摘要
本试验以2368.91倍的小菜蛾对虫螨腈的抗性品系(RR)与敏感品系(SS)进行杂交，F_1代进行自交，及F_1代与亲本回交，结果表明，杂交后的显性度(D)分别为0.5517和0.5402，说明小菜蛾对虫螨腈的抗性遗传是常染色体、不完全显性遗传，而且可能是由多基因控制的。杂交后代的抗性基因频率明显下降。
通过比较抗性品系与敏感品系的生物学特性发现，除抗性品系的幼虫历期有所延长，蛹期缩短，单雌平均产卵量明显低于敏感品系外，其余各指标与敏感品系差异均不显著。敏感品系的净增殖率为55.4，抗性品系的净增殖率为25.2，因此抗性品系相对于敏感品系具有0.45的适合度。因此小菜蛾对虫螨腈的抗性品系在生长发育和繁殖上均存在生存的不利性。
对抗性品系在停止喷药，消除选择压的条件下饲养9代，发现小菜蛾对虫螨腈的抗性水平一直呈下降趋势。从F_1代～F_3代，抗性衰退速度较为缓慢，从F_3代～F_6代，抗性衰退相对较快，从F_7代～F_9代，抗性衰退速度又趋向于缓慢，至第九代，抗性倍数下降了7～8倍，抗性倍数由2368.91倍下降到305.38倍。
通过对小菜蛾抗性品系和敏感品系点药前后呼吸速率进行测定，结果发现，抗性品系与敏感品系受虫螨腈处理后，呼吸速率显著不同，抗性品系受处理前后的呼吸速率变化不大，而敏感品系受处理前后的呼吸速率的变化较为显著。说明抗性品系小菜蛾的耐药性高于敏感品系小菜蛾。F_1代和F_2代受处理前后呼吸速率的变化介于抗性品系与敏感品系之间，回交后代点药后与点药前的差异明显大于F_1代和F_2代点药前后的差异。由此可以初步判定，小菜蛾呼吸速率的变化与敏感性恢复有关。
经过各种群的酯酶、羧酸酯酶、谷胱甘肽-S-芳基转移酶活性测定，结果显示，抗性品系的酯酶比活力略高于敏感品系，但两者之间并无明显差异。杂交代的酯酶活力均低于敏感品系，表现没有一定的规律性。抗性品系与敏感品系的谷胱甘肽-S-芳基转移酶活性存在一定差异。抗性品系小菜蛾的谷胱甘肽-S-芳基转移酶活性明显低于敏感品系，仅为敏感品系的0.5775倍，其杂交后代的谷胱甘肽-S-芳基转移酶活性介于两亲本之间，比抗性亲本有所升高，由此可以初步判定，小菜蛾对虫螨腈的抗性与酯酶及羧酸酯酶活性无关，与谷胱甘肽-S-芳基转移酶活性有关。
用聚丙烯酰胺凝胶电泳分析各品系的酯酶同工酶，在抗性品系的酶带中发现一条特征性酶带，说明抗性品系可能有新酶出现。
The genetics of resistance to chlorfenapyr were carried out on susceptible laboratory strains and resistant strains (2368.91 X ) of diamondback moth, Plutella xylostella. The LD50 and probit regression lines of susceptible and resistant parents and their F1 hybrids, F1-backcross progeny and F2-masscross progeny were assessed in order to determine inheritance character. The result showed that the degree of dominance of FRS and FSR were 0.5517 and 0.5402 respectively. It suggested that the resistance of diamondback moth to chlorfenapyr was autosomal, incompletely dominant and probably polygenic control. The resistance gene frequency decreased significantly.
The research was taken to two different 'strains in the terms of developmental and reproducetive characterstics under artifitial climate condition. Life tables of the resistant strain and the susceptible strain were constructed. The results indicated that the resistant strain possessed some developmental disadvantage including prolonged larva duration, and reproductive disadvantage including lower mean number of eggs per female. The intrinsic rate of natural increase in the resistant and susceptible strain calculated by establishing life table were 25.2 and 55.4, respectively. Rate of relative fitness of resistant strain was 0.45 based on comparing with that of susceptible strain.
The resistance ratios (RR) of Plutella xylostella declined when the resistant strain was reared on fresh cabbage leaves in the laboratory. From F1 to F3, resistance reversion rate was slow. From F4 to F6, resistance reversion rate was fast relatively. From F7 to F9, there was a tendency for declining slowly once again. After 9 generation, the resistance ratios were over 7-8 folds from 2368.91 folds to 305.38 folds.
Great difference was found between the two strains in rate of respiration after treated by insecticide chlorfenapyr, the resistant strain showed little variation treated by insecticide, but the susceptible strain showed great decrease treated by insecticide. The difference of F1 hybrids and F2-masscross progeny treated varied between those of the resistant strain and susceptible strain, backcross progeny while the difference of treated by insecticide was greater than those of F1 and F2. So it was estimated that the variation of respiration rate was related to resistance reversion.
The activity of 3 enzymes (esterase, carboxylesterase and glutathione-S-transferase)
from two strains were determined. The results showed that the activity of esterase and carboxylesterase of the resistant strain has no distinct difference compared with those of the susceptible strain, and those of F1 hybrids, F2 and BC were all lower than those of the susceptible strain and there were not any regularities.The activity of glutathione-S-transferase of the resistant strain was lower than that of the susceptible strain, was 0.5775-fold compared with the susceptible strain, while that of other strains between that of the resistant strain and susceptible strain and greater than that of the resistant strain. The results indicated that the glutathione-S-transferase contributed to resistance of diamondback moth to Chlorfenapyr.
The esterase of hemolymph of the diamondback moth was analysed by polyacrylamide gelelectrophoresis (PAGE). In contrast to the susceptible strain, there was a special enzyme band in the resistant strain, the results indicated that perhaps there was a new enzymes.
引文
[1] 吴青君，张文吉等．小菜蛾发生特点及抗药性现状[J]．中国蔬菜，2001，(5)：49-51．
[2] Talekar N S, Shelton A M, Bioloth. ecoloth and management of the diamondback moth[J]. Ann Rev Ent.1993, 38:275—301.
[3] 王旭，高希武，郑炳宗．小菜蛾抗药性的研究[J]．世界农业，1997，(11)：27-29．
[4] 沈阳农学院编．蔬菜昆虫学[M]．北京：农业出版社，1980．
[5] 赵建周．小菜蛾的抗药性及其治理[J]．植保技术与推广，1994，14(5)：20-21．
[6] 唐振华．昆虫抗药性及其治理[M]．北京：中国农业出版社，1993．
[7] Georhgiou G P. The magnitude of the resistance problem. In: Pesticide resistance: strategies and tactics for management [M]. National Academy Press,Washington D.C. 1986,14-44.
[8] Brattsten L B. Insecticide resistance research and management[J]. Pesticide science, 1989,26:329-322.
[9] Georghiou G P. Lagunes-Tejeda[M].A FAO ROME,1991.
[10] 刘维德，刘金发．淡色库蚊(Culex pipeienus pallens)幼虫的不同发育阶段对几种氯化烃类杀虫剂敏感度变化的研究[J]．昆虫学报，1963,12：276-281．
[11] 俞渊，徐树人，陆秀琴．蚊虫抗药性的研究[J]．昆虫学报，1963，12：163-166．
[12] 屈天祥，陈其瑚．黄条跳甲(phyllotreta vittata Fabr.)对DDT的抗性测定[J]．昆虫知识，1963，7：51-55．
[13] Tsukamoto M. Methods of genetic analysis of insecticide resistance,In G.P.Georghiou & T.Saito (eds). Pest resistance to pesticides.Plenum [M]. New York, 1983,71-98.
[14] D.Craig Heirn, Inheritance of Fenvalerate and Carbofuran Resistance in Colorado Beetles-Leptinotarsa decemlineata(Say)-from North Carolina[J]. Pestie Sci. 1992:34:303-311.
[15] 李雁声，李文质等．谷蠹和米象对磷化氢抗性遗传的研究[J]．昆虫学报，1994，37(3)：271-279．
[16] 梁永生，覃章贵，邓刚．谷蠹磷化氢高抗性品系的抗性遗传分析[J]．粮食储藏，2001，(3)：3-7．
[17] Collins. P. J. 1986. Genetic analysis of fenitrothion resistance in the sawtoothed grain beetle. Oryzaephillus surtinamensis (Coleoptera._ Cucujidae) [J]. J. Econ. Ent. 79:1196-1199.
[18] 刘泽文，韩召军．褐飞虱对马拉硫磷的抗性遗传和交互抗性研究[J]．华东昆虫学报，2003，12(1)：19-23．
[19] 王开运，慕立义．亚洲玉米螟对氰戊菊酯抗性遗传的研究[J]．华东昆虫学报，1995，4(2)：103-105．
[20] 刘永杰，沈晋良．甜菜夜蛾抗氯氟氰菊酯品系相对适合度、抗性生化机理及抗性遗传方式[J]．昆虫学报，2003，46(5)：567-572．
[21] Roush R.T. Inheritance of Methomyl Resistance in the Tobacco Budworm (Lepidoptera:Notuidae) [J]. J. Econ. Entomol. 1985,78:1020-1022.
[22] 吴益东，沈晋良，尤子平．棉铃虫对氰戊菊酯抗性遗传分析[J]．昆虫学报，1995，38(1)：20-23．
[23] 杨亦桦，沈晋良，吴益东等．棉铃虫抗溴氰菊酯品系选育、生化机理及遗传方式研究[J]．昆虫学报，1996，23(2)：163-170．
[24] Daly J C et al. Inheritance of metabolic resistance to the synthetic pyrethroids in Australian Helicoverpa armigera(Lepidoptera:Noctuidae) [J]. Bull. Entomol. Res. Sup. 1992, 82:5-12.
[25] Gunning R V et al. Inheritance of resistance to fenvalerate in Heliothis armigera(hü bner)(Lepidoptera:Noctuidae) [J]. J.Australian Ent, Soc. 1987,26:249-250.
[26] 李凤良，程罗根，韩招久等．小菜蛾对溴氰菊酯的抗性遗传分析[J]．西南农业学报，2000，13(4)：62-66．
[27] 程罗根，李凤良，王荫长等．小菜蛾对杀螟丹抗药性的生化遗传研究[J]．南京农业大学学报，1998，21(3)：36-40．
[28] 李腾武，高希武，郑炳宗等．小菜蛾对阿维菌素的抗性遗传方式和相对适合度研究[J]．昆虫学报，2000，43(3)：255-263．
[29] 李腾武，高希武，郑炳宗．小菜蛾对阿维菌素的抗性遗传分析及交互抗性研究[J]．植物保护学报，1999，25(6)：12-14．
[30] 李凤良，程罗根，韩招久等．小菜蛾对杀虫双的抗性遗传研究[J]．植物保护学报，1998，25(4)：345-350．
[31] Georghiou, G.P. Genetics of resistance to insecticides in houseflies and mosquitoes[J]. Exp. Parasitol. 1969,26:224-255.
[32] Konno Y, Scott J G. Biochem is try and genetics of abamectin resistance in the housefly[J]. Pestic. Biochem. Physiol., I991,41:21-28.
[33] 黎云根，唐振华．抗马拉硫磷淡色库蚊的形式遗传研究．昆虫学研究集刊[M]．上海：上海科学技术出版社．1982-83 第三集，85-92．
[34] 吴孔明，刘芹轩．朱砂叶螨抗氧化乐果品系选育及遗传分析[J]．生态学报，1994，14(14)：391-396．
[35] Keena M and Granett J. Genetic analysis of propargite resistance in pacific spider mite and two-spotted spider mite (Acari: Tetranychidae) [J]. J. Econ. Entomol., 1990,83(3):655—661.
[36] Hoy M A. et al. Cyhexatin and fenbutatin-oxide resistance in pacific spider mite (Acari:Tetranychidae):stability and mode of inheritance[J]. J.Econ. Entomol.. 1988, 81(1):57-64.
[37] Hoy M A and Conley J. Propargite resistance in pacific spider mite (Acari:Tetranychidae):stability and mode of inheritance [J]. J.Econ. Entomol. 1989,82 (1): 11-16.
[38] 柯励生．拟长毛钝绥螨抗乐果品系的筛选及遗传分析[J]．昆虫学报，1990，33(4)：393-397．
[39] 黄明度．尼氏钝绥螨抗亚胺硫磷品系的筛选及遗传分析[J]．昆虫学报，1987，30(2)：133-139．
[40] Ankersmit G W. DDT-resistance in Plutella maculipennis(Cutis)(lep.) in Bull[J]. Entomology Reseach. 1993,44:421-425.
[41] 闰艳春，乔传令，钱传范．小菜蛾抗药性研究进展[J]．昆虫知识，1997，35(5)：310-314．
[42] Georghiou, G P., Tavor, C E. Proceedings of ⅩⅤth International congress entomology [J]. Washington DC: College Park, 1976, 759--785.
[43] Pemg F S., Yao, M C., Hung, C F., et al Teflubenzuron Resistance in Diamondback Moth(Lepidoptera:Plutellidae) [J]. Journal of Economic Entomology,1988, 81:1277-1282.
[44] Tabashnick B E. Field Development of Resistance to Bacillus thuringiensis in Diamondback Moth(Lepidoptera:Plutellidae) [J]. J. Econ. Entomol. 1990,83: 1671-1676.
[45] 赵善欢．小菜蛾的抗药性及防治策略[J]．西北农业大学学报，1995，23(3)：21-24．
[46] 曹毅．小菜蛾抗药性研究进展[J]．长江蔬菜，2001，(1)：4-5．
[47] 梁谊，陈宗麒．小菜蛾抗药性研究现状[J]．云南农业大学学报，2000，15(4)：367-370．
[48] 刘长令．农药品种开发现状与发展趋势[J]．化工管理，2001，(8)：17．
[49] 阮郎．吡咯杀虫剂的发现与评论[J]．农药译丛，1995，19(2)：24-31．
[50] 罗万春．世界新农药与环境-发展中的新型杀虫剂口[M]．世界知识出版社，2002．
[51] Wier Alan T, Boethel David J, Leonard B Roger etal. Laboratory toxicity and field efficacy of AC-303,630 (Priate) against beet armyworm,Spodoptera exigua [J]. J. Agric.Entomol., 1994,11 (4): 311-320.
[52] 陈之浩，刘传秀，李风良等．小菜蛾继代繁殖大量饲养方法研究初报[J]．贵州农业科学，1990，(4)：52-53．
[53] 刘传秀，韩招久，李凤良等．应用蛭石萝卜苗法室内继代大量繁殖小菜蛾的研究[J]．昆虫知识，1993，30(6)：341-344．
[54] 杨广，尤民生．小菜蛾对蔬菜气味的定向行为[J]．武夷科学，2002，18(12)：73-79．
[55] FAO. Method for the diamond back moth (Plutella xylostella L.) [J]. FAO Plant Prote.Bull., 1979,27(2):No.21:44-46.
[56] 陈之浩等．杀虫双和杀螟丹选育对小菜蛾抗药性的形成及其抗性机制[J]．昆虫学报，1993，36(4)：409-417．
[57] Liu Y B, Tabashnik B E. Visual determination of sex of diamondback moth larvae[J]. The
Canadian Entomologist, 1997,129 (3): 585-586.
[58] Tsukamoto M. The log dosage-porbit mortality curve in genetic researches of insect resistante to insecticides[J]. Botyu-kagaku, 1963,28:91-98.
[59] Georghiou G P, Garber M J. Studies on the inheritance of carbamate-resistance in the house fly Musca domestica L[J]. Bull. WHO, 1965,32:181-196.
[60] Sokal R R, Rohlf R L. Biometry. 2nd ed. Freeman[M]. San Francisco,1981.
[61] Stone B F. A formula for determining degree of dominance in case of monofactorial inheritance of resistance to chemicals[J]. Bull. WHO,1968,38:325-326.
[62] 吴坤君，陈玉平，李明辉．不同温度下的棉铃虫实验种群生命表[J]．昆虫学报，1978，21(4)：385-392
[63] 吴坤君，陈玉平，李明辉．温度对棉铃虫实验种群生长的影响[J]．昆虫学报，1980，23(4)：358-363．
[64] 吴福桢，管致和．中国农业百科全书(昆虫卷)[M]．北京：农业出版社 1990-91：341．
[65] 慕立义．植物化学保护研究方法[M]．北京：中国农业出版社，1985．
[66] Kao C H, Hung C F, Sun C N. Parathion and methyl parathion resistance In diamondback moth(Lepidoptera:Plutellidae)larvae[J]. Jounal of Economic Entomology, 1989,82:1299-1304.
[67] Bradford M M, Arapid sensitive method for the quantitation of micro-gram quantilies of protein utilizing the principle of protein binding Anal[J]. Biochem., 1976,72:248-254.
[68] 杨安钢，毛积芳，药立波．生物化学与分子生物学实验技术[M]．北京：高等教育出版社，2001
[69] 郭尧君，蛋白质电泳实验技术[M]．北京：科学出版社，2001，72．
[70] 莽克强．聚丙烯酰胺凝胶电泳[M]．北京：科学出版社，1976．
[71] 蒋成山．中华按蚊和雷氏按蚊嗜人亚种八种同工酶的遗传学分析及其亲缘关系的研究[J]．遗传学报，1983，10(5)：390～397．
[72] Devonshire A L. Studies of the carboxylesterases of Myzus persicae resistant and susceptible to organophosphorus insecticides. Proc 8th Brit Inseetic Fungic Conf,[C]. 1975,1:67-73.
[73] 张宗炳．杀虫药剂的毒力测定[M]．北京：科学出版社，1988．
[74] 张志祥，徐汉虹，程东美．EXCEL在毒力回归计算中的应用[J]．昆虫知识，2002，39(1)：67-70．
[75] Roush R.T. Combs R L, Randolph T C et al. Inheritance and effective dominance of pyrethroid resistance in the horn fly (Diptera:Muscidae) [J]. J. Econ. Entomol. 1986,79:1178-1182.
[76] Tabashnik B E, Determining the mode of inheritance of pesticide resistance with backcross experiments[J]. J. Econ. Entomol. 1991,84:703-712.
[77] Bruce C, Black B, Robert M H, Kabeer I A et al. Insecticidal action and Mitochondrial Uncoupling
Activity of AC-303,630 and related halogenated pyrooles[J]. Pesticide Biochemistry and physicalogy 1994,50:115-128.
[78] YU S J. Inheritance of Insecticide Resistance and Microsomal oxidases in the diamondback moth (Lepidoptera:Yponomeutidae)[J].Journal of Economic Entomology, 1993,(86):680-683
[79] YU S J, Nguyen S N. Insecticide susceptibility and detoxication enzyme activities in permethrin-selected diamondback moths[J]. Pestic Biochem Physiol, 1996,56(1):69-77.
[80] Ferre J M,Real D,Rie J V, et al Resistance to the Bacillus thuringiensis bioinsecticide in a field population of plutella xylostella is due to a change in a midgut membrane receptor[J]. Proceeding of the National Academy of sciences of the USA, 1991,88:5119-5123
[81] Tabashnik B E, Schwartz J M,Finsonn, et al.. Inheritance of Resistance to Bacillus thuringiensis in Diamondback Moth (Lepidotera:plutellidae) [J]. Journal of Entomology, 1992,85:1046-1055
[82] Imaik,Mori Y. In:3rd International workshop on the Management of Diamondback Moth and other Crucifer Pest [M]. Malaysia, 1996,202-209.
[83] Forester N W, et al. Management of pyrethoid and endosulfan resistance in Helicoverpa armigera (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae) in Australia[J]. Bull Entomol Res Sup, 1993(1):36-43.
[84] 吴益东，沈晋良，谭福杰等．棉铃虫对氰戊菊酯抗性品系和敏感品系的相对适合度[J]．昆虫学报，1996，39(3)：233-237．
[85] 孟香清，芮昌辉，赵建周等．抗三氟氯氰菊酯棉铃虫种群相对适合度研究[J]．植物保护，1998，24(6)：12-14．
[86] 任晓霞，韩召军，王荫长．棉铃虫对久效磷抗性和敏感性品系的生物适合度[J]．南京农业大学学报，2001，24(2)：41-44．
[87] 吴青君，张文吉，张友军等．敏感和抗阿维菌素小菜蛾的生物适合度[J]．农药学学报，2000，2(1)：36-40．
[88] Rose M H. A comparison of reproduction and longevity in pyrethroid-resistant and susceptible German cockroach (Blattodea: Blattellidae) field-collected strains [J]. Journal of Econmic Entomology, 1991,26(4):408-418.
[89] Argentine J A, Clark J M, Ferro D N. Relative fitness of insecticide-resistant Colorado potato bettle strains (Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae) [J]. Environment Entomology, 1989,18(4):705-710.
[90] Follet P A, Gould F, Kennedy O G. Comparative fitness of three strains of Colorado potato bettle (Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae) in field: spatial and temporal variation in insecticide selection[J].Journal of Econmic Entomology, 1993,86(5): 1324-1333.
[91] Bhatia S K, Pradhan S. Studies on resistance to insecticides in Tribolium castanetum Herbst Ⅰ Selection of a strain resistant to DDT and its biological characteristics[J]. Indian J. Entomol., 1968,30:13-32.
[92] Blackman R L, Spence J M etal. Inheritance of the amplif-yied esterase genes responsible for insecticide resistance in Myzus persicae (Homoptera:Aphididae)[J]. Heredity, 1996,77:154-167.
[93] Foster S P, Denhom I, Harling Z Ketal. Intensification of insecticide resistance in UK field populations of the peach-potato aphid, Myzus persicae (Homoptera:Aphididae) in 1996[J]. Bull. Entomol. Res., 1998,88(2):127-130.
[94] Wyatt I J, White P F. Simple estimation of intrinsic increase rates for aphids and tetranychid mites[J]. Journal Applant Ecology, 1977,14:757-766.
[95] Moustafa F L. Systematic studies of endrin resistance in Spodoptera littoralis(Boisd.). Comparative biological studies in laboratory and endrin resistant strains of the cotton leafworm, Spodoptera littoralis Bdv[In] Proceeding,4th A rb Pest Conference[M]. Tanta Univ., Egypt, 1981,279-289.
[96] 慕卫，吴孔明，粱革梅等．高效氯氟氰菊酯不同抗性基因型甜菜夜蛾相对适合度研究[J]．农药学学报，2001，3(4)：49-52．
[97] Campanhola C,Plapp F W. Toxicity and synergism of insecticide against susceptible and pyrethroid-resistant third instars of the tobacco budworm(Lepidoptera:Noctuidae)[J]. Journal of Econmic Entomology, 1989,82(6): 1495-1501.
[98] Han Z J, Wang Y C, Zhang Q S etal. Dynamics of pyrethroid resistance in a field population of Helicoverpa armigera(Hubner) in China[J]. Pesticide Science, 1999,55(4):462-466.
[99] Groeters F R, Tabashnik B E, Finson N etal. Fitness costs of resistance to Bacillus thringiensis in the diamondback moth (plutella xylostella) [J]. Evolution. 1994,48(1): 197-201.
[100] Ferrari J A, Georghiou G P. Effect of insecticidal selection and treatmint on reproductive pontential of resistant, susceptible and heterozugous strains of the southern house mosqueito[J]. Journal of Econmic Entomology. 1981,74:323-392.
[101] 芮昌辉，赵勇，孟香清等．害虫的抗药性[M]．化学工业出版社，1995：117-187
[102] 唐振华，韩罗珍，张朝远．抗马拉硫磷淡色库蚊不同基因型的自然内禀增长率及其对抗性演化的影响[J]．昆虫学报，1990，33(4)：385-392．
[103] Roush R.T, Plapp F W, Biochemical genetics of resistance to aryl carbarnate insecticide in the predaceous mite, Metaseiulus occidentalis[J]. Journal of Econmic Entomology,1982,75:708-713.
[104] Scott J A, Plapp F W, Bay D E. Pyrethroid resistancd associated with decreased biotic fitness in horn flies (Diptera:Museidae) [J]. Southwestern Entomol., 1997,22(4):405-410.
[105] Batterham P, Davies A G, Game A Y etal. Asymmetry-where evolutionary and development genetics meet[J]. Bio.Essays, 1996,18(10):841-845.
[106] Mckenzie J A, Farrell K. Modifecation of developmental instability and fitness: malathion resistance in the Australian sheep blowfly, Lucilica cuprina[J]. Genetica, 1993,89(1-3):67-76.
[107] Kasamatsu K, Ogawa M. Relative reproducetivity of two-spotted spider mite, Tetranychus urticae(Koch) selected by fenpropathrin[J]. J.Appl.Entomol.Zool, 1992,36(4):256-258.
[108] Mcenroe W D, Naegele J A. The coadaptive process in an organophosphorus resistant strain of the two spotted spider mite, Tetranychus urticae[J]. Ann. Entomo. Soc.Am., 1968,61:1055-1059.
[109] 姚洪渭．白背飞虱抗药性机理的研究—药剂敏感性变化的生理学与生理生化基础[D]．浙江大学，2000．
[110] 罗余平，黄章欣，吴佳教．小菜蛾抗药性衰退的初步研究[J]．植物保护，1995，21(2)：26-27．
[111] 朱树勋，司升云，邹丰等．小菜蛾抗药性消失动态研究[J]．中国蔬菜，1996(1)：20-22．
[112] 李建洪，伍建宏，喻子牛．小菜蛾对苏云金芽孢杆菌的抗药性研究[J]．华中农业大学学报，1998，17(3)：215-217．
[113] 赵建周．小菜蛾的抗药性及其治理[J]．植保技术与推广，1994，(5)：20-21．
[114] 陈之浩，刘传秀，李凤良．杀虫双和杀螟丹选育对小菜蛾抗药性形成及其抗性机制[J]．昆虫学报，1993，36(4)：409—417．
[115] Cheng E Y, Kao C H, Chin C S. Insecticide resistance study in Plutella xylostella L.X. IGR resistance and the possible management strategy[J]. J. Agric.Res. China. 1990,39:208-220.
[116] 傅丽君，尤民生，戴小华．球孢白僵菌对小菜蛾呼吸作用的影响[J]．福建农业大学学报，2000，29(2)：197-200．
[117] 姚洪渭．寄主植物影响害虫药剂敏感性的研究进展[J]．昆虫学报，2002，45(2)：253-264．
[118] 唐振华．我国昆虫抗药性研究现状及展望[J]．昆虫知识，2000，37(2)：97-102．