用户名: 密码: 验证码:
大小兴安岭森林生态功能区森林保险发展研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
大小兴安岭森林生态功能区是《全国主体功能区规划》中限制开发区域目录下的重要生态功能区,也是全国最大的国有林区,行政区域跨内蒙古自治区与黑龙江两省,在维护国家生态安全、应对气候变化、保障国家长远木材供给等方面具有不可替代的作用。大小兴安岭森林生态功能区处于我国重要的气候分带---季风区与非季风区的分界线上,森林灾害特别是森林火灾发生比较频繁,灾害不仅对林区的经济社会发展和人民生活影响巨大,而且对于森林生态系统影响深远,因此对转嫁森林风险的最佳工具---森林保险具有客观需求。
     由于大小兴安岭林区自开发建设以来即进行国有经营,中央政府与地方政府每年需要投入巨资支付森林灾害造成的损失,帮助林业企业恢复林业生产和维持正常生活,这已成为政府的一个沉重的经济负担,因此政府层面也亟需在该地区开展森林保险业务,通过保险公司的运营来转嫁政府部门过重的救灾负荷。林业企业因为“委托代理关系”的存在,依赖政府对森林灾害的灾害救助及补偿供给,林业企业对政府高度依存,缺乏购买森林保险的意愿。企业负担沉重,在艰难支撑庞杂的社会支出之余,很难拿出巨资来缴纳森林保险的费用,这种既无意愿保险也无实力保险的现实在一定程度上制约着该区域森林保险业务的开展。因此寻求合理的森林保险发展方式,如何组织森林保险运行是该地区森林保险发展的重点。
     文章首先进行了森林保险发展的国内外比较研究。运用比较分析方法,在对我国二十几年森林保险发展实践分析的基础上,考察我国森林保险发展的现状,总结森林保险现实存在的问题及面临的障碍。比较分析北欧、美国、日本、澳大利亚和俄罗斯等国家森林保险的共同特点和成功经验,分析对我国森林保险发展的有益启示,为本文明确大小兴安岭森林生态功能区森林保险的发展方向提供可借鉴之处。
     其次分析了大小兴安岭森林生态功能区的区域现状、发展森林保险的影响因素及各方主体行为。通过基本情况分析可知,大小兴安岭森林生态功能区生态区位非常重要,区域森林生态系统服务物质量及价仇较为显著,区域经济和社会事业发展的总体状况不容乐观。运用回归分析方法,得到该地区保险发展的主要因素有森林管护程度、森林灾害受害率与地区发展水平。接下来对大小兴安岭开展森林保险的各主体行为进行了分析,明确了在现有的产权关系下,政府既应该是保险制度的主体,也应该是组织供给的主体。林业企业处于不愿投保也无力投保的经营现状,保险公司在高致损性高赔付率情况下亦不愿承保的现实。
     第三,明确了大小兴安岭森林生态功能区森林保险发展路径。首先基于博弈论模型,分别就竞争和垄断两种市场定位进行比较,分析得出垄断机制下整个社会的目标函数与保险人的目标函数一致,也就是说,政府施行的垄断决策能够使得生态功能区森林保险发展实现最优,社会福利达到最大化。同时运用福利经济学相关理论对强制保险的几种方式进行了比较,最终明确强制与补贴相结合的森林保险方式是大小兴安岭森林生态功能区森林保险发展的正确选择。
     第四,对大小兴安岭森林生态功能区森林保险产品进行设计。尝试按照森林经营性质差别构建多样化的森林保险产品。从保险精算理论出发,运用损失率法对该区的森林火灾保险的费率进行了厘定,尝试使用卫星遥感(MODIS)数据产品,利用温度植被干旱指数模型(TVDI)对森林火灾保费的厘定进行扩展分析。同时从大小兴安岭森林生态功能区森林生态和经济价值出发对森林保险保额进行确定。
     第五,进行大小兴安岭森林生态功能区森林保险组织建构。首先明确设立国有林保险公司专门承保国有林保险,大小兴安岭林区国有林应由其下设分支机构负责保险。进而选择Delta战略模型指导该地区森林保险进行战略性经营,为森林保险顺利发展提供分析问题、判断形势的战略工具。同时明确该地区森林保险的组织层次结构与组织体系,分别从协同体系、激励体系与保障体系出发,确定该区森林保险发展的组织体系,力求能够为该地区的森林保险顺利发展服务。
     最后,提出促进大小兴安岭森林生态功能区森林保险快速发展和有效运行的对策措施,主要从政府创新的牵引对策、政策倾斜的催化对策及学术支撑的动力对策等方面研究提出加快大小兴安岭森林生态功能区森林保险发展的保障对策与措施建议。
The forest ecological function regionalization of Greater and Lesser kningan Mountains is an important forest ecological function regionalization of the national limit developing zone and the biggest state-owned forest region of China, which administrative areas across Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region and Heilongjiang province. It plays irreplaceable role on ecological security, climate change and long-term supply of timber. This area is an important climate zone that dividing the line between monsoon and non-monsoon. So, forest disasters especially forest fire occur frequently, which not only have an huge impact on the economic and social development and people's lives, but also have far-reaching influence on the growth of vegetation under the forest system. So, this region has completely objective demand for this best tool of transferring forest risks.
     Because of state-owned operation form building, the central government and local governments need invest a huge sum of money to pay the forest disasters losses every year in order to restore forestry production and maintain normal life, which has become a heavy economic burden. So, government needs carry out the forest insurance and relief the burden through the operation of insurance company. Because of "principal-agent", forest enterprises rely on the compensation and salvation of forest disaster from government that lead these forest enterprises highly dependent on government and lack of the willingness to buy forest insurance. Furthermore, forest enterprises also have a heavy burden so that it is different to take out a huge sum of money to pay the forest insurance besides supporting the confused social spending. This reality of nether willingness nor capability for insurance restricts the development of forest insurance in some extent. Therefore, finding a reasonable organization of forest insurance and reasonable design of technical elements is the key point of developing forest insurance.
     First, the paper makes a comparative research of the development of forest insurance at home and abroad. Using comparative analysis, based on the forest insurance development in more than20years of China, the paper investigates the present situation of forest insurance in China, summarizes problems and obstacles of the forest insurance. It analyzes common features and successful experience of forest insurance between the northern Europe, the United States, Japan, Australia Russia and other countries to get some beneficial enlightenment for development of our forest insurance, which provides referential points for the forest insurance system of the forest ecological function regionalization of Greater and Lesser kningan Mountains.
     Second, the paper analyzes the present situation, the influence factors of forest insurance and the main body behavior of the forest ecological function regionalization of Greater and Lesser kningan Mountains. Based on these basic situation, the ecological location of the forest ecological function regionalization of Greater and Lesser kningan Mountains is very important, the quality and value of forest ecosystem service is significant, while its economic and social development is not optimistic. The main influence factors are the degree of forest management, the rate of forest disaster and the level of forestry development by regression analysis. Then, the paper analyzes the main body behavior and makes clear government should be not only the subject of insurance system but also the subject of organization supply under the present property rights. Forest enterprises have unwillingness and incapability to insure and insurance companies also have unwilling to cover under this high loss and high rate of compensation.
     Then, the paper makes qualitative research on insurance pattern of the forest ecological function regionalization. Based on the game theory model, the paper discusses two kinds of insurance, competition mechanism and monopoly mechanism. It shows that the forest ecological function regionalization should take compulsory forest insurance for ecological forest. Under the monopoly mechanism, the objective function between the insurer and the whole society is uniformly. It means the decisions form government can achieve optimization of the forest ecological function regionalization and maximize social welfare. And it makes clear that the forest insurance pattern of combining compulsory with allowance is the correct choice of developing forest insurance in the region.
     Then, the paper designs insurance products for the forest ecological function regionalization of Greater and Lesser kningan Mountains. The paper designs diversified insurance products based on difference of forest management. From the actuarial theory, it determines the forest fire insurance premium by losing method. Try to use MODIS date products and the Temperature Vegetation Drought Index (TVDI) to deeply analyze the forest fire insurance premium. At the same time, it determines the sum insured form the characteristics of forest ecological and economic value in the forest ecological function regionalization of Greater and Lesser kningan Mountains.
     Then, the paper constructs organization of the forest insurance for the forest ecological function regionalization of Greater and Lesser kningan Mountains. Firstly set up a state-owned insurance company specialized state-owned forest insurance and its branch responsible for forest insurance of the state-owned forest region of Greater and Lesser kningan Mountains. Secondly, it chooses Delta strategy model to guide the strategic management of forest insurance, which provide a strategic tool to analyze problems and judge situations for the development of forest insurance. At the same time, the paper makes clear the organization structure and organization system and definite organization system from synergistic system, incentive system and security system that try to service for development of forest insurance in this area.
     Finally, the paper puts forward some suggestions and effective measures from policy, government and academy to promote the development and effective operation of forest insurance in the forest ecological function regionalization of Greater and Lesser kningan Mountains.
引文
[1]《全国生态环境保护纲要》,国务院,2000
    [2]《全国主体功能区规划》,2011
    [3]金正道.我国森林保险的现状和前景[J].国土绿化,2001,(5):13
    [4]石焱.我国南方集体林区森林保险事业发展对策研究,北京林业大学,2009
    [5]王丹,陈珂.我国森林保险的现状、问题与对策[J].沈阳农业大学学报(社会科学版),2005,7(1):13-16.
    [6]李丹,我国森林保险发展与运行体系研究,东北林业大学,2008
    [7]潘家坪.林业保险的性质与发展我国林业保险事业[J].林业资源管理,1997,(4):16-19.
    [8]陈玲芳.我国森林保险发展的现状、问题与对策研究[J].福建农林大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2005,8(4):38-41
    [9]王华丽,陈建成.政府支持与我国森林保险发展的经济学分析[J].经济问题,2009.(10)
    [10]潘家坪,常继锋.我国森林保险面临的机遇与挑战[J].林业建设,2000,(5):2-4
    [11]何运才.林业保险的险种应再广一点,2008
    [12]田芸.林业保险浅析[J].林业经济问题,1996,(2):51-55
    [13]金刚.阿坝州森林保险初探[J].四川金融,1991(9):43-44.
    [14]王中奎,王丙灵,刘献华.开展森林火灾保险一促进林业生产发展明.森林防火,1995,(3):16
    [15]曹冠武,夏艳芳.河南省开展森林保险的实践和思考[J].中国减灾,1996,6(4):22-23
    [16]刘红梅,周小寒等.加快发展我国林业保险的研究,经济体制改革,2007(1)41
    [17]陈盛伟,薛兴利.林业标准化促进林业保险发展的机理分析[J].林业经济问题,2006,26(2):138-141
    [18]黄祖梅,李萍.森林保险市场的信号甄别和激励机制[J].湖北工业大学学报,2006(6):89-91
    [19]http://www.gov.cn/zt/qlzhkyyxbdzhgz/
    [20]段昆.美国农业保险制度及其对我国农业保险发展的启示[J].中国软科学,2002(03):125-127
    [21]王锦.林业受灾直接经济损失573亿元.中国证券报,2008-2-20
    [22]石焱,夏自谦.我国森林保险发展缓慢的深层次原因及对策分析[J].林业济,2008(12):69-73
    [23]王华丽.基于风险区划的中国森林保险区域化发展研究,北京林业大学博士论文,2011
    [24]张长达.完善我国政策性森林保险制度研究,北京林业大学博士论文,2012
    [25]Reidar Holst. Forest fire insurance in Norway[J].American Forests,1923,34(8):487-490.
    [26]H. E. Carlson. Norwegian forest fire insurance[J]. Journal of Institute Statistics, 1923,3(4):65.
    [27]A. Angstrom.Forest insurance in Sweden[C]. Forest fire prevention and control: proceedings of an international seminar organized by the Timber Committee of the United Nations EconomicCommission for Europe, Warsaw, Poland,1981,(5):223-227
    [28]Anonymous. Fire insurance[J]. Forestry Quart,1908,6 (4):434-435
    [29]Franz Heske. German forestry. New Haven,1938:342 pp
    [30]William N. Sparhawk. Suggestions for rating risks in forest insurance[J]. Journal of forestry,1920,18(7):701-709.
    [31]C.C. Averill, L. M. Frost. Some factors underlying forest fire insurance in Massachusetts. Harvard Forest Bulletin 17,1933:10.
    [32]Washington, D. C.Forest fire insurance in the Pacific Coast States. U. S. Department of Agriculture, Tech. Bulletin 551.1937
    [33]M. Yatagai. History and present status of forest fire insurance in Japan[J]. Journal of forestry.1933,31(1):23-29
    [34]金满涛.美国、北欧、日本森林保险比较及其启示[J].保险职业学院学报,2008(6):74-77
    [35]Jan H,Jaroslav S Jan T,et al.Fire risk insurance model for forest stands growing in the area of Slovak Paradise [J],2003
    [36]Blennow K,Sallnas O.Risk Percept ion Among Non-industrial Private Forest Owners[J],Scaninavian Journal of Forest Research.2002(17):472-479
    [37]Holthausen N,P Baur.The Demand for an Insurance against Storm Damage in Swiss Forests [J] Schweizerische Zeischrift fur Forstwesen,2004(10):426-436
    [38]Ruohola T.H, et al. Availability and Use of Forest Insurances [J] Tyotehoseuran Metsatiedote 2005(4)
    [39]Brunette M.Couture S.Effects of Public Compensation for Disaster Damages on Private Insurance and Forest Managament Decisions[J]2007(6):1-31
    [40]Lufeng. Principles of Economics(China Version).PEKING UNIVERSITY PRESS. ISBN 7-301-05504-8/F.0505 2005.08
    [41]John Sloman.Economics [England] ISBN 7-5058-2617-9.2001.10
    [42]John Friedmann. Regional Development Policy:A Case Study of Venezuela [M].The MIT press,1966:5
    [43]王一鸣.中国区域经济政策研究[M].北京:中国计划出版社,1998
    [44]张可云.区域经济政策[M].北京:商务印书馆,2005:5
    [45]哈维阿姆斯特朗和吉姆泰勒.区域经济学与区域政策[M].上海:上海人民出版社,2007.
    [46]刘玉.中国区域政策[M].北京:经济口报出版社,2007
    [47]史同广,王慧.区域开发规划原理[M].山东:山东省地图出版社,1994].
    [48]任勇,冯东方,俞海等.中国生态补偿理论与政策框架设计[M].北京:中国环境科学出版社,2008.
    [49]李世繁.桂林地区森林保险事业有新的进展.广西林业,(4):35
    [50]孔繁文.我国森林保险发站的回顾及建议[J].中国林业,1996,(10):34
    [51]金正道.我国森林保险的现状和前景[J].国土绿化,2001,(5):13
    [52]陈玲芳.我国森林保险发展的现状、问题与对策研究[J].福建农林大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2005,8(4):38-41
    [53]陈学群,戴广翠.浙江省森林保险的构想与框架.林业经济,(4):41-43
    [54]黄伟纲.建立林业保险制度的思考.华东地区保险理论研讨会论文汇编,2004:82-84
    [55]http://sd.cnpension.net/syylbx/news/2011-06-04/1237656.html
    [56]http://yn.yunnan.cn/html/2011-11/08/content_1898592.htm
    [57]http://www.gxbx.com.cn/bencandy.php?fid-79-id-19358-page-1.htm
    [58]http://www.597mm.com/news/show.php?itemid=4194
    [59]http://www.circ.gov.cn/web/site0/tab3591/i103440.htm
    [60]http://www.forestry.gov.cn/portal/gzzz/s/913/content-483429.html
    [61]http://www.snsc.gov.cn:8080/
    [62]http://www.circ.gov.cn/web/site0/tab3132/i195899.htm
    [63]黄应来,高国辉.广东试点政策新森林保险,南方日报,2012,3:20
    [64]石焱,夏自谦,田芸.我国森林保险发展缓慢的深层次原因及对策分析[J],林业经济,2008,12
    [65]H.I. Baldwfn. Scandinavian forest fire insurance companies organize a union[J]. Journal of Forestry,1931,29 (1):134
    [66]http://www.forestry.gov.cn/portal/main/map/sjly/fenlan/finlandO 1.html
    [67]United States Bureau of Agricultural Economics. Crop and livestock insurance. A selected list of references to literature issued since 1898. U.S. Bureau Agricultural Economics Bibliog.1936,(67):264 pp
    [68]Ellis T. Williams. Forest insurance. Northestern Forest Experiment Station. Station Paper No.26,1949,6:1-88
    [69]王丹.我国森林保险理论及实证分析[D].沈阳农业大学,2005
    [70]李丹,曹玉昆.国外森林保险发展现状及启示.世界林业研究,2008,(02):6-10
    [71]张绍强,王丹,李峰.世界森林保险发展及其对我国的借鉴[J].经济师,2008(6):85-86
    [72]C.C. Averill, L. M. Frost. Some factors underlying forest fire insurance in Massachusetts. Harvard Forest Bulletin 17,1933:10.
    [73]F.E. Hook. A bill to further the conservation and proper use of publicly and privately owned forest lands, and for other purposes, H.R.6221,79th Cong.,2nd sess.1946
    [74]成晓星.美国农业政策和农业现代化探析[J].青海社会科学,2007.4:20-24
    [75]穆叶久.日本的森林保险[J].世界林业研究,2003,16(2):62—63.
    [76]王丹.我国森林保险理论及实证分析[D].沈阳农业大学,2005
    [77]http://www.daff.gov.au/forestry
    [78]http://www.forestry.gov.cn/portal/main/s/239/content-19301.html
    [79]http://www.smes-tp.com/Article_Show.asp?ArticleID=29945
    [82]白冬艳,翟印礼,张德成.俄罗斯森林保险发展政策分析与借鉴[J].林业经济,2012(1):91-96
    [87]Goodwin,B. K. Problems with Market Insurance in Agriculture [J]. American Journal of Agricultural Economics.2001 (03):643-649
    [88]Glauber, W.J, K.J.Collins. Crop Insurance. Disaster Assistance, and the Role of the Federal Government in Providing Catastrophic Risk Protection [J] Agricultural Finance Review,2002. Fall:82-103
    [89]Hoelcy. J.. B. Giertliova. An Integrated Forest Management Risk Insurance Model for Beech Stands Attacked by Selected Climate Extremes [J].2009
    [90]Kendra, M. S.. Natural Insurance, Forest Access, and Compounded Misfortune:Forest Resources in Smallholder Coping Strategies Before and After Hurricane Mitch, Northeastern Honduras [J]. World Development,2005 (09):1453-1471.
    [91]Bourgeon J, Chambers R G.Optirnal,Area-Yield Crop Insurance Reconsidered [J]. Amrican Journal of Agrieultural Economics.2003,85(3):590-604.
    [92]Cafiero C,Capitanio F,Cioffi A.Risk and Crisis Management in the Reformed EuroPean
    [93]Agricultural Policy [J].Canadian Journal of Agrieultural Eeonomies.2007,55(4):419-441.
    [94]Costanza R, Norton B.Toward an operational definition of health, Ecosystem Health-New Goals for Environmental Managements 992,Washington,DC:Island Press
    [95]Costanza R, Rapport D J.Ecological and economic system health and social decision making, Evaluating and Monitoring the Health of Large-scale Ecosydtem,1995,New York:Springer-Verlag
    [96]Dixon G C,Brown S.et al.Carbon pool and flux of global forest ecosystems, Science, 263:185
    [97]蒋有绪,中国森林生态系统结构与功能规律研究,1996,北京,中国林业出版社
    [98]陈仲新,张新时,中国生态系统效益的价值,科学通报,2000,,4(1):17-22
    [99]黄平,侯长谋,张弛等,广东省森林生态系统服务功能,生态科学,2002,21(2):160-163
    [100]李少宁,王兵等,森林生态系统服务功能研究进展—理论与方法,世界林业研究,2004,17(4):14-18
    [101]侯元兆,张佩昌等.中国森林资源核算研究,中国林业出版社,北京,1995
    [102]赵同谦,中国陆地生态系统服务功能及其价值评估研究,北京,中国科学院研究生博士论文,2004
    [103]鲁绍伟,中国森林生态系统服务功能的动态分析及仿真预测,北京,北京林业大学博士论文,2006
    [104]中国森林生态生态服务功能评估项目组,中国森林生态服务功能评估,北京,中国林业出版社,2010
    [105]逯红梅,关于农户森林保险需求影响因素的回归分析,2011,林业科学(9),22卷,49-50
    [106]李彧挥,李彩鸽,孔祥智,政策性森林保险支付意愿及影响因素分析—以湖南省安化县为例,2012(03),北京林业大学学报,2012(1期22卷)80-85
    [107]王林娟,我国集体林区政策性森林保险需求研究,北京林业大学硕士论文.2012
    [108]杨琳,浙江农户森林保险需求意愿分析,浙江农林大学硕士论文,2010
    [109]A.Veltman. R.Hassin.Equilibrium in queueing systems with complementary products. Queueing Systems.2005.50:325-342
    [110]S Takahashi.The number of pure Nash equilibria in a random game with nondecreasing best responses.Games and Economic Behavior,2008,63:328-340
    [111]R.Hassin, M..Haviv.Nash equilibrium and sub-game perfection in observable queues.Annals of Operations Research,2002,,113(1-4):15-26
    [112]韩伯棠,管理运筹学(第3版),高等教育出版社,2010,11.ISBN:9787040283877
    [113]M.Chaudhry, J.Templeton.A first course in bulk queues.John wiley&Sons,1983
    [114]保罗·萨谬尔森等著.微观经济学.北京,华夏出版社,1982
    [115]K.Goldberg,A.Golman,M.Newman.The Probability of an equilibrium point. J.Res. Nat.Bureau Standards-B.Math.Sci,1968,72B:93-101
    [116]Marco Arena, Does Insurance Market Activity prmote Economic Growth?Country Study for Industrial and DevelopingCountries, World Bank Policy Research Working PaPer No.4098.2006
    [117]游春,强制保险的未来发展趋势与启示[J]金融会计,2009(1)
    [118]谭湘渝,蒋毅 巨灾保险制度的经济学分析与模式选择[J]生产力研究,2009(4)
    [119]何小伟,代宝 强制保险制度的国际经验极其借鉴[J]金融与经济,2010(1)
    [120]雷冬嫦,李加明,周云.基于巨灾风险的可保性研究[J].经济问题探索,2010(7)
    [121]Sandholt I, Rasmussen K, Andersen J. A Simple Interpre-tation of the Surface Temperature/vegetation Index Space for Assessment of Surface Moisture Status (J) Remote Sensing of Environment.2002,79:213-224
    [122]http://datamirror.csdb.cn
    [123]宋小宁,赵英时.应用MODIS卫星数据提取植被-温度-水分综合指数的研究[J].地理与地理信息科学,2004,20(2):13-17
    [124]罗伯特·康斯坦扎等,世界生态体系服务的价值和自然资本,《自然》,1997,5.:253-259
    [125]Briefing Note for National Forestry Programmes Decentralized and participatory Planning.FAO,1995
    [126]侯元兆,王琦.中国森林资源核算研究,世界林业研究,1995(3)51-56
    [127]郎奎建等.林业生态工程10种森林生态效益计量理论和方法[J].东北林业大学学报.2000,1(28):(1-7)
    [128]万志芳,蒋敏元.林业生态工程生态效益计量的理论和方法演技,林业经济2001(11)24-27
    [129]黄强.平顶山矿区森林环境资源可持续发展及森林生态经济效益定量研究[D].2003
    [130]孙源和,俞国平,金佩英.浙江省森林资源经济评价方法探析[J],浙江林业科技.1992,5(12):(54-59
    [131]常人卫,罗静书.国家级生态示范区间中市森林生态效益评估[J],四川环境.2002,(21):(79-80)
    [132]康文星,田大伦.湖南省森林公益效能的经济评价一一森林的木材生产效益与水源涵养效益[J].中南林学院学报.2001,3(2):(13~17)
    [133]康文星,田大伦.湖南省森林公益效能的经济评价一森林的固土保肥、改良土壤和净化大气效益[J].中南林学院学报.2001,4(21):(1-4)
    [134]李顺龙,森林碳汇经济问题研究,东北林业大学,2005
    [135]Stephen.P.Robbins, MANAGEMENT (4Th,end) [M]北京,中国人民大学出版社,1996.4-5

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700