社会-生态系统恢复力研究进展——基于CiteSpace的文献计量分析
|
摘要
社会-生态系统恢复力为深化人类与自然的复杂相互作用过程与机理研究提供了新的视角,并成为推动跨学科整合与全球可持续发展的重要工具。运用CiteSpace文献计量方法,以社会-生态系统恢复力研究文献为对象,通过对关键词、作者、研究机构与引证文献等要素的分析,得出了国外社会-生态系统恢复力研究的总体特征,并从概念内涵、评估量化、体制转换与适应性管理4个方面系统总结了该领域主要研究内容及其进展动态,结合我国研究现状对未来研究提出展望。研究发现:社会-生态系统恢复力相关文章数量呈快速上升趋势,主要集中在生态环境与地理学领域;斯德哥尔摩大学的Folke是该领域的代表性学者;社会-生态系统恢复力研究呈现多元分散特征,理论分析、实证方法与实践层面的适应性管理是该领域主要的研究热点;尺度问题、社会-生态系统整合、恢复力量化评估以及体制转换与恢复力变化关系是该领域未来研究需要进一步强化与深化的内容。
引文
[1] 傅伯杰.地理学:从知识、科学到决策.地理学报,2017,72(11):1923- 1932.
[2] 陆大道,郭来喜.地理学的研究核心——人地关系地域系统——论吴传钧院士的地理学思想与学术贡献.地理学报,1998,53(2):97- 105
[3] 美国国家科学院研究理事会.理解正在变化的星球:地理科学的战略方向.刘毅,刘卫东,译.北京:科学出版社,2011.
[4] 樊杰.人地系统可持续过程、格局的前沿探索.地理学报,2014,69(8):1060- 1068.
[5] Walker B,Holling C S,Carpenter S R,Kinzig A.Resilience,adaptability and transformability in social-ecological systems.Ecology and Society,2004,9(2):5.
[6] Kates R W,Clark W C,Corell R,Hall J M,Jaeger C C,Lowe I,McCarthy J J,Schellnhuber H J,Bolin B,Dickson N M,Faucheux S,Gallopin G C,Grübler A,Huntley B,J?ger J,Jodha N S,Kasperson R E,Mabogunje A,Matson P,Mooney H,Moore III B,O′Riordan T,Svedlin U.Environment and development:sustainability science.Science,2001,292(5517):641- 642.
[7] Angeler D G,Allen C R.Quantifying resilience.Journal of Applied Ecology,2016,53(3):617- 624.
[8] Pope K L,Allen C R,Angeler D G.Fishing for resilience.Transactions of the American Fisheries Society,2014,143(2):467- 478.
[9] Walker B H,Salt D.Resilience Thinking:Sustaining Ecosystems and People in A Changing World.Washington,D.C.:Island Press,2006.
[10] 王云,马丽,刘毅.城镇化研究进展与趋势——基于CiteSpace和HistCite的图谱量化分析.地理科学进展,2018,37(2):239- 254.
[11] 李杰,陈超美.CiteSpace:科技文本挖掘及可视化.北京:首都经济贸易大学出版社,2016.
[12] Holling C S.Resilience and stability of ecological systems.Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics,1973,4:1- 23.
[13] Folke C.Resilience (Republished).Ecology and Society,2016,21(4):44.
[14] 黄晓军,黄馨.弹性城市及其规划框架初探.城市规划,2015,39(2):50- 56.
[15] 徐江,邵亦文.韧性城市:应对城市危机的新思路.国际城市规划,2015,30(2):1- 3.
[16] 闫海明,战金艳,张韬.生态系统恢复力研究进展综述.地理科学进展,2012,31(3):303- 314.
[17] 汪辉,徐蕴雪,卢思琪,任懿璐,象伟宁.恢复力、弹性或韧性?——社会—生态系统及其相关研究领域中“Resilience”一词翻译之辨析.国际城市规划,2017,32(4):29- 39.
[18] Carpenter S R,Arrow K J,Barrett S,Biggs R,Brock W A,Crépin A S,Engstr?m G,Folke C,Hughes T P,Kautsky N,Li C A,McCarney G,Meng K,M?ler K G,Polasky S,Scheffer M,Shogren J,Sterner T,Vincent J R,Walker B,Xepapadeas A,de Zeeuw A.General resilience to cope with extreme events.Sustainability,2012,4(12):3248- 3259.
[19] Speranza C I,Wiesmann U,Rist S.An indicator framework for assessing livelihood resilience in the context of social-ecological dynamics.Global Environmental Change,2014,28(1):109- 119.
[20] Resilience Alliance.Assessing Resilience in Social-Ecological Systems:Workbook for Practitioners.Version 2.0,2010.
[21] Quinlan A E,Berbés-Blázquez M,Haider L J,Peterson G D.Measuring and assessing resilience:broadening understanding through multiple disciplinary perspectives.Journal of Applied Ecology,2016,53(3):677- 687.
[22] Bousquet F,Botta A,Alinovi L,Barreteau O,Bossio D,Brown K,Caron P,Cury P,D′Errico M,DeClerck F,Dessard H,Kautsky E E,Fabricius C,Folke C,Fortmann L,Hubert B,Magda D,Mathevet R,Norgaard R B,Quinlan A,Staver C.Resilience and development:mobilizing for transformation.Ecology and Society,2016,21(3):40.
[23] O′Connell D,Walker B,Abel N,Grigg N.The Resilience,Adaptation and Transformation Assessment Framework:from Theory to Application.CSIRO,Australia,2015.
[24] Carpenter S R,Westley F,Turner M G.Surrogates for resilience of social-ecological systems.Ecosystems,2005,8(8):941- 944.
[25] Biggs R,Carpenter S R,Brock W A.Turning back from the brink:detecting an impending regime shift in time to avert it.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America,2009,106(3):826- 831.
[26] Biggs R,Schlüter M,Schoon M L.Principles for Building Resilience:Sustaining Ecosystem Services in Social-Ecological Systems.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,2015.
[27] Perry R I,Masson D.An integrated analysis of the marine social-ecological system of the Strait of Georgia,Canada,over the past four decades,and development of a regime shift index.Progress in Oceanography,2013,115(4):14- 27.
[28] Liu Y B,Wu G P,Zhao X S.Recent declines in China′s largest freshwater lake:trend or regime shift?Environmental Research Letters,2013,8(1):014010.
[29] Yang Z,Zhou Y,Wenninger J,Uhlenbrook S.The causes of flow regime shifts in the semi-arid Hailiutu River,Northwest China.Hydrology and Earth System Sciences,2012,16(1):87- 103.
[30] Rodionov S N.A sequential algorithm for testing climate regime shifts.Geophysical Research Letters,2004,31(9):L09204.
[31] Filatova T,Polhill J G,van Ewijk S.Regime shifts in coupled socio-environmental systems:Review of modelling challenges and approaches.Environmental Modelling & Software,2016,75:333- 347.
[32] Johnny M T.A Regime Shift Analysis of Poverty Traps in Sub-Saharan Africa:Identifying Key Feedbacks and Leverage Points for Change.Uppsala Universitet,2012.
[33] L?fgren H,Robinson S.Spatial Networks in Multi-Region Computable General Equilibrium Models.Washington,D.C.:Trade and Macroeconomics Division,International Food Policy Research Institute,1999.
[34] Lade S J,Tavoni A,Levin S A,Schlüter M.Regime shifts in a social-ecological system.Theoretical Ecology,2013,6(3):359- 372.
[35] Gaucherel C,Théro H,Puiseux A,Bonhomme V.Understand ecosystem regime shifts by modelling ecosystem development using Boolean networks.Ecological Complexity,2017,31:104- 114.
[36] Chen N,Wang X P.Driver-system state interaction in regime shifts:a model study of desertification in drylands.Ecological Modelling,2016,339:1- 6.
[37] Rocha J C,Peterson G D,Biggs R.Regime shifts in the anthropocene:drivers,risks,and resilience.PLoS One,2015,10(8):e0134639.
[38] Sugiarto H S,Chung N N,Lai C H,Chew L Y.Socioecological regime shifts in the setting of complex social interactions.Physical Review E,2015,91(6):062804.
[39] Kinzig A P,Ryan P,Etienne M,Allison H,Elmqvist T,Walker B H.Resilience and regime shifts:assessing cascading effects.Ecology and Society,2006,11(1):20.
[40] Berkes F.Understanding uncertainty and reducing vulnerability:lessons from resilience thinking.Natural Hazards,2007,41(2):283- 295.
[41] Lebe L,Anderies J M,Campbell B,Folke C,Hatfield-Dodds S,Hughes T P,Wilson J.Governance and the capacity to manage resilience in regional social-ecological systems.Ecology and Society,2006,11(1):19.
[42] Folke C,Carpenter S,Elmqvist T,Gunderson L,Holling C S,Walker B.Resilience and sustainable development:building adaptive capacity in a world of transformations.AMBIO:A Journal of the Human Environment,2002,31(5):437- 440.
[43] Olsson P,Folke C,Berkes F.Adaptive comanagement for building resilience in social-ecological systems.Environmental Management,2004,34(1):75- 90.
[44] Armitage D R,Plummer R,Berkes F,Arthur R I,Charles A T,Davidson-Hunt I J,Diduck A P,Doubleday N C,Johnson D S,Marschke M,McConney P,Pinkerton E W,Wollenberg E K.Adaptive co-management for social-ecological complexity.Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment,2009,7(2):95- 102.
[45] Folke C,Hahn T,Olsson P,Norberg J.Adaptive governance of social-ecological systems.Annual Review of Environment and Resources,2005,30:441- 473.
[46] Gunderson L,Cosens B A,Chaffin B C,Tom Arnold C A,Fremier A K,Garmestani A S,Craig R K,Gosnell H,Birge H E,Allen C R,Benson M H,Morrison R R,Stone M C,Hamm JA,Nemec K,Schlager E,Llewellyn D.Regime shifts and panarchies in regional scale social-ecological water systems.Ecology and Society,2017,22(1):1- 31.
[47] 王俊,杨新军,刘文兆.半干旱区社会—生态系统干旱恢复力的定量化研究.地理科学进展,2010,29(11):1385- 1390.
[48] 葛怡,史培军,周忻,辜智慧,陈磊,钱新,刘婧,徐伟.水灾恢复力评估研究:以湖南省长沙市为例.北京师范大学学报:自然科学版,2011,47(2):197- 201.
[49] 战金艳,闫海明,邓祥征,张韬.森林生态系统恢复力评价——以江西省莲花县为例.自然资源学报,2012,27(8):1304- 1315.
[50] 李玉照,刘永,赵磊,邹锐,王翠榆,郭怀成.浅水湖泊生态系统稳态转换的阈值判定方法.生态学报,2013,33(11):3280- 3290.
[51] 李强.区域经济恢复力探究.中央财经大学学报,2014,(S1):45- 46.
[52] 杨新军,石育中,王子侨.道路建设对秦岭山区社会—生态系统的影响——一个社区恢复力的视角.地理学报,2015,70(8):1313- 1326.
[53] 陈佳,杨新军,尹莎.农户贫困恢复力测度、影响效应及对策研究——基于农户家庭结构的视角.中国人口·资源与环境,2016,26(1):150- 157.
[54] 于翠松.山西省水资源系统恢复力定量评价研究.水文,2008,(2):13- 17,66- 66.
[55] 刘焱序,王仰麟,彭建,魏海,宋治清,张小飞.耦合恢复力的林区土地生态适宜性评价——以吉林省汪清县为例.地理学报,2015,70(3):476- 487.
[56] 孙晶,王俊,杨新军.社会-生态系统恢复力研究综述.生态学报,2007,27(12):5371- 5381.
[57] 周晓芳.社会-生态系统恢复力的测量方法综述.生态学报,2017,37(12):4278- 4288.
[58] Walker B,Salt D.弹性思维:不断变化的世界中社会-生态系统的可持续性.彭少麟,陈宝明,赵琼,译.北京:高等教育出版社,2010.
[59] 王群,陆林,杨兴柱.千岛湖社会—生态系统恢复力测度与影响机理.地理学报,2015,70(5):779- 795.
[60] 陈娅玲,杨新军.西藏旅游社会—生态系统恢复力研究.西北大学学报:自然科学版,2012,42(5):827- 832.
[2] 陆大道,郭来喜.地理学的研究核心——人地关系地域系统——论吴传钧院士的地理学思想与学术贡献.地理学报,1998,53(2):97- 105
[3] 美国国家科学院研究理事会.理解正在变化的星球:地理科学的战略方向.刘毅,刘卫东,译.北京:科学出版社,2011.
[4] 樊杰.人地系统可持续过程、格局的前沿探索.地理学报,2014,69(8):1060- 1068.
[5] Walker B,Holling C S,Carpenter S R,Kinzig A.Resilience,adaptability and transformability in social-ecological systems.Ecology and Society,2004,9(2):5.
[6] Kates R W,Clark W C,Corell R,Hall J M,Jaeger C C,Lowe I,McCarthy J J,Schellnhuber H J,Bolin B,Dickson N M,Faucheux S,Gallopin G C,Grübler A,Huntley B,J?ger J,Jodha N S,Kasperson R E,Mabogunje A,Matson P,Mooney H,Moore III B,O′Riordan T,Svedlin U.Environment and development:sustainability science.Science,2001,292(5517):641- 642.
[7] Angeler D G,Allen C R.Quantifying resilience.Journal of Applied Ecology,2016,53(3):617- 624.
[8] Pope K L,Allen C R,Angeler D G.Fishing for resilience.Transactions of the American Fisheries Society,2014,143(2):467- 478.
[9] Walker B H,Salt D.Resilience Thinking:Sustaining Ecosystems and People in A Changing World.Washington,D.C.:Island Press,2006.
[10] 王云,马丽,刘毅.城镇化研究进展与趋势——基于CiteSpace和HistCite的图谱量化分析.地理科学进展,2018,37(2):239- 254.
[11] 李杰,陈超美.CiteSpace:科技文本挖掘及可视化.北京:首都经济贸易大学出版社,2016.
[12] Holling C S.Resilience and stability of ecological systems.Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics,1973,4:1- 23.
[13] Folke C.Resilience (Republished).Ecology and Society,2016,21(4):44.
[14] 黄晓军,黄馨.弹性城市及其规划框架初探.城市规划,2015,39(2):50- 56.
[15] 徐江,邵亦文.韧性城市:应对城市危机的新思路.国际城市规划,2015,30(2):1- 3.
[16] 闫海明,战金艳,张韬.生态系统恢复力研究进展综述.地理科学进展,2012,31(3):303- 314.
[17] 汪辉,徐蕴雪,卢思琪,任懿璐,象伟宁.恢复力、弹性或韧性?——社会—生态系统及其相关研究领域中“Resilience”一词翻译之辨析.国际城市规划,2017,32(4):29- 39.
[18] Carpenter S R,Arrow K J,Barrett S,Biggs R,Brock W A,Crépin A S,Engstr?m G,Folke C,Hughes T P,Kautsky N,Li C A,McCarney G,Meng K,M?ler K G,Polasky S,Scheffer M,Shogren J,Sterner T,Vincent J R,Walker B,Xepapadeas A,de Zeeuw A.General resilience to cope with extreme events.Sustainability,2012,4(12):3248- 3259.
[19] Speranza C I,Wiesmann U,Rist S.An indicator framework for assessing livelihood resilience in the context of social-ecological dynamics.Global Environmental Change,2014,28(1):109- 119.
[20] Resilience Alliance.Assessing Resilience in Social-Ecological Systems:Workbook for Practitioners.Version 2.0,2010.
[21] Quinlan A E,Berbés-Blázquez M,Haider L J,Peterson G D.Measuring and assessing resilience:broadening understanding through multiple disciplinary perspectives.Journal of Applied Ecology,2016,53(3):677- 687.
[22] Bousquet F,Botta A,Alinovi L,Barreteau O,Bossio D,Brown K,Caron P,Cury P,D′Errico M,DeClerck F,Dessard H,Kautsky E E,Fabricius C,Folke C,Fortmann L,Hubert B,Magda D,Mathevet R,Norgaard R B,Quinlan A,Staver C.Resilience and development:mobilizing for transformation.Ecology and Society,2016,21(3):40.
[23] O′Connell D,Walker B,Abel N,Grigg N.The Resilience,Adaptation and Transformation Assessment Framework:from Theory to Application.CSIRO,Australia,2015.
[24] Carpenter S R,Westley F,Turner M G.Surrogates for resilience of social-ecological systems.Ecosystems,2005,8(8):941- 944.
[25] Biggs R,Carpenter S R,Brock W A.Turning back from the brink:detecting an impending regime shift in time to avert it.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America,2009,106(3):826- 831.
[26] Biggs R,Schlüter M,Schoon M L.Principles for Building Resilience:Sustaining Ecosystem Services in Social-Ecological Systems.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,2015.
[27] Perry R I,Masson D.An integrated analysis of the marine social-ecological system of the Strait of Georgia,Canada,over the past four decades,and development of a regime shift index.Progress in Oceanography,2013,115(4):14- 27.
[28] Liu Y B,Wu G P,Zhao X S.Recent declines in China′s largest freshwater lake:trend or regime shift?Environmental Research Letters,2013,8(1):014010.
[29] Yang Z,Zhou Y,Wenninger J,Uhlenbrook S.The causes of flow regime shifts in the semi-arid Hailiutu River,Northwest China.Hydrology and Earth System Sciences,2012,16(1):87- 103.
[30] Rodionov S N.A sequential algorithm for testing climate regime shifts.Geophysical Research Letters,2004,31(9):L09204.
[31] Filatova T,Polhill J G,van Ewijk S.Regime shifts in coupled socio-environmental systems:Review of modelling challenges and approaches.Environmental Modelling & Software,2016,75:333- 347.
[32] Johnny M T.A Regime Shift Analysis of Poverty Traps in Sub-Saharan Africa:Identifying Key Feedbacks and Leverage Points for Change.Uppsala Universitet,2012.
[33] L?fgren H,Robinson S.Spatial Networks in Multi-Region Computable General Equilibrium Models.Washington,D.C.:Trade and Macroeconomics Division,International Food Policy Research Institute,1999.
[34] Lade S J,Tavoni A,Levin S A,Schlüter M.Regime shifts in a social-ecological system.Theoretical Ecology,2013,6(3):359- 372.
[35] Gaucherel C,Théro H,Puiseux A,Bonhomme V.Understand ecosystem regime shifts by modelling ecosystem development using Boolean networks.Ecological Complexity,2017,31:104- 114.
[36] Chen N,Wang X P.Driver-system state interaction in regime shifts:a model study of desertification in drylands.Ecological Modelling,2016,339:1- 6.
[37] Rocha J C,Peterson G D,Biggs R.Regime shifts in the anthropocene:drivers,risks,and resilience.PLoS One,2015,10(8):e0134639.
[38] Sugiarto H S,Chung N N,Lai C H,Chew L Y.Socioecological regime shifts in the setting of complex social interactions.Physical Review E,2015,91(6):062804.
[39] Kinzig A P,Ryan P,Etienne M,Allison H,Elmqvist T,Walker B H.Resilience and regime shifts:assessing cascading effects.Ecology and Society,2006,11(1):20.
[40] Berkes F.Understanding uncertainty and reducing vulnerability:lessons from resilience thinking.Natural Hazards,2007,41(2):283- 295.
[41] Lebe L,Anderies J M,Campbell B,Folke C,Hatfield-Dodds S,Hughes T P,Wilson J.Governance and the capacity to manage resilience in regional social-ecological systems.Ecology and Society,2006,11(1):19.
[42] Folke C,Carpenter S,Elmqvist T,Gunderson L,Holling C S,Walker B.Resilience and sustainable development:building adaptive capacity in a world of transformations.AMBIO:A Journal of the Human Environment,2002,31(5):437- 440.
[43] Olsson P,Folke C,Berkes F.Adaptive comanagement for building resilience in social-ecological systems.Environmental Management,2004,34(1):75- 90.
[44] Armitage D R,Plummer R,Berkes F,Arthur R I,Charles A T,Davidson-Hunt I J,Diduck A P,Doubleday N C,Johnson D S,Marschke M,McConney P,Pinkerton E W,Wollenberg E K.Adaptive co-management for social-ecological complexity.Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment,2009,7(2):95- 102.
[45] Folke C,Hahn T,Olsson P,Norberg J.Adaptive governance of social-ecological systems.Annual Review of Environment and Resources,2005,30:441- 473.
[46] Gunderson L,Cosens B A,Chaffin B C,Tom Arnold C A,Fremier A K,Garmestani A S,Craig R K,Gosnell H,Birge H E,Allen C R,Benson M H,Morrison R R,Stone M C,Hamm JA,Nemec K,Schlager E,Llewellyn D.Regime shifts and panarchies in regional scale social-ecological water systems.Ecology and Society,2017,22(1):1- 31.
[47] 王俊,杨新军,刘文兆.半干旱区社会—生态系统干旱恢复力的定量化研究.地理科学进展,2010,29(11):1385- 1390.
[48] 葛怡,史培军,周忻,辜智慧,陈磊,钱新,刘婧,徐伟.水灾恢复力评估研究:以湖南省长沙市为例.北京师范大学学报:自然科学版,2011,47(2):197- 201.
[49] 战金艳,闫海明,邓祥征,张韬.森林生态系统恢复力评价——以江西省莲花县为例.自然资源学报,2012,27(8):1304- 1315.
[50] 李玉照,刘永,赵磊,邹锐,王翠榆,郭怀成.浅水湖泊生态系统稳态转换的阈值判定方法.生态学报,2013,33(11):3280- 3290.
[51] 李强.区域经济恢复力探究.中央财经大学学报,2014,(S1):45- 46.
[52] 杨新军,石育中,王子侨.道路建设对秦岭山区社会—生态系统的影响——一个社区恢复力的视角.地理学报,2015,70(8):1313- 1326.
[53] 陈佳,杨新军,尹莎.农户贫困恢复力测度、影响效应及对策研究——基于农户家庭结构的视角.中国人口·资源与环境,2016,26(1):150- 157.
[54] 于翠松.山西省水资源系统恢复力定量评价研究.水文,2008,(2):13- 17,66- 66.
[55] 刘焱序,王仰麟,彭建,魏海,宋治清,张小飞.耦合恢复力的林区土地生态适宜性评价——以吉林省汪清县为例.地理学报,2015,70(3):476- 487.
[56] 孙晶,王俊,杨新军.社会-生态系统恢复力研究综述.生态学报,2007,27(12):5371- 5381.
[57] 周晓芳.社会-生态系统恢复力的测量方法综述.生态学报,2017,37(12):4278- 4288.
[58] Walker B,Salt D.弹性思维:不断变化的世界中社会-生态系统的可持续性.彭少麟,陈宝明,赵琼,译.北京:高等教育出版社,2010.
[59] 王群,陆林,杨兴柱.千岛湖社会—生态系统恢复力测度与影响机理.地理学报,2015,70(5):779- 795.
[60] 陈娅玲,杨新军.西藏旅游社会—生态系统恢复力研究.西北大学学报:自然科学版,2012,42(5):827- 832.