用户名: 密码: 验证码:
电力企业生产中人因失误影响因素及管理对策研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
电力行业的公益性和网络性决定了电力安全生产的极端重要性。诸多研究和电力行业事故的统计数据表明,人的因素,尤其是人员不严格执行安全工作规程,误操作、违章操作等人因失误行为是电力生产中故障与问题发生的主要原因。如何结合电力企业生产实际情况,对电力企业生产中存在的人因失误问题进行系统研究,探索出一套有效控制人因失误的对策,无疑是一个具有十分重要现实意义的课题。然而,当前对电力企业生产中人因失误的研究成果并不多,已有的研究成果主要集中在生产违章和误操作两方面,这些研究多数理论性较为薄弱。
     本文借鉴管理学、组织行为学、心理学、安全科学等学科的理论知识,对电力企业生产中存在的人因失误及其影响因素进行了深入研究和分析,并结合电力企业实际情况,探讨了减少电力企业人因失误的组织管理对策。主要研究成果如下:
     (1)结合电力企业安全生产之实际和轨迹交叉论等理论对电力企业生产系统的特点以及“人因”和“物因”对安全生产作用的特性进行了分析,论证了人因失误问题对安全生产的重要影响作用;通过对电力企业生产中人因失误类型、机理、特性等进行分析,论证了电力企业生产中普遍存在的违章、误操作等人因失误行为既具有客观存在性更具有可管理性的特征;通过查阅和分析文献资料,对电力企业生产中人因失误的影响因素进行了整理,并运用层次分析法对不同因素的重要程度进行了判定,确定了重点对员工人格特征、能力素质、心理健康等个体性因素和组织沟通、安全生产职能部门、组织文化等组织性因素进行研究。
     (2)针对电力企业生产中的人因失误及其影响因素进行了广泛地实地调查,并对问卷数据进行了统计分析,进一步认识了电力企业生产中人因失误的基本特点,如人因失误发生情况与年龄成负相关关系;人因失误发生最频繁的人群为有一定工龄的人而非新员工;已婚者人因失误发生的频繁程度较低;管理措施不得力引发的事故及操作失误十分频繁等。
     (3)在调查研究的基础上,对重要且易于通过管理手段改善的6个人因失误影响因素从个体视角和组织视角两个方面进行了深入分析和探讨,获得了一些有价值的结论。具体包括:对“事故倾向”理论进行了评析,由“事故频发”导出了“失误倾向”的概念,依据卡特尔16种人格因素指出了“失误倾向者”的基本人格特征;提出了影响员工人因失误的六个主要素质能力指标:准确性、注意力、快速反应能力、熟练性、判断力、预见性等;对电力企业员工的心理压力状况进行了说明,并分析了心理压力对人因失误的影响机理;系统分析了电力企业组织沟通、安全生产职能部门、组织文化的特点和基本情况,并结合调研数据分析了各个组织性因素对人因失误的影响作用,为探讨人因失误组织管理对策奠定了基础。
     (4)结合调查分析所得,从行业和企业管理层面提出了控制和减少电力企业生产中人因失误(包括组织管理失误)的对策建议。包括:“以人为本”理念指导下的人因失误管理模式;借鉴员工帮助计划(EAP)的思路和做法提出了电力企业员工安全帮助计划(ESAP);在群体动力学思想的基础上,提出了改善组织沟通氛围、提高安监部门的地位以及培育电力企业安全文化的对策建议;针对电力企业组织管理方面的失误对员工人因失误和安全生产的重要影响,提出了基于风险管理的组织失误控制模式等。
The great importance of power industry determines the extreme importance of its safety production.A lot of research and many power industry accident statistics indicate that the human factor,such as employees not strictly enforce the safe working order,misoperation,illegal operation errors,is the main reason for the power production accident.Therefore,how to combine the power production actual situation with the new theories and methods to explore the effective countermeasures of the human error is undoubtedly a very important issue with great practical significance. But the current research on it is not only lack but also have low level of theory.
     In this dissertation,based on the research program that the author participate during the Dr.study and the extensive survey for this dissertation writing,the author use the knowledge and theories of the psychology,psychometrics,management, organizational behavior disciplines and made an in-depth study and analysis of the human error and its influencing factors in the power enterprise.The following aspects were studied in this dissertation:
     (1)Through the use of cross-track theory and other accident theories,the author analyze the situation of the electricity enterprise safety production and accidents,as well as the function of the "people" and "objects" in the safety production system,and demonstrate that the significance of studying the human errors.The author also analyze the type,mechanism,characteristics of the human error,demonstrate that human error in the electric power enterprises have the features of both the inevitability and manageability.Through the reference of the books and the historical documents for power safety production,the author collected most all the factors affecting human errors.After inquiring the experts,the author used the AHF and determined the importance of different factors,decided to make deep research on the following six factors:individual factors including ability,personality characteristics and mental health of the employee;organizational factors including organizational communication, organizational structure and organizational culture.
     (2) To a better understanding of the human errors and its influencing factors of the electricity production,the author conducted a questionnaire survey,through the descriptive statistical analysis,we got the following conclusions:there is a negative correlation between the age and the human error happening;t the married people have less human errors;management factors trigger lots of human errors.etc.
     (3)Based on the survey,the author carried out an in-depth analysis and discussion of the six important factors which influence the human errors.Through the review of the "accident proneness" theory,the author put forward the "error proneness" and its personality characteristics with the 16PF questionnaire;brought forward the six major indicators affected the employees' safety production ability;explored the influencing mechanism of the psychological stress on human errors;analyzed the characteristics of the organizational communication,organization,framework organizational culture of the electricity enterprise and its influencing functions to the human errors.All these researches lay the foundation for exploring management countermeasures for the human error.
     (4)At last,the dissertation put forwards systematic,practical countermeasures and proposals for the control of the human error,such as the "people-oriented" human error control mode,ESAP,group dynamics-based management improving measures,based on risk control of the management organization and failures,.etc.
引文
[1]E.Hollnagel.Human Reliability Analysis,Context and Control.London:Academic Press.1993:2-3.
    [2]Robert L Helmreich.On error management:lessons from aviation.British Medical.Journal.No.7237.2000(320):781-785.
    [3]Alenka Hudoklin,Vojan Rozman,and Human error versus stress,Reliability engineering and systems safety,and 1992(37):231-236.
    [4]A.Raouf,B.S.Dhillion.Safety assessment,A quantitative approach.Lewis Publisher,1994:61-64.
    [5]J.M.Christensen,J.M.Howard& B.S.Stevens.Field experiment in maintenance.In:J.Rasmussen,W.B.Rouse(Eds),human detection and diagnosis of system failures.Plenum Press,1981:111-133.
    [6]Rigby,L.The nature of human error.In:Annual technical conference Transactions of the ASQC.Milwaukee.1970.
    [7]Swain A D,Guttmann H E.Handbook of human-reliability analysis with emphasis on nuclear power plant applications.NUREG/CR-1,1983:278.
    [8]Reason J.Human Error.UK,Cambridge University Press.1990:2-35.
    [9]Senders J,Moray N.Human Error:Cause,Prediction,and Reduction.Lawrence Erlbaum Associates,Hillsdale,N J,1991.
    [10]Rothblum.A.M.Human error and marine safety.Retrieved July 1,2001 from the:www.uscg.mil/hq/g%2Dm/risk/e%2Dgnidelinesihtml/vo 14/volum.../humanerr.htm.1996.
    [11]THEMES.Report on undated list of methods and critical description.WP 4,D4.1.2001.
    [12]张力,王以群,邓志良.复杂人-机系统中的人因失误.中国安全科学学报.1996(12):35-38.
    [13]H.L Williams,Reliability evaluation of the human Component in man-machine system.Electrical Manufacturing.1995(4),78 -82.
    [14]Rouse W B and Rouse S H.Analysis and classification of human error.IEEE Transactions on Systems,Man and Cybernetics.1983(13):539-549.
    [15]Reason J.Human Error.Cambridge,UK:Cambridge University Press.1990:40-55.
    [16]Rasmussen J.Mental procedures in real-life tasks:A case study of electronic troubles hooting.Ergonomics.1974(17):293-307.
    [17]Rasmussen J.Skill,and Knowledge;Signals,Signs,and Symbols,and Other Distinctions in Human Performance Models.IEEE Transactions on Systems,Man,and Cybernetics.1983,13(3):257-266.
    [18]Don O.Koval,and H.Landis Floyd,Ⅱ.Human Element factors Affecting Reliability and Safety.IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications.1998,34(2):410-411.
    [19]Chen-tau Hwang,Sheue-ling Hwang.A Stochastic model of human error on system reliability,Reliability engineering and System Safety.1990(27):139-153.
    [20]Hollnagel E.Cognitive reliability and error analysis method(CREAM).London:Elsevier Science Ltd.,1998:1-67
    [21]戴巍.人为失误及其控制.安全与健康(上半月版).2006(12):23-24.
    [22]Swain A D.and Guttmann H E.Handbook of Human Reliability Analysis with Emphasis on Nuclear Power Plant Applications(NUREG/CR-1278).U.S Nuclear Regulatory Commission,Washington DC.1983.
    [23]Meister,David.Human Factors:Theory and Practice.John Wiley & Sons.1971.
    [24]B.Kirwan.Human error identification in human reliability assessment,part 2:detailed comparison of techniques.Applied Ergonomics,1992(23):371-381.
    [25]Glendon A I,Dorn L.Reliability of the driver behavior inventory.Ergonomics.1993,36(5):719-726.
    [26]Parry,G.Suggestions for an improved HRA method for use in probabilistic safety assessment.Reliability Engineering and System Safety.1995(49):1-12.
    [27]刘燕子,张力,王以群.复杂系统中人误原因因素的层次分析法.安全与环境学报.2005,5(5):39-42.
    [28]廉士乾 张力 王以群 宋洪涛.人因失误机理及原因因素研究.工业安全与环保.2007,33(11):46-48.
    [29]Reason J.Human Error.U K Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.1990.
    [30]Reason J.Managing the management risk:New approaches to Organizational safety.In B.Wilpert,T.U.Q vale(Eds).Reliability and Safety in Hazardons Work System.U K Hove:Lawrence Erlbaum Associates,1993:7 -22.
    [31]Wilpert B.Klumb P.Social dynamics,organization and management:Factors contributing to system safety.In B.Wilpert,T.U.Qvale(Eds).Reliability and Safety in Hazardous Work System.U K,Hove:Lawrence Erlbaum Associates,1993:87-99.
    [32]Rasmussen J.Learning from experience? How? Some research issues in industrial risk management.In B.Wilpert,T.U.Qvale(Eds).Reliability and Safety in Hazardons Work System.U K Hove:Lawrence Erlbaum Associates,1993:43-66.
    [33]Wagenaar WA,Sluverijn AM,Hudson PTW.Safety management in intensive care wards[M].In B.Wilpert,T.U.Qvale(Eds).Reliability and Safety in Hazardous Work System.U K,Hove:Lawrence Erlbaum Associates,1993:157-169.
    [34]Qvale TU.Design for safety productivity in large-scale industrial projects:The case of the Norwegian offshore oil development.In B.Wilpert,T.U.Qvale(Eds).Reliability and Safety in Hazardous Work System.U K,Hove:Lawrence Erlbaum Associates,1993:195-221.
    [35]Amalberti R.Safety in flight.In B.Wilpert,T.U.Qvale(Eds).Reliability and Safety in Hazardous Work System.U K,Hove:Lawrence Erlbaum Associates,1993:171-194.
    [36]Baram M.Industrial technology,chemical accidents,and social control.In B.Wilpert,T.U.Qvale(Eds).Reliability and Safety in Hazardous Work System.U K,Hove:Lawrence Erlbaum Associates,1993:223-236.
    [37]Martha Grabowski,Karlene HR.Human and Organizational Error in Large Scale Systems.IEEE Transaction on System,Man,and Cybernetics2part A:System and Human,1996,26(1):2-16.
    [38]Hollnagel E.Cognitive reliability and error analysis method(CREAM).London:Elsevier Science Ltd.,1998.
    [39]李永娟,王二平等.核电组织错误的表现与类型.核动力工程.2003,24(4):380-383.
    [40]张力.概率安全与人因可靠性分析技术.北京:原子能出版社.2006:85-88.
    [41]戴立操,黄曙东,张力.组织人因失误分析.人类工效学.2005,11(2):42-46.
    [42]李永娟,王二平.组织错误的研究.人类工效学,2001,7(3):48-52.
    [43]肖东生.组织错误理论研究的现状与趋势.经济与管理研究.2008(4):23-27.
    [44]彭希平,蔡大成.人的不安全行为难以控制的原因及对策.电力安全技术.2007(4):34-35.
    [45]宋守信,武淑平编著.电力安全人因管理.北京:中国电力出版社.2008.10:70-83.
    [46]毛海峰.有意违章行为动因分析与控制对策探讨.中国安全科学学报.2003,13(2):18-21.
    [47]陈新明.电气误操作的主要原因及预防对策.水利电力劳动保护.2003(2):24-25.
    [48]郭成功.电气误操作事故分析与思考.电力安全技术.2003,5(7):25-26,29.
    [49]王建庆,陶宁平.浅析电气误操作事故的原因及对策.宁夏电力.2007(5):31-32.
    [50]张大伟.电气误操作事故规律初探.电力安全技术.1998(4):27-30.
    [51]杨冲、龙玉勇等.发电企业防止电气误操作的措施及对策.贵州电力技术.2007(9):35-37.
    [52]朱世龙.浅析电气误操作事故的原因及对策.电力安全技术.2002,4(4):26-27.
    [53]袁勇志、奚国泉.期望理论述评.南京理工大学学报(社会科学版).2004(6):25-27.
    [54]乐国安主编.社会心理学理论新编.天津人民出版社.2009,1:3-30.
    [55]王有智,欧阳仑.心理学基础--原理与运用.北京:首都经贸大学出版社.2003:320-337.
    [56]Cattell H-E-P,Schuerger,-J-M.Essentials of 16PF assessment.New York,NY,US,John Wiley and Sons,Inc,2003,307.
    [57]李绍衣.卡特尔16中个性因素测验指导手册.辽宁教育科学研究所.1998.
    [58]Eysenck H J,et al Manual of the Eysenck Personality Scales(EPS Adult).London:Hoddert&Stoughton Publishers,1996.
    [59]金瑜.心理测量.上海:上海华东师范大学出版社.2001:3-25.
    [60]Barbaranelli Claudio,Caprara Gian-Vittorio.How many dimensions to describe personality?.A comparison of Cattell,comrey,and big five taxonomies of personality traits.European Review of Applied Psychology,1996,46(1):15-24.
    [61]马前锋,孔克勤.人格五因素结构研究的新进展.心理科学.1997,20(1):85.
    [62]张智勇,王登峰.论人格特质“大七”因素模型.心理科学.1997,20(1):48-51.
    [63]Harrison R-H.Atypical emotions in relationships as correlates of the MMPI.Journal of Psychology.1994,128(2):165-175.
    [64]邵辉,王凯全.安全心理学.北京:化学工业出版社.2004.5.
    [65]栗继祖.安全心理学.北京:中国劳动社会保障出版社.2007.8.
    [66]周刚,程卫民等.人因失误与人不安全行为相关原理的分析与探讨.中国安全科学学报.2008,18(3):10-14.
    [67]毛海峰.现代安全管理理论与实务.北京:首都经济贸易出版社.2000.8.
    [68]陈宝智.安全原理(第二版).北京:冶金工业出版社.2004.9.
    [69]Frank A.Haight(2001),Accident Proneness:The History of an Idea,Institute of Transportation Studies University of California,http://www.its.uci.edu/its/publications/papers/WP-01-4.pdf.
    [70]隋鹏程.安全原理与事故预测.北京:冶金工业出版社.1988:43-48.
    [71]徐江、吴穹编.安全管理学.北京:航空工业出版社.1993:45.
    [72]崔国璋.安全管理.北京:海洋出版社.1997,35-36.
    [73]Cooper,M.D.Towards a model of safety culture.Safety Science,2000(36):111-136.
    [74]罗云,何谓企业安全文化?中国安全生产报.2005.04.02.
    [75]国际核安全咨询组.安全文化.安全丛书No.75-INSAG-4,原子能出版社.1992.
    [76]Cooper,M.D."Improving Safety Culture:A Practical Guide." Hull,UK:Applied Behavioral Sciences,2001.
    [77]Geller,E.Scott.“Ten Principles for Achieving a Total Safety Culture.” Professional Safety.1994,39(9):9.
    [78]徐德蜀,邱成著.安全文化通论.北京:化学工业出版社.2004.
    [79]罗云.企业安全文化建设.北京:煤炭工业出版社.2007.12.
    [80]Hinze,Rabound P.Safety on Large Building Construction Projects.Journal of Construction Engineering and Management.1988,114(2):286-293.
    [81]Terrero,Nancy,Yates,Janet K.Construction industry safety measures.Cost Engineering (Morgantown,West Virginia),n2,1997,39(2):23-31.
    [82]Embrey D E.SLIM-MAUD:An Approach to Assessing Human Error Probabilities Using Structured Expert Judgment(NUREG / CR-3518)[R].Washington,DC:US Nuclear Regulatory Commission.1984.
    [83]Hanaman G W.Spurgin A J,Lukic Y.Human Cognitive Reliability model for PRA analysis (NUS4531)[R].Draft EPRJ Report,Electric Power Research Institute.1984.
    [84]Williams J C.A Data-based Method for Assessing and Reducing Human Error to Improve Operational Performance[C].Proc.IEEE 4th Human Factor and Power Plants.1988:436-453.
    [85]Barriere M.Technical Basis and Implementation Guidelines for a Technique for Human Event Analysis(ATHEANA)(NUREG-1624)[R].Rev.1,Washington,DC:US Nuclear Regulatory Commission,2000.
    [86]Hollnagel E.Cognitive Reliability and Error Analysis Method(CREAM).Elsevier Science Ltd,1998.
    [87]王文先.对不安全行为的分析与控制.中国矿业.2003,12(7):34-36.
    [88]李万帮、肖东生.事故致因理论述评.南华大学学报:社会科学版.2007,8(1):57-61
    [89]转引自;魏绍敏,田水承,陈勇刚.矿山人因事故的构成要素及分类初步研究.煤炭技术.2003(10):1-2
    [90]曾维华,程声通.环境灾害学引论.北京:中国环境科学出版.2000.
    [91]林泽炎.煤矿工人冒险行为与人为事故的关系分析.人类工效学.1996,(4):25-26,
    [92]Reason J.Human Error.UK,Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,1990.
    [93]Greenwood M,Woods HM.The incidence of industrial accidents upon individuals with special reference to multiple accidents.Industrial Fatigue research Board,Medical Research Committee,Report No.4.Her Britannic Majesty's stationary Office,London,1919:384-389.
    [94]Newbold,E.M.,1926:A Contribution to the Study of the Human Factor in Causation of Accidents.British Industrial Health Research Board,No.34.
    [95]Marbe K:Praktische Psychologies deer Unf(?)lle und Betrieb-sch(?)den.Munich,Springer.1926.
    [96]Farmer E,Chambers EG:A study of accident proneness among motor drivers.Ind Health Res Bd Report No.84,1939.
    [97]Mintz,A.,Blum,M.L.A re-examination of the accident proneness concept.Journal Applied Psychology.1949(33):195-211.
    [98]Willard A.Kerr.Accident proneness of factory departments,Journal of Applied Psychology.Issue 3,1950,34(6):167-170.
    [99]Mohr,D.L.,Clemmer,D.I.The “accident prone” worker an example from heavy industry.Accident Prevention.1988,20(2):123-127.
    [100]Bernacki,E.J.,1976.Accident proneness or accident liability:which model for industry7.Conn.Med.40(8):535-538.
    [101]谭跃进,陈英武,易先进.系统工程原理.长沙:国防科技大学出版社.1999:66-70.
    [102]陶谦坎.系统工程应用案例.北京:机械工业出版社.1990:344-345.
    [103]NEA Committee on the Safety of Nuclear Installations.Critical Operator Actions:Human Reliability Modeling And Data Issues.Principal Working Group No.-Task 94-1.NEA/CSNI/R (98).1998.
    [104]Basra.G.& Kirwan,B.Collection of Offshore Human Error Probability Date.Reliability Engineering and System Safety.1998(61):77-3.
    [105]Germanischer Lloyd & Det Norske Veritas.The Concerted Action an Formal Safety and Environmental Assessment of Ship Operations,WA-96-CA-1155.1999.
    [106]Faruqui,A.Forecasting Industrial Electricity Consumption By End-use,Demand Forecasting for Electric Utilities.The Fairmont Press,Inc.1992.
    [107]许正权,宋学锋,李敏莉.本质安全化管理思想及实证研究框架.中国安全科学学报.2006,16(12):79-85.
    [108]罗云,吕海燕,白福利,事故分析预测与事故管理.北京:化学工业出版社.2006,1:143.
    [109]隋鹏程,陈宝智,隋旭编著,安全原理.北京:化学工业出版社.2005.4:55.
    [110]山东电力集团公司编.安全生产反违章管理手册.山东电力集团公司.2006.6.
    [111]http://baike.baidu.com/view/40544.htm
    [112]张锦、张力.人因失效模式、影响及危害性分析.南华大学学报:理工版.2003,17(2):35-38。42.
    [113]转引自:彭澎、黄曙东.组织管理因素对人因事故的作用与影响.人类工效学.2001,7(2):53-57.
    [114]杜栋,庞庆华.现代综合评价方法与案例精选.北京:清华大学出版社.2005.9:12-19.
    [115]陈梦雪、胡国贞.浅析生产中易出事故的个性和心理因素.教学与科技.2005,18(3):26-30.
    [116]符文琛、令俊华.操作者的性格对事故的影响.工业卫生与职业病.1994,20(1):8-11.
    [117]王维彤.心理因素与安全管理.安全.健康和环境.2005,5(8):23-24.
    [118]周华云.核电厂操纵员的心理健康与事故预防.核安全.2004(2):33-38.
    [119]王贵山、成义仁.煤矿工人工伤事故与心理健康因素的研究.精神医学杂志.2008,21(5):327-329.
    [120]宋守信.事故倾向与人因管理.中国电力企业管理.2003(12):32-33.
    [121]张丽.从安全心理学谈电力全生产.电力安全技术.2008(1):46-47
    [122]张华.浅析员工工作心理状态与安全安生产的关系.科技创新导报.2008(3):147
    [123]廖元文.安全管理与心理疏导.中国电力企业管.2007(2):59-61
    [124]转引自:何长福.改善组织沟通的途径.管理科学文摘.2005(5):39-40.
    [125]查尔斯·E·贝克.管理沟通.北京:中国人民大学出版社.2003:10-11
    [126]赵慧军.管理沟通.北京:首都经济贸易大学出版社.2003:78-82.
    [127]孙建敏.管理中的沟通,北京:企业管理出版社.2004:53-56.
    [128]Schein,E.H.Organization Culture.American Psychologist.1990,45(2):109-119.
    [129]Daniel R.Dension.The Climate,Culture and Effectiveness of Work Organizations:A Study of Organizational Behavior and Financial Performance[D].University of Michigan:Ph.D.Dissretation,1982:53-67.
    [130]王方华编著.现代企业管理.上海:复旦大学出版社.2001:428-432.
    [131]毛海峰.企业安全管理群体行为与动力理论探讨.中国安全科学学报.2004(1):48-52.
    [132]王淑云.群体动力学在企业安全管理中的应用探讨.南华大学学报(社会科学版).2005(2):30-35.
    [133][日]三隅二不二等编著.金会庆等译.事故预防心理学.上海:上海交通大学出版社,1993.5.
    [134][美]斯蒂芬·P·罗宾斯.组织行为学(第10版).北京:中国人民大学出版社.2005.10:260-262.
    [135]Varonen U.,Mattilam.The safety climate and its relationship to safety practices,safety of the work environment and occupational accidents in eight wood processing companies.Journal of Accident Analysis and Prevention,2000,32:761-769.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700