用户名: 密码: 验证码:
基于指数积公式的串联机构运动学标定方法研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
在不过分增加制造成本的前提下提高数字化脑立体定向仪的定位精度,研究了串联机构运动学标定方法。其中,串联机构运动学参数辨识是串联机构运动学标定的核心步骤也是本文的主要研究内容。指数积公式在串联机构运动学建模方面有许多优点,但对其在运动学参数辨识方面的研究不多,主要表现为:1)基于指数积公式的误差模型中是否存在冗余参数尚未研究。2)尚未见将指数积公式引入基于运动轨迹的运动学参数辨识的研究。本文研究了指数积公式在串联机构运动学参数辨识中的实现方法和过程,进行了一系列仿真和实验。
     为了明确基于指数积公式的误差模型的参数冗余性,在分析了现有指数映射关于旋量的微分求解方法之后,对一般串联机构建立了显式的误差模型。按辨识矩阵中向量之间的线性相关性,分析了误差模型中的运动学参数可辨识性,得到了3个实用的误差模型。分析结果表明,所有关节旋量坐标均可辨识;若误差模型中包含关节变量,则当所有关节旋量坐标组成的矩阵为列满秩时,关节变量可辨识。
     根据指数映射和对数映射的特性,证明了在基于指数积公式的误差建模法的参数辨识算法中所采用的迭代最小二乘法收敛。
     将指数积建模方法引入基于运动轨迹的运动学参数辨识,给出了实现方法,并通过实验验证了该方法的可行性和有效性。在实验中体现出优于现有同类方法,表现为可以直接从各关节运动轨迹得到运动学建模所需参数一关节旋量坐标和关节变量当量系数,而无繁琐的连杆间坐标系还原过程。
     通过常见工业机器人和三坐标测量机的运动学参数辨识仿真实验,验证了3个误差模型的有效性。仿真结果表明,在理想实验条件下,它们的运动学参数均可辨识,且本文方法得到的辨识结果比其他相关方法更接近于预设真值。此外,通过仿真实验分析了测量位姿组数,测量噪声和迭代计算初值对辨识结果的影响。仿真结果表明,在测量位姿组数较少或加入测量噪声或计算初值偏离预设真值较大等不利情况下,辨识算法仍表现出良好的鲁棒性。
     通过数字化脑立体定向仪标定实验,验证了基于误差建模和基于运动轨迹的串联机构运动学参数辨识方法的有效性和可操作性,给出了该方法的实现过程。经参数辨识后,数字化脑立体定向仪的绝对定位误差由1.87 mm降低到1.04 mm且距离测量误差由1.02 mm降低到0.46 mm,达到设计要求。
     通过本文研究,建立了具有显式表达的指数积公式的串联机构运动学误差模型,提出了三个实用误差模型。将指数积公式建模方法引入关节运动轨迹法运动学参数辨识。阐明了关节变量零位偏差的可辨识条件。证明了基于指数积公式误差模型中最小二乘迭代算法的收敛性。仿真与实验表明,此两种串联机构运动学参数辨识方法具有通用性和实用性。
In order to improve absolute accuracy of the digitalized stereotactic apparatus without increasing manufacturing costs excessively, kinematic calibration for serial mechanisms has been investigated. As a key procedure of kinematic calibration, the kinematic parameter identification of serial mechanisms is focused on in this dissertation. Although product-of-exponential formula (POE formula) has many advantages over the other kinematic modeling methods, such few researches have given close attention to the kinematic parameter identification based on POE formula that:1) It is still not clear that whether the error model based on POE formula is involved in any redundant parameters or not.2) The POE formula has not been introduced into kinematic identification based on each joint trajectory. Not only implementation and procefure of the kinematic parameter identifcation based on POE formula was presented, but also some simulations and experiments have been conducted in this dissertation. The main contributions of this dissertation are as follows:
     To clearify the identifiability of parameters in error model based on POE formula, the explicit-form error model was built for serial mechanisms after some existing approaches to solving the differential of the exponential map at twist have been analyzed. Then, the identifiability of parameters in this error model was analyzed by the linear dependence of vectors in the identification Jacobian matrix, and three practicable error models were obtained. The analysis shows that:(1) Errors in all joint twists are identifiable. (2) If the matrix formed by all joint twists is full column rank, the joint zero-position errors can be identified.
     The iterative least-squares algorithm was proved to be convergent by using the characteristic of exponential map and logarithm map, which is the important part of identification algorithm based on error modeling method.
     The POE formula was introduced into kinematic identification based on each joint trajectory. The procedure of kinematic identification was presented. The experiment has been conducted to demonstrate the feasibility and effectiveness of this method. This method has an advantage over the other this type of kinematic identification:joint twists and joint motion resolutions can be directly obtained from joint trajectories without the complicated procedures of the link coordinate frames'reconstruction.
     Simulation results show that all kinematic parameters of common industrial robots and CMM are identifiable under the ideal experimental condition. In comparison to the simulation results in references, the identified results are closer to the true values with the suggested method. The number of measurement configurations, measurement noise and the initial values of iterative calculation, which are the influence factors on kinematic identification, are also analyzed. Although the identification algorithm was in some bad situations, such as few measurement configurations, injected measurement noise or big deviations between the computational initial values and the presetted true values, the algorithm is robust.
     The experimental results of calibrating the digitalized stereotactic apparatus show that the kinematic parameter identification based on either error modeling or joint trajectory is effective and practicable. After the kinematic parameter identification, the position error and the mesuring distance error of digitalized stereotactic apparatus is reduced from 1.87 mm to 1.04 mm and from 1.02 mm to 0.46 mm respectively, which meets the requirement of design.
     According to the study, three practical error models based on the exponential product formula were established, which are in explicit expressions. The exponential product formula was introduced into the kinematic parameter identification based on joint trajectories. The condition of identifying the joint zero-position errors was illustrated. The least-squares iterative algorithm using the exponential product formula based error model was proved to be convergent. Simulation and experiment results show that the two kinematic parameter identification methods are versatile and practical.
引文
[1]佟德华.人脑出血颅骨模型的制作、虚拟重建及其在数字化脑立体定向手术系统中的应用[D].武汉:华中科技大学,2007.
    [2]王俊杰.五自由度脑微创手术框架精度的研究[D].武汉:华中科技大学,2007.
    [3]石元洪.机器人辅助立体定向脑出血硬通道血肿穿刺术的实验研究[D].武汉:华中科技大学,2010.
    [4]Junchuan L., Yuru Z., Zhen L. Improving the Positioning Accuracy of a Neurosurgical Robot Systems[J]. IEEE/ASME Transactions on Mechatronics.2007, 12(5):527-533.
    [5]许理.脑立体定向手术系统的位姿测量与误差分析[D].武汉:华中科技大学,2007.
    [6]Meggiolaro M. A., Dubowsky S. An Analytical Method to Eliminate the Redundant Parameters in Robot Calibration[C].in:Proceedings of the IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation. San Francisco, CA:IEEE,2000. 3609-3615.
    [7]Schroer K., Albright S. L., Grethlein M. Complete, Minimal and Model-Continuous Kinematic Models for Robot Calibration[J]. Robot. Comput.-Integr. Manuf.1997, 13(1):73-85.
    [8]Veitschegger W., Wu C. H. Robot Accuracy Analysis Based On Kinematics[J]. IEEE Trans. Robot. Autom.1986, RA-2(3):171-179.
    [9]Hayati S., Mirmirani M. Improving the Absolute Positioning Accuracy of Robot Manipulators[J]. J. Robot. Syst.1985,2(4):397-413.
    [10]Hayati S., Tso K., Roston G. Robot Geometry Calibration[C].in:Proceedings of the IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation. Philadelphia, PA: IEEE,1988.947-951.
    [11]Hayati S. A. Robot Arm Geometric Link Parameter Estimation[C].in:Proc.22nd IEEE Conference on Decision and Control. San Antonio, TX:IEEE,1983. 1477-1483.
    [12]Zhuang H., Roth Z. S., Hamano F. A Complete and Parametrically Continuous Kinematic Model for Robot Manipulators[J]. IEEE Trans. Robot. Autom.1992,8(4): 451-463.
    [13]Park F. C., Okamura K. Kinematic Calibration and the Product of Exponential Formula[M].In:Advances in Robot Kinematics and Computational Geometry, Lenarcic J., Ravani B., Cambridge:MIT Press,1994,119-128.
    [14]Okamura K., Park F. C. Kinematic Calibration Using the Product of Exponentials Formula[J]. Robotica.1996,14:415-421.
    [15]Chen I. M., Yang G. Kinematic Calibration of Modular Reconfigurable Robots Using Product-of-Exponentials Formula[J]. J. Robot. Syst.1997,14(11):807-821.
    [16]Chen I. M., Yang G., Tan C. T., et al. Local Poe Model for Robot Kinematic Calibration[J]. Mech. and Mach. Theory.2001,36(11/12):1215-1239.
    [17]Mustafa S. K., Yang G., Yeo S. H., et al. Kinematic Calibration of a 7-Dof Self-Calibrated Modular Cable-Driven Robotic Arm[C].in:Proceedings of the IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation. Pasadena, CA:IEEE,2008. 1288-1293.
    [18]Seong-Ho K., Pryor M. W., Tesar D. Kinematic Model and Metrology System for Modular Robot Calibration[C].in:Proceedings of the IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation. New Orleans, LA, USA:IEEE,2004.2894-2899.
    [19]Bernhardt R., Albright S. L. Robot Calibration[M]. Chapman and Hall, Ltd. London, UK,1993.
    [20]Zhuang H., Roth S. Z. Camera-Aided Robot Calibration[M]. Boca Raton, Florida: CRC Press,1996.
    [21]Mooring B. W., Roth Z. S., Driels M. S. Fundamentals of Manipulator Calibration[M]. John Wiley and Sons Inc., New York (1991).:John Wiley and Sons Inc.,1991.
    [22]Roth Z., Mooring B., Ravani B. An Overview of Robot Calibration[J]. IEEE Trans. Robot. Autom.1987,3(5):377-385.
    [23]Khalil W., Gautier M., Enguehard C. Identifiable Parameters and Optimum Configurations for Robots Calibration[J]. Robotica.1991,9:63-70.
    [24]Mirman C. R., Gupta K. C. Identification of Position-Independent Robot Parameter Errors Using Special Jacobian Matrices[J]. Int. J. Robot. Res.1993,12(3):288-298.
    [25]Hollerbach J. M., Wampler C. W. The Calibration Index and Taxonomy for Robot Kinematic Calibration Methods[J]. Int. J. Robot. Res.1996,15(6):573-591.
    [26]Gatti G., Danieli G. A Practical Approach to Compensate for Geometric Errors in Measuring Arms:Application to a Six-Degree-of-Freedom Kinematic Structure[J]. Meas. Sci. Technol.2008,19(1):15107.
    [27]Wu C. A Kinematic Cad Tool for the Design and Control of a Robot Manipulator[J]. Int. J. Robot. Res.1984,3(1):58-67.
    [28]Everett L., Driels M., Mooring B. Kinematic Modelling for Robot Calibration[C].in: Proceedings of the IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation. Raleigh, North Carolina:IEEE,1987.183-189.
    [29]Everett L. J., Hsu T. W. The Theory of Kinematic Parameter Identification for Industrial Robots[J]. ASME J. Dynam. Syst. Meas. Contr.1988,110(1):96-100.
    [30]Everett L. J., Suryohadiprojo A. H. A Study of Kinematic Models for Forward Calibration of Manipulators[C].in:Proceedings of the IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation. Philadelphia, PA:IEEE,1988.798-800.
    [31]Santolaria J., Aguilar J. J., Yaguuue J. A., et al. Kinematic Parameter Estimation Technique for Calibration and Repeatability Improvement of Articulated Arm Coordinate Measuring Machines[J]. Prec. Eng.2008,32(4):251-268.
    [32]Verl A., Boye T., Pott A. Measurement Pose Selection and Calibration Forecast for Manipulators with Complex Kinematic Structures[J]. CIRP Annals-Manufacturing Technology.2008,57(1):425-428.
    [33]Uddin M. S., Ibaraki S., Matsubara A., et al. Prediction and Compensation of Machining Geometric Errors of Five-Axis Machining Centers with Kinematic Errors[J]. Prec. Eng.2008,33(2):194-201.
    [34]Sun Y., Hollerbach J. M. Active Robot Calibration Algorithm[C].in:Proc. IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation. Pasadena, CA:IEEE,2008. 1276-1281.
    [35]Lightcap C., Hamner S., Schmitz T., et al. Improved Positioning Accuracy of the Pa10-6Ce Robot with Geometric and Flexibility Calibration[J]. IEEE Transactions on Robotics.2008,24(2):452-456.
    [36]Ha I. C. Kinematic Parameter Calibration Method for Industrial Robot Manipulator Using the Relative Position[J]. Journal of Mechanical Science and Technology.2008, 22(6):1084-1090.
    [37]Park F. C., Bobrow J. Geometric Optimization Algorithms for Robot Kinematic Design[J]. Journal of Robotic Systems.1995,12(6):453-463.
    [38]Park J., Chung W. Geometric Integration On Euclidean Group with Application to Articulated Multibody Systems[J]. IEEE Transactions on Robotics.2005,21 (5): 850-863.
    [39]Yang G., Chen I. M., Lee W. K., et al. Self-Calibration of Three-Legged Modular Reconfigurable Parallel Robots Based On Leg-End Distance Errors[J]. Robotica. 2001,19(2):187-198.
    [40]Zhuang H., Roth Z. S., Hamano F. Observability Issues in Kinematic Error Parameter Identification of Manipulators[C].in:American Control Conference. San Diego, CA, USA:IEEE,1990.2287-2293.
    [41]Zhuang H., Roth Z. S., Hamano F. Observability Issues in Kinematic Identification of Manipulators[J]. ASME J. Dynam. Syst. Meas. Contr.1992,114(2):319-322.
    [42]Barker L. K. Vector-Algebra Approach to Extract Denavit-Hartenberg Parameters of Assembled Robot Arms[R]. NASA,1983.
    [43]Hollerbach J. M., Giugovaz L., Buehler M., et al. Screw Axis Measurement for Kinematic Calibration of the Sarcos Dextrous Arm[C].in:Proc. IEEE/RSJ International Conference on Intelligent Robots and Systems. Yokohama:IEEE,1993. 1617-1621.
    [44]Harb S., Burdekin M. A Systematic Approach to Identify the Error Motion of an N-Degree of Freedom Manipulator[J]. The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology.1994,9(2):126-133.
    [45]Abderrahim M., Whittaker A. R. Kinematic Model Identification of Industrial Manipulators[J]. Robotics and Computer Integrated Manufacturing.2000,16(1): 1-8.
    [46]叶声华,王一,任永杰,等.基于激光跟踪仪的机器人运动学参数标定方法[J].天津大学学报.2007,40(2):202-205.
    [47]张建忠.机器人连杆参数的视觉标定[J].制造业自动化.2004,26(11):32-34.
    [48]Zhuang H., Roth Z. S. A Linear Solution to the Kinematic Parameter Identification of Robot Manipulators[J]. IEEE Trans. Robot. Autom.1993,9(2):174-185.
    [49]Shih S. W., Hung Y. P., Lin W. Kinematic Parameter Identification of a Binocular Head Using Stereo Measurements of Single Calibration Point[C].in:IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation. Nagoya:IEEE,1995. 1796-1801.
    [50]Shih S. W., Hung Y. P., Lin W. Error Analysis On Closed-Form Solutions for Kinematic Calibration[R]. Nankang, Taipei, Taiwan, R.O.C.:Inst. Inform. Sci., Academia Sinica,1996.TR-IIS-96-014.
    [51]Shih S., Hung Y., Liu W. New Closed-Form Solution for Kinematic Parameter Identification of a Binocular Head Using Point Measurements[J]. IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics, Part B.1998,28(2):258-267.
    [52]Stone H. W. S. A. Arm Signature Identification[C].in:Proceedings of the IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation. San Fransico:IEEE,1986. 41-48.
    [53]Stone H. W., Sanderson A. A Prototype Arm Signature Identification System[C].in: IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation. Raleigh, NC:IEEE, 1987.175-182.
    [54]Stone H. W. Kinematic Parameter Identification for Robotic Manipulators[P]. US Patent 4,698,572. [Oct.6,1987].
    [55]Stone H. W., Sanderson A. Statistical Performance Evaluation of the S-Model Arm Signature Identification Technique[C].in:IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation. Philadelphia, PA:IEEE,1988.939-946.
    [56]Broderick P. L., Cipra R. J. A Method for Determining and Correcting Robot Position and Orientation Errors Due to Manufacturing[J]. J. Mech. Transm. Autom. Des. 1988,110(3):3-10.
    [57]Ziegert J., Datseris P. Robot Calibration Using Local Pose Measurements [J]. International Journal of Robotics and Automation.1990,5(2):68-76.
    [58]Ibrahim S. A., Wager J. G. A Technique for Independent-Axis Calibration of Robot Manipulators with Experimental Verification[J]. International Journal of Computer Integrated Manufacturing.2001,14(5):501-512.
    [59]Zhuang H., Roth Z. S. A Note On "a Linear Solution to the Kinematic Parameter Identification of Robot Manipulators"[J]. IEEE Transactions on Robotics and Automation.1995,11(6):922.
    [60]Jiang X., Cheng D. C. Fitting of 3D Circles and Ellipses Using a Parameter Decomposition Approach[C].in:Fifth International Conference on 3-D Digital Imaging and Modeling. Ottawa, Canada:IEEE,2005.103-109.
    [61]Judd R. P., Knasinski A. B. A Technique to Calibrate Industrial Robots with Experimental Verification[J]. IEEE Trans. Robot. Autom.1990,6(1):20-30.
    [62]Shakarji C. M. Least-Squares Fitting Algorithms of the Nist Algorithm Testing System[J]. National Institute of Standards and Technology, Journal of Research. 1998,103(6):633-641.
    [63]Zhuang H., Wu W. C., Roth Z. S. Camera-Assisted Calibration of Scara Arms[J]. IEEE Robotics and Automation Magazine.1996,3(4):46-53.
    [64]Driels M. R., Pathre U. S. Significance of Observation Strategy On the Design of Robot Calibration Experiments[J]. Journal of Robotic Systems.1990,7(2):197-223.
    [65]Pathre U. S., Driels M. Simulation Experiments in Parameter Identification for Robot Calibration[J]. The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology. 1990,5(1):13-33.
    [66]Wu C. H. The Kinematic Error Model for the Design of Robot Manipulator[C].in: American Control Conference. San Francisco, CA:IEEE,1983.497-502.
    [67]Veitschegger W., Wu C. H. A Method for Calibrating and Compensating Robot Kinematic Errors[C].in:Proc. IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation. Raleigh, NC:IEEE,1987.39-44.
    [68]Veitschegger W. K., Wu C. Robot Calibration and Compensation[J]. IEEE Journal of Robotics and Automation.1988,4(6):643-656.
    [69]Mirman C., Gupta K. C. Compensation of Robot Joint Variables Using Special Jacobian Matrices[J]. Journal of Robotic Systems.1992,9(1):113-137.
    [70]Jang J. H., Kim S. H., Kwak Y. K. Calibration of Geometric and Non-Geometric Errors of an Industrial Robot[J]. Robotica.2001,19(3):311-321.
    [71]Motta J. M. S. T., de Carvalho G. C., Mcmaster R. S. Robot Calibration Using a 3D Vision-Based Measurement System with a Single Camera[J]. Robotics and Computer-Integrated Manufacturing.2001,17(6):487-497.
    [72]Megahed S. M. Symbolic Computation of Robot Models for Geometric Parameters Identification with Singularity Analysis[J]. J. Intell. Robot. Syst.1996,16(2): 103-121.
    [73]Goswami A., Quaid A., Peshkin M. Calibration and Parameter Identification of a 6-Dof Robot Using a Single Radial-Distance Transducer[C].in:IEEE International Conference on Systems, Man and Cybernetics. Chicago, IL:IEEE,1992.177-182.
    [74]Goswami A., Quaid A., Peshkin M. Identifying Robot Parameters Using Partial Pose Information [J]. IEEE Control Syst. Mag.1993,13(5):6-14.
    [75]Everett L. J. Models for Diagnosing Robot Error Sources[C].in:Proc. IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation. Atlanta, GA:IEEE,1993. 155-159.
    [76]Khalil W., Caenen J., Enguehard C. Identification and Calibration of the Geometric Parameters of Robots[C].in:The First International Symposium on Experimental Robotics I. Montreal, Canada:Springer-Verlag,1989.528-538.
    [77]Khalil W., Garcia G., Delagarde J. F. Calibration of the Geometric Parameters of Robots without External Sensors[C].in:Proceedings of IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation. Nagoya, Japan:1995.3039-3044.
    [78]Moon S. K., Moon Y., Kota S., et al. Screw Theory Based Metrology for Design and Error Compensation of Machine Tools[C].in:ASME 2001 Design Engineering Technical Conferences. Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania:ASME,2001.21083.
    [79]Ziegert J. C., Olson D. G., Datseris P. Description of Machine Tool Errors Using Screw Coordinates[J]. Journal of Mechanical Design.1992,114(4):531-535.
    [80]Rueda M. P. A., Feria A. L., Marinero J. C. F., et al. Manipulator Kinematic Error Model in a Calibration Process through Quaternion-Vector Pairs[C].in:Proc. IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation ICRA'02. Washington, DC: IEEE,2002.135-140.
    [81]Lou Y., Chen T., Wu Y., et al. Improved and Modified Geometric Formulation of Poe Based Kinematic Calibration of Serial Robots[C].in:Proceedings of the 2009 IEEE/RSJ international conference on Intelligent robots and systems. St. Louis: IEEE,2009.5261-5266.
    [82]Yang G., Chen I. M. A Novel Kinematic Calibration Algorithm for Reconfigurable Robotic Systems[C].in:Proc. IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation. Albuquerque, New Mexico:IEEE,1997.3197-3202.
    [83]Mavroidis C., Dubowsky S., Drouet P. A Systematic Error Analysis of Robotic Manipulators:Application to a High Performance Medical Robot[C].in:Proceedings of the 1997 International Conference in Robotics and Automation. Albuquerque, NM:IEEE,1997.980-985.
    [84]Chalfoun J., Bidard C., Keller D., et al. Calibration Using Generalized Error Matrices of a Long Reach Articulated Carrier[C].in:Proceedings of the 3rd Annual IEEE Conference on Automation Science and Engineering. Scottsdale, AZ, USA:IEEE, 2007.777-782.
    [85]Umetsu K., Furutnani R., Osawa S., et al. Geometric Calibration of a Coordinate Measuring Machine Using a Laser Tracking System[J]. Measurement Science and Technology.2005,16(12):2466-2472.
    [86]Meggiolaro M. A., Dubowsky S., Mavroidis C. Geometric and Elastic Error Calibration of a High Accuracy Patient Positioning System [J]. Mechanism and Machine Theory.2005,40(4):415-427.
    [87]Vincze M., Filz K. M., Gander H., et al. A Systematic Approach to Model Arbitrary Non Geometric Kinematic Errors[M].In:Advances in robot kinematics and computational geometry, Lenarcic J. R. B., MIT Press,1994,129-138.
    [88]Vincze M., Spiess S., Parotidis M., et al. Automatic Generation of Non-Redundant and Complete Models for Geometric and Non-Geometric Errors of Robots[J]. International Journal of Modelling and Simulation.1999,19(3):236-243.
    [89]Bennett D. J., Hollerbach J. M. Identifying the Kinematics of Robots and their Tasks[C].in:IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation. Scottsdale, AZ:IEEE,1989.580-586.
    [90]Bennett D. J., Hollerbach J. Autonomous Calibration of Single-Loop Closed Kinematic Chains Formed by Manipulators with Passive Endpoint Constraints[J]. IEEE Trans. Robot. Autom.1991,7(5):597-606.
    [91]Goswami A., Bosnik J. R. On a Relationship Between the Physical Features of Robotic Manipulators and the Kinematic Parameters Produced by Numerical Calibration [J]. Journal of Mechanical Design.1993,115(4):892-900.
    [92]Ishii M., Sakane S., Kakikura M., et al. A New Approach to Improve Absolute Positioning Accuracy of Robot Manipulators[J]. J. Robot. Syst.1987,4(1):145-156.
    [93]Lam J., Greenspan M. An Iterative Algebraic Approach to Tcf Matrix Estimation[C].in:IEEE/RSJ International Conference on Intelligent Robots and Systems. San Diego, CA:IEEE,2007.3848-3853.
    [94]Zhuang H., Roth Z. S. A Note On Singularities of the Mcpc Model[J]. Robotics and Computer Integrated Manufacturing.1996,12(2):169-172.
    [95]Kurbanhusen M. S., Yang G. L., Lin W., et al. Kinematic Calibration of an Intrinsically-Safe 7-Dof Robotic Arm[R]. Singapore:Nanyang Technological University,2007.
    [96]Everett L. J., Ong L. E. Determining Essential Parameters for Calibration[C].in: Proceedings of the 1993 ASME Winter Annual Meeting. New Orleans, LA:ASME, 1993.295-302.
    [97]Etienne D., Wisama K. Modeling, Performance Analysis and Control of Robot Manipulators (Control Systems, Robotics and Manufacturing Series)[M]. Wiley Blackwell,2006.
    [98]Borm J. H., Menq C. Experimental Study of Observability of Parameter Errors in Robot Calibration[C].in:Proceedings of the IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation. Scottsdale, AZ:IEEE,1989.587-592.
    [99]Schroer K. Theory of Kinematic Modelling and Numerical Procedures for Robot Calibration[M].In:Robot Calibration, Bernhardt R., Albright S. L., Chapman and Hall,1993,157-196.
    [100]Baker D. R. Some Topological Problems in Robotics[J]. The Mathematical Intelligencer.1990,12(1):66-76.
    [101]Neagoe M., Gogu G., Diaconescu D. High Degree Accuracy Modelling and Calibration of Serial Robots with Large Errors[M].In:Product Engineering, Talaba D., Roche T., Springer,2004,397-408.
    [102]Renders J. M., Rossignol E., Becquet M., et al. Kinematic Calibration and Geometrical Parameter Identification for Robots[J]. IEEE Trans. Robot. Autom. 1991,7(6):721-732.
    [103]Rousseau P., Desrochers A., Krouglicof N., et al. Machine Vision System for the Automatic Identification of Robotkinematic Parameters[J]. IEEE Trans. Robot. Autom.2001,17(6):972-978.
    [104]Zhang C., Cai H., Wu W. A Kinematic Model and Identification of Geometric Parametres of Robots[J]. Journal of Harbin Institute of Technology(New Series). 1998,5(3):14-17.
    [105]Ziegert J., Datseris P. Basic Considerations for Robot Calibration[C].in: Proceedings of IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation. Philadelphia, PA:IEEE,1988.932-938.
    [106]ISO/Tr 13309. Manipulating Industrial Robots-Informative Guide On Test Equipment and Metrology Methods of Operation for Robot Performance Evaluation in Accordance with Iso 9283[S]. Iso,1995.
    [107]Maas H. G. Dynamic Photogrammetric Calibration of Industrial Robots[C].in: Proceedings of the Meeting:Videometrics V. San Diego, CA:SPIE,1997.106-112.
    [108]Alici G., Shirinzadeh B. Laser Interferometry Based Robot Position Error Modelling for Kinematic Calibration[C].in:Proc. IEEE/RSJ International Conference on Intelligent Robots and Systems. Las Vegas, Nevada:IEEE,2003.3588-3593.
    [109]Song J., Yao D., Hu J., et al. A Novel Calibration System for a Space Manipulator[C].in:IEEE/RSJ International Conference on Intelligent Robots and Systems. Beijing:IEEE,2006.4672-4677.
    [110]Janocha H., Diewald B. Icaros:Over-All-Calibration of Industrial Robots[J]. Industrial robot.1995,22(3):15-20.
    [111]Bai Y., Zhuang H., Roth Z. S. Experiment Study of Puma Robot Calibration Using a Laser Tracking System[C].in:IEEE international Workshop on Soft Computing in Industrial Applications. Binghaniton, New York:IEEE,2003.23-25.
    [112]Driels M. R., Swayze W., Potter S. Full-Pose Calibration of a Robot Manipulator Using a Coordinate-Measuring Machine[J]. The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology.1993,8(1):34-41.
    [113]Dolinsky J. U. The Development of a Genetic Programming Method for Kinematic Robot Calibration[D]. Liverpool:Liverpool John Moores University,2001.
    [114]Alici G., Shirinzadeh B. A Systematic Technique to Estimate Positioning Errors for Robot Accuracy Improvement Using Laser Interferometry Based Sensing[J]. Mechanism and Machine Theory.2005,40(8):879-906.
    [115]Schwenke H., Franke M., Hannaford J., et al. Error Mapping of Cmms and Machine Tools by a Single Tracking Interferometer[J]. CIRP Annals-Manufacturing Technology.2005,54(1):475-478.
    [116]Vincze M., Prenninger J. P., Gander H. A Laser Tracking System to Measure Position and Orientation of Robot End Effectors Under Motion[J]. The International Journal of Robotics Research.1994,13(4):305-314.
    [117]Chang Y. Z., Hou J. F., Lee S. Accurate Calibration of a Robotic Positioning System Using the Evolutionary Search[C].in:32nd Annual Conference on IEEE Industrial Electronics. Paris:IEEE,2006.3886-3891.
    [118]Zhuang H., Wang K., Roth Z. S. Simultaneous Calibration of a Robot and a Hand-Mounted Camera[J]. IEEE transactions on robotics and automation.1995, 11(5):649-660.
    [119]Guo J. Y., Zhang J. L., Lu T. S. Robot Calibration Using Active Vision-Based Measurement[J]. Journal of Donghua University.2004,21(1):7-12.
    [120]Sun L., Liu J., Sun W., et al. Geometry-Based Robot Calibration Method[C].in: IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation. New Orleans, LA: IEEE,2004.1907-1912.
    [121]Xu W., Mills J. K. A New Approach to the Position and Orientation Calibration of Robots[C].in:Proceedings of IEEE International Symposium of Assembly and Task Planning. Port, Portugal:IEEE,1999.268-273.
    [122]Song Y., Wu L., Tian J., et al. An Approach to Measure the Pose of Rhjd 4-1 Arc Welding Robot for Calibration[J].2002,11(1):5-8.
    [123]Smith G. C., Smith R. A Non-Contact Method for Detecting On-Line Industrial Robot Position Errors Using a Microwave Doppler Radar Motion Detector[J]. The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology.2006,29(5): 605-615.
    [124]Simpson N., Hayes M. Simulation of a Kinematic Calibration Procedure that Employs the Relative Measurement Concept[C].in:Proc. CSME Forum. Ontario, Canada:Kluwer Academic Press,2004.62-71.
    [125]Gatla C., Lumia R., Wood J., et al. Calibration of Industrial Robots by Magnifying Errors On a Distant Plane[C].in:Proceedings of the 2007 IEEE/RSJ International Conference on Intelligent Robots and Systems. San Diego, CA, USA:IEEE,2007. 3834-3841.
    [126]Gatla C. S., Lumia R., Wood J., et al. An Automated Method to Calibrate Industrial Robots Using a Virtual Closed Kinematic Chain[J]. IEEE Transactions on Robotics. 2007,23(6):1105-1116.
    [127]Giugovaz L., Hollerbach J. M. Closed-Loop Kinematic Calibration of the Sarcos Dextrous Arm[C].in:Proc. IEEE/RSJ/GI International Conference on Intelligent Robots and Systems'94.'Advanced Robotic Systems and the Real World'. Munich: IEEE,1994.329-334.
    [128]Watanabe A., Sakakibara S., Ban K., et al. A Kinematic Calibration Method for Industrial Robots Using Autonomous Visual Measurement[J].2006,55(1):1-6.
    [129]Li A., Wu D., Ma Z. Robot Calibration Based On Multi-Thread Particle Swarm Optimization[C].in:6th IEEE International Conference on Industrial Informatics. Daejeon:IEEE,2008.454-457.
    [130]Santolaria J., Brau A., Velazquez J., et al. A Self-Centering Active Probing Technique for Kinematic Parameter Identification and Verification of Articulated Arm Coordinate Measuring Machines[J]. Measurement Science and Technology. 2010,21(5):55101.
    [131]Kang H. J., Jeong J. W., Shin S. W., et al. Autonomous Kinematic Calibration of the Robot Manipulator with a Linear Laser-Vision Sensor[C].in:Third International Conference on Intelligent Computing. Qingdao, China:Springer-Verlag,2007. 1102-1109.
    [132]Wei G. Q., Hirzinger G. Active Self-Calibration of Hand-Mounted Laser Range Finders[J]. IEEE Transactions on Robotics and Automation.1998,14(3):493-497.
    [133]Ikits M., Hollerbach J. M. Kinematic Calibration Using a Plane Constraint[C].in: Proc. IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation. Albuquerque, NM:IEEE,1997.3191-3196.
    [134]Zhong X., Lewis J. M. A New Method for Autonomous Robot Calibration[C].in: Proc. IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation. Nagoya:IEEE, 1995.1790-1795.
    [135]Maurine P., Dombre E., Latte J. An Automatic and Autonomous Calibration Procedure for Robots Manipulators[C].in:Troisieme congres Japon-France et premier congres Europe-Asie sur la Mecatronique Besancon. Franch:1996.354-359.
    [136]Khalil W., Lemoine P., Gautier M. Autonomous Calibration of Robots Using Planar Points[C].in:Proc.6th Int. Symp. on Robotics and Manufacturing. Montpellier, France:1996.383-388.
    [137]Tang Z., Niu Z., Liu X. Autonomous Calibration Research of Polishing Robot[C].in: Intelligent Control and Automation, WCICA 2006. Dalian, China:IEEE,2006. 8938-8942.
    [138]Zhuang H., Motaghedi S. H., Roth Z. S. Robot Calibration with Planar Constraints[C].in:IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation. Detroit, Michigan:IEEE,1999.805-810.
    [139]Besnard S., Khalil W., Garcia G. Geometric Calibration of Robots Using Multiple Plane Constraints[M].In:Advances in robot kinematics, Lenarcic J. S. S., Kluwer Academic Publishers,2000,61-70.
    [140]Roning J., Korzun A. A Method for Industrial Robot Calibration[C].in:Proc. IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation. Albuquerque, NM:IEEE, 1997.3184-3190.
    [141]Gong C., Yuan J., Ni J. A Self-Calibration Method for Robotic Measurement System[J]. Journal of manufacturing science and engineering.2000,122(1): 174-181.
    [142]任永杰,邾继贵,杨学友,等.基于距离精度的测量机器人标定模型及算法[J].计量学报.2008,29(3):198-202.
    [143]Liu Y., Xi N., Zhao J., et al. Development and Sensitivity Analysis of a Portable Calibration System for Joint Offset of Industrial Robot[C].in:Proceedings of the 2009 IEEE/RSJ international conference on Intelligent robots and systems. St. Louis, MO:IEEE,2009.3838-3843.
    [144]Chen H., Fuhlbrigge T., Choi S., et al. Practical Industrial Robot Zero Offset Calibration[C].in:Proc. IEEE/RSJ International Conference on Intelligent Robots and Systems. Washington DC:IEEE,2008.516-521.
    [145]Liu Y., Xi N., Zhang G., et al. An Automated Method to Calibrate Industrial Robot Joint Offset Using Virtual Line-Based Single-Point Constraint Approach[C].in: IEEE/RSJ International Conference on Intelligent Robots and Systems. St. Louis, USA:IEEE,2009.715-720.
    [146]Edwards C., Galloway-Jr R. L. Single-Point Calibration Technique for a Six Degree-of-Freedom Articulated Arm[J]. The International Journal of Robotics Research.1994,13(3):189-198.
    [147]Menq C. H., Borm J. H., Lai J. Z. Identification and Observability Measure of a Basis Set of Error Parameters in Robot Calibration[J].1989,111 (4):513-518.
    [148]Borm J. H., Meng C. Determination of Optimal Measurement Configurations for Robot Calibration Based On Observability Measure[J]. The International Journal of Robotics Research.1991,10(1):51-63.
    [149]Horne A., Notash L. Comparison of Pose Selection Criteria for Kinematic Calibration through Simulation[C].in:Computational Kinematics:Proceedings of the 5th International Workshop on Computational Kinematics. Duisburg, Germany: Springer-Verlag,2009.291-298.
    [150]Sun Y., Hollerbach J. Observability Index Selection for Robot Calibration[C].in: Proc. IEEE International Conf. on Robotics and Automation. Pasadena, CA:IEEE, 2008.831-836.
    [151]Nahvi A., Hollerbach J. M., Hayward V. Calibration of a Parallel Robot Using Multiple Kinematic Closed Loops[C].in:Proc. IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation. San Diego, CA:IEEE,1994.407-412.
    [152]Nahvi A., Hollerbach J. M. The Noise Amplification Index for Optimal Pose Selection in Robot Calibration[C].in:Proc. IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation. Minneapolis, MN:IEEE,1996.647-654.
    [153]Young K., Chen J. J. Implementation of a Variable D-H Parameter Model for Robot Calibration Using an Fcmac Learning Algorithm[J]. Journal of Intelligent and Robotic Systems.1999,24(4):313-346.
    [154]Hollerbach J., Khalil W., Gautier M. Model Identification[M].In:Springer handbook of robotics, Siciliano B., Khatib O., New York:Springer-Verlag,2008, 321-344.
    [155]Bay J. S. Autonomous Parameter Identification by Optimal Learning Control[J]. IEEE Control Systems Magazine.1993,13(3):56-61.
    [156]Daney D., Papegay Y., Madeline B. Choosing Measurement Poses for Robot Calibration with the Local Convergence Method and Tabu Search[J]. The International Journal of Robotics Research.2005,24(6):501-518.
    [157]Zhuang H., Wang K., Roth Z. S. Optimal Selection of Measurement Configurations for Robot Calibration Using Simulated Annealing[C].in:Proc. IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation. San Diego, CA:IEEE,1994.393-398.
    [158]Zhao X., Cheng H., Wang S. Optimal Selection of Measurement Configurations for Robot Calibration with Solis&Wets Algorithm[C].in:Proc. IEEE International Conference on Control and Automation ICCA 2007. Guangzhou:IEEE,2007. 2429-2432.
    [159]Zhuang H., Wu J., Weizhen H. Optimal Planning of Robot Calibration Experiments by Genetic Algorithms[C].in:Proc. IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation. Minneapolis, MN:IEEE,1996.981-986.
    [160]Zhuang H. Q., Jie W., Huang W. Z. Optimal Planning of Robot Calibration Experiments by Genetic Algorithms[J]. Journal of Robotic Systems.1997,14(10): 741-752.
    [161]Huang C., Xie C., Zhang T. Determination of Optimal Measurement Configurations for Robot Calibration Based On a Hybrid Optimal Method[C].in:International Conference on Information and Automation. Zhangjiajie, China:IEEE,2008. 789-793.
    [162]Huang M. Z., Masory O. A Simple Method of Accuracy Enhancement for Industrial Manipulators[J]. The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology. 1993,8(2):114-122.
    [163]Bennett D. J., Hollerbach J. M. Self-Calibration of Single-Loop, Closed Kinematic Chains Formed by Dual Or Redundant Manipulators[C].in:Proceedings of the 27th IEEE Conference on Decision and Control. Austin, TX:IEEE,1988.627-629.
    [164]赵刚,黄攀峰,邵玮,等.基于混合算法的空间机器人运动学参数辨识[J].计算机仿真.2008,25(12):92-94,179.
    [165]Liu Y., Jiang Y. S., Liang B., et al. Calibration of a 6-Dof Space Robot Using Genetic Algorithm[J]. Chinese Joural of Mechanical Engineering.2008,21(6):6-13.
    [166]高贯斌,王文,林铿,等.应用改进模拟退火算法实现关节臂式坐标测量机的参数辨识[J].光学精密工程.2009,17(10):2499-2505.
    [167]王东署,迟健男,徐方,等.遗传神经网络法及其在机器人误差补偿中的应用[J].东北大学学报(自然科学版).2006,27(1):13-16.
    [168]Alici G., Jagielski R., Sekercoglu Y. A., et al. Prediction of Geometric Errors of Robot Manipulators with Particle Swarm Optimisation Method[J]. Robotics and Autonomous Systems.2006,54(12):956-966.
    [169]Young K. Y., Chen J. J., Wang C. An Automated Robot Calibration System Based On a Variable D-H Parameter Model[C].in:Proceedings of the 35th IEEE Decision and Control. Kobe:IEEE,1996.881-886.
    [170]Murray R. M., Li Z., Sastry S. S. A Mathematical Introduction to Robotic Manipulation[M]. Boca Raton, FL:CRC Press,1994.
    [171]Park F. C. Computational Aspects of the Product-of-Exponentials Formula for Robot Kinematics[J].1994,39(3):643-647.
    [172]Aspragathos N. A., Dimitros J. K. A Comparative Study of Three Methods for Robot Kinematics[J]. IEEE transactions on systems, man, and cybernetics-part B: cybernetics.1998,28(2):135-145.
    [173]Schroer K. Precision and Calibration[M].In:Handbook of industrial robotics,2nd. ed; Nof S. Y., New York:John Wiley & Sons, INC.,1999,795-810.
    [174]Chen N., Parker G. Inverse Kinematic Solution to a Calibrated Puma 560 Industrial Robot[J]. Control Engineering Practice.1994,2(2):239-245.
    [175]ISO 9283 Manipulating Industrial Robots-Performance Criteria and Related Test Methods[S]. Iso,1998.
    [176]Brockett R. W. Robotic Manipulators and the Product of Exponentials Formula[C].in:Fuhrman P. A. Mathematical Theory of Networks and Systems. New York:Springer-Verlag,1984.120-129.
    [177]Selig J. M. Geometric Fundamentals of Robotics[M].2nd ed. Springer-Verlag, 2005.
    [178]于靖军,刘辛军,丁希仑,等.机器人机构学的数学基础[M].北京:机械工业出版社,2008.
    [179]Selig J. Lie Groups and Lie Algebras in Robotics[M].In:Computational Noncommutative Algebra and Applications, Byrnes J., Springer,2004:136, 101-125.
    [180]Hambleton I., Pedersen E. K. Compactifying Infinite Group Actions[C].in: Geometry and Topology, Aarhus:Conference on Geometry and Topology. Aarhus University, Aarhus, Denmark:2000.203-212.
    [181]Wang X., Red E. Robotic Tcf and Rigid-Body Calibration Methods[J]. Robotica. 1997,15(6):633-644.
    [182]吴卫东.光学扫描精度影响因素及对策分析[J].工具技术.2005,39(1):59-62.
    [183]R. Steinmeier, J. Rachinger, M. Kaus, et al. Factors Influencing the Application Accuracy of Neuronavigation Systems[J]. Stereotactic and Functional Neurosurgery. 2000,75(4):188-202.
    [184]J M. Fitzpatrick, J B. West, C. Maurer. Predicting Error in Rigid-Body Point-Based Registration[J]. IEEE Transactions on Medical Imaging.1998,17(5):694-702.
    [185]刘军传.脑外科机器人系统定位精度研究[D].北京:北京航空航天大学,2006.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700