用户名: 密码: 验证码:
知识产权保护与发展中国家的经济增长
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
内生增长理论认为,知识的积累是经济增长的重要源泉。知识的公共物品性质使得知识产权成为知识经济时代一种不可或缺的重要资源,知识产权保护对于一国的技术创新、国际技术转移与经济增长具有重要意义。
     发展中国家的知识产权保护能否促进其技术进步与经济增长一直都是国际经济理论学界和国际政策谈判领域争论的焦点。作为WTO三大支柱之一的《与贸易有关的知识产权》(TRIPS)协定的实施对发展中国家经济增长的影响,理论界一直存在较大的争议。TRIPS协定下发展中国家的知识产权保护政策,已成为能否克服技术困境、促进经济长期增长的关键因素。中国是一个区域经济发展不平衡的后发大国,研究TRIPS协定下知识产权保护与区域经济增长之间的关系,对于制定合理可行的知识产权保护策略,更好地促进中国区域经济协调增长,无疑也具有重大实践意义。
     以往研究主要以知识产权保护制度比较完善的发达国家为研究对象,从发展中国家角度考察知识产权保护对经济增长影响的研究甚少。本文基于发展中国家技术供给的视角,在内生增长理论和南北贸易的分析框架下考察了知识产权保护对发展中国家技术供给与经济增长的效应,并对知识产权保护影响发展中国家经济增长的作用机制展开了深入研究。知识产权保护通过影响技术供给而作用于发展中国家的经济增长,通过理论研究和实证分析,本文得到的基本结论是:
     第一,知识产权保护对发展中国家进口贸易和FDI的影响呈现显著的行业特征,其效应受到经济发展水平、模仿能力、市场规模等东道国经济特征的制约;知识产权保护对中国进口贸易和FDI的影响也存在显著的行业特征,其效应依赖于不同行业的模仿能力,而这一点以往的研究并没有考虑到。
     第二,与以往研究不同,本文研究发现知识产权保护与发展中国家经济增长之间呈现非线性关系的特征,知识产权保护对经济增长的影响呈现显著的门限效应特征,其效应依赖于经济发展水平。经济发展水平位于门限水平以上,知识产权保护对经济增长的影响显著为正;经济发展水平位于门限水平以下,知识产权保护对经济增长的影响不显著。
     第三,知识产权保护对中国区域经济增长的影响呈现非线性关系的特征,知识产权保护对区域经济增长的影响存在显著的门限效应特征,其效应依赖于地区经济发展水平。当经济发展水平位于门限水平以上,知识产权保护对经济增长的影响显著为正;经济发展水平位于门限水平以下,知识产权保护对经济增长的影响不显著。而这些研究结论与国内其他学者的研究显著不同。
     本文的结论对于发展中国家具有很强的政策性启示。发展中国家对于知识产权保护制度的安排要围绕本国经济发展水平制定相应的战略性知识产权保护政策,在经济发展水平的不同阶段,采取不同的知识产权保护战略,知识产权保护水平经历由弱到强的变化趋势。中国知识产权保护强度要因地制宜,因经济发展水平而异,因行业而异,知识产权保护政策应具备明显的区域性、阶段性和行业性。技术水平较低的地区或产业,应实行宽松的知识产权保护政策,而技术水平相对较高的地区或产业,应实行严格的知识产权保护政策。
Endogenous growth theory claims that knowledge accumulation is the crucial source for economic growth. Public goods characteristics of knowledge have made intellectual property rights an even more important resource during the times of knowledge-based economy, and efficient intellectual property rights protection (IPP) is of great importance to technological innovation, international technology transfer and economic growth.
     The effect of IPP on technological progress and economic growth in less developed countries (LDCs) is a topic for dispute in fields for international economics and international policy negotiation. The effect of implement of agreement on trade-related intellectual property rights (TRIPS) as one of three mainstays of WTO on economic growth in LDCs has been debated intensively in the theoretical and practical fields. Intellectual property rights policy in LDCs under TRIPS has been a critical factor for overcoming the dilemma in technology-choices and promoting long-run economic growth. China is a developing country with unbalanced regional economies, the relationship between IPP and economic growth in different regions is undoubtedly of great practical importance to formulate appropriate and flexible strategies for IPP and to promote harmonious regional growth in China.
     While most previous studies focused on developed countries (DCs) with more perfect institutional arrangement of IPP, very few studies investigated the effect of IPP on economic growth in LDCs. Viewed from technology supply in LDCs, this dissertation investigates the effect of IPP on technology supply and economic growth in LDCs under the analytical frameworks of endogenous growth theory and north-south trade, and explores the channels through which IPP exerts impacts on economic growth in LDCs. It is shown that technology supply, as determined by international trade, FDI and technology licensing, plays a major role in promoting economic growth in LDCs. Three interesting findings are noted as follows:
     First, the effect of IPP on import trade and FDI in LDCs has displayed significant industry-specific characteristics. It is also heavily dependent on country-specific characteristics of host country such as economic development stages, imitative ability and market size etc. The effect of IPP on import trade and FDI in China has also demonstrated significant industry-specific characteristics and is also related to imitative ability of different industries. Similar empirical evidences have not appeared in the previous studies.
     Second, unlike previous studies, this dissertation has proved theoretically and empirically a nonlinear relationship between IPP and economic growth in LDCs; The effect of IPP on economic growth in LDCs depends on economic development stages and has displayed a significant threshold effect. While IPP will exert a positive impact economic growth above the threshold, no statistically significant relation is found between IPP and economic growth below the threshold.
     Third, the relationship between IPP and economic growth in China is also found nonlinear; Both regional-specific characteristics and the threshold effect exist in the cross-section investigation using cross-province data. The results differ remarkably from the previous studies.
     These findings have important implications for policy suggestions. Institutional arrangement of and policy design for intellectual property rights protection in developing countries should evolve with domestic economic development stages. The IPP control should intensify with economic growth and development process. It seems meaningful to suggest that in China a more flexible policy toward IPP be followed in less technology-intensive regions and industries.
引文
①王景、朱利.知识产权对微观经济的作用机理研究[J].昆明理工大学学报(理工版),2004 (6),pp119-122.
    ②郑成思.知识产权法教程[M].北京:法律出版社,1993.
    ③刘春田.知识产权法[M].北京:中国人民大学出版社,2000.
    ④周寄中.科学技术创新管理[M].北京:经济科学出版社,2002.
    ①本文实证研究中采用的发展中国家知识产权保护强度指数的测算主要是以专利法为基础的;中国年度和地区知识产权保护立法强度的测算主要以专利法为基础,同时考虑知识产权保护的执法强度,并测算出了中国实际的知识产权保护强度。
    ②UNCTAD Secretarial.Compilation of Legal Material.Dealing With Transfer & Development of Technology.UNCTAD Publication,1982。
    ③唐晓云.国际技术转移的非线性分析与经济增长[M].上海:复旦大学出版社,2005。
    ①Maskus,K.E.,2000,Intellectual Property Rights in the Global Economy,Institute for International Economics Washington.D.C.
    ①Falvey,R.E.,N.Foster,and D.Greenway.,2006,“Trade,Imitative Ability and Intellectual Property Rights.”Working Papers,August.
    ①Arora,Ashish and Marco Ceccagnoli.,2004,“Patent Protection,Complementary Assets and Firms' Incentives for Technology Licensing.”Working Paper,http://mgt.gatech.edu/news_room/news/2004/reer/files/ceccagnoli.pdf.
    ①Anand,B.N.and Khanna,T.,2000,“The Structure of Licensing Contracts.” Journal of Industrial Economics,48,pp103-135.
    ②Hahn,Robert W,2003,“The Economics of Patent Protection:Policy Implications From The Literature,http://www.vwl.uni.mannheim.de/.
    ①Keller,W.,2004,“International Technology Diffusion.”Journal of Economic Literature,9,pp752-782.
    ②赵江林.东亚技术供给、知识产权保护与经济增长[M].北京:经济科学出版社,2007.
    ③Grossman,G.M.and E.Helpman.1991,Innovation and Growth in the Global Economy,Cambridge,MIT Press.
    ④Quah,D.and J.E.Rauch,1990,Openness and the Rate of Economic Growth,Working Paper,University of Califonia.
    ①殷德生.报酬递增、动态比较优势与产业内贸易[M].北京:经济科学出版社,2006。
    ①Coe,D.and E,Helpman.,1995,“International R&D Spillovers.” European Economic Review,39,pp859-887.Keller,W.,2004,“International Technology Diffusion.”Journal of Economic Literature,9,pp752-782.Eaton,J and S,Kortum.,1996,“Trade in Ideas:Patenting and Productivity in the OECD.” Journal of International Economics,40,pp 251-278.
    ②Zhang,Xiaoming and Heng-fu,Zou.,1995,“Foreign Technology Imports and Economic Growth in Developing Countries,The World Bank Policy Working Paper No.1412.
    ①Oda,S.H.,1999,“Trade in Capital Goods Generated by International Diffusion of Technology.”Structural Change and Economic Dynamics,10,pp195-208.
    ②Navaretti,Giorio Barba and Isidro Soloag.,2001,“Weightless Machines and Costless Knowledge:An Empirical Analysis of Trade and Technology Diffusion,The World Bank Policy Working Paper No.2598.
    ③Erk,Nejat,Sanly Ate and Ysmail Tuncer.,2000,“Test of Endogenous Growth Theory via Technological Spillover Effects of International Capital Good Flows.” ERC/METU International Conference in Economics Ⅳ,Ankara-TURKEY,13-16.
    ④Dunning,J.H.,1993,Multinational Enterprises and the Global Economy,Addison Wesley Publishers Ltd.,England.Caves,Richard E.,1974,“Multinational Firms,Competition and Productivity in Host-Country Markets.” Economica,41 (62),ppl76-193.
    ①Markusen,J.R.and A.J.Venables.,1999,“Foreign Direct Investment as a Catalyst for Industrial Development.”European Economic Review,43,pp335-356.
    ②Ethier,W.J.and J.R.Markusen.,1996,“Multinational Firms,Technology Diffusion and Trade.” Journal of International Economics,41,pp1-28.
    ①Aitken,B.and A.Harrison.,1999,“Do Domestic Firms Benefit From Foreign Direct Investment? Evidence from Venezuela.”American Economic Review,89,pp605-618.Djankov,Simeon and Bernard Hoekman.,2000,“Foreign Investment and Productivity Growth in Czech Enterprises.” World Bank Economic Review,14(1),pp49-64.
    ①Sherwood,Robert M.,1997,“Intellectual Property Systems and Investment Stimulation:The Ratings of Systems in Eighteen Developing Countries.”IDEA:Journal of Law and Technology,37 (2),pp261-370.
    ①张红霞.TRIPS协定对发展中国家经济发展的影响分析,亚太经济,2006年第6期,第114页。
    ①公衍照,李平.知识产品与国际直接投资、技术转让,经济问题探索,2006年第6期:58-61页。
    ①曲三强.被动立法的百年轮回---谈中国知识产权保护的发展历程,中外立法,1999 (2)。
    ②许春明,陈敏.中国知识产权保护强度的测定及验证.知识产权,2008 (1)。
    ①韩玉雄,李怀祖.关于中国知识产权保护水平的定量分析,科学学研究,2005年第3期。许春明,陈敏.中国知识产权保护强度的测定及验证.知识产权,2008 (1)。
    ①重庆的数据纳入四川进行测算。
    ②万君康,李华威.知识产权与贸易相关性的理论与实证分析.国际经贸探索,2005(3)。
    ①Global Business Policy Council,A.T.Kenney,Inc,“FDI Confidence Index,2004”,October,2004,Vol6.
    ②通过OLS估计结果表明误差项的原序列在5%水平下是平稳的,因为根据μ_t的ADF单位根检验结果发现ADF的检验值为-3.8347小于5%水平下的临界值-3.0521。
    ①J.Dunning.The Electric Paradigm of International Production:A Restatement and Some Possible Extensions[J].Journal of International Business Studies,1988,19,1-31.
    ②陈国宏.中国FDI、知识产权保护与自主创新能力关系实证研究.中国工业经济,2008 (4)。
    ①沈国兵.TRIPS协定下中国知识产权保护的核心难题及基准,财经研究,2008年第10期.
    [1]吴汉东.后TRIPS时代知识产权制度的变革与中国的应对方略.法商研究,2005年第5期.
    [2]沈国兵.中美贸易平衡问题研究.北京:中国财政经济出版社,2007.
    [3]张国强.发展中国家知识产权对FDI、技术溢出及福利的影响.世界经济与政治论坛,2006(6).
    [4]李平.随洪光.知识产权保护对外商直接投资溢出效应影响的研究.经济评论,2007(6).
    [5]程恩富.构建知识产权优势理论与战略---兼论比较优势和竞争优势.当代经济研究,2003(9).
    [6]李辉.我国知识产权保护对外商直接投资的影响.东北财经大学学报,2007 (2).
    [7]李辉.知识产权保护与中国利用外资的相关性分析.国际商务,2008 (2).
    [8]朱竹颖.知识产权保护与FDI关系的实证研究.中国科技信息,2008年第3期.
    [9]柒江艺,阳立高,冯涛.我国知识产权保护对FDI的影响研究.经济问题探索,2008(1).
    [10]邹薇.知识产权保护的经济学分析.世界经济,2002 (2).
    [11]殷德生,唐海燕.内生技术进步、南北贸易与干预政策.财经研究,2006 (4).
    [12]殷德生.贸易与内生增长:一个理论综述.南开经济研究,2004 (6).
    [13]张国强.知识产权保护、跨国研发与发展中国家技术进步.世界经济与政治论坛,2007(3).
    [14]文礼朋,郭熙保.专利保护与技术创新关系的再思考.经济社会体制比较,2007 (6).
    [15]熊红轶,杨伟.知识产权保护对经济增长的影响研究综述.广东财经职业学院学报,2007(6).
    [16]赵伟,吕盛行,管汉晖.与贸易相关的知识产权理论最新进展及启示.财贸经济,2004(9).
    [17]赵伟,吕盛行,管汉晖.知识产权保护与外商直接投资.价格理论与实践,2005 (3).
    [18]吴建新.开放经济条件下的研发、专利与中国经济增长.世界经济研究,2008 (3).
    [19]尹翔硕.创新能力、模仿能力与知识产权保护中的执行成本.世界经济研究,2008(3).
    [20]张亚斌,易先忠.南方国家知识产权保护与南北经济收敛.财经研究,2006 (6).
    [21]许春明,陈敏.中国知识产权保护强度的测定及验证.知识产权,2008 (1).
    [22]张亚斌,易先忠,刘志勇.后发国知识产权保护与技术赶超.中国软科学,2006 (7).
    [23]陈国宏.中国FDI、知识产权保护与自主创新能力关系实证研究.中国工业经济,2008(4).
    [24]孙赫.发展中国家知识产权保护的经济效应研究.世界经济研究,2007 (2).
    [25]易先忠,张亚斌,吴江.知识产权保护、FDI与国际收入转移.财经研究,2007 (7).
    [26]朱东平.外商直接投资、知识产权保护与发展中国家的社会福利.经济研究,2004(1).
    [27]潘士远.最优专利制度研究.经济研究,2005(12).
    [28]张先锋,刘厚俊.中国知识产权保护中的企业与政府行为分析.财经研究,2007 (5).
    [29]庄子银,杜娟.发展中国家知识产权保护的理论与经验分析.武汉大学学报,2003 (7).
    [30]万君康,李华威.知识产权与贸易相关性的理论与实证分析.国际经贸探索,2005(3).
    [31]张亚斌,吴江,易先忠.知识产权保护与南北技术扩散.世界经济研究,2007 (1).
    [32]韩玉雄,李怀祖.知识产权保护对工资率水平及经济增长的影响:一个修正的技术扩散模型.数量经济技术经济研究,2004(11).
    [33]王晓春.知识产权、企业竞争与发展中国家的经济增长.复旦大学博士论文,2004.
    [34]邹薇,代谦.技术模仿、人力资本积累与经济赶超.中国社会科学,2003 (5).
    [35]余长林,王瑞芳.知识产权保护、技术差距与发展中国家的技术进步.当代经济科学,2008 (4).
    [36]余长林,王瑞芳.知识产权保护与国际技术转移的关系研究进展.财经问题研究,2009 (3).
    [37]余长林,王瑞芳.发展中国家的知识产权保护与技术创新:只是线性关系吗?当代经济科学,2009 (3).
    [38]余长林,王瑞芳.知识产权保护、东道国特征与外商直接投资:一个跨国的经验研究.世界经济研究,2009 (6).
    [39]沈国兵.TRIPS协定下中国知识产权保护的核心难题及基准,财经研究,2008年第10期.
    [40]刘勇,周宏.知识产权保护与经济增长:基于省际面板数据的研究.财经问题研究,2008 (6).
    [41]格罗斯曼和赫尔普曼.全球经济中的创新与增长[M].北京:中国人民大学出版社2003.
    [42]菲利普·阿吉翁,彼得·霍依特.内生增长理论[M].北京:北京大学出版社,2004.
    [43]赵江林.东亚技术供给、知识产权保护与经济增长[M].北京:经济科学出版社,2007.
    [44]韩玉雄、李怀祖.知识产权保护对社会福利水平的影响,世界经济,2003年第9期.
    [45]张亚斌、易先忠.知识产权、技术差距与后发国技术进步.数量经济技术经济研究,2006(10).
    [46]易先忠、张亚斌.自主创新、国外模仿与后发国知识产权保护.世界经济,2007 (3).
    [47]韩玉雄、李怀祖.关于中国知识产权保护水平的定量分析.科学学研究,2005 (3).
    [48]杨全发、韩樱.知识产权保护与跨国公司对外直接投资策略.经济研究2006年第4期.
    [49]盛斌.中国对外贸易政策的政治经济分析[M].上海三联书店:上海人民出版社.2002年.
    [50]王元颖.关税保护与动态比较优势的理论与经验分析[M].北京:经济科学出版社.2008年.
    [51]Acemoglu,D,Aghion P and Zilibotti F.,2006,“Distance to frontier,Selection and Economic Growth.” Journal of the European Association,4(1),pp37-74.
    [52]Acemoglu,D and Akcigit,U.,2008,“State Dependent Intellectual Property Rights Policy.”NBER Working Paper No.12775.
    [53]Aghion,P and P,Howitt.,Endogenous Growth Theory,The MIT Press,Cambridge,Massachusetts,1998.
    [54]Aghion,P and P,Howitt.,1992,“A model of Growth through Creative Destruction.” Econometrica,60,pp321-351.
    [55]Akiyama,T and Y,Furukawa.,2008,“Intellectual Property Rights and Technological Openness.” Mimeo,Yokohama National University.
    [56]Arrow,Kenneth J.,1962a,“Methodological Individualism and Social Knowledge,”American Economic Review,84,pp 1-9.
    [57]Arrow,Kenneth J.,1962b,“The Economic Implications of Learning by Doing.”Review of Economic Studies,29,pp155-173.
    [58]Almeida,R and A.M,Fernandes,2006,“Technology Adoption in Developing Countries:Evidence from Firm Level Surveys.” World Bank,March.
    [59]Andrew,H and Edwin L.-C.Lai.,1996,“Patent Length and the Rate of Innovation.” International Economic Review,37(4),pp785-801.
    [60]Allred,B.B and W.G.Park.,2007,“The Influence of Patent Protection on Firm Innovation Investment in Manufacturing Industries.” Journal of International Management,13, pp91-109.
    [61] Adolf, H.,2001, "Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights and Developing Countries." The Developing Economies,3,pp49-84.
    [62] Anand, B.N. and Khanna, T., 2000,"The Structure of Licensing Contracts." Journal of Industrial Economics,48,pp 103-135.
    [63] Arrow,K., Economic Welfare and the Allocation of Resources for Invention. The Rate and Direction of Inventive Acitivity,ed.R.Nelson, Princeton,NJ:Princeton University Press, 1969.
    [64] Arundel,A and Isavelle,K., 1998,"What Percentage of Innovations are Patented? Empirical Estimates for European Firms." Research Policy,27,pp 127-141.
    [65] Barro,R.J, and Sala-i-Martin,X. Economic Growth,The MIT Press,2003.
    [66] Barro,R.J.and Sala-i-Martin,X, 1997, "Technological Diffusion, Convergence, and Growth." Journal of Economic Growth,2, pp1-27.
    [67] Barro,R.J. and J-W, Lee., 2001, "Internatinal Data on Educational Attainment: Updates and Implications." Oxford Economic Papers,53,pp541-563.
    [68] Basu,S and Weil,David N., 1998, "Appropriate Technology and Growth." The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 113, 4, pp 1025-1054.
    [69] Benhabib,J. and M.M, Spiegel, "Human Capital and Technology Diffusion." Working paper,December,2002.
    [70] Belderbos, Bene, Kyoji Fukao and Hyeog Ug Kwon, 2006,"Intellectual Property Rights protection and the Location of Research and Development Activities by Multinational Firms." Hitotsubashi University, Discussion Paper Series No.167. June.
    [71] Bergstrand,J.,1985, "The Gravity Equation in International Trade: Some Microeconomic Foundations and Empirical Evidence." Review of Economics and Statistics,67,pp474-481.
    [72] Bergstrand,J.,1989, "Generalized Gravity Equation,Monopolistic Competition and Factor Proportions Theory in International Trade."Review of Economics and Statistics, 71, ppl43-153.
    [73] Bergstrand,J.,1990, "The Heckscher-Ohlin-Samuelson Model, the Linder Hypothesis and the Determinants of Bilateral Intraindustry Trade."Economic Journal,100,ppl216-1229.
    [74] Bessen,J. and E, Maskin, 2008, "Sequential Innovation, Patents and Imitation."Rand Journal of Economics, forthcoming.
    [75] Bessen,J.,2005,"Patents and Diffusion of Technological Information."Economics Letters,86,ppl21-128.
    [76] Blyde, Juan S. and Cristina Acea,2002, The Effects of Intellectual Property Rights on Trade and FDI in Latin America, InterAmerican Development Bank, Manuscript.
    [77] Borensztein,E., J.De Gregorio.and J-W. Lee., 1998, "How Does Foreign Direct Investment Affect Economic Growth." Journal of International Economics,45,pp 115-135.
    [78] Branstetter,L., R. Fisman, and F. Foley, 2006, "Does Stronger Intellectual Property Rights Increase International Technology Transfer? Empirical Evidence from U.S. Firm-level Data."Quarterly Journal of Economics,484,pp321-349.
    [79] Besley,T.,1995, "Property Rights and Investment Incentives: Theory and Evidence from Ghana."Journal of Political Economy,103,pp903-937.
    [80] Bosco,M.G.,2001, "Integration,Technological Transfer and Intellectual Property Rights." Working paper of Bocconi University.
    [81] Chen yongming, P, Thitima., 2005, "Intellectual Property Rights and Innovation in Developing Countries."Journal of Development Economics,78, pp474-493.
    [82] Corix, Sumner J.La and Denise Eby Konan,2002, "Intellectual Property Rights in China: the Changing Political Economy of Chinese-American Interests."Economics Study Area Working Paper No.39, East-West Center.
    [83] Co,C.C.,2004, "Do Patent Rights Regimes Matter?" Review of International Economics, 12, pp359-373.
    [84] Coe,D.and E,Helpman., 1995, "International R&D Spillovers." European Economic Review, 39, pp859-887.
    [85] Coe,D., E,Helpman.And A.W Hoffmaister., 1997, "North-South R&D Spillovers."Economic Journal,107,ppl34-150.
    [86] Crosby,M.,2000, "Patent, Innovation and Growth." Economic Record,76,pp255-262.
    [87] Chin, Judith C. and Gene M. Grossman., 1990, "Intellectual Property Rights and North-South Trade." NBER Working Paper No.2769.
    [88] Contractor, Farok J., 1984, "Choosing Between Direct Investment and Licensing: Theoretical Considerations and Empirical Tests." Journal of International Business Studies, 15(3), pp167-188.
    [89] Currie,D,P, Levine.,J, Pearlman.and M, Chui.,1999, "Phases of Imitation and Innovation in a North-South Endogenous Growth Model."Oxford Economic Papers,51,pp60-88.
    [90] Das, Dilip K.,2005," Intellectual Property Rights and the Doha Round." Journal of World Intellectual Property, 8(1),pp1-12.
    [91] Datta,A., and Mohtadi,H., 2006,"Endogenous Imitation and Technology Absorption in A Model of North-South Trade." International Economic Journal,20,pp431-459.
    [92] Dunning,J., 1981, " Explaining the International Direct Investment Position of Countries: Towards a Dynamic or Development Approach." Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv, 117,pp30-64.
    [93] Davidson, W. H. and D.G. McFetridge, 1985, "Key Characteristics in the Choice of International Technology Transfer Mode." Journal of Industrial Business Studies,Summer, pp5-21.
    [94] Deardorff,A.V.,1992," Welfare Effects of Global Patent Protection." Econometrica,59,pp35-51.
    [95] Dixit,Aand Joseph E. Stiglitz.,1977, "Monopolistic Competition and Optimum Product Diversity. "American Economic Review,67,52-64.
    [96] Dinopoulos,E., and Segerstrom,P.,2006,"North-South Trade and Economic Growth. "Mimeo,University of Florida, Stockholm School of Economics.
    [97] Dinopoulos,E., and Segerstrom,P.,2007, "Intellectual Property Rights, Multinational Firms and Economic Growth. "Mimeo,University of Florida, Stockholm School of Economics.
    [98] Feenstra,Robert,C, Advanced international trade:theory and evidence ,Princeton University Press,2004.
    [99] Diwan,I and Rodrik,D., 1991, "Patents , Appropriate Technology, and North-South Trade." Journal of International Economics,29 (1), pp27-48.
    [100] Ethier, W.J. and Markusen, J.R., 1996, " Multinational Firms, Technology Diffusion and Trade." Journal of International Economics,41,pp1-28.
    [101] Eaton, J and S, Kortum., 1996, " Trade in Ideas: Patenting and Productivity in the OECD." Journal of International Economics,40,pp251-278.
    [102] Eaton, J and S,Kortum.,1999 , "International Technology Diffusion: Theory and Measurement." International Economic Review,40,pp537-570.
    [103] Eicher,T., and C, Garcia-Penalosa.,2008, " Endogenous Strength of Intellectual Property Rights: Implications for Economic Development and Growth." European Economic Review,52(2),pp237-258.
    [104] Evenson,R.and S.Kumar.,2001"Does Intellectual Property Protection Spur Technological Change? "Yale Economic Growth Center Discussion Paper No.831.
    [105] Fosfuri,A., 2000, " Patent Protection, Imitation and the Mode of Technology Transfer." International Journal of Industrial Organization, 18, pp 1129-1149.
    [106] Falvey,R, Branatetter,L., R. Fisman., C.F Foley, and K. Saggi.,2007, "Intellectual Property Rights, Imitation, and Foreign Direct Investment: Theory and Evidence. "NBER Working Paper, No. 13033.
    [107] Fink, C.,2000," How Stronger Patent Protection in India Might Affect the Behavior of Transnational Pharmaceutical Induatries." World Bank Policy Research Paper No.2352.
    [108] Falvey, R.E., N. Foster, and D. Greenway.,2006," Intellectual Property Rights and Economic Growth,."Review of Development Economics,10(4),pp700-719.
    [109] Falvey, R.E., N. Foster, and D. Greenway.,2006," Trade, Imitative Ability and Intellectual Property Rights." Working Papers,August.
    [110] Falvey, R.E., N. Foster, and D. Greenway., 2006, "The Role of Intellectual Property Rights in Technology Transfer and Economic Growth: Theory and Evidence." UNIDO, Strategic Research and Economics Branch.
    [111] Futagami,K, and Iwaisako,T., 2007, " Dynamics Analysis of Patent Policy in An Endogenous Growth Model." Journal of Economic Theory,132,pp306-334.
    [112] Futagami,K, and Iwaisako,T., and H, Tanaka.,2006, " Innovation, Licensing, and Imitation: The Effects of Intellectual Property Rights Protection and Industrial Policy. "Working Paper.
    [113] Findlay,R.,1978, " Relative Backwardness, Direct Foreign Investment and the Transfer of Technology:A Simple Dynamic Model."Quarterly Journal of Economics,92, pp1-16.
    [114] Fink, C. and C.A. Primo-Braga.,2005, "How Stronger Protection of Intellectual Property Rights Affects International Trade Flows." In C, Fink and K.E. Maskus(eds), Intellectual Property and Development: lessons from Recent Research(Washington DC. The World Bank/Oxford University Press).
    [115] Ferrantino, Michael J.,1993, " The Effects of Intellectual Property Rights on Intellectual Trade and Investment,."Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv,129,pp300-331.
    [116] Furukawa,Y., 2007, "The Protection of Intellectual Property Rights and Endogenous Growth: Is Stronger Always Better?"Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control, 31 ,pp3644-3670.
    [117] Gallini,Nancy T, 2002, " the Economics of PatentLessons from Recent U.S. Patent Reform."Journal of Economic Perspectives, 16,pp131-154.
    [118] Gilbert,R. and Shapiro,C, 1990, " Optimal Patent Length and Breadth. "RAND Journal of Economics,21 ,pp 106-112.
    [119] Gilles Koleda.,2008, "Promoting Innovation and Competition with Patent Policy." Journal of Evolution Economics, 18,pp433-453.
    [120] Giannakas,K.,2003, "Infringement of Intellectual Property Rights."American Agricultural Economics Association,84(2),pp482-494.
    [121] Ginarte,J.C and Park,W.G, 1997," Determinants of Patents Rights: A Cross-national Study." Research Policy,26, pp283-301.
    [122] Glass,A.J.,2000, "Costly R&D and Intellectual Property Rights Protection." International Journal of Technology Management, 19,pp179-193.
    [123] Glass A.J.and Saggi, K.,2002a," Intellectual Property Right and Foreign Direct Investment." Journal of International Economics,56, pp387-410.
    [124] Glass, A.J and K. Saggi., 2002b, "Multinational Firms and Technology Transfer." Scandinavian Journal of Economics,104,pp495-513.
    [125] Goh,Ai-T. and Olivier,J.,2002, " Optimal Patent Protection in a Two-Sector Economy." International Economic Review,43,ppl 191-1214.
    [126] Goh,Ai-T. and Olivier,J.,2001, " Free Trade and Protection of Intellectual Property Rights: Can We Have One Without the Other?" Working Paper. [127] Gould,D.M., Gruben, W.C., 1996, " The role of Intellectual Property Rights in Economic Growth." Journal of Development Economics,48,pp323-350.
    [128] Grossman, G.M. and E. Helpman.,1991a, Innovation and Growth in the Global Economy, Cambridge, MIT Press.
    [129] Grossman, G.M. and E. Helpman.,1991b, " Endogenous Product Cycles." Economic Journal,101,pp1214-1229.
    [130] Grossman, G.M. and E. Helpman., 1991c, " Quality ladders and Product Cycles."Quarterly Journal of Economics,pp557-586.
    [131] Grossman, G.M. and E. Helpman., 1991d , "Quality Ladders in the Theory of Growth."Review of Economic Studies,58,pp43-61.
    [132] Grossman, G.M. and E. L.C. Lai.,2004, " International Protection of Intellectual Property." American Economic Review,94,pp1635-1653.
    [133] Gallini, N.,2002, " The Economics of Patents: Lessons from Recent U.S. Patent Reform." Journal of Economic Perspectives,16(2),pp131-154.
    [134] Glass, Amy J. and K,Saggi.,1998, "International Technology Transfer and the Technology Gap."Journal of Development Economics,55,pp369-398.
    [135] Glass, Amy J. and Kamal Saggi,, 1999, "Foreign Direct Investment and the Nature of R&D,."Canadian Journal of Economics,32(1),pp92-117.
    [136] Glass, Amy J. and Xiaodong Wu., 2007, " Intellectual property Rights and Quality Improvement,."Journal of Development Economics,82(2),pp393-415.
    [137] Hall,Bronwyn H., Adam B,Jaffe, and M,Trajtenberg., 2001, "The NBER Patent Citations Data File: Lessons, Insights and Methodological Tools." NBER Working Paper.
    [138] Hansen, Bruce E.,1996, " Inference when a nuisance parameter is not identified under the null hypothesis." Econometrica, 64(2),pp413-430.
    [139] Hansen, Bruce E.,1999, "Threshold Effects in Non-Dynamic Panels: Estimation, Testing, and Inference."Journal of Econometrics,93,pp345-368.
    [140] Hansen, Bruce E., 2000, "Sample Splitting and Threshold Estimation."Econometrica, 68(3),pp575-603.
    [141] Helpman, E.,1993, " Innovation,Imitation,and Intellectual Property Rights." Econometrica, 61, pp1247-1280.
    [142] Hagedoorn, J, D,Cloodt, and H.V.Kranenburg,., 2005, "Intellectual property Rights and Governance of International R&D Partnerships." Journal of International Business Studies,36,pp175-186.
    [143] Horii,R., and T, Iwaisako.,2007, " Economic Growth with Imperfect Protection of Intellectual Property Rights." Journal of Economics ,1,pp48-85.
    [144] Horstmann, I. and J.R. Markusen., 1987, " Licensing versus Direct Investment: A Model of Internalization by the Multinationalo Enterprise." Canadian Journal of Economics, 20, pp464-481.
    [145] Heston,A.,R.Summers and B.Aten,2002.Penn World Table Version 6.1.Center for International Comparisons at the University of Pennsylvania(CICUP).
    [146] Hwan C. Lin., 2002, "Shall the Northern Optimal R&D Subsidy Rate Inversely Respond to Southern Intellectual Property Protection?"Southern Economic Journal,69(2),pp381-397.
    [147] Iwaisako,J., and K, Futagami.,2003, " Patent Policy in An Endogenous Growth Model." Journal of Economocs,3,pp239-258.
    [148] Iwasa,T.,and Odagiri,H.,2004, "Overseas R&D,Knowledge Sourcing and Patenting:An Empirical Study of Japanese R&D Investment in the U.S.Research Policy,33,pp807-828.
    [149] N, Jinji., 2006,"Intellectual Property Rights Protection, FDI and Process Innovation in North-South Trade." Okayama University Working Paper.
    [150] Jaffe,Adam B., 2000, " the U.S. Patent System on Transition:Policy Innovation and the Innovation Process." Research Policy,29,pp531-557.
    [151] Javorcik,B-,2004, "The Composition of Foreign Direct Investment and Protection of Intellectual Property Rights:Evidence from Transition Economies."European Economic Review,48,pp39-62.
    [152] Judd, K. L.,1985, "on the Performance of Patents."Econnmetrica,53,pp 567-585.
    [153] Jones,C.I., 1995a," Times Series Tests of Endogenous Growth Models."Quarterly Journal of Economics, 110,pp495-525.
    [154] Jones,C.L, 1995b," R&D-Based Models of Economic Growth." Journal of Political Economy, 103,pp759-784.
    [155] Kanwar,S. and R.E. Evenson.,2003, " Does Intellectual Property Rights Spur Technological Change?" Oxford Economic Papers,55,pp235-264.
    [156] Keller,W.,2004 , "International Technology Diffusion." Journal of Economic Literature,42,pp752-782.
    [157] Krugman,P., 1979, "A Model of Innovation, Technology Transfer, and World Distribution of Income." Journal of Political Economy,87,pp253-266.
    [158] Kondo E.K.,1995, "the Effect of Patent Protection on Foreign Direct Investment." Journal of World Trade,29,pp97-122.
    [159] Kumar,N.,2001, " Deteminants of Location of Overseas R&D Activities of Multinational Enterprises: The Case of US and Japanese Corporations." Research Policy,30,pp159-174.
    [160] Kumar,N., 2002, " Intellectual Property Rights, Technology and Economic Development: Experiences of Asian Countries. "Commission Background paper,2, pp27-35.
    [161] Kortum, S., and J. Lerner., 1999, "Stronger Protection or Technological Revolution: What is Behind the Recent Surge in Patenting?" Research Policy,,28,pp1-22.
    [162] Kultti,K., and T, Takalo.,2008, " Optimal Fragmentation of Intellectual Property Rights." International Journal of Industrial Organization, 26 (1), ppl37-149.
    [163] Kwan Y.K. and Lai,E.L.-C, 2003, "Intellectual Property Rights Protection and Endogenous Economic Growth."Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control,27,pp853-873.
    [164] Keller, Wolfgang., 1996, "Absorptive capacity :on the creation and acquisition of technology in development." Journal of Development Economics,49,pp199- 227.
    [165] Krugman, Paul.,1990,"Endogenous Innovation, International Trade and Growth." Journal of Political Economy,2, 31-42.
    [166] Lai, E.L.C.,1998," International Intellectual Property Rights Protection and the Rate of Product Innovation."Journal of Development economics, 55,pp133-153.
    [167] Lall,S.,2003, "Indicators of the Relative Importance of IPRS in Developing Countries." Research Policy,32,pp 1657-1680.
    [168] Lesser,W., The Effect of TRIPs-Mandated Intellectual Property Rights On Economic Activities in Developing Countries. Prepared under WIPO Special Service Agreements WIPO. 2003.
    [169] Lee,J.Y. and Mansfield,E.,1996, "Intellectual Property Protection and U.S. Foreign Direct Investment."Review of Economics and Statistics,78,pp 181 -186.
    [170] Lai,Edwin L.-C, and Larry D. Qiu,2003, " The North's Intellectual Property Rights Standard for the South?"Journal of International Economics,59,pp183-209.
    [171] Lall,S. and M. Albaladejo., 2002, " Indicators of the Relative Importance of IPRs in Developing Countries." Queen Elizabeth House Working Paper No. 85, Oxford.
    [172] Lanjouw, J.,1998. "Patent Protection in the Shadow of Infringement: Simulation Estimations of Patent Value." Review of Economic Studies,65(4),pp671-710.
    [173] Lanjouw, J. and I. Cockburn.,2000" Do Patents Matter? Empirical Evidence after GATT." NBER Working Paper No.7495.
    [174] Leahy,D., and A, Naghavi., 2006,"Intellectual Property Rights and Entry into A Foreign Market: FDI vs. Joint Ventures."KTHC,working Paper.
    [175] Lesser,W.,2003, The Effect of TRIPs-Mandated Intellectual Property Rights On Economic Activities In Developing Countries. Prepared under WIPO Special Service Agreements WIPO.
    [176] Lucas.Robert E.Jr.,1988, "On the Mechanics of Economic Development."Journal of Monetary Economics,22,pp3-42.
    [177] May, C.,2000," A Global Political Economy of Intellectual Property Rights: The New Enclosures? "London, Routledge,82-84.
    [178] Mansfield, E.,1981," Mark Schwartz and Samuel Wagner, Imitation Costs and Patents: An Empirical Study." The Economic Journal,12, pp907-18.
    [179] Mansfield, E., 1995, "Intellectual Property Protection, Direct Investment and Technology Transfer: Germany, Japan and the United States." The World Bank. International Finance Corporation Discussion Papers27.
    [180] McCalman P.,2001" Reaping What you Sow: An empirical Analysis of International Patent Harmonization."Journal of International Economics,55,pp161-186.
    [181] McCalman,P.,2004, "Foreign Direct Investment and Intellectual Property Rights: Evidence from Hollywood's Global Distribution of Movies and Videos." Journal of International Economics ,62,pp107-123.
    [182] McCalman,P.,2005, " International Diffusion and Intellectual Property Rights: An Empirical Analysis." Journal of International Economics,67,pp353-372.
    [183] Markusen James, 2001, "Contracts, Intellectual Property Rights, and Multinational Investment in Developing Countries."Journal of International Economics,53,189-204.
    [184] Mansfield, E, 1995, ." Intellectual Property Rights Protection , Foreign Direct Investment, and Technology Transfer."Interenational Finance Corporation Discussion Paper No.19.
    [185] Maskus,K,E.,2000, " The Global Effects of Intellectual Property Rights: Measuring What Cannot Be Seen." Edited in Intellectual Property Rights in the Global Economy, www.iie.com.
    [186] Maskus, K.E., 2000, Intellectual Property Rights in the Global Economy, Institute for International Economics, Washington DC.
    [187] Maskus, K.E.,1999, "Impacts of the Japanese Patent System on Productivity Growth." Japan and the World Economy,11,pp557-574.
    [188] Maskus, K.E., Penubarti,M.,1995, " How trade-related are Intellectual Property Rights? " Journal of International Economics, 39,pp227-248.
    [189] Maskus, K.E.,1998 , "The International Regulation of Intellectual Property." Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv, 134,pp186-208.
    [190] Maskus, K.E.,2002,Intellectual Property Rights and Foreign Direct Investment, University of Adelaide Policy Discussion Paper No.
    [191] Markus,K.E.,2003,Encouraging International Technology Transfer,Draft UNCTAD/ICTSD Capacity Building Project on Intellectual Property Rights and Sustainable Development.
    [192] Markus, K.E., and Denise Eby-Konan, 1994,Trade-Related Intellectual Property Rights: Issues and Exploratory Results, edited in Alan V. Deardorff and Robert M. Stern, Analytical and Negotiation Issues in the Global Trading System, University of Michigan Press.
    [193] Maskus, K.E., and M. Penubarti,1997,Patent and International Trade: An Empirical Study' in Maskus K., Hooper, P., Learner, E., and J.D. Richardson, Quiet Pioneering: Robert Stern and His International Economic Legacy, Ann Arbor: Michigan: University of Michigan Press.
    [194] Maskus, K.E.,1998,"The Role of Intellectual Property Rights in Encouraging Foreign Direct Investment and Technology Transfer." Duke of Comparative and International Law,9,pp109-161.
    [195] Mondal,D., and Gupta, M.R.,2008, " Intellectual Property Rights and Unemployment in a North-South Model: A Theoretical Analysis."Economic Modelling,25, pp463-484.
    [196] Mondal,D., and Gupta, M.R.,2006, " Innovation, Imitation and Intellectual Property Rights: A Note on Helpman's Model." Journal of Economics,, 1,pp29-53.
    [197] Mondal,D., and Gupta, M.R.,2008, " Innovation, Imitation and Intellectual Property Rights: Introducing Migration in Helpman'S Model."Japan and the World Economy,20, pp369-394.
    [198] Naghavi,A.,2007 , "Stragetic Intellectual Property Rights Policy and North-South Technology Transfer." Review of World Economics,143(1),pp55-78.
    [199] Nordhaus, W. D. ,1969, Invention, Growth, and Welfare:A Theoretical Treatment of Technological Change, Cambridge, Mass.
    [200].Nelson, R and Phelps,E., 1966, " Investment in Humans 、 Technological Diffusion and Economic Growth." American Economic Review,56(2), pp69-76.
    [201] Nicholson, M.,2003, Intellectual Property Rights, Internalization, and Technology Transfer, Bureau of Economics, Federal Trade Commission Working Paper.
    [202] Nicholson, M.2003 , Intellectual Property Protection,Multinational Enterprise,and Technological Development,University of Colorado at Boulder.
    [203] Nicholson, M.,2007, "The Impact of Industry Characteristic and IPR Policy on Foreign Direct Investment." Review of World Economics, 143(1),pp27-54.
    [204] Nicholson, M.,2003, The Impact of Industry Characteristics on International Technology Transfer, Bureau of Economics, Federal Trade Commission Working Paper.
    [205] Nunnenkamp,P., and J,Spatz.,2002, "Determinants of FDI in Developing Countries:Has Globalization Changed the Rules of the Games?"Transnational Corporations,11(2),pp 1-34.
    [206] Nunnenkamp,P., and J,Spatz.,2004, Intellectual Property Rights and Foreign Direct Investment: The Role of Industry and Host-Country Characteristcs. Kiel Working Paper 1167. Institute for World Economics,Kiel.
    [207] Nunnenkamp,P., and J,Spatz.,2004, "Intellectual Property Rights and Foreign Direct Investment: A Dissggregated Analysis."Review of World Economics,140(3),pp393-414.
    [208] O'DonoghueJ., Scotchmer S., Thisse, J.-F.,1998." Patent Breadth, Patent Life, and the Pace of Technological Progress." Journal of Economics and Management Strategy,7,pp1-32.
    [209] O'DonoghueJ., and Zweimuller,J.,2004, " Patents in a Model of Endogenous Growth." Journal of Economic Growth,9,pp81-123.
    [210] Oxley J.E., 1999, "Institutional Environment and the Mechanisms of Governance: the Impact of Intellectual Property Protection on the Structure of inter-firm Alliance." Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization,38,pp283-309.
    [211] Robert L., Ostergard,Jr.,2000 , "The Measurement of Intellectual Property Rights Protection."Journal of International Business Studies,31(2),pp349-360.
    [212] Parello,C.P.,2008, "A North-South Model of Intellectual Property Rights Protection and Skill Accumulation."Journal of Development Economics,85, pp253-281.
    [213] Popovici, I., 2006, "Impact of Intellectual Property Rights Reforms on the Diffusion of Knowledge through FDI." Florida International University.
    [214] Park,W.G.,2008, "International Patent Protection: 1960-2005."Research Policy,37, pp761-766.
    [215] Park,W.G.,and Wagh,S., 2002, "Index of Patent Rights,in Economic Freedom of the World:2002 Annual Report."Chapter,2,pp33-43.
    [216] Primo Braga,C, Fink, C .,2000, "International Transctions in Intellectual Property and Developing Countries."International Journal of Technology Management,19,pp35-56.
    [217] Puttianun,T., 2006, "Intellectual Property Rights and Multinational Firms'Modes of Entry."Journal of Intellectual Property Rights,11,pp269-273.
    [218] Rafiquzzaman,M.,2002, "the Impact of Patent Rights on International Trade: Evidence from Canada."The Canadian Journal of Economics,35(2),pp307-330.
    [219] Rivera-Batiz L.A. and Paul M. Romer.,1991, " economic integration and endogenous growth." Quarterly Journal of Economics, 106, pp531-556.
    [220] Nair-Reichert,U.and Duncan,R.,2008, "Patent Regimes, Host Country Policies, and the nature of MNE Activities."Review of International Economics,16(4),pp783-797.
    [221] Rapp R and R.P. Rozek., 1990, "Benefits and Costs of Intellectual Property Protection in Developing Countries.'Mournal of World Trade,75(77),pp75-102.
    [222] Romer, P., 1990, "Endogenous Technological Change. "Journal of Political Economy,98(1), pp71-102.
    [223] Sachs,J.D.and A, Warner. 1995, "Economic Reform and Process of Global Integration."World Bank Research Observer, 1, pp1 -118.
    [224] Segerstrom, Paul S., A.T.C. Anant and E,Dinopoulos.,1990, "A Schumpererian Model ofthe Product Life Cycle."American Economic Review,80,pp1077-1091.
    [225] Sheshinski E.,1967, Optimal Accumulation with Learning by Doing, In: Essays on the Theory of Optimal Growth.Cambridge: MIT Press.
    [226] Saint-Paul,G.,2007, "Welfare Effects of Intellectual Property in A North-South Model of Endogenous Growth with Comparative Advantage.'The Open-Access, Open-Assessment E-Journal Discussion Paper.
    [227] Scherer,F.M.and S.Weisburst.,1995, "Economics Effects of Strengthening Pharmaceutical Patent Protection in Italy." International Review of Industrial Property and Copyright Law,26,pp1009-1024.
    [228] Schneider, P.H., 2005, "International Trade, Economic Growth and Intellectual Property Rights: A Panel Data Study of Developed and Developing Countries." Journal of Development Economics,78,pp529-547.
    [229].Segerstrom, P.S,1991,"Innovation, Imitation and Economic Growth,."Journal of Political Economy,99,pp807-827.
    [230] Sener,F.,2006, " Intellectual Property Rights and Rent Protection in North-South Product Cycle Model." mimeo.
    [231] Sakakibara,M. and L. Branstetter,2001, "Do Stronger Patents Induce More Innovation? Evidence from the 1988 Japanese Patent Reforms."Rand Journal of Economics, 32, pp71-100.
    [232] Seyoum,B.,1996 , "The Impact of Intellectual Property Rights on Foreign Direct Investment."The Columbia Journal of World Business,Spring,pp50-59.
    [233] Sherwood R.M., 1997, "Intellectual Property Systems and Investment Stimulation: the Rating Systems in Eighteen Developing Countries." IDEA: The Journal of Law and Technology,37(2),pp261-370.
    [234] Smith, P.J., 1999, "Are Weak Patent Rights a Barrier to U.S. Exports?" Journal of International Economics,48,pp 151 -177.
    [235] Smith P.J., 2001, "How do Foreign Patent Rights Affect U.S. Exports, Affiliate Sales and Licenses?" Journal of International Economics,55,pp411-439.
    [236] Solow,Robert M., 1956, "A Contribution to the Theory of Economic Growth."Quarterly Journal of Economics,70, pp65-94.
    [237] Taylor,M.S.,1993 , "TRIPS, Trade and Technology Transfer." Canadian Journal of Economics,26,pp625-637.
    [238] Taylor,M.S.,1994, "TRIPS, Trade and Growth."International Economic Review, 35, pp361-381.
    [239] Thompson,M.A.,Rushing,F.,1996, "An Empirical Analysis of the Impact of Patent Protection on Economic Growth."Journal of Economic Development,21,pp61-79.
    [240] Thompson,M.A.,Rushing,F., 1999, "An Empirical Analysis of the Impact of Patent Protection on Economic Growth: An Extension."Journal of Economic Development, 24, pp67-76.
    [241] Tanaka, H, T.I. Iwaisako, and K,Futagami.,2007, "Dynamic Analysis of Innovation and International Transfer of Technology Through Licensing." Journal of International Economics, 73,ppl89-212.
    [242] Tanaka,H., 2006, " Dyanmic Analysis of Imitation and Technology Gap."Journal of Economics,3,pp209-240.
    [243] Vishwasrao,S., 1994, "Intellectual Property Rights and the Mode of Technology Transfer,."Journal of Development Economics,44,pp381-402.
    [244] Vishwasrao,S.,1994, " Trade-Related Intellectual Property Rights and Product versus Process Innovations."Working Paper.
    [245] Vishwasrao,S., S, Gupta., and H, Benchekroun.,2007," Optimum Tariffs and Patent Length in A Model of North-South Technology Transfer." International Review of Economics and Finance, 16,pp 1-14.
    [246] Vernon,R.,1966, "International Investment and International Trade in the Product Cycle,."Quarterly Journal of Economics, 80,pp 190-207.
    [247] Walasugi, R and B, Ito.,2005, How Enforcement of Intellectual Property Rights Affects the International Technology Transfer: Evidence From Japanese MNCs, Global Security Research Institute, Keio University, G-SEC Working Paper No.1.
    [248] WIPO,2002 , Intellectual Property Rights and Development Policy Report of the Commission on Intellectual Property Rights, London.
    [249] Yang ,Yong.,1998, " Why do Southern Countries Have Little Incentive to Protect Northern Intellectual Property Rights?"The Canadian Journal of Economics,31(4),pp800-816.
    [250] Xu, B and E.P. Chiang,.,2005, "Trade , Patents and International Technology Diffusion." Journal of International Trade and Economic Development,14,pp115-135.
    [251] Yang Guifang and Maskus, K.E., 2001a, "Intellectual Property Rights and Licensing: An Econometric Investment." Weltwirtschaftliches Archiu. 137, pp58-79.
    [252] Yang Guifang and Maskus, K.E.,2001b, " Intellectual Property Rights, Licensing and Innovation in an endogenous Product Cycle Model." Journal of International Economics, 53, pp169-187.
    [253] Yang, Guifang and Markus, K.E.,2003, "Intellectual Property Rights, Licensing, and Innovation." The World Bank Research Working Paper No.2973.
    [254] Yiannaka,A., and Fulton,M., 2006, "Stragegic Patent Breadth and entry Deterrence with Drastic Product Innovations.'Tnternational Journal of Industrial Organization,24,pp177-202.
    [255] Zizic,K.,1998, "Intellectual Property Rights Violations and Spillovers in North-South Trade." European Economic Review,42,pp1779-1799.
    [256] Zizic,K., 2000,"Strategic Trade Policy, Intellectual Property Rights Protection and North-South Trade."Journal of Development Economics,61, pp27-60.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700