基于碳排放核算的中国区域旅游业生态效率测度及比较研究

详细信息    查看全文 | 推荐本文 |

英文篇名：Measuring of tourism eco-efficiency and its comparative research based on carbon emissions 作者：刘军 ; 问鼎 ; 童昀 ; 马勇 英文作者：LIU Jun;WEN Ding;TONG Yun;MA Yong;Tourism Development Institute of Hubei University;Business School of Hubei University;University of Chinese Academy of Sciences;Center for Tourism Development and Management Studies of Hubei; 关键词：旅游业生态效率 ; 碳排放 ; 旅游可持续 英文关键词：eco-efficiency;;carbon emission;;tourism sustainable development 中文刊名：STXB 英文刊名：Acta Ecologica Sinica 机构：湖北大学旅游发展研究院;湖北大学商学院;中国科学院大学;湖北旅游开发与管理研究中心; 出版日期：2018-12-21 16:37 出版单位：生态学报 年：2019 期：v.39 基金：国家社会科学基金项目(17CJY051);; 湖北省教育厅人文社科项目(17Q012) 语种：中文; 页：STXB201906012 页数：14 CN：06 ISSN：11-2031/Q 分类号：106-119

摘要

旅游业作为国民经济发展的战略性支柱产业在区域发展中具有重要作用。借鉴生态效率的基本思想,考虑区域能源消费结构差异,使用自下而上的方法将旅游交通、旅游住宿与游憩活动碳排放进行加总估算出2000—2013年中国旅游业碳排放量;接着运用单一比值法计算出2000—2013年中国及各地区旅游业生态效率值,利用变异系数、莫兰指数对测度结果进行分析并与可持续发展生态效率值进行比较。研究结果表明:(1)2000—2013年,中国旅游业碳排放量不断增加,从2000年的1202.71万t增加到2013年的4151.57万t。旅游业部门之间碳排放量差异较大,尤其是旅游交通部门占到旅游业碳排放量的90%左右;(2)得益于2000—2013年旅游业发展的促进政策,中国及各地区旅游业生态效率总体上呈现不断改善的趋势,中国旅游业生态效率由2000年0.1193 kgCO_2-e/$下降到0.0309 kgCO_2-e/$。(3)时间维度上,中国旅游业生态效率的区域不平衡问题仍然存在,相比于2000年旅游业生态效率变异系数0.7114,2013年的变异系数反而增加到0.7483;空间维度上,各地区旅游业生态效率聚集模式发生了明显变化,莫兰指数由0.3036减少到0.0278。(4)通过将测度结果进行比较,中国旅游业自2000年开始进入可持续发展阶段,中国旅游业的整体可持续水平要优于其他产业,各地区的旅游业在2010年全部进入可持续发展状态。最后,对结果进行了讨论并提出旅游业生态效率的优化应从旅游收入增加与旅游业减排两方面进行。
        Tourism is a strategic pillar industry for national economic development, which plays an important role in regional development. As an emerging field, tourism eco-efficiency has been an important tool to determine the sustainability of the tourism industry. On the basis of a literature review, large-scale studies measuring tourism eco-efficiency and exploring the results are limited. Limited research has focused on the regional differences of energy consumption when calculating tourism eco-efficiency. In this paper, the total tourism carbon emissions, including transportation, accommodation, and recreational activities in China from 2000 to 2013 were determined using the bottom-up method. In the calculation process, the differences of regional energy consumption structures were considered and eco-efficiency was determined. The tourism eco-efficiency of China and its regions were analyzed using the single ratio method with the calculated carbon emissions data. A coefficient of variation and Moran′s index were used to analyze the total Chinese and provincial eco-efficiency, which could also be compared with the eco-efficiency of global sustainable development. The results showed that:(1) Chinese tourism carbon emissions have increased substantially and its total emissions reached 41.51 million tons in 2013 from 12.02 million tons in 2000. Besides, tourism carbon emission is very different among tourism sectors; the largest source is transportation, which accounts for about 90% of the total;(2) benefiting from policies on the promotion of tourism development from central and local governments, tourism eco-efficiency in China and its regions have improved; the value decreased from 0.1193 kgCO_2-e/$ in 2000 to 0.0309 kgCO_2-e/$ in 2013;(3) over time, based on the coefficient of variation, there was an imbalance in Chinese tourism eco-efficiency, where has increased from 0.7114 in 2000 to 0.7483 in 2013. Regarding spatial variation, there was a remarkable change in cluster patterns of tourism eco-efficiency, where Moran′s index decreased from 0.3036 to 0.0287, which implied the spatial relations of eco-efficiency became weakened;(4) the sustainable development of the Chinese tourism industry has occurred since 2000, and was found to be superior to that of other industries. Moreover since 2010, the tourism industry in all regions of China has been in the sustainable development stage. Finally, the results suggested tourism eco-efficiency could be optimized by not only increasing tourism income, but also reducing tourism carbon emissions.

引文

[1] Schaltegger S,Sturm A.?kologische Rationalit?t.Die Unternehmung,1990,4(4):273- 290.
    [2] World Business Council for Sustainable Development.Eco-efficient:leadership for improved economic and environmental performance.Geneva:WBCSD,1995.
    [3] G?ssling S,Peeters P,Ceron J P,Dubois G,Patterson T,Richardson R B.The eco-efficiency of tourism.Ecological Economics,2005,54(4):417- 434.
    [4] Fernández-Viňé M B,Gómez-Navarro T,Capuz-Rizo S F.Eco-efficiency in the SMEs of Venezuela.Current status and future perspectives.Journal of Cleaner Production,2010,18(8):736- 746.
    [5] Zhang B,Bi J,Fan Z Y,Yuan Z W,Ge J J.Eco-efficiency analysis of industrial system in China:a data envelopment analysis approach.Ecological Economics,2008,68(1/2):306- 316.
    [6] Robaina-Alves M,Moutinho V,Macedo P.A new frontier approach to model the eco-efficiency in European countries.Journal of Cleaner Production,2015,103:562- 573.
    [7] 尹科,王如松,周传斌,梁菁.国内外生态效率核算方法及其应用研究述评.生态学报,2012,32(11):3595- 3605.
    [8] Hahn T,Figge F,Liesen A,Barkemeyer R.Opportunity cost based analysis of corporate eco-efficiency:a methodology and its application to the CO2-efficiency of German companies.Journal of Environmental Management,2010,91(10):1997- 2007.
    [9] 张晓娣.生态效率变动的产业及要素推动:基于投入产出和系统优化模型.自然资源学报,2015,30(5):748- 760.
    [10] 关伟,许淑婷.中国能源生态效率的空间格局与空间效应.地理学报,2015,70(6):980- 992.
    [11] 成金华,孙琼,郭明晶,徐文赟.中国生态效率的区域差异及动态演化研究.中国人口·资源与环境,2014,24(1):47- 54.
    [12] 刘军,马勇.旅游可持续发展的视角:旅游生态效率的一个综述.旅游学刊,2017,32(9):47- 56.
    [13] 李鹏,杨桂华,郑彪,张一群.基于温室气体排放的云南香格里拉旅游线路产品生态效率.生态学报,2008,28(5):2207- 2219.
    [14] Perch-Nielsen S,Sesartic A,Stucki M.The greenhouse gas intensity of the tourism sector:the case of Switzerland.Environmental Science & Policy,2010,13(2):131- 140.
    [15] Bruijn de K,Dirven R,Eijgelaar E,Peeters P,Nelemans R.The Carbon Footprint of Dutch Holidaymakers in 2011 and the Development Since 2002.Breda,Netherlands:NHTV Breda University for Applied Sciences,2013.
    [16] Qiu X P,Fang Y P,Yang X T,Zhu F B.Tourism eco-efficiency measurement,characteristics,and its influence factors in China.Sustainability,2017,9(9):1634.
    [17] Kytzia S,Walz A,Wegmann M.How can tourism use land more efficiently?A model-based approach to land-use efficiency for tourist destinations.Tourism Management,2011,32(3):629- 640.
    [18] 刘佳,陆菊.中国旅游产业生态效率时空分异格局及形成机理研究.中国海洋大学学报:社会科学版,2016,(1):50- 59.
    [19] Liu J,Zhang J F,Fu Z B.Tourism eco-efficiency of Chinese coastal cities–analysis based on the DEA-Tobit model.Ocean & Coastal Management,2017,148:164- 170.
    [20] 彭红松,章锦河,韩娅,汤国荣,张瑜.旅游地生态效率测度的SBM-DEA模型及实证分析.生态学报,2017,37(2):628- 638.
    [21] Kelly J,Haider W,Williams P W,Englund K.Stated preferences of tourists for eco-efficient destination planning options.Tourism Management,2007,28(2):337- 390.
    [22] Reilly J,Williams P,Haider W.Moving towards more eco-efficient tourist transportation to a resort destination:the case of Whistler,British Columbia.Research in Transportation Economics,2010,26(1):66- 73.
    [23] 姚治国.低碳旅游生态效率研究[D].天津:天津大学,2013.
    [24] 肖建红,于爱芬,王敏.旅游过程碳足迹评估——以舟山群岛为例.旅游科学,2011,25(4):58- 66.
    [25] 甄翌.基于温室气体排放的旅游目的地旅游生态效率研究——以张家界为例.安徽农业科学,2013,41(8):3485- 3487.
    [26] 蒋素梅,幸岭.旅游业生态效率研究——以昆明市为例.旅游研究,2014,6(2):14- 19.
    [27] 石培华,吴普.中国旅游业能源消耗与CO2排放量的初步估算.地理学报,2011,66(2):235- 243.
    [28] 袁宇杰.中国旅游间接能源消耗与碳排放的核算.旅游学刊,2013,28(10):81- 88.
    [29] 肖潇,张捷,卢俊宇,钟士恩,尹立杰.旅游交通碳排放的空间结构与情景分析.生态学报,2012,32(23):7540- 7548.
    [30] 姚治国,陈田.旅游生态效率模型及其实证研究.中国人口·资源与环境,2015,25(11):113- 120.
    [31] 岳婷,龙如银.中国省域生活能源碳排放空间计量分析.北京理工大学学报:社会科学版,2014,16(2):40- 46.
    [32] Li G D,Fang C L.Analyzing the multi-mechanism of regional inequality in China.The Annals of Regional Science,2014,52(1):155- 182.
    [33] Huppes G,Ishikawa M.Eco-efficiency and its terminology.Journal of Industrial Ecology,2005,9(4):43- 46.
    [34] 魏艳旭,孙根年,马丽君,李静.中国旅游交通碳排放及地区差异的初步估算.陕西师范大学学报:自然科学版,2012,40(2):76- 84.
    [35] Carlsson-Kanyama A,Lindén A.Travel patterns and environmental effects now and in the future:implications of differences in energy consumption among socio-economic groups.Ecological Economics,1999,30(3):405- 417.
    [36] Becken S,Frampton C,Simmons D.Energy consumption patterns in the accommodation sector—the New Zealand case[J].Ecological Economics,2001,39(3):371- 386.
    [37] 邢丽涛.倡导绿色旅游消费发挥无烟产业优势.中国旅游报,2017-01- 19(01).
    [38] 唐晓云.中国旅游发展政策的历史演进(1949—2013)——一个量化研究的视角.旅游学刊,2014,29(8):15- 27.
    本研究数据中尚未统计中国港澳台和西藏的数据。