电信运营企业跨国经营目标国选择战略
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
区位决策是企业对外直接投资过程中的首要问题,也是现阶段中国电信运营企业在“走出去”过程中面临的重要决策问题。目标国选择的好坏直接关系到企业跨国经营的成败。电信运营企业深受管制制度影响,各国在电信市场准入制度上的差异使企业能否进入目标国以及以何种地位进入均具有很大的不确定性,而全球移动通信市场逐步趋于饱和更使这种有限的市场进入机遇变得越来越具有竞争性,这使得传统的目标市场选择方法难以满足决策需要,成功的市场进入需要企业从战略视角审视目标国选择问题。本文基于竞争优势理论和FDI区位理论,从电信产业特性出发总结了电信运营企业跨国经营的现状和特点,在案例研究和大样本统计实证研究的基础上,挖掘电信运营企业跨国经营绩效的关键影响因素,并据此构建了目标国选择(TCS)决策模型,以中国移动为例进行了应用研究,为企业跨国经营目标国选择提供战略建议。
     本文的创新点主要有以下三个方面:
     1、对全球20家跨国电信运营企业在152个国家的竞争地位数据进行了统计,探讨了企业跨国经营理论对电信运营企业的适用性。研究发现,电信运营企业跨国经营并不总是从周边国家开始,其区位分布是随各国电信私有化和自由化改革进程的时间顺序进行。经济发展落后、国家风险高的新兴国家正成为投资热点,这与传统目标市场选择方法的结论相悖。现有的文献没有论证殖民地、语言等因素对企业跨国经营区位分布的影响程度,本文运用统计结果区分了各因素在不同区域对不同企业的影响。历史上的殖民地因素在拉丁美洲影响显著,语言和宗教因素在阿拉伯国家影响显著,区域经济一体化因素在欧洲影响显著,在非洲和亚太国家各因素均有影响,但影响程度在逐步弱化,在亚太国家尚没有形成具有区域主导地位的运营商。研究建议企业在跨国经营初期阶段应避免选择这些因素影响显著的区域。
     2、选取了20家跨国电信运营企业从1995年至2009年的162次市场进入行为数据,运用多元回归分析等方法论证了企业进入目标国时的排名是电信运营企业跨国经营绩效的关键影响因素。本文将电信运营企业跨国经营绩效的影响因素分为目标国环境因素和企业市场进入行为两类,提出了各影响因素与绩效之间关系的7项研究假设,设置了相应的10个变量。研究结果表明,3项研究假设得到验证,其中企业进入目标国时的排名与企业跨国经营运营绩效呈显著正相关关系,目标国竞争者数量和进入时移动用户普及率与企业跨国经营绩效呈微弱负相关关系。而与原假设结论相反的是,目标国国家竞争力水平对企业跨国经营财务绩效产生一定负向影响。因此,建议企业选择能取得较高市场进入排名的目标国,选择移动用户普及率低、竞争者数量相对较少的国家并正视目标国国家竞争力水平低可能带来的风险,这一结论为TCS决策模型的指标设置提供了论据。
     3、构建了TCS决策模型,并以中国移动为例对模型进行了应用研究,提供了具体到国家层次的目标国评价结果。本文按跨国经营的不同动因将模型分成寻求市场和追随客户两大类,决策按动因分析、目标国筛选、目标国评估、战略制定四个程序依次进行。现有的电信运营企业目标市场选择文献多是基于区域的选择结果和建议,方法上未考虑市场进入地位不确定情况下各影响因素的不同表现,本文在TCS模型构建过程中综合了前人的研究成果和研究假设的论证结果,在筛选机制中设置定量指标,在评估机制中采用定性定量指标相结合的方法,拓宽了评估范围。在两类决策过程中,分别对191个国家和30个国家样本进行筛选和评估,得到了五组战略方案组合,结果表明,与新加坡电信进行少数股权合作、收购MTN部分股权进入非洲市场、等待埃塞俄比亚和缅甸市场开放机遇在五组方案中相对较优。
Location choice is a primary decision-making problem for enterprises to make foreign direct investment and it is also a key issue facing Chinese telecom operators at their initial stage of implementing the "Going Global" strategy. Whether a target country is well selected or not is directly related to the success or failure of transnational operations of telecom operators. Telecom operators are highly affected by regulation policies. Due to the difference in market entry policies among countries, whether the operators can enter into the market or not and their possible market positions are of great uncertainty. As the global mobile communications market gradually becomes saturated, this limited market entry opportunities become even more competitive. Thus, the existing market selection methods are unable to meet the needs of decision-makers. Successful market entry requires the operators to look into the problem from the strategic perspective. In order to provide a simple and cost-effective method for China's telecom operators, a Target Country Selection (TCS) model is proposed in this dissertation. It is based on the earlier research in the areas of competitive advantage and FDI location theory together with telecom operators'special characteristics in transnational operations. Case studies and large sample statistical empirical research are used to find the relative influencing factors to lay the foundation of indicators for TCS model. China Mobile is selected as an example to apply the model and the suggestions regarding translational operations of the company is given afterwards.
     The main contributions of this dissertation are as follows:
     1. Twenty most internationalized telecom operators are ranked worldwide and their market positions in152countries are illustrated in statistics to analyze the applicability of traditional internationalization theories on telecom operators. Analysis shows that telecom operators chose target countries gradually according to the different regulatory reform timeframe of privatization and liberalization of various countries rather than just starting from neighboring countries. Emerging countries with less developed economy and higher country risks are becoming hotspot for global telecom investors, which are inconsistent with the results of traditional market selection methods. The degree to which extend the influencing factors such as colony, language and other factors have affected the location distribution of telecom operators are not analyzed yet in the existing literatures while this work has been done in this dissertation based on the statistics. Findings suggest that factors play different role in different regions. Latin America is affected significantly by the historical colonial factors. Linguistic and religious factors are important factors in Arab states and regional economic integration factors affected European countries greatly. In African and Asia-Pacific countries, all factors play a less important role as compared with other regions and there is no dominant global telecom operator in Asia-Pacific counties. Therefore, it is suggested that countries which are significantly affected by these factors should be better avoided during the initial stage of investment.
     2. Market entry ranking is tested to be a key influencing factor on the performance of telecom cross-border operations by using multiple regression analysis method based on a sample of162foreign market entry moves conducted by20international telecom operators in the period from1995to2009. Influencing factors are divided into two types including target country environmental factors and operators'market entry behaviors. Seven hypotheses are proposed based on the relationship between factors and performance and10variables are set accordingly. Three hypotheses are finally tested.Among which, market entry ranking is positively correlated with the operators'operational performance while cross-border performance is negatively affected by the number of competitors in the target countries and the mobile penetration rate. However, Indicators of Global Competitive Index display negative affect on the operators'performance, which is different from the hypotheses. Therefore, it is important for operators to select those countries where they can achieve higher entry ranking. Countries with lower mobile penetration rate and relatively smaller number of competitors should be taken into account in selection and their potential risks which may be brought by the low GCI ranking should be addressed. Those results provide foundation for the indicators of TCS model.
     3. A TCS model is established and China Mobile is selected to apply the model and evaluation results are given at a detailed country-level. The model is divided into two types as market seeking and follow-the-client respectively. For each type of model, the decision-making procedure will go through driver analysis, target country selection, target country assessment and strategy development. The existing literatures offer suggestions only on regional bases and fail to consider the difference in the factors resulted from the uncertainty of the possible market access statues the operators may have. While based on the previous research findings and the tested hypothesis, the TCS model adopt quantitative indicators in the screening procedure and make a combination of qualitative and quantitative indicators in the assessment procedure so that the assessment can be largely broadened. In the two types of decision-making process,191countries and30countries are screened and assessed and five groups of strategic options are obtained. Research finding suggest that getting minority interest in Singapore telecom or MTN, paying constant concern to wait for the market opening of Ethiopia and Myanmar are recommended options.
引文
1本论文得到国家自然科学基金项目资助,是“国际化逃程中提升中国电信运营企业国际竞争力途径的研究”(项目批准号:70773012)项目的组成部分。文中脚注与参考文献均以上标数字方式出现,其中参考文献的上标数字外加注了中括号。
    2本文中出现的国外电信运营企业的英文名称、中文译名及常用简称对照在附录Ⅰ中有详细说明。
    3参考了郑园园发表在2002年9月19日《环球时报》中的“疯狂投资失败法国电信负债700亿”一文。
    8参考了2004年7月28日《通信世界》“中国电信业‘走出去’的背后是什么”一文。
    14北京邮电大学经济管理学院电信企业跨国经营相关硕士论文包括:①张莹,中国电信运营企业跨国并购战略研究,2007年3月;②赵卫卫,电信运营企业海外扩张中的资本运作,2007年10月;③晏建,中国电信运营企业的国际化现状及对策研究,2008年3月;④丁婕,电信运营商国际化战略决策模型研究,2009年2月;⑤张里,中国电信企业国际化实证研究,2009年2月。
    15参考了2006年华中科技大学黄雅俊的硕士论文。
    16参考了2004年7月28日《通信世界》“中国电信业‘走出去’的背后是什么”一文。
    26参考了林敏发表在2002年9月17日《通信信息报》中的“中国电信获美牌照有利提供全球‘一站式’服务”一文。
    27参考自古晓宇“在中国移动在台子公司获批成立”的报道,文章发表红2010年5月12日的《京华时报》。
    28参考自马勇“沃达丰出售中国移动3.2%股权套现447亿元”的报道,文章发表在2010年9月9日的《羊城晚报》。
    29资料参考中国移动官方网站http://10086.cn/aboutus/intro/200907/t2009072712053.htm。
    30参考自明叔“中国移动止步Millicom"的报道,文章发表在2006年7月10日的《互联网周刊》。
    33中国移动巴基斯坦案例数据来自巴基斯坦电信管理局PTA2007,2008,2009,2010年年报。
    34郭永宏,中国移动巴基斯坦首席执行官。他对于中田移动巴基斯坦的运营经验总结方面可参见文献[130],
    “巴基斯坦与中国电信业的主要差异”,“巴基斯坦电信业监管政策及其对运营商的影响”,以及2008年通信世界网对他的采访“中国移动巴基斯坦公司CEO:爱拼才会赢”等相关文献及报道。
    35观点参考自马晓芳“王建宙五进巴基斯坦中国移动突围田际化”的报道,文章发表在2010年6月23日的《第一财经日报》。
    57参考自FitchRatings,Rating European Telecoms Companies, Telecommunications Europe Special Report,Feb.2010
    59参考自Fitch Ratings, Telecommunications Asia Pacific Special Report:Impact of Regulation on Free Cash Flow and Ratings, Dec.1,2009.
    64观点来自与印度电信专家Chowdary在北邮进行的交流。
    65参考了2010年5月《第一财经日报》中马晓芳的撰文“华为的‘印度式’成长:禁售源于华为的强大”
    [1]朱金周.电信竞争力——评价与对策[M].北京:北京邮电大学出版社.2006.
    [2]司先秀.“走出去”,该去哪?国外先进运营商选择目标国的经验[J].当代通信,2005(22).
    [3]吴洪,黄秀清,苑春荟.通信经济学第2版[M].北京:北京邮电大学出版社,2007.
    [4]Trillas, F.Mergers, acquisitions and control of telecommunications firms in Europe[J]. Telecommunications Policy,2002,(26):269-286.
    [5]Curwen,P.,Whalley,J. Mobile Telecommunications in a High-Speed World [M].UK:Gower Publishing Ltd.2010.
    [6]曾剑秋Globalization and Competitiveness in the Telecommunications Industry[M].北京:北京邮电大学出版社,2004.
    [7]郭小红.李跃诠释中国移动走出去战略将围绕3个市场[J].中国电信业,2005.
    [8]Laanti, R. J. Internationalisation Strategies of Companies in Service Industries:A Study of National Telecommunication Operators from Small and Open Economies (SMOPECs)[D]. University of Adelaide,2009.
    [9]Jakopin N. M., Internationalisation in the telecommunications services industry: Literature review and research agenda [J].Telecommunications Policy,2008, (32): 531-544.
    [10]Anwar, S.T. Vodafone and the wireless industry:A case in market expansion and global strategy[J]. Journal of Business & Industrial Marketing,2003, (18).
    [11]Turner, C. The international strategies of Europe's incumbent telecom-munications operators:towards a strategic typology [J].European Business Review,2005, (17):340-351.
    [12]Sarkar, M.B., Cavusgil, S.T., & Aulakh, P.S.International expansion of telecom-munications carriers:The influence of market structure, network characteristics, and entry imperfections [J]. Journal of International Business Studies,1999,30(2): 361-382.
    [13]Curwen,P., Whalley,J. Measuring internationalisation in the mobile telecom-munications industry[J].International Business Review,2006, (15):660-681.
    [14]Curwen,P., Whalley,J. The restructuring of African mobile telecommunications provision and the prospects for economic development[J]. Info,2011,13(2):53-71.
    [15]Gerpott, T.J., & Jakopin, N. M. The degree of internationalization and the financial performance of European mobile network operators[J]. Telecommuni-cations Policy,2005(29):635-661.
    [16]Gerpott, T.J., & Jakopin, N. M.Firm and target country characteristics as factors explaining wealth creation from international expansion moves of mobile network operators[J]. Telecommunications Policy,2007,(31):72-92.
    [17]Pogrebnyakov, N.Internationalization of mobile telecommunications operators: country factors, institutional distance and regional effects [C]. America conference on information systems (AMCIS) 2007 Proceedings,2007.
    [18]弗柯,覃韦杰.浅论中国电信运营业的国际化战略[J].当代通信,2005,(2).
    [19]孙倩.中国电信企业国际化经营的战略分析[J].管理现代化,2006,(4).
    [20]贾永嘉.中国电信运营企业跨国经营问题研究[D].北京师范大学博士论文.2005.
    [21]许可.国际电信运营商的海外战略分析及其对中国移动国际化战略的启示[R].2004.
    [22]叶小忠.关于中国电信业“走出去”战略的几点认识[J].当代通信,2005,(16):36-38.
    [23]姚群峰.中国电信企业国际化的战略路径分析[J].世界电信,2005,(9):27-30.
    [24]孙一平,齐佳音,舒华英.电信运营企业的国际化运营[J].重庆邮电学院学报(社会科学版),2006,(5).
    [25]李亚林.信息产业“走出去”战略的现状、意义及对策[J].中国通信,2009,(7):14-16.
    [26]赵保国,李卫卫.电信运营商国际化战略研究[M].北京:北京邮电大学出版社,2010..
    [27]Anwar, S.T. Vodafone and the wireless industry:A case in market expansion and global strategy. Journal of Business & Industrial Marketing [J],2003,(18): 270-288.
    [28]曾剑秋.网和天下——三网融合理论、实验与信息安全[M].北京:北京邮电大学出版社.2010.
    [29][1] Lijphart,A.Comparative politics and the comparative method.The American Political Science Review.1971,65(3).
    [30]李怀祖.管理研究方法论[M].西安:西安交通大学出版社,2004.
    [31]梁雄健,杨瑞祯.电信组织管理[M].北京:人民邮电出版社,1999.
    [32]徐德辰.跨国经营的国际比较研究[D].吉林大学博士论文,2005.
    [33]吴先明.中国企业对外直接投资论[M].北京:经济科学出版社,2003.
    [34]Hymer. S.H. The International Operations of National Firms:A Study of Direct Foreign Investment[D], Cambridge,Mass:MIT,1960.
    [35]Dunning, J.H.Non-Equity Forms of Foreign Economic Involvement and the Theory of International Production, Re search in International Business and Finance, Part A [M], JAI Press Inc.,1984.
    [36]文余源.FDI理论与区位决策研究述评[J].地理科学进展,2008,(3).
    [37]Caves, R.E. Multinational Enterprise and Economic Analysis[M]. Cambridge: Cambridge Uminversity Press,1982.
    [38]Johnson, H.G. Comparative Cost and Commercial Policy Theroy for a Developing World Economy[M]. Stockholm:Almqvist & Wiksell,1968.
    [39]Buckley, P.J., Casson, M. The Future of Multinational Enterprise [M], London and Basingstoke:The Macmillan Press Ltd,1976.
    [40]Vernon, R. International Investment and International Trade in the Product Cycle [J]. The Quarterly Journal of Economics,1966,80(2):190-207.
    [41]Kojima, K. Direct Foreign Investment:A Japanese Model of Multinational Business Operations [M]. London:Groom Helm,1978.
    [42]Wells, L.T. Third World Multinationals[M].Cambridge, Mass:MIT Press,1983.
    [43]Lall, S. The New Multinationals:the Spread of Third World Enterprises[M]. New York:John Wiley & Sons,1983.
    [44]Knickerbocker, F. F. Oligopolistic Reaction and the Multinational Enterprise [M]. Boston:Harvard University Press,1973.
    [45]Bell J. Single or Joint Venturing? A Comprehensive Approach to Foreign Entry Mode Choice[M]. Avebury, Brookfield, USA,1996.
    [46]Hill, C.P. Hwang & W. Kim. An Eclectic Theory of the Choice of International Entry Mode [J]. Strategic Management Journal,1990, (11):117-128.
    [47]迈克尔·波特.竞争优势[M].陈小悦译.北京:华夏出版社.2005.
    [48]Dussage, P. Garrette B. Determinants of Success in International Strategic Alliances:Evidence from the Global Aerospace Industry [J]. Journal of International Business Studies,1995,26(3):505-530.
    [49]Harrigan, K. Strategic Alliances:Their New Role in Global Competition[J]. Columbia Journal of World Business,1987,22(2):67-69.
    [50]Johansson & Wiedersheim, P.F. The Internationalization of the firm:Four Swedish cases[J]. Journal of Manangement Studies,1975,12(3):305-322.
    [51]Johanson,J. & Vahlne, J.E. The internationalization process of the firm:A model of knowledge development and increasing foreign market commitment [J]. Journal of International Business Studies.1977,8(2):23-32.
    [52]丁祥生.中国企业的对外直接投资:优势、动因与战略选择[D].南开大学博士论文,2009.
    [53]迈克尔·波特.国家竞争优势[M].李明轩,邱如美译.北京:华夏出版社.2002.
    [54]马亚明,张岩贵.寡头竞争、策略互动与对外直接投资[J].世界经济,2002,(04):38-43.
    [55]Cantwell, J.A. Tolentino, P.E.E. Technological Accumulation and Third World Multinationals. University of Reading Discussion Paper in International Investment and Business Studies,1990:139.
    [56]马亚明,张岩贵.策略竞争与发展中国家的对外直接投资[J].南开经济研究, 2000,(04):29-32.
    [57]国务院发展研究中心企业研究所课题组.中国企业国际化战略[M].北京:人民出版社,2006.
    [58]联合国贸发会议.2006年世界投资报告——来自发展中经济体和转型经济体的外国直接投资:对发展的影响[M].冼国明等译.北京:中国财政经济出版社,2007.
    [59]Qian,L.H. & Delios A. Internalization and experience:Japanese banks' international expansion,1980-1998[J]. Journal of International Business Studies,2008(39):231-248.
    [60]Teece, D.; Piasno G. and Shuen, A.Dynamic Capabilities and Strategic Management[J]. Strategic Management Journal,1997,18 (7):509-533.
    [61]马刚.企业竞争优势的内涵界定及其相关理论评述[J].经济评论,2006,(1).
    [62]陆淳鸿.企业竞争优势理论演进评述[J].经济问题,2007,(4).
    [63]迈克尔·波特.竞争战略[M].陈小悦译.北京:华夏出版社,2005.
    [64]蒋峦,谢卫红,蓝海林.企业竞争优势理论综述[J].软科学,2005,19(4):15-18.
    [65]葛京,杨莉,李武.跨国企业集团管理[M].北京:机械工业出版社,2002.
    [66]晏双生.跨国公司竞争优势的理论演进述评[J].科技管理研究,2007,(4)
    [67]Buckley,P.J., Devinney, T.M., & Louviere J.J. Do managers behave the way theory suggests? A choice-theoretic examination of foreign direct investment location decision-making [J]. Journal of International Business Studies.2007, (38):1069-1094.
    [68]毛蕴诗.20世纪的国际直接投资理论及发展述评(上)[J].南方经济,1996,(6).
    [69]张娟.中国企业对外直接投资的区位选择研究:基于价值链的视角[M].上海:上海社会科学院出版社,2008.
    [70]王利华.中国跨国公司对外直接投资区位选择研究[D].华东师范大学博士论文.2009.
    [71]鲁明泓.制度因素与国际直接投资区位分布:一项实证研究[J].经济研究,1999,(7).
    [72]鲁明泓.国际直接投资区位决定因素[M].南京:南京大学出版社,2000.
    [73]宋刚.知识经济时代国际直接投资的区位选择[J].经济体制改革,2002,(3).
    [74]姜国杰.世界外国直接投资的特点及区位因素分析[J].国际贸易问题,2002,(7).
    [75]张为付.中国企业对外直接投资的区位选择和路径安排[J].国际贸易问题,2006,(7).
    [76]陈秋敏.关于发展中国家对外直接投资理论的思考[J].国际商务,2000,(6).
    [77]Porter, M. E. Clusters and the new economics of competitiveness [J]. Harvard Business Review,1998,(12):77-90.
    [78]Ellison, G., & Glaeser, E. L. The geographic concentration of industry:Does natural advantage explain agglomeration?[J] The American Economic Review, 1999,89(2):311-316.
    [79]Woodward,D.P. and Rolfe,R.J. The location of exportoriented foreign direct investment in the Caribbean basin[J] Journal of International Business Studies,1993,24(1):121-144.
    [80]Barkema, H.G.,Bell,J.H.J. and Pennings,J.M. Foreign entry,culture barriers and learning[J]. Strategic Management Journal,1996,17(2):151-166.
    [81]Chandprapalert,A. The determinants of US direct investment in Thailand:a survey of managerial perspectives[J]. Multinational Business Review,2000,8(2):82-88.
    [82]Mitra,D. and Golder,P.N. Whose culture matters?Near-market knowledge and its impact on foreign market entry timing[J] Journal of Marketing Research,2002, 39(3):350-365.
    [83]程惠芳,阮翔.用引力模型分析中国对外直接投资的区位选择[J].世界经济,2004,(14).
    [84]马先仙.我国企业对外直接投资的区位选择[J].国际商务,2006,(1).
    [85]胡博,李凌.我国对外直接投资的区位选择——基于投资动机的视角[J].国际贸易问题,2008,(12).
    [86]刘凤根.FDI投资区位的决定因素的实证——来自中国对外直接投资的经验数据[J].科学决策,2009,(7).
    [87]Stobaugh, R.B.How to analyze Foreign Investment Climates[J]? Harvard Business Review,1969,(9):102.
    [88]郭波.国际投资:理论·政策·战略——以中国利用外资与对外投资为视角[M].北京:中国社会科学出版社,2009.
    [89]王慧炯,闵建蜀等.中国的投资环境[M].香港:京港学术交流中心,1987.
    [90]Klaus Schwab,et al. The Global Competitiveness Report 2010-2011[R].Geneva: World Economic Forum,2011.
    [91]迈克尔·波特,泽维尔·萨拉-艾-马丁,克劳斯·施瓦布.2007-2008全球竞争力报告[M].杨世伟,高闯等译.北京:经济管理出版社.2009.
    [92]中国出口信用保险公司编著.国家风险分析报告2010[M].北京:中国财政经济出版社.2010.
    [93]Gerpott, T.J., & Jakopin, N. M.Determinants of mobile network operators' choice of cross-border entry modes,17th European Regional ITS Conference[C], 2005.
    [94]Curwen, P.,&Whalley, J.Mobile operators in the new millennium-retrospect and prospect[J]. Info,2010,12(3):30-45.
    [95]Whalley, J., & Curwen, P. An investigation into internationalisation among mobile telecommunication companies in 2003[J].Info,2005,7(4):21-29.
    [96]Curwen, P.,&Whalley, J.Merging incumbent European mobile operators:veni, vidi, non vici[J]. Info,2009,11(4):34-52.
    [97]Curwen, P. & Whalley, J. Telecommunications Strategy:Cases, Theory and Applications [M]. Routledge, Oxford,2004.
    [98]Curwen, P., Whally,J. The internationalisation of mobile telecommunications: strategic challenges in a global market.[M].Cheltenham:Edward Elgar,2008.
    [99]赵保国,李卫卫.电信运营商国际化战略研究[M].北京:北京邮电大学出版社,2010.
    [100]Clegg, J.,&Kamall, S. The internationalization of telecommunications services firms in the European Union[J]. Transnational Corporations,1998,7(2):39-96.
    [101]ITU. World Telecommunication Development Report[R].Geneva,1997.
    [102]Kim, W.S., Lee, M., Kim., K.D. Strategic differentiation of international-lization in the mobile telecommunications industry:case studies [J]. ETRI Journal,2009,31(1).
    [103]王映.我国政府对电信企业走出去的政策支持[J].当代通信,2005,(23).
    [104]王淑敏,廖忠双.中国电信企业如何“走出去”[J].中国新通信,2007,(7):75.
    [105]蔡莹,刘丽丹,唐守廉.中国移动怎样走出去[J]?通信企业管管理.2006,(1):60-62.
    [106]莫听玮.市场进入模式与中国电信运营商的国际化[J].中国通信,2009,(7).
    [107]史炜.中国电信服务业的市场化演进[J].中国工业经济,2002,(7).
    [108]史炜.体制因素制约电信公司“走出去”战略[J].世界电信,2005,(10).
    [109]肖云.对我国电信运营商融资策略的思考[J].世界电信,2004,(10).
    [110]许可.电信运营商国际化战略的制定方法探讨[J].世界电信,2004,(8).
    [111]石军.法国电信国际化:在探索中前行[J].世界电信,2007,(7):47-49.
    [112]梁雄健,杨瑞祯.电信组织管理[M].北京:人民邮电出版社,1999.
    [113]李苑,曾剑秋.有壁垒,才有创新[J]?中国通信,2009,(5).
    [114]ITU.Trends in telecommunications reform[R]. Geneva:International Telecom-munications Union,2010.
    [115]Curwen,P.,Whalley,J. Mobile Telecommunications in a High-Speed World [M].UK:Gower Publishing Ltd.2010
    [116]Kramer,A.D,Cellphone Operator Moves to Expand Beyond Russia[N].New York Times,2010-10-04.
    [117]Lioyd,I.,Mellor, D通信法.[M].曾剑秋译.北京:北京邮电大学出版社.2006.
    [118]周道平.全球电信市场开放趋势及对策研究[J].现代电信科技.2007,(4).
    [119]UNCTAD.World Investment Report 2011[R].United Nations.New York and Geneva.2011.
    [120]Hacklin, F.Management of Convergence in Innovation:Strategies and Capa-bilities for Value Creation Beyond Blurring Industry Boundaries[M], Physica-Verlag,2008.
    [121]孙倩.中国电信业管制制度的选择[D].对外经济贸易大学博士论文,2004.
    [122]徐传谌,孟繁颖.制度变迁内部动力机制分析[J].税务与经济,2006,(6):15-20.
    [123]曾剑秋.电信产业发展概论[M].北京:北京邮电大学出版社,2001.
    [124]尹柳营,辛钢平.我国电信管制制度的变迁及发展趋势[J].通信企业管理,2006,(10):50-51.
    [125]严涉.中国移动提速国际化步伐[J].中国投资,2005,(12).
    [126]Gao,P.,Rafiq,A.The transformation of the mobile telecommunications industry in Pakistan:A developing country perspective[J]. Telecommunications Policy,2009,(33):309-323.
    [127]Ramamurti,R.Risks and Rewards in the Globalization of Telecommunications in Emerging Economies[J]. Journal of World Business.2000,35(2).
    [128]Hung,C.L, Yeh,S.Y.Why i-mode Moved Slowly in the Overseas Markets? A Perspective from Institutional Differences[C].IEEE International Conference on Management of Innovation and Technology,2006.
    [129]李珊珊.移动巨头沃达丰兵败日本 我行我素自酿苦果[N].IT时代周刊.2006-05-11.
    [130]索世儒,郭永宏.巴基斯坦与中国电信业的主要差异[J].电信技术,2008,(2).
    [131]商务部,国家统计局,国家外汇管理局.2010年度中国对外直接投资统计公报[R].2011.
    [132]张宇燕,田丰.新兴经济体的界定及其在世界经济格局中的地位[J].国际经济评论.2010,(4).
    [133]黄长著.全球化背景下的世界诸语言:使用及分布格局的变化[J].国外社会科学.2009,(6).
    [134]陈王,龙诗.区域经济一体化对国家发展战略的影响[J].经济导刊.2010,(9).
    [135]Gerpott, T.J., & Jakopin, N. M.. International marketing standardization and financial performance of mobile network operators-an empirical analysis.Schmalenbach Business Review,2005,(57):198-228.
    [136]析展红.现代信息经济与产业规制[M].北京:北京邮电大学出版社.2008.
    [137]IMF. Direction of Trade Statistics Yearbook [R].US:International Monetary Fund,2010.
    [138]张龙,王文博,曹培慎.计量经济学[M].北京:清华大学出版社北京交通大学出版社,2010.
    [139]邱皓政.量化研究与统计分析[M].重庆:重庆大学出版社.2009.
    [140]商务部,国家统计局,国家外汇管理局.2009年度中国对外直接投资统计公报[R].2010.
    [141]Steven R. P. On The Internationalization of European Wireless Telecom-munications Service Providers[C]. In Wireless Telecommunications Symposium, WTS 2009,2009.
    [142]冯劲,代吉林.战略管理理论综述:竞争理论与资源观的理论纷争与融合[J].现代管理科学,2007,(3):50-52.
    [143]Lloyd,I.,& Mellor, D.通信法[M].曾剑秋译.北京:北京邮电大学出版社,2006.
    [144]李荣华,傅天明,欧阳晓风.中国移动“一家独大”的经济学分析[J].财经科学,2007,(6).
    [145]Gao P., Rafiq, A. The transformation of the mobile telecommunications industry in Pakistan:A developing country perspective[J].Telecommunications Policy, 2009,(33):309-323.
    [146]UNCTAD.Handbook of Statistics 2010[R].United Nations.New York and Geneva.2010.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700