用户名: 密码: 验证码:
突发群体事件演化及其应对预案构建研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
突发群体事件(Mass Emergency)是当前社会转型阶段影响社会稳定和公共安全的一个重要因素,其应对效力是考验政府执政能力的关键指标。正确认识和处理突发性群体性事件,对于确保社会平稳运行、减少社会损失、维护社会稳定、构建和谐社会,具有重大的现实意义。现有的突发群体事件应对预案体系在处置突发群体事件中发挥了一定积极作用,但是也暴露出在预案措施针对性、操作性方面的欠缺,需要结合突发群体事件演化特点对应对预案进行体系构建。
     本文把突发群体事件看作一个复杂自组织系统,运用自组织理论和演化博弈理论来对突发群体事件演化过程的实质进行动态研究。在突发群体事件演化分析地基础上运用案例推理理论和情景分析方法提出突发群体事件应对预案构建体系。考虑到突发群体事件具有事先难以预测、甚至无法预测,但又需要紧急处理的特点;考虑到突发群体事件关系错综复杂,需要剖析其演化实质的需求;考虑到突发群体事件应对预案对突发群体事件应急管理具有提前准备和支持作用,本文基于管理学、社会学、计算机科学、复杂系统科学等领域的基础理论,对突发群体事件演化和应对预案体系构建进行了详细的探讨。论文内容主要包括:
     (1)支撑突发群体事件演化和应对预案构建研究的基础理论分析。对突发群体事件进行了系统分析,分析了自组织理论和演化博弈方法用于支撑突发群体事件演化规律及模型的基础理论,提出了突发群体事件演化博弈的基准模型。分析了情景分析方法和案例推理方法用于支撑应对预案构建研究的基础理论及两种方法的结合模式。
     (2)突发群体事件演化模型研究。在突发群体事件典型案例剖析的基础上,分析了突发群体事件演化的自组织静态结构和演化博弈动态流程,在此基础上提出了突发群体事件综合演化模型;分析了影响突发群体事件演化的主要指标,提出了突发群体事件演化的影响指标体系。此部分研究为突发群体事件的应急管理和应对预案构建研究提供了基础支撑。
     (3)突发群体事件应对的“案例-情景-预案”构建体系结构。在突发群体事件系统演化模型基础上,提出了突发群体事件应急管理的规律和指导思想,提出了一种突发群体事件应急管理体系框架,并阐明了应对预案在其中的关系和地位;提出了基于案例推理的应对的“案例-情景-预案”构建体系框架:构建了突发群体事件应对预案内容模型和基于案例推理的应对预案系统实现模型,并研究和分析了构成模型的应对预案情景特征提取模块等五个子模块的功能和相互关系。
     (4)突发群体事件应对的“案例-情景-预案”构建途径。在应对的“案例-情景-预案”构建体系结构基础上,运用情景分析方法、案例推理方法及相关计算机系统索引、检索、匹配方法,研究了突发群体事件应对预案体系中五个子模块的实现思路和途径,其中提出了应对预案系统案例描述结构框架及各子结构描述方法,设计了应对预案系统索引模块、案例检索模块、用户接口模块的实现方法,并基于情景分析法,给出应对预案系统案例生成流程框架。
     (5)突发群体事件应对方案实时生成和验证。详细阐述了突发群体事件应对方案生成过程,并以瓮安事件及S市新发生突发群体事件为案例,对本文提出的突发群体事件应对预案系统的实施进行验证。
     运用自组织理论和演化博弈理论对突发群体事件进行演化分析,在此基础上运用案例推理理论和情景分析方法提出突发群体事件应对预案构建体系,对于剖析突发群体事件演化实质,构建具有针对性、操作性的应对预案体系,对地方政府有效应对突发群体事件具有重要的理论和现实意义,使事件的演化过程能得以控制,保证社会的稳定和公共的安全。
Mass Emergency is one important factor that influences the social stability and social security in the present period of social transition. Mass Emergency is also a crucial point that testing the executive ability of government. Correctly realizing and dealing with outburst Mass Emergency, it is of great real significance to ensure social stability, reduce social lost, maintain social stability and build harmonious society. The prior Mass Emergency preplan system has a certain positive function in dealing with the outburst Mass Emergency, but the shortcomings in pertinence and operation of the preplan are also exposed. Therefore, the preplan should be systematically constructed according to the evolutionary features of Mass Emergency.
     The paper serves Mass Emergency as a complex self-organizing system, and it does the dynamic research on the essence of Mass Emergency evolutionary process by applying the self-organizing theory and evolutionary game theory. Based on the analysis of Mass Emergency evolution, the Mass Emergency preplan constructure system is proposed by using the case-based reasoning theory and the scenario analysis method. Considering that Mess Emergency is characterized in difficult forecasting or even incapable of forecasting but requiring emergency disposal, considering that the relation of Mass Emergency is complex and needs to take apart the evolutionary essence, considering that the Mass Emergency preplan has the advanced preparing and supporting function to the Mass Emergency management, the paper, based on the basic theory in the field of management, social science, computer science and science of complexity, makes a detailed discussion on the evolutionary process and emergency preplan system of Mass Emergency. The main content of the paper comprises:
     (1) The basic theory analysis supporting the evolution of Mass Emergency and the constructing research of the emergency preplan. The Mass Emergency is systematically analyzed. The self-organizing theory and evolutionary game method are analyzed for supporting the basic theory of Mass Emergency evolutionary rules and of models. A reference model of the Mass Emergency evolutionary game is proposed. The scenario analysis method and case-based reasoning method for supporting the basic theory of emergency preplan constructing research are analyzed, and the combined mode of the two methods is also analyzed.
     (2) The research on the Mass Emergency evolutionary model. Based on the typical case analysis of the Mass Emergency, the self-organizing static structure and evolutionary game dynamic flow of Mass Emergency evolution are analyzed, based on which, the integrated evolutionary model of Mass Emergency is proposed. In addition, the main index influenced the Mass Emergency evolution is analyzed, and the influenced index system of Mass Emergency evolution is put forward. The research of this portion provides a basic support for the research of the emergency management and preplan construction of Mass Emergency.
     (3) The structure of preplan“case-scenario-preplan”system of Mass Emergency. Based on the evolutionary model of Mass Emergency system, the rule and directing ideology of the emergency management of Mass Emergency are proposed, and an emergency management system frame of Mass Emergency is proposed. The relation and position of the emergency preplan in the frame are illustrated. The preplan“case-scenario-preplan”system frame based on the case-based reasoning is put forward, and the preplan content model and case-based reasoning preplan actualizing model of Mass Emergency are built. The pick-up module of preplan scenario feature formed the model is studied and analyzed, and the function and mutual relation among the five branch modules are also studied and analyzed.
     (4) Constructing approach of preplan“case-scenario-preplan”of Mass Emergency. Based on the structure of preplan“case-scenario-preplan”system of Mass Emergency, the achieving thought and approach of the five branch modules in the Mass Emergency preplan system are studied by using scenario analysis, case-based reasoning method and relative indexing, searching and matching methods in computer system. The descriptive frame of preplan system case and the branch structural descriptive methods are put forward. The actualizing method of preplan system index module, case searching module and user interface module is designed. In addition, based on the scenario analysis, the generating flow frame of preplan system case is presented.
     (5) Realtime generation and validation of Mass Emergency preplan. The generating process of Mass Emergency preplan is illustrated in full detail. Taking Weng’an Mass Incident and the Mass Emergency currently occurred in S city as cases, the implement of Mass Emergency preplan system can be validated.
     The Mass Emergency can be analyzed in evolution by using self-organizing theory and evolutionary game theory, based on which, the Mass Evolution preplan system can be put forward by using case-based reasoning theory and scenario analysis theory. For analyzing the evolutionary essence of Mass Emergency and constructing the preplan system with pertinence and operation, it has a great theoretical and real significance for local government to deal with Mass Emergence effectively, thereby the evolutionary process of the emergency can be controlled, and the social stability and security can be ensured.
引文
1王中汝.我国现行利益表达机制运行中存在的问题.理论参考. 2006,(2): 51~52.
    2王飞跃.平行系统方法与复杂系统的管理和控制.控制与决策. 2004, 19(3): 485~489
    3陈月生.群体性突发事件构成要素、特征和类型的舆情视角.理论月刊. 2006,(2):82~85
    4艾伦.艾萨克.政治学概论.台湾:五南图书出版公司. 1993
    5孟庆英.群体性事件的诱因及预防.理论探索. 2006,(6):136~138
    6张建勇.论群体性突发事件的产生原因及有效防范.兰州学刊. 2004, (3): 901~902
    7夏国章.行政管理学.广州:中山大学出版社. 1998:100~101
    8徐寅峰,刘德海.群体性突发事件产生根源的主观博弈分析.预测.2004, (6): 43~45
    9王来华.舆情研究概论——理论、方法和现实热点.天津:天津社会科学院出版社. 2003:336
    10董清民.人民内部突发性群体矛盾的特点及处理原则.理论前沿. 1999, (3):7~9
    11张国亮.关于妥善处置群体性突发事件的理性思考.河北省社会主义学院学报.2005, 7(3):30
    12张玉磊.当前我国群体性突发事件的六大特征.党政干部学刊. 2008, (10): 60~61
    13杨连专.论突发群体事件的法治防范与控制机制.昆明理工大学学报. 2008, (3):21~52
    14方善诗.当前突发群体事件的特点、成因探析.中共合肥市委党校学报. 2003, (2):23~25
    15王来华,陈月生.论群体性突发事件的基本含义、特征和类型.理论与现代化. 2006,(5):80~84
    16潘晶安.论公安机关对群体性事件处置的传播致效因素.中国人民公安大学学报(社会科学版). 2006,(2):95~98
    17张爱民.当前我国突发群体事件的特点及效应评价.世纪桥. 2007,(7):47~48
    18刘旭东.群体性事件深度剖析.党政论坛. 2009,(1):44~46
    19张百杰.群体性事件的理论阐述.辽宁公安司法管理干部学院学报. 2005, (5):34~36
    20 Stallings R.A., Schepart C.B. Contrasting Local Government Response to a Tornado Disaaater in Two Communities. In: R. T. Sylves, W. L. Wagh, ed, Cities and Disaster: North American Studies in Emergency Management. 1990: 75~90
    21胡宁生.中国政府形象战略.北京:中共中央党校出版社. 1999: 1173~1177
    22花蓉,付春江.社会转型期群体事件产生的心理原因探析.江西师范大学学报. 2005,(3):94~97
    23王战军.群体性事件的界定及其多维分析.政法学刊. 2006,(5):9~13
    24于建嵘.中国的社会泄愤事件与管制困境.当代世界与社会主义. 2008, (1): 4~9
    25童星,张海波.群体性突发事件及其治理——社会风险与公共危机综合分析框架下的再考量.学术界. 2008,(2):35~45
    26 Denis S, Dominic E. Crisis Management: Systems and Structures for Prevention and Recovery. Oxford:Routledge. 2006:67~68
    27陈福今,唐铁汉.公共危机管理.北京:人民出版社. 2006:30
    28余潇枫.非传统安全与公共危机治理.浙江大学出版社. 2007:101~106
    29刘旭东.群体性事件深度剖析.党政论坛. 2009,(1):44~46
    30王志尧.关于基层政府如何处理群体性事件的思考.法制与经济. 2009, (1): 112~113
    31李朝智.群体性突发事件的有效处置方法.领导科学. 2008,(18):13~14
    32金建萍.和谐社会视域中的突发群体事件治理方略.四川行政学院学报. 2006,(4):66~69
    33于建嵘.社会泄愤事件反思.双周刊. 2008,(15):20~22
    34杨丽荣.传染病模型在群体性事件研究中的应用.高校理科研究:87
    35童星,张海波.群体性突发事件及其治理——社会风险与公共危机综合分析框架下的再考量.学术界. 2008,(2): 35~45
    36 Federal Response Plan (FRP). http://fema.gov/pdf/rrr/frp/.
    37 Hoetmer G J. Emergency Management: Principles and Practice for Local Government. International City Management Association, Washington, DC. 1991: 23~124
    38计雷,池宏,陈安.突发事件应急管理.北京:高等教育出版社. 2006:24~25
    39 SEMS: Standardized Emergency Management System. http://www.fema.Gov.
    40 National Response Team. Incident Command System/ Unified Command ( ICS/UC) . Technical Assistant Document, http://www. nrt.org/ production
    41蒋珩,佘廉.区域突发公共事件应急联合组织体系研究.武汉理工大学学报. 2007,(10):595~598
    42童星,张海波.中国转型期的社会风险及其识别.南京:南京大学出版社. 2007: 26~30
    43严利,叶鹏飞,赵燕.突发事件应急法制体系的国际比较与框架设计.中国管理科学. 2006,(10):794~800
    44杨连专.论突发群体事件的法治防范与控制机制.昆明理工大学学报. 2008, (3): 21~52
    45翟晓敏,盛昭瀚,何建敏.应急研究综述与展望.系统工程理论与实践. 1998,(7):17~24
    46胡宁生.中国政府形象战略.北京:中共中央党校出版社. 1999:36~38
    47帅向华,成小平,姜立新.基于ArcView的地震应急快速响应信息系统.地震. 2001, 21(4):94~99
    48姜立新,帅向华.地震应急指挥管理信息系统的探讨.地震. 2003, 23(2): 115~120
    49刘铁民.突发事件应急指挥系统与联合指挥.中国公共安全. 2006,(3): 31~35
    50薛澜,张强,钟开斌.危机管理——转型期中国面临的挑战.北京:清华大学出版社. 2003:45~46
    51刘铁民.重大事故应急指挥系统(ICS)框架与功能.中国安全生产科学技术. 2007,(4):3~7
    52 Uriel Rosenthal, Bert Pijnenburg. Crisis Management and Decision Making. Kluwer Academic Publishers. 1991
    53 G. A. Klein, et, al. Decision Models: Some Lessons From the Field. IEEE Transaction on SMC. 1991,21(5):101~106
    54 Tsoglin Y. L., Klimenko IA. Ukraine Early Warning. Nuclear Engineering International.1995,40(490):31~33
    55 Salvatore Belardo, John Harrald. A Framework for the Application of Group Decision Systems to the Problem of Planning for Catastrophe Events. IEEE Transactions on the Engineering Management. 1992, 39(4):400~411
    56欧盟FP6应急信息平台项目网站.http://www.eu-orchestra.org/
    57欧盟GMES项目网站, http://www.gmes.info/,2003.12.20
    58美国国家应急管理系统NIMS网站,http://www.fema.gov/ emergency/ nims/ index.shtm,2004.1.12
    59美国USC/ISI突发事件研究中心网站, http://crue.isi.edu,2004.2.13
    60美国国家标准技术局NIST网站, http://www.nist.gov/,2004.5.5
    61黄以宽.浅谈应急信息系统的功能需求和规划.信息化建设. 2005,(8):13~15
    62刘铁民,李湖生.突发公共事件应急信息系统的高端设计.数字通信世界. 2006,(3):18~21
    63薛克勋.城市应急指挥基于GIS的智能辅助决策探究.警察技术. 2002, (1):10~12
    64米红,杨帆,曾东海. GIS技术和数学模型在城市应急系统中的应用.测绘科学. 2005,(2):69~72
    65陈涛.标准化的应急指挥体系与专业化的应急队伍.中国应急管理. 2009, (2)
    66薛澜,张强,钟开斌.危机管理——转型期中国面临的挑战.北京:清华大学出版社. 2003:207
    67 Homeland Security, Nationwide Plan Review Phase 2 Report. 2006:70~78
    68柳永法.应急预案及其制定的必要性.中国救灾. 2005, (6):33~35
    69詹承豫,顾林生.转危为安:应急预案的作用逻辑.中国行政管理.2007,(5)
    70李红臣,邓云峰,刘艳军.应急预案的形式化描述.中国安全生产科学技术. 2006,(8):29~34
    71范文.应急预案本体研究及应用.天津大学. 2007
    72孙颖,黄全义.基于Arc GIS的消防灭火数字预案系统中应急工具箱的制作.测绘信息与工程. 2007, 32(1):21~22
    73王威.南宁市城市应急联动系统.办公自动化. 2003,(10):24~26
    74金会庆,李湖生.公安应急指挥系统研究.人类工效学. 2004,(4):15~18
    75中国行政管理学会课题组:政府应急管理机制研究.中国行政管理. 2005, (1):18~20
    76李朝智.群体性突发事件的有效处置方法.领导科学. 2008,(18):13~14
    77 W. Thomas, D. Thomas,1928,The Child in America: Behavior Problem and Programs, New York: A. A. Knopf: 572
    78 E. L. Quarantelli, The Future Is Not The Psat Repeated: Projecting Disasters in the 21st Century From Current Trends, Journal of Contingencies and CrisisManagement. 1996,4:228~240
    79李锡海,任忠英,高佃正.正确认识和处理“群体性事件”.社会学研究. 2001,(3):10~15
    80梁栋.中国党政干部及干群关系的调查分析. 2004年《中国社会形势分析与预测》.社会蓝皮书.社会科学文献出版社. 2004:36
    81中共四川省委组织部课题组.正确分析和处理突发群体事件.马克思主义与现实. 2001,(2):50~57
    82叶皓.从被动应付走向积极应对——试论当前政府和媒体关系的变化.南京大学学报. 2008,(1):46~54
    83吴廷俊,夏长勇.论公共危机传播中的主流媒介角色——以贵州“6.28瓮安事件”为例.现代传播. 2009,(2):30~34
    84吴彤.自组织方法论研究.北京:清华大学出版社. 2001:10
    85沈小峰,吴彤,曾国屏.自组织哲学:一种新的自然现象和科学观.第二章.北京:中共中央党校出版社. 1993
    86王仁贵.研究者称中国基尼系数连续上升.贫富差距或恶化. 2009.5.18
    87齐善鸿,乐国林,刘金岩,于翔.基于熵与自组织理论的突发事件分析模型.科技管理研究. 2006,(10):238~241
    88 Lewontin M.Asimple Model of Herd Behavior. Journal of Economics. 1960, (12):456~471
    89 Smith M J. Group Selection and kin Selection. Nature. 1973,(1):1145~1147
    90 Nowak M A. Five Rules for The Evolution of Cooperation. Science. 2006, (314):1560~1563
    91 Nowak M, Sigmund K. Evolution of Indirect Reciprocity by Image Scoring. Nature. 1998,(393):573~577
    92 Hamilton, W.D. The Evolution of Altruistic Behavior. American Naturalist. 1995,(97):354~356
    93 Aoki W.D. The Genetical Evolution of Social Behavior. The Journal of Theoretical Biology. 1996,(7):1~16
    94 Matthews M, Sigmund K. Evolution of Indirect Reciprocity. Nature. 2000, (437):1291~1298
    95 Sandholm O. Genetic Relatedness and the Evolution of Altruism. Philosophy of Science. 2000,(13):69~72
    96 Juang B. The Evolution of Partnerships. Sociological Methods and Research. 2002, 28(3):364~380
    97 Barbera. A theory of equity, reciprocity, and competition. The American Economic Review, 2002, 90:166~193
    98 Nyborg M, Rege K M. The Power of ESS: and Experimental Study. Journal of Evolutionary Economics. 2003,(13):161~181
    99沙莲香.社会心理学.北京:中国人民大学出版社.2002:247~248
    100廖和平,曹汉林.群体性事件产生的社会心理机制及对策探究.创新. 2009, (1): 83~87
    101国家统计局统计科研所课题组. 2007年中国全面建设小康社会进程统计监测报告.四川省情. 2009, (2):43~44
    102张磊.新农村建设评价指标体系研究.经济纵横. 2009, (7):67~70
    103高艳.和谐城市评价指标体系框架设计.商业时代. 2009, (4):10~11
    104李鹏.危机状态下政府的媒体政策选择.江西行政学院学报. 2004,(1):17~19
    105张诗蒂.政府、媒体和公众关系的动态平衡.四川大学学报. 2005, (1):48~52
    106 H. Kahn. A. Wiener. The Year 2000. MacMillan: New York. 1967
    107 Miller K D, Waller H. Real Options and Integrated Risk Management. Long Range Planning. 2003, 36(1): 1063 ~1071
    108 Brauers J, Weber M. A New Method of Scenario Analysis For strategic Planning. Journal of Forecasting. 1988,(7):31~47
    109 Oryang D. Probabilistic Scenario Analysis (PSA)—Amethodology for Quantitative Risk Assessment. http://www.nappo.org/PRA- Symposium/PDF- Final/ Oryang.pdf
    110 Fahey L. Competitor Scenarios: Projecting a Rival’s Marketplace Strategy. Competitive Intelligence Review. 1986 ;10(2):1001~1013
    111 Fink A, Schlake O. Scenario Management An Approach for Strategic Fore sight. Competitive Intelligence Review. 2000, 11(1):203~230
    112岳珍,赖茂生.国外“情景分析”方法的进展.情报杂志. 2006,(7):59~64
    113 Fahey L. Competitor Scenarios: Projecting a Rival’s Marketplace Strategy. Competitive Intelligence Review. 1986, 10(2):100~119
    114 Swart R J, Raskin P, Robinson J. The Problem of the Future: Sustainability Science and Scenario Analysis. Global Environmental Change. 2004, (14): 137~146
    115 Theo B M. Postma, Liebl F. How to Improve Scenario Analysis as a Strategic Management Tool. Technological Forecasting & Social Change. 2005, (72): 161~173
    116许怀东.情景分析:一种灵活而富于创造性的软系统方法.科学学研究., 1987, 5(4):35~41
    117宗蓓华.战略预测中的情景分析法.预测. 1994,(2):50~51
    118朱跃中.中国交通运输部门中长期能源发展与碳排放情景设计及其结果分析.中国能源. 2001,(11):25~27
    119杨高峰,康重庆,谷兴凯,于德龙.电力市场中基于情景分析的电网规划方案适应性评估.电网技术. 2006,(7):64~70
    120张颖,王灿,王克,陈吉宁.基于LEAP的中国电力行业CO2排放情景分析.清华大学学报(自然科学版).2007,(3):365~368
    121熊琦,虞明远.基于情景分析法的北京市道路省际客运需求预测研究.交通运输工程与信息学报. 2006,(4):94~99
    122张宏,李仲学.煤炭需求影响因素及情景分析.煤炭学报. 2007,(5):557~560
    123宗跃光,徐建刚,伊海伟.情景分析法在工业用地置换中的应用——以福建省长汀腾飞经济开发区为例.地理学报. 2007,(8):887~896
    124余艳春,邵春福,董威.情景分析法在交通规划中的应用研究.武汉理工大学学报(交通科学与工程版).2007,(4):304~307
    125宋学锋,刘耀彬.基于SD的江苏省城市化与生态环境耦合发展情景分析.系统工程理论与实践. 2006,(3):124~130
    126钱程,苏德林,姚瑶.情景分析法在黑龙江省水环境污染防治工作中的应用.环境科学与管理. 2006,(2):78~80
    127黄一凡,曾德慧,王如松,阳文锐.中国省域人口流动趋势的情景分析.中国可持续发展论坛. 2005,(5):20~29
    128刘洪波,尹永刚,黄树军,李勇.情景分析法在工业园区水环境影响预测评价中的应用.中国科技信息. 2006,(24):20~21
    129于红霞,汪波,钱荣.情景分析在企业发展战略中的应用研究.科技管理研究. 2006,(11):91~94
    130宁钟,孙薇,石香研.供应链分享的情景分析与管理.物流科技. 2006, (l29): 56~60.
    131宁钟,王雅青.基于情景分析的供应链风险识别——某全球性公司案例分析.工业工程与管理. 2007,(2):88~94
    132穆荣平,王瑞祥.技术预见的发展及其在中国的应用. http://www.cas. cn/ html/ Dir/2004/ 07/30/6940.htm.
    133沈云斐,李丹,陶琨,覃征.基于关联规则和情景规则的网络告警分析模型.小型微型计算机系统. 2007,(2):271~273
    134吉小东,汪寿阳,李振涛.一种基于聚类分析的多阶段情景生成方法.系统工程理论与实践. 2006,(7):11~18
    135徐枞巍,殷章驹,聂会星.中国移动运营市场竞争格局情景分析.经济研究导刊. 2007,(11):117~119
    136丛沛桐,陈存恩,薄景山.大庆油田地震应急预案情境分析.华南地震. 2007,27(2):49~54
    137 Schank R. Dynamic Memory. New York: Cambridge Univ. Press. 1982: 45~78
    138 Kolodner J L. Improving Human Decision Making Through Case-based Reasoning Techniques.AIMagazine.1991,12(3):52~59
    139 Jo?l Colloc, La?d Bouzidi. A Case Based Reasoning Decision Support System for use in Medicine. 2001,(11):156~164
    140 Juan A. Recio, Belen diaz-Agudo, Nirmalie Wiratunga. Extending JCOLIBRI for Textual CBR. In Proceedings of the 6th International Conference on Case-Based Reasoning, ICCBR’. 2005,(5): 421~435
    141 Nirmalie Wiratunga, Ivan Koychev, and Stewart Massie. Feature Selection and Generalization for Retrieval of Textual Cases.ECCBR 2004, LNAI 3155, Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg. 2004: 806~820
    142 Weber,R., Aha, D.W., Sandhu,N. and Munoz-Avila, H.. A Textual Case-based Framework for Knowledge Management Applications. In Proceedings of the
    9th Workshop on Case-Based Reasoning.Shaker Verlag. 2001
    143 Aamodt A., Plaza E. Case-based Reasoning: Foundational Issues, Methodological Variations, and System Approaches. Artificial Intelligence Communications. 1994, 7(1): 39~59
    144 K.J.McDonell. An Inverted Index Implementation. The Computer Journal. 1977, 20(2):116~123
    145 J. Zobel, A. Moffat, and K. Ramamohanarao. Inverted Files Versus Signature Files for Text Indexing. ACM Transactions on Database Systems. 1998, 23(4): 453~490
    146 Wang Zhi-qiang, Liu Jian-yi The Design and Realization of a Real-time Updating Index. Applications of the Computer Systems. 2005, (10): 79~82
    147 D. Cutting, J. Pedersen. Optimization for Dynamic Inverted Index Maintenance. in: Proceedings of the 13th Annual International ACM SIGIR Conference on Research and Development in Information Retrieval. Brussels, Belgium. 1990. New York: ACM Press. 1990. 405~411
    148 J. Zobel, A. Moffat. Adding Compression to a Full-Text Retrieval System. Software Practice and Experience. 1995, 25(8): 891~903
    149 A. Moffat, J. Zobel. Information Retrieval Systems for Large Document Collections. in: The 3th Text Retrieval Conference(TREC-4). Gaithersburg, Maryland, USA. 1994. USA: TREC Press.1994:13~29
    150 W. B. Frakes, R.Baeza-Yates. Information Retrieval: Data Structures & Algorithms. New Jersey: Prentice Hall. 1992:44~82
    151李朝智.群体性突发事件的有效处置方法.领导科学. 2008,(18):13~14
    152郭瑞鹏.基于预案的危机决策方法研究.科技进步与对策. 2006,(2):44~46
    153于建嵘.社会泄愤事件中群体心理研究——对“瓮安事件”发生机制的一种解释.北京行政学院学报. 2009,(1):24~30

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700