用户名: 密码: 验证码:
农村最低生活保障制度研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
农村的稳定和可持续发展关系到和谐社会的建设,也关系到全面建设小康社会目标的实现。新中国成立以来,尤其是改革开放30年来,我国农村发生了显著的变化,农民的生存状况和生活质量有了很大提高,但是农村的贫困问题却一直存在。为了解决农村的贫困问题,我国政府投入了大量的人力物力,开展了多种形式的扶贫工作,但是近年来的扶贫效果却越来越差,这是因为目前引起贫困的主要原因有一部分是难以得到根本解决的,例如因为残疾或重病造成的低工作能力,或者是因为家庭劳动力减少而造成的高抚养率的问题等。这说明我国传统的开发式扶贫政策对于解决我国农村的绝对贫困问题已经是事倍功半,需要一种新的制度安排来解决我国农村剩余贫困问题。
     社会保障制度是经济社会发展的稳定器,作为社会保障制度的一个重要组成部分,农村居民最低生活保障制度是解决我国农村剩余贫困问题的现实选择,这是因为农村最低生活保障制度更具有制度上的规范性以及精确性,可以形成解决困难群众生活问题的长效机制,而且我国当前也已经具备了在全国范围内建立农村最低生活保障制度,全面解决农村温饱问题的财力和能力。
     我国农村最低生活保障制度的探索始于1992年山西省左云县的试点,由于受到传统农村集体福利思维定式的影响,缺少中央和地方财政的投入,农村最低生活保障制度的建设一度出现停滞和倒退。从2007年起,我国开始在全国范围内建立农村最低生活保障制度,到目前为止,农村居民最低生活保障制度仍然在不断地改进和完善,并且也起到了保障和维护农民的利益,缓和社会矛盾,维护社会稳定的作用,但同时制度本身也存在一定的问题。正是在此背景下,本研究围绕农村最低生活保障制度运行的评价与改进展开。
     本研究的目的在于评价江苏省农村最低生活保障制度的运行效果,发现农村最低生活保障制度运行中存在的问题,寻找制度中有待于进一步改进和完善之处,进而提出制度改进的措施与建议。本研究的理论意义在于对我国农村最低生活保障制度运行的管理体制、运行机制等方面进行研究,尤其是对在我国现阶段国情的约束下,农村最低生活保障制度的定位以及应该如何建设和发展进行了探讨,可以丰富我国的社会保障理论和农村发展理论。同时通过以江苏省为例,进行农村最低生活保障制度的分析研究,发现问题,提出相应的建议,为江苏省农村最低生活保障制度的发展与完善提供政策参考。
     本论文的主要创新点在于以扩展线性支出模型为基础,提出具有可操作性的农村最低生活保障标准的制定依据和方法;以低保资金需求系统模型为基础,结合用扩展线性支出模型计算出的农村最低生活保障线,制定出科学的人均补差的计算方法。同时,本论文也对江苏省农村最低生活保障制度的地区、城乡差别的合理性在理论上进行了探讨,并得出初步的结论。
     本文在已有研究的基础上,逐步展开论述,首先分析了我国农村最低生活保障制度的发展历程、现状及问题。指出由于农村居民收入界定困难以及地方财力的不足,农村最低生活保障制度未能实现应保尽保;在农村最低生活保障制度的资金筹集方面,我国农村最低生活保障的筹资渠道比较单一,主要依靠政府财政的投入,这导致在一些经济欠发达的地区单靠地方财政难以保证低保资金的充分供应,在一定程度上影响了农村最低生活保障制度的保障效果;在保障标准方面,我国农村最低生活保障待遇标准过低,保障线的制定存在一定的随意性,保障标准的地域差异也比较大;在管理体制方面,存在农村最低生活保障制度缺乏法律保障,基层工作人员数量不足,管理信息化程度低等问题,降低了农村最低生活保障制度的管理效率。
     本文对江苏省农村最低生活保障制度运行与保障水平进行了分析,因为政府资源投入的意愿和力度是影响制度建设的重要因素,而政府出台的政策能够反映政府资源投入的倾向,因此,在该部分的分析中,首先基于城乡对比的视角分析了江苏省最低生活保障相关政策,发现江苏省农村最低生活保障制度的建设落后于城市;然后介绍了江苏省农村最低生活保障制度的运行机制,分析了江苏省农村最低生活保障水平的年度、城乡、地区差异,指出农村最低生活保障标准和人均补差逐年提高,并且在2007年由于保障标准自然增长机制的建立使得保障标准的增长呈现拐点。在地区差异方面,保障标准的地区差异与传统上的江苏省经济发展苏南、苏中、苏北三个层次相吻合,而苏中和苏北的人均补差水平则差异不大。在城乡差别方面,城市最低生活保障标准和人均补差均高于农村,各地城市之间最低生活保障制度的补差水平逐渐接近,而农村最低生活保障制度补差水平的差距在逐渐扩大。本部分的最后以江苏省丹阳市作为案例分析了农村最低生活保障制度的运行情况以及存在的问题。
     本文还对对江苏省农村最低生活保障政策的实施效果进行了评价,在对农村最低生活保障标准与人均收入相关联的政策进行评价时,根据回归分析的结果,得出目前江苏省已经建立起农村最低生活保障标准与农村人均纯收入的关联关系的结论;通过剔除省补资金后对江苏省人均补差地区差异的分析,得出省补资金在弥合地区差异方面确实发挥了作用的结论。本部分用扩展线性支出模型计算出农村居民的基本消费需求,与实际的最低生活保障线进行对比,得出目前江苏省农村最低生活保障标准偏低、计算方法不科学的结论。通过构建低保资金需求模型,计算低保户的补助资金需求,并与实际的补差数额比较,得出目前补差水平偏低的结论。本部分的最后融合扩展线性支出模型和低保资金需求模型,提出了修改后的农村最低生活保障补差模型。
     在提出政策建议之前,本文对国外社会救助制度的经验进行了借鉴。在全文的最后提出文章的结论,指出农村最低生活保障制度存在应保未保、筹资方式单一、保障标准不合理、农村最低生活保障制度的建设滞后于城市等问题、提出了建立切实可行的农村最低生活保障标准和补差的测算方法,加大国家投入力度,建立混合筹资机制,提高最低生活保障工作人员素质,加强最低生活保障监督管理等政策建议,并且对城乡最低生活保障制度一体化的前景进行了展望,提出通过“统一筹划,制度有别”,“制度统一,标准有别”两个阶段最终建立城乡统一的最低生活保障制度。
The stable and sustainable development in rural areas is related to the construction of harmonious society and the goals of building a moderately prosperous society in an all-round. Since the establishment of P. R. China, especially the thirty years after the reforms and opening-up, significant changes have occurred in the rural area, but at the same time the poverty of rural areas has been a problem for a long time. In order to solve the problem of rural poverty, our government inputs a lot of human and material resources and carries out various forms of poverty alleviation, but in recent years the effect of poverty reduction is getting worse and worse. The reason is that now the part of the main causes of poverty is difficult to be solved totally, such as low working ability caused by disability or serious illness, the high dependency ratio caused by the reduction family labor and so on. This shows that the traditional developmental rural poverty reduction policies which solve the problem of absolute poverty in rural areas are already a duplication of efforts, and we need a new institutional arrangement to solve the problem of poverty in rural remainder.
     Social security system is the stabilizer of economic and social development. As an important part of the social security system, the rural minimum living security system is the realistic choice of solving the problem of the rural remaining poverty, which is because the rural minimum living security system is institutionally normative and accuracy and can form the long-term mechanism to solve people's living problem. At the same time, our country has already had the financial resources and capacity to set up a national rural minimum living security system to solve the shortage of food and clothing in rural areas totally.
     The exploration of building rural minimum living security system began in Zuoyun Town in Shanxi Province,1992. Due to the affection of the traditional rural welfare thought style and lack of financial investment from the central and local governments, the construction of rural minimum living security system met some stagnation and retrogression in certain period. Since 2007, China began to establish a nationwide minimum living security system in rural areas and the project has been improved and perfected continually so far and it has played an important role in protecting farmers'interest and easing social conflicts and maintaining the social stability. At the same time, there are also some shortcomings and problems, so the study tries to focus on the evaluation and improvement of the rural minimum living standard security system and to develop a deeper exploration under such complex background.
     The purpose of this study is to evaluate the effectiveness of the rural minimum living security system in Jiangsu Province, find out the problems of the system and propose the suggestions and countermeasures for further improvement. The theoretical significance of this study is to discuss the management and operation methods on the rural minimum livelihood security system, especially the position and development of the rural minimum living standard security system in regarding of the constraints of our present situations, as well as to enrich the theory of China's social security and development in countryside. Meanwhile, the study takes Jiangsu Province as a sample to analyze the rural minimum living security system, identify problems and make recommendations accordingly for the rural minimum living security system of Jiangsu Province.
     The main innovation of the thesis is to develop the foundation and methods of a workable rural minimum living security line on the basis of the expanding linear expenditure model, to make the scientific methods of calculating per capita subsidy on the basis of minimal needs-based funding requirements model, combining with the rural minimum living security line which is worked out to help expanding linear expenditure model. Meanwhile, the study also discusses the rationality of the urban-rural differences in the places where carries out the system in Jiangsu Province and then puts forward preliminary conclusions.
     Based on existing research, the article expands the statement gradually. First, the article analyzes the development process, current situation and problems of the rural minimum living security system, which points out that due to the difficulties in defining the income of rural residents and the lack of local financial resources, the rural minimum living security system did not cover all the people who should be in. In the rural minimum living security system funding side, the ways of funding are relatively simple and mainly rely on governmental financial input which resulted in a number of underdeveloped areas having difficulties in ensuring adequate supply of subsistence allowances only relying on the local governmental financial resources. To some extent, this reduces the effects of rural minimum living security system. In the security standards side, the standards of treatment of the rural minimum living security system are so low, the formulation of the security lines is certainly arbitrariness, and the differences in security standards of different regions are that great. In the administration system side, there is a lack of legal protection for the rural minimum living security system, grass-roots staff and management information, and all these problems reduce management efficiency of the rural minimum living security system.
     The article analyzes the operational and security level of the rural minimum living security system in Jiangsu Province. It is because that willingness and strength of the government resources put into is an important factor and the policies made by the government can reflect the tendency of government resources put in. So, in this part, the article first analyzes the related policies about Jiangsu Province subsistence policies based on the perspective of the comparison of urban and rural areas, and finds that the construction of the rural minimum living security system goes far more behind urban areas. Next, the article introduces the operation mechanism of the rural minimum living security system in Jiangsu Province and analyses the differences of annual minimum living standard in urban and rural areas and in different regions of the Jiangsu Province which points out that the rural minimum living standards and per making up increase year by year, and security standards in 2007 the security standard makes up the turning point because of natural growth in the establishment of mechanism. In the regional differences aspect, the differences in security standards of different regions match traditional three levels'economic development of Jiangsu Province, Southern, Middle and Northern, whereas differences in the per making up between middle and northern Jiangsu are not significant. In the urban-rural differences aspect, the security standards and per making up in urban minimum living are higher than that of the rural areas. Besides, the difference in per making up of the minimum living system between cities approaches gradually, while the difference in per making up of the minimum living system between villages expands larger and larger gradually. Finally, at the end of this part, taking Danyang City of Jiangsu Province as an example, the article studies the operation and problems of rural minimum living security system.
     This article also evaluates the results of Jiangsu rural minimum living policy. When evaluating the rural minimum living standard and per capita income related policies, according to the results of the regression analysis, the article obtains that at present Jiangsu Province has established the relationship between rural minimum living standard and per capita net income in rural areas. By the analysis of the difference in various areas where per making up is carried out and the eliminating Jiangsu's own allowance, the paper draws up that the provincial funds indeed plays a role to bridge the regional differences. In this part, we make use of the extended linear expenditure model to calculate the basic consumption needs of rural residents to compare with the actual minimum living security line, and make the conclusions that the rural minimum living standard of Jiangsu Province is low and unscientific. By building minimum living security fund demand model, to calculate the demand for subsidies for household subsistence allowances, and to compare with the actual amount of makeup, we come to the conclusion of the current low level of the makeup. Finally, we revised the model of the rural minimum living making up though the integration of the extended linear expenditure model and the minimal needs funding requirements model.
     Before making policy recommendations, this paper references the experience of foreign social assistance system. At the end of the paper, the conclusion is indicated which points out that the rural minimum living security system exits some problems, like limited coverage, simplex fund collection, illogical security standard, the construction of the rural minimum living security system far behind the urban areas, etc. Besides, the article also puts forward some countermeasures and suggestions:establishment the realistic calculation method for security standard and subsidy, increasing national investment and mixed financial mechanisms, improving the staff's professional knowledge, strengthening the supervision and management of the system etc. In addition, a brighter future of the integration of the minimum living security system for urban and rural is prospected. After the two stages that "Unified Design, Different System" and "Unified System, Different Standard", here will establish the urban-rural integration minimum living standard system.
引文
3详见郝自充.城镇贫困的成因和贫困救助政策的效果.吉林大学硕士学位论文.2007
    4详见杨宜勇,张英,顾严.构建城乡统筹的最低生活保障体系[J].中国人口科学.2006,(6).
    1. Aaron H. J, The Docial. Insurance Paradox., Canadian Journal of Economics and 2. Political Science,1996.
    3. Albert PARK, Sangui WANC. China's poverty statistics, China Economic Review,12(2001).
    4. Alecander Berk Agriculture Issues and Policies. Nova Science Publishers, Inc,2002
    5. Amartya · Sen. Choice Welfare and Measurement. Harvard University Press:New edition, September 15,1997.
    6. Averting the old Age Crisis, A World Bank Policy Research Report, Oxford University Press,1994.
    7. Bill Jordan.A Theory of Poverty and Social Exclusion.Cambridg:Polity Press,1996.
    8. Board of Govermors of Federal Reserve System, "Report to the Congress on the Avaiability of Credit to Small Business".2000.
    9. Buchannan, J. M:"An Economic Theory of Clubs", Economics,1965.12.
    10. Budior Social Risk Management. A new conception framework for social protection and beyond.2000.
    11. Burrows, B. A Mayne P. Newbury, Into the 21st Century:A Handbook for a Sustainable Future, Tiwickenham, UK:Adamantine Press,1991.
    12. Dana L. Hoag, Agricultural Crisis in America, Santa Barara, California,2000.
    13. David H. Rosenbloom/Robert S. Kravchuk, Public Administration:Understanding Management, Politics, and Law in the Public Sector,2002.
    14. Eardley,T., Bradshaw, J., Ditch, J. Gough, I., &Whiteford,P. Social Assistance in OECD Countries (Volume Ⅰ):Synthesis Report. London:HMSO,1996.
    15. Eardley, tletall,1996, social assistance in OECD countries (volumel):synthesis report,london:hmso.
    16. Harvard. American Agriculture in the Twentieth Century, Harvard University Press,2002.
    17.Hussain, Arthur, Peter Lanjouw, and Nicholas Stern, Income Inequalities in China:Evidence from Household Survey Data, World Development,1994.8.
    18. Kanbur, Ravi and Xiaobo Zhang, Which Regional Inequality? The Evolution of Rural-Urban and Inland-Coastal Inequality in China from 1983 to 1995, Comparative Economics,1999.10.
    19. Khan, Griffin and Riskin, Period of Economic Reform "Income Distribution in Urban China during the and Globalisation".2001.
    20. Nicholas Barr, The Economics of the Welfare State,3rd edition. Stanford:Stanford University Press,1998.
    21. OECD,1998, the battle against exclusion, paris:organization for economic co 2 operation and developmentl.
    22. Robert W.Wassmer. Readings in urban economics:issues and public policy, Blackwell publishers Inc, Blackwell publishers Ltd,2000.
    23. Saraceno, C. Social Assistance Dynamics in Europe:National and Local Poverty Regimes.Bristol,UK:Policy press.2002.
    24. Shujie YAO, Zongyi ZHANG and Lucia HANMER. Growing inequality and poverty in China, China Economic Review,15(2004).
    25. Stephen. P.Robbins. Organizational Bahavior-Controversies, and Applications.NJ: Prentice Hall Inc.2001.
    26. Subbarao, K., Bonnerjee, A., Jeanine, B., Carvalho, S., Ezemenari, K., Graham, C. &Thompson, A., Safety Net Programs and Poverty Reduction:Lessons from Cross-Country Experience. Washington, D.C.:World Bank,1997.
    27. Tang, W. S. and Jenkins, Urbanization Processes, Policies and Patterns, Routledge,1990.
    28. Tim Allen and Alan Thomas, Poverty and development into 21st century, Oxford:Open University in association with Oxford University Press,2000.
    29.Tsui, KaiYuen, China's Regional Inequality:1952-1985, Comparative Economics,1991.
    30. Vermon Bogdanor, The Blackwell Encyclopaedia of Political Institutions, Basil Blackwell Ltd,1987.
    31.A.C.庇古著.何玉长,丁晓钦译.福利经济学[M].上海:海财经大学出版社,2009.
    32.(美)萨缪尔森.《经济学》上册[M].北京:北京经济学院出版社,1995.
    33.《2000/2001年世界发展报告》编写组.2000/2001年世界发展报告[R].北京:中国财政经济出版社,2001.
    34.柏龙彪.农村居民最低生活保障制度探析——基于一个实证分析[J].西南民族大学学报(人文社科版),2006,(10).
    35.毕天云.建立农村居民最低生活保障制度的重要性[J].云南师范大学学报,2003,35(2).
    36.毕天云.社会福利的场域习惯[M].北京:中国社会科学出版社,2004.
    37.财政部财政科学研究所“农村低保制度研究”课题组.农村低保制度研究[J].经济研究参考.2007,(15).
    38.蔡昉,都阳.建立农村“低保”制度的条件已成熟[J].中国党政干部论坛,2004,(9).
    39.曹阳,陈玉能.农村最低生活保障标准的资金需求模型建立[J].北方经济,2008,(6).
    40.陈立中.中国转型时期城镇贫困测度研究[D].湖北:华中科技大学博士学位论文,2007.
    41.陈良谨.中国社会工作百科全书[M].北京:中国社会出版社,1999.
    42.陈少晖.农村社会保障制度缺陷与政府责任[J].福建师范大学学报,2004,(4).
    43.谌立平.构建城乡一体居民低保制度的探讨[J].东岳论丛,2006,27,(6).
    44.崔芸芸,郭连太.我国农村居民最低生活保障制度的保障对象的法律思考[J].2006,(12)
    45.戴卫东.构建农村最低生活保障制度责任的思考[J].安徽师范大学学报(人文社会科学版),2006,34(6).
    46.丁萌萌,卓玛措.贫困线与我国农村贫困[J].重庆交通学院学报(社会科学版),2006.(1)
    47.都阳,蔡昉.中国农村贫困性质的变化与扶贫战略调整[J].中国农村观察,2005(5).
    48.多吉才让.中国最低生活保障制度研究与实践[M]北京:人民出版社,2001.
    49.范利祥.让“低保”农民有尊严地活着[J].中国改革,2004,(11).
    50.范酉庆,顾听,高梦滔.中国城乡社会救助项目绩效评价研究——基于筹资水平的横向公平性分析[J].财经研究,2007,33(10).
    51.方卫东,糜仲春,程永宏.社会保障制度中贫困线和贫困率的测算[J].上海经济研究.2001,(2).
    52.封铁英,贾继开.农村最低生活保障线测定的模型构建及应用[J].西安交通大学学报(社会科学版),2008,28,(2).
    53.高伟娜.中国农村最低生活保障标准研究[J].西北人口,2005(1).
    54.顾昕,范酉庆,高梦滔.中国城乡社会救助的横向公平性[J].东岳论丛,2007,(1).
    55.关信平.论建立农村居民最低生活保障制度的条件、原则及运行机制[J].文史哲,2007,(1).
    56.官翃.农村最低生活保障制度悖论分析[J].求索,2006,(7).
    57.郭海清.建立农村居民最低生活保障制度的最大难点与解决办法[J].经济师,2004,(1).
    58.国务院.城市居民最低生活保障条例[Z],1999.
    59.国务院.关于在全国建立农村最低生活保障制度的通知[Z].新华社,2007.
    60.郝悦,吕学静.探析最低生活保障制度的城乡差异[J].人口与经济,2009,(4).
    61.何菊芳.构建农村最低生活保障制度的设想[J].当代经济研究.2005,(9).
    62.黄君洁.社会保障筹资方式的国际比较与借鉴[J].经济纵横,2006,10
    63.江亮演.社会救助的理论和实践[M].台湾:台北桂冠图书公司,1990.
    64.凯恩斯著.高鸿业译.就业、利息和货币通论[M].北京:商务印书馆,1999.
    65.劳埃德·雷诺兹,微观经济学:分析和政策[M],北京:商务印书馆,1982.
    66.李明,李律成.浅析中国特色的农村最低生活保障新模式[J].农业经济,2007,(12).
    67.李小云,董强,刘启明等.农村最低生活保障政策实施过程及瞄准分析[J].农业经济问题,2006,(11).
    68.李迎生.计划经济时期的农村社会保障建设评析[J],河南社会科学,2005,13(4).
    69.李永军,王欢.论农村最低生活保障制度的完善[J].职业圈,2007,(15).
    70.林莉红,孔繁华.从宪定权利到法定权利——我国农村居民最低生活保障制度建立情况调查[J].河南省政法管理干部学院学报,2007,(4)
    71.林梅.城乡统筹发展与农村社会保障制度建设[J].科学社会主义,2007(2).
    72.林闽钢.福利多元主义的兴起及其政策实践[J].社会,2002,(7).
    73.刘博雅.基于扩展线性支出系统模型的中国农村居民消费结构分析[J].经济前沿,2009,(5).
    74.刘健平.贫困线测定方法研究[J].山西财经大学学报.2003,(4).
    75.刘明慧.统筹城乡社会救助的财政政策[J].大连海事大学学报(社会科学版),2008,(4)
    76.鲁开垠.建立中国农村最低生活保障制度的政策建议[J].南方论刊,2005,(6).
    77.陆娟,解佳涛.小城镇面向弱势群体社会救助标准的确定研究[J].财经问题研究,2004,(11).
    78.罗伯特·萨格登.著方饮译.权利、合作与福利的经济学[M].上海:上海财经大学出版社,2008.
    79.马斌,蔡鹭.建立农村最低生活保障制度的路径选择——以广东省为例[J].华南师范大学学报(社会科学版).2006,(3).
    80.马俊贤.农村贫困线的划分及扶贫对策研究[J].统计研究.2001,(6).
    81.马强,我国推行农村低保制度的障碍与对策[J].农村经济与科技,2005,(11).
    82.马斯洛著,许金声等译动机与人格(第三版)[M].北京:中国人民大学出版社,2007.
    83.孟昭元.农村最低生活保障线的建立与实施[J].桂海论丛,2005,(3).
    84.莫泰基.香港减贫政策探索:社会发展的构思[M].北京:三联书店,1999.
    85.曲大维.城市贫困救助的福利政策研究[D].上海:复旦大学博士学位论文,2008.
    86.任才方,陈晓杰.城镇贫困线与建立贫困监测系统[J].统计与决策,1995,(1).
    87.申学锋.国外农村低保制度经验借鉴与启示[J].地方财政研究,2009.5(5).
    88.盛朗.中国城市贫困人口数量分析[J].人口研究,1999,(11).
    89.世界银行.1990年世界发展报告[M].北京:中国财政经济出版社,1999.
    90.世界银行.从贫困地区到贫困人群:中国扶贫议程的演进[R].2009.
    91.唐均.中国城市居民贫困线研究[M].上海:上海社会科学院出版社,1998.
    92.唐钧.确定中国城镇贫困线方法的探讨[D].社会学研究,1997,(2).
    93.唐钧.完善社会救助制度的思路与对策[J].社会工作,2004,(9).
    94.童万亨.福建省全面实施农村居民最低生活保障制度的调查与思考[J].农业经济问题,2005,(1).
    95.童星,刘松涛.城市居民最低生活保障线的测定[J].社会学研究,2000,(4).
    96.王翠琴,薛惠元.我国农村低保的公共经济学分析[J].农村经济与科技,2005,(12).
    97.王登成,王玲.对市场经济条件下扶贫救困问题的思考[J].阴山学刊,1999,(1).
    98.王桂胜.福利经济学[M].北京:中国劳动社会保障出版社,2007.
    99.王谦.城乡公共服务均等化问题研究[D].山东:山东大学博士学位论文,2008.
    100.王荣党.农村贫困线的测度与优化[J].华东经济管理.2006,(3).
    101.王淑娟,王磊.社会转型期构建全民低保的障碍因素分析[J].理论与改革,2009,(3)
    102.王有捐.对城市居民最低生活保障政策执行情况的评价[J].统计研究,2006,(10)
    103.王有捐.中国城市贫困状况测量[M].北京:社会科学文献出版社,2003.
    104.吴玲,施国庆.我国最低生活保障制度的伦理缺陷[J].南京师大学报(社会科学版),2005,(2).
    105.肖云,杜毅.农村最低生活保障制度研究综述[J].生产力研究,2009,(13).
    106.肖云,刘慧.农村最低生活保障制度实施中的问题与对策[J].农村经济与科技,2007,(10).
    107.徐清照.山东农村居民最低生活保障制度发展现状与发展趋势研究[J].聊城大学学报(社会科学版),2009,(1).
    108.徐清照.我国农村居民最低生活保障制度发展趋势研究[J].理论学刊,2009,(1).
    109.许立群.建立农村居民最低生活保障制度及其政策选择[J].北京行政学院学报,2002,(6).
    110.薛惠元,王翠琴.建立农村最低生活保障制度的若干思考[J].农业经济,2006,(3).
    111.闫锡杰,冯兴华,卢丙文.实施农村最低生活保障制度的实践与思考[J].农村财政与财务,2006,(11).
    112.阎红梅.我国农村最低生活保障线测定方法研究[D].南京农业大学硕士学位论文,2007.
    113.杨国涛.贫困线理论及其在中国农村的实践[J].农村展望.2005,(9).
    114.杨茗茗.完善贵州省农村居民最低生活保障制度研究[D].贵州大学,2008.
    115.杨宜勇,张英,顾严.构建城乡统筹的最低生活保障体系[J].中国人口科学.2006,(6).
    116.杨紫煊.经济法[M].北京:北京大学出版社,高等教育出版社,1999.
    117.易根花,吴国权.建立农村居民最低生活保障制度的经济学分析[J].经济与管理.2007,21(9).
    118.张宝田.中国较发达地区城乡统筹协调发展道路的新探索[J].社会科学战线,2009,(2).
    119.张秉铎、唐钧.城市居民最低生活保障制度研究[M].江苏:江苏人民出版社,1997.
    120.张海鹰.社会保障词典[M].经济管理出版社,2000.
    121.张洁云,娄之歆.我国农村低保对象的科学界定[J].农村经济,2006,(1).
    122.张时飞,唐钧.”全民低保”进入攻坚阶段[J].中国社会保障,2007,(1).
    123.张时飞,唐钧.辽宁、河北两省农村低保制度研究报告[J].东岳论丛,2007,28(1).
    124.张时飞.正确认识“农村绝对贫困人口”与“农村低保对象”[J].工作研究与建设,2007,(5).
    125.张左己.加快完善有中国特色的社会保障体系[J].求是,2001,(2).
    126.赵福昌.财政部财政科学研究所“农村低保制度研究”课题组.农村低保制度研究[J].经济研究参考,2007,(15).
    127.郑功成.社会保障法学[M].北京:中国人民大学出版社,2002.
    128.郑功成,中国社会保障改革与制度建设[J].中国人民大学学报,2003,(1).
    129.郑功成.中国社会保障制度变迁与评估[M].北京:中国人民大学出版社,2002.
    130.朱丽芳.国外农村最低生活保障制度[J].农村工作通讯,2008,(19).
    131.祝梅娟.贫困线测算方法的最优选择[J].经济问题探索.2003,(6).
    132.邹文开.全面推行农村低保制度的障碍分析[J].怀化学院学报,2004,(3)
    133.左菁.中国“反贫困”社会救助法律制度——农村最低生活保障制度实施的制度障碍分析[J].河北法学,2007.25(7)

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700