用户名: 密码: 验证码:
基于系统性风险的银行资本监管及其宏观经济效应
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
2008年金融危机的发生促使人们反思金融监管政策领域的缺陷,危机的一个重要教训在于,以单家银行机构稳健经营为目标的微观审慎监管和资本约束机制不能有效维护银行体系稳定,在抵御系统性风险方面存在重大缺陷,基于宏观审慎视角及系统性风险的金融监管成为后危机时代各国监管理念和工具的主要发展趋势及调整方向。2010年巴塞尔协议III的实施,将中国银行业资本监管由关注微观风险推向了宏观与微观审慎相结合的实施阶段。如何衡量我国大型银行机构的系统性风险贡献度,如何识别宏观经济体系的信用融资水平和金融累积风险,如何建立起基于这些系统性风险的资本监管工具,资本监管新规对于宏观经济波动和社会福利损失有哪些影响,如何权衡与协调逆周期资本政策与货币政策的相互关系?这一系列问题不仅仅是理论问题,更是重要的现实问题,对于我国银行系统性风险的有效监管和防范,宏观审慎政策的制定与实施以及维护金融体系的稳定具有非常重要的理论意义和实践价值。
     在这一背景下,本文从加强宏观审慎监管的角度出发,对基于系统性风险的我国银行资本监管政策设计和实际应用,以及资本监管的宏观经济效应及其与货币政策的协调关系,进行了深入的理论研究和实证分析,本文的研究结构包含三大部分:第一部分是对于系统性风险的测度和资本监管设计,具体包括两个方面,根据系统性风险的截面维度和时间维度,一方面探讨了系统重要性银行的测度评估框架和系统性附加资本的设计、计提方法,另一方面建立了逆周期资本监管框架下宏观系统性风险指标体系,并对逆周期资本工具的设计、开发和运用进行了探讨和研究。论文第二部分是在DSGE模型基础上研究了基于系统性风险资本监管的宏观经济效应,在一般均衡框架下讨论了监管资本要求提高,以及逆周期资本监管政策的实施所造成的宏观经济效应和福利影响。第三部分探讨了最优货币政策与逆周期资本监管政策的权衡与协调问题,在一个统一的模型框架内,对两种政策的相互关系以及在应对不同宏观经济情形上的效果进行研究。本文的工作主要包括以下几个方面:
     1、对我国系统重要性银行进行测度并建立了有差别的系统重要性银行附加资本。本文从风险传染的直接影响和间接影响两方面,分别应用基于资产负债表关联数据的金融网络分析法,和基于市场价格数据的CoVaR方法对我国银行的系统重要性水平和风险传染效应进行测度,并综合考虑银行机构的规模、系统关联性、可替代性、复杂性、同质性和跨境活跃度六类指标,建立了银行业系统性风险的综合度量框架,并对我国63家银行的系统重要性进行评估和排序,在此基础上将银行区分为高度系统性银行、部分系统重要性银行、非系统性大型金融机构与非系统性中小银行等,为系统重要性银行附加资本的计提提供了量化标准和监管依据。
     2、对于我国银行业资本监管的顺周期性及其相应的逆周期资本监管框架设计进行研究。逆周期银行资本监管是实现银行体系宏观审慎监管的核心内容,但如何准确的判断经济周期和识别宏观系统性风险的特征、水平和变化趋势,以及如何把握逆周期工具的时点和程度则是实施该项监管中的难题。本文在对我国商业银行资本充足率变动的顺周期效应进行实证分析的基础上,从中国银行业和宏观金融风险的实际情况出发,构建了多层次、多维度的宏观系统性风险度量指标框架,以反映我国金融体系和社会整体的信用融资水平,并以此作为逆周期缓冲资本的指导变量;在识别系统性风险状态和判断逆周期资本工具的应用时点方面,论文引入了Markov机制转移模型对周期转变和风险状态的阶段性变迁进行识别和分析,以确定逆周期资本的计提时点和程度,为风险判别和逆周期监管建立起系统性的定量分析方法作支撑。
     3、建立了包含银行监管资本影响和金融加速器效应的DSGE模型,对基于系统性风险资本监管的宏观经济效应进行研究。通过建立一个含有银行部门监管资本影响和金融加速器效应的新凯恩斯主义DSGE模型,分析在巴塞尔III新监管框架下银行资本充足率要求提高和逆周期资本政策的实施对宏观经济波动的冲击和影响,围绕三个核心问题:即第一,货币政策的银行资本传导渠道对于宏观经济波动的作用机制和效果如何;第二,银行资本监管要求提高对于宏观经济变量的冲击和影响程度有多大;第三,逆周期资本监管政策的实施能否对真实经济波动起到平抑作用。通过理论和校准模拟分析,深入研究了银行监管资本变动通过信贷渠道对于宏观经济波动的影响机制和效果,为我国货币政策和宏观审慎政策的实施和政策工具的选择与权衡等提供理论与经验支持。
     4、基于DSGE模型对货币政策与逆周期资本监管政策的权衡与协调问题进行研究。在一个统一的模型框架内,对货币政策与逆周期资本监管政策的相互关系,以及在应对不同宏观经济情形上的效果进行研究和对比,通过校准和数值模拟对不同政策组合下的社会福利损失进行比较,并对逆周期资本监管的政策参数选择及其经济效果进行全面评估,为有效把握货币政策与逆周期审慎监管政策的相互关系,以及衡量两种政策工具在应对不同政策目标(包括物价稳定和金融稳定)上的层次顺序和政策效果提供有意义的借鉴参考。
     5、回顾和总结了金融危机后美国、欧盟、英国、日本等国提出的基于系统性风险的银行监管改革方案、监管工具和发展方向,比较了各国建立宏观审慎监管的机构分工和监管框架,提出从增强宏观审慎意识、加强系统性风险分析与评估、明确监管部门职责与工具、把握金融部门与实体经济的相互影响以及协调审慎政策与货币财政政策的相互关系方面,为后危机时代中国建立宏观审慎与微观审慎紧密结合的监管框架体系提供借鉴。
     本文的不足之处在于:由于金融危机尚未结束,对于银行系统性风险的识别、测度和相应资本监管问题的研究仍在深入中,无论从研究数据还是研究方法上均存在较大的改进空间,此外,论文所建立的DSGE理论模型还较为简单,在提高系统的复杂性和与实际经济特征一致性方面还有待进一步深入,所提出的分析方法、框架和政策建议仍有待于在实践中进行检验。
The recent financial crisis since2008has motivated researchers to reflect on thedrawback in the area of the financial regulatory policies. One important lesson of thecrisis is that micro-prudential supervision and capital regulation which is focused onsingle bank institution risk can not effectively safeguard the stability of the bankingsystem. Moreover inflation target monetary policy may not guard against systemicrisk and lead controversial topic in the research. Implementation of Basel III in2010has guide China bank capital regulation from focus on micro-financial risk to acombination of both macro-and micro-prudential regulation. In this circumstance howto measure the systemic risk contribution of bank institution in China, how to identifythe macro-system level of credit financing and cumulative risk, and how to build thecapital regulation tools based on systemic risk and measure the welfare loss that thenew regulatory capital regulation on macroeconomic volatility. And last how tobalance and coordinate this policy with monetary policy. All these important questionsare not only theoretical but practical issues and important to China’s financialregulation and macro-prudential policy framework design. It is also of significance tothe coordination of prudential capital policy and monetary policy in macro adjustmentprocess.
     In this context, from the point strengthening macro-prudential supervision, westudy the design and practical application of bank capital regulation based on systemicrisk, and its macroeconomic effects based on theoretical and empirical research. Thestructure of the study consists of three parts: the first part is to measure the banksystemic risk and design capital regulation. It includes two aspects according to thecross-sectional dimension and time dimension of systemic risk. On the one hand, westudy the evaluation framework for systemic important banks and the design ofsystemic capital surcharge, on the other hand we establish a macro-systemic riskindex framework for counter-cyclical capital regulation and study on the applicationand design of countercyclical regulation tools. The second part is a DSGE model to study the macroeconomic effect of the capital regulation which is based on systemicrisk. In a general equilibrium framework we measure the macroeconomic cost andwelfare effect of both increasing capital regulation and implementing countercyclicalcapital regulation. The third section is to discuss the trade-offs and coordinationproblems of optimal monetary policy and macro-prudential capital regulation, abouttheir relationship of the two policies as well as the effect under differentmacroeconomic circumstances. This paper is divided into the following aspects:
     1、we measure and rank the systemically important banks in China and build thecapital surcharge based on its systemic contribution. Considering the direct andindirect effect of risk contagion, we use both financial network analysis based onbalance sheet data, and CoVaR method based on market data to calculate the systemiccontribution and risk contagion effect of domestic banks. We also establish acomprehensive framework to evaluate63banks systemic risk contribution accordingto six types of indicators which include assets, system correlation, complexity,homogeneity and cross-border activity. Based on this calculation we divided the63banks into highly systemic banks, partial systemic banks, non-systemic large banks,and tiny banks. Our calculation provide quantitative basis for the capital surcharge ofsystemic banks.
     2. We study the pro-cyclical effect of bank capital in China’s banking industryand the corresponding design of counter-cyclical capital regulation framework.Counter-cyclical bank capital regulation is the core content of the macro-prudentialsupervision. However, it is a difficult problem about how to accurately determine theeconomic cycle and identify the characteristics, level and trend of macro systemicrisks, and also difficult about the timing and extent to implement counter-cyclicalregulation. Based on pro-cyclical effect analysis of our banking system, we build amulti-level and multi-dimensional macro-systemic risk framework to reflect thewhole credit level of our society and financial system, and also as indicator index forcounter-cyclical capital regulation. As for the identification of systemic risk status andits shift trend, the paper introduces Markov regime switching model to identify andanalyze the cycle and to determine the timing and extent of counter-cyclical capital provision. Our research provide the quantitative support for systemic riskidentification and counter-cyclical capital regulation.
     3. We establish a DSGE model which includes bank capital accelerator effect andfinancial accelerator effect to analyze the macroeconomic cost of capital regulationbased on systemic risk. By constructing a new Keynes DSGE model with bank capitaleffect and financial accelerator effect, we analyze the macroeconomic impact andinfluence of increasing regulatory capital and implementing countercyclical regulation.Our discuss is around three core issues: Firstly, what is the effect and mechanismabout the bank capital channel of the monetary policy transmission? Secondly, howare the shocks and influences to macroeconomic variables when increasing bankcapital regulation? Thirdly, whether the countercyclical capital regulation playing astabilizing role in real economic fluctuations. By theory and calibration analysis, wemake in-depth study about the role of bank capital to whole credit and the realeconomy, and provide theoretical and empirical study about how to implement bothmacro-prudential policy and monetary policy.
     4. Based on DSGE model we also study the relationship and coordination of bothmonetary policy and macro-prudential policy. In a unified framework we comparestress test results under different macroeconomic situation and compare the welfareloss under different combination of the two policies, so as to evaluate the sensitivityof policy parameters and its economic impact. Our in-depth study about therelationship between monetary policy and counter-cyclical capital is meaningful tounderstand the order, objective and economic effect of the two policies.
     5. We review US, Europe and UK etc bank regulatory reform acts, compare theirmacro-prudential framework and sum up reforms in systemic risk regulation. Wesuggest to improve macro-prudential supervision, strengthen systemic risk assessment,assure authorities’ regulatory responsibilities and tools, and value the coordinationbetween economy and finance sector and between monetary and macro-prudentialpolicy.
     As the financial crisis in not yet over, the identification measure and capitalregulation of bank systemic risk is still under discussion. There is large room for improvement in research data and methods. Moreover, the DSGE model we use issimple and can be improved in its complexity to accord with actual economy.Meanwhile, the research methodology and policy suggestion need to be tested inpractice.
引文
[1].Angelini P.,Neri S. and Panetta F. Grafting Macro-prudential Policies in a MacroeconomicFramewok Choice of Optimal Instruments and Interaction with Monetary Policy.
    [2].Angelini P. Maresca G. Russo D. Systemic Risk in the Netting System1996
    [3].Angeloni I. and Faia E. Capital Regulation and Monetary Policy with Fragile Banks.2010
    [4]. Angeloni I. and Faia E. A Tale of Two Policies Prudential Regulation and Monetary Policywith Fragile Banks.2009
    [5].Angelini P., Neri S., Panetta F. Monetary and Macro-prudential Policies.2010
    [6]. Alfred Lehar. Measuring Systemic Risk: A Risk Management Approach[J]. Journal ofBanking and Finance2004.09pp1-26
    [7]. Aliaga-Diaz R., Olivero M. and Powell A. The Macroeconomic Effects of Anti-Cyclical BankCapital Requirements Latin America as a Case Study.2011.04
    [8]. Aguiar,A. and I.Diumond. Monetary Policy Amplification Effects through a Bank CapitalChannel. Money Macro and Finance Research Group Conference.2006
    [9]. Antipa P. Mengus E. and Mojon B. Would macro-prudential policy have prevented the GreatRecession? Banque de France mimeo.2011
    [10]. Alvaro Aguiar, Ines Drumond. Business Cycle and Bank Capital: Monetary PolicyTransmission under the Basel Accords[R]. FEP Working Papers242, Universidade do Porto,Faculdade de Economia do Porto,2007
    [11]. Arturo Estrella. The Cyclical Behavior of Optimal Bank Capital[J]. Journal of Banking andFinance2001,(4):1469-1498
    [12]. Allen, F. and D. Gale. Financial Contagion[J]. Journal of Political Economy,2000.108(1), pp1-33
    [13].Acharya Viral V., Pedersen, Philippon and Richardson. ATax on Systemic Risk[J].
    [14]. Acharya Viral V., Lasse H. Pedersen, Thomas Philippon and Matthew Richardson.Measuring Systemic Risk[J]. Working Paper.
    [15]. Acharya Viral V. A Theory of Systemic Risk and Design of Prudential Bank Regulation[J].Journal of Financial Stabiliy.2009.05pp224-255
    [16]. Blien U, Grae F. Entropieoptimi Erungsverfahren In Der Empirischen Wirtschaftsforschung(Entropy Optimization in Empirical Economic Research)[J]. Jahrbuch fur Nationalokonomieund Statistik,208,4:399-413.
    [17]. Boss,Michael, Helmut Elsinger, Martin Summer, and Stefan Thurner. Network Topology ofthe interbank market[J]. Quantitative Finance,2004, Vol.4, No.6pp677-684
    [18]. Baeerll,R.,Davis,E.P.,KarimD. and Liadze,I. Calibrating macroprudential policy.2010.09
    [19]. Bernanke, B.and A.Blinder. Credit Money and Aggregate Demand[J]. American EconomicReview1988,78(2):435-439
    [20]. Brownlees. Engle. Volatility, Correlation and Tails for Systemic Risk Measurement.2010.05
    [21]. Brunnermeier, Markus, Andrew Corckett, Charles Goodhart, Avinash D. Persaud and HyunShin. The fundamental principles of financial regulation. Geneva Reports on the WordEconomy-Preliminary Conference Draft, International center for monetary and banking studies,2009
    [22]. Blavarg M, Nimander P. Interbank Exposures and Systemic Risk[J]. Economic Review,2002,2:19-45
    [23]. Beau, D., Clerc, L. and Mojon B. Macro-prudential Policy and the Conduct of MonetaryPolicy. Working Paper.2012
    [24]. Bernanke, B.S.,M. Gertler and S.Gilchrist. The Financial Accelerator in a QuantitativeBusiness Cycle Framework. Handbook of Macroeconomics,1999.01. pp1341-1393
    [25]. Bernanke, B., and M. Gertler. Should Central Banks Respond to Movements in AssetPrices?[J]. American Economic Review.2001.05pp:253-257
    [26]. Bernanke, B.S. Financial Reform to Addressing Systemic Risk. Remarks at the Council onForeign Relations.2009.03
    [27]. Benigo, Gianluca, Huigang Chen, Christopher Otrok and Eric Young. Monetary andMacro-prudential policies an integrated analysis.2011
    [28]. Bernanke, Ben(2010) Monetary Policy and the Housing Bubble. Remarks at theAmericanEconomicAssociation meetings January3, Atlanta, GA
    [29]. BIS. Basel III: A Global Regulatory Framework for more Resilient Banks and BankingSystems. BIS Committee on Banking Supervision.2011
    [30]. BIS. Macroprudential policy and addressing procyclicality. BISAnnual Report.2010
    [31]. Borio, C., Furine C. and Lowe,P. Procyclicality of Financial System and Financial Stability:Issues and Policy Options. BIS Working Papers No1.,2001pp:1-57
    [32]. Borio,C., Furine C. Towards a Macro-prudential Framework for Financial Supervision andRegulation? CESifo Economic Studies, vol49, No.2,2003pp:181-216
    [33]. Borio,C. and Shim, I. What Can Prudential Policy do to Support Monetary Policy? BISWorking Papers.2007, No.242
    [34]. Borio,C. The Macroprudential Approach to Regulation and Supervision.2009
    [35]. Brunnermeier, M. Crockett, A., Goodhart, C., Persaud A.D. and Shin, H.,2009. Thefundamental principles of financial regulation, International Center for Monetary and BankingStudies, Geneva, Switzerland.
    [36]. Brunnermeier, M. and Y.Sannikov. AMacroeconomic Model with a Financial Sector. Mimeo.Princeton University.2009.11
    [37]. Blum,J. and Hellwig, M. The Macroeconomic Implications of Capital AdequacyRequirements for Banks[J]. European Economic Review.1995Vol.51
    [38]. Benes,J. and Kumhof, M. Risky Bank Lending and Optimal Macro-Prudential Regulation.IMF Working Paper.2011.
    [39]. BCBS. The Transmission Channels Between the Financial and Real Sectors: A CriticalSurvey of the Literature. BIS Working
    [40]. Caruana, J. The International Policy Response to Financial Crises: Making theMacroprudential Approach Operational. Panel Remarks Jackson Hole.2009.08
    [41]. Christensen I., Meh C. and Moran K. Bank Leverage Regulation and MacroeconomicDynamics.2011.08
    [42]. Christensen, Ian, Cesaire Meh and Kevin Moran. On the Equivalence of Capital Adequacyand Monetary Policy. Mimeo.2010
    [43]. Christiano,L.J., Motto, R. and Rostagno, M. Financial Factors in Business Cycles. EuropeanCentral Bank Working Paper Series.2010No.1192
    [44]. Christiano,L.,M.Eichenbaum and C.Evans. Nominal Rigidities and the Dynamic Effects of aShock to Monetary Policy[J]. Journal of Political Economy.2005.Vol.113(1),pp1-46
    [45]. Césaire Meh, Kevin Moran, The Role of Bank Capital in the Propagation of Shocks[R].Working Papers, Bank of Canada,2008-36
    [46]. Chan-Lau, J. et al. Network Analysis as a Tool to Assess Cross Border Financial Linkages.IMF Working Paper
    [47]. Cecchetti S. and Kohler M.,2010,“On the equivalence of capital adequacy and monetarypolicy”, BIS mimeo
    [48]. Collard F., Dellas H, Diba B, Loisel O. Macro-prudential policies and optimal monetarypolicy.2012.4
    [49]. C.Lim, F.Columba, A.Costa, P.Kongsamut, A.Otani. Macroprudential Policy WhatInstruments and How to Use Them? Lessons from Countrry Experience. IMF Working Paper.2011.10.
    [50]. Canuto, Otaviano. How Complementary are Prudential Regulation and Monetary Policy.Econoic Premise No.60.
    [51]. Curdia, Vasco, and Michael Woodford. Conventional and Unconventional Monetary Policy.Mimeo.2009
    [52]. Committee on the Global Financial System. Macroprudential indicator project. CGFSMeeting,2009.09
    [53]. Calvo, G(1983). A. Staggered Prices in a Utility-Maximizing Framework[J]. Journal ofMonetary Economics. Vol.12
    [54]. Chami, R. and T Cosimano(2001). Monetary policy with a touch of Basel. IMF Workingpaper.
    [55]. Degryse H, and Nguyen G. Interbank Exposures An Empirical Examination of Systemic Riskin the Belgian Banking System[J]. The International Journal of Central Banking2004,3:123-172
    [56]. Dilip K.Patro, Min Qi, Xian Sun “ASimple Indicator of Systemic Risk”[J].2010.03
    [57]. Demyanyk, Otto Van Hemert. Understanding the subprime mortgage crisis[R]. FederalReserve Bank of Chicago,2008,(5):171-192
    [58]. Dilip K.Patro, Min Qi, Xian Sun “ASimple Indicator of Systemic Risk”[J].2010.03
    [59]. Demirguc-Kunt, Asli&Detragiache, Enrica,1999."Monitoring banking sector fragility: amultivariate logit approach with an application to the1996-97banking crises," Policy ResearchWorking Paper Series2085, The World Bank.
    [60]. Elsinger H, Lehar A and Summer M. A New Approach to Assessing the Risk of InterbankLoans[R]. OeNB Financial Stability Report3,2002:75-86
    [61]. E.Faia and T. Monacelli. Optimal Interest Rate Rules, Asset Prices and Credit Frictions[J].Journal of Economic Dynamics and Conrol. pp2007.31
    [62]. Furfine C. Interbank Exposures: Quantifying the risk of contagion[J]. Journal of MoneyCredit and Banking,2003,35:111-128
    [63]. FSA(Financial Services Authority). The Turner Review:Aregulatory response to the globalbanking crisis.
    [64]. FSA(Financial Services Authority). Report of the Financial Stability Forum on AddressingProcyclicality in the Financial System.
    [65]. Gai, Kapadia “Contagion in financial networks”Bank of England working paper2010
    [66]. Gauthier, Lehar, Souissi(2010)“Macroprudential capital requirements and systemic risk”2010.06
    [67]. G20. Guidance to assess the systemic importance of financial institutions markets andinstruments: initial considerations.2009
    [68]. G20. Enhancing Sound Regulation and strengthening Transparency.2009
    [69]. G30. Financial Reform: AFramework for Financial Stability.2009
    [70]. Gray, Dale F., Robert C Merton, and Zvi Bodie. New framework for measuring andmanaging macrofinancial risk and financial stability” Working Paper2008. No.09-015(Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard Business School, August)
    [71]. Gerali,A.,S. Neri, L.Sessa and F.M.Signoretti. Credit and banking in a DSGE model. Bank ofItaly, mimeo.2008.
    [72]. Gerali, A., S. Neri, and F. M. Sessa, Luca Signoretti. Credit and Banking in a DSGE modelof the EuroArea[J]. Journal of Money, Credit and Banking.2010.42(S1).pp107-141
    [73]. Gertler, Mark and Karadi, P. A Model of Unconventional Monetary Policy. New YorkUniversity. Working Paper.
    [74]. Gertler, Mark and Nobuhiro Kiyotaki. Financial Intermediation and Credit Policy inBusiness CycleAnalysis. Mimeo.2009
    [75]. Goodfriend, M. and B.T. McCallum. Banking and Interest Rates in Monetary PolicyAnalysis: AQuantitative Exploration[J]. Journal of Monetary Economics.200754(5).
    [76]. Hyunduk Suh. Evaluating Macro-prudential Policy from Operational Perspectives.2012.08
    [77]. Hyunduk Suh. Evaluating Macro-prudential Policy with Financial Friction DSGE model2011.4
    [78]. Hyunduk Suh. Simple Implementable Optimal Macro-prudential Policy.2011.6WorkingPaper.
    [79]. Huang, Zhou and Zhu. A Framework for Assessing the Systemic Risk of Major FinancialInstitutions[J]. Journal of Banking and Finance33(11),2009, pp2036-2049
    [80]. Humphrey D.B. Payments Finality and Risk of Settlement Failure1996
    [81]. Hesse, Heiko, and Miguel Segoviano. Distress Dependence, Tail Risk and Regime Changes.IMF Working Paper, forthcoming
    [82]. Hanson S., Kashyap K, Stein J. A Macro-prudential Approach to Financial Regulation.2010.07
    [83]. Iacoviello,M. and Neri S. Housing Market Spillovers: Evidence from an Estimated DSGEModel. Banca d’Italia Discussion papers.2008. No.659
    [84]. Iacoviello,M. House Prices, Borrowing Constraints and Monetary Policy in the BusinessCycle[J]. American Economic Review.2005,95(3). pp739-764
    [85]. Illing, Mark and Ying Liu. Measuring Financial Stress in a Developed Country: AnApplication to Canada[J]. Journal of Financial Stability.2006.Vol.2, No3. pp243-265
    [86]. IMF. Lessons of the Financial Crisis for Future Regulation of Financial Institutions andMarkets and for Liquidity Management[R].2009
    [87]. IMF Global Financial Stability Report2008.10,2009.04,2010.04
    [88]. IMF Financial Soundness Indecators Complication Guide.2006
    [89]. Juan Ayuso, Daniel Perez, Jesus Saurina. Are capital buffers pro-cyclical? Evidence fromSpanish panel data[J]. Journal of Financial Intermediation2004,(4):249-264
    [90]. Jaap Bikker, Paul Metze. Is bank capital procyclical? A cross-country analysis[R]. DNBWorking paper009, Netherlands Central Bank, Research Department
    [91]. Jeanette Muller. Two approached to assess contagion in the interbank market. Swiss NationalBank Discussion paper.2003.12(23)
    [92]. Jorge A. Chan-Lau. Balance sheet network analysis of too-connected-to-fail risk in globaland domestic banking system. IMF working paper2010
    [93]. Jean Charles Rochet, Jean Tirole. Interbank lending and systemic risk[J]. Journal of MoneyCredit and Banking, Vol.281996,11
    [94]. Jerman, U. and Quadrini,E. Macroeconomic Effects of Financial Shocks. NBER WorkingPaper.2009No.15338
    [95]. Kaminsky, G. and Reinhart, C.,“On crisis contagion and confusion” Journal of internationaleconomics, vol.51,2000
    [96]. Kannan, P.,P. Rabanal, and A.Scott,2009,“Monetary and macroprudential policy rules in amodel with house price booms” IMF working paper.2009.11
    [97]. Kiyotaki, N. and Gertler, M. Financial Intermediation and Credit Policy in Business CycleAnalysis. Handbook of Monetary
    [98]. Kiyotaki, N. and J. Moore(1997).Credit Cycles[J]. Journal of Political Economy, Vol.105(2),211-48
    [99]. L. Zicchino, O. Aspachs, C. Goodhart, M. Segoviano, D. Tsomocos. Searching for a Metricfor Financial Stability[R]. OFRC Working Papers Series, Oxford Financial Research Centre,2006,(9)
    [100]. Liu Guangling and Seeiso N(2011). Business Cycle and Bank Capital Regulation: Basel IIProcyclicality. Working Paper.
    [101]. Macroeconomic Assessment Group,2010,“Assessing the macroeconomic impact of thetransition to stronger capital and liquidity requirements” Group established by Financial Stabilityboard and the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision
    [102] Mervi Toivanen. Financial Interlinkages and Risk of Contagion in the Finnish InterbankMarket[J]. University of Vaasa Working papers
    [103]. Michiel Bijlsma, Jeroen Klomp and Sijmen Duineveld. Systemic Risk in the FinancialSector–AReview and Synthesis[J]. Working Paper. No.210
    [104] Mistrulli, Paolo Emilio. Assessing Financial Contagion in the Interbank Market: MaximumEntropy Versus Observed Interbank Lending Patterns. Bank of Italy’s Working Paper641
    [105]. N’Diaye,P. Countercyclical Macro prudential in a supporting role to monetary policy.2009.IMF Working paper
    [106] Nier E, Yang J, Yorulmazer Y and Alentorn A. Network Models and Financial Stability[J].Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control,31:2033-2060
    [107]. Prescott, E.C. Theory Ahead of Business Cycle Measurement[J]. Federal Reserve Bank ofMinneapolis Quarterly Review.1986.10pp9-22
    [108]. Quint,D.,Rabanal, P.,2011,“Monetary policy and macroprudential policy in an estimatedDSGE model of the Euro area” IMF working paper.
    [109]. Rungporn Roengpitya, Phurichai Rungcharoenkitkul. Measuring Systemic Risk andFinancial Linkages in the Thai Banking System IMF working paper2009.10
    [110]. Ralph Chami, Thomas F. Cosimano. Monetary Policy with a Touch of Basel[R]. IMFWorking Papers2001,01/151
    [111]. Raphael Douady.“A Non-cyclical capital adequacy rule and the aversion of systemic risk”SSRN working paper2009.12
    [112]. Satty, T.L. TheAnalytic Hierarchy Process[M]. NewYork. McGraw Hill.1980
    [113]. Smets, F. and Wouters, R. An Estimated Dynamic Stochastic General Equilibrium Model ofthe Euro Area[J]. Journal of the European EconomicAssociation.2003.01(05)
    [114]. S.J.Hanson, A. K. Kashyap, and J.C.Stein. A Mcro-prudential Approach to FinancialRegulation[J]. Journal of Economic Perspectives.2011.25. pp3-28
    [115]. Tobias Adrian, Markus K.Brunnermeier.“CoVaR” mimeo,http://www.princeton.edu/%7Emarkus/research/papers/CoVaR.pdf2009.08
    [116]. Tanaka, Misa, How Do Bank Capital and Capital Adequacy Regulation Affect the MonetaryTransmission Mechanism?[R]. CESifo Working Paper Series,2002
    [117]. Terhi Jokippi, Alistair Milne. The Cyclical Behavior of European Bank Capital Buffers[R].Bank of Finland Discussion Paper No.2006.17
    [118]. Tarashev, N., Borio, C., Tsatsaronis, K. Allocating Systemic Risk to Individual Institutionsmethodology and policy applications. BIS working papers2009.09
    [119]. Tarashev, N., Borio, C., Tsatsaronis, K. The Systemic Importance of Financial Institutions.BIS Quarterly Review2010.09
    [120]. Upper C and Worms A. Estimating Bilateral Exposures in the German Interbank Market: Isthere a Danger of Contagion?[J]. European Economic Review,2004,48:827-849
    [121]. Van den Heuvel, Skander J. The Welfare Cost of Bank Capital Requirements[J]. Journal ofMonetary Economics,2008(3):298-320
    [122]. VanHoose, D. Bank Behavior Under Capital Regulation What does the Academic LiteratureTell us? NFI Working Paper.2006.07
    [123]. Wells S. Financial Interlinkages in the United Kindom’s Interbank Market and the Risk ofContagion[J]. Bank of England Working paper, No.230,2004
    [124]. Woodford, M. Interest and prices foundations of a theory of monetary policy[M]. PrincetonUniversity Press.2003.
    [125]. Walque,G., Pierrard, O. and Rouabah A. Financial Stability Supervision and LiquidityInjections a DSGE Approach[J]. The Economic Journal.2010.12
    [126]. Zhang Longme(i2010).Bank Capital Lending Channel and Business Cycles. IMF WorkingPaper
    [127].巴曙松、王璟怡、杜婧.从微观审慎到宏观审慎:危机下的银行监管启示[J].国际金融研究2010.5:83-88
    [128].巴曙松、朱元倩等著.巴塞尔协议III研究[M].中国金融出版社2011
    [129].陈颖、李楠、陈敏.后危机时代银行资本结构的新安排[J].新金融2012.1:42-47
    [130].陈军系统重要性金融机构评估标准的构建[J].西部金融2012.1:69-73
    [131].范小云、王道平、方意.我国金融机构的系统性风险贡献测度和监管[J].南开经济研究2011.4:3-18
    [132].范小云、王道平.巴塞尔III在监管理论与框架上的改进:微观与宏观审慎有机结合[J].国际金融研究2012.1:63-70
    [133].范小云著.繁荣的背后[M].中国金融出版社2006
    [134].范小云、曹元涛中国金融改革中的金融安全与风险控制[M].中国金融出版社2008
    [135].范小云、曹元涛、胡博态银行系统性风险测度最新研究比较[J].金融博览2006.3
    [136].冯科中国宏观金融风险预警系统构建研究[J].南方金融.2010.12
    [137].方芳、刘鹏.中国金融顺周期效应的经济学分析[J].国际贸易问题2010
    [138].高国华、潘英丽我国商业银行资本充足率顺周期效应研究[J].经济与管理研究,2010.12
    [139].高国华、潘英丽基于资产负债表关联的银行系统性风险研究[J].管理工程学报,2012.04
    [140].高国华逆周期资本监管框架下的宏观系统性风险度量与风险识别研究[J].国际金融研究,2013.03
    [141].高国华、潘英丽银行系统性风险度量——基于动态CoVaR方法的分析[J].上海交通大学学报(自然科学版),2011.12
    [142].高国华、潘英丽基于DCC模型的上市银行系统风险实证研究上海管理科学[J].2011.2
    [143].高国华基于动态相关性的我国银行系统性风险度量研究[J].管理评论,2013.01
    [144].高志勇.系统性风险与宏观审慎监管——基于美国银行业的实证研究[J].2010.05pp12-18
    [145].高铁梅计量经济分析方法与建模[M].清华大学出版社2006
    [146]郭晨、宋清华宏观经济变量冲击与我国银行间市场风险传染[J].湖北经济学院学报2010.05pp36-43
    [147].龚明华、宋彤.关于系统性风险识别方法的研究[J].国际金融研究2010.5:90-96
    [148].侯荣华、张洋、李峰.银行资本与货币政策关系研究述评[J].经济学动态2010.5:116-121
    [149].黄宪、熊启跃.银行资本约束下货币政策传导机理的“扭曲”效应[J].经济学动态2010
    [150].黄聪、贾彦东.金融网络视角下的宏观审慎管理[J].金融研究2010.4:1-14
    [151].黄宪、王露璐、马理、代军勋.货币政策操作需要考虑银行资本监管吗[J].金融研究2012.4:17-29
    [152].黄宪、王露璐反思金融危机中的巴塞尔协议——基于金融理论界长期批判的跟踪[J].国际金融研究2009.9
    [153].黄亭亭著.宏观审慎监管操作框架研究[M].中国金融出版社2011
    [154].贾彦东.金融机构的系统重要性分析——金融网络中的系统风险衡量与成本分担[J].金融研究2011.10:17-32
    [155].江曙霞、何建勇.银行资本、银行信贷与宏观经济波动——基于C-C模型的影响机理分析的拓展研究[J].金融研究2011.05
    [156].金陶玲.新一轮国际金融监管体制改革的核心[J].比较.
    [157].李扬、全先银.危机背景下的全球金融监管改革:分析评价及对中国的启示[J].中国金融.2011:14-17
    [158].李妍.系统性风险与宏观审慎监管[D].对外经贸大学博士论文
    [159].李文泓、吴祖鸿.自救安排及其在我国的应用[J].中国金融.2011.6:50-54
    [160].李文泓.关于宏观审慎监管框架下逆周期政策的探讨[J].金融研究2009.7:7-24
    [161].李文泓、罗猛.关于我国商业银行资本充足率顺周期性的实证研究[J].金融研究,2010(2):147-157
    [162].李文泓.宏观审慎监管框架下的逆周期政策研究[M].中国金融出版社2010
    [163].李楠、汪翀.关于巴塞尔协议规避银行系统危机的有效性研究[J].国际金融研究2012.1:54-61
    [164].刘斌.资本充足率对我国贷款和经济影响的实证研究[J].金融研究,2005,(11):18-31
    [165].刘春航、朱元倩.银行业系统性风险度量框架的研究[J].金融研究2011.12:85-114
    [166].刘胜会基于通胀和稳定的多目标宏观审慎政策框架[J].金融与经济.2011.08
    [167].马君潞、范小云、曹元涛中国银行间市场双边传染的风险估测及其系统性特征分析[J].经济研究2007,01:68-78
    [168].麦强盛、刘洪波.基于宏观审慎的金融监管指标体系构建研究[J].金融教育研究2011.6
    [169].毛奉君系统重要性金融机构监管问题研究[J].国际金融研究2011.9:78-84
    [170].苗永旺、王亮亮.金融系统性风险与宏观审慎监管[J].国际金融研究2010.8:59-68
    [171].彭建刚、钟海、李关政.对巴塞尔新资本协议亲周期效应缓释机制的改进[J].2010.9:184-197
    [172].祈斌.美国金融监管改革法案:历程、内容、影响和借鉴[J].金融发展评论.2010.9:30-43
    [173].仝冰(2010).货币、利率与资产价格——基于DSGE模型的分析与预测[D].北京大学博士论文
    [174].汤柳、王旭祥(2012)后危机时代国际金融监管改革动态:回顾、评价与展望[J].上海金融2012.7:58-63
    [175].谭洪涛、蔡利、蔡春.金融稳定监管视角下的系统性风险研究述评[J].经济学动态2011.10:137-142
    [176].王力伟.宏观审慎监管研究的最新进展:从理论基础到政策工具[J].国际金融研究2010.11:62-72
    [177].王胜邦、陈颖.新资本协议内部评级法对宏观经济运行的影响:亲经济周期效应研究[J].金融研究,2008,(05):48-63
    [178].王立勇、张良贵、刘文革(2012)不同粘性条件下金融加速器效应的经验研究[J].经济研究2012.10:69-81
    [179].王靖国(2011)顺周期行为机制下的系统性金融风险:理论与实证分析[D].财政部财政科学研究所博士论文
    [180].谢平、邹传伟.金融危机后有关金融监管改革的理论综述[J].金融研究2010.2:1-16
    [181].许伟、陈斌开.银行信贷与中国经济波动:1993-2005[J].经济学季刊2009.4
    [182].徐明东.资本充足率约束与银行资产组合行为及其宏观经济效应[D].复旦大学博士论文
    [183].徐超.系统重要性金融机构识别方法综述[J].国际金融研究2011.11:57-64
    [184].徐慧玲、许传华.金融风险预警模型述评[J].经济学动态2010.11:131-134
    [185].叶永刚、张培.中国金融监管指标体系构建研究[J].金融研究.2009.04
    [186].张晓朴.系统性金融风险研究:演进、成因与监管[J].国际金融研究2010.7:58-67
    [187].钟伟、谢婷迷途难返——货币政策与金融监管新走向[M].中国经济出版社2011
    [188].钟伟、谢婷.巴塞尔协议III的新近进展及其影响初探[J].国际金融研究2011.3:46-55
    [189].张强、冯超.金融危机后我国上市商业银行系统性风险测算[J].上海金融2010.12:32-35
    [190].张健华、贾彦东.宏观审慎政策的理论与实践进展[J].金融研究.2012.1:20-35
    [191].张显球著.宏观审慎监管:理论含义及政策选择[M].中国金融出版社2012
    [192].周炎、陈昆亭利差、准备金率与货币增速——量化货币政策效率的均衡分析[J].经济研究2012.3:22-34
    [193].周炎、陈昆亭金融经济周期模型拟合中国经济的效果检验[J].管理世界2012.6:17-29
    [194].周源.宏观审慎政策与货币政策目标协作研究[J].上海金融.2011.08
    [195].中国银行国际金融研究所课题组.美国金融监管改革对全球金融市场的影响及中国的风险[J].国际金融研究2010.9:79-87
    [196].吴培新.以货币政策和宏观审慎监管应对资产价格泡沫[J].国际金融研究2011.05
    [197].连玉君、彭方平、苏治.融资约束与流动性管理行为[J].金融研究2010.10

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700