用户名: 密码: 验证码:
EPR制度下废旧家电回收主体的利益博弈与激励机制研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
我国是一个家电生产和消费大国。随着科技的快速发展和人民生活水平的不断提高,家电产品的更新周期日趋缩短,每年都有大量的家电产品淘汰报废。但目前我国废旧家电回收处理的整体水平很低,尚未建立起规范有效的回收处理体系及管理机制。因此,面对大量的废旧家电,如何实现废旧家电的无害化、资源化回收处理,促进循环经济发展,已成为社会经济发展中亟待解决的一个重大课题。
     为了提高资源的回收利用率和有效地保护环境,同时从源头控制废物的增长,在大多数经济合作与发展组织(OECD)国家都实施生产者责任延伸(EPR)制度。近年来我国也在积极探讨和制订基于EPR制度的有关法规和标准,以促进循环经济发展。本文正是在这样的背景下,较深入系统地研究了EPR制度下废旧家电回收主体的利益博弈与激励机制。重点关注参与废旧家电回收的主体(生产商、经销/零售商、消费者、回收企业、处理企业、政府)之间互动的关系如何?如何定量分析回收主体间的收益?主体之间的责任如何划分?如何建立有效的激励机制解决回收主体问的矛盾,提高EPR制度下实施废旧家电回收物流的积极性等问题。
     论文首先从国内外相关研究成果入手,梳理了与废旧家电回收处理模式、回收主体利益和回收激励机制相关的文献。指出了目前在EPR制度框架下对废旧家电回收体系、回收主体之间关系、处置责任分担以及对回收主体激励机制研究的不足,并提出本论文的研究内容和研究方案。
     国外发达国家回收处理废旧家电的先进经验值得我国借鉴,论文分别从政策立法、生产商责任、付费机制和管理部门几个方面对国内外废旧家电回收处理的现状进行了比较,指出我国废旧家电的回收处理亟需规范。在此基础上,以规范回收为前提,在家电制造商、专业处理企业以及行业联盟负责废旧家电处理三种模式下,考虑经销方式的不同和参与回收主体的不同情形,构建了回收处理所有可能的模型。并指出目前在国内外家电领域实施EPR制度时几种较为典型的模式:(1)生产商负责处理:分销情形下,生产商回收模式(MDC-CM)和分销商回收模式(MDC-CDM);直销情形下生产商回收模式(MC-CM);(2)专业处理企业负责处理:分销情形下第三方回收企业回收模式(MDC-C(TP)R)和专业处理企业回收模式(MDC-CR);(3)分销情形下行业联盟负责废旧家电回收处理(MDC-CA).
     合理界定各参与主体在废旧家电回收处置阶段应承担的责任在家电领域实施EPR制度至关重要。论文将主体在渠道中的利益分配比例与主体参与渠道的不同程度相对等,通过约束主体参与渠道的程度,构造了从0~1的各种程度合作关系的连续流。同时,用0-1选择表示生产商是将处理业务完全外包还是由自己完全处理。其次,针对MDC-CM、MDC-CDM、MC-CM、MDC-C(TP)R、MDC-CR、MDC-CA等几种较典型的模式,在一定的假设条件下,基于Stackelberg博弈理论,建立了能够兼容分销/直销和不同程度合作回收/处理的数学模型。定量分析了不同模式下参与主体之间的利益博弈关系;依据受益者负担和责权利对等原则界定了各参与主体在废旧家电回收处置阶段应承担的责任比例。然后,考虑到生产企业是实施EPR制度最直接和最关键的主体,引入了多维博弈理论,分析生产企业在积极、消极两种态度下实施EPR制度对其市场利益的影响。
     在前文定量分析结果的基础上,基于“以人为本”的理念、权变的思想,充分考虑参与回收主体的差异,通过经济因素和非经济因素对激励对象产生的心理和行为的影响,建立了生产商、分销商、消费者、回收企业和处理企业等参与回收主体的差异化激励机制。
     论文最后总结了本文的研究工作,指出了本文的主要创新之处,并对相关领域未来的研究进行了展望。
     本文的研究工作对我国废旧家电回收物流的规范发展将起到一定的促进作用,并提供了一些可以借鉴的思路和方法,具有重要的理论和实际应用价值。
China is a big country which produces and consumes a lot of household appliances. With the fast development of science and technology and increase of people's living standard, the updating period of household appliances has been reduced day by day and a large number of household appliances are deserted every year. However, the present overall standard of recycling the used household appliances is quite low. The standard and effective recycling system and management mechanism haven't been set up. Thus, in face of large numbers of used household appliances, how to recycle the used household appliances harmlessly and resourcefully and boost the development of circular economy has become a serious problem which needs to be solved in the development of society and economy.
     In order to improve the recycling of the resources and protect the environment effectively, and to control the increase of the waste in the source, EPR system (Extended Producer Responsibility) is carried out in most OECD (Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development) countries. In recent years China has been discussing and establishing relevant laws and rules based on EPR in order to boost the development of circular economy. Against this background, the dissertation studies interests game and incentive mechanism of the main body of recycling used household appliances under the system of EPR. The main focuses are as follows:How about the interactive relationship among the main bodies of recycling used household appliances (manufacturers, dealers or retailers, consumers, recycling enterprises, handling enterprises and government)? How to analyze the interests among the main recycling bodies quantitatively? How to divide the responsibility among the main bodies? How to establish the effective incentive mechanism to solve the contradiction among the main recycling bodies and improve the initiative of recycling used household appliances under the system of EPR.
     First, the dissertation reviews all the relevant literature home and abroad. It reviews the literature on the model of recycling used household appliances, the interests of main bodies and incentive mechanism of recycling. It points out the weakness in the study on the system of recycling used household appliances, the relationship among the main recycling bodies, the share of handling responsibility and the incentive system for the main recycling bodies. It also points out the research content and research method in the study.
     The advanced experiences of recycling used household appliances in advanced foreign countries should shed light on our country. The dissertation compares the different current situations of recycling used household appliances home and abroad from the perspective of policy stipulation, manufacturers' responsibility, paying mechanism and administrative institutions. It also points out that recycling used household appliances in China needs to be standardized urgently. Based on this, all the possible recycling models have been set up at the premise of standard recycling. These models are set up under three recycling models being in the charge of household appliances manufacturers, professional recycling enterprises and industrial alliance, considering different situations of sale ways and main recycling bodies concerned. Meanwhile, it points out three typical models under the system of EPR in the world:(1) manufacturers in charge of recycling:MDC-CM and MDC-CDM in the case of distribution; MC-CM in the case of direct sale; (2) professional recycling enterprises in charge of recycling:MDC-C(TP)R and MDC-CR in the case of distribution; (3) MDC-CA in the case of distribution.
     It is vital to define properly the responsibility of respective main bodies involved shared at the stage of recycling used household appliances in order to implement the system of EPR in the field of home appliances. The dissertation corresponds the interests allocation rate of the main bodies in the channels to the different extent of participation in the channels. The continuum of different cooperative relationship at different levels from 0 to 1 is set up through constraining the extent of the main bodies'participation in the channels. Meanwhile, the choice between 0 and 1 indicates whether the manufacturers outsource the recycling business or not. For such typical models as MDC-CM, MDC-CDM, MC-CM, MDC-C(TP)R, MDC-CR and MDC-CA, based on Stackelberg's Game Theory, the mathematic model which includes distribution, direct sale and different extent of recycling has been set up under certain assumptions. It analyzes quantitatively the interests game relationship among different main bodies concerned in different models. It also defines the responsibility rate shouldered by different main bodies in recycling used household appliances according to beneficiary-pay rule and the rule that responsibility, right and duty are equal to each other. At the same time, it illustrates the model of MDC-CDM. The result indicates that with the change of the main bodies in recycling used household appliances and the change of manufacturers'participation in the channels, the interests allocation rate among the main bodies, outer environment cost afforded and the responsibility rate in the recycling will change. However, considering the manufacturing enterprises are the most direct and critical enterprises in carrying out the system of EPR and the competition among the enterprises is multidimensional, it uses Multidimensional Game Theory to analyze the effects of EPR on manufacturing enterpeises'market interests with active and passive attitudes.
     On the basis of above results of quantitative analysis, the value of people first, the idea of rights change, and the differences of main bodies involved in recycling. Based on these and combined with the foregoing quantitative analysis results, differentiated incentive mechanism of such main recycling bodies as manufacturers, distributors, consumers, recycling enterprises and handling enterprises has been set up through analyzing the difference among different main recycling bodies and analyzing the psychological and behavioral effects of economic and noneconomic factors on the subjects motivated.
     Finally, it summarizes the research, points out the main innovation in the research and sheds light on the future research in the relevant field.
     The research results will promote the standard development of recycling logistics of used household appliances in China and provide some enlightening ideas and methods, thus they are significant in both theory and practice.
引文
[1]黄平沙,谭大鹏.国外废旧家用电子电器回收再利用研究[J].中国人口·资源与环境.2003,13(4):103-107
    [2]慕凡,胡春华,刘汉红,杨嵘.电子废物管理中生产者责任延伸制度及对策研究[J].科技进步与对策.2005,(2):57-59
    [3]守许.面向家电产品的逆向物流关键技术研究[D].合肥工业大学博士学位论文.2007:5-7
    [4]张友良.回收利用废电子电器利国利民[J].电子电器科技.2000,(7):14-15
    [5]林逢春,王钰.中国废旧电脑产生量预测及对策研究[J].上海环境科学.2003,(22):479-482
    [6]李金惠,温雪峰,刘彤宙等.我国电子电器废弃物处理政策、技术及设施[J].家电科技.2005,(1):31-34
    [7]邱胜鹏.国内电子废弃物处理现状[J].能源与环境.2006,(1):61-63
    [8]刘助仁.迎接电子垃圾的挑战[J].再生资源研究.2004,(4):6-8
    [9]陶学宗,钟雁.我国W EEE逆向物流的现状与对策分析[J].物流科技.2006,29(127):48-50.
    [10]L Savov,D J anke. Recycling of scrap in steel making in view of the tramp element problem. Metall,1998,52(6):374-383
    [11]Lindhqvist, T., and R. Lifset. Getting the Goal right:EPR and DfE[J]. Journal of Industrial Ecology.1998,2 (1):6-8
    [12]王兆华,尹建华.基于生产者责任延伸制度的我国电子废弃物管理研究[J].北京理工大学学报(社会科学版).2006,8(4):49-51
    [13]孙佑海.点评《固体废物污染环境防治法》细化责任明令回收城乡兼顾[J].有色金属再生与利用.2005,(5):30-31
    [14]史瑞琼,李霞.论废旧家电回收利用主体的责任—《废旧家电及电子产品回收处理管理条例》(征求意见稿)之评析[J].中国资源综合利用.2005,(4):29-31
    [15]C-H. Lee, C.T. Chang, S.L. Tsai. Development and implementation of producer responsibility recycling system [J]. Resources, conservation and recycling,1998,(24):121-135
    [16]王干.论我国生产者责任延伸制度的完善[J].现代法学.2006,28(4):167-173
    [17]滕吉艳,林逢春.电子废物立法及其实施效果国际比较[J].环境保护.2004,(11):10-14
    [18]王长琼.逆向物流[M].北京:中国物资出版社,2007:4-14
    [19]Stock J R. Reverse logistics [J]. Council of logistics management. Oak brook, IL,1992
    [20]柳键.供应链的逆向物流[J].商业经济与管理.2002,(6):11-13
    [21]Adam D. Read. "A weekly doorstep recycling collection, I had no idea we could!" Overcoming the local barriers to participation[J].Resources, Conservation and Recycling,1999,(26):217-249
    [22]Li-Hsing Shih. Reverse logistics system planning for recycling electrical Appliances and computers in Taiwan[J]. Resources, Conservation and Recycling,2001,(32):55-72
    [23]Catherine K. Lin, Linan Yan and Andrew N. Davis. Globalization, Extended producer responsibility and the problem of discarded computers in China: An exploratory proposal for environmental protection[M].Georgetown international environmental law review,2002:525-579
    [24]Thomas Lindhqvist, Reid Lifset. Can we take the concept of individual producer responsibility from theory to practice? [J]. Journal of industrial ecology.2003,(7):3-6
    [25]Frans Melissen. Designing Collection Rate Enhancing Measures for'Small' Consumer Electronics [D]. Technische Universiteit Eindhoven,2003.
    [26]A.J.Spieer, M.R.Johnson. Third-party demanufacturing as a solution for extended product responsibility[J]. Joural of Cleaner Production. 2004,(12):37-45.
    [27]V. Ravi, Ravi Shankar and M.K. Tiwari. Analyzing alternatives in reverse logistics for end-of-life computers:ANP and balanced scorecard approach [J].Computers & Industrial Engineering.2005,(48):327-356
    [28]Eric Masanet, Arpad Horvath.Assessing the benefits of design for recycling for plastics in electronics:A case study of computer enclosures [J].Materials and Design.2007,(28):1801-1811
    [29]魏洁.生产者责任延伸制下的企业回收逆向物流研究[D].西南交通大学博士学位论文,2006
    [30]范江华.逆向物流运作模式研究[J].物流科技.2004,(7):21-23
    [31]许民利,刘嘉.废旧家电产品逆向物流模式研究[J].生态经济.2007,(4):69-72
    [32]王发鸿,达庆利.电子行业再制造逆向物流模式选择决策分析[J].中国管理科学.2006,14(6):44-49
    [33]兰晖.废旧家电逆向物流体系研究[D].武汉理工大学.2006
    [34]李明.企业逆向物流运作模式初探[J].新选择.2006,(8):107
    [35]常香云,范体军,黄建业.基于“生产者责任延伸”的逆向物流管理模式[J].现代科学管理.2006,(5):35-37
    [36]张云里.我国废旧电子产品逆向物流联合回收模式的构建[D].沈阳工业大学硕士学位论文,2006
    [37]来清民,李金铭,高 霞.电子垃圾资源化和无害化的综合处理模式研制报告[J].河南教育学院学报(自然科学版).2006,15(1):1-5
    [38]杨永超.电子产品逆向物流运营模式研究[D].江西财经大学硕士学位论文.2007
    [39]贾扬蕾.家电企业逆向物流回收模式选择的关键因素分析[J].物流科技,2007,(7):20-22
    [40]Carsten Nagel.Take IT back-European approaches for setting up reverse logistics systems [J]. IEEE,1998:25-29
    [41]糜仲春,丙缅云.废旧家电回收的反向物流系统模型研究[J].科技进步与对策.2003,(10):68-69
    [42]姚卫新.电子商务环境下闭环供应链的原子模型研究[[J].管理科学.2003,(2):65-68
    [43]曾强银,王加宽,刘寒阳.逆向物流回收模式研究[[J].南京审计学院学报.2005,(2):76-78
    [44]徐剑,张云里,金玉然.废旧电子产品逆向物流模式的决策研究[J].物流科技.2006,29(128):14-16
    [45]靖麦玲.电子电器企业逆向物流的有效经营与控制研究[D].中国海洋大学硕士学位论文.2006
    [46]裴杰夫.上海久信物流发展废旧电子产品逆向物流的分析研究[D].上海海事大学硕士学位论文.2007
    [47]卢洁.废旧家电逆向物流模式的选择研究—从家电制造企业的视角[D].东南大学硕士学位论文.2007
    [48]刘健敏.我国废旧家电逆向物流回收机制探讨[J].物流科技,2008,(8):26-28
    [49]Carsten Nagel, Peter Meyer. Caught between ecology and economy: end-of-life aspects of environmentally conscious manufacturing [J]. Computers & industrial engineering,1999,(36):781-792
    [50]H.R.Krikke, A.van Harten and P.C.Schuur. Business case Roteb:recovery strategies for monitors [J]. Computers & industrial engineering,1999,(36): 739-757
    [51]Anna Nagurney, Fuminori Toyasaki. Reverse supply chain management and electronic waste recycling:a multi-tiered network equilibrium framework for e-cycling[J].Transportation Research Part E:Logistics and Transportation Review,2005,(41):1-28
    [52]Der-Horng Lee, Meng Dong. A heuristic approach to logistics network design for end-of-lease computer products recovery[J].Transportation Research Part E:Logistics and Transportation Review, In Press, Corrected Proof, Available online 12 February 2007
    [53]周垂日,梁棵,许传永.废旧电器的逆向物流规划模型研究[J].预测.2005,24(6):74-77
    [54]马祖军,代颖.产品回收逆向物流网络优化设计模型[J].管理工程学报.2005,(4):114-117
    [55]魏洁,李军,魏航.电子废物回收逆向物流模型研究[J].物流技术.2005,(1):28-30
    [56]张敏,李艳.论青岛废旧家电回收物流网络的建设[J].物流技术.2005,(5):19-22
    [57]徐剑,张云里,金玉然.废旧电子产品回收网络研究[J].物流科技.2005,28(115):56-59
    [58]韩雪冰,欧阳惠卿,朱向阳.OEM模式下电子废弃物逆向配送网络研究[J].机械与电子.2005,(10):3-6
    [59]曾敏刚,周明剑.废旧电脑的逆向物流优化模型与应用研究[J].工业工程.2006,(6):55-59
    [60]陈汇博.家电行业逆向物流网络构建[J].当代经济.2006,(7)下:51-52
    [61]胡筱沽.家电产品逆向物流模式研究[D].对外经济贸易大学硕士学位论文,2006
    [62]曾敏刚,徐禾芳.废旧电子类产品的逆向物流研究[J].科技管理研究.2006,(8):60-63
    [63]Jacob H, Joseph C, Michellel M, Chem N. Determinants of Recycling Behavior:A Synthesis of Research Results[J]. The Journal of Socio-Economics.1995,24(1):105-127
    [64]Zsolt Istvan, Garamvolgyi. Reverse logistics and management of end-of-life electric products[J].IEEE,2000:15-19
    [65]Qin Lu and Julie Ann Stuart. An investigation of bulk recycling and planning for an Electronic recycling facility receiving industrial returns versus residential returns[J]. IEEE Transaction on electronic packaging manufacturing.2003,26(4):320-327
    [66]Jae-chun Lee, Hyo Teak Song, Jae-Min Yoo. Present status of the recycling of waste electrical and electronic equipment in Korea[J], Resources, Conservation and Recycling.2007,(50):380-397
    [67]童昕.论电子废物管理中的延伸生产者责任原则[J].中国环境管理.2003,(2):1-7
    [68]温素彬,薛恒新.面向可持续发展的延伸生产者责任制度[J].经济问题.2005,(2):11-13
    [69]刘冰,梅光军.在电子废弃物管理中生产者责任延伸制度探讨[J].中国人口·资源与环境.2006,(2):120-123
    [70]徐成,林翎,陈利.瑞士电子废物生产者责任延伸制度[J].环境科学与技术.2008,31(3):117-119
    [71]吴刚,陈兰芳,游宗君,王煜洲.基于博奕论的逆向供应链EPR实施模式研究[J].铁道运输与经济.2008,30(2):65-68
    [72]Chris Coggins. Waste prevention-An Issue of Shared Responsibility for UK Producers and Consumers:Policy Options and Measurement [J]. Resources Conservation & Recycling.2001,(32):181-190
    [73]I. C. Nnorom, O. Osibanjo. Overview of electronic waste(e-waste) management practices and legislations and their poor applications in the developing countries [J]. Resources, Conservation and Recycling.2008, (52):843-858
    [74]Molly Macauley, Karen Palmer, Jhih-Shyang Shih. Dealing with electronic waste:modeling the costs and environmental benefits of computer monitor disposal [J]. Journal of Environmental Management.2003,(68):13-22
    [75]Ab Stevels, Jaco Huisman.消费电子产品寿命终期的生态效益研究(一)[J].家电科技.2005,(4):68-71
    [76]Ab Stevels, Jaco Huisman.消费电子产品寿命终期的生态效益研究(二)[J].家电科技.2005,(5):64-67
    [77]Ab Stevels, Jaco Huisman.消费电子产品寿命终期的生态效益研究(三)[J].家电科技.2005,(6):68-71
    [78]David Hammond, Patrick Beullens. Closed-loop supply chain network equilibrium under legislation[J]. European Journal of Operational Research.2007,183(12)895-908
    [79]Xianbing Liua, Masaru Tanaka, Yasuhiro Matsui. Economic evaluation of optional recycling processes for waste electronic home appliances [J]. Journal of Cleaner Production 2009,17(1):53-60
    [80]Jianxin Yang, Bin Lu, Cheng Xu. WEEE flow and mitigating measures in China [J]. Waste Management.2008,(28):1589-1597
    [81]周进.关于废旧家电回收利用法之“付费制度体系”的研究[J].再生资源研究.2004,(5):14-16
    [82]周进.再论建立废旧家电回收处理之“付费制度体系”的科学性[J].再生资源研究.2005,(6):18-21
    [83]史瑞琼,李霞.论废旧家电回收利用主体的责任—《废旧家电及电子产品回收处理管理条例》(征求意见稿)之评析[J].中国资源综合利用.2005,(4):29-31
    [84]钟蕾.基于循环经济下逆向物流成本与收益模型研究[D].东北林业大学硕士学位论文.2005
    [85]常香云,雷玉华.电子电器产品回收利用的“付费机制”研究[J].企业经济.2006,(5):105-107
    [86]杨晓辉.电子废弃物处置的责任承担与制度构建[D].中国政法大学硕士学位论文.2006:17-27
    [87]李燕燕,徐金锋,周伯煌.废旧家电回收责任问题研究[J].企业家天地·理 论版.2006,(5):147-148
    [88]陈魁,姚从容.电子废弃物的再循环利用:企业、政府与公众的角色和责任[J].再生资源研究.2006,(1):18-22
    [89]郑红,张振业.发达国家及地区废旧家电多元化回收和集中处理模式[J].家电科技.2006,(6):39-43
    [90]潘会平.供应链下游成员合作与协调的经济分析[D].华中科技大学博士学位论文.2004
    [91]潘会平,陈荣秋.供应链合作的利润分配机制研究[J].系统工程理论与实践.2005,25(6):87-93
    [92]王文宾,达庆利.考虑消费者利益的逆向供应链利润分配[J].东南大学学报(自然科学版).2007,(4):726-730
    [93]McGuire TW, Staelin R. An Industry Equilibrium Analysis of Downstream Vertical Integration[J]. Marketing Science.1983,(2):161-191
    [94]Kopichi R J, Berg M J, Legg L, Dasappa V, Maggioni C. Reuse and recycling:reverse logistics opportunities [J]. Oak brook, IL.1993
    [95]Stock J.R., Development and Implementation of Reverse Logistics Programs[M]. Council of Logistics Management, Oak Brook, IL.1998
    [96]Abel P. Jeuland, Steven M. Shugan. Channel of Distribution Profits whenChannel Members form Conjectures [J]. Marketing Science.1988,7(2):202-210
    [97]Sandy D. Jap, Chris Manolis, Barton A. Weitz. Relationship Quality and Buyer-Seller Interactions in Channels of Distribution [J]. Journal of Business Research.1999,(46):303-313
    [98]Klausner M, Hendrickson C. Reverse logistics strategy for product take back [J]. Interfaces.2000,30 (3):156-165
    [99]Realff M J, Ammons J C, Newton D. Strategic design of reverse production systems [J]. Computers and Chemical Engineering.2000,(24):991-996
    [100]Uwe Hansen. Reverse logistics is the key for remanufacturing and a sustainable development [J].IEEE.2000:238-242
    [101]Hrgensen J S, Sigue S P, ZaccourG. Stackelberg Leadership in a Marketing Channel[J]. International GameTheory Review. 2001,(3):13-26.
    [102]Pilar L. Gonzalez-Torre, B.Adenso-Diaz and Hakim Artiba. Environmental and reverse logistics policies in European bottling and packaging firms [J]. International journal of production economics. 2004,(88):95-104
    [103]Toshimitsu Kumazawa, Hideki Kobayashi. A simulation system to support the establishment of circulated business[J]. Advanced Engineering Informatics.2006,(20):127-136
    [104]Rico Wojanowski, Vedat Verter, Tamer Boyaci. Retail-collection network design under deposit-refund[J]. Computers & Operations Research. 2007,(34):324-345
    [105]Hilary Nixon, Jean-Daniel M. Saphoresb. Financing electronic waste recycling Californian households'willingness to pay advanced recycling fees[J]. Journal of Environmental Management.2007,(84):547-559
    [106]G. Davis, S. Heart. Electronic waste:The local government perspective in Queensland, Australia[J]. Resources, Conservation and Recycling. 2008,(52):1031-1039
    [107]王效俐,安宁.商品流通渠道最大化利润模型及利润分配策略的确定[J].系统工程.2003,21(6):32-35
    [108]韩建军,郭耀煌.基于事前协商的动态联盟利润分配机制[J].西南交通大学学报.2003,38(6):686-690
    [109]卢少华,陶志样.动态联盟企业的利益分配博弈[J].管理工程学报.2004,18(3):65-68
    [110]A.I.Barros, R.Dekker and V Scholten. A two-level network for recycling sand:A case study [J].European Journal of Operational Research. 1998,(110):199-214
    [111]Markus Biehl, Edmund Prater, Matthew J.Realff. Assessing performance and uncertainty in developing carpet reverse logistics systems[J].Computers & Operations Research.2007,(34):443-463
    [112]Stefan Minner. Strategic safety stocks in reverse logistics supply chains [J].International Journal of Production Economics.2001,(71):417-428
    [113]罗乐娟.基于可持续发展的废旧家电逆向物流系统构建研究[D].南昌大学硕士学位论文.2005
    [114]罗乐娟,竺宏亮. 废旧家电逆向物流的激励机制研究[J].物流技术. 2004,(11):72-74
    [115]顾巧论,陈秋双.不完全信息下逆向供应链中制造商的最优合同[J].计算机集成制造系统.2007,(3):596-601
    [116]伍云山,张正祥.逆向供应链的激励机制研究[J].工业工程.2006,(1):52-55
    [117]许颖,胡天军.电子产品逆向物流研究[J].物流科技.2006,29(128):44-46
    [118]吴怡、诸大建.生产者责任延伸制的SOP模型及激励机制研究[J].中国工业经济.2008,(3):32-39
    [119]谭德庆.多维博弈论[M].四川:西南交通大学出版社.2006:14-55
    [120]张友良.台湾地区废旧家电回收处理业考察情况[J].家电科技.2006,(9):15-17.
    [121]曾延光.美国电子废物回收法规概览[J].信息技术与标准化.2007,(5):10-15
    [122]电子废弃物循环体系的实现与政策研究课题组.中外电子废弃物循环体系立法比较[J].中国物流与采购.2007,(2):66-67
    [123]美国各州加快制定规范电子废弃物的法律[J].节能与环保.2008,(2):12
    [124]刘若微,蒋建平,朱培武.美国3州电子废弃物法案最新进展及应对[J].WTO经济导刊.2008,(9):86-88
    [125]宋晓芳.规范化废旧家电回收体系构建及其经济分析[D].西南交通大学,2008
    [126]王茵.EPR制度下废旧家电回收处理模式及回收渠道决策研究[D].西南交通大学,2008
    [127]魏邦岩.关于建设青岛市废旧家电及电子废物回收处理体系的探讨[J].资源与发展.2006,(1):29-31
    [128]李彬.戴尔电脑将制定旧电脑回收计划并公开接受监督[J].再生资源研究.2003,(3):42
    [129]再协.废旧家电回收处理试点及示范项目进展情况[J].中国资源综合利用.2005,(5):2-3
    [130]Hahn K H, Hwang H, Shinn S W. A Returns Policy for Distribution Channel Coordination of Perishable Items [J]. European Journal of Operational Research,2004,152(3):770-780.
    [131]Wensheng He, Zujun Ma. The Responsibility of the Main Recovering Body of the Used Household Appliances on a Reciprocal Principle of Benefit and Responsibility[C]//Proceedings of the Eighth International Conference of Chinese Logistics and Transportation Professionals. Reston: The Transportation & Development Institute of the American Society of Civil Engineers Press,2008:582-588.
    [132]一台电视只赚20元,彩电利润低到可怕.http//:www.xici.net/b 1019888/ d42549864.htm,2006
    [133]瑞典、 德国废旧家电回收利用体系考察报告http://www.sx.xinhuanet.com/qyzx,2004
    [134]企业所得税怎么计算.http//:www.0532HR.com,2008
    [135]贾小玫,冉净斐.逆向物流的博弈分析[J].商业经济与管理,2005,160(2):9-12
    [136]覃艳华,曹细玉.企业逆向物流活动的博弈分析[J].生态经济,2006,(4):77-79.
    [137]汪传旭.逆向物流动态博弈分析模型[J].中国航海,2003,57(4):78-81.
    [138]Hilary G. Grimes-Casey, Thomas P. Seager, Thomas L. et al. A game theory framework for cooperative management of refillable and disposable bottle lifecycles[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production, In Press, Corrected Proof, Available online 29 September 2006.
    [139]黄晓波.差异化激励理论与差异化激励机制[J].北京工商大学学报(社会科学版),2006,21(1):33-37.
    [140]齐红倩.基于选择性理性的激励模型及应用研究[J].中国工业经济,2005,(2):97-103.
    [141]王家龙.激励理论的发展过程和趋势分析[J].求实,2005,(4):48-50.
    [142]张维迎.企业理论与中国企业改革[M].北京:北京大学出版社,1999.
    [143]王月红.激励强度确定与激励替代互补—防止军事人才“亚流失”的激励机制设计[J].军事经济研究,2006,(11):13-16.
    [144]高海霞.消费者的感知风险及减少风险行为研究[D].浙江大学,2003.
    [145]刘志超,白静.消费者购买动机类型及其在市场营销中的应用[J].华南理工大学学报(自然科学版),1999,27(9):53~58.
    [146]王芳.基于消费者回收行为分析的废旧家电回收渠道改进方案[D].西 南交通大学,2008
    [147]http://www.china.com.cn
    [148]朱守先,张雷.静脉产业发展模式探讨生态经济[J].2007,(11):105-108.
    [149]孙颖.废弃电子电气设备WEEE资源化产业发展策略研究[D].北京化工大学,2006.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700