用户名: 密码: 验证码:
中国和欧盟低碳发展比较研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
气候变化问题已成为人类社会面临的严峻考验之一。这场考验不仅威胁人类的生存和发展,还使得人类面临着来自能源安全性方面的挑战,此外,2009年的全球金融危机促使世界各国寻求新的经济增长点。发展低碳经济作为应对气候变化、协调社会经济发展、保障能源安全与应对气候变化的基本途径,已经逐渐取得世界上越来越多国家的认同。为了应对全球气候变化和确保能源安全,确保在新一轮的国际新秩序建立过程中抢占有利地位,很多发达国家都转变了发展思路,寻求向低碳发展模式转变。
     本文从历史演进的角度,以二氧化碳排放强度、人均二氧化碳排放量、二氧化碳排放总量三个指标为切入点,对碳排放历史演进阶段及各阶段的主导性驱动因素进行分析,并在此基础上对中欧当前所处的低碳发展阶段进行判定;接下来又基于脱钩理论对中国和欧盟国家近期经济发展与碳排放脱钩程度进行比较研究,结果如下:
     (1)欧盟15国基本上跨越了碳排放强度的倒U型曲线高峰,但是各国碳排放强度高峰出现时的经济发展水平差异很大,各国碳排放强度峰值也存在较大差异。中国的碳排放强度呈现出比较明显的双峰曲线特征,分别于上世纪60年代初、70年代中后期出现碳排放强度峰值,中国碳排放强度在上世纪80年代和90年出现持续下降趋势,但是在21世纪初又出现了反弹,这说明中国尚未完全实现碳排放强度的稳定下降。
     (2)一些发达国家如德国、比利时、丹麦、法国、爱尔兰、瑞典、荷兰、英国和美国等基本上跨越了人均碳排放量的高峰,芬兰、希腊、意大利、葡萄牙等国的人均碳排放量发展趋势仍需继续观察,他们目前可能或者正在跨越人均二氧化碳排放量高峰。虽然中国已经实现了碳排放强度高峰的跨越,但是其碳强度下降趋势还不稳定,中国还需要很长的时间才能达到人均碳排放量峰值。
     (3)仅有7个欧盟国家(比利时、丹麦、法国、德国、荷兰、瑞典、英国等)跨越了碳排放总量高峰。
     (4)通过观察近半个世纪中国、欧盟15国、美国、日本、印度和巴西的碳排放和经济发展的关系可以发现:大部分发达国家都出现过强脱钩,且发达国家脱钩弹性值的变化趋势基本一致;但是3个发展中国家经济增长与碳排放脱钩特征的变化趋势差异较大。发展阶段不同将会对中欧低碳国际定位、低碳战略目标的制定和低碳政策的取向产生不同的影响。
     在对中欧低碳发展阶段比较研究的基础上,研究中欧追求的低碳发展国际定位。在低碳发展国际领导力方面,欧盟具有低碳发展的先发优势,而且其还通过一系列举措强化这些优势,尽管近年来随着经济的低迷欧盟低碳发展领导力出现下降,但这并未动摇其领导者地位;目前中国在国际低碳发展领域仍处于追随者的地位,中国已成为世界上最大的温室气体排放国,在领导力方面与欧盟存在很大差距,但是中国仍存在实现低碳发展领导力的潜力和可能性。
     国内低碳政策的有效实施是欧盟实现低碳发展国际领导力的重要基础。本文从低碳政策历史演进、低碳发展战略目标与实施路径规划、低碳发展政策实施现状3个方面对中欧低碳发展政策进行比较研究,其中低碳发展政策实施现状比较研究主要从中欧追求低碳发展的财税政策、面向企业的节能政策以及能效政策3个维度展开。研究结论如下:
     (1)欧盟应对气候变化、追求低碳发展的政策演进历程也是其政策一体化逐步深化的过程,大致经历了萌芽(20世纪80年代中后期)、发展(20世纪90年代)和基本成熟(2000年以后)三个阶段;相对而言,中国应对气候变化、低碳发展政策的发展速度比较慢,20世纪80年代至2005年是中国应对气候变化、追求低碳发展政策的萌芽阶段,迄今为止中国的低碳发展政策尚处于发展阶段。
     (2)中国进行节能减排控制对象和欧盟温室气体减排控制对象非常相似,都是以重点耗能企业作为控制对象,且两者都是以循序渐进的手段逐步扩大控制对象的范围,但是两者具有不同的政策工具选择偏好:欧盟低碳发展政策的主要特点是以市场机制为基础;而中国当前的低碳政策是以政府管制为主,市场机制为辅。
     发展阶段不同、政策环境不同,造成中欧低碳发展目标选择的不同。中国在选择低碳发展政策工具时应认真考虑自身当期的经济发展状况、政策环境状况、碳排放发展的阶段特征以及低碳发展目标。基于以上对中国和欧盟低碳发展的定性和定量比较研究,本文提出中国深化低碳发展建议如下:
     (1)通过加强国际合作等方式提升中国应对气候变化国际影响力,在全球低碳发展新秩序构建中占据有利地位,为追求气候变化国际领导力奠定基础;
     (2)中国应为应对气候变化、实现低碳发展制定中长期目标并对实现目标的的路线图进行规划;
     (3)继续使用以管制-命令和制定标准为代表的传统政策工具;
     (4)推进基于市场的政策工具:积极探索低碳税收政策;循序渐进的推进碳排放交易市场建设。
Climate change has become one of the severe issues in the world, it is not only threat human survival and development but also challenge energy security.In addition, the global financial crisis in2009prompted the world to seek new economic growth point.The development of low-carbon economy as a way to address climate change, coordination of socio-economic development, energy security and climate change has gradually gained more and more countries' recognition.In order to address global climate change and energy security issues, to ensure seize a favorable position in the process of establishing of a new international order, many developed countries have to adjust their development strategies, try transiting to a low-carbon economy.
     This article make qualitative and quantitative comparative study of China and EU in carbon emissions trends, low-carbon development strategies, policy instrument, the means of implementation, low-carbon development situations.
     Quantitative studies include:the historical development trends study of China-EU carbon, emissions and study of China-EU low-carbon development current situation based on the decoupling theory, the conclusion of the study are as follows:
     (1) EU-15countries are basically crossed the peak of inverted U-shaped curve of carbon intensity, but these countries' carbon intensity peak value and economic development level are quite different in carbon intensity peak period.China's carbon intensity shows an obvious bimodal curve, carbon intensity peak values appeared in the early1960s and the late1970s separately,then China carbon intensity experienced a longer period of decline, it is rebounded in2000, above facts indicating that China still has not fully achieve a steady decline in carbon intensity.
     (2) Belgium, Denmark, France, Germany, Ireland, the Netherlands, Sweden, the United Kingdom, the United States are crossed the per capita carbon emissions peak basically, while Finland, Greece, Italy, Portugal and other countries likely to span the per capita carbon emissions peak, the situation of these countries need to be further observation yet.China still needs more time to achieve across the per capita carbon emissions peak.
     (3)Only seven EU countries (Belgium, Denmark, France, Germany, the Netherlands, Sweden, and the United Kingdom) crossed the peak of the total carbon emissions.
     (4)In past half century, most of the developed countries experienced strong decoupling between carbon emissions and economic growth, and these developed countries' decoupling elasticity values show consistent trend, however, developing countries' economic growth and carbon emissions decoupling trends are quite different.
     Qualitative comparativestudy of China and the EU are mainly focused on the China and EU low-carbon development international leadership, China and EU low-carbon development policies and measures, the results are as follows:
     (1) The course of EU low-carbon policy development is a process of gradual deepening policy integration, experienced sprout stage (the late1980s), development stage (1990s) and mature (after2000) stage; while China's low-carbon policy late start, late1990s is the embryonic stage of China's low-carbon development, China's low-carbon development policy is still in the development stage so far.EU climate change leadership combines structural leadership, intelligent leadership, direction leadership characteristics,after the Copenhagen conference in2009EU climate change leadership shows downward trend.China has the inherent advantage of structured leadership, at the same time has the potential advantages of the intelligent leadership and direction leadership,China should pursue low-carbon development international leadership by strengthen international exchanges and cooperation, establish a positive image of addressing climate change actively.
     (2) Control objects of low-carbon development and energy saving in China and greenhouse gas emission reduction in EU is very similar,but they have different policy tools select preferences:China's current low-carbon policy is the main government regulation, supplemented by market mechanisms, while the main features of the EU low-carbon development policy is based on market mechanisms. By observing the low-carbon policy from the EU and China, we think that application of low-carbon development policy instruments should be adapted to the development stages which can be featured as national carbon emissions, carbon intensity, per capita carbon emissions, and carbon emissions trends and so on.
     Based on the above qualitative and quantitative research on low-carbon development in China and the European Union, this article presents several proposals for deepening China's low-carbon development are as follows:Continue to use the traditional policy instruments such as control-command instrument and standard-made instrument;take full account of the conditions of application of policy tools, and promote the market-based policy instruments steadily;improve energy efficiency as the core objective of the recent low-carbon policy tools;explore low-carbon tax policy actively;promote carbon trading marketstep by step.
引文
Agrawal A, Perrin N, Chhatre A, et al.2013. Climate policy processes, local institutions, and adaptation actions:mechanisms of translation and influence[J]. Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Climate Change,4(1):72-72.
    Andrews-Speed P.2012.The governance of energy in China:transition to a low-carbon economy[M]. Palgrave Macmillan.
    Arnell N W, Lowe J A, Brown S, et al.2013.A global assessment of the effects of climate policy on the impacts of climate change[J]. Nature Climate Change,3:512-519.
    Arroyo V.2013.Are there winning strategies for enacting climate policy? Climate Clever: How Governments Can Tackle Climate Change (and Still Win Elections)[J]. Climate Policy,13(1): 142-144.
    Birdsall N.1992.Another look at population and global warming:Population, health, and nutrition policy research, working paper. Washington DC:World Bank.
    Boserup E.1981. Population and Technological Change:A Study of Long-Term Trends[M]. Chicago:University of Chicago Press.
    Chang Y F, Lin S J.,1998. Structural decomposition of industrial CO2 emissionsin Taiwan:an input-output approach[J]. Energy Policy,26(1):5-12.
    Chevallier J.2009. Carbon futures and macroeconomic risk factors:a view from the EU ETS[J]. Energy Economics,31(4):614-625.
    Chi C, Ma T, Zhu B.2012.Towards a low-carbon economy:Coping with technological bifurcations with a carbon tax[J]. Energy Economics,34(6):2081-2088
    Colette A, Koelemeijer R, Mellios G, et al.2012.Cobenefits of climate and air pollution regulations, The context of the European Commission Roadmap for moving to a low carbon economy in 2050[R]. ETC/ACM-EEA, Copenhagen,78.
    Council of the European Union,2008. Energy and Climate Change:Elements of the Final Compromise[R]. Brussels,17215/08,2008-12-12.
    Council of the European Union,2009. Council Adopts Climate-energy Legislative Package,[R].Brussels,8434/09,2009-04-06.
    Dalton M, O'Neill B, Prskawetz A, et al.2008. Population aging and future carbon emissi ons in the United States[J]. Energy Economics,30:642-675.
    Dasgupta S., Laplante B., Wang H. and wheeler D.2002, Confronting the Environmental Kuznets Curve[J]. Journal of Economic perspectives.16:147-168.
    DTI U K.2003. Energy White Paper:Our energy future-creating a low carbon economy[J]. DTI, London.
    Duscha V, Schleich J.2013.Can no-lose targets contribute to a 2℃ target?[J]. Climate Policy, 13(3):305-327.
    Dupont C.2013. Integrating climate, energy and air pollution policies[J]. Environment and Planning C:Government and Policy,32(2):378-382.
    Eckes C.2013. EU Climate Change Policy:A Choice between Justice and Environmentalism?[J]. EUROPEAN UNION'S SHAPING OF THE INTERNATIONAL LEGAL ORDER, Fabian Amtenbrink, Dimitry Kochenov, eds., CUP,2013:2012-102.
    Elgstroem, O.2007.The European Union as a leader in international multilateral negotiations-a problematic aspiration?[J]. International Relations,21:445-458.
    European Commission,2008.The EU climate and energy package[R/OL], http://ec.europa.eu/clima/policies/brief/eu/package en.htm.2008-12-17.
    European Commission,2009. Europeans'Attitudes towards Climate Change[R/OL], http://ec.europa.eu/public opinion/archives/ebs/ebs 322 en.pdf,2009-11-12.
    European Commission,2010. Energy 2020:a strategy for competitive, sustainable and secure energy[R/OL]. http://europa.eu/legislation summaries/energy/european energy policy/en0024 en.htm. 2010-12-21.
    European Comission,2011. Energy Roadmap 2050 R/OL]. http://ec.europa.eu/energy/energy2020/roadmap/index en.htm.2011-12-15.
    European Commission.2011. A Roadmap for moving to a competitive low carbon economy in 2050[R/OL]. http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=CELEX:52011DC0112:EN:NOT. 2011-03-08
    European Council.2007.An Energy Policy for Europe[R/OL]. http://register.consilium.europa.eu/pdf/en/07/st07/st07224-re01.en07.pdf,2007-03-09
    Foxon T J.2003.Introducing Innovation for a Low-carbon Future:Drivers, Barriers and Policies:a Report for the Carbon Trust[M]. Carbon Trust.
    Galeotti M, Lanza. A, and Pauli F.2006.Reassessing the environmental Kuznets Curve for CO2 emissions:a robustness exercise[J]. Ecological Economics,57:152-163.
    Galeotti M.2003. Environment and Economic Growth:Is Technical Change the Key to Decoupling?[R/OL].http://ssrn.com/abstract=465221.2003-11-09.
    Carraro C, Favero A, Massetti E.2012. Investments and public finance in a green, low carbon, economy[J]. Energy Economics,34(1):515-528.
    Gawel E, Strunz S, Lehmann P.2013. A public choice view on the climate and energy policy mix in the EU:How do the emissions trading scheme and support for renewable energies interact?[R]. UFZ Discussion Papers.
    Gerlagh R, Wietze L.2003.Induced Technological Change under Carbon Taxes[DB/OL]. http://ssrn.com/abstract=464841 or doi:10,2139/ssrn.464841.2003-09-22.
    Glaeser, E. L., and M. E. Kahn,2010. The greenness of cities:carbon dioxide emissions and urban development[J]. Journal of Urban Economics,67:404-418.
    Gorecki P K, Lyons S, Tol R S J.2010. EU climate change policy 2013-2020:Using the Clean Development Mechanism more effectively in the non-EU-ETS Sector[J]. Energy Policy, 38(11):7466-7475.
    Green paper on the security of energy supply [R/OL]. http://europa.eu/legislation summaries/energy/external dimension enlargement/127037 en.htm. 2007-10-02.
    Greenpeace,2010. Evaluation:The Swedish Presidency Gets a Red Card for Environmental Failure[R/OL]. http://www.greenpeace.org/raw/content/sweden/rapporter-och-doku-ment/evaluation-the-swedish-presid.pdf.
    Greenstone M,2002. The impacts of environmental regulation on industrial activity: evidence from the 1970 and 1977 Clean Air Act Amendments and the Census of Manufactures[J]. Journal of Political Economy,110:1175-1219.
    Gupta J, Grubb M.,2000. Climate change and European leadership:A sustainable role for Europe?[M]. Dordrecht:Kluwer Academich Publishers.
    Gupta J, Ringius L.2001. The EU's climate leadership:Reconciling ambition and reality [J].International Environmental Agreements:Politics, Law and Economics,1:281-299.
    Halicioglu F.2007. Residential electricity demand dynamics in Turkey[J]. Energy Economics, 29:199-210.
    Heidenheimer, A. J., Heclo, H., & Adams, C. T.1990.Comparative Public Policy:the politics of social choice in America, Europe, and Japan[M].New York:St.Martin's Press.
    Hildingsson R, Stripple J, Jordan.2012. A. Governing renewable energy in the EU: confronting a governance dilemma[J]. European Political Science,11(1):18-30.
    Huang W M, Lee G W M, Wu C C.2008. GHG emissions, GDP growth and the Kyoto Protocol:a revisit of environmental Kuznets curve hypothesis[J]. Energy Policy,36:239-247.
    IEA.2006. Energy Technology Perspectives:Scenarios and Strategy to 2050[R].Paris: International Energy Agency,39-104
    IEA.2010. Energy Technology Perspectives:Scenarios and Strategy to 2050[R].Paris: International Energy Agency,74-81.
    IPCC.2001.Climate change 2001:impacts, adaptation, and vulnerability:contribution of Working Group II to the third assessment report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change[M]. Cambridge University Press.
    IPCC.2001. Climate Change 2001:Mitigation, Contribution of working group Ⅲ to the Third Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change[M]. Cambridge University Press.
    IPCC.2007. Climate Change 2007:The Physical Science Basis[R/OL].Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, http://www.ipcc.ch/.
    Jones L E, Manuelli R E.1995. A Positive Model of Growth and Pollution Controls[R]. National Bureau of Economic Research,520-525.
    Jordan A, Huitema D, Van Asselt H.2010.Climate change policy in the European Union: confronting the dilemmas of mitigation and adaptation?[M]. Cambridge University Press.
    Jordan A J, Van Asselt H, Berkhout F, et al.2012. Climate change policy in the European Union:Understanding the paradoxes of multi-level governing[J]. Global Environmental Politics, 12(2):43-46.
    Kainuma M, Miwa K, Ehara T, et al.2013.A low-carbon society:global visions, pathways, and challenges[J]. Climate Policy,13(sup01):5-21.
    Kahn M E.2009.Urban growth and climate change[J]. Annu. Rev. Resour. Econ.1(1): 333-350.
    Kane G.2012.The green executive:Corporate leadership in a low carbon economy[M]. Routledge.
    Khanna N.2002.The Income Elasticity of Non-Point Source Air Pollutants: RevisitingtheEnvironmental Kuznets[J]. Economics Letters,77(3):387-392.
    Kilian B, Elgstrom O.2010. Still a green leader:The European Union's role in international climate negotiations[J]. Cooperation and Conflict,45:255-273.
    King D A.2004.Climate Change Science:Adapt, Mitigate, or Ignore?[J]. Science,1:176-177.
    Kinzig A P, Kammen D M.,1998. National Trajectories of Carbon Emissions:Analysis of Proposals to Foster the Transition to Low-carbon Economies[J].Global Environmental Change, 8(3):183-208.
    Kovanda J, Hak T.2007. What are the possibilities for graphical presentation of decoupling? An example of economy-wide material flow indicators in the Czech Republic[J]. Ecological Indicators,7(1):123-132.
    Lanoie P, Laplante B, Roy M,1998. Can Capital Markets Create Incentives for Pollution Control?[J]. Ecological Economics.26:31-41.
    Lantz V, Feng Q.2006. Assessing income, population, and technology impacts on CO2 emissions in Canada, where's the EKC?[J]. Ecological Economics,57:229-238.
    Lasswell H D, Kaplan A.1950. Power and society:A framework for political inquiry[M]. New Haven:Yale University Press.
    Liu Y.,2009. Exploring the Relationship between urbanization and energy consumption in China using ARDL (Autoregressive Distributed Lag) and FDM (Factor Decomposition Model)[J]. Energy,34:1846-1854.
    Lopez R.1994.The Environment as a Factor of Production:The Effects of Economic Growth and Trade Liberalization[J]. Journal of Environmental Economics.27:163-184.
    Malnes R.1995. "Leader" and "Entrepreneur" in International Negotiations:A Conceptual Analysis[J]. European Journal of International Relations,1(1):87-112.
    Markus P.2002.Technical Progress, StructuralChange, and the Environmental Kuznets Curve[J]. Ecological Economics,42:381-389
    Meehl G A, Stocker T F, Collins W D, et al.2007.Global climate projections[J].Climate change,747-845.
    Mehling M, Kulovesi K, de Cendra J.2013.Climate Law and Policy in the European Union: Accidental Success or Deliberate Leadership?[M]//Climate Change and the Law. Springer Netherlands,509-522.
    Metcalf G E, Weisbach D.2009. The Design of a Carbon Tax[J]. Harvard Environmental Law Review,33(2):499.
    Metcalf G E.2009. Tax policies for low-carbon technologies[J]. National Tax Journal,62(3): 519-533.
    Mishra, V., R. Smyth, and S. Sharma,2009. The energy-GDP nexus:Evidence from a panel of Pacific island countries[J]. Resource and Energy Economics,31:210-220.
    Moomaw W R, Unruh G C.1997. Are environmental Kuznets Curve misleading US? The case of CO2 emissions, special issue on Environmental Kuznets Curves[J]. Environmental and Development Economics,2:451-463.
    Munoz J I, Bunn D W.2013.Investment risk and return under renewable decarbonization of a power market[J]. Climate Policy,13(sup01):87-105.
    Nelson D, Pierpont B.2013. The Challenge of Institutional Investment in Renewable Energy[R/OL]. http://assets.fiercemarkets.com/public/sites/energy/reports/climatepolicyinitiative.pdf.2013-03-25.
    Nordhaus W.2005.Life after Kyoto:Alternative Approaches to Global Warming[R]. National Bureau of Economic Research.
    Oberthur S, Roche Kelly C.2008.EU Leadership in International Climate Policy: Achievements and Challenges[J]. The International Spectator,43(3):35-50
    O-Sung. Economic Growth and the Environment:the EKC Curve and Sustainable Development, an Endogenous Growth Model[D]. Washington:University of Washington.
    Parker L.2011.Climate change and the EU emissions trading scheme (ETS):Looking to 2020[M]. DIANE Publishing.
    Puliafito S E, Puliafito J L, Grand M C.2008. Modeling population dynamics and economic growth as competings pecies:An application to CO2 global emissions[J]. Ecological Economics, 65(3):602-615.
    Rayner T, Jordan A.2013.The European Union:the polycentric climate policy leader?[J]. Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews:Climate Change,4(2):75-90.
    Ru X J, Chen S F, Dong H X,2012b. An Empirical Study on Relationship between Economic Growth and Carbon Emissions[J]. Journal of Sustainable Development,5(8):44-51
    Ru X J, Chen S F, Liu Y, Su L Y.2012a. A Study on Evolution and Driving forces of Carbon. Dioxide Emissions[J]. Journal of Sustainable Development,5(5):111-120.
    Ru X J, Chen S F.2012.A Study on relationship between CO2 emissions and economic development in China based on dematerialization theory[J].Energy and Environment Research,2(2):37-44.
    Salman.M.2002.Interstates water disputes in India:an analysis of the settlement[J].Process Policy,4(3):223-237.
    Schreurs, M., Tiberghien, Y.2007.Multi-Level Reinforcement:Explaining European Union Leadership in Climate Change Mitigation[J]. Global Environmental Politics,7(4):19-46.
    Selden.T.M, Song D.1994.Environmental Quality and Development:Is There a Kuznets Curve for Air Pollution?[J]. Journal of Environmental EconomicsandManagement,27:147-162.
    Shafik N,S Bandyopadhyay.1992.Economic growth and environmental quality:time series and cross-country evidence[R].Washington,DC:World Bank. Background paper for the World Development Report
    Shi A.2003.The impact of population pressure on global carbon dioxide emissions, 1975-1996:Evidence from pooled cross-country data[J].Ecological Economics,44:29-42
    Sjostedt, G., & Penetrante, A. M. (Eds.).2013. Climate Change Negotiations:A Guide to Resolving Disputes and Facilitating Multilateral Cooperation[M]. Routledge.
    Skodvin, T., Andresen, S.2006.Leadership Revisited[J]. Global Environmental Politics, 6(3):13-27.
    Solana J.2003. A Secure Europe in a Better World-European Security Strategy[R/OL], http://www.iss.europa.eu/uploads/media/solanae.pdf.2003-12-23.
    Smith A.2013.The climate bonus:Co-benefits of climate policy[M].Routledge, Taylor & Francis.
    Stern N.2007. The Economics of Climate Change:The Stern Review[M]. Cambridge University Press.
    Sultan M, Fiske M, Stein T, et al.1999, Monitoring the urbanization of the Nile Delta, Egypt[J]. Ambio,28(ANL/ER/JA-32942).
    Tachibana J, Hirota K, GotoN et al.2008. A method for regional-scale material flow and decoupling analysis:A demonstration case study of Aichi prefecture, Japan[J]. Resources, Conservation and Recycling,52(12):1382-1390.
    Tapio P.2005. Towards a theory of decoupling:degrees of decoupling in the EU and case of road traffic in Finland between 1970 and 2001[J].Transport Policy,12:137-151.
    Taylor M S, Copeland B R.,2004. Trade, Growth and theEnvironment[J].Journal of Economic Literature,42:7-71.
    Tavoni M, De Cian E, Luderer G, et al.2012. The value of technology and of its evolution towards a low carbon economy[J]. Climatic change,114(1):39-57.
    Tol R S J.2013a.Carbon tax:Still the best way forward for climate policy[J]. Intereconomics, 48(2):70-71.
    Tol R S J.2013b.Targets for global climate policy:An Overview[J]. Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control,37(5):911-928.
    Tol R, Verde S F.2013. Fiscal limits on first-best climate policy:A CGE analysis for Europe[R/OL].http://www.sussex.ac.uk/economics/documents/wps-58-2013.pdf,2013-03-10.
    Urry J.2013. A low carbon economy and society[J]. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A:Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences,371(1986):1-15.
    Underdal, A.1994. Leadership theory:Rediscovering the arts of management. In International multilateral negotiation:Approaches to the management of complexity[M]. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass Publishers.
    Van Asselt H, Zelli F.2012.Connect the Dots:Managing the Fragmentation of Global Climate Governance[J]. Earth System Governance Working Paper, (25).
    V. Lantz, Q. Feng.2006.Assessing income, population, and technology impacts on CO2 emissions in Canada:Where's the EKC[J].Ecological Economics 57:229-238.
    Virkanen J.1998. Effect of Urbanization on Metal Deposition in the Bay of Toolonlahti, Southern Finland, Marine Pollution Bulletin[J]. Southern Finland 36(9):729-738.
    Vogler, J.2005.The European Contribution to Global Environmental Governance[J]. International Affairs,81(4):835-850.
    Wagner M.2008. The carbon Kuznets Curve:a cloudy picture emitted by bad econometrics?[J]. Resource and Energy Economics,30:388-408.
    Wallstroem M.,2009. The low-carbon economy-. A necessity and an opportunity[N/OL]. http://www.eu-un.europa.eu/articles/es/article 8970 es.htm.2013-04-11.
    Wang C, Chen J N, Zou J.2005. Decomposition of energy-related CO2 emission in China: 1957-2000[J]. Energy,30:73-83.
    Wei, B. R., H. Yagita, A. Inaba, and M.Sagisaka,2003.Urbanization impact on energy demand and CO2 emission in China[J].Journal of Chongqing University-English version,5:46-50.
    Young O R.1991. Political leadership and regime formation:On the development of institutions in international society[J].International Organization,45:281-309.
    CCICED.2009.2009中国发展低碳经济途径研究[M]//张坤民,等.低碳发展论.北京:中国环境科学出版社,1041-1067.
    托马斯,2009.理解公共政策(第12版)[M].北京:中国人民大学出版社.
    鲍健强,苗阳,陈锋.2008.低碳经济:人类经济发展方式的新变革[J].中国工业经济,4:153-160.
    薄燕,陈志敏.2011.全球气候变化治理中欧盟领导能力的弱化[J].国际问题研究,1:37-45.
    蔡林海.2009.低碳经济大格局[M].北京:经济科学出版社,第18-22页.
    财政部、国家发展改革委员会、国家能源局.2011.可再生能源发展基金征收使用管理暂行办法.http://zhs.mof.gov.cn/zhengwuxinxi/zhengcefabu/201112/t20111212_614767.html, 2011-11-29.
    财政部、国家发展改革委员会.2004.财政部国家发展改革委关于印发《节能产品政府采购实施意见》的通知,http://www.sdpc.gov.cn/hjbh/hijsjyxsh/t20050912_45899.htm,2004-12-17.
    财政部、国家环保总局.2006.财政部、国家环保总局联合印发《关于环境标志产品政府采购实施的意见》.http://www.jngp.gov.cn/jsp/cms/staticHtml/16805.html.2006-10-24.
    陈庆云.1995.公共政策分析及其历史沿革[J].行政论坛,(3):7-l0.
    陈立宏.2010.欧盟应对气候变化的财税政策[J].中国财政,5:20-28.
    陈劭锋,刘扬,邹秀萍,苏利阳,汝醒君.2009.二氧化碳排放演变驱动力的理论与实证研究[J].科学管理研究.1:45-50.
    陈劭锋,刘扬,苏利阳.2011.发展低碳经济需跨越能源消费或碳排放的三大高峰[J].科技促进发展.7:38-44.
    陈劭锋.2010.可持续发展管理的理论与实证研究:中国环境演变驱动力分析[D].中国科技大学.
    陈健鹏.2012.温室气体减排政策:国际经验及对中国的启示——基于政策工具演进的视角[J].中国人口、资源与环境.22(9):26-32.
    重庆市财政局、重庆市工商联(总商会)家具商会.2005.关于印发《重庆市办公家具政府采购指导意见》的通知.1http://www.cqagri.gov.cn/detail.asp?pubID=131939,2005-09-15.
    崔宏伟.2010.欧盟能源安全战略研究[M].北京:知识产权出版社,第11-14页.
    陈诗一.2010.节能减排与中国工业的双赢发展:2009-2049.[J].经济研究.3:129-143.
    戴维·伊斯顿.1993.政治体系:政治学研究状况[M].北京:商务印书馆.
    德内拉·梅多斯.2006.增长的极限[M].北京:机械工业出版社.
    董勤.2012.欧盟气候变化政策的能源安全利益驱动--兼析欧盟气候单边主义倾向[J].国外理论动态,2:71-77.
    傅聪.2010.欧盟应对气候变化治理研究[D].中国社会科学院研究生院.
    费勒尔·海迪.2006.比较公共行政(第6版)[M].北京:人民大学出版社.
    葛军.2007.特别代表解读“气候变化”——访外交部气候变化谈判特别代表于庆泰大使[J].世界知讽20:46-47.
    国务院办公厅.2007.国务院办公厅关于建立政府强制采购节能产品制度的通知.http://www.gov.cn/zwgk/2007-08/06/content_707549.htm.2007-08-06.
    国家环保总局.2006.我国将逐步推广政府绿色采购制度.http://www.zhb.gov.cn/gkml/hbb/qt/200910/t20091023_180041.htm.2006-11-22.
    2050中国能源和碳排放研究课题组.2009.2050中国能源和碳排放报告.[M].北京:科学出版社.
    国务院发展研究中心应对气候变化课题组.2009.当前发展低碳经济的重点与政策建议[J].经济观察8:13-15.
    韩玉军,陆旸.2007.经济增长与环境的关系——基于对CO2环境库兹涅茨曲线的实证研究[R].中国人民大学经济学院工作论文.
    胡秀莲,刘强,姜克隽.2007.关于我国碳排放问题的若干对策与建议[J].气候变化研究进展.12(4):l-8.
    胡振宇.2009.低碳经济的全球博弈和中国的政策演化[J].开放导报,5:15-19.
    江国成,程群.2011.万家企业节能行动启动5年或节约2.5亿吨标准煤[N/OL].人民网. http://finance.people.com.cn/GB/70846/16743898.html.
    姜克隽,庄幸,贺晨旻.2012.全球升温控制在2℃以内目标下中国能源与排放情景研究[J].中国能源.34(2):14-19.
    蒋萍,余厚强.2010.EKC拐点类型、形成过程及影响因素.[J].财经问题研究,(6):3-9.
    孔曙光,王宇平.2011.浅议欧盟环境政策在国际气候变化领域中的领导力及脆弱性[J].商品与质量,11:128-130.
    李坚明,孙一菱,庄敏芳.2005.台湾二氧化碳排放脱钩指标建立与评估[R].//两岸环境保护与与可持续发展研讨会论文[C].
    李齐云,商凯.2009.二氧化碳排放的影响因素分析与碳税减排政策设计[J].财政研究,10:41-44.
    李克国,魏国印,张宝安等.2003.环境经济学[M].北京:中国环境科学出版社,第6-8页.
    李楠,邵凯,王前进.2011.中国人口结构对碳排放量影响研究[J].中国人口·资源与环境.21(6):19-23.
    李丽平,田春秀.2009.欧盟气候政策有何新动向?[N].中国环境报,2009-01-12.
    李忠民,庆东瑞.2010.经济增长与二氧化碳脱钩实证研究:以山西省为例[J].福建论坛(人文科学版),2:67-72.
    李忠民,宋凯,孙耀华.2011.碳排放与经济增长脱钩指标的实证测度[J].统计与决策.14:86-88.
    林伯强,蒋竺均.2009.中国二氧化碳的环境库茨涅茨曲线预测及影响因素分析[J].管理世界,4:27-36.
    刘兰翠,范英,吴刚等.2005.温室气体减排政策问题研究综述[J].管理评论.17(10):46-54.
    刘青,刘传江.2009.低碳经济与绿色金融发展[J].今日财富,7:22-25.
    刘志林,戴亦欣,董长贵,齐晔.2009.低碳城市理念与国际经验[J].城市发展研究,6:1-7.
    刘竹,耿涌,薛冰,董会娟.2011.基于“脱钩”评价模式的低碳城市评价[J].中国人口·资源与环境,21(4):19-24.
    卢山冰,黄孟芳.2010.低碳产业政策工具的理论基础[N].光明日报.
    卢祖丹,赵定涛.2010.西部大开发对工业碳排放的影响解析[J].中国科技论坛,11:79-85.
    卢祖丹.2011.我国城镇化对碳排放的影响研究[J].中国科技论坛,7:134-140.
    卢祖丹.2011.我国经济发展及制度变迁对碳排放的影响研究.[D].中国科技大学,第10-12页.
    陆虹.2000.中国环境问题与经济发展的关系分析——以大气污染为例[J].财经研究,26(10):53-59.
    孟华.2010.提高能源有效利用是最重要的“能源”.新华网-经济参考报[N].http://jjckb.xinhuanet.com/gnyw/2010-04/19/content_217494.htm,2010-04-19.
    欧盟能源政策绿皮书主要内容.2006.中华人民共和国发展改革委网站,http://www.sdpc.gov.cn/nyjt/gjdt/t20060519_69404.htm,2006-05-16.
    潘家华.2009.怎样发展中国的低碳经济[J].绿叶,5:20-27.
    潘家华,陈迎.2009.碳预算方案:一个公平、可持续的国家气候制度框架[J].中国社会科学,5:83-98.
    清华大学气候政策研究中心.2011.中国低碳发展报告(201l-2012)[M].北京:社会科学文献出版社,第110-116页.
    清华大学气候政策研究中心.2012.中国低碳发展报告2013[M].北京:社会科学文献出版社,第152-160页.
    青岛市财政局、青岛市环境保护局.2005.山东省青岛市财政局、青岛市环境保护局关于发布 《绿色采购环保产品政府采购清单》(第一批) 的通知.http://www.110.com/fagui/law_108152.html.2015-12-17.
    渠慎宁,郭朝先.2010.基于STIRPAT模型的中国碳排放峰值预测研究[J].中国人口、资源与环境,20:122-126.
    任卫峰.2008.低碳经济与环境金融创新[J].上海经济研究,3:38-46.
    汝醒君,苏利阳.2009.基于15国经济增长与碳排放的脱钩研究[J].可持续发展研究,l:39-43.
    汝醒君,苏利阳,陈茜.2009.基于减物质化的中国碳排放分析[J].生态经济,12:39-42.
    汝醒君,陈茜,严晓星.2010.亚洲国家低碳经济发展的政策经验分析[J].科技促进发展,9:20-24.
    汝醒君,陈茜,严晓星.2011.国际气候谈判中的博弈---以哥本哈根会议为例[J].科技促进发展,5:18-24.
    桑玉成,刘百鸣.1992,公共政策学导论[M].上海:复旦大学出版社,第6-13页.
    苏明,傅志华.2009.碳税的国际经验与借鉴环境经济[J].9:29-32.
    苏明,傅志华.2009.我国开征碳税的效果预测和影响评价[J].经济研究参考,72:23-27.
    涂晓芳.2011.比较公共政策[M].北京:北京航天航空大学出版社,第2,6-8页.
    王硕,陆绮雯.2010.低碳经济:助力亚洲经济转型[N].解放日报.2010-06-08.
    王灿,陈吉宁,邹骥.2005.基于CGE模型的CO2减排对中国经济的影响[J].清华大学学报(自然科学版).45(1):1621-1624.
    王峰.2010.中国能源消费与经济发展脱钩管理研究[D].北京工业大学.
    王锋,吴丽华,杨超.2010.中国经济发展中碳排放增长的驱动因素研究[J].经济研究,2:123-136.
    王军.2006.如何开展政府绿色采购制度[N].政府采购信息网http://www.chinabidding.com/zxzx-detail-409062.html,2006-04-07.
    王鹤鸣,岳强,陆钟武.2011.中国1998年-2008年资源消耗与经济增长的脱钩分析[J].资 源科学,33(9):175-177.
    王韬.2008.中国的低碳经济未来[M]//张坤民,等.低碳经济论.北京:中国环境科学出版社,第127-142页.
    王淑敏.2011.低碳经济发展水平评价指标体系研究及策略分析.[D].北京:北京交通大学.
    王铮,朱永彬,刘昌新,马晓哲.2010.最优增长路径下的中国碳排放估计[J].地理学报.65(12):1559-1568.
    魏一鸣,范英,王毅等.2006.与限控CO2排放有关的若干指标分析[J].中国人口、资源与环境.2(1):15-20.
    吴文洁,王小妮.2011.陕西碳排放与经济增长关系研究——基于“EKC”与“脱钩”理论[J].西南石油大学学报,13(6):69-75.
    伍启元.1989.公共政策[M].香港:商务印书馆(香港)公司,第10-15页.
    谢来辉.2012.为什么欧盟积极领导应对气候变化[J].世界经济与政治.8:72-84.
    解振华.2009.中国应对气候变化坚持六项基本原则[N].新华网.http://news.xinhuanet.com:80/fortune/2009-06/26/content 11608200.htm.2009-06-26.
    厦门技术性贸易措施信息网.2010.欧盟多种政策扶持新能源产业“绿色壁垒”应警惕[N].http://www.xmtbt-sps.gov.cn/detail.asp?id=24986,2010-10-14.
    邢继俊,赵刚.2007.中国要大力发展低碳经济.[J].中国科技论坛10:15-20.
    邢继俊,赵刚,程建润.2008.加快工作部署迎接我国低碳经济时代[J].中国科技产业.4:5-8.
    刘江,尚军.2009.《哥本哈根协议》——全球应对气候变化新起点[N].新华网.http://news.xinhuanet.com/world/2009-12/24/content 12699975_3.htm.2009-12-24.
    杨金林,陈立宏.2010.国外应对气候变化的财政政策及其经验借鉴[J].环境经济.6:18-26.
    俞岚,周锐.2011.中国称德班会议取得五大成果巴厘路线图谈判未完成[N].中国新闻网.http://www.cnstock.com:80/index/zhuangti/2011 dbdh/2011 db/201112/1732330.htm.2011-12-11
    杨兴.2005.《气候变化框架公约》研究:兼论气候变化问题与国际气候变化法[D].湖北:武汉大学.第235页.
    曾刚,万志宏.2009.国际碳金融市场:现状、问题与前景[J].国际金融研究,10:20-25.
    邹敏,张璐.2012.论中国碳税制度的建立[J].江苏大学学报(社会科学版),6:18-26.
    张焕波.2010.中国、美国和欧盟气候政策分析[M].北京:社会科学文献出版社.
    张金马.2004.公共政策分析:概念、过程、方法[M].北京:人民出版社,第3页.
    张坤民.1997.可持续发展论[M].北京:中国环境科学出版社,第25-26页.
    张坤民.2008.低碳世界中的中国:地位、挑战与战略.中国人口、资源与环境[J].18(3):1-7.
    张坤民.2009.中国走低碳发展之路:必要性与可行性[M]//张坤民,等.低碳发展论.北京:中国环境科学出版社,第67-81页.
    张雷.2003.中国一次能源消费的碳排放区域格局变化[J].地理研究,25(1):1-9.
    赵敏,张卫国,俞立中.2009.上海市能源消费碳排放分析[J].环境科学研究,22(8):984-989.
    赵勇强,熊倪娟.2010.我国可再生能源经济激励政策回顾与建议.经济与管理[J].4:22-27.
    赵一平,孙启宏,段宁.2006.中国经济发展与能源消费响应关系研究--基于相对“脱钩”与“复钩”理论的实证研究[J].科研管理,27(3):128-134.
    中国科学院可持续发展战略研究组.2009.2009中国可持续发展报告:探索中国特色的低碳道路[M].北京:科学出版社.
    中国科学院可持续发展战略研究组.2010.中国可持续发展战略报告:绿色发展与创新[M].科学出版社.
    中国科学院可持续发展战略研究组.2011.2011中国可持续发展战略报告:实现绿色的经济转型[M].北京:科学出版社.
    中国科学院可持续发展战略研究组.2012.2012中国可持续发展战略报告:全球视野下的中国可持续发展[M].北京:科学出版社.
    中国科学院可持续发展战略研究组.2013.2013中国可持续发展战略报告:未来10年的生态文明之路[M].北京:科学出版社.
    中华人民共和国国务院新闻办公室.2012.中国能源政策白皮书2012.[R/OL].http://www.gov.cn/jrzg/2012-10/24/content 2250377.htm.2012-10-24.
    高健.2010.“坎昆答卷”发出积极信号,达成两项主要决议[N/OL].中国证券报.http://www.chinanews.com/cj/2010/12-13/2716647.shtml.2010-12-13.
    中国环境与发展国际合作委员会.2008.中国发展低碳经济途径研究(国合会政策研究报告2008)[R/OL].http://wenku.baidu.com/view/0e774ac189eb172ded63b761.html.
    钟茂初,张学刚.2010.环境库兹涅兹曲线理论及研究的批评综论.[J].中国人口、资源与环境,20(2):62-67.
    仲云云,仲伟周.2012.我国碳排放的区域差异及驱动因素分析——基于脱钩和三层完全分解模型的实证研究[J].财经研究,38(2):123-134.
    周鹏,周德群,袁虎.2012.低碳发展政策:国际经验与中国策略[M].北京:经济科学出版社.第3-6页.
    周宏春.2012.低碳经济学:低碳经济理论和发展路径[M].北京:机械工业出版社.
    庄贵阳.2005.中国经济低碳发展的途径与潜力分析[J].国际技术经济研究,3:79-87.
    庄贵阳.2007.低碳经济:气候变化背景下中国的发展之路[M].北京:气象出版社.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700