用户名: 密码: 验证码:
我国中小企业板IPO抑价问题研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
IPO抑价现象普遍存在于世界各国,在中国尤为严重。不少中国学者曾在西方的IPO抑价理论基础上对中国股市进行分析,但由于我国资本市场有着自身的特点,存在很多的特殊性,股权分置这一重要的制度性前提存在下的的中国资本市场的有效性并不强,西方对该问题的研究解释在我国资本市场的适用性有待考察。本文结合西方成熟的理论研究成果,选取了股权分置改革后中小板市场上的股票作为样本进行实证分析,力求找出我国中小板独特的、不同于其他国家的IPO超额收益的成因。
     为了达到研究目的,本文采用了定量和定性相结合的分析方法。首先,对现有的有关新股发行抑价的研究文献进行了回顾,在对国内外研究成果进行综述、分析、归纳后,找出现有研究成果存在的不足。其次,阐述了创业板市场的内涵,对我国中小企业板和海外创业板的发行机制进行了介绍和比较分析。然后在近年来IPO抑价的主要理论的基础上,对我国中小企业板发行的股票进行了实证分析,发现中小企业板IPO存在相对严重的抑价现象;最后总结了实证分析的结果,提出了政策建议,并讨论了本文的研究局限和有关研究领域未来的扩展方向。
     本文的研究结论:我国中小企业板IPO存在相对严重的抑价现象,但是西方学者关于抑价现象的研究及其理论解释并不能很好的解释我国中小板市场IPO抑价现象,中小板高抑价产生的原因应从其自身的特点中去找,并且应该逐步解决这些问题,推动IPO抑价的理性回归。
Initial public offering underpricing is a world-wide phenomenon, but especially serious in China. Some Chinese scholars have done studies on Chinese stock market on the basis of western theories, but they neglest the equity separation system. This paper conducts an empirial study after the reform of equity separation while still on the basis of western theories to find out the special and unique factors that influencing IPO excess returns in the Chinese stock market.
     To achieve its goal, this paper applies both quantitative analysis and qualitative analysis. Firstly, the paper related literature on the IPO underpricing, summarizes the recent empirical results in China and other countries. Secondly, this paper studies the main procedure of IPO, analyses and summarizes orientian, fuction, establishment, the present developing and future trend of main overseas growth enterprise markets and SME board. And then, this paper reviews the theories of IPO underpricing in recent years, and makes an empirial study on SME Board. The study indicates that there is an excess rate of return on SME Board. Some of SSE Guidelins have the positive effect on the development of SME Board. Finanlly, the conclusion is drawn, the suggestions are given and the limitation are postulated.
     The follow are the main conclusions in this dissertation: the study indicates that there is an excess rate of return on SME Board, the this paper finds out that the research and explanation of western scholars is not very helpful to understand the underpricing phenomenon in China. Instead it concludes that some of the special and unique factors affect the IPO underpricing in China. Chinese stock market IPO underpricing may has its unique reasons, and it is better to solve these problems to push IPO underpricing into a reasonable extent.
引文
9 成思危,“2008年中国改革论坛”,南方日报,2008-4-8
    10 一价定律:相同的物品应该具有相同的价格。即在资本市场中,相同的证券(也就是具有完全相同的支付结构的证券)必须具有相同的价格。Protopapadakis,A.and Stoll,H.R.Spot and Futures Prices and the Law of One Price,Journal of Finance,1983,5:1431-1455
    11 做空机制是于做空紧密相连的一种运作机制,是指投资者因对整体股票市场或某些个股的未来走向(包括短期和中长期)看跌所采取的保护自身利益和借机获利的操作方法以及与此有关的制度总和。贺显南,中国股票市场做空机制初探,上海金融,2001,(10):30-31。
    [1] Asquith Daniel Jonathan, Jones D. and Robert Kieschnick, Evidence on price stabilization and underpricing in early IPO returns, The Journal of Finance,1998, 53:1759-1773
    [2] Aggarwal R Rivoli P, Fads in the initial public offering market? FinancialManagement, 1990, 19:45-57
    [3] Aggarwal Reena, Stabilization activities by underwriters after initial public offerings, Journal of Finance , 2000, 55:1075-1103
    [4] Allen Franklin and Gerald R. Faulhaber, Signaling by Underpricing in the IPO Market, Jounal of Financial Economics, 1989, 23:303-324
    [5] Baron David RA, model of the Demand for Investment Banking Advising and Distribution Services for New Issues, Journal of Finance, 1982, 37:955-976
    [6] Barry Christopher Christopher Muscarella and Michael Vetsuypens, Underwriter warrants , underwriter compensation, and the costs of going public, Journal of Financial Economics, 1991,29:113-136
    [7] Beatty R.P. and J.R.Ritter, Investment banking reputaion and the under pricing of initial public offerings, Journal of Financial Economics, 1986, 15:213-232
    [8] Benveniste Lawrence and Paul Spindt, How investment bankers determine the offer price and allocation of new issuesjournal of Financial Economics , 1989, 24 :343-361
    [9] Booth J.R. and L. Chua, Ownership Dispersion Costly Information and IPO Under pricing, Journal of Financial Economics, 1996, 44:291-310
    [10] Carter Richard and Steven Manaster, Initial public offeings and underwriter reputation, Journal of Finance, 1990, 45:1045-1067
    [11] Chowdhry Bhagwan and Vikram Nanda, Stabilization , syndication and pricing of IPOs Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 1996, 31 : 25—42
    [12] Carter R. B and Dark F. H, The Use of the overallotment option in initial public offerings of equity : Risks and underwriter prestige, Financial Management,1990, 19 (3) :55-64
    [13] Carter, R.B. and Manaster S, Initial public offerings and underwriter reputation, Journal of Finance 1990,45:1045-1067
    [14] Chi Jing and Carol Padgett, Short-Run Under pricing and Its Characteristics in Chinese IPO Markets, Working Paper, University of Reading,2002, 7:133-198
    [15] Dong wei Su Belton Fleisher, An Empirical Investigation of Under pricing in Chinese IPOs, Pacific-Basin Finance Journal, May 1999, 7:173-202
    [16] Grinblatt, Mark and Chuan Yang Hwang, Signaling and the pricing of new issues, Journal of Finance, 1989, 44:393-420
    [17] Hanley Kathleen W. Arun Kumar and Paul Seguin, Price stabilization in the market for new issues, Journal of Financial Economics,1993, 34:177-197
    [18] Hui Y.V and Henry M.K. Mok, Under pricing and after market Performance of IPOs in Shanghai, China, Pacific — Basin Finance Journal, 1998, 6:453-474
    [19] Ibbotson R.G Sindelar J and Ritter J, The Market's Problems with the Pricing Of Initial Public Offerings, Journal of Applied Corporate Finance, 1994, 7:66-74
    [20] Ibbotson Roger G. Price Performance of Common stock New Issues, Journal of Financial Economics, 1975, 2:235-272
    [21] Ibbotson R.G and J.R. Ritter, Initial Public Offerings[A]. R.A. Jarrow,V. Maksimovic and W.T. Ziemba. Handbooks of Operations Research and Management Science: Finance[C]North-Holland, 1995, 993-1016
    [22] Krigman L Shaw W H and Womack K L, Why do firms switch underwriters ? Journal of Financial Economics,2001,60 (2) :245 - 284
    [23] Loughran Tim Jay R Riter and Kristian Rydqvist, Initial Public Offerings: International Insights, Pacific -- Basin Finance Journal, 1994, 2:165-199
    [24] Loughran Tim and Jay R.. Ritter, Why Don't Issuers Get Upset about Leaving Money on the Table in IPOs? Review of Financial Studies,2002, 15:413-443
    [25] Logue Dennis E, On the pricing of unseasoned equity issues: 1965-1969,Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,1973, 8:91-103
    [26] Liu Ti, Investment Without Risk an Empirical Investigation of IPO Under pricing in China, the China Project Report No.4 RIIA/Cambridge University, July 2003,38:1457-1469
    [27]Muscarella Chris J and Michael R.Vetsuypens,A Simple Test of Baron's Model of IPO Underpricing,Jounal of Financial Economics,1989,24:125-136
    [28]Miller Robert E and Frank Reilly,An examination of mispricing,returns,and uncertainty for initial public offerings,Financial Management,1987,16:33-38
    [29]Richard Chung Lawrence Kryzanowski and Ian Rakita,The relationship between overallotment options,underwriting fees and price stabilization for Canadian IPOs,Multinational Finance Journal,2000,4(l&2):5-34
    [30]Ritter Jay.R,Investment banking and securities issuance,North-Holland Handbook of the Economics of Finance,2002,56:158-190
    [31]Ritter Jay.R,Initial Public offerings,Contemporary Finance Digest,1998,1:5-30
    [32]Ritter Jay.R,The 'hot issues' market of 1980,Journal of Business,1984,57:215-240
    [33]Rock Kevin,Why New Issues are Underpriced,Journal of Finandal Economics,1986,15:187-212
    [34]Reilly Frank K,Further evidence on short-run results for new issues investors,Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,1973,8:83-90
    [35]Ruud J.S,Underwriter Support and the IPO Under pricing Puzzle,Journal of Financial Economics,1993,34:135-151
    [36]Schultz Paul H.and Mir A.Zaman,Aftermarket Support and Under pricing of Initial Public Offerings,Journal of Financial Economics,1994,35:199-219
    [37]Stoll H R Curley A J,Small business and the new issues market for equities,Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,1970,5:309-322
    [38]Stoll Hans R,The pricing of underwritten offerings of listed common stocks and the compensation of underwriters,Journal of Economics and Business,1976,28:96-103
    [39]Tinic Seha M,Anatomy of Initial Public Offerings of Common Stock,Journal of Finance,1988,43:789-822
    [40]Welch Ivo,Seasoned Offerings,Imitation Costs,and the Underpricing of initial Public offerings,Journal of Finance,1989,44:421-450
    [41]成思危,全国人大常委会副委员长成思危在中小企业板块启动仪式上的致辞,中国证券报,2004-5-31
    [42]陈工孟 高宁,中国股票一级市场发行抑价的程度与原因,金融研究,2000,(8):1-12
    [43]陈霆,试论新股发行价格改革,中国工业经济,2000,(9):30—34
    [44]邓召明,我国股票发行定价效率实证研究,南开经济研究,2001,(6):60-64
    [45]靳云汇、杨文,新股折价现象的实证分析,统计研究,2003,(3):49-53
    [46]何沛利、章早立,透析我国IP0公司利润操纵,证券时报,2002-11-1
    [47]韩德宗、陈静,中国IPO定价偏低的实证研究,统计研究,2001,(4):29-35
    [48]韩杨、新规则下的新股发行抑价:券商决策模型,南开经济研究,2001,(4):56-58
    [49]贺金凌,海外创业板市场发行上市制度的总结与分析,中国证券报,2001-5-10(17)
    [50]贺显南,中国股票市场做空机制初探,上海金融,2001,(10):30-31
    [51]刘力、李文德,中国股市股票首次公开发行首日超额收益研究,中国会计与财务研究,2000,(4):1-25
    [52]刘彤、吴世农,论我国首次公开发行股票的价格行为与信息不对称,中国经济问题,2001,(3):23-25
    [53]陆建军,中国股票市场新股发行高抑价率的实证分析,华南金融研究,2002,(8):43-46
    [54]刘煜辉、熊鹏,股权分置、政府管制和中国IP0抑价,经济研究,2005,(5):85-95
    [55]李翔、阴永晟,发行管制变迁下的中国股市IPO首日回报率研究,经济科学,2004,(3):43-53
    [56]李博、吴世农,中国股市新股发行(IPOs)的初始收益率研究,Nankai Business Review.,2000,(5):57-65
    [57]李江林,中小企业板块的政策效应,巨田证券研究,2004-5-29
    [58]李军坡、杜俊涛、白彦壮,中国新股发行定价效率--中小企业板与主板IP0公司的对比分析,北京航空航天大学学报(社会科学版),2006,(12):22-25
    [59]龙菊,新股发行定价:理论与现实,数量经济技术经济研究,2003,(9):108-111
    [60]蒋顺才、蒋永明,我国新股发行制度变迁与IPO高抑价的实证研究,海南大学学报人文社会科学版,2005,(3):337-344
    [61]贾伟,深交所公布中小企业板块实施方案,经济日报,2004-5-18
    [62]金晓斌、吴淑琨、陈代云,中国投资银行声誉、IPO质量分布与发行制度创新,2004
    [63]浦剑悦、韩杨,新股发行抑价的两种模型检验,南开管理评论,2002,(4):45-47
    [64]任柏强、张一力、易晓文,影响新股申购收益率因素的分析,金融研究,2001,(4):88-96
    [65]沈红波、钱沁如,中国H股市场IPO抑价现象实证研究,上海立信会计学院学报,2007,(3):36-41
    [66]沈艺峰、陈雪颖,我国首次公开发行股票的实证研究,厦门大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2002,(2):79-87
    [67]桑榕,国外股票IPO的三种实证现象及其理论解释,证券市场导报,2002,(5):40-45
    [68]施锡锉、周侃,信息不完全情况下新股发行定价的选择及效率,统计研究,2000,(11):34-38
    [69]宋永明,我国证券市场投机行为研究,财经贸易,1997,(5):44-45
    [70]宋逢明、梁洪昀,发行市盈率放开后的A股市场初始回报研究,金融研究,2001,(2):94-100
    [71]田嘉、占卫华,投资银行的声誉与IPO定价偏低关系的实证研究,中国社会科学院研究生院学报,2000,(4):33-36
    [72]王海峰、何君光、张宗益,询价制与承销风险实证研究,金融研究,2006,(5):61-68
    [73]王晋斌,新股申购预期超额报酬率的测度及其可能原因的解释,经济研究,1997,(12):17-24
    [74]王春峰、姚锦,中国股票发行市场价值低估现象实证,天津大学学报(社会科学版),2002,(4):316-321
    [75]王铮、顾保国,国际IPO平均抑价差异的解释,证券市场导报,2004,(3):47-50
    [76]夏新平、占卫华,原始股东持股比例对IPO价值影响的实证分析,华中理工大学学报,2000,(2):36-39
    [77]徐文燕、武康平,承销商托市对新股初始回报的影响,当代经济科学,2002, (上):80-86
    [78]苑德军、黄格非、张剑霞,我国新股发行定价机制的市场化改革,中国金融,2004,(10):54-56
    [79]杨记军、赵昌文,定价机制、承销方式与发行成本:来自中国IPO市场的证据,金融研究,2006,(5):52-60
    [80]杨丹、王莉,中国新股发行抑价:一个假说的检验,复旦学报(社会科学版),2001,(5):85-90
    [81]俞颖,核准制IPO初始收益率实证研究,生产力研究,2004,(10):44-47
    [82]俞颖、伶德庆,我国新股发行定价效率的实证分析,生产力研究,2005,(4):57-59
    [83]易丹辉,数据分析与EVIEWS应用,中国统计出版社,2005
    [84]朱武祥、蒋殿春、张新,中国公司金融学,上海三联书店,2005年4月第1版,56-82
    [85]张歆,中小企业板询价第一股诞生,证券日报,2005-1-25
    [86]张人骥、朱海平、王怀芳、韩星,上海股票市场新股发行价格过程分析,经济科学,1999,(4):64-70
    [87]卓贤,中国新股IPO抑价与发行方式的实证分析,会计之友,2003,(11):15-16
    [88]周民源,创业板证券市场的内涵及其功能,华北金融,2003,(8):39-40
    [89]周观君,中国A股市场新股抑价现象的实证研究,管理科学,2005,(2):66-70
    [90]周乃敏、韦洪兴,国内外二板市场的比较研究,科研管理,2003,(3):137-144

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700