用户名: 密码: 验证码:
中国农村信贷配给及其绩效评价研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
建设社会主义新农村是事关全面建设小康社会和现代化建设全局的重大历史任务。无论是发展现代农业,促进粮食生产和农民增加收入,还是加强农村基础设施建设,全面进行农村综合改革,都离不开农村金融的大力推动和支持。然而,中国农村信贷配给机制现况扩大了农村信贷资金的供需缺口,成为制约新农村建设的重要因素。
     理论逻辑证明,制度内生和信贷市场不完全使得非均衡信贷配给和均衡信贷配给成为中国农村信贷市场的典型现象。信贷配给理论也表明,利率管制、逆向选择和道德风险、交易成本、产权与制度缺失、金融垄断等因素都可能成为信贷配给产生的诱因。经验研究表明,农户和农村中小企业普遍面临着严重的信贷配给问题。农户和农村中小企业的信贷配给程度高、贷款覆盖面窄和信贷可获性差是众多学者调查研究结论的共鸣。
     基于此种现实,本文依据信贷配给理论、农村经济发展理论,运用协整、Match估计、数据包络分析(DEA)等计量分析方法,采用宏观与微观分析相结合、定性与定量分析相结合的研究方法,对中国农村金融机构信贷配给的绩效进行计量和评价,以正确把握中国农村信贷市场的特征,并在此基础上,提出了有效提升中国农村信贷配给绩效的政策建议。
     本文主要有两个研究目标:一是以信贷配给理论为理论基础,研究中国农村信贷市场的信贷配给特征;二是在计量农村信贷配给的经济效应的基础上,评价中国农村信贷配给的绩效。为了实现这两个目标,本文设计了八章三大部分内容。第一部分包括第1章、第2章和第3章。本部分首先在对信贷配给的内涵和外延进行明确界定的基础上,定性地剖析均衡与非均衡信贷配给现象的产生原因;然后,以此为理论基础,以经验研究为事实论据,定性与定量地论证均衡与非均衡信贷配给现象在中国农村信贷市场的存在性;最后,追溯中国农村金融制度的变迁,全面解剖制度内生下的信贷配给演进的来龙去脉。第二部分包括第4章、第5章、第6章和第7章。第4章首先构建两期动态模型,分析信贷配给对农村经济实体的投资产出的影响,然后阐明货币政策的信贷配给传导渠道,分别从微观和宏观的角度对信贷配给的经济效应进行理论分析;第5章在对中国农村的信贷需求和信贷供给进行定性和定量描述的基础上,计量信贷供给对信贷需求的满足程度,初步评价中国农村信贷配给的绩效;第6章运用协整分析和Match估计的方法,分别计量中国农村信贷配给的效率和农户的福利效应,进一步评价中国农村信贷配给的绩效;第7章首先分析农村金融机构信贷配给经营的收益与成本,利用收益与成本对比的分析方法,初步评价中国农业银行、中国农业发展银行和农村信用社等金融机构的信贷配给效益;然后,在初步评价的基础上,利用DEA评价模型,以山东省JN市农村信用社为研究样本,进一步评价农村金融机构信贷配给经营的效率;最后,以山东省JN市样本农村信用社为研究对象,在对其信贷风险进行统计描述的基础上,利用DEA模型进一步评价样本农村信用社利用信贷配给防范信贷风险的效率。第三部分是第8章,对本文的研究结论进行了总结,并在此基础上提出了有效提升中国农村信贷配给绩效的政策与建议。
     本文的基本研究结论是:
     (1)中国农村具有非均衡和均衡信贷配给的双重特征。从导致信贷配给现象产生的因素来看,中国农村信贷市场几乎囊括了能够诱发信贷配给的制度因素和市场因素。制度内生于中国农村信贷市场,非均衡信贷配给特征伴随着农村金融体制的变迁而演进,与农村金融机构的发展、农村信贷市场的结构、利率管制以及国家的信贷管理体制密切相关。
     (2)农村信贷配给程度在总体上有所缓解。农业信贷配给度的变迁取决于农村金融体制的变迁。农业和农村中小企业的信贷配给程度具有显著差异:农业信贷配给度呈下降趋势,而农村中小企业的信贷配给程度逐年加深。这种差异与信息不对称的程度有关。但是,在信息对称的情况下贫困者会受到更严重的信贷配给,而且信息越完全,贫困者受到的信贷配给程度越严重,这意味着政府(财政)应在扶贫信贷中发挥主导作用。
     (3)通过协整分析发现,农业信贷资源的配给效率较低,导致这一结果的因素包括逆向选择、政府的贷款指令计划、要素产出的边际递减规律和贷款的可替代性;农村中小企业的配给效率较高,其原因在于,与农户相比农村中小企业的信息不对称程度较低。通过对比分析可以发现,农村金融体系形成与稳固阶段的农业的信贷配给效率高于农村金融改革的推进和深化阶段的农业信贷配给效率,原因包括信贷行政投入的盲目性和要素产出的边际递减;农村中小企业的信贷配给效率高于农业的信贷配给效率,这种差异与信息不对称的程度有关。
     (4)农村信贷配给损失了农户福利,导致了农户的收入、生活消费、医疗消费和教育消费等方面的缩水。利用Match估计法对调查取得的样本进行分析发现,信贷配给具有传导作用。信贷配给会直接地减少受到信贷配给的农户的福利水平,也会间接地减少未受到信贷配给的农户的福利。因此,缓解农村信贷配给是提高农民福利水平的一个重要举措,是新农村建设及农村金融体制深化改革的当务之急。
     (5)通过收益与成本对比的分析发现,中国农业银行与样本农村信用社的信贷配给经营亏损,而中国农业发展银行的信贷配给经营盈利。导致这种结果的关键因素是制度和市场:一方面,利率管制压缩了农村金融机构的获利空间;另一方面,信贷市场的不完善产生了高昂的放贷成本。因此,本文认为,放松制度约束和完善信贷市场是提高农村金融机构信贷配给效益的关键举措。在2003年国家“花钱买机制”的作用下,农村信用社的信贷配给经营效率总体上有所提升:随着农信社信贷配给规模的增加,其信贷配给成本有减少的趋势。DEA模型分析发现,信贷配给有效地防范了信贷风险,实现了农村金融机构信贷配给经营的初衷。这可能是信贷配给现象的唯一“益处”。但是,农村金融机构利用信贷配给防范信贷风险的效果也存在个体差异。
The construction of Socialistic New Country is a most important historical mission relative to the construction of Well-off Society and Modernization. Whether to develop the Modern Agriculture, or to promote agricultural production and increase the farmers’income, or to build the rural infrastructure, rural finance is very necessary. However, the Chinese rural ration widens the gap between the demand and the supply for the rural credit. The Chinese rural ration becomes the obstacle for the construction of New Country.
     Theoretically,The endogenetic system and the credit market imperfection make the disequilibrium ration and the equilibrium ration to be typical phenomenon in the Chinese rural credit market. The Ration Theory indicates that interest control, adverse selection, moral hazard, transaction cost, absence of property right and system and financial monopolization can all lead to ration. The evidence says that the Chinese farmers and rural medium & small enterprises face terrible ration problems. The researchers believe in their survey that the rural credit resource in the rural credit market is hardly available for the farmers and rural medium & small enterprises. Based on the fact and the Ration Theory above and Rural Economic Ddevelopment Theory, this paper uses many quantitative methods, such as Co integration Analysis, Match Estimation and DEA, etc, to calculate and assess the performance of the Chinese rural ration macroscopically and microcosmically, qualitatively and quantificationally, to check the efficiency of the Chinese rural ration. Finally, this paper makes suggestions and policy advice to promote the ration’s performance.
     This paper has tow targets: one is to research the credit ration feature in the Chinese rural credit market based on the credit ration theory, and the other is to calculate and appraise the performance of the Chinese rural credit ration on the basis of the credit ration’s effect on the economy. The article is divided to three parts for the targets, including eight chapters. The first part contains Chapter 1, Chapter 2 and Chapter 3. In this part, the paper firstly qualitatively analyzes the factors that generate the rural credit ration after the credit ration’s concept and its extension. Then the paper uses empirical studies to ague qualitatively and quantificationally about the existence of the credit ration in the Chinese rural credit market. At last, the third chapter traces the transition of the financial system to know completely the course of the rural credit ration. The second part contains Chapter 4, Chapter 5, Chapter 6 and Chapter 7. Chapter 4 designs a two-period dynamic model to find how the credit ration affects the investment and production of the rural economic entities and explain clearly the ways in which credit ration influences the money policy. Following that, Chapter 5 describes qualitatively and quantificationally the credit demand and supply in the country, then calculates how much the credit demand is satisfied to assess the performance of the credit ration preliminarily. To acquaint more about the performance of the credit ration, Chapter 6 continues to compute the efficiency of the rural credit ration by Co integration and analyze the effect the credit ration has on the farmers’welfare by Match Estimation. Then Chapter 7 researches the income and the cost in the ration process of the rural financial institutes and assesses preliminarily the credit ration’s performance for China Agricultural Bank and Agricultural Development Bank of China,and takes the Rural Credit Cooperatives of JN City in Shan Dong province for example to assess further the credit ration’s performance for rural financial institutes by DEA. Finally, the paper measures the credit ration’s efficiency for risk controlling by DEA with the Rural Credit Cooperatives of JN City in Shan Dong province as example. The third part has Chapter 8 only included. This part puts forward policies and proposals to improve the performance of the rural credit ration at the basis of the paper’s summary of research findings.
     The paper’s basic research conclusions are:
     (1) Disequilibrium ration and equilibrium ration are obviously present at Chinese rural credit market. From the factors leading to credit ration, there are all the factors about system and market in Chinese rural credit market. System is endogenous at Chinese rural credit market, and disequilibrium ration changes with the transition of the rural financial system very relative to the development of rural financial institutions, the structure of rural credit market, the interest controlling and the system of the country credit management.
     (2) The degree of rural credit ration generally is alleviated. The changes of the degree of the agricultural credit ration depend on the rural financial system. There is a difference in the credit ration degree between agriculture and medium & small enterprises. In detail, the degree of agricultural ration becomes smaller and smaller; relatively, the degree of medium & small enterprises’ration becomes more and more terrible year by year. The difference has something to do with the information imperfection. However, in the case of information perfection, the poor are rationed terribly and the information is more perfect, the ration is more terrible for the poor. So the government should play the most roles in the project of supporting the poor.
     (3) The paper finds that the efficiency of agricultural credit ration is very low, and the causes include adverse selection, the government’s credit policy, the law of diminishing marginal and the credit substitution. At another hand, that of medium & small enterprises is relatively high. This is because the information perfection degree between the financial institutes and medium & small enterprises is lower than that between the financial institutions and farmers. Another discovery by comparison is the efficiency of agricultural credit ration at the initial stage of the rural financial system is higher than that at the later stage, which results from the blindness of the government credit and the law of diminishing marginal. The comparison also finds that the credit ration’s efficiency of medium & small enterprises is higher than that of agriculture, which results from the information imperfection.
     (4) One of the conclusions is that rural credit ration cuts down the farmers’welfare in the income, life consumption, medical expenditure and education expenditure. The paper finds by the Match Estimation that the credit ration has conduction. That means, the credit ration can reduce directly the rationed farmers’welfare, and also indirectly reduce the welfare of those who are not rationed. As a result, credit ration must be removed to promote the farmers’lives.
     (5) The article finds out that credit ration brings loss for China Agricultural Bank and Rural Credit Cooperatives and brings profit for Agricultural Development Bank of China, which results from the system and market: at one hand, the interest controlling narrows the profit space; at the other hand, the imperfect market increases the credit ration cost. So lessening the system constraint and making the credit market perfect is the key to improve the performance of the credit ration. At last, the paper finds by DEA the credit ration can restrain the risk from credit, which may be the only“advantage”of the credit ration. However, there are differences in the risks controlling by ration for different financial institutions.
引文
1这种歧视又被称为“基于偏好的歧视”,转引自金俐,2006。
    2这种歧视称为“所有制歧视”。
     3亚当斯密著:《国富论》,商务印书馆,1996。
    6王怡,信贷市场信息不对称研究,硕士论文,2007年9月,华东师范大学。
     7伍海华:金融区域二元结构及发展对策[J],经济理论与经济管理,2002.8,P22-27。
    8厉以宁著:《非均衡的中国经济》,经济日报出版社,1990年版。
    13崔红、赵伟、杨永淼:关于我国农村金融市场结构的思考,山东农业大学学报,2008.01。
    14见Pranab Kumar Das:《Credit rationing and firms’investment and production decisions》,Internantional Review of Economics & Finance,2004,P87-114。
    15黄祖辉等:中国农户的信贷需求:生产性抑或消费性,管理世界,2007年第3期。
    19 Modigliani & Miller(1958)[0],The Cost of. Capital,Corporation Finance and the Theory of Investment American Economic Review,1958,(48):261-297。
    20楚尔鸣等:农村经济主体的融资次序与信贷需求层次[J],广西财经学院学报,2007.20,P94。
    
    21杜志雄:对农村企业信贷需求与供给的实证分析[J],中国农村经济,2004.5,46-55。
    22根据调查结果计算而得。
    23同脚注22。
    26中国人民银行上饶市中心支行课题组,中国农村融资现实审视:制度重构[J],金融研究,2006.1,P151。
    33李锐、朱喜:农户金融抑制及其福利损失的计量分析,经济研究,2007.02。
    
    34信贷成本的具体内容将在下一部分做具体阐述。
    35卞政惠:中国商业银行经营绩效研究,博士学位论文,2004。
    39盛昭翰、朱乔、吴广谋:DEA理论、方法与应用[M],科学出版社,1996。
    41韩俊等著:《中国农村金融调查》,上海远东出版社,2007年7月第1版,P289-290。
    (1)爱德华.肖,经济发展中的金融深化[M],中国社会科学出版社,1989.
    (2)白钦先、王伟,信贷配给、政府介入与政策性金融[J],浙江金融,2004.4,4-5.
    (3)卞政惠,中国商业银行经营绩效研究[MA],华东师范大学硕士学位论文,2004.7.
    (4)曹倩,“二元”市场竞争结构与中小银行信贷配给[J],济南金融,2005.10,34-35.
    (5)查恒亮,我国商业银行经营绩效评价的实证研究[J],海南金融,2006.11,27-30.
    (6)常玉春、曹霞,经济转轨时期的信贷配给及其经济后果[J],山东财政学院学报,2006.6,31-34.
    (7)陈锡文,资源配置与中国农村发展[J],中国农村经济,2004.1,4-9.
    (8)陈天阁、邓学衷、方兆本,农户融资与信贷供给[J],农村金融研究,2005.1,39-41.
    (9)陈欣,中国信贷配给问题研究[J],理论学刊,2007.2,63-65.
    (10)成思危,改革与发展:推进中国的农村金融[M],经济科学出版社,2005.
    (11)程卫红,评述信贷配给论[J],金融研究,2003.11,81-88.
    (12)程怡,信货配给对于我国货币政策传导机制的影响[MA],武汉大学硕士学位论文,2004.5。
    (13)崔红、赵伟、杨永淼,关于我国农村金融市场结构的思考[J],山东农业大学学报,2008.01,47-49.
    (14)董意凤、曹倩,基于市场竞争结构的中小银行信贷配给分析[J],山东商业职业技术学院学报,2006.3,41-46.
    (15)杜晓山,农村金融体系框架、农村信用社改革和小额信贷[J],中国农村经济,2002.8,4-19.
    (16)杜志雄,对农村企业信贷需求与供给的实证分析[J],中国农村经济,2004.5,46-55.
    (17)冯海发、李溦,我国农业为工业化提供资金积累的数量研究[J],经济研究,1993.9,60-64.
    (18)冯兴元,温州市苍南县农村中小企业融资调查报告[J],管理世界,2004.9,53-66.
    (19)冯兴元,中国的乡镇企业融资与内生民间金融组织制度创新[J],中国集体经济,2008.8,5-7.
    (20)冯兴元、何梦笔[德]、何广文,试论中国农村金融的多元化——一种局部知识范式视角,网址:http://www.cngdsz.net/,2004年10月.
    (21)弗里德曼、哈恩,货币经济学手册第2卷[C],经济科学出版社,2002.6,844-845.
    (22)甘春开,中国经济转轨中的信贷配给问题研究[D],复旦大学博士论文,2004.4.
    (23)戈岚,信贷配给对我国货币政策传导机制作用分析[MA],吉林大学硕士学位论文,2006.4.
    (24)古文威,国有金融体制变迁中的信贷配给问题分析——对金融控制和商业化改革的再思考[MA],西南财经大学硕士论文,2000.5.
    (25)管毅平,现实的信贷配给现象与宏观经济波动[J],学术月刊,2000.8,19-22.
    (26)郭沛,中国农村非正规金融规模估算[J],中国农村观察,2004.2,21-25.
    (27)韩俊等著,中国农村金融调查[M],上海远东出版社,2007年7月第1版,P289-290.
    (28)韩立岩、蔡红艳,我国资本配置效率及其与金融市场关系评价研究[J],管理世界,2002.1,65-70.
    (29)何春、方积乾,可交换条件下多维结构回归模型总体平均处理效应的估计[J],生物数学学报,2003.15(3),321-327.
    (30)何广文,中国农村金融供求特征及均衡供求的路径选择[J],中国农村经济,2001.10,40-45.
    (31)何广文,从农村居民资金借贷行为看农村金融抑制与金融深化[J],中国农村经济,1999.10,42-48.
    (32)何建明,基于信贷配给的货币政策有效性问题探究[J],学术界,2006.6,159-163.
    (33)胡红星,中小企业信贷配给机制的系统分析[D],苏州大学博士论文,2005.4.
    (34)胡三宁,信货配给理论发展述评[J],首都经济贸易大学学报,2005.4,28-31.
    (35)华静,我国货币政策传导的信贷配给机制探析[J],武汉金融,2000.11,31-33.
    (36)黄季、马恒运,从资金流动看改革20年农业的基础作用[J],改革,1998.5,56-63.
    (37)黄树青,信贷配给与我国乡镇企业融资困境[J],华南全融研究,2001.10,10-13.
    (38)黄祖辉、刘西川、程恩江,中国农户的信贷需求:生产性抑或消费性[J],管理世界,2007.3,73-80.
    (39)江成会等,信贷供求非均衡状态下农户信贷模式的理性选择[J],金融研究,2006.4,176-184.
    (40)姜长云,必须从战略高度重视乡镇企业的转型发展问题,经济观察网,2008年4月18日.
    (41)姜琳、赵苹,中国商业银行信用风险的评估,统计与决策[J],2007.8,103-106.
    (42)焦瑾璞、周诚君,我国农村金融服务现状分析与改革展望[J],河南金融管理干部学院学报, 2004.03,1-3.
    (43)金俐,信贷配给论:制度分析[M],上海财经大学出版社,2006年10月第1版.
    (44)凯恩斯著,货币论,商务印书馆,1986.6.
    (45)匡家在,改革开放以来农村金融体制改革的政策演变[J],河南广播电视大学学报,2007.1,15-19.
    (46)蓝虹,张晓华,论信贷配给作用于宏观经济波动的机理[J],生产力研究, 2005.7,9-32.
    (47)雷蒙德·W·戈德史密斯著,金融结构与金融发展[M],上海人民出版社,1994年3月.
    (48)李冠军,商业银行信贷成本与中小企业融资[J],会计之友,2007.14,60-62.
    (49)李红卫、叶晴,商业银行经营绩效评价研究[J],南方金融,2005.3,12-14.
    (50)李莉莉,正规金融机构小额信贷运行机制及其绩效评价[D],中国农业大学博士论文,2005.6.
    (51)李锐、李超,农户借贷行为和偏好的计量分析[J],中国农村经济,2007.8,4-14
    (52)李锐,李宁辉,农户借贷行为及其福利效果分析[J],经济研究,2004.12,96-104.
    (53)李锐、朱喜,农户金融抑制及其福利损失的计量分析[J],经济研究,2007.2,146-155.
    (54)李文豪,我国银行经营绩效评价标准对信贷配给程度的影响[J],金融研究,2006.10,82-89.
    (55)李文豪,我国银行信贷配给程度及其对货币政策效果的影响[D],浙江大学博士论文,2006.9.
    (56)厉以宁著,非均衡的中国经济[M],经济日报出版社,1990年版.
    (57)梁山,对农户小额信贷需求、安全性、盈利性和信用状况的实证研究[J],金融研究,2003.6,128-134.
    (58)廖肇辉,关于信贷配给理论的若干争论[J],经济学动态,2005.10,71—74.
    (59)林毅夫,论中国经济改革的渐进式道路[J],经济研究,1993.09,3-11.
    (60)林毅夫、李永军,中小金融机构发展与中小企业融资[J],经济研究,2001.1,10-18.
    (61)林毅夫,中国的农业信贷和农场绩效[J],比较经济学,1989.13.
    (62)刘健、崔砺金,“贷款难”:农民增收又一坎[J],记者观察,2002.07,26-28.
    (63)刘民权、徐忠,农村信用社改革和政府的职能[J],经济学季刊,2003.4,555-572.
    (64)刘民权主编,中国农村金融市场研究[M],中国人民大学出版社,2006年版.
    (65)刘明显、魏桦,关于信贷配给的产权分析[J],江苏理工大学学报(社会科学版),2001.1,40-42.
    (66)刘文忻,新凯恩斯主义的信贷配给理论[J],商业经济与管理,1997.5,53-57.
    (67)刘西川,贫困地区农户的信贷需求与信贷约束[D],浙江大学博士论文,2007年12月.
    (68)刘智、黄平,商业银行信贷配给与货币政策有效性[J],山东财政学院学报,2004.2,54-57.
    (69)陆磊、丁俊峰,中国农村合作金融转型的理论分析[J],金融研究,2006.6,1-14.
    (70)罗恩平,转型期我国农户信贷供求分析及政策选择[D],福建农林大学博士论文,2007.4.
    (71)罗凡、何勇,对近年我国信货配给双重性的探讨[J],现代管理科学,2004.3.
    (72)罗正英,我国中小企业信贷融资可获性特征研究[J],上海经济研究,2005.3,33-42.
    (73)米什金著:货币金融学,中国人民大学出版社,1998.
    (74)马宏,转轨经济条件下的信贷配给分析[J],经济评论,2007.2,85-89.
    (75)马九杰、董琦,中小企业信贷约束的成因与衡量:理论背景及分析框架[J],中国软科学,2004.03,59-68.
    (76)马九杰、孔祥智、朱勇,县域中小企业信贷约束及源自信贷供给行为的影响[J],农业经济问题,2004.7,22-28.
    (77)马九杰,信用风险评价模型进展及其对我国农村信用社适用性研究[J],中国地质大学学报(社会科学版),2001.3,27-33.
    (78)马九杰、董琦,中小企业信贷约束的成因与衡量:理论背景及分析框架[J],中国软科学,2004.3,59-68.
    (79)么振辉.规范投资行为拓展投资领域———关于我国农户借贷行为的调查报告[J].调研世界,2000.5,25-28.
    (80)穆争社,道德风险引起的信贷配给及其治理[J],财贸研究,2002.6,65-68.
    (81)穆争社,论信贷配给对宏观经济波动的影响[J],金融研究,2005.1,74-81.
    (82)穆争社,信贷配给对货币政策有效性的影响[J],中央财经大学学报,2004.1,40-44.
    (83)潘文卿、张伟,中国资本配置效率与金融发展相关性研究[J],管理世界,2003.8,16-23.
    (84)庞鑫,我国货币政策信贷渠道传导及实证研究[MA],东北财经大学硕士论文,2005.12.
    (85)彭志慧,信贷配给理论研究[MA],西南财经大学硕士论文,2005.4.
    (86)乔海曙,农村经济发展中的金融约束及解除[J],农业经济问题,2001.3,20-23.
    (87)任兆璋、郁方,中国农村的行政性金融垄断:症结与消解[J],学术研究,2008.1,85-90.
    (88)盛昭翰、朱乔、吴广谋,DEA理论、方法与应用[M],北京科学出版社,1996.
    (89)石良平、叶慧,中国转轨经济增长中的金融约束分析(上) [J],社会科学,2003.6,5-11.
    (90)石良平、叶慧,中国转轨经济增长中的金融约束分析(下) [J],社会科学,2003.7,6-14.
    (91)宋亚敏、黄绪江,对信贷配给模型的基层实证:咸宁个案[J],金融研究, 2002.03,17-22.
    (92)孙立明,关于发展新型农民资金互助合作组织的研究[MA],吉林大学硕士论文,2006.08.
    (93)孙令安,中国农户信贷特征研究[J],农村金融研究,1990.8,1-12.
    (94)孙志华,基于模型信息的平均处理效果的拟似然估计[J],中国科学,2006,36(11):1288—1301.
    (95)田俊丽,中国农村信贷配给及农村金融体系重构[D],西南财经大学博士论文,2006.4.
    (96)田力、胡改导、王东方,中国农村金融融量问题研究[J],金融研究,2004.3,125-135.
    (97)童士清,自上而下的金融体制改革路径及其绩效评价[J],经济评论,2000.2,81-84.
    (98)王健,不完善信贷市场与国有商业银行信贷配给[J],理论前沿,1997.15,10-11.
    (99)王静,涉农经济组织的融资及信贷配给[J],财经科学,2007.7,38-43.
    (100)王柯、苏毅,商业银行经营绩效的效率前沿分析[J],中山大学研究生学刊(社会科学版),1999.4,118-122.
    (101)王希、顾磊,不对称信息与信贷配给——我国中小企业融资困境的内因及建议[J],华东经济管理,2005.8,138-140.
    (102)王怡,信贷市场信息不对称研究[MA],华东师范大学硕士论文,2007.9.
    (103)吴典军、张晓涛,农户的信贷约束——基于684户农户调查的实证研究[J],农业技术经济,2008.4,41-47.
    (104)伍海华,金融区域二元结构及发展对策[J],经济理论与经济管理,2002.8,22-27.
    (105)谢平,我国存款准备金制度的改革设想[J],改革,1996.S1,31-36.
    (106)谢平、徐忠、沈明高,农村信用社改革绩效评价[J],金融研究,2006.1,23-39.
    (107)谢平,中国农村信用合作制改革的争论[J],金融研究,2001.1,1-13.
    (108)徐滇庆,农村金融改革与民营银行[J],当代财经,2004.9,27-31.
    (109)徐强,风险认知差异与信贷配给程度的关系[J],预测,2005.1,44-55.
    (110)许亦玫,论中国惜贷现象——通过信贷员行为分析信贷配给模型[J],首都经济贸易大学学报,2002.4,65-67.
    (111)亚当斯密,国富论[M],华夏出版社,2005.6,206.
    (112)阎小波,我国信贷市场逆向选择风险研究[J],预测,2000.3,45-48.
    (113)颜志杰、张林秀、张兵,中国农户信贷特征及其影响因素分析[J],农业技术经济,2005.4,2-8.
    (114)杨红丽、陈彤,新疆农户信贷需求现状分析[J],商业研究,2008.2,181-183.
    (115)杨咸月、何光辉,金融自由化、金融抑制与信贷配给[J],上海经济研究,2000.11,44-51.
    (116)杨雪莱,利率市场化条件下中小企业的融资约束及解决方法[J],商业研究,2004.13,66-68.
    (117)杨再斌、匡霞,国有商业银行对中小企业信贷配给行为的内生制度根源分析[J],财贸研究,2003.1,26-32.
    (118)姚耀军,中国农村金融改革绩效评价[J],江苏社会科学,2006.1,96-101.
    (119)姚耀军,中国农村金融体系的资金配置功能分析[J],财经理论与实践,2006.7,26-30.
    (120)姚耀军,中国农村金融研究的进展[J],浙江社会科学,2005.4,178-183.
    (121)易纲,中国的货币供求与通货膨胀[J],经济研究,1995.5,51-58.
    (122)尹志华,我国的信贷配给及原因分析[J],经济研究参考,2008.6,24-25.
    (123)岳朝龙、严忠、黄永兴主编,SAS系统与经济统计分析[Z],中国科技大学出版社,2003年版。
    (124)翟照艳、王家传等,中国农户投融资行为的实证分析[J],经济问题探索,2005.4,30-34.
    (125)张兵、许国玉,江苏省农村信贷资金配置效率[J],中国农村经济,2007.6,54-70.
    (126)张徳?谐》只碌男糯涓托糯试床恍髋渲醚芯縖MA],湘潭大学硕士论文,2007.5.
    (127)张杰,二重结构与制度演进——对中国经济史的一种新的尝试性解释[J],当代经济科学,1998.6,1-11.
    (128)张杰,解读中国农贷制度[J],金融研究,2004.2,1-7.
    (129)张杰,中国农村金融制度:结构、变迁与政策[M],中国人民大学出版社,2003年.
    (130)张军,储蓄差异及贷款需求的满足——一个经济外向型村庄农户金融活动分析[J],中国农村观察,2000.3,12-21.
    (131)张乐柱、王家传,中小企业融资问题再探讨[J],山东农业大学学报(社科版),2004.3,55-62.
    (132)张胜林、李英民、王银光,交易成本与自发激励:对传统农业区民间借贷的调查[J],金融研究,2002.2,125-134.
    (133)张勋民,信贷配给:从理论模型到中国实际[J],价值工程,2004.6,113-116.
    (134)章奇,推动农村金融改革的多元思考[J],中国农村信用合作,2005.07.
    (135)郑振东、王岗,双重信贷配给与中国银行业的流动性隐患研究[J],金融与经济,2004.9,12-13.
    (136)中国人民银行赣州市中心支行课题组,市场分割与信贷配给:利率市场化的体制及经济效应[J],金融研究,2006.1,127-138.
    (137)中国人民银行上饶市中心支行课题组,中国农村融资现实审视:制度重构[J],金融研究,2006.01,151。
    (138)中国人民银行鹰潭市中心支行课题组,农村信用社垄断问题研究[J],武汉金融,2003.8,30-32.
    (139)钟敏等,市场分割与信贷配给:利率市场化的体制及经济效应[J],金融研究, 2006.1,127-138.
    (140)钟正生、宋旺,对新凯恩斯信贷配给理论的反思——一种新制度经济学的诠释[J],金融教学与研究,2003.1,28-31.
    (141)周鸿卫,信贷配给的效率分析[J],财经理论与实践,2001.11,34-36.
    (142)周小斌,中国农业信贷市场的运行机制与绩效[D],中国农业大学博士论文,2003.6.
    (143)周振海,基于垄断和价格管制条件下的中国农村小额信贷市场分析[J],金融研究,2007.8,182-190.
    (144)朱守银、张照新、张海阳、汪承先,中国农村金融市场供给和需求——以传统农区为例[J],管理世界,2003.3,88-95.
    (145)朱方圆,我国非均衡信贷配给与经济增长相关性的实证分析[MA],东北师范大学硕士论文,2006.5.
    (146)朱佶,中国农村经济发展的金融支持研究[D],哈尔滨工程大学博士论文,2006.4.
    (147)朱喜、李子奈,改革以来我国农村信贷的效率分析[J],管理世界,2006.7,68-76.
    (148)朱喜、李子奈,我国农村正式金融机构对农户的信贷配给——一个联立离散选择模型的实证分析[J],数量经济技术经济研究,2006.3,37-49.
    (149)朱粤伟,农村金融交易成本分析[J],武汉金融,2007.9, 48-49.
    (150)祝健,中国农村金融体系重构研究[D],福建师范大学博士论文,2007.5.
    (151)Azzi,C.F. & J.C.Cox, A theory and test of credit ratinning:Comment[J],The American Economic Review,66(5):911-917,1976.
    (152)Baltensperger,Ernst(1978),Credit Rationing:Issues and Questions[J],Journal of Money,Credit and Banking,May,10(2):170-183.
    (153)Belongia,M.T. & Gilbert,R.A.(1990),The Effects of Federal Credit Programs on Farm Output[J],American Journal of Agricultural Economics,pp.769-773.
    (154)Berger, A. N. & G. F. Udell (1990),Collateral,loan quality ,and bank risk[J],Journal of Monetary Economics,25(1):21-42.
    (155)Bernhardt,D.(2000),Credit rationing? [J]the American Economic Review,90(1): 235-239.
    (156)Besanko & Thakor (1987),Collateral and rationing:Sorting equilibrium in monopo- listic and competitive markets[J],Internantional Economic Review,28(3):671-689.
    (157)Bester,H.,The role of collateral in credit markets with imperfect infomsation[J],European Economic Review,31:887-899,1987.
    (158)Bester,H.,Screening vs rationing,in credit markets with imperfect infomation[J],The American Economic Review,75(4):850-855,1985.
    (159)Binswanger,H.P. & Khandker,S.R.,1995. The Impact of Formal Finance on The Rural Economy of India[J],Journal of Development Study,32(2),234-262.
    (160)De Meza & D. D. Webb (2000),Does credit rationing imply insufficient lending? [J] Journal of Public Economics,78:215-234.
    (161)De Meza & D.D. Webb (1987),Too much investment: A problem of asymmetric infor- mation[J],Quarterly Journal of Economics 102(21):281-292.
    (162)De Meza & D.D.Webb (1992),Efficient credit rntioning[J],Etuopean Economic Review 36(6):1277-1290.
    (163)Donald R Hodgman,Credit risk and Credit rationing [J],Quarterly Journal of Economics, May 1960,Vol.74,Issue 2.
    (164)Dwight.M.Jaffee & Franco Modigliani,A Theory and Test of Credit Rationing[J],American Economic Review,Dec1969,Vol.59,Issue5.
    (165)Dwight.M.Jaffee & Thomas Russlle,Imperfect Information,Uncertainty,and Credit Rationing:a reply[J],Quarterly Journal of Economics,Nov1984.
    (166)Ellis,Howard,S(1951),The Rediscovery of Money,in Money,Trade and Economic Growth[J],New York:Macmillan Company,pp.253-269.
    (167)Fried & Howitt,Credit Rationing and Implicit Contract Theory[J],Journal of Money Credit and Banking,1980,Aug,12(3):471-487.
    (168)Gale & Hellwig,Incentive-compatible Debt Contracts:the One-period Problem[J],The Review of Economic Studies,1985,LII,647-663.
    (169)Guttentag,Jack M.(1960),Credit Availability,Interest Rates,and Monetary Policy[J],Southern Economics Journal,Jan.,26:219-228.
    (170)Hung-Jen,Wang,Symmetric information and credit rationing:Graphical Demonstra- tions[J],Financial Analysis Journal,2000,56(2):85-95.
    (171)Jaffee,D. M. & J.E. Stiglitz(1990),Credlt rationing,Ch.16 in M.B.Friedman & F.H. Hahn(ed.),Handbooks of Monetary Economics,Vol.II,Elsevier.
    (172)Jaffee,Dwight M. & Russell,Thomas(1976),Imperfect Information,Uncertainty and Credit Rationing[J],The Quarterly Journal of Economics,Nov.90(40):651-666.
    (173)Keeton,W.R.,Equilibrium Credit Rationing[M],Garland Publishing Inc.,New York and London,1979.
    (174)Kerry,D.Wandell,Imperfect information uncertainty,and credit rationging:a reply[J]. Quarterly Journal of Economics,Nov1984.
    (175)Khandker,S.R. & Faruqee,R.R.,2003,The Impact of Farm Credit in Pakistan[J], Agricultural Economics,28(3),pp.197-213.
    (176)Lensink,R. & E.Sterken,The option to wait to invest and equilibrium credit rationing[J],Journal of Money,Credit & Banking,34(1):221-225,2002.
    (177)Peter Temin & Hans-Joachim Voth, Credit rationing and crowding out during the industrial revolution: evidence from Hoare’s Bank,1702-1862[J],Explorations in Economic History,42:325-348,2005.
    (178)Pranab Kumar Das,Credit rationing and firms’investment and production decisions[J],Internantional Review of Economics & Finance,2004,87-114。
    (179)Riley,J.G,Credit rationing:A further remark[J],The American Economic Review,77(1):224-227,1987.
    (180)Roosa,R.V.,1951,Interest rates and the central bank,Money,Trade and Economic Growth:Essays in Honour of John H.Williams,Macmillan,New York.
    (181)Shaffer,S.,Competition conduct and demand elastricity[J], Economic Letters,1982. 10.167-171
    (182)Spence,A.M.(1973),Job market signaling[J],Quarterly Journal of Economics,87: 355-379.
    (183)Stephen D.Williamson,Costly Monitoring,Loan Contract,and Equilibrium Credit Rationing[J],Quarterly Journal of Economics,Feb1987,Vol.102,Issue 1.
    (184)Stiglitz,J.E.& A.Weiss(1983),Incentive effects of terminations:Applications to the credit and labor markets[J],The American Economic Review,73(5):912-927.
    (185)Stiglitz,J.E.& A.Weiss (1992),Asymmetric information in credit markets and its implications for macro-economics[J],Oxford Economic Papers,44(4):694一724.
    (186)Stiglitz,J.E. & A.Weiss(1987),Credit rationing with many borrowers[J],The American Economic Review,77:228-231.
    (187)Stiglitz,J.E. & A.Weiss,Credit rationing in markets with imperfect information[J],American Economic Review,Jun1981,Vol.71,Issue3.
    (188)Wilson,J.S.G.(1954),Credit Rationin and the Relevant Rate of Interest[J],Economics New Series,Feb.,21(8):21-31.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700