用户名: 密码: 验证码:
企业慈善捐赠行为与税收政策关系的研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
很多研究都发现公司慈善捐赠支出与税收政策密切相关,这些研究虽然指出公司捐赠行为与政策之间存在一定的关系,但各个国家税收法律制度的不同以及企业自身传统观念的差别使得税收的影响程度在不同国家和地区之间存在明显的差异。本研究运用理论分析和实证研究的方法,着重研究我国现行税收法律制度对公司捐赠行为的影响,为政策的优化指明方向。
     我国作为新兴市场国家,企业的行为与发达国家和其他一些国家的企业相比,存在一定的差异。在本文中,我们将借鉴前人研究的思想方法,对中国企业在慈善捐赠行为过程中对于税收政策的敏感性进行分析。企业的慈善捐赠可以看作是支出(或消费),也可以看作是需求(获得某种自身满足的一项需求)。而企业慈善捐赠的价格可以定义为企业每进行一个单位的慈善实际需要付出的金额。可以算出,当企业所得税率为t时,每单位捐赠在无税情况下的支出成本为1;在可全部税前扣除的情况下的成本为1-t;在可部份税前扣除的情况下的支出成本为1-μ*t(μ为可扣除比例),这种支出通常被称之为慈善捐赠的税收价格,由于目前我国在企业所得税税法中还制定了较多的税收优惠政策,企业的实际所得税税收负担率与名义税收负担率之间还有较大的差异,因此我们用企业慈善捐赠的税收价格=1-企业的所得税实际税负率来进行计算,其中企业的所得税实际税负率=企业实际缴纳的所得税税额/企业的利润额。实证分析部分通过对企业发放调查表收集了414户企业的数据,同时还采用了企业在税务部门的申报信息,具体指标包括企业的销售收入、利润总额、资产、负债、慈善捐赠支出等,选取828户无锡地区的企业在2003-2009年间的数据(其中部分数据有缺项,但不影响回归处理),处理方法上采用最小二乘法进行回归分析,通过对各种指标的回归计算对比,筛选出较优的回归模型,我们还从中筛选39户数据较完整的企业,采用固定效应模型进行分析,并将回归结果与前一方法得出的结论进行了对比验证。
     我国企业的慈善捐赠与国家税收政策之间存在一定的相关度,但与国外相比相关度还较低。不同企业的反应行为存在差异,对于企业捐赠行为,我国的税收政策总体上应当给与一定的鼓励。原因是,第一中国幅员辽阔,地区之间的发展不平衡,在经济欠发达地区,政府的财力有限,难以处理好所有社会问题,需要企业和社会各方面力量的共同投入。第二目前我国的很多企业还处于起步阶段,在其发展初期,企业的实力不强,参与社会公益事业的能力有限,需要国家在政策上给予支持。第三企业在自已熟悉的领域参于社会公益活动可以节省社会交易成本,促进社会资源的有效配置,提高全社会的经济效益和社会效益。但是社会公益事业不应当只看作企业的责任,税收优惠应当是有限度的,对税收抵免政策的实施必须加强管理和审查,防止个别企业借机偷逃税款。
A lot of researches had discovered that the corporation's charitable giving has a close relationship with tax policy. But when we consider this problem in different countries, there are different legal systems of tax revenue in different country and the corporation's action may become quit different and this leads to the result that the tax policy has a distinct different influence between countries. In this research, we try to set up a model of relationship between the corporation's charitable giving and tax policy in China.
     As one of the emerging market economics, the company in China is quit different compared with other countries. In the paper, we focus to the problem of sensitive of the Chinese corporation to the change of tax policy. Corporate charitable giving can be both looked as expenditure (consume) and a kind of demand. The tax price of corporation's charitable giving is been defined as the amount of payment when corporate donates one yuan and if the corporation's income tax rate is t, it equals 1—μ*t(hereμrepresents the deductible rate).In China, there are many preferential policies in the income tax law of corporation, the actual tax rate is quite different from nominal tax rate so we should use the expression of tax price=1-μ*the actual income tax rate of corporation,where the actual income tax rate equals the income tax divides the profit of corporation. We use the declared information in tax department which include index of the sales income,total profit, assets, liabilities, charitable giving of 828 corporate and the time period is from 2003 to 2009. Through the compare of different regression model, we choose the best that coincide with the data. To show clearly the difference in different corporation's action, we also use the reasonably complete data of 39 corporations and use fix effect model to deal with this problem. The result of different data simulation had been compared accordingly.
     The corporate charitable giving has some relationship to tax policy in China, but comparing with advanced countries, it is relatively lower. The tax policy should give more incentive to the corporate charitable giving in China for two reasons:Firstly, China was vast in territory and it's social and economic development is quit unbalanced in different areas and the government can not solve all the problem of the society, the corporation can deal with their familiar area to save social cost and to get efficient disposal of resources. Secondly, the corporation's ability is quiet limited in China and their charitable activities should be encouraged by policy support. From the government point of view, we should also pointed out that the tax preferential policy should be regulated to avoid of the use of the preferential item for the evasion of tax by some companies.
引文
戴维·罗根,企业:定义及其关键特征,华夏出版社,2002,P4
    James Allen Smith.The Evolving American Foundation,Philanthropy and the Nonprofit Sector in a Changing America,Indiana University Press.1999.P37
    翰.埃尔金顿,茧经济—通向“企业公民”模式的企业转型,上海人民出版社,2005,P2
    ①Carroll. A.B. Corporate social Responsibility:Evolution of a Definitional Construct. Business and Society 1999. 38(3):268-295.Carroll,A. B.A three-dimensional conceptual model of corporate social performance. Academy of Management Review,1979(4):497-505.
    ②Collins,M. Global corporate philanthropy and relationship marketing. European Management Journal. 1994(12):226-233.Collins, M. Global-Corporate philanthropy:Marketing beyond the call of duty? European Journal of Marketing,1993,27(2):46-58.
    杨团,葛道顺.公司与社会公益Ⅱ,北京:社会科学文献出版社,2003,P106
    ④Caroil.Cone.Mark A.Feldman:Alison T.Dasilva.Causes and Effeets.Harvard Business Review.July 2003:95-101
    ⑤Roger Martin,The virtue Matrix:Calculating the Return on corporate Responsibility. Harvard Business Review, 2002(3):69-75
    Michael E.Porter corporate philanthropy:Taking the High Ground. New York City. May 14,2003. www.fsg-impact.org/ideas/item/304
    (?)米尔顿.弗里德曼.资本主义与自由.商务印书5馆,1986.第8章
    密尔顿·弗里德曼,弗里德曼文萃,北京经济学院出版社,1991,P125
    Michael E. Porter and M R. Kramer The competitive Advantage of corporate philanthropy Harvard Business Review December.2002:57-68
    加里.贝克尔.人类行为的经济分析.上海三联出版社,1993.P63
    Harbough.W. What do Donations Buy? A Model of Philanthropy Based on Prestige and Warm Gow. Journal of Public Economics.pp.269-284.1998
    ②姚俭建Janet Collins美国慈善事业的现状分析:一种比较视角,上海交通大学学报(哲社版)2003(1)
    Andreoni.J. An experimental test of the public goods:crowding-out hypothesis. American Economic Review 83:1317-1327.1993
    Sonnemans.J..A.Schram and T.Offeitglan. Strategic behavior in public good games:when partners drift apart.Economics Letters 62:35-41.1999
    Comes R.Sandier T. The theory of externalities,public goods and club goods. Cambridge University Press. Cambridge. UK.1986
    Steinberg.Richard. Voluntary Donations and Public Expenditures in a Federalist System. March 1987.pp.24-36
    ① Olson Mancur, The Logic of Collective Action, Harvard:Harvard University Press,1965
    ② Becker.Gary S,A theory of social interactions. Journal of Politics Economy.vol.82, pp.1063,1974
    ③D.Kreps and R.Wilson. Reputation and Imperfect Information. Journal of Economic Theory.27(2):253-279.1982
    ④Webster, fredrick E.Jr. Determining the Characteristics of the Socially Conscious Consumer. Journal of Consumer Research.2:188-196.1983
    ⑤Michael E Porter, Mark R Krainer. The competitive advantage of corporate philanthropy Harvard Business Review.2002(12):57-68
    Stephen Brammer. Andrew Millington. Corporate Reputation and philanthropy:An empirical analysis. Journal of Business Ethics.2005.61:29-44
    Campbell L. C S Gulas. T S Gruca. Corporate giving behaviour and decision-maker social consciousness. Journal of Bussiness Ethics.1999.19(4):375-383 Edmondson V C. A B Carroll.Giving back:An examination of the philanthropic motivations, orientations and activities of large black owned businesses. Journal of Bussiness Ethics,1999.19(2):171-179.Sanchez C M. Cowton C J. Corporate philanthropy in the U.K.. Journal of Bussiness Ethics.1987.6(7):553-558. Motives for corporate philanthropy in El Salvador. Altruism and Political Legitimacy.2000.27:363-376
    Andreoni J.Impure altruism and donations to public goods:A theory of warm-glow giving Economic Journal,1990,100:464-477
    Neiheisel S R. Corporate Strategy and the Politics of Goodwill.A Political Analysis of Corporate Philanthropy in America. New York:Peter Lang Publishing Inc..1994
    Haley U C V. Corporate contributions as managerial masques:Reframing corporate contributions as strategies to influence society. Journal of Management Studies,1991.28(5):485-509.
    Arulampalam W. P Stoneham. An investigation into the givings by large corporate donors to U.K. charities. 1979-1986. Applied Economics,1995.27:935-945
    Charles T Clotfelter. The economics of giving [EB/OL] July.2002. http://fds.duke.edu/db/Sanford/faculty/charles.clotfelter
    Grahn,J.L..Hannaford,W..I..& Laverty.K.J Corporate philanthropy and marketing strategy. A review and directions for research in AMA educators proceeding(Series53).Chicago:American Marketing Association.1987
    Marx.J.D.. Corporate philanthropy:What is the strategy? Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly,1999,28(2)185-198
    Johnson.O. Corporate Philanthropy:An analysis of corporate contributions. Journal of Business,1966.39:489-504
    Mark. S.Leolair,Kelly. Cordon.Corporate support for artistic and culture activities "What determines the contribution of corporate giving? Journal of Cultural Economics.2000.24:225-241
    Griffin. J.J.,Mathon. J.F. The Corporate social performance and corporate financial performance debate: Twenty-five years of incomparable research. Business and Society,1997.36(1)
    Bruce Seifert. Sara A. Morris. Barbara R. Bartkus. Comparing big givers and small givers:Financial correlates of corporate philanthropy. Journal of Business Ethics,2003,12(7):195-211
    Pamela Greene,Robert Mccelland. Taxes and Charitable giving. National Tax Journal,2001,3:433-454
    Useem. M. Market and institutional forces in corporate contributions. California Management Review,1988. 30(2).77-88
    Stephen Brammer. Andrew Millington. Firm size, organizational visibility and corporate philanthropy:an empirical analysis. Business Ethics:A European Review.2006.6-18
    David Campbell. Richard Slack. Public visibility as a determinant of the rate of corporate charitable donations. Business Ethics:A European Review,2006.19-28
    Schwartz R A. Corporate philanthropic contributions. Journal of Finance,1968.22:479-497
    Levy F.Shatto G M. The evaluation of corporate contributions. Public Choice,1979,33:19-28
    Kedia.B.L., Kuntx. E.C. The context of social performance:an empirical study of Texas banks. Research in corporate social performance and policy. Greeenwich. CT:JA1.1981,88
    McElory.K.M., Siegfried,J.J, The effect of firm size on corporate philanthropy. Quarterly Review of Economics and Business,1985.25(2).18-26
    Matin,S.A. An Essential Grace,Toronto:McClelland Stewart,1985.211.
    Lerner, L.D..& Fryxell,G.E. CEO stakeholder attitudes and corporate social activity in the Fortune 500. Business & Society,1994.33(1)
    Campbell.L. C.S. Gulas.T.S. Gruca. Corporate giving behavior and decision-maker social consciousness[J]. Journal of Business Ethics.1999.19(4):375:383
    Atkinson. L..& Galaskiewicz. J. Stock ownership and company contributions to charity. Administrative Science Quarterly..1988.33
    Thompson.J.K., Hood. J.N. The practice of corporate social performance in minority vs. nonminority-owned small business. Journal of Business Ethics,1993.12(3)
    Wang. J..Coffey. B.S.Board composition and corporate philanthropy. Journal of Business Ethics,1992,11(10)
    Eric Helland. Janet Kiholm Smith. An analysis of corporate philanthropic practice [EB/OL]. http://fei.claremontmckenna.edu/papers/pdf/2004-03.pdf
    Christopher Marquis. Maryann Glynn. Gerald F. Davis. Community isomorphism and corporate social action[EB/OL]. http://www.people.hbs.edu/cmarquis/marquis glynndavis AMR forthcoming.pdf.2007.3
    1胡俊坤,我国公益救济性捐赠扣除政策存在的问题及改进意见,涉外税务,2001(9),P65
    ②Robert Murray Haig. The Concept of Income-Economic and Legal Aspects. The Federal Income Tax.New York: Columbia University Press.1921.P59
    Henry C. Simons. Personal Income Taxation:The Definition of Income as a Problem of Fiscal Policy. University of Chicago Press. 1938.P597
    Boris I. Bittker. "The Propriety and Vitality of a Federal Income Tax Deduction for Private Philanthropy" in Tax Impacts on Philanthropy Symposium Conducted by the Tax Institute of America. December P2-3,1971
    同上
    Richard Goode. "The Individual Income Tax". University of British Columbia Press:Revised edition. Jul 11 2005. pp.65
    法利克劳斯:美国慈善事业中公司的作用,马伊里,杨团:公司与社会公益,华夏出版社,2002.10,P83
    E. Blake Bromley. Charity. Philanthropy and Stewardship:A Philosophical Perspective on Tax Reform.(1988)7:2 Philanthropy. P12.http://www.ohlj.ca/archive/articles/42_1_duff.pdf.
    Neil Brooks. The Tax Credit and Charitable Contributions:Giving Credit where None is Due in Phillips. Chapman & Stevens.at 464.from David G. Duff,Tax Treatment of Charitable Contributions in Canada:Theory. Practice and Reform.http://www.ohlj.ca/archive/articles/42_1_duff.pdf
    John D. Colombo. The Marketing of Philanthropy and the Charitable Contributions Deduction:Integrating Fheories for the Deduction and Tax Exemption. Wake Forest Law Review.36(2001).pp.677
    刘亚莉,公司捐赠税收优惠制度研究,安徽大学法律评论,2007(02)
    Reece. William S. Charitable Contributions:New Evidence on Household Behavior. American Economic Review:Mar1979.vol.69 Issue 1.p142-151
    Raimondo. Henry J. Federal Tax Policy and Charitable Giving(Book Review).Southern Economic Journal. Jul 86.vol.53:294. Issue 1
    Randolph. William C. Dynamic Income. Progressive Taxes.and the Timing of Charitable Contributions. Journal of Political Economy:Aug 95.vol.103:709. Issue 4
    Day. K.M., and R.A. Devlin. Do Government Expendures Crowd Out Corporate Contributions. Public Finance Review 32:404,2004
    Clotfelter. Federal Tax Policy and Charitable Giving.University of Chicago Press. Chicago.1985
    Katarina Svitkova. Essays on Philanthropy Katarina Svitkova. Dissertation. January 2007
    张怡超,论公司慈善捐赠中的利益冲突与平衡,兰州商学院学报,2006(3)
    张莉、脱剑锋,公司捐赠的法律激励与约束,兰州大学学报(社会科学版),2004(2),P125-128
    刘敏,试论公司捐赠行为的法律约束机制,南方经济,2004(7),P2729
    吴勇敏、竺效,公司捐赠行为的法理剖析,浙江学刊,2001(1),P143-147
    吴勇敏、竺效,论公益捐赠行为的法律性质,浙江大学学报(人文社会科学版),2001,(4):132-139
    古小东,公司捐赠行为的法律规制,当代法学,2003(5),P123-125
    钟骏华、梅玲,企业捐赠及接受捐赠的会计处理及纳税调整新探[J],现代会计,2004(6),P20-21
    金未,企业捐赠的会计处理及纳税诘整,福建金融管理干部学院学报,2005(1),P25-29
    彭海颖,浅淡企业捐赠活动中的纳税筹划,浙江万里学院学报,2004(5),P122-124
    柴重光,肖妍,企业捐赠行为的所得税会计处理,天津经济,2004(3)
    茹长云,关于企业捐赠支出扣除标准问题的思考,河北审计,2001(7),P37-38
    靳东升,非政府组织所得税政策的国际比较,涉外税务,2004(10)
    ⑦庄梅兰,中外企业捐赠模式比较研究,鞍山科技大学学报,2006(4)
    ⑧马小勇、许琳,慈善行为的经济学分析西北大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2001(11)
    ⑨黄桂香、黄华清,税收政策影响慈善捐赠行为的经济学分析价格月刊 2008(2)
    ①任浩、陈子丰、徐雪松,企业慈善捐赠行为的经济学分析,当代财经,2007(12)
    ②黄国良,非营利组织赞助者募款认知之研究:田野调查与多评准决策理论之应用[EB/OL].http://140.117.77.69/pam_org/journal/review_2nd/2_3.doc
    ③田雪莹、蔡宁,企业慈善捐赠行为研究,基于上海企业的实证分析,科技进步与对策,2009(10)
    ④黄营杉,齐德彰.企业伦理、社会责任与公益作为之研究,人文暨社会科学期刊,2005(2),P65-82
    ⑤葛道顺,企业捐赠的理念和行为调查报告(北京),社会保障与社会政策系列总第三集(1),2003(8)
    ⑤何汇江,慈善捐赠的动机与行为激励,商丘师范学院学报,2006(6)
    ①曹洪彬,我国捐赠的公共经济学分析,中国经济学年会论文(2006)
    ②许婷,上市公司慈善捐赠影响因素实证研究—以2006年上市公司慈善排行榜为例市场周刊(理论研究),2008(12)
    ③陈宏辉、王鹏飞,企业慈善捐赠行为影响因素的实证分析,当代经济管理2010(8)
    杨团、葛道顺,企业与社会公益Ⅱ,北京社会科学文献出版社,2000
    李立清 企业社会责任评价理论与实证研究:以湖南省为例南方经济2006年第1期
    ①徐雪松:论企业慈善捐赠的十大动因世界经济文汇,2006年第6期
    [1]Andreoni J. Impure altruism and donations to public goods:A theory of warm-glow giving [J]. Economic Journal,1990,100:464-477.
    [2]Archie.B.Carroll. A Three-Dimensional Conceptual Model of Corporate Social Performance, Academy of Management Review[J],1979,4:4.
    [3]Archie.B.Carroll. Business Society:Ethics and Stakeholder Management,3rd ed[M]. Cincinnati,Ohio:South-Western Publishing Company,1996:37.
    [4]Arulampalam W, P Stoneham. An investigation into the givings by large corporate donors to U. K. charrities[J]. Applied Economics,1995,27:935-945.
    [5]Atkinson, L.,& Galaskiewicz, J. Stock ownership and company contributions to charity. Administrative Science Quarterly[J],1988,33.
    [6]Aupperle, K.E., A.B.Carroll, and J.D.Hatfield. An Empirical Examination of the Relationship between Corporate Social Responsibility and Profitability[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 1985,28(2):446-463.
    [7]Benabou,R.and Tirole, J.,Incentives and Prosocial Behavior[J]. American Economic Review,2006:1652-1678.
    [9]Boatsman, J.R. and S.Gupta. Taxes and Corporate Charity:Evidence from Micro-Level Panel Data[J]. National Tax Journal,1996,49(2):193-213.
    [10]Broman, Amy J. Statutory tax rate reform and charitable contributions:Evidence from a recent period ofreform[J]. The Journal of the American Taxation Association,1989,11(1):7-20.
    [11]Brown W., Helland E, and Smith J. Corporate Philanthropic Practices[J]. Journal of Corporate Finance.2006:855-877.
    [12]Bruce Seifert, SaraA. Morris, Barbara R. Bartkus. Comparing big givers and small givers: Financial correlates of corporate philanthropy[J]. Journal of Business Ethics,2003,12(7):195-211.
    [13]Campbell L, C S Gulas, T S Gruca. Corporate giving behaviour and decision-maker social consciousness[J]. Journal of Bussiness Ethics,1999,19(4):375-383.
    [14]Carrigan M. The Great Corporate Give-away—Can Marketing Do Good for the Do Gooders[J]. European Business Journal,1997,9 (4).
    [15]C.Eugene Steuerle. Charitable contributions, In How taxes affect economic behavior[M], eds. Henry J.Aaron and Joseph A. Pechman,, Washington, D.C.:Brookings Institution,1981.
    [16]Charles.T.Clotfelter. The economics of giving [EB/OL]. July,2002. http://www.pubpol.duke.edu/people/faculty/clotfelter/giving.pdf. [14]Cornell B.and A.C.Shapiro, Corporate Stakeholders and Corporate Finance[J]. Financial Management,1987,16(1):5-14.
    [17]Chrisman,JJ,&Carroll,A.B. Corporate Responsibility—Reconciling Economic and Social Goals[J]. Sloan Management Review,1984,25 (2)
    [18]Chrisman, J.J,&Carroll, A.B. Corporate Responsibility—Reconciling Economic and Social Goals[J]. Sloan Management Review,1984,25 (2)
    [19]Chritian, Charles W., and James R. Boatsman. Cross-sectional price elasticity estimates of the charitable contributions deduction[J]. Advances in Taxation,1990,3:45-66
    [20]Christian, Charles W., James R. Boastsman, and J. Hal Reneau. The interpretation of econometric estimates of the tax incentive to engage in philanthropy[J]. The Journal of the American Taxation Association,1990,12(1):7-17.
    [21]Christopher Marquis, Mary Ann Glynn, Gerald F Davis.Community isomorphism and corporate social action [EB/OL]. http://www.peopje.hbs.edu/cmarquis/marquis glyno davis amr forthcoming.pdf.
    [22]Clotfeler, Charles T. Federal T. Federal Tax Policy and Charitable Giving. Chicago[M], University of Chicago Press,1985.
    [23]Clotfelter, Charles T., Tax incentives and charitable giving:Evidence from a panel of Taxpayers[J]. Journal of Public Economics,1980.6(13):319-40.
    [24]Cowton C J. Corporate philanthropy in the U.K[J]. Journal of Bussiness Ethics,1987,6(1):553-558.
    [25]Craig Smith. The New Pattern of Corporate Philanthropy[J]. Harvard Business Review.1994, May-June.
    [26]Dali Ma, William L.Parish.Tocqueville Moments:Charitable Contributions by Chinese Private Entrepreneurs[J], Social Forces,2006(85).
    [27]David Campbell, Richard Slack. Public visibility as a determinant of the rate of corporate charitable donations[J]. Business Ethic:A European Review,2006:19-28
    [28]Devid Logan, Delwin Roy, Laurie Regelbrugge. Global corporate citizenship-Rationale and strategies[M], published by the Hitachi foundation.1997.
    [29]Edmonson V C, A B Carroll. Giving back:An examination of the philanthropic motivations, orientations and activities of large blackowned businesses[J], Journal of Bussiness Ethics,1999,19(2):171-179.
    [30]Edwin M Epstein,&Dow Votaw. Rationality, Legitimacy, Responsibility:Search for New Directions in Businessand Society[M]. Snata, Monica, CA:Goodyear Publishing Co,1978
    [31]Eiko Ibuki. Innovations in Corporate Philanthropy:Adopting Balanced Scorecard Methodologies to Build Strategy and Evaluation Systems[D]. Nomura Research Institute Papers,2001,38:1-13.
    [32]Eric Helland, Janet Kiholm Smith. An analysis of corporate philanthropic practices[EB/OL]. http://fei.claremontmckenna.edu/papers/pdf/2004-03.pdf.
    [33]Feeberg, Daniel. Are tax price models really identified:the case of charitable giving[J]. National Tax Journal,1987(45), no.3:267-290..
    [34]Feenberg, Daniel. Identification in tax-price regression models:The case of charitable giving[J]. National Bureau of Economic Research working paper,1982, no.988
    [35]Feldstein, Martin, The income tax and charitable contributions:Part Ⅰ-Aggregates and distributional effects[J]. National Tax Journal,1975, vol.28:81-100.
    [36]File, K.M,& Prince, R.A. Cause Related Marketing and Corporate Philanthropy in the Privately Held Enterprise[J]. Journal of Business Ethics,1998 (17).
    [37]Fombrun,C,& Shanley,M. What's in a Name? Reputation Building and Corporate Strategy[J]. Academy of Management Journal,1990, (33).
    [38]Freeman, R.E., Business Ethics[M]. Oxford University Press, New York,1991.
    [39]Friedman, M., Freedom and Philanthropy (An interview)[J]. Business and Society Review,1989, (71)Fall:11-21.
    [40]Friedman, M.. The Methodology of Positive Economics[M]. Mcmillan Publishing Inc.. New York,1968.
    [41]Friedman M. The social responsibility of business is to increase its profit[J]. New York Times Magazine,1970,(9):12126.
    [42]Galaskiewicz J. Contributions to charity:Nothing more than a marketing strategy, Philanthropic Giving:Studies in varieties and goals.1989:246-260.
    [43]George Balabanis, Hugh C. Phillips, Jonathan Lyall. Corporate social responsibility and economic performance in the top British companies:are they linked?[J] European Business Review; 1998,vol.98 Issue:1.
    [44]Gerald E Auten, Holger Sieg, Charles T Clotfelter. Charitable giving, income, and taxes:An analysis of panel data[J]. The American Economic Review; Mar 2002,92(1):371.
    [45]Gerald Vinten. The Charity:Pivotal Social Policy Role[J]. International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy; 1994, vol.14 Issue:3/4/5.
    [46]Godfrey,P.C.,The Relationship between Corporate Philanthropy Shareholder Wealth:A Risk Management Perspective[J]. Academy of Management Review,2005,30(4):777-798.
    [47]Hagan,& Harvey. Why do Companies Sponsor Arts Events? Some Evidence and a Proposed Lassification[J]. Journal of Cultural Economics,2000(24)
    [48]Haley U C V. Corporate contributions as managerial masques:Reframing corporate contributions as strategies to influence society[J]. Journal of Management Studies,1991, 28(5):485-509.
    [49]James D Werbel, Suzanne M Carter. The CEO's influence on corporate foundation giving[J]. Journal of Bussiness Ethics,2002,40:47-60.
    [50]John V Kania. Benchmarking philanthropy, FSG perspectives on corporate philanthropy [EB/OL].http://fsgimpactor.web 133.discountasp.net.
    [51]Johnson, Orace and Walter L. Johnson. Comment-The Elasticity of Corporate Philanthropy[J], Journal of Finance, March,1970:149-152.
    [52]Johnson, Orace. Corporate philanthropy:An Analysis of Corporate Contributions[J]. Journal of business, October,1966:489-504.
    [53]Jos van lwaarden. Ton van der Wiele, Roger Williams, Claire Moxham Charities:how important is performance to donors?[J] International Journal of Quality & Reliability Management, 2009,vol.26 Issue:1.
    [54]Karen Pittel. Dirk T.G. Rubbelke Private provision of public goods:incentives for donations[J]. Journal of Economic Studies,2006, vol.33. Issue:6;
    [55]Katarina Svitkova. Essays on Philanthropy[D]. Center for Economics Research and Graduate Education Charles University Prague, June 2007.
    [56]Keim G D, Corporate social responsibility:an assessment of the enlightened self interest model[J], Academy of Management Review,1978(1)
    [57]Keith Davis, Can Business Afford to Ignore Social Responsibilities?[M] California Management Review, Spring 1960:70.
    [58]Levy, Ferdinand K. and Gloria M. Shatto, The Evaluation of Corporate contributions[J], Public Choice,1978,33:19-28.
    [59]Logsdon, Reiner and Burke. Corporate Philanthropy:Strategic Responses to the Firms Stakeholders[J], Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector, Quarterly,1990(19).
    [60]Marcel van Marrewijk, Concepts and Definitions of CSR and Corporate Sustainability[J], Journal of Business Ethics,vol.44,2003.
    [61]Margolis, J.D. and J.P.Walsh. Misery loves companies:Rethinking Social Initiatives by Business, Administrative Science Quarterly,2003,48(2):268-305.
    [62]Mark.S.Leolair, Kelly. Cordon. Corporate support for artistic and cultural activities:What determines the distribution of corporate giving?[J]. Journal of Cultural economics. 2000,24:225-241
    [63]McElroy, Katherine Maddox and John J. Siegfried. The Community Influence on Corporate Contributions[J], Public Finance Quarterly,1986(October):394-414.
    [64]McElroy, Katherine Maddox and John J. Siegfried. The Effect of Firm Size on Corporate Philanthropy[J]. Quarterly Review of Economics and Business,1985 (Summer):18-24.
    [65]Mescon,T.S,&Tilson,D.J. Corporate Philanthropy:A Strategic Approach to the Bottom-line[J]. California Management Review,1987,29 (2).
    [66]Michael E Porter, Mark R Kramer. Philanthropys New Agenda:Creating Value. Harvard Business Review, November December,1999.
    [67]Michael E Porter, Mark R Krainer. The competitive advantage of corporate philanthropy[J]. Harvard Business Review,2002(12):57-68.
    [68]Morris and Biederman, How to give away money intelligently[J]. Harvard Business Review, 1985(11).
    [69]M. Todd Henderson Anup Malani. Corporate philanthropy and the market for altruism[J]. Columbia Law Review,2009, vol.109:571
    [70]Myrna Wulfson, The ethics of corporate social responsibility and philanthropy ventures. Journal business of ethics, Klower Academic Publish. Carnegie,2001.
    [71]Navarro, Peter, The Income Elasticity of Corporate Contributions[J]. Quarterly Review of Economics and Business,1988b (Winter):66-75.
    [72]Navarro, P., Why Do Corporations Give to Charity?[J]. Journal of Business,1988, 61(1):65-93.
    [73]Neiheisel, S.R., Corporate Strategy and the Politics of Goodwill:A Political Analysis of Corporate Philanthropy in America[M]. Peter Lang Publishing Inc., New York.1994.
    [74]Owen,D. English Philanthropy 1660-1960[M]. Oxford University Press and Harvard University Press, London and Cambridge, MA.1965.
    [75]Paine, L.S. Value Shift[M]. McGraw-Hill, New York,2002.
    [76]Pamela Greene, Robert McClelland. Taxes and charitable giving[J]. National Tax Journal, 2001,3:433-454.
    [77]Paul C Godfrey. The Relationship between Corporate Philanthropy and Shareholder Wealth:A Risk Management Perspective[J]. Academy of Management Review,2005,30 (4).
    [78]Pittman, Russell. The Effect of Industry Concentration and Regulation on Contributions in Three 1972 U.S. Senate Campaigns, Public Choice,1976,27,(Fall):71-80.
    [79]Porter, M.E. and M.R.Kramer. The Competitive Advantage of Corporate Philanthropy[J]. Harvard Business Review,2002,12:57-68.
    [80]Robinson, John R. Estimates of the price elasticity of charitable giving:A reappraisal using 1985 itemizer and nonitemizer charitable deduction data[J]. Journal of the American Taxation Association,1990.12, no.2:39-59.
    [81]Roger Bennett. Corporate philanthropy in France, Germany and the UK:International comparisons of commercial orientation towards company giving in European nations[J]. International Marketing Review,1998,vol.15 Issue:6.
    [82]Roger Martin. The Virtue Matrix:Calculating the Return on Corporate Responsibility[J]. Harvard Business Review,2002(3):69-75.
    [83]Rudney, Gabriel. Charitable deductions and tax reform:New evidence on giving behavior[J]. Tax Notes 1985 (January):367-68.
    [84]Sanchez C M. Motives for corporate philanthropy in El Salvador[J]. Altruism and Political Legitimacy,2000,27:363-376.
    [85]Schwartz, M.S. and A.B.Carroll.Corporate Social Responsibility:A Three-Domain Approach[J], Business Ethics 2003,Quarterly,13(4):503-530.
    [86]Schwartz, R.A. Corporate Philanthropic Contributions[J]. Journal of Finance, 1968(June):479-497.
    [87]Schwartz, R.A. The Income Elasticity of Corporate Philanthropy:Reply[J]. Journal of Finance,1970 (March):153-57.
    [88]Slemrod, Joel. Are estimated tax elasticities really just tax evasion elasticities? The case of charitable contributions[J]. National Bureau of Economic Research working paper no.2733(1988).
    [89]Smith, Craig. The New Corporate Philanthropy[J]..Harvard Business Review,1994,72 (5).
    [90]Steiner G A. Changing managerial philosophies[J]. Business Horizons,1971(1).
    [91]Stephen Brammer, Andrew Millington. Corporate Reputation and philanthropy:An empirical analysis[J],Journal of Business Ethics,2005,61:29-44.
    [92]Stephen Brammer, Andrew Millington. Firm size, organizational visibility and corporate philanthropy:an empirical analysis[EB/OL], http://fei.claremontmckenna.edu/papers.
    [93]Turban,D.B. and D.W.Greening. Corporate Social Performance and Organizational Attractiveness to Prospective Employees[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 1997,40(3):658-672.
    [94]USEEM M. Market and institutional factors in corporate contributions[J]. California Management Review,1988,30:77-88.
    [95]Waddock, S.A. and S.B.Graves. The Corporate Social Performance-financial Performance Link[J]. Strategic Management Journal,1997,18(4),303-319.1997(5):65-76.
    [96]Wang, Jia and Betty S. Coffey, Board Composition and Corporate Philanthropy[J]. Journal of Business Ethics,1992,11:771-778.
    [97]William A. Duncan and Robert W. Jamison JLTR. Contributions of S Corporation Debased Debt to Charity:Opportunities, Problems, and Policy Questions Abound with Double Dipping[J]. Journal of Legal Tax Research 2005,3:66-77.
    [98]Willams, R.J. and J.D.Barrett. Corporate Philanthropy,Criminal Activity, and Firm Reputation: Is There a Link?[J]. Journal of Business Ethics,2000,26(4):341-350.
    [99]Williamson, Oliver E. Managerial Discretion and business behavior, American Economic Review,53,1963(December):1032-1057.
    [100]Windsor,D. Corporate Social Responsibility:A theory of the Firm Perspective-Some Comments[J]. Academy of Management Review,2001,26(4):502-504.
    [101]Wood, D.J. and R.E.Jones. Stakeholder Mismatching:A Theoretical Problem in Empirical Research on Corporate Social Performance[J]. International Journal of Organizational Analysis 3(3),1995:229-267.
    [102]Young, D,& Burlingame, D. Paradigm Lost:Research toward a New Understanding of Corporate Philanthropy[A]. Burlingame and Young(eds.). Corporate Philanthropy at the Crossroads[C]. Indiana University Press,1996.
    [103]阿奇.B卡罗尔.企业与社会:伦理与利益相关者管理[M].北京:机械工业出版社,2004.
    [104]波斯特、劳伦斯、韦伯.企业与社会:公司战略、公共政策与伦理[M].北京:人民大学出版社,2005.
    [105]陈宏辉.战略性慈善捐赠探析[J].现代管理科学,2007(2).
    [106]陈支武.企业慈善捐助的理论分析与策略探讨[J].当代财经,2008(4):68-72.
    [107]陈成文.论社会慈善事业[J],理论与改革,2000(3).
    [108]陈瑞霞.浅析中国企业的慈善行为[J].中国发展,2006(1).
    [109]陈华荣,可持续发展战略管理研究[D].华中科技大学博士论文,2009(11).
    [110]曹洪彬.我国捐赠的公共经济学分析[D].厦门大学,2006.
    [111]蔡宁,沈奇泰松,吴结兵.经济理性、社会契约与制度规范:企业慈善动机问题研究综述与扩展[J].浙江大学学报(人文社会科学版),2009,39(2).
    [112]杜中臣.企业的社会责任及其实现方式[J].中国人民大学学报,2005(4)
    [113]菲利普·科特勒,南希.李[M].企业的社会责任,北京:机械工业出版社,2006.
    [114]樊丽明,郭健.国外社会捐赠税收政策效应研究述评[J].经济理论与经济管理,2008(7).
    [115]冯丽.公益、救济性捐赠的税收政策分析与税收筹划初探[J].经济视角,2009(2).
    [116]傅穹.公司转投资、保证、借贷、捐赠规则[J].中国政法大学学报,2004(5):67.
    [137]龚汝富.中国古代商人的善德观与慈善事业[J].江西财经大学学报,2002(4).
    [118]葛道顺.企业慈善捐赠的理念和行为调查报告[J].社会保障与社会政策系列
    [119]葛道顺.我国慈善事业的现状和发展对策[J].中国社会科学院院报,2005(3).
    [120]葛顺道.捐赠场域:跨国公司生产的基本路径[EB/OL]. http://www.sociology.cass.net.cn
    [121]甘碧群、曾伏娥.企业营销行为的道德感知与测度:消费者视角[J].管理世界,2004.
    [122]胡俊坤.完善我国公益救济性捐赠扣除政策[J].财政研究,2001(11).
    [123]胡胜军.我国慈善捐赠与慈善投资的现状与困境[J].集团经济研究,2006(14).
    [124]胡浩.基于改善竞争环境的跨国公司慈善行为研究[J].企业管理,2003(15).
    [125]贺立平.慈善行为的经济分析[J].北京科技大学学报社会科学版,2004,20(2).
    [126]黄丹,姚俭建.当代中国慈善事业发展的战略路径探讨[J].社会科学,2003(8).
    [127]黄营杉,齐德彰.企业伦理、社会责任与公益作为之研究[J].人文暨社会科学期刊,2005(2):65-82.
    [128]黄晨熹,周烨.社会福利政策导论(刘红译)[M].上海:华东理工大学出版社,2003.
    [129]何晔.论企业慈善行为的动机与演变[J].现代企业教育,2008(2).
    [130]贺立平.慈善行为的经济分析[J].北京科技大学学报(社会科学版),2004(2).
    [131]江希和.税收激励慈善行为的政策原则分析[J].生产力研究,2007(12).
    [132]江希和.我国企业慈善行为实践轨迹与现状分析[J].生产力研究,2008(7).
    [133]江若尘.企业思维模式的新趋势:企业利益相关者问题研究[J].商业经济与管理,2006(6).
    [134]罗公利,肖强.企业公益捐赠研究的回顾与展望[J].青岛科技大学学报(社会科学版),2006(4).
    [135]刘磊.企业捐赠的税务处理问题研究[J].税务研究,2006(1):85-88.
    [136]刘俊海.公司的社会责任[M].法律出版社,1999.
    [137]刘连煜.公司治理与公司社会责任[M].北京:中国政法大学出版社,2001.
    [138]刘磊,企业捐赠的税收处理问题研究[J].税务研究,2006(1).
    [139]刘亚莉,股份公司捐赠中的利益冲突与平衡[D].中国政法大学博士论文,2007(4).
    [140]李倩,企业公益性捐赠的税前扣除[J].工业技术经济,2010(3).
    [141]李淑英.社会契约理论视野中的企业社会责任[J].中国人民大学学报,2007(2).
    [142]李立清、李燕凌.企业社会责任研究[M].人民出版社,2005.
    [143]李丽萍,段淳林论民营企业的发展与企业的社会责任[J]海南大学学报人文社会科学版,2003(2).
    [144]李海舰、原磊.企业永续发展的制度安排[J].中国工业经济,2005(12).
    [145]兰花.论我国政府与慈善组织的互动关系[J].理论与现代化,2007(6).
    [146]黎友焕.企业社会责任在中国—广东企业社会责任建设前沿报告[M].华南理工大学出 版社,2007.
    [147]卢代富.国外企业社会责任界说评述[J].现代法学,2001(6).
    [148]卢代富.企业社会责任的经济学与法学分析[M].北京:法律出版社,2002.
    [149]刘京.中国慈善捐赠发展蓝皮书[M].北京:中国社会文献出版社,2008.
    [150]李骏.中国企业慈善的发展现状[J].社会观察,2005(9).
    [151]李立清.企业社会责任研究[M].北京:法律出版社,2002.
    [152]李亚平、于海.第三域的兴起[M].上海:复旦大学出版社,1998.
    [153]李敏、曾国军.跨国公司在华投资策略及中国企业的应对措施研究进展[J].管理世界,2004(8).
    [154]刘连煌.公司治理与公司社会责任[M].北京:中国政法大学出版社,2001.
    [155]刘澄、刘志伟、叶波.改进中国慈善捐赠的制度安排[J].国际经济评论,2006(3).
    [156]迈克尔·波特.竞争优势[M].北京:华夏出版社,1997.
    [157]迈克尔·波特,马克·克雷默,吴言译.企业慈善事业的竞争优势[J].哈佛商业评论,2003(2):40-55.
    [158]米尔顿·弗里德曼.资本主义与自由[M].商务印书馆,2004.
    [159]马伊里、杨团.公司与社会公益[M].北京:华夏出版社,2002.
    [160]马小勇、许琳.慈善行为的经济学分析[J].西北大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2001.
    [161]乔·马尔科尼.公益营销[M].北京:机械工业出版社,2005.
    [162]乔治·斯蒂纳、约翰·斯蒂纳.企业、政府与社会[M].华夏出版社2002.
    [163]齐良书:利他行为及其经济学意义[J],经济评论,2006(3)。
    [164]企业所得税改革工作小组,企业所得税法实施条例释义(连载三十二)[N].中国税务报,2008.8.18
    [164]任浩、徐雪松.从“自利”到“他利”:论企业慈善捐赠的十大动因[J].世界经济文汇,2006(6).
    [165]R.爱德华.弗里曼.战略管理:利益相关者方法[M].上海:上海译文出版社,2006.
    [166]苏.阿德金斯.善因营销:推动企业和公益事业共赢[M].北京:中国财经出版社,2006.
    [167]苏勇.现代管理伦理学—理论与企业的实践[M].石油工业出版社,2003.295
    [168]施星辉.企业公民—中国企业社会责任状况调查报告[J].中国企业家,2003(1).
    [169]施泰因曼、霍尔斯特.企业伦理学基础[M].上海:上海社会科学院出版社,2001.
    [170]孙辉,万启霞.我国税法对企业捐赠行为影响研究[J].经济问题探索,2008(2).
    [171]孙自愿、黄元元、朱学义,企业公益性捐赠的纳税筹划[J].企业管理,2008(12).
    [172]山立威、甘得梨、郑涛.公司捐赠与经济动机[J].经济研究,2008(11).
    [173]田利华、陈晓东.企业策略性捐赠行为研究:慈善投入的视角[J].中央财经大学学报,2007(2).
    [174]田中禾、魏敏.试论我国企业和个人向NPO捐赠的所得税优惠政策[J].科技管理研究,2006(12).
    [175]田雪莹、蔡宁.企业慈善捐赠行为研究-基于上海企业的实证分析研究[J].科技进步与对策,2009(10).
    [176]田雪莹,企业捐赠非营利组织的行为及竞争优势研究[D].浙江大学博士论文,2008(4).
    [177]托马斯.西尔克主编,亚洲公益事业及其法规[M].科学出版社,2000(1)第1版.
    [178]唐更华、王学力.企业慈善行为策略研究新进展[J].管理评论,2004(9):41-46.
    [179]唐更华、许卓云.西方策略性企业慈善行为理论、实践与方法评介[J].外国经济与管理,2005(9)
    [180]谭深.跨国公司的社会责任与中国社会[M].北京:中国政法大学出版社,2001.
    [181]王辉.从“企业依存”到“动态演化”—一个利益相关者理论文献的回顾与评述[J].经济管理,2003(10).
    [182]王粤.跨国公司与公益事业[M].北京:社会科学文献出版社,2005.
    [183]王红一.公司法功能与结构法社会学分析—公司立法问题研究[M],北京大学出版社,2002.
    [184]王卓祺、Alan·Walker西方社会政策理念与21世纪中国福利事业的发展-中国的第二次革命[M].商务印书馆,2001.
    [185]王妮丽.关于阻碍我国公益捐赠的因素分析[J].社会科学论坛:学术研究卷,2006(10).
    [186]王艳梅.公司社会责任的法理学研究[D].吉林大学,2005.
    [187]王大祥,几种捐赠方式的纳税分析[N].中国税务报,2008.6.2
    [188]吴伟,慈善捐赠、公共物品的自愿提供与非营利组织[J].财经理论与实践,2007(7).
    [189]魏学强,云霄,于洋;公司治理结构与企业捐赠——基于2008年度中国A股上市公司数 据的实证研究[J].中南财经政法大学研究生学报,2010(8).
    [190]西尔克.T.亚洲公益事业及其法规[M].北京:科学出版社,2000.
    [191]徐麟.中国慈善事业发展研究[M].北京:中国社会出版社,2005.
    [192]徐雪松.企业慈善行为研究[D].同济大学博士学位论文,2007.
    [193]徐雪松、任浩;企业公益行为与利益相关者管理的关系[J].现代经济探讨,2007(1).
    [194]袁秀梅.企业捐赠税收优惠研究[EB/OL].http://www.cftl.cn/,2006.8.28.
    [195]沃尔夫冈·查普夫.现代化与社会转型[M].社会科学文献出版社,1998.
    [196]叶航.利他行为的经济学解释[J].经济学家,2005(3).
    [197]杨团,葛道顺.公司与社会公益Ⅱ[C].北京:社会科学文献出版社,2003.
    [198]杨清荣.企业伦理与现代企业制度[M].武汉:湖北人民出版社,2000.
    [199]姚长辉,用足用好现行捐赠减免政策[N].中国财经报,2008.5.20
    [200]张向前.和谐社会企业公益活动管理研究[J].科技和产业,2006(11).
    [201]张传良,中外企业慈善捐赠状况对比调查[J].中国企业家,2005(17).
    [202]张莉,脱剑锋.公司捐赠的法律激励与约束[J].兰州大学学报(社会科学版),2004(2):125-128.
    [203]张彦宁,陈兰通.2007中国企业社会责任发展报告[R].北京:中国电力出版社,2008(1).
    [204]张建君、张志学.中国民营企业家的政治策略[J].管理世界,2005(7).
    [205]郑祝君.公司与社会的和谐发展—美国公司制度的理念变迁[J].法商研究,2004(4).
    [206]郑若娟.西方企业社会责任理论研究进展—基于概念演进的视角[J].国外社会科学,2006(2).
    [207]钟宏武.企业捐赠作用的综合解析[J].中国工业经济,2007(2).
    [208]钟宏武.正确看待慈善捐赠对企业的价值和作用[J].WTO经济导刊,2007(7).
    [209]中国企业家调查系统:企业家看社会责任—2007中国企业家成长与发展报告[M].机械工业出版社,2007.
    [210]中国税网涉税风险研究室:毛岚,赈灾捐赠案例:新闻回放和纳税分析[N].中国税务报,2008.6.30
    [211]朱为群.捐赠行为税收政策效应分析[J].财政研究,2002(04).
    [212]周丽梅.房地产商的社会公益活动投资[J].经济论坛,2004(11).
    [213]周晓虹:中国社会与中国研究[M].社会科学文献出版社,2004:238.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700