
Kamolpornwijit, W., L. Y. Liang, G. R. Moline, T. Hart and O. R. West (2004)."Identificationand quantification of mineral precipitation in Fe-0filings from a column study."ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE&TECHNOLOGY38(21):5757-5765.
Kanew, S. R., H. Choi, J.-Y. Kim, S. Vigneswaran and W. G. Shim (2006)."Removal ofarsenic(III) from groundwater using low-cost industrial by-products-Blast furnaceslag." Water Quality Research Journal of Canada41(2):130-139.
Karadag, D., S. Tok, E. Akgul, M. Turan, M. Ozturk and A. Demir (2008)."Ammoniumremoval from sanitary landfill leachate using natural Gordes clinoptilolite." Journal ofHazardous Materials153(1-2):60-66.
Komnitsas, K., G. Bartzas and I. Paspaliaris (2004)."Efficiency of limestone and red mudbarriers: laboratory column studies." Minerals Engineering17(2):183-194.
Kong, X., J. Ma, Y. Yang, F. Liu and E. Bi (2012)."Laboratory Column Study for Evaluatinga Bio-chemical Permeable Reactive Barrier to Remove Ammonium from Groundwater."Enviromental Science and Technology35(12):1-5.
Lagergren, S.(1898). Zur Theorie der sogenannten Absorption gel ster Stoffe, PA Norstedt&s ner.
Lai, K. C. K., I. M. C. Lo, V. Birkelund and P. Kjeldsen (2006)."Field monitoring of apermeable reactive barrier for removal of chlorinated organics." Journal ofEnvironmental Engineering-Asce132(2):199-210.
Lee, J., A. J. Graettinger, J. Moylan and H. W. Reeves (2009)."Directed site exploration forpermeable reactive barrier design." Journal of Hazardous Materials162(1):222-229.
Lei, L., X. Li and X. Zhang (2008)."Ammonium removal from aqueous solutions usingmicrowave-treated natural Chinese zeolite." Separation and Purification Technology58(3):359-366.
Li, L., C. H. Benson and E. M. Lawson (2006)."Modeling porosity reductions caused bymineral fouling in continuous-wall permeable reactive barriers." JOURNAL OFCONTAMINANT HYDROLOGY83(1-2):89-121.
Liu, S., X. Li and H. Wang (2011)."Hydraulics Analysis for Groundwater Flow ThroughPermeable Reactive Barriers." Environmental Modeling&Assessment16(6):591-598.
Lojkasek‐Lima, P., R. Aravena, O. Shouakar‐Stash, S. K. Frape, M. Marchesi, S. Fiorenzaand J. Vogan (2012)."Evaluating TCE Abiotic and Biotic Degradation Pathways in aPermeable Reactive Barrier Using Compound Specific Isotope Analysis." Ground WaterMonitoring&Remediation32(4):53-62.
Ma, J., Y. Shi, X. Chen and H. X. Wang (2013)."Nitrogen load from rural non-point sourcepollution in suburb area of Shenyang: A case study of Damintun town." AdvancedMaterials Research610:3277-3281.
Mackenzie, P. D., D. P. Horney and T. M. Sivavec (1999)."Mineral precipitation and porositylosses in granular iron columns." Journal of Hazardous Materials68(1–2):1-17.
Nardo, A. D., M. D. Natale, A. Erto, D. Musmarra and I. Bortonea (2010)."Permeablereactive barrier for groundwater PCE remediation: the case study of a solid waste landfillpollution." Computer Aided Chemical Engineering28:1015-1020.
O'Hannesin, S. F. and R. W. Gillham (1998)."Long-term performance of an in situ 'iron wall'for remediation of VOCs." Ground Water36(1):164-170.
Ouellet-Plamondon, C., R. Lynch and A. Al-Tabbaa (2011)."Metal Retention Experiments forthe Design of Soil-Mix Technology Permeable Reactive Barriers." CLEAN–Soil, Air,Water39(9):844-852.
Paredes, D., P. Kuschk, T. Mbwette, F. Stange, R. Müller and H. K ser (2007)."New aspectsof microbial nitrogen transformations in the context of wastewater treatment–a review."Engineering in Life Sciences7(1):13-25.
Patterson, B. M., M. E. Grassi, G. B. Davis, B. S. Robertson and A. J. McKinley (2002)."Useof polymer mats in series for sequential reactive barrier remediation ofammonium-contaminated groundwater: Laboratory column evaluation."ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE&TECHNOLOGY36(15):3439-3445.
Patterson, B. M., M. E. Grassi, B. S. Robertson, G. B. Davis, A. J. Smith and A. J. McKinley(2004)."Use of polymer mats in series for sequential reactive barrier remediation ofammonium-contaminated groundwater: Field evaluation." ENVIRONMENTALSCIENCE&TECHNOLOGY38(24):6846-6854.
Phillips, D., T. V. Nooten, L. Bastiaens, M. Russell, K. Dickson, S. Plant, J. Ahad, T. Newton,T. Elliot and R. Kalin (2010)."Ten year performance evaluation of a field-scalezero-valent iron permeable reactive barrier installed to remediate trichloroethenecontaminated groundwater." ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE&TECHNOLOGY44(10):3861-3869.
Phillips, D. H., T. V. Nooten, L. Bastiaens, M. I. Russell, K. Dickson, S. Plant, J. M. E. Ahad,T. Newton, T. Elliot and R. M. Kalin (2010)."Ten year performance evaluation of afield-scale zero-valent iron permeable reactive barrier installed to remediatetrichloroethene contaminated groundwater." Environmental Science and Technology44(10):3861-3869.
Powell, R. and P. Powell (1998)."Iron metal for subsurface remediation." The Encyclopediaof Environmental Analysis and Remediation. Robert A. Myers, ed. John Wiley&Sons,Inc., New York8:4729-4761.
Puls, R. W., C. J. Paul and R. M. Powell (1999)."The application of in situ permeablereactive (zero-valent iron) barrier technology for the remediation ofchromate-contaminated groundwater: A field test." Applied Geochemistry14(8):989-1000.
Puls, R. W. and R. W. Powell (1997)."Permeable Reactive Subsurface Barriers for theInterception and Remediation of Chlorinated Hydrocarbon and Chromium (VI) Plumesin Ground Water.4pp." US EPA Remedial Technology Fact Sheet.
Robertson, W., J. Vogan and P. Lombardo (2008)."Nitrate Removal Rates in a15‐Year‐Old Permeable Reactive Barrier Treating Septic System Nitrate." Ground WaterMonitoring&Remediation28(3):65-72.
Ruthven, D. M.(1984)."Principles of adsorption and adsorption processes."
Srinivasan, R., D. W. Hoffman, J. E. Wolfe and L. J. Prcin (2008)."Evaluation of removal oforthophosphate and ammonia from rainfall runoff using aboveground permeable reactivebarrier composed of limestone and zeolite." Journal of Environmental Science andHealth Part a-Toxic/Hazardous Substances&Environmental Engineering43(12):1441-1450.
Suponik, T.(2010)."ADSORPTION AND BIODEGRADATION IN PRB TECHNOLOGY."Environment Protection Engineering36(3):43-57.
Sutton, M.(2013)."Global implications of enhanced nitrogen deposition over China."
Teerakun, M., A. Reungsang, C.-J. Lin and C.-H. Liao (2011)."Coupling of zero valent ironand biobarriers for remediation of trichloroethylene in groundwater." Journal ofEnvironmental Sciences23(4):560-567.
Thiruverikatachari, R., S. Vigneswaran and R. Naidu (2008)."Permeable reactive barrier forgroundwater remediation." Journal of Industrial and Engineering Chemistry14(2):145-156.
U.S.EPA (1998)."Permeable reactive barrier technologies for contaminant remediation."600R98125.
U.S.EPA (2004)."Technologies for Treating MtBE and Other Fuel Oxygenates." U.S.Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, DC, USA EPA542-R-04-009.
V r smarty, C. J., P. McIntyre, M. O. Gessner, D. Dudgeon, A. Prusevich, P. Green, S.Glidden, S. E. Bunn, C. A. Sullivan and C. R. Liermann (2010)."Global threats tohuman water security and river biodiversity." Nature467(7315):555-561.
Van Nooten, T., L. Diels and L. Bastiaens (2010)."Microbially Mediated ClinoptiloliteRegeneration in a Multifunctional Permeable Reactive Barrier Used to RemoveAmmonium from Landfill Leachate Contamination: Laboratory Column Evaluation."ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE&TECHNOLOGY44(9):3486-3492.
Vignola, R., R. Bagatin, A. D. F. D'Auris, C. Flego, M. Nalli, D. Ghisletti, R. Millini and R.Sisto (2011)."Zeolites in a permeable reactive barrier (PRB): One year of fieldexperience in a refinery groundwater-Part1: The performances." Chemical EngineeringJournal178:204-209.
WANG, X. C., DING, Z. B.,&DU, D. J.(2001). Zeolite Properties in Water Treatment. Journal ofPLA University of Science and Technology (Natural Science),4,018.
Wen, D.-h.(2003)."Mechanism for physical-chemical actions of natural zeolite on NH~4^+in solution." CHINA ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE-CHINESE EDITION-23(5):509-514.
Widiastuti N, Wu H, Ang HM, Zhang D. Removal of ammonium from greywater usingnatural zeolite. Desalination2011;277:15-23.
Yusof, A. M., L. K. Keat, Z. Ibrahim, Z. A. Majid and N. A. Nizam (2010)."Kinetic andequilibrium studies of the removal of ammonium ions from aqueous solution by ricehusk ash-synthesized zeolite Y and powdered and granulated forms of mordenite."Journal of hazardous materials174(1):380-385.
Zhang, S., Y. Zhang, X. Su and Y. Zhang (2013)."In situ remediation of petroleumcontaminated groundwater by permeable reactive barrier with hydrothermal palygorskiteas medium." Chemical Research in Chinese Universities29(1):37-41.
Zhang, X., Z. Wu, Z. Wang, Q. Zhou and D. Yang (2010)."Adsorption characteristics ofammonium ions by natural clinoptilolite powder." Chin Environ Sci30:609-614.
Zhang, Y., Y. L. Zhang, S. Y. Zhang, F. Song, J. Y. Huang, Y. Zhang and X. D. Bai (2012)."Utilization of Scoria as PRB Reactive Media for the Removal of PetroleumHydrocarbon from Groundwater." Advanced Materials Research535:2457-2461.
Zhang, Y. S. and R. K. Gillham (2005)."Effects of gas generation and precipitates onperformance of Fe degrees PRBs." Ground Water43(1):113-121.
Zhuo, N., Z. Cuiyun and Z. Sheng (2011)."Study of Groundwater Contamination ofAmmonium and Its Nitrogen Isotope." South-to-North Water Transfers and WaterScience&Technology9(3):129-132.
白雁冰(2008)."折点加氯法脱氨氮后余氯的脱除."环境科学与管理(11):102-108.
毕二平,李政红(2001)."石家庄市地下水中氮污染分析."水文地质工程地质28(2):31-34.
毕晶晶(2011).间歇性离子交换—电再生技术去除水中硝酸盐硕士,中国海洋大学.
蔡勇,马宏瑞(2005).石油污染地下水吸附-降解联合修复方法的研究.首届全国农业环境科学学术研讨会,中国湖南长沙.
陈坚(2011).铵态氮在包气带介质中的吸附机制及转化去除研究,中国地质大学(北京).
陈坚,黄国鑫,刘菲,秦晓鹏,辛晓华,金爱芳(2011)."天然沸石去除地下水中氨氮的研究."安徽农业科学(10).
陈梦熊,马凤山(2002).中国地下水资源与环境,地震出版社.
陈水飞,张焕祯,赵茜,汤宣林,潘丽娜(2011)."高氟地下水PRB修复介质的选择."华北水利水电学院学报(05):138-141.
揣小明(2012)."利用PRB技术去除氯代有机污染物的研究进展."安徽农业科学(07):4202-4204+4207.
崔亚伟,刘云根(2009)."污染地下水原位处理PRB技术研究进展."地下水(06):100-102+139.
戴长雷,迟宝明,陈鸿雁(2005)."傍河型地下水水源地论证."工程勘察(2):26-28.
狄军贞,刘建军,闫立永(2009)."垃圾污染地下水的PRB修复数学模型及模拟."武汉工业学院学报(03):72-74+101.
董军,赵勇胜,黄奇文,等(2004)."用双层PRB技术处理垃圾填埋场地下水污染的可行性研究."环境科学学报(06):1021-1026.
董军,赵勇胜,赵晓波,等(2003)."垃圾渗滤液对地下水污染的PRB原位处理技术."环境科学(05):151-156.
冯绍元,黄冠华(1997)."试论水环境中的氮污染行为."灌溉排水16(2):34-36.
高国振,王银,陈晶(2013)."Fe~0-PRB在放射性废水处理中的研究与展望."广东化工(13):94+74.
顾莹莹,雷亚妮,高孟春,等(2013)."海绵铁作为渗透反应墙介质去除地下水中NO_3~--N的初步研究."环境污染与防治(04):33-37+42.
何敏良(2009)."探讨生活饮用水中氨氮的污染问题."环境(S1):36.
胡宏韬(2009)."电动与渗透反应格栅联合修复镉污染地下水实验."环境工程学报(10):1773-1777.
胡丽娟,董晓丹,周琪(2005)."零价铁修复土壤及地下水的PRB技术."环境保护科学(04):48-50.
胡日查,孙立波,付芝(2012)."泥炭对甲苯的吸附-解吸行为研究."环境工程学报(02):550-554.
胡莺(2006)."地下水污染修复的零价铁PRB技术."环境(S1):29-31.
孔祥科(2012).复合介质渗透反应格栅去除地下水中氨氮的柱实验研究硕士,中国地质大学(北京).
寇文杰,江岳,林健,等(2013)."污染河水对浅层地下水环境的影响范围研究."人民黄河34(12):88-90.
郎印海,聂新华,贾永刚(2006)."零价铁渗透反应格栅原位修复地下水中氯代烃的应用及研究进展."土壤(01):23-28.
李慧芳(2004).化学—生物组合型反应墙修复阿特拉津污染地下水的实验研究硕士,吉林大学.
李雅(2011). Fe~0-PRB修复地下水中铬铅复合污染的研究博士,西北农林科技大学.
李志萍,谢振华,林健(2010)."地下水污染风险评价指标体系及方法探讨."黑龙江水专学报(03):115-117.
李志萍,张金炳,屈吉鸿,等(2004)."污染河水中氨氮对浅层地下水的影响."地球科学:中国地质大学学报29(3):363-368.
廖国权(2012).钢渣作为PRB介质修复砷污染地下水的研究硕士,山西大学.
廖梓龙,魏永富,郭中小,等(2012)."可渗透反应栅(墙)技术综述."水资源保护(06):70-74+80.
刘超(2011).模拟降雨条件下非均质包气带中“三氮”迁移转化规律研究硕士,中国地质大学(北京).
刘菲,黄园英,何小娟(2005)."与铁相关的几种渗透反应格栅材料性能的比较."地学前缘(S1):170-175.
刘菲,钟佐燊(2001)."地下水中氯代烃的格栅水处理技术."地学前缘(02):309-314.
刘虹(2012).原位修复石油烃污染地下水的PRB技术及长效性研究,吉林大学.
刘虹,张兰英,刘娜,等(2013)."生物可渗透性反应墙修复石油烃污染地下水的效果及微生物多样性研究."环境污染与防治(03):1-4+9.
刘文君(2003).饮用水中可生物降解有机物和消毒副产物特性研究,高等教育出版社.
刘文玲,刘汉伟,郭秀珍(2001)."齐齐哈尔市地下水中氮化合物污染水平分析及防治对策."黑龙江环境通报25(1):45-46.
刘翔,唐翠梅,陆兆华,等(2013)."零价铁PRB技术在地下水原位修复中的研究进展."环境科学研究(12):1309-1315.
刘晓蒙,张焕祯,刘峻平(2012)."PRB修复铬污染地下水反应介质研究进展."环境科学与技术(S1):174-177.
刘玉龙,刘菲,陈宏坤,等(2011)."影响铁渗透反应格栅修复地下水中氯代烃长期运行性能的研究进展."地学前缘(03):331-338.
龙小庆,富良,顾玉其,等(2002)."活性滤池去除微污染水中有机物和氨氮."中国给水排水18(8):44-45.
陆泗进,王红旗,杜琳娜(2006)."污染地下水原位治理技术——透水性反应墙法."环境污染与防治(06):452-457.
罗广英(2009)."折点加氯去除水中氨氮."广州化工(05):172-173+187.
罗仙平,李健昌,严群,等(2010)."处理低浓度氨氮废水吸附材料的筛选."化工学报(1):216-222.
罗育池,李传生(2007)."PRB技术及其在地下水污染修复中的应用."安徽农业科学(27):8656-8657+8660.
骆其金(2008).应用可渗透反应墙技术修复被污染河水的试验研究硕士,湖南农业大学.
马琳(2010).砷污染地下水修复的渗透反应墙材料筛选及除砷机理研究硕士,华中农业大学.
牛少凤,李春晖,富强,等(2009)."PRB连续反应单元模拟与敏感性分析."环境科学研究(6):718-722.
邱锦安,张澄博,李洪艺,等(2011)."PRB在地下水污染修复中的应用与研究进展."广东农业科学(13):144-146+152.
全国地下水污染防治规划(2011-2020),(2011)."中华人民共和国环境保护部."
任义,王磊,狄雅茹(2008)."氨氮废水处理技术进展综述."西安文理学院学报(自然科学版)(03):90-93.
沈照理,朱宛华,钟佐燊(1993).水文地球化学基础,地质出版社.
陶征义(2009).可渗透反应墙处理酸性矿山废水实验研究硕士,贵州大学.
田家宇,陈忠林,梁恒,等(2008)."斜发沸石替代石英砂强化生物过滤除污染性能."JOURNAL OF HARBIN INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY40(4).
王大纯(1995).水文地质学基础,地质出版社.
王俊杰(2013).沈阳浑河傍河区域地下水氮素污染研究,中国地质大学(北京).
王兴润,翟亚丽,舒新前,等(2013)."修复铬污染地下水的可渗透反应墙介质筛选."环境工程学报(07):2523-2528.
谢李,刘菲,刘玉龙(2010)."释氧渗透反应格栅填料的改进研究."环境科学与技术33(2):44-48.
许洪星,蒲春生,李燕红(2012)."大功率超声波处理近井带聚合物堵塞实验研究."油气地质与采收率(5):93-96.
严建伟(2013).基于数值模拟的李官水源地地下水污染PRB优化设计,中国地质大学(北京).
杨敏,曲久辉(2007)."水源污染与饮用水安全."供水技术(4):1-5.
杨胜科,郭春林(2000)."沸石去除地下水中的氨氮的影响因素分析及作用机理探讨."西安工程学院学报22(3):69-72.
杨维,丁斌,王恩德,等(2004)."地下水傍河水源地数值模拟."沈阳建筑大学学报(自然科学版)20(4):325-328.
杨维,郭毓,王泳,等(2007)."氨氮污染地下水的动态实验研究."沈阳建筑大学学报:自然科学版23(5):826-831.
杨维,王恩德,李勇,等(2005)."浑河冲洪积扇中下游地下水中氮转化与水文地球化学特征的研究."水文地质工程地质32(2):39-41.
杨维,王立东,林森,等(2007)."新型改性膨润土制备及其对Cr(Ⅵ)的吸附性能."沈阳建筑大学学报(自然科学版)(06):1004-1008.
杨维,杨军锋,王立东,等(2007)."膨润土研究现状及其作为PRB反应介质的探讨."地质与资源(02):155-160.
叶辉,许建华(2000)."饮用水中的氨氮问题."中国给水排水16(11):31-34.
袁晓玲(2004).吸附—氧化还原化学反应墙去除水源水中POPs-BHC的效果研究硕士,吉林大学.
岳舜琳(2001)."给水中的氨氮问题."净水技术(02):12-15.
张曦,吴为中,温东辉,等(2003)."生物沸石床污水脱氮效果及机理."环境科学24(5):75-80.
张英(2012).腐殖酸共存条件下沸石对氨氮的去除特性及机理研究硕士,中国地质大学(北京).
张莹,张玉玲,张晟瑀,等(2010)."修复石油类污染地下水的PRB反应介质研究."吉林大学学报(地球科学版)(02):399-404.
张永发,祝济之,胡长华(2006)."超声波地层解堵机理研究初步."北京理工大学学报26(5):397-400.
赵强,王金生(2004)."应用可渗透反应墙技术原位修复地下水污染."污染防治技术(03):94-97.
郑涵,姜萍萍(2013)."微污染水源水中氨氮去除研究."城镇供水(1):18-21.
郑致远,陈冬毅(2006)."原水氨氮较高期间氯耗高的原因及对策."中国给水排水(10):87-89.
周启星,林海芳(2001)."污染土壤及地下水修复的PRB技术及展望."环境污染治理技术与设备(05):48-53.
朱琳(2006).双层可渗透生物反应格栅去除地下水中MTBE的研究硕士,天津大学.