用户名: 密码: 验证码:
赣南淘锡坑钨矿床He-Ar同位素地球化学研究
详细信息    查看全文 | 推荐本文 |
  • 英文篇名:He and Ar isotopes of ore-forming fluids in the Taoxikeng tungsten deposit,southern Jiangxi Province,China
  • 作者:宋生琼 ; 潘力川 ; 魏文凤
  • 英文作者:SONG ShengQiong;PAN LiChuan;WEI WenFeng;State Key Laboratory of Ore Deposit Geochemistry,Institute of Geochemistry,Chinese Academy of Sciences;Guizhou Land Survey & Plan Institute;College of Earth Sciences,Chengdu University of Technology;
  • 关键词:淘锡坑钨矿床 ; 流体包裹体 ; He和Ar同位素 ; S型花岗岩 ; 地幔组分
  • 英文关键词:Taoxikeng tungsten deposit;;Fliud inclusions;;He and Ar isotopes;;S-type granites;;Mantle-derived component
  • 中文刊名:YSXB
  • 英文刊名:Acta Petrologica Sinica
  • 机构:中国科学院地球化学研究所矿床地球化学国家重点实验室;贵州省国土资源勘测规划研究院;成都理工大学地球科学学院;
  • 出版日期:2019-01-15
  • 出版单位:岩石学报
  • 年:2019
  • 期:v.35
  • 基金:中科院战略性先导科技专项(XDB18000000);; 国家“973”项目(2007CB411400)联合资助
  • 语种:中文;
  • 页:YSXB201901020
  • 页数:9
  • CN:01
  • ISSN:11-1922/P
  • 分类号:249-257
摘要
华南石英脉型黑钨矿的形成一直被认为是与地壳沉积物质重熔形成的S型花岗岩有关。然而,近年来对南岭中生代成岩成矿机制的研究发现,地幔组分可能参与了钨、锡成矿作用。本文对淘锡坑石英脉型钨多金属矿床与黑钨矿共生的黄铁矿和毒砂中流体包裹体的He、Ar同位素进行了研究。结果显示,上述矿物中流体包裹体的~3He/~4He值为0. 37~2. 11Ra(Ra为空气的~3He/~4He值,1Ra=1. 39×10~(-6)),介于地幔与地壳的~3He/~4He值之间;~(40)Ar/~(36)Ar值为309. 5~383. 6,平均335. 4,略高于大气的~(40)Ar/~(36)Ar比值(295. 5)。研究表明,成矿流体具有壳-幔两端元混合的特征。其中,地壳端元的流体为经过地下循环的低温饱和大气水,地幔端元的流体为矿区隐伏花岗岩体成岩过程中分异出的岩浆流体。结合前人研究成果,认为该矿床的形成与华南中生代燕山期发生的软流圈上涌、岩石圈减薄、地壳伸展等地球动力学作用有密切联系。这种动力学过程为地幔组分带来的热引起地壳沉积物质重熔形成钨多金属成矿花岗岩浆提供了条件。
        China accounts for about 60% tungsten reserves of the world. More than 90% of the Chinese tungsten resources occur in the Nanling region as tungsten polymetallic deposits. The Nanling region locates at the central west Cathaysia Block in South China where abundant Jurassic granitic intrusions are distributed. Previous studies have significantly advanced our understanding of the tungsten ore formation in the Nanling region. These deposits are usually of the quartz-wolframite vein type. They have ages of about 150~160 Ma,and are spatially and temporally related to the Jurassic granites,believed to be produced by crustal anatexis. The formation of quartz-vein type tungsten deposits in South China has always been considered to be related to S-type granite derived from remelting of crustal materials. However,in recent years,studies on the metallogenic mechanism of Mesozoic W-Sn deposits in Nanling region have demonstrated that mantle material and mantle fluid may be involved in tungsten and tin mineralization. The Taoxikeng deposit is a large-sized W deposit located at Jiangxi. Here,we conducted studies He and Ar isotope of pyrite-and arsenopyrite-trapped fluid inclusions on Taoxikeng quartz-vein type wolframite deposit. The analytical results of He and Ar isotope of pyrite-and arsenopyritetrapped fluid inclusions show that,~3He/~4He ratio of arsenopyrite between 1. 38 and 2. 11 Ra( Ra is ~3He/~4He in air,1 Ra = 1. 39 ×10-6). The ~3He/~4He of pyrite between 0. 67 and 0. 37 Ra. The concentration of ~4He is between 1. 98 × 10~(-7) and 49. 1 × 10~(-7) cm~3 STP/g. The concentration of ~(40)Ar is 4. 19 × 10~(-7)~ 51. 4 × 10~(-7) cm~3 STP/g,~3He/~4He is 0. 37 ~ 2. 11 Ra.~(40)Ar/~(36)Ar is 309. 5 ~ 383. 6,slightly higher than the ratio of atmosphere ~(40)Ar/~(36)Ar( 295. 5),the ratio of ~(38)Ar/~(36)Ar is 0. 19 ~ 0. 23,with the average of 0. 183,which is close to the atmospheric value( 0. 188). These indicate that the ore-forming fluid has the characteristics of mixing both ends of the crust and mantle. The crustal fluid is composed of low temperature atmospheric water interacted with crustal rocks,and the fluid containing mantle-derived components is exsolved from granite. Combined with previous studies,it is believed that the deposit is closely related to Mesozoic large-scale asthenosphere upwelling,lithospheric thinning and crustal extension in South China,which provided favorable condition to lead the mantle-derived He/heat upward and then to melt the crustal materials and to form the oreforming granitic magmas.
引文
Allègre CJ,Staudacher T and Sarda P.1987.Rare gas systematics:Formation of the atmosphere,evolution and structure of the earth’s mantle.Earth and Planetary Science Letters,81(2-3):127-150
    Ballentine CJ,Burgess R and Marty B.2002.Tracing fluid origin,transport and interaction in the crust.Reviews in Mineralogy and Geochemistry,47(1):539-614
    Burnard PG,Hu R,Turner G and Bi XW.1999.Mantle,crustal and atmospheric noble gases in Ailaoshan gold deposits,Yunnan Province,China.Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta,63(10):1595-1604
    Burnard PG and Polya DA.2004.Importance of mantle derived fluids during granite associated hydrothermal circulation:He and Ar isotopes of ore minerals from Panasqueira.Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta,68(7):1607-1615
    Chen ZH,Wang DH,Qu WJ,Chen YC,Wang PA,Xu JX,Zhang JJand Xu ML.2006.Geological characteristics and mineralization age of the Taoxikeng tungsten deposit in Chongyi County,southern Jiangxi Province,China.Geological Bulletin of China,25(4):496-501(in Chinese with English abstract)
    Chi GX and Lai JQ.2009.Roles of fluid inclusions in study of mineral deposits.Mineral Deposits,28(6):850-855(in Chinese with English abstract)
    Craig H and Lupton JE.1976.Primordial neon,helium,and hydrogen in oceanic basalts.Earth and Planetary Science Letters,31(3):369-385
    Elliot T,Ballentine CJ,O’Nions RK and Ricchiuto T.1993.Carbon,helium,neon and argon isotopes in a Po Basin(Northern Italy)natural gas field.Chemical Geology,106(3-4):429-440
    Feng CY,Feng YD,Xu JX,Zeng ZL,She HQ,Zhang DQ,Qu WJ and Du AD.2007.Isotope chronological evidence for Upper Jurassic petrogenesis and mineralization of altered granite-type tungsten deposits in the Zhangtiantang area,southern Jiangxi.Geology in China,34(4):642-650(in Chinese with English abstract)
    Graham DW.2002.Noble gas isotope geochemistry of mid-ocean ridge and ocean island basalts:Characterization of mantle source reservoirs.Reviews in Mineralogy and Geochemistry,47(1):247-317
    Graupner T,Kempe U,Dombon E,Patzold O,Leeder O and Spooner ETC.1999.Fluid regime and ore formation in the tungsten(-yttrium)deposits of Kyzyltau(Mongolian Altai):Evidence for fluid variability in tungsten-tin ore systems.Chemical Geology,154(1-4):21-58
    Graupner T,Bray CJ,Spooner ETC and Herzig PM.2001.Analysis of fluid inclusions in seafloor hydrothermal precipitates:Testing and application of an integrated GC/IC technique.Chemical Geology,177(3-4):443-470
    Guo CL,Wang DH,Chen YC,Wang YB,Chen ZH and Liu SB.2007.Precise zircon SHRIMP U-Pb and quartz vein Rb-Sr dating of Mesozoic Taoxikeng tungsten polymetallic deposit in southern Jiangxi.Mineral deposits,26(4):432-442(in Chinese with English abstract)
    Guo CL,Lin ZY,Wang DH,Chen W,Zhang Y,Feng CY,Chen ZH,Zeng ZL and Cai RQ.2008.Petrologic characteristics of the granites and greisens and muscovite40Ar/39Ar dating in the Taoxikeng tungsten polymetallic deposit,southern Jiangxi Province.Acta Geologica Sinica,82(9):1274-1284(in Chinese with English abstract)
    Guo CL,Mao JW,Bierlein F,Chen ZH,Chen YC,Li CB and Zeng ZL.2011.Shrimp U-Pb(zircon),Ar-Ar(muscovite)and Re-Os(molybdenite)isotopic dating of the Taoxikeng tungsten deposit,South China Block.Ore Geology Reviews,43(1):26-39
    Hu RZ,Burnard PG,Turner G and Bi XW.1998.Helium and Argon isotope systematics in fluid inclusions of Machangqing copper deposit in West Yunnan Province,China.Chemical Geology,146(1-2):55-63
    Hu RZ,Bi XW,Turner G and Burnard PG.1999.He and Ar isotopic geochemistry of gold ore-forming fluids in the Ailaoshan gold mineralization belt.Science in China(Series D),29(4):321-330(in Chinese)
    Hu RZ,Burnard PG,Bi XW,Zhou MF,Pen JT,Su WC and Wu KX.2004.Helium and argon isotope geochemistry of alkaline intrusionassociated gold and copper deposits along the Red River-Jinshajiang fault belt,SW China.Chemical Geology,203(3-4):305-317
    Hu RZ,Burnard PG,Bi XW,Zhou MF,Peng JT,Su WC and Zhao JH.2009.Mantle-derived gaseous components in ore-forming fluids of the Xiangshan uranium deposit,Jiangxi Province,China:Evidence from He,Ar and C isotopes.Chemical Geology,266(1-2):86-95
    Hu RZ and Zhou MF.2012.Multiple Mesozoic mineralization events in South China:An introduction to the thematic issue.Mineralium Deposita,47(6):579-588
    Hu RZ,Bi XW,Jiang GH,Chen HW,Peng JT,Qi YQ,Wu LY and Wei WF.2012.Mantle-derived noble gases in ore-forming fluids of the granite-related Yaogangxian tungsten deposit,southeastern China.Mineralium Deposita,47(6):623-632
    Hu RZ,Mao JW,Hua RM and Fan WM.2015.Intra-Continental Mineralization of South China Craton.Beijing:Science Press,1-903(in Chinese)
    Jean-Baptiste P and Fouquet Y.1996.Abundance and isotopic composition of helium in hydrothermal sulfides from the East Pacific Rise at 13°N.Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta,60(1):87-93
    Kendrick MA,Burgess R,Pattrick RAD and Turner G.2001.Fluid inclusion noble gas and Halogen evidence on the origin of Cuporphyry mineralizing fluids.Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta,65(16):2651-2668
    Li ZL,Hu RZ,Yang JS,Peng JT,Li XM and Bi XW.2007.He,Pb and S isotopic constraints on the relationship between the A-type Qitianling granite and the Furong tin deposit,Hunan Province,China.Lithos,97(1-2):161-173
    Lippolt HJ and Weigel E.1988.4He diffusion in40Ar-retentive minerals.Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta,52(6):1449-1458
    Liu YM,Wang CL,Xue YZ,Lu HZ,Kang WQ and Zeng T.1998.Metallogenic conditions and metallogenic models of Shizhuyuan ultralarge tungsten polymetallic deposit.Science in China(Series D),28(Suppl.):49-56(in Chinese)
    Lu HZ,Fang HR,Nie P,Ou GX,Shen K and Zhang WH.2004.Fluid Inclusion.Beijing:Science Press,1-487(in Chinese)
    Ma TQ,Wu GY,Jia BH,Bai DY,Wang XH and Chen BH.2005.Middle-Late Jurassic granite magma-mixing in the middle segment of the Nanling Mountains,South China:Evidence from mafic microgranular enclaves.Geological Bulletin of China,24(6):506-512(in Chinese with English abstract)
    Mao JW,Xie GQ,Li XF,Zhang CQ and Mei YX.2004.Mesozoic large scale mineralization and multiple lithospheric extension in South China.Earth Science Frontiers,11(1):45-55(in Chinese with English abstract)
    Mao JW,Cheng YB,Chen MH and Pirajno F.2013.Major types and time-space distribution of Mesozoic ore deposits in South China and their geodynamic settings.Mineralium Deposita,48(3):267-294
    Paradis S,Chi G and Lavoie D.2004.Fluid inclusion and isotope evidence for the origin of the Upton Ba-Zn-Pb deposit,Quebec Appalachians,Canada.Economic Geology,99(4):807-817
    Podosek FA,Bernatowicz TJ and Kramer FE.1981.Adsorption of xenon and krypton on shales.Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta,45(12):2401-2415
    Roedder E.1984.Fluid inclusions.Reviews in Mineralogy and Geochemistry,12:644
    Song SQ,Hu RZ,Bi XW,Wei WF and Shi SH.2009.Hydrogen,oxygen and sulfur isotope geochemical characteristics of Taoxikeng tungsten deposit in Chongyi County,southern Jiangxi Province.Acta Mineralogica Sinica,(Suppl.):328(in Chinese)
    Song SQ,Hu RZ,Bi XW,Wei WF and Shi SH.2011a.Fluid inclusion geochemistry of the Taoxikeng tungsten deposit in southern Jiangxi Province,China.Geochimica,40(3):237-248(in Chinese with English abstract)
    Song SQ,Hu RZ,Bi XW,Wei WF and Shi SH.2011b.Hydrogen,oxygen and sulfur isotope geochemical characteristics of Taoxikeng tungsten deposit in Chongyi County,southern Jiangxi Province.Mineral Deposits,30(1):1-10(in Chinese with English abstract)
    Stuart FM,Burnard PG,Taylor RP and Turner G.1995.Resolving mantle and crustal contributions to ancient hydrothermal fluids:HeAr isotopes in fluid inclusions from Dae Hwa W-Mo mineralisation,South Korea.Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta,59(22):4663-4673
    Sun T and Zhou XM.2002.Late Mesozoic extension in Southeast China:Petrologic symbols.Journal of Nanjing University(Natural Science),38(6):737-746(in Chinese with English abstract)
    Torgersen T and Jenkins WJ.1982.Helium isotopes in geothermal systems:Iceland,the geysers,Raft River and steamboat springs.Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta,46(5):739-748
    Torgersen T,Kennedy BM,Hiyagon H,Chiou KY,Reynolds JH and Clarke WB.1989.Argon accumulation and the crustal degassing flux of40Ar in the Great Artesian basin,Australia.Earth and Planetary Science Letters,92(1):43-56
    Trull T,Kurz MD and Jenkins WI.1991.Diffusion of cosmogenic3He in olivine and quartz:Implications for surface exposure dating.Earth and Planetary Science Letters,103(1-4):241-256
    Tu GC.1998.The unique nature in ore composition,geological background and metallogenic mechanism of non-conventional superlarge ore deposits:A preliminary discussion.Science in China(Series D),41(Suppl.):1-6
    Turner G,Burnard P,Ford JL,Gilmour JD,Lyon IC and Stuart FM.1993.Tracing fluid sources and interactions.Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London Series A:Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences,344(1670):127-140
    Wang XD,Ni P,Jiang SY,Zhao KD and Wang TG.2010.Origin of oreforming fluid in the Piaotang tungsten deposit in Jiangxi Province:Evidence from Helium and argon isotopes.Chinese Science Bulletin,55(7):628-634
    Wei SL,Jia BH and Zeng QW.2006.Metallogenic mechanism of tungsten deposit in Nanling area.Resources Survey&Environment,27(2):103-109(in Chinese with English abstract)
    Wilkinson JJ.2001.Fluid inclusions in hydrothermal ore deposits.Lithos,55(1-4):229-272
    Wu LY,Hu RZ,Peng JT,Bi XW,Jiang GH,Chen HW,Wang QY and Liu YY.2011.He and Ar isotopic compositions and genetic implications for the giant Shizhuyuan W-Sn-Bi-Mo deposit,Hunan Province,South China.International Geology Review,53(5-6):677-690
    Wu YB and Zheng YF.2013.Tectonic evolution of a composite collision orogen:An overview on the Qinling-Tongbai-Hong’an-Dabie-Sulu orogenic belt in central China.Gondwana Research,23(4):1402-1428
    Wu ZJ,Xu ML,Zhao L,Luo XH and Wu ST.2009.The structural orecontrolled mechanism of the large-scaled Taoxikeng tungsten ore.China Tungsten Industry,24(1):16-20,39(in Chinese with English abstract)
    Xi BB,Zhang DH,Zhou LM,Zhang WH and Wang C.2008.Characteristics of ore-forming fluid evolution in Dajishan tungsten deposit,Quannan County,Jiangxi.Acta Geologica Sinica,82(7):956-966(in Chinese with English abstract)
    Xie GQ,Mao JW,Hu RZ,Li RL and Cao JJ.2005.Discussion on some problems of Mesozoic and Cenozoic geodynamics of Southeast China.Geological Review,51(6):613-620(in Chinese with English abstract)
    Xu ML,Feng WD,Zhang FR,Li JD and Luo XH.2006.Metallogenicy characteristics of Taoxikeng wolfram deposit,Chongyi.Resources Survey&Environment,27(2):159-163(in Chinese with English abstract)
    Xu XS,Dong CW,Li WX and Zhou XM.1999.Late Mesozoic intrusive complexes in the coastal area of Fujian,SE China:The significance of the gabbro-diorite-granite association.Lithos,46(2):299-315
    Yang F,Xiao RG,Bai FJ and Liang T.2014.REE geochemistry of the Taoxikeng tungsten deposit in Ganzhou,Jiangxi Province.Geology and Exploration,49(6):1139-1152(in Chinese with English abstract)
    Yu JH,Zhou XM,O’Reilly YS,Zhao L,Griffin WL,Wang RC,Wang LJ and Chen XM.2005.Formation history and protolith characteristics of granulite facies metamorphic rock in Central Cathaysia deduced from U-Pb and Lu-Hf isotopic studies of single zircon grains.Chinese Science Bulletin,50(18):2080-2089
    Yuan SD,Peng JT,Hu RZ,Li HM,Shen NP and Zhang DL.2008.Aprecise U-Pb age on cassiterite from the Xianghualing tinpolymetallic deposit(Hunan,South China).Mineralium Deposita,43(4):375-382
    Yuan SD,Peng JT,Hao S,Li HM,Geng JZ and Zhang DL.2011.In situ LA-MC-ICP-MS and ID-TIMS U-Pb geochronology of cassiterite in the giant Furong tin deposit,Hunan Province,South China:New constraints on the timing of tin-polymetallic mineralization.Ore Geology Reviews,43(1):235-242
    Yuan SD,Mao JW,Cook NJ,Wang XD,Liu XF and Yuan YB.2015.A Late Cretaceous tin metallogenic event in Nanling W-Sn metallogenic province:Constraints from U-Pb,Ar-Ar geochronology at the Jiepailing Sn-Be-F deposit,Hunan,China.Ore Geology Reviews,65:283-293
    Zhang SB and Zheng YF.2013.Formation and evolution of Precambrian continental lithosphere in South China.Gondwana Research,23(4):1214-1260
    Zhang WL,Hua RM,Wang RC,Chen PR and Li HM.2006.New dating of the Dajishan granite and related tungsten mineralization in southern Jiangxi.Acta Geologica Sinica,80(7):956-962(in Chinese with English abstract)
    Zhao ZH,Bao ZW,Zhang BY and Xiong XL.2001.Crust-mantle interaction and its contribution to the Shizhuyuan superlarge tungsten polymetallic mineralization.Science in China(Series D),44(3):266-276
    Zou X.2006.The research on the geochemical characteristic and genesis of tungsten deposit in Taoxikeng,Jiangxi.Master Degree Thesis.Beijing:China University of Geosciences,1-60(in Chinese)
    陈郑辉,王登红,屈文俊,陈毓川,王平安,许建祥,张家菁,许敏林.2006.赣南崇义地区淘锡坑钨矿的地质特征与成矿时代.地质通报,25(4):496-501
    池国祥,赖健清.2009.流体包裹体在矿床研究中的作用.矿床地质,28(6):850-855
    丰成友,丰耀东,许建祥,曾载淋,佘宏全,张德全,屈文俊,杜安道.2007.赣南张天堂地区岩体型钨矿晚侏罗世成岩成矿的同位素年代学证据.中国地质,34(4):642-650
    郭春丽,王登红,陈毓川,王彦斌,陈郑辉,刘善宝.2007.赣南中生代淘锡坑钨矿区花岗岩锆石SHRIMP年龄及石英脉Rb-Sr年龄测定.矿床地质,26(4):432-442
    郭春丽,蔺志永,王登红,陈文,张彦,丰成友,陈郑辉,曾载淋,蔡汝青.2008.赣南淘锡坑钨多金属矿床花岗岩和云英岩岩石特征及云英岩中白云母40Ar/39Ar定年.地质学报,82(9):1274-1284
    胡瑞忠,毕献武,Turner G,Burnard P.1999.哀牢山金矿带金成矿流体He和Ar同位素地球化学.中国科学(D辑),29(4):321-330
    胡瑞忠,毛景文,华仁民,范蔚茗.2015.华南陆块陆内成矿作用.北京:科学出版社,1-903
    刘义茂,王昌烈,胥友志,卢焕章,康卫清,曾提.1998.柿竹园超大型钨多金属矿床的成矿条件与成矿模式.中国科学(D辑),28(增刊):49-56
    卢焕章,范宏瑞,倪培,欧光习,沈昆,张文淮.2004.流体包裹体.北京:科学出版社,1-487
    马铁球,伍光英,贾宝华,柏道远,王先辉,陈必河.2005.南岭中段郴州一带中、晚侏罗世花岗岩浆的混合作用---来自镁铁质微粒包体的证据.地质通报,24(6):506-512
    毛景文,谢桂青,李晓峰,张长青,梅燕雄.2004.华南地区中生代大规模成矿作用与岩石圈多阶段伸展.地学前缘,11(1):45-55
    宋生琼,胡瑞忠,毕献武,魏文凤,石少华.2009.赣南崇义地区淘锡坑钨矿氢、氧、硫同位素地球化学研究.矿物学报,(增刊):328
    宋生琼,胡瑞忠,毕献武,魏文凤,石少华.2011a.赣南淘锡坑钨矿床流体包裹体地球化学研究.地球化学,40(3):237-248
    宋生琼,胡瑞忠,毕献武,魏文凤,石少华.2011b.赣南崇义淘锡坑钨矿床氢、氧、硫同位素地球化学研究.矿床地质,30(1):1-10
    孙涛,周新民.2002.中国东南部晚中生代伸展应力体制的岩石学标志.南京大学学报(自然科学),38(6):737-746
    涂光炽.1998.试论非常规超大型矿床物质组成、地质背景、形成机制的某些独特性-初谈非常规超大型矿床.中国科学(D辑),28(增刊):1-6
    魏绍六,贾宝华,曾钦旺.2006.南岭地区钨矿成矿机理探讨.资源调查与环境,27(2):103-109
    吴至军,徐敏林,赵磊,罗仙华,邬思涛.2009.江西淘锡坑大型钨矿构造控矿机制探讨.中国钨业,24(1):16-20,39
    席斌斌,张德会,周利敏,张文淮,王成.2008.江西省全南县大吉山钨矿成矿流体演化特征.地质学报,82(7):956-966
    谢桂青,毛景文,胡瑞忠,李瑞玲,曹建劲.2005.中国东南部中-新生代地球动力学背景若干问题的探讨.地质论评,51(6):613-620
    徐敏林,冯卫东,张凤荣,李江东,罗仙华.2006.崇义淘锡坑钨矿成矿地质特征.资源调查与环境,27(2):159-163
    杨帆,肖荣阁,白凤军,梁涛.2014.江西赣州淘锡坑钨矿床稀土地球化学研究.地质与勘探,49(6):1139-1152
    张文兰,华仁民,王汝成,陈培荣,李惠民.2006.赣南大吉山花岗岩成岩与钨矿成矿年龄的研究.地质学报,80(7):956-962
    赵振华,包志伟,张伯友,熊小林.2000.柿竹园超大型钨多金属矿床形成的壳幔相互作用背景.中国科学(D辑),30(增刊):161-168
    邹欣.2006.江西淘锡坑钨矿地球化学特征及成因研究.硕士学位论文.北京:中国地质大学,1-60

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700