用户名: 密码: 验证码:
基于资源基础理论的国家竞争力评价研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
随着人类社会经济文化的不断发展,任何层面的组织之间(无论是企业之间还是国家之间)的竞争都日趋激烈。从企业战略管理的经典理论——资源基础理论(ResourceBasedTheory,RBT)角度来说,战略资源是企业获得竞争优势并进而实现经营目标的重要影响因素。实际上,战略资源不仅仅是企业获取竞争优势的重要支撑要素,也是一个国家获得竞争能力和实现持续发展的有效保障。本文正是从战略资源这一视角对国家竞争力评价的理论框架进行了较为全面的探讨,并结合应用大量数据对部分国家进行了实证研究,对提升我国战略资源水平,进而提高国家竞争力提出了相应的对策建议。
     在相关研究综述的基础上,本文首先探讨了从资源基础理论的视角研究国家竞争力的可行性。资源基础理论多用于企业层面,很多学者以此为理论基础研究企业的成长和企业竞争力,并对其做出评价。本篇论文结合资源基础理论和国家竞争力的相关研究,从资源基础理论的视角来研究国家竞争力,分析资源与国家竞争力的关系,将国家竞争力等同于那些特殊的资源,即对国家竞争优势具有决定意义的国家战略资源。
     在对国家战略资源的作用机制研究当中,借鉴企业层面的相关研究中把企业资源划分为有形资源和无形资源的做法,本文从战略资源对国家竞争力的作用机理的角度,将国家战略资源划分为显性资源和隐性资源。这用划分方法使我们能够从本质上理解资源与国家竞争力的关系,并且也为国家竞争力评价模型的构建提供理论依据。
     在构建基于资源基础理论的国家竞争力评价模型过程中,本文提出了自然资源的环境保护指数和隐性战略资源的效用指数的概念,更加科学地表达了不同资源与国家竞争力之间的关联关系。在基于资源基础理论的国家竞争力评价模型的基础上,本文将基于模糊Borda数分析法引入到国家竞争力评价指标的权重计算当中,并采用68项指标对14个典型国家的竞争力进行了评价和深入分析,提出了中国提升国家竞争力的对策建议。
Along with human society economic civilization unceasing development,competition among organizations becomes more and more vehement. From the angleof resource based theory (RBT), the strategic resources are the key factor to obtaincompetitive advantage. In fact, the strategic resources are not only the key factor toobtain competitive advantage, but also an guarantee for countryto obtain competitiveability and realize sustained development. Under this circumstance, this thesis hascarried on comprehensive discussion on national competence theory frame from theangle of strategic resources, making use of sufficient data, this thesis conduct anempirical study and will promote our country strategic resources level by puttingforwardcorrespondingcountermeasure.
     Based on related research, this article firstly discusses the feasibility to studycountrycompetence from the angle of resource base theory. The resource base theoryhas been mostly used in enterprise field and many scholars take this theory onenterprise's growth as well as enterprise competitive power. By uniting resource basetheory and related research on national competitive power, this thesis studies thenational competitive power from the resource base theory's angle of view, analyzesthe relationship between resources and national competence, and regards nationalcompetitive power as a kind of special resource, namely the decisively significantnationalstrategyresourcestothecountrycompetitiveadvantage.
     In the function mechanism research on national strategy resources, manyscholars divide enterprise resource into two kinds, namely explicit resource and tacitresource. Taking this research angle for reference, this article divides the nationalstrategy resources into the dominant resources and the recessive resources from theangleoffunctionmechanismonstrategicresourcestothenational competitivepower.This method enables us thoroughly understand the relationship between resource andnational competence, and also provides the theoretical basis for evaluation model onnationalcompetence.
     In the process of constructing national competence evaluation model based onthe resource base theory's, this thesis puts forward the concept of natural resource'senvironmental protection index and the recessive strategic resources' effectivenessindex, thus better describe the relationship between the different resources and thenational competence. Based on national competence evaluation model taking RBTinto consideration, this article introduce the fuzzyBorda number analytic method into the weight calculation of evaluation indicator on national competence, carry onthorough evaluation as well as analysis upon 14 typical country competence using 68index, and put forward the corresponding suggestions to enhance Chinese countrycompetence.
引文
[1] Dollar D., Wolf E. Competiveness, Convergence and InternationalSpecialization [M],Cambridge: The MIT Press,1993
    [2] Magee S P, Brock W A, and Young L. Black Hole Tarifs and EndogenousPolicy Formation[M], Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1989.
    [3] Hoffman K. Clothing, Chips and Comparative Advantage: the Impact ofMicroelectronics on Trade and Production in the Garment Industry [J],World Development, 1985. 13: 371-92.
    [4]中国科学院可持续发展研究组,2003中国可持续发展战略报告[M],科学出版社,2003
    [5]黄硕风,中国综合国力与未来[J],未来与发展,1999,(5): 8-11
    [6]黄硕风,大国较量[M],北京:世界知识出版社,2006
    [7]赵彦云,汪涛等,2001年中国国际竞争力评价和分析[J],经济理论与经济管理,2002, (6):5-11
    [8]施祖辉,新中国的综合国力—时序轨迹与空间比较[J],财经研究,1999,(10): 32-38
    [9] Michael Porter,Competitive Advantage of Nations[M],New York:The FreePress,1990
    [10] Yang and Borland,A microeconomic mechanism for economic growth[J], Journal of Political Economy,1991
    [11] Barre. R J. Economic Growth in a Gross Section of Countries [J],Quarterly Journal of Economics, May. 1991. 101: 407-43.
    [12]亚当·斯密,国民财富的性质和原因的研究[M],北京:商务印书馆,1972
    [13]大卫·李嘉图,政治经济学和赋税原理[M],北京:商务印书馆,1976
    [14] Eli F Heckscher,The Effect of Foreign Trade on the Distributionof Income[J], Ekonomisk Tidskrift, 1919, 21(2), pp: 497-512
    [15]伯尔蒂尔·奥林,地区间贸易和国际贸易[M],北京:商务印书馆,1986
    [16] R.E.Baldwin,Determinants of Trade and Foreign Investment:FurtherEvidence[J],Review of Economics and Statistics,February 1979,61(1),PP: 40-48
    [17] P.B.Kenen, Nature,Capital and Trade[J], Journal of PoliticalEconomy, October 1965, 73 ,PP:437-460
    [18] M.V.Posner, International Trade and Technical Change[J], OxfordEconomic Papers,October 1961 13(3),PP:323-341
    [19] G.C.Hufbauer, Synthetic Materials and the Theory of InternationalTrade[M], Duckworth, 1965
    [20]熊伟,新国家竞争优势论:当今国际贸易的理论基础――兼对国际贸易主要理论述评[J],财经理论与实践,2004,25(2):98-102
    [21]胡鞍钢,王绍光,第二次转型—国家制度建设[C],北京:清华大学出版社,2003
    [22]胡鞍钢,影响决策的国情报告[M],北京:清华大学出版社,2002
    [23] Stopford. J. M., and Strange. S., Rival states, rival firms:Competition for world market shares[M], Cambridge: CambridgeUniversity Press,1991
    [24] Ozlemoz ,The Competitive Advantage of Nations, the Case of Turkey:Assessing Porter's Framework for National Advantage[M], AshgatePublishing,1999
    [25] Solow.R.M, A Contribution to the Theory of EconomicGrowth[J],Quarterly Journal of Economics,1956,70(1), PP:65-94
    [26] Paul M.Romer, Increasing Returns and Long-Run Growth[J], Journalof Political Economy, October 1986, 94(5), PP:1002-37.
    [27] R.E.Lucas, 0n the mechanics of economic development [J], Journalof Monetary Economics. 1988, 22(1),PP:3—42
    [28] Ernst D, O'Conner D. Technology and Global Competition: theChallenge for Newly Industrializing Countries[R]. Development Centerof the OECD, 1989
    [29] Dollar D. Technical Diferences as a Source of ComparativeAdvantage[J],American Economic Review, May. 1993, 88: 431-501
    [30] Balance R., et.al. Consistensy Tests of Alternative Measures ofComparative Advantage [J]. Review of Economics and Statistics,1987.69: 157-161.
    [31] Barney J . B,Strategic Factor Market:Expectation,Luck,andBusiness Strategy[J],Management Science,1986, 32(10),PP:1231—1241
    [32] Rumelt, Diversification strategy and profitability, StrategicManagement Review, 1982 (3), PP:359-369
    [33] Grant R . M,The Resource—Based Theory of CompetitiveAdvantage:Implications for Strategy Formulation[J],CaliforniaManagement Review,1991, 33(3),spring,PP:114—135
    [34] Barney J . B,Firm Resources and Sustained CompetitiveAdvantage[J],Journal of Management,1991,17(1),PP:99—120
    [35] Wegloop P . ,Linking Firm Strategy and GovernmentAction:Toward a Resources—Based perspective on Innovation andTechnology Policy[J],Technology in Society,1995,17(4),PP:413—428
    [36] Cheung S N S. The Structure of a Contract and the Theory of aNon-Exclusive Resource [J]. Journal of Law & Economics, 1970. 13(1):49-70
    [37] Pilat D, Rao D S. Multilateral Comparisons of Output, Productivityand Purchasing Power Parities in Manufacturing[J].Review of Incomeand Wealth, 1996.42: 113-129
    [38] Selznick P . ,Leadership in Administration:A SociologicalInterpretation,Row,Peterson and Company[M],New York:Free Press,1957
    [39] Chandler, Alfred Dupont, Strategy and structure, M.I.T. Press,1962
    [40] Ansoff,Corporate Strategy,1965
    [41] Penrose E.T,The Theory of the Growth of the Firm [M],New York:JohnWiley,1959
    [42] Wernerfelt B,A resource—Based View of the Firm [J],StrategicManagement Journal,1984,5(1),PP:171—180
    [43] Prahalad , C. K. and Gary Hamel, The core competence of thecorporation,HarvardBusinessReview,1990
    [44] Petersf M . A . ,The Comerstones of Competitive Advantage:AResource—Based View[J],Strategic ManagementJournal,1993,14(3),PP:179—191
    [45] David Collis, Cynthia A Montgomery, Competing on Resource, HarvardBusiness Review, 1995,7-8
    [46] Conner K. R.,A Historical Comparison of Resources—Based Theoryand Five School of Thought within Industrial OrganizationEconomics:D0 We Have a New Theory of the Firm ? [J],Journal ofManagement,1991,17(1),PP:121—154
    [47]黄旭,企业战略变革研究[M],成都:四川大学出版社,2004
    [48] Locks J. "Second Treatise of Government", in Arthur J and ShawW(ed.). Social&Political Philosophy [C]. Prentice Hall 1,1992:493-505.
    [49] CollisDJ,How Valuable Are Organizational Capabilities?,StrategicManagement Joumal, 1994 (3):l43-152
    [50] IMD,World CompetitivenessYearbook(2001)[R],IMD,Lausanne,Switzerland,2001
    [51]联合国环境规划,转引自:杨秀苔,资源经济学[M],重庆:重庆大学出版社,1993
    [52]马克思,资本论[A].马克思恩格斯全集[M](第23卷),北京:人民出版社,1972
    [53]恩格斯,自然辩证法[M],北京:人民出版社,1984
    [54]刘成武,杨志荣,方中权,自然资源概论[M],北京:科学出版社,2000
    [55] J.Coleman,Foundation of Social Theory[M] ,Cambridge: CambridgeUniversity Press,1990;中译本社会理论的基础[M],北京:社会科学文献出版社,1999
    [56]薛平,资源论[M],北京:地质出版社,2004
    [57]周鸿,论我国社会发展中大资源开发利用的五大原则[J],软科学,2001,15(4):11-13
    [58]刘克,郭晓立、刘若维,改善外部环境,促进民营企业核心能力的形成[J],当代经济研究,2002,(3):31-32
    [59]高海滨,构筑企业未来竞争优势的战略性资源[J],企业活力,1999,(6):4-6
    [60]邱琼,陈炳富,企业战略资源:企业竞争优势的源泉和基础[J],江西财经大学学报,2000,(3):21-24
    [61]杨杰,战略资源与核心能力[J],经营与管理,2000,(10):28-29
    [62]肖永平,基于资源观的持续竞争优势研究:[硕士学位论文],东南大学企业管理,2004,3
    [63]李维华,韩红梅,资源观的演化及全面资源论下的资源定义[J],管理科学文摘,2003,(2):10-14
    [64]谷树忠,姚予龙,沈镭,吕耀,资源安全及其基本属性与研究框架[J],自然资源学报,2002,17(3):280-285
    [65]胡鞍钢,门洪华,中美日俄印有形战略资源比较——兼论旨在“富民强国”的中国大战略[J],战略与管理,2002,(2):26-41
    [66]詹家峰,国家战略能力与综合国力关系浅析[J],现代国际关系,2005,(4):21-27
    [67]王辉,张选伟,为国家竞争力服务—美国运输部组织结构转变的启示[J].中国改革,2000, (5): 52-53
    [68] Aschauer.D.A,“Is Public Expenditure Productive?”,Journalof Monetary Economics,1989a.23,PP:177—200
    [69] Catherine J.Morrison and Amy Ellen Schwartz, State infrastructureand productive performance.The American Economic Review,1996,Vol86,No.5,PP:l095一llll
    [70] Vijaya G . Duggal,Cynthia Saltzman,Lawrence R.Klein,Infrastructure and productivity:a nonlinear approach,Journal ofEconometrics 92,1999,PP:47—74
    [71]韦正球,覃明兴,从小资源到大资源—一种新的资源观[J],广西大学学报,2006,28(2):67-71
    [72]王军,郭顺,环境管制与国际竞争力[J],经济研究参考,2004,(71):39
    [73] De Ferranfi,D.,G.Perry,D.Laderman,W.Maloney,“From naturalresources to the knowledge economy”.World Bank Latin American andCaribbean Studies,The World Bank,Washington.DC,2002
    [74] De Long,J.B.,J.G.Williamson,“Natural resources and convergencein the nineteenth and twentieth centuries”,unpublished paper,HarvardUniversity,1994
    [75] Wright,G.,“The origins of American industrial success,1879—1940”,AER,1990,(80):651-668
    [76] Gylfason,Thorvaldur,“Natural resources,eduecafion,and economicdevelopment”,European Economic Review , 2001,45(4—6):847—859.
    [77] Sachs,J.D., A.M.Warner,“Natural resources abundance and economicgrowth”,NBER Working Paper No.5398.1995
    [78] Gylfason.T.,G.Zoega,“Natural resources and economic growth:Therole of investment”,CEPR Discussion Paper No.2743.2001
    [79] R.Hausmann,R.Rigobon,“An alternafive interpretation 0f the‘resource curse’”.NBER Working Paper No.9424.2OO2
    [80] Sala-i-Martin,X . ,A . Subramanian,“Addressing the naturalresource curse:An illustration from Nigeria”,NBER Workjng PaperNo.9804,2003
    [81] Priem R L,Butler J E,Is the Resource-based View a UsefulPerspective for Strategic Management Research ,Academy of ManagementReview,2001.26(1):35-37
    [82]西奥多.W.舒尔茨,人力资本投资:教育和研究的作用[M].北京:商务印书馆,1990, PP:52—53
    [83] Andrea Bassanini,Stefano Scarpetta.Does human capital matter forgrowth in OECD countries? a pooled mean_group approach[J].EconomicsLetters,2002,74(3):399—405.
    [84] Romer P . M . Endogenous technological change[J] . Journal ofPolitical Economy,1990,(98):71—102
    [85]沈利生,朱运法,人力资源开放与经济增长关系的定量研究[J],数量经济技术经济研究,1997,(12):9—13
    [86]游士兵,胡彭辉,对国家竞争力的综合影响因素分析,全国商情·经济理论研究,2005(4):10-14
    [87] Mankiw N G,Romer D,Weil D. N,A Contribution to the Empirics ofEconomic Growth[J],Quarterly Journal ofEconomics,1992,(107):407—37.
    [88] R.J.Barro,Determinants of Economic Growth,MIT Press,1997
    [89] R . J . Barro,“Human capital and in cross_countryregressions”,unpublished,Harvard University, 1998
    [90]马谦杰,于本海,信息资源评价理论与方法[M],北京:经济科学出版社,2002
    [91] G.Stigler, The Economics of Information,Journal of PoliticalEconomy, 1961,69
    [92] Porat,The Information Economy,Washington,1997
    [93] Kohlberg E, Mertens J. On the Strategic Stability of Equilibria[J]. Econometrics, 1986. 54: 1003-1039.
    [94]崔雪松,企业技术战略的分析与选择:[博士学位论文],东北大学,2005
    [95]李春田,标准化概论[M],北京:中国人民大学出版社,1995
    [96]李兴国,张令保,黄闵,科技进步贡献率的测算方法与应用[J],运筹与管理,1996,5(4):41-44
    [97]舒辉,标准化理论与实务[M],北京:经济管理出版社,1999
    [98] Lall S. Competitiveness Indices and Developing Countries: AnEconomic Evaluation of the Global Competitiveness Report [J]. WorldDevelopment, 2001. 29(9): 1501-1525.
    [99] Solow.R . M,A Contribution to the Theory of EconomicGrowth[J],Quarterly Journal of Economics,1956,PP:70
    [100] Denison,E.F, The rsources of Economic Growth in the United Statesand the Alternatives before US,New York:Committee for EconomicDevelopment,1962
    [101]刘明兴,陶然,章奇,制度、技术和内生经济增长[J],世界经济文汇,2003,(6):64—80
    [102]冯江源,综合国力系统:多元要素和结构的整约与共适[J],科学学研究,2006,6(18):20-24
    [103]马克斯·韦伯,新教伦理和资本主义精神[M],上海:上海三联书店,1987
    [104] D.C.诺斯,制度、制度变迁与经济绩效[M],上海:上海三联书店,1994
    [105] Greif. A,Cultural Beliefs and Organizations of Society: A Historical and Theoretical Reflection on Collectivist and IndividualSocieties[J], Journal of Political Economy, vol. 102, No. 5, 1994, PP:912-950
    [106] Faria, J.R., M. Leon-Ledesma,Testing the Balassa Samuelsoneffect:Implications for growth and the PPP[J],Journal ofMacroeconomics,2003,25, PP:241-253
    [107]韦森,文化精神、制度变迁与经济增长——中国-印度经济比较的理论反思[J],国际经济评论,2004,(4):60-63
    [108]韦森,从文化传统反思东西方市场经济的近代形成路径[J],世界经济,2002,(10):33-40
    [109] Paul M.Romer,Increasing Returns and Long-Run Growth,Journal ofPolitical Economy, October 1986, 94(5):1002-1037
    [110] R.E.Lucas,0n the mechanics of economic developement”,Journalof Monetary Economics,1988,(22):3-42
    [111] Mayer W,Endogenous Tarif Formation[J],American Economic Review,1984,74(5):970-985
    [112]马信行,国家竞争力指标之重构及教育对竞争力贡献的探讨[J],中国高等教育评估,2001,(4): 50-54
    [113] R.Nurkse,Problems of Capital Formation in UnderdevelopedCountries [M]. Oxford,1953: 59-68
    [114] W .A.Lewis,Economic development with unlimited supply oflabor,The Manchester school of economic and social studies,1954
    [115] R.R.Nelson,A Theory of Low Level Equilibrium Trap inUnderdeveloped Countries[J],American Economic Review,1956,1:49
    [116] P.N.Rosenstein-Rodan,Industrialization of Eastern and South-Eastern Europe[J].Economic Journal, 1943,53
    [117]萨伊,政治经济学概论[M],北京:商务印书馆,1982
    [118]凯恩斯,就业、利息与货币通论[M],北京:商务印书馆,1982
    [119]马克思,资本论(第1卷)[M],北京:人民出版社,1972,124
    [120]金暗,产业国际竞争力研究[J],经济研究,1996,(11): 39-44, 59
    [121]刘重力,赵军华,以竞争优势提升中国工业产业国际竞争力实证分析[J],南开经济研究,2004,(5):43-49
    [122]余鲁,西部大开发与重庆优势产业的选择[J],渝州大学学报,2001,18(1):23-26
    [123]李冰,浅谈产业集群与经济发展[J],广西轻工业,2006,(5):103-107
    [124]雷·克莱因,一九七七年世界国力评估[M],台湾:商务印书馆,1978
    [125]约瑟夫·奈,软力量:世界政坛成功之道[M],吴小辉,钱程译,北京:东方出版社,2005
    [126] WEF.,The Global Competitiveness Report 2003-2004[R] , WET,2004212
    [127]黄硕风,综合国力新论:兼论新中国综合国力[M],北京:中国社会科学出版社,1999
    [128]海平等,各国综合国力排行榜[M]北京:中国经济出版社,1998
    [129]丁峰峻,综合国力论——2000年我国国家发展战略刍议[J],学术界动态,1987,(6)
    [130]张文奎,人文地理学概论[M],长春:东北师范大学出版社,1987
    [131]朱喜安,肖腊珍,综合国力对比方法研究[J],统计与决策,1999,(1):13-14
    [132]于宏义,王佑棣,综合国力测度评价[J],科技进步与对策,1989,(5):51-55
    [133]侯经川,基于博弈论的国家竞争力评价体系研究[D]:[博士学位论文],武汉大学,2005
    [134]凯勒,个人结构心理学[M],杭州:浙江教育出版社,2001
    [135]杨季美,史本山,群体评价中的并合方法[J],系统工程理论与实践,1992,(1):49-51
    [136]谢伏瞻,世界统计年鉴-2006/2007[M],北京:中国财政经济出版社,2007
    [137]刘国平,世界经济统计[M],北京:经济科学出版社,2002
    [138]周浩然,世界经济文化年鉴[M],北京:中国社会科学出版社,2002
    [139] (德)康纳利斯等,世界经济论坛2002-2003年全球竞争力报告(方丽英,罗志先等译)[M],北京:机械工业出版社,2003
    [140]国际能源机构, http://www.iea.org,访问时间:2007-11-24
    [141]联合国教育科学文化组织, http://unstats.un.org/unsd/default.htm,访问时间:2007-11-24
    [142]世界银行, http://www.worldbank.org,访问时间:2007-11-24
    [143]连玉明,中国国情报告2003[M],北京:中国时代经济出版社,2003
    [144]连玉明,中国国力报告2003[M],北京:中国时代经济出版社,2003
    [145]连玉明,中国国策报告2003[M],北京:中国时代经济出版社,2003
    [146]侯伦,信息化对国际竞争力的影响[J] ,电子科技大学学报(社科版) ,2001,3(3): 8-12
    [147]赵景柱,丁丁等,可持续发展综合国力的理论分析[J] ,环境科学,2003,24(1): 1-7
    [148]杨家宏,关于国家石油安全战略之研究[J],学术界,2002,(1):78-84
    [149]赵英,超越危机:国家经济安全的监测预警[M],福建:福建人民出版社1999,160-161
    [150]谢小立,长江中游三省粮食安全与水问题对策[M],北京:北京科技出版社1999,217-222
    [151] Kurt W R,Feddema R, Comprehensive security in Asia: views from Asiaand the West on a changing security environment,2000
    [152]陆伟国,我国粮食消费量中长期预测模型—兼论趋势与对策[J],粮食问题研究,1996(1):32-34
    [153]陈雅芝,解俊贤,中国科技国际竞争力及其评价[J] ,科技进步与对策,2000,17(9): 37-39
    [154]李军,我国服务业国际竞争力分析[J],经济问题,2004,(5): 27-29

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700