用户名: 密码: 验证码:
中国开放式基金投资者申购赎回行为研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
本文以我国股票型开放式基金投资者的申购赎回行为为研究对象,试图通过分析开放式基金份额变动率与证券市场回报、基金业绩等十大因素的关系来考察影响投资者申赎行为的因素,并对投资者申赎行为是否理性做进一步的分析。
     本文通过分阶段回归(以半年为一个考察区间)、区分不同市场环境回归(牛市、熊市)以及综合回归,从三个层面考察影响开放式基金申购赎回的因素。实证结果表明:上期证券市场回报、基金的累计平均净值增长率对开放式基金当期的申购、赎回和净申购都具有显著的正向影响;基金存续时间、基金评级与基金的申购和净申购存在正相关关系,与基金的赎回存在负相关关系;对基金规模的分析表明,规模大的基金能吸引更多的申购,但却不能有效降低基金的赎回;个人持有比例和基金单位净值这两个因素比较特殊,在牛市、熊市不同的市场环境中,与基金申购赎回的关系有所不同。个人持有比例与申购赎回在牛市阶段呈正向关系,而在熊市阶段呈反向关系;单位净值与申购在牛市阶段呈反向关系,熊市阶段呈正向关系。
     在对开放式基金投资者申购赎回行为是否理性的实证检验过程中,本文使用累计平均超额回报率(CAR)模型和FF三因素模型分别进行直接检验和间接检验。CAR模型的实证结果表明:被投资者净赎回的基金与被投资者净申购的基金在未来大多数时期业绩表现没有显著差异。在某些时期,被投资者净申购的基金的未来表现甚至比净赎回的基金差。而FF三因素模型更证明了被投资者申购的基金表现明显不如被投资者抛弃的基金,投资者基本上没有表现出明显的鉴别优秀基金的能力。
     由此,本文建议开放式基金投资者应该增强独立思考能力,根据自身理财目标和风险承受能力选择长期业绩表现良好、有品牌、份额稳定的基金长期持有,以获得比较稳定的回报。建议基金公司通过保持良好的基金业绩、树立良好的品牌形象、设置合理的收费机制和建立开放式基金投资者信息数据库等手段,吸引投资者,保持基金份额的稳定。建议监管部门通过加强投资者教育、创建良好的证券市场环境、加强基金信息披露的透明度及披露频率、规范基金公司的销售宣传活动,维护基金持有人的利益,促进基金行业的稳健发展。
This paper focuses on investor's purchase and redemption behavior on the open-end fund market in China. To explore the factors affecting investor's behavior, I analyze the relation between fund share's rate of change and 10 possible factors such as market return and fund performance, and further examine the rationality of investor's behavior.
     Three major methods employed here to study the factors contributing to purchase and redemption include multi-stage regression on semi-annual data, regressions with different market trends (bull and bear), and comprehensive regression. The empirical results indicate that market return of last period and growth rate of cumulative average return have significantly positive impact on purchase and redemption as well as net purchase of this period, and that the span of fund's existence and fund's rating are positively correlated with purchase and net purchase but negatively correlated to fund's redemption, and that larger funds have advantage in attracting purchase but not in preventing redemption, and that two factors-household shareholding ratio and fund's unit net asset value-are special in that their relation to purchase and redemption vary in bull and bear markets:in bull market household shareholding ratio is positively correlated to purchase, while unit net asset value is negatively correlated, and vice versa in bear markets.
     To test the rationality of investor's purchase and redemption behavior, I adopt the cumulative abnormal returns (CAR) model and the FF 3-factor model for direct and indirect tests respectively. The outcome shows little differences between the funds under redemption and the ones on purchase in terms of their performance, demonstrating investor's limited capability in picking quality funds.
     Therefore, this paper suggests investors think independently and choose, according to their investment goal and risk-bearing capacity, the well-performed and stable-sized fund with moderately concentrated shares for long-term investment, so as to achieve smooth return. To attract investors, the fund management companies should build the database of investor's characteristics, keep a good level of performance, establish their brand name, and set a reasonable charge mechanism. For protecting investor and boosting the development of the fund industry, the regulatory institutions can promote investor education, improve security market structures, enforce transparency and frequency of fund's disclosure of information, and standardize fund's marketing and sales.
引文
[1]Agnus, J.R. and H. Neudecker, "Symmetry,0-1 matrices and Jacobians:a review, " Econometric Theory,1986,2,157-190.
    [2]Aigner, D, C. Lovell, and P. Schmidt, "Formulation and estimation of stochastic frontier production function models", Journal of Econometrics,1997,6,21-37.
    [3]Andre Santos and Joao Tusi and Newton Da Costa, Jr and Sergio Da Silva, "Evaluating Brazilian mutual funds with stochastic frontiers," Economics Bulletin,2005,13,1-6
    [4]Annaert, J., J. Van De Broeck, and R. Vennet, "Determinants of mutual fund underperformance:a Bayesian stochastic frontier approach", European Journal of Operational Research,2003,31,617-632
    [5]Annaert, J.V.D.Broeck and R.V.Vennet, "Determinants of Mutual Fund Performance:A Bayesian Stochastic Frontier Approach ", European Journal of Operational Research,2003,151,617-632.
    [6]Arya, A., Glover, J., S. Sunder, "Earnings management and revelation principle", Review of Accounting Studies,1998
    [7]Barber, B. B., Odean, T., and Zheng, L., "The behavior of mutual fund investors, University of California at Davis", Working Paper,2000.
    [8]Battese, G.E., and Coelli, T.J., "Frontier Production Functions, Technical Efficiency and Panel Data with Application to Paddy Farmers in India", Journal of Productivity Analysis 1992,3,153-169
    [9]Battese, GE., and G.S. Corra, "Estimation of a Production Frontier model: with Application to the Pastoral Zone of Eastern Australia" Australian Journal of Agricultural Economics,1077,21,169-179
    [10]Bergstresser, D. and J. Poterba, "Do After-tax Returns Affect Mutual Fund Infows Journal of Financial Economics,",2002,63,381-414.
    [11]Berk, J. B. and Green, R. C., "Mutual Fund Flows and Performance in Rational Markets, Journal of Political Economy,2004,112,1269-1295.
    [12]Brown, Stephen J., William N. Goestzman,"Performance Persistence." The Journal of Finance,1995,50,679-698
    [13]Caporale G.Maria, Nikolaos Philippas and Nikitas Pittis, "Feedbacks Between Mutual Fund Flows and Security Returns:Evidence from the Greek Capital Market",Applied Financial Economics,2004,14,981-989.
    [14]Carhart, Mark, "On Persistence in Mutual Fund Performance",Journal of Finance 1997,52,57-82.
    [15]Carlson,R.S., "Aggregate Performance of Mutual Fund,1948-1967", Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,,1970,3,1-31
    [16]Chakarabarti, A., and H. Rungta., "Mutual Funds Industry in India:An In-depth Look into the Problems of Credibility, Risk and Brand",The ICFAI Journal of Applied Finance,2000,6,27-45
    [17]Chalmers, John., Roger, Edelen., and Kadlec, G.,"On the Perils of? Financial Intermediaries Setting Security Prices:the Mutual Fund Wild Card Option", Journal of Finance,2001,2209-2236
    [18]D. Hendricks, J. Patel & R.Zeckhauser, "Hot hands in Mutual Funds: Short-Run Persistence of Relative Performance,1974-1988 ", Journal of Finance, 1993,148,93-130
    [19]Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky, "Prospect theory:An analysis of decision under risk", Econometrica,1979,47,263-291. Kahneman, D. and A. Tversky, " judgment under uncertainty:heuristics and biases, Science",1974,185,1124-1131
    [20]Dickey, D. A. and W. A. Fuller, "Likelihood Ratio Statistics for Autoregressive Time Series with a Unit Root",Econometrica,1981,49,1057-1072
    [21]Droms, William G., David A. Walker, "Persistence of Mutual Fund Operating Characteristics:Returns, Turnovers rates, and Expense ratios",Applied Financial Economics,2001,11,457-466
    [22]Edelen, R., and Warner, J., "Aggregate Price Effect of Institutional Trading: A Study of Mutual Fund Flow and Market Returns", Journal of Financial Economics,2001,2,195-220.
    [23]Edwards, F. R., and X. Zhang, "Mutual Funds and Stock and Bond Market Stability," Journal of financial Services Research,1998,13,257-282.
    [24]Erik R.Sirri,Peter Tufano, "Costly search and mutual fund flows", Journal of Finance,1998,53,1589-1622
    [25]Ferson W E, Schadt R W., "Measuring fund strategy and performance in changing economic conditions", Journal of Finance,1996,51,425-461
    [26]Ferson, W.E., Warther, V.A., "Evaluating Fund Performance in a Dynamic Market", Financial Analysts Journal,1996,12,20-28.
    [27]Fortune, P., "Fund Flows and Security Returns," New England Economic Review,1998,20,3-22.
    [28]Franklin Fant L, "Investment Behavior of mutual fund shareholders:the evidence from aggregate fund flows," Journal of financial markets,1999,2,391-402
    [29]Gharghori, P., Veeraraghavan, M, Mudumba, S, "How Smart is Money?An Investigation into Investor Behaviour in the Australian Managed Fund Industry", Pacific-Basin Finance Journal,2007,15,494-513
    [30]Goetzmann, W. and N. Peles, "Cognitive Dissonance and Mutual Fund Investing." Journal of Financial Research,1997,20,145-158.
    [31]Goetzmann, W., and R. Ibbotson, ""Do winners repeat Patterns in mutual fund performance," Journal of Portfolio Management,1994,20,9-18.
    [32]Greene, Jason T., Charles W., " Redemption Policies and Daily Mutual Fund Flows", Journal of Banking & Finance,2007,3,3822-3842.
    [33]Gruber, M.J., "Another puzzle:The growth in actively managed mutual funds", Journal of Finance,1996,51,783-810
    [34]Hu, Ping, J. R. Kale, and A. Subramanian, "Relative risk choices by mutual fund managers," working paper,2002
    [35]Ippolito, R.A., "Efficiency with costly information:A study of mutual fund performance,1965-1984", Quarterly Journal of Economics,1989,104,1-23
    [36]Ippolito,Richard A, "Consumer reaction to measures of poor quality:evidence from the mutual fund industry", Journal of Law and Economics,1992,35,45-70
    [37]Judith Chevalier, Glenn Ellison, "Risk taking by mutual funds as a response to incentives", Journal of Political Economy 1997,105,1167-1200.
    [38]Kahneman, D. and A. Tversky, "Prospect theory:An analysis of decision under risk", Econometrica,1979,47,263-291. Shefrin H, R Thale, "The behavioral life of cycle hypothesis", Economic Inquity,1988,24,609-643
    [39]Ke, D., Ng, L., and Wang, Q, " Smart money? Evidence from the performance of mutual fund investors", University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee, Working Paper,2005
    [40]Kempf, Alexander and Stefan Ruenzi. Family Matters, " The Performance Flow Relationship in the Mutual Fund Industry", University of Cologne,2004.
    [41]Kempf, Alexander and Stefan Ruenzi. Family Matters, "The Performance Flow Relationship in the Mutual Fund Industry", University of Cologne,2004.
    [42]Keswani, A. and D. Stolin,, "Which money is smart?", Journal of Finance, 2008,63,85-118
    [43]Latzko, David A, " Economies Scale in Mutual Fund Administration", Journal of Financial Research,1999,22,331-339
    [44]Martin J. Gruber," Another puzzle:the growth in actively managed mutual funds', Journal of Finance,1996,51,783-810.
    [45]Martin J. Gruber. Another puzzle, "the growth in actively managed mutual funds", Journal of Finance 1996,51,783-810
    [46]Nanda, Vikram, Z. Jay Wang, and Lu Zheng, "Family Values and the Star Phenomenon:Strategies of Mutual Fund Families", Review of Financial Studies,2004,17,667-698.
    [47]Pei-Gi Shu, Yin-Hua Yeh, "Takeshi Yamada, The behavior of Taiwan mutual fund investors-performance and fund flows ", Pacific-Basin Finance Journal,2002,10,583-600
    [48]Pettit R R., "Dividend announcements,security performance and capital market efficiency,",Journal of Finance,1972,35,993-1007
    [49]Potter M., "Determinants of aggergate mutual fund flows", Journal of Business &Economic Studies 2000,2,55-74
    [50]Rea,John and Richard Marci, "Mutual Fund Shareholder Activity During US Stock Market Cycles,1944-1995,"Investment Company Institute Perspective,1996,2,1-16.
    [51]Roston,Marcn, "Mutual Fund Managers and Mutual Fund Flows ", Journal of Finance,1998,53,1589-1622.
    [52]S.D.Hodges,r.A.Brealey, "Portfolio Selection in a Dynamic and Uncertain World",Financial Analysis Journal,1973,3-14
    [53]Santini, D.L., J. W. Aber, " Determinants of Net New Money Flows to the Equity Mutual Fund Industry," Journal of Economics and Business,1998,50,419-429
    [54]Shefrin H, M.Statm, "an,"Behavioral capital asset pricing theory", Journal of Finance and Quantitative Analysis,1994,29,323-349.
    [55]Sirri, E. R., and P. Tufan, "Costly Search and Mutual Fund Flows", Journal of Finance,1998,53,1589-1622
    [56]Sirri, E. R., and P. Tufano., "Costly Search and Mutual Fund Flows", Journal of Finance,1998,53,1589-1622.
    [57]Thaler R., "Mental accounting matters", Journal of behavior decision making, 1999,12, 183-205
    [58]Thomas Dangl,Youchang Wu,Josef Zechne, "Mutual Fund Flows and Optimal Manager Replacement", working paper,2004
    [59]Travis Sapp and Ashish Tiwari, "Dose stock return momentum explain the smart money effect?", Journal of finance,2004,59,2605-2622.
    [60]Vikram Nanda, N arayana, "Liquidity,investment ability, and mutual fund structure",Journal of Financial Economics,2000,1,256-279
    [61]Zheng Lu, "Is money smart? A study of mutual fund investors' fund selection ability", Journal of Financ,1999,54.901-933
    [62]陈慧群:行为金融学对投资基金现象之解释,市场周刊,2004(7)
    [63]贺京同、徐小兵:我国开放式基金发展面临的问题及对策,经济纵横,2007(8)
    [64]刘海龙、仲黎明、吴冲锋:开放式基金流动性风险的最优控制[J];控制与决策;2003年02期
    [65]李国秋、邹儒楠、严众开: 基金业品牌竞争力的实证分析,金融教学与研究,2007(5)
    [66]李曜、于进杰:开放式基金赎回机制的外部效应,财经研究,2004(12)
    [67]李曜、徐端丰:股票基金红利再投资比例的实证研究,《上海立信会计学院学报》,2007(6)
    [68]林翔:对中国证券咨询机构预测的分析,经济研究,2000年(2)
    [69]刘志远:财务管理与政策[M].东北财经大学出版社,2000(11).
    [70]刘志远、姚颐:开放式基金的“赎回困惑”现象研究.证券市场导报,2005(2)
    [71]雷良桃、黎实:开放式基金赎回问题研究——基于Panel-Data的Granger因果检验,南方经济,2007(9)
    [72]陆蓉:基金业绩与投资者的选择——中国开放式基金赎回异常现象的研究,经济研究,2007(6)
    [73]马顺福、梁永强:换个角度看我国开放式基金的赎回悖论,上海证券报,2005年08月24日
    [74]任淮秀,汪涛:我国开放式基金赎回行为的实证分析,经济理论与经济管理,2007(6)
    [75]束景虹:开放式基金赎回现象的实证研究,数量经济技术经济研究,2005(4)
    [76]王雯:开放式基金“赎回困惑”:基于行为金融学的成因分析,生产力研究,2006(2)
    [77]汪慧建:中国开放式基金赎回异象的实证研究,南方经济,2007(8)
    [78]徐妍、林捷、裘孝锋:证券投资基金投资行为对市场影响实证研究,申银万国证券股份有限公司,2004
    [79]谢盐、田彭、赵世英:开放式基金结构与投资者赎回行为关系的分析,数量经济技术经济研究,2004(6)
    [80]姚颐、刘志远:我国开放式基金赎回行为的实证研究,经济科学,2004(5).
    [81]郑仲林:股利政策:公司对股东的回报体现?——相关文献综述,当代财经,2002(8)
    [82]张根明、田浪:开放式基金中投资者赎回行为的进化博弈分析,技术经济,2004(9)
    [83]赵旭、吴冲锋:开放式基金流动性赎回风险实证分析与评价,运筹与管理,2003(12)
    [84]赵坚毅,于泽,李颖俊:投资者参与和证券投资基金风格业绩的评估,经济研究,2005(7)
    [85]里.格雷米林,《美国开放式共同基金》,中国金融出版社,2006年5月
    [86]刘红忠,《投资学》,高等教育出版社,2003年8月
    [87]贝政新,《基金治理研究》,复旦大学出版社,2006年12月
    [88]赵昌文,俞乔,郑璐,《共同基金与投资者行为理论研究前沿》,科学出版社,2008年5月

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700