游客密度、拥挤感与满意度——展览馆情境下游客拥挤感知的主要影响因素研究
|
摘要
近年来,游客对文化创意产品的消费需求急速增长,使拥挤成为制约展览馆等文化创意旅游项目发展的重要因素。文章从环境-行为角度出发,综合运用环境心理学的相关理论,探讨展览馆情境下游客拥挤感知的主要影响因素,并进一步厘清密度、拥挤感知和满意度三者之间的关系。通过对378份有效样本数据进行相关分析、方差分析和回归分析发现:室内空间形态对游客拥挤感知有显著的影响,在折线、矩形、圆形和自由形4种不同空间内,游客的拥挤感知程度依次增强;个人社会经济背景特征方面,客源地和出游方式对拥挤感知有直接影响,来自中西部地区的团体游客拥挤敏感度最高;密度是影响拥挤感知的最主要因素,但不是影响游客满意度的关键因素;拥挤感知对满意度没有直接的负向作用,但在高密度情境下,该负向作用显著且得到强化。
The increasing demand for tourism consumption and the scarcity of tourism resources have become dramatic in recent years. Crowding has become a common phenomenon in traditional hot spots. In addition, along with the rapid development of creative cultural industries, all regions of China actively incorporated modern science and technologies into a wide variety of creative tourism projects,such as art galleries, science museums and waxwork museums, which have attracted large numbers of tourists. In contrast to other tourism products, exhibition hall or museum visitors need to concentrate on visiting, learning and understanding, while the physical fatigue caused by stop-and-go movements is more likely to result in tiredness. In this situation, a crowded external environment further aggravates the tourists' stimulation load and affects the quality of their experience. Therefore, considering effective crowding management is vital to the development of tourism attractions, especially creative tourism projects such as exhibition halls.However, the existing studies on crowding perception mainly focused on outdoor recreation areas where the research conclusions about the factors influencing tourists' crowding perception and its effect on their satisfaction have not yet formed a consensus. In addition, scholars in this field regard the natural landscape as the main object of study and rarely explore the human landscape. Therefore, as exhibition halls are a kind of cultural landscape, the existing research conclusions for outdoor recreation areas have limited reference to crowding management in exhibition halls. Considering the existing research differences and the space characteristics of exhibition halls, this paper starts from the perspective of environment-behavioral relationships by synthetically using the relevant theories of environmental psychology to explore the main factors influencing tourists' crowding perception in exhibition hall environments and further clarify the relationships between density, crowding perception and satisfaction.Based on five proposed research hypotheses, this paper performs a series of empirical statistical analyses, including correlation analysis, one-way analysis of variance and multiple linear regression, on a usable sample of 378 tourists to four exhibition halls on Gulangyu Island in Xiamen, Fujian Province.The results show that interior space form significantly impacts tourists' crowding perception. The degree of crowding perception progressively increased in broken line, rectangle, round and free spaces,where the latter were considered the most crowded. In terms of individual socioeconomic background characteristics, both tourist-generating regions and travel patterns directly impact crowding perception.tourists from the central and western regions of China were most sensitive to crowding. However, density was the most important factor affecting tourists' perception of crowding. Thus, when the area is not increased or the space expanded, controlling the number of tourists is still the key to managing crowding perceptions. Moreover, crowding perception has no direct effect on tourists' overall satisfaction;however, in the case of high density, its negative effect becomes significant and enhanced. Thus, without controlling the number of tourists reasonably, crowding perception may threaten the quality of their tourism experience. Furthermore, no significant relationships emerged between density and tourists' overall satisfaction. Additional interviews were conducted and showed that tourists' adjustment behaviors play an important role in the relationship between crowding perception and satisfaction. Therefore,management concerns should focus on making full use of interior spaceform, adopting differentiated strategies for different types of tourists, attaching importance to tourists' adjustment behaviors and taking timely guidance and evacuation measures according to these warning signals.
The increasing demand for tourism consumption and the scarcity of tourism resources have become dramatic in recent years. Crowding has become a common phenomenon in traditional hot spots. In addition, along with the rapid development of creative cultural industries, all regions of China actively incorporated modern science and technologies into a wide variety of creative tourism projects,such as art galleries, science museums and waxwork museums, which have attracted large numbers of tourists. In contrast to other tourism products, exhibition hall or museum visitors need to concentrate on visiting, learning and understanding, while the physical fatigue caused by stop-and-go movements is more likely to result in tiredness. In this situation, a crowded external environment further aggravates the tourists' stimulation load and affects the quality of their experience. Therefore, considering effective crowding management is vital to the development of tourism attractions, especially creative tourism projects such as exhibition halls.However, the existing studies on crowding perception mainly focused on outdoor recreation areas where the research conclusions about the factors influencing tourists' crowding perception and its effect on their satisfaction have not yet formed a consensus. In addition, scholars in this field regard the natural landscape as the main object of study and rarely explore the human landscape. Therefore, as exhibition halls are a kind of cultural landscape, the existing research conclusions for outdoor recreation areas have limited reference to crowding management in exhibition halls. Considering the existing research differences and the space characteristics of exhibition halls, this paper starts from the perspective of environment-behavioral relationships by synthetically using the relevant theories of environmental psychology to explore the main factors influencing tourists' crowding perception in exhibition hall environments and further clarify the relationships between density, crowding perception and satisfaction.Based on five proposed research hypotheses, this paper performs a series of empirical statistical analyses, including correlation analysis, one-way analysis of variance and multiple linear regression, on a usable sample of 378 tourists to four exhibition halls on Gulangyu Island in Xiamen, Fujian Province.The results show that interior space form significantly impacts tourists' crowding perception. The degree of crowding perception progressively increased in broken line, rectangle, round and free spaces,where the latter were considered the most crowded. In terms of individual socioeconomic background characteristics, both tourist-generating regions and travel patterns directly impact crowding perception.tourists from the central and western regions of China were most sensitive to crowding. However, density was the most important factor affecting tourists' perception of crowding. Thus, when the area is not increased or the space expanded, controlling the number of tourists is still the key to managing crowding perceptions. Moreover, crowding perception has no direct effect on tourists' overall satisfaction;however, in the case of high density, its negative effect becomes significant and enhanced. Thus, without controlling the number of tourists reasonably, crowding perception may threaten the quality of their tourism experience. Furthermore, no significant relationships emerged between density and tourists' overall satisfaction. Additional interviews were conducted and showed that tourists' adjustment behaviors play an important role in the relationship between crowding perception and satisfaction. Therefore,management concerns should focus on making full use of interior spaceform, adopting differentiated strategies for different types of tourists, attaching importance to tourists' adjustment behaviors and taking timely guidance and evacuation measures according to these warning signals.
引文
[1]CHEN Xing,ZHANG Song,OU Tong,et al.Design of the Asian games historical exhibition center in Guangzhou[J].Journal of Building Structures,2010,31(3):114-122.[陈星,张松,区彤,等.广州亚运城历史展览馆结构设计[J].建筑结构学报,2010,31(3):114-122.]
[2]ZHOU Zongbin,ZHU Qun.Construction technology of seismic strengthening for Sichuan Exhibition Hall[J].Construction Technology,2009,38(2):58-60.[周宗彬,祝群.四川省展览馆抗震加固施工技术[J].施工技术,2009,38(2):58-60.]
[3]WANG Shaobin.Building display form and spatial experience with characteristic of regional culture:Taking display design of Yunfu City Planning Exhibition Hall for example[J].Journal of Decoration,2014,57(1):86-87.[王少斌.构建地域文化特征的展示形式和空间体验--以云浮城市规划展览馆展陈设计实践为例[J].装饰,2014,57(1):86-87.]
[4]HAN Shaoshi.A brief discussion on the history of the development of museum,definition and distinction from the exhibition hall[J].Cultural Relics of Central China,1984,8(2):109-111.[韩绍诗.浅议博物馆的发展史、定义及其与展览馆的区别[J].中原文物,1984,8(2):109-111.]
[5]ZHENG Jianyu.Event Venue Management[M].Beijing:Tourism Education Press,2007:9.[郑建瑜.会展场馆管理[M].北京:旅游教育出版社,2007:9.]
[6]YU Shaolu,ZHANG Jingqiu.A study on spatial differentiation of cultural facility utilization in Beijing:A case study of museums,gymnasiums and galleries[J].Social Sciences of Beijing,2010,25(3):73-77.[于绍璐,张景秋.北京城区文化设施利用的空间分异研究--以博物馆、体育馆、展览馆为例[J].北京社会科学,2010,25(3):73-77.]
[7]ZHAO Pengfei.Analysis and research of exhibition design of contemporary display[J].Packaging Engineering,2011,32(2):119-122.[赵鹏飞.当代展览馆的展示设计分析与研究[J].包装工程,2011,32(2):119-122.]
[8]SCHMIDT D E,KEATING J P.Human crowding and personal control:An integration of the research[J].Psychological Bulletin,1979,86(4):680-700.
[9]SHELBY B,VASKE J J,HEBERLEIN T A.Comparative analysis of crowding in multiple locations:Results from fifteen years of research[J].Leisure Sciences,1989,11(4):269-291.
[10]LEE H,GRAEFE A R.Crowding at an arts festival:Extending crowding models to the front country[J].Tourism Management,2003,24(1):1-11.
[11]SHELBY B,VASKE J J.Using normative data to develop evaluative standards for resource management:A comment on three recent papers[J].Journal of Leisure Research,1991,23(2):173-187.
[12]ABSHER J D,LEE R G.Density as an incomplete cause of crowding in backcountry settings[J].Leisure Sciences,1981,4(3):231-247.
[13]LE Guoan.What is environmental psychology[J].Advances in Psychological Science,1988,6(2):40-43.[乐国安.什么是环境心理学[J].心理科学进展,1988,6(2):40-43.]
[14]STOKOLS D.On the distinction between density and crowding:Some implications for future research[J].Psychological Review,1972,79(3):275-277.
[15]STOKOLS D.A social-psychological model of human crowding phenomena[J].Journal of the American Institute of Planners,1972,38(2):72-83.
[16]BELL P A,FISHER J D,BAUM A,et al.Environmental Psychology(the 5thEdition)[M].Philadelphia:Holt,Rinehart,Winston,Inc,1990:279-321.
[17]YE Chongxin.Psychology[M].Taipei:Psychological Press,2000:83.[叶重新.心理学[M].台北:心理出版社,2000:83.]
[18]DITTON R B,FEDLER A J,GRAEFE A R.Factors contributing to perceptions of recreational crowding[J].Leisure Sciences,1983,5(4):273-288.
[19]PRISKIN J.Tourist perceptions of degradation caused by coastal nature-based recreation[J].Environmental Management,2003,32(2):189-204.
[20]LEUJAK W,ORMOND R F G.Visitor perceptions and the shifting social carrying capacity of South Sinai's coral reefs[J].Environmental Management,2007,39(4):472-489.
[21]FLEISHMAN L,FEITELSON E,SALOMON I.The role of cultural and demographic diversity in crowding perception:Evidence from nature reserves in Israel[J].Tourism Analysis,2004,9(1/2):23-40.
[22]VASKE J J,DONNELLY M P,PETRUZZI J P.Country of origin,encounter norms,and crowding in a frontcountry setting[J].Leisure Sciences,1996,18(2):161-176.
[23]ZEHRER A,RAICH F.The impact of perceived crowding on customer satisfaction[J].Journal of Hospitality&Tourism Management,2016,29(12):88-98.
[24]SAYAN S,KARAGüZEL O.Problems of outdoor recreation:The effect of visitors’demographics on the perceptions of Termessos National Park,Turkey[J].Environmental Management,2010,45(6):1257-1270.
[25]WESTOVER T N,COLLINS J R.Perceived crowding in recreation settings:An urban case study[J].Leisure Sciences,1987,9(2):87-99.
[26]SCHREYER R,ROGGENBUCK J W.The influence of experience expectations on crowding perceptions and socialpsychological carrying capacities[J].Leisure Sciences,1978,1(4):373-394.
[27]BOWES S M.Watercraft Characteristics,Preferences,Experiences,Expectations and Perceptions of Crowding on the Upper Delaware Scenic and Recreational River[D].New York:State University of New York,1997.
[28]LEARY E C.Crowding Expectation,Perception and Use Distribution of Front Country Visitors to The Grand Staircase Escalante National Monument[D].Logan:Utah State University,2005.
[29]HAMMITT W E,KNAUF L R,NOE F P.A comparison of user vs.researcher determined level of past experience on recreation preference[J].Journal of Leisure Research,1989,21(3):202-213.
[30]HAMMITT W E,BACKLUND E A,BIXLER R D.Experience use history,place bonding and resource substitution of trout anglers during recreation engagements[J].Journal of Leisure Research,2004,36(3):356-378.
[31]VASKE J J,DONNELLY M P,HEBERLEIN T A.Perceptions of crowding and resource quality by early and more recent visitors[J].Leisure Sciences,1980,3(4):367-381.
[32]GNOTH J.Tourism motivation and expectation formation[J].Annals of Tourism Research,1997,24(2):283-304.
[33]ARNBERGER A,HAIDER W.Social effects on crowding preferences of urban forest visitors[J].Urban Forestry&Urban Greening,2005,3(3/4):125-136.
[34]ROGGENBUCK J W,SCHREYER R.Relations between River Trip Motives and Perception of Crowding,Management Preference,and Experience Satisfaction[R].New York:USDAForest Service General Technical Report Nc,1977.
[35]SHELBY B,Heberlein T A,Vaske J J,et al.Expectations,preferences,and feeling crowded in recreation activities[J].Leisure Sciences,1983,6(1):1-14.
[36]GRIESER K A.Quantification and Characterization of Recreational Paddling on Tivoli Bays and Constitution Marsh[D].New York:State University of New York,2006.
[37]ROGGENBUCK J W,WILLIAMS D R,Watson A E.Defining acceptable conditions in wilderness[J].Environmental Management,1993,17(2):187-197.
[38]BAKHTIARI F,JACOBSEN J B,JENSEN F S.Willingness to travel to avoid recreation conflicts in Danish forests[J].Urban Forestry&Urban Greening,2014,13(4):662-671.
[39]VASKE J J,DONNELLY M P.Generalizing the encounternorm-crowding relationship[J].Leisure Sciences,2002,24(3/4):255-269.
[40]CESSFORD G.Perception and reality of conflict:Walkers and mountain bikes on the Queen Charlotte Track in New Zealand[J].Journal for Nature Conservation,2003,11(4):310-316.
[41]HEBERLEIN T A,SHELBY B.Carrying capacity,values,and the satisfaction model:A reply to Greist[J].Journal of Leisure Research,1977,9(2):142-148.
[42]RUDDELL E J,GRAMANN J H.Goal orientation,norms,and noise-induced conflict among recreation area users[J].Leisure Sciences,1994,16(2):93-104.
[43]HEYWOOD J L,MURDOCK W E.Social norms in outdoor recreation:Searching for the behavior-condition link[J].Leisure Sciences,2002,24(3/4):283-295.
[44]CHOI G C.Situational and Personal Factors in Perception of Crowding[D].Laramie:The University of Wyoming,1978.
[45]CHANG C Y.A Simulation Approach to Crowding in Outdoor Recreation[D].Mckeesport Allegheny:The Pennsylvania State University,1993.
[46]TARRANT M A,Cordell H K,Kibler T L.Measuring perceived crowding for high-density river recreation:The effects of situational conditions and personal factors[J].Leisure Sciences,1997,19(2):97-112.
[47]NEEDHAM D,ROLLINS R B,Wood C J B.Site-specific encounters,norms and crowding of summer visitors at alpine ski areas[J].International Journal ofTourism Research,2004,6(6):421-437.
[48]LI J.The Effects of Store Physical Environment on Perceived Crowding and Shopping Behavior[D].Auburn:Auburn University,2004.
[49]JACOB G R,SCHREYER R M.Conflict in outdoor recreation:A theoretical perspective[J].Journal of Leisure Research,1980,12(4):368-380.
[50]KIM S O,SHELBY B,NEEDHAM M D.Effects of facility developments and encounter levels on perceptions ofsettings,crowding,and norms in a Korean park[J].Environmental Management,2014,53(2):441-453.
[51]STERL P,WAGNER S,ARNBERGER A.Social Carrying Capacity of Canoeists in Austria's Danube Floodplains National Park[R].Helsinki:Finnish Forest Research Institute,2004.
[52]KIM S O,SHELBY B.Effects of soundscapes on perceived crowding and encounter norms[J].Environmental Management,2011,48(1):89-97.
[53]GRIFFITT W,VEITCH R.Hot and crowded:Influences of population density and temperature on interpersonal affective behavior[J].Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,1971,17(1):92-98.
[54]HEBERLEIN T A,TRENT T N,BAUMGARTNER R M.The influence of hunter density on firearm deer hunters'satisfaction:A field experiment[A]//Transactions of the 47th North American Natural Resource and Wildlife Conference[C].Washington D.C.:Wildlife Management Institute,1982:665-676.
[55]BUDRUK M,SCHNEIDER I E,ANDRECK K L,et al.Crowding and satisfaction among visitors to a built desert attraction[J].Journal of Park&Recreation Administration,2002,20(3):1-17.
[56]GRAMANN J H,BURDGE R J.Crowding perception determinants at intensively developed outdoor recreation sites[J].Leisure Sciences,1984,6(2):167-186.
[57]WICKHAM T D,KERSTETTER D L.The relationship between place attachment and crowding in an event setting[J].Event Management,2000,6(3):167-174.
[58]WANG Bing.The Visitor Perception of Crowding Research of the Summer Palace in Beijing[D].Beijing:Beijing Forestry University,2008.[王冰.北京颐和园游客拥挤感知研究[D].北京:北京林业大学,2008.]
[59]LIANG Hongwen,ZHU Chunhua.The architectural design of foreign exhibition hall and museum[J].Architectural Journal,1979,26(2):38-41.[梁鸿文,朱纯华.国外展览馆、博物馆的建筑设计[J].建筑学报,1979,26(2):38-41.]
[60]MANNING R E,VALLIERE W A,Wang B.Crowding norms:Alternative measurement approaches[J].Leisure Sciences,1999,21(2):97-115.
[61]MOYLE B,CROY G.Crowding and visitor satisfaction during the off-season:Port Campbell National Park[J].Annals of Leisure Research,2007,10(3/4):518-531.
[62]RATHNAYAKE R M W.How does‘crowding’affect visitor satisfaction at the Horton Plains National Park in Sri Lanka?[J].Tourism Management Perspectives,2015,16(1):129-138.
[63]BULTENA G,FIELD D,WOMBLE P,et al.Closing the gates:A study of backcountry use-limitation at Mount McKinley National Park[J].Leisure Sciences,1981,4(3):249-267.
[64]LIN Yanzhou.Comparison of methods for determining social recreational carrying capacity[J].Journal of Outdoor Recreation Study,2000,13(1):1-20.[林晏州.社会游憩容许量评估方法之比较[J].户外游憩研究,2000,13(1):1-20.]
[65]MANNING R,LEUNG Y F,BUDRUK M.Research to support management of visitor carrying capacity of Boston Harbor Islands[J].Northeastern Naturalist,2005,12(3):201-220.
[66]SHELBY B,Heberlein T A.Carrying Capacity in Recreation Settings[M].Corvallis:Oregon State University Press,1986:65-89.
[67]BRUINS J,BARBER A.Crowding,performance,and affect:Afield experiment investigating mediational processes[J].Journal of Applied Social Psychology,2000,30(6):1268-1280.
[68]EVANS G W,WENER R E.Crowding and personal space invasion on the train:Please don’t make me sit in the middle[J].Journal of Environmental Psychology,2007,27(1):90-94.
[69]GIFFORD R,SACILOTTO P A.Social isolation and personal space:A field study[J].Canadian Journal of Behavioural Science,1993,25(2):165-174.
[70]HU Zhengfan.Environmental Psychology[M].Beijing:China Architecture&Building Press,2012:161-374.[胡正凡.环境心理学[M].北京:中国建筑工业出版社,2012:161-374.]
[71]ZEVI B.Architecture as Space:How to Look at Architecture[M].Zhang Sizan,trans.Beijing:China Architecture&Building Press,1985:89.[布鲁诺·赛维.建筑空间论:如何品评建筑[M].张似赞,译.北京:中国建筑工业出版社,1985:89.]
[72]YANG Fan,CAO Dongxu.Analysis and research on interior space form design[J].Modern Decoration(Theory),2016,32(5):37.[杨帆,曹东旭.室内空间形态设计的分析与研究[J].现代装饰(理论),2016,32(5):37.]
[73]DESOR J A.Toward a psychological theory of crowding[J].Journal of Personality&Social Psychology,1972,21(1):79-83.
[74]BREBNER J.Environmental Psychology in Building Design[M].London:Applied Science Publishers,1982:162-181.
[75]EDWARDS J N,FULLER T D,Sermsri S,et al.Why people feel crowded:An examination of objective and subjective crowding[J].Population&Environment,1994,16(2):149-173.
[76]HU Wenyue.A model of tourists’perceived crowding in recreational settings[J].Tourism Forum,2015,8(6):30-35.[户文月.旅游景区游客拥挤感知影响因素模型建构[J].旅游论坛,2015,8(6):30-35.]
[77]WU Yihong,YANG Xiaozhong,PENG Min.Research on the influencing factors of perceived crowding in theme park:A case study of Fantawild adventure[J].Human Geography,2014,29(4):119-125.[吴义宏,杨效忠,彭敏.主题公园拥挤感知的影响因素研究:以方特欢乐世界为例[J].人文地理,2014,29(4):119-125.]
[78]REN Liuzhu,GONG Lu.Research on visual perception and interior space form design[J].Literature and Art for the Populace,2012,57(13):66-67.[任留柱,龚露.探析视觉感知与室内空间形态设计[J].大众文艺,2012,57(13):66-67.]
[79]XIA Wanshuang,OU Yali.Foundation and Practice of Interior Design[M].Shanghai:Shanghai Jiao Tong University Press,2012:63.[夏万爽,欧亚丽.室内设计基础与实务[M].上海:上海交通大学出版社,2012:63.]
[80]FREEDMAN J L,KLEVANSKY S,EHRLICH P R.The effect of crowding on human task performance[J].Journal of Applied Social Psychology,1971,1(1):7-25.
[81]HESHKA S,NELSON Y.Interpersonal speaking distance as a function of age,sex,and relationship[J].Sociometry,1972,35(4):491-498.
[82]EROGLU S A,MACHLEIT K A.An empirical study of retail crowding:Antecedents and consequences[J].Journal of Retailing,1990,66(2):201-221.
[83]WORCHEL S.Reducing crowding without increasing space:Some applications of an attributional theory of crowding[J].Journal of Population,1978,1(3):216-230.
[84]DAI Kun,YOU Xuqun,YAN Bihua.Research development of crowding studies:Concepts,theories and influence factors[J].Chinese Journal of Applied Psychology,2010,16(4):362-368.[戴琨,游旭群,晏碧华.拥挤研究进展--概念、理论与影响因素[J].应用心理学,2010,16(4):362-368.]
[85]RUSSELL J A,LANIUS U F.Adaptation level and the affective appraisal of environments[J].Journal of Environmental Psychology,1984,4(2):119-135.
[86]REGOECZI W C.When context matters:A multilevel analysis of household and neighbourhood crowding on aggression and withdrawal[J].Journal of Environmental Psychology,2003,23(4):457-470.
[87]PAN Lili,MA Yangmei.Psychological capacity of tourist in Xixi National Wetland Park based on crowding perception[J].Wetland Science,2014,12(5):662-668.[潘丽丽,马扬梅.基于拥挤感知的西溪国家湿地公园游客心理容量研究[J].湿地科学,2014,12(5):662-668.]
[88]FREEDMAN J L.Crowding and Behavior[M].San Francisco:W.H.Freeman&Company,1975:85-112.
[89]TANFORD S,JUNG S.Festival attributes and perceptions:Ameta-analysis of relationships with satisfaction and loyalty[J].Tourism Management,2017,61(4):209-220.
[90]SUN Deming.Light and morphological art of indoor space[J].Journal of Zhengzhou Institute of Light Industry:Social Science Edition,2006,7(6):41-43.[孙德明.光与室内空间形态艺术[J].郑州轻工业学院学报:社会科学版,2006,7(6):41-43.]
[91]LIANG Hongwen,ZHU Chunhua.The interior design of foreign exhibition hall and museum[J].Architectural Journal,1979,26(4):48-53.[梁鸿文,朱纯华.国外展览馆、博物馆的内部设计[J].建筑学报,1979,26(4):48-53.]
(1)数据来源:http://news.163.com/14/1008/10/A81DRJJM00014JB6.html.
(1)数据来源:厦门市鼓浪屿万石山风景名胜区管委会内部资料。
(1)东部地区包括辽宁、北京、天津、河北、山东、江苏、上海、浙江、福建、广东、海南;中部地区包括山西、吉林、黑龙江、安徽、江西、河南、湖北、湖南;西部地区包括陕西、甘肃、青海、宁夏、新疆、四川、重庆、云南、贵州、西藏、广西、内蒙古。
[2]ZHOU Zongbin,ZHU Qun.Construction technology of seismic strengthening for Sichuan Exhibition Hall[J].Construction Technology,2009,38(2):58-60.[周宗彬,祝群.四川省展览馆抗震加固施工技术[J].施工技术,2009,38(2):58-60.]
[3]WANG Shaobin.Building display form and spatial experience with characteristic of regional culture:Taking display design of Yunfu City Planning Exhibition Hall for example[J].Journal of Decoration,2014,57(1):86-87.[王少斌.构建地域文化特征的展示形式和空间体验--以云浮城市规划展览馆展陈设计实践为例[J].装饰,2014,57(1):86-87.]
[4]HAN Shaoshi.A brief discussion on the history of the development of museum,definition and distinction from the exhibition hall[J].Cultural Relics of Central China,1984,8(2):109-111.[韩绍诗.浅议博物馆的发展史、定义及其与展览馆的区别[J].中原文物,1984,8(2):109-111.]
[5]ZHENG Jianyu.Event Venue Management[M].Beijing:Tourism Education Press,2007:9.[郑建瑜.会展场馆管理[M].北京:旅游教育出版社,2007:9.]
[6]YU Shaolu,ZHANG Jingqiu.A study on spatial differentiation of cultural facility utilization in Beijing:A case study of museums,gymnasiums and galleries[J].Social Sciences of Beijing,2010,25(3):73-77.[于绍璐,张景秋.北京城区文化设施利用的空间分异研究--以博物馆、体育馆、展览馆为例[J].北京社会科学,2010,25(3):73-77.]
[7]ZHAO Pengfei.Analysis and research of exhibition design of contemporary display[J].Packaging Engineering,2011,32(2):119-122.[赵鹏飞.当代展览馆的展示设计分析与研究[J].包装工程,2011,32(2):119-122.]
[8]SCHMIDT D E,KEATING J P.Human crowding and personal control:An integration of the research[J].Psychological Bulletin,1979,86(4):680-700.
[9]SHELBY B,VASKE J J,HEBERLEIN T A.Comparative analysis of crowding in multiple locations:Results from fifteen years of research[J].Leisure Sciences,1989,11(4):269-291.
[10]LEE H,GRAEFE A R.Crowding at an arts festival:Extending crowding models to the front country[J].Tourism Management,2003,24(1):1-11.
[11]SHELBY B,VASKE J J.Using normative data to develop evaluative standards for resource management:A comment on three recent papers[J].Journal of Leisure Research,1991,23(2):173-187.
[12]ABSHER J D,LEE R G.Density as an incomplete cause of crowding in backcountry settings[J].Leisure Sciences,1981,4(3):231-247.
[13]LE Guoan.What is environmental psychology[J].Advances in Psychological Science,1988,6(2):40-43.[乐国安.什么是环境心理学[J].心理科学进展,1988,6(2):40-43.]
[14]STOKOLS D.On the distinction between density and crowding:Some implications for future research[J].Psychological Review,1972,79(3):275-277.
[15]STOKOLS D.A social-psychological model of human crowding phenomena[J].Journal of the American Institute of Planners,1972,38(2):72-83.
[16]BELL P A,FISHER J D,BAUM A,et al.Environmental Psychology(the 5thEdition)[M].Philadelphia:Holt,Rinehart,Winston,Inc,1990:279-321.
[17]YE Chongxin.Psychology[M].Taipei:Psychological Press,2000:83.[叶重新.心理学[M].台北:心理出版社,2000:83.]
[18]DITTON R B,FEDLER A J,GRAEFE A R.Factors contributing to perceptions of recreational crowding[J].Leisure Sciences,1983,5(4):273-288.
[19]PRISKIN J.Tourist perceptions of degradation caused by coastal nature-based recreation[J].Environmental Management,2003,32(2):189-204.
[20]LEUJAK W,ORMOND R F G.Visitor perceptions and the shifting social carrying capacity of South Sinai's coral reefs[J].Environmental Management,2007,39(4):472-489.
[21]FLEISHMAN L,FEITELSON E,SALOMON I.The role of cultural and demographic diversity in crowding perception:Evidence from nature reserves in Israel[J].Tourism Analysis,2004,9(1/2):23-40.
[22]VASKE J J,DONNELLY M P,PETRUZZI J P.Country of origin,encounter norms,and crowding in a frontcountry setting[J].Leisure Sciences,1996,18(2):161-176.
[23]ZEHRER A,RAICH F.The impact of perceived crowding on customer satisfaction[J].Journal of Hospitality&Tourism Management,2016,29(12):88-98.
[24]SAYAN S,KARAGüZEL O.Problems of outdoor recreation:The effect of visitors’demographics on the perceptions of Termessos National Park,Turkey[J].Environmental Management,2010,45(6):1257-1270.
[25]WESTOVER T N,COLLINS J R.Perceived crowding in recreation settings:An urban case study[J].Leisure Sciences,1987,9(2):87-99.
[26]SCHREYER R,ROGGENBUCK J W.The influence of experience expectations on crowding perceptions and socialpsychological carrying capacities[J].Leisure Sciences,1978,1(4):373-394.
[27]BOWES S M.Watercraft Characteristics,Preferences,Experiences,Expectations and Perceptions of Crowding on the Upper Delaware Scenic and Recreational River[D].New York:State University of New York,1997.
[28]LEARY E C.Crowding Expectation,Perception and Use Distribution of Front Country Visitors to The Grand Staircase Escalante National Monument[D].Logan:Utah State University,2005.
[29]HAMMITT W E,KNAUF L R,NOE F P.A comparison of user vs.researcher determined level of past experience on recreation preference[J].Journal of Leisure Research,1989,21(3):202-213.
[30]HAMMITT W E,BACKLUND E A,BIXLER R D.Experience use history,place bonding and resource substitution of trout anglers during recreation engagements[J].Journal of Leisure Research,2004,36(3):356-378.
[31]VASKE J J,DONNELLY M P,HEBERLEIN T A.Perceptions of crowding and resource quality by early and more recent visitors[J].Leisure Sciences,1980,3(4):367-381.
[32]GNOTH J.Tourism motivation and expectation formation[J].Annals of Tourism Research,1997,24(2):283-304.
[33]ARNBERGER A,HAIDER W.Social effects on crowding preferences of urban forest visitors[J].Urban Forestry&Urban Greening,2005,3(3/4):125-136.
[34]ROGGENBUCK J W,SCHREYER R.Relations between River Trip Motives and Perception of Crowding,Management Preference,and Experience Satisfaction[R].New York:USDAForest Service General Technical Report Nc,1977.
[35]SHELBY B,Heberlein T A,Vaske J J,et al.Expectations,preferences,and feeling crowded in recreation activities[J].Leisure Sciences,1983,6(1):1-14.
[36]GRIESER K A.Quantification and Characterization of Recreational Paddling on Tivoli Bays and Constitution Marsh[D].New York:State University of New York,2006.
[37]ROGGENBUCK J W,WILLIAMS D R,Watson A E.Defining acceptable conditions in wilderness[J].Environmental Management,1993,17(2):187-197.
[38]BAKHTIARI F,JACOBSEN J B,JENSEN F S.Willingness to travel to avoid recreation conflicts in Danish forests[J].Urban Forestry&Urban Greening,2014,13(4):662-671.
[39]VASKE J J,DONNELLY M P.Generalizing the encounternorm-crowding relationship[J].Leisure Sciences,2002,24(3/4):255-269.
[40]CESSFORD G.Perception and reality of conflict:Walkers and mountain bikes on the Queen Charlotte Track in New Zealand[J].Journal for Nature Conservation,2003,11(4):310-316.
[41]HEBERLEIN T A,SHELBY B.Carrying capacity,values,and the satisfaction model:A reply to Greist[J].Journal of Leisure Research,1977,9(2):142-148.
[42]RUDDELL E J,GRAMANN J H.Goal orientation,norms,and noise-induced conflict among recreation area users[J].Leisure Sciences,1994,16(2):93-104.
[43]HEYWOOD J L,MURDOCK W E.Social norms in outdoor recreation:Searching for the behavior-condition link[J].Leisure Sciences,2002,24(3/4):283-295.
[44]CHOI G C.Situational and Personal Factors in Perception of Crowding[D].Laramie:The University of Wyoming,1978.
[45]CHANG C Y.A Simulation Approach to Crowding in Outdoor Recreation[D].Mckeesport Allegheny:The Pennsylvania State University,1993.
[46]TARRANT M A,Cordell H K,Kibler T L.Measuring perceived crowding for high-density river recreation:The effects of situational conditions and personal factors[J].Leisure Sciences,1997,19(2):97-112.
[47]NEEDHAM D,ROLLINS R B,Wood C J B.Site-specific encounters,norms and crowding of summer visitors at alpine ski areas[J].International Journal ofTourism Research,2004,6(6):421-437.
[48]LI J.The Effects of Store Physical Environment on Perceived Crowding and Shopping Behavior[D].Auburn:Auburn University,2004.
[49]JACOB G R,SCHREYER R M.Conflict in outdoor recreation:A theoretical perspective[J].Journal of Leisure Research,1980,12(4):368-380.
[50]KIM S O,SHELBY B,NEEDHAM M D.Effects of facility developments and encounter levels on perceptions ofsettings,crowding,and norms in a Korean park[J].Environmental Management,2014,53(2):441-453.
[51]STERL P,WAGNER S,ARNBERGER A.Social Carrying Capacity of Canoeists in Austria's Danube Floodplains National Park[R].Helsinki:Finnish Forest Research Institute,2004.
[52]KIM S O,SHELBY B.Effects of soundscapes on perceived crowding and encounter norms[J].Environmental Management,2011,48(1):89-97.
[53]GRIFFITT W,VEITCH R.Hot and crowded:Influences of population density and temperature on interpersonal affective behavior[J].Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,1971,17(1):92-98.
[54]HEBERLEIN T A,TRENT T N,BAUMGARTNER R M.The influence of hunter density on firearm deer hunters'satisfaction:A field experiment[A]//Transactions of the 47th North American Natural Resource and Wildlife Conference[C].Washington D.C.:Wildlife Management Institute,1982:665-676.
[55]BUDRUK M,SCHNEIDER I E,ANDRECK K L,et al.Crowding and satisfaction among visitors to a built desert attraction[J].Journal of Park&Recreation Administration,2002,20(3):1-17.
[56]GRAMANN J H,BURDGE R J.Crowding perception determinants at intensively developed outdoor recreation sites[J].Leisure Sciences,1984,6(2):167-186.
[57]WICKHAM T D,KERSTETTER D L.The relationship between place attachment and crowding in an event setting[J].Event Management,2000,6(3):167-174.
[58]WANG Bing.The Visitor Perception of Crowding Research of the Summer Palace in Beijing[D].Beijing:Beijing Forestry University,2008.[王冰.北京颐和园游客拥挤感知研究[D].北京:北京林业大学,2008.]
[59]LIANG Hongwen,ZHU Chunhua.The architectural design of foreign exhibition hall and museum[J].Architectural Journal,1979,26(2):38-41.[梁鸿文,朱纯华.国外展览馆、博物馆的建筑设计[J].建筑学报,1979,26(2):38-41.]
[60]MANNING R E,VALLIERE W A,Wang B.Crowding norms:Alternative measurement approaches[J].Leisure Sciences,1999,21(2):97-115.
[61]MOYLE B,CROY G.Crowding and visitor satisfaction during the off-season:Port Campbell National Park[J].Annals of Leisure Research,2007,10(3/4):518-531.
[62]RATHNAYAKE R M W.How does‘crowding’affect visitor satisfaction at the Horton Plains National Park in Sri Lanka?[J].Tourism Management Perspectives,2015,16(1):129-138.
[63]BULTENA G,FIELD D,WOMBLE P,et al.Closing the gates:A study of backcountry use-limitation at Mount McKinley National Park[J].Leisure Sciences,1981,4(3):249-267.
[64]LIN Yanzhou.Comparison of methods for determining social recreational carrying capacity[J].Journal of Outdoor Recreation Study,2000,13(1):1-20.[林晏州.社会游憩容许量评估方法之比较[J].户外游憩研究,2000,13(1):1-20.]
[65]MANNING R,LEUNG Y F,BUDRUK M.Research to support management of visitor carrying capacity of Boston Harbor Islands[J].Northeastern Naturalist,2005,12(3):201-220.
[66]SHELBY B,Heberlein T A.Carrying Capacity in Recreation Settings[M].Corvallis:Oregon State University Press,1986:65-89.
[67]BRUINS J,BARBER A.Crowding,performance,and affect:Afield experiment investigating mediational processes[J].Journal of Applied Social Psychology,2000,30(6):1268-1280.
[68]EVANS G W,WENER R E.Crowding and personal space invasion on the train:Please don’t make me sit in the middle[J].Journal of Environmental Psychology,2007,27(1):90-94.
[69]GIFFORD R,SACILOTTO P A.Social isolation and personal space:A field study[J].Canadian Journal of Behavioural Science,1993,25(2):165-174.
[70]HU Zhengfan.Environmental Psychology[M].Beijing:China Architecture&Building Press,2012:161-374.[胡正凡.环境心理学[M].北京:中国建筑工业出版社,2012:161-374.]
[71]ZEVI B.Architecture as Space:How to Look at Architecture[M].Zhang Sizan,trans.Beijing:China Architecture&Building Press,1985:89.[布鲁诺·赛维.建筑空间论:如何品评建筑[M].张似赞,译.北京:中国建筑工业出版社,1985:89.]
[72]YANG Fan,CAO Dongxu.Analysis and research on interior space form design[J].Modern Decoration(Theory),2016,32(5):37.[杨帆,曹东旭.室内空间形态设计的分析与研究[J].现代装饰(理论),2016,32(5):37.]
[73]DESOR J A.Toward a psychological theory of crowding[J].Journal of Personality&Social Psychology,1972,21(1):79-83.
[74]BREBNER J.Environmental Psychology in Building Design[M].London:Applied Science Publishers,1982:162-181.
[75]EDWARDS J N,FULLER T D,Sermsri S,et al.Why people feel crowded:An examination of objective and subjective crowding[J].Population&Environment,1994,16(2):149-173.
[76]HU Wenyue.A model of tourists’perceived crowding in recreational settings[J].Tourism Forum,2015,8(6):30-35.[户文月.旅游景区游客拥挤感知影响因素模型建构[J].旅游论坛,2015,8(6):30-35.]
[77]WU Yihong,YANG Xiaozhong,PENG Min.Research on the influencing factors of perceived crowding in theme park:A case study of Fantawild adventure[J].Human Geography,2014,29(4):119-125.[吴义宏,杨效忠,彭敏.主题公园拥挤感知的影响因素研究:以方特欢乐世界为例[J].人文地理,2014,29(4):119-125.]
[78]REN Liuzhu,GONG Lu.Research on visual perception and interior space form design[J].Literature and Art for the Populace,2012,57(13):66-67.[任留柱,龚露.探析视觉感知与室内空间形态设计[J].大众文艺,2012,57(13):66-67.]
[79]XIA Wanshuang,OU Yali.Foundation and Practice of Interior Design[M].Shanghai:Shanghai Jiao Tong University Press,2012:63.[夏万爽,欧亚丽.室内设计基础与实务[M].上海:上海交通大学出版社,2012:63.]
[80]FREEDMAN J L,KLEVANSKY S,EHRLICH P R.The effect of crowding on human task performance[J].Journal of Applied Social Psychology,1971,1(1):7-25.
[81]HESHKA S,NELSON Y.Interpersonal speaking distance as a function of age,sex,and relationship[J].Sociometry,1972,35(4):491-498.
[82]EROGLU S A,MACHLEIT K A.An empirical study of retail crowding:Antecedents and consequences[J].Journal of Retailing,1990,66(2):201-221.
[83]WORCHEL S.Reducing crowding without increasing space:Some applications of an attributional theory of crowding[J].Journal of Population,1978,1(3):216-230.
[84]DAI Kun,YOU Xuqun,YAN Bihua.Research development of crowding studies:Concepts,theories and influence factors[J].Chinese Journal of Applied Psychology,2010,16(4):362-368.[戴琨,游旭群,晏碧华.拥挤研究进展--概念、理论与影响因素[J].应用心理学,2010,16(4):362-368.]
[85]RUSSELL J A,LANIUS U F.Adaptation level and the affective appraisal of environments[J].Journal of Environmental Psychology,1984,4(2):119-135.
[86]REGOECZI W C.When context matters:A multilevel analysis of household and neighbourhood crowding on aggression and withdrawal[J].Journal of Environmental Psychology,2003,23(4):457-470.
[87]PAN Lili,MA Yangmei.Psychological capacity of tourist in Xixi National Wetland Park based on crowding perception[J].Wetland Science,2014,12(5):662-668.[潘丽丽,马扬梅.基于拥挤感知的西溪国家湿地公园游客心理容量研究[J].湿地科学,2014,12(5):662-668.]
[88]FREEDMAN J L.Crowding and Behavior[M].San Francisco:W.H.Freeman&Company,1975:85-112.
[89]TANFORD S,JUNG S.Festival attributes and perceptions:Ameta-analysis of relationships with satisfaction and loyalty[J].Tourism Management,2017,61(4):209-220.
[90]SUN Deming.Light and morphological art of indoor space[J].Journal of Zhengzhou Institute of Light Industry:Social Science Edition,2006,7(6):41-43.[孙德明.光与室内空间形态艺术[J].郑州轻工业学院学报:社会科学版,2006,7(6):41-43.]
[91]LIANG Hongwen,ZHU Chunhua.The interior design of foreign exhibition hall and museum[J].Architectural Journal,1979,26(4):48-53.[梁鸿文,朱纯华.国外展览馆、博物馆的内部设计[J].建筑学报,1979,26(4):48-53.]
(1)数据来源:http://news.163.com/14/1008/10/A81DRJJM00014JB6.html.
(1)数据来源:厦门市鼓浪屿万石山风景名胜区管委会内部资料。
(1)东部地区包括辽宁、北京、天津、河北、山东、江苏、上海、浙江、福建、广东、海南;中部地区包括山西、吉林、黑龙江、安徽、江西、河南、湖北、湖南;西部地区包括陕西、甘肃、青海、宁夏、新疆、四川、重庆、云南、贵州、西藏、广西、内蒙古。
© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号 地址：北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编：100083 电话：办公室：(+86 10)66554848；文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新：66554700 |