摘要
作为现代中国大陆最早开展台湾原住民田野调查的人类学先驱,林惠祥在1929、1935年两次台湾之行中都拍摄了不少台湾原住民社会生活的影像。这些珍贵的田野摄影作品,不仅生动地展示了20世纪初日本殖民统治时期台湾原住民的族群景观与社会状况,而且体现了第一代中国人类学家很早就通过光影之间的视觉手段来生产民族知识。围绕林惠祥这些尚未被广泛认识的早期台湾原住民田野摄影的相关讨论,有助于思考人类学、田野摄影与民族志文本之间的互文性。
引文
[1]李亦园.林惠祥的人类学贡献[J].东南学术,1998,(5):28.
[2]郭志超.开辟荆榛:台湾番族之原始文化[C]//载汪毅夫,郭志超主编.纪念林惠祥文集.厦门:厦门大学出版社,2001.193-201;陈建樾.林惠祥与中国大陆的台湾原住民研究[J].民族研究,2011,(4):25-33;贾益.林惠祥的台湾“原住民”研究及其民族意识[J].北方民族大学学报,2015,(6):77-82.
[3]宋文萱.跨越世纪的影像:鸟居龙藏眼中的台湾原住民[M].台北:顺益博物馆,1994.
[4]Elizabeth Edwards,ed.,Anthropology and Photography,1860-1920.New Haven and London:Yale University Press,1992.
[5]英国皇家人类学会编.田野调查技术手册[M].何国强等译.上海:复旦大学出版社,2016.243-247.
[6]Elizabeth Edwards,“Science Visualized:E.H.Man in the Andaman Islands”,in Elizabeth Edwards,ed.,Anthropology and Photography,1860-1920.pp.108-121.
[7]Edwards Edwards,Raw Histories:Photographs,Anthropology and Museums.Oxford,NY:Berg,2001.
[8]Paul Hockings,“The yellow bough:Rivers’s use of photograph in The Todas”.In Elizabeth Edwards,ed.,Anthropology and Photography,1860-1920.pp.179-186.
[9]Bronislaw Malinowski,Michael W.Young,Malinowski’s Kiriwina:Fieldwork Photography 1915-1918.Chicago:University of Chicago Press,1999;A.R.Radcliffe Brown:The Andaman Islanders,The University of Cambridge Press,1922.
[10]Samain E.Bronislaw Malinowski et la photographie anthropologique.Vethnographie,1995.
[11]Ira Jacknis,“Margaret Mead and Gregory Bateson in Bali:Their Use of Photography and Film”,Cultural Anthropology,Vol.3,No.2(May,1988),pp.160-177.
[12]Elizabeth Edwards,“Foreword”,VII,in Elizabeth Edwards,ed.,Anthropology and Photography 1860-1920,New Haven and London:Yale University Press,1992.
[13]Gregory Bateson and Margaret Mead:Balinese character,A photographic analysis,New York:The A-cademy of Science,1942.
[14][15][16][17][18][19][21][24][25][26][27][28][29][31][32]林惠祥.台湾番族之原始文化[C]//蒋炳钊等编.林惠祥文集(上).厦门:厦门大学出版社,2013.33.56.98-110.6.34.104.37.37.38.39.39.108-109.33.85.109.
[20]Satadru Sen,“Savage Bodies,Civilized Pleasures:M.V.Portman and the Andamanese”,American Ethnologist,Vol.36,No.2(May,2009),pp.366-368.
[22]林惠祥.世界人种志[C]//蒋炳钊等编.林惠祥文集(上).厦门:厦门大学出版社,2012.160.
[23]Turner,T.S,Not Work Alone:A Cross-Cultural View of Activities Superfluous to Survival.Beverly Hills,CA:Sage.1980,pp.112-140.
[30]张先清.物件的文化:中国学者的早期田野采集志反思[J].民族学刊,2016,(1):1-7.
[33][34]胡惠生.参观台湾番族生活品标本后[J].铁路周刊,1930,(11,12-13).
[35]顾天枢.介绍林惠祥编:台湾番族之原始文化[J].边疆,1939,2(3-4).
[36][37]Elizabeth Edwards,ed.,Anthropology and Photography 1860-1920,“introduction”,p.8.p.10.
[38]Gregory Bateson and Margaret Mead:Balinese character,A photographic analysis,1942.
[39][40][41]林惠祥.二十五年之秘密[C]//蒋炳钊等编.林惠祥文集(上).厦门:厦门大学出版社,2012.7.
[42]Aaron Glass,A Cannibal in the Archive:“Performance,Materiality,and(In)Visibility in Unpublished Edward Curtis Photographs of the Kwakwaka’wakw Hamat’sa”,Visual Anthropology Review,Vol.25,Issue 2(2009),pp.128-149.