用户名: 密码: 验证码:
第三产业发展对资源型区域经济转型的促进机制研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
从20世纪中叶开始,国内外众多资源型区域在经济、社会、环境等多个领域遭遇发展困境,这使得资源型区域的经济转型问题逐渐得到了各国学者的广泛关注。对于正处于改革发展关键时期的中国,资源型区域进行经济转型既是贯彻“科学发展观”、实施可持续发展战略的客观要求,又是我国转变经济增长方式的一个缩影。因此,对我国资源型区域经济转型的方式和路径进行研究具有重大的理论和现实意义。
     本文从“第三产业”的视角切入资源型区域经济转型问题,提出发展第三产业能有效促进资源型区域的经济转型,在论证过程中采用了理论研究和实证研究相结合的方法。在理论层面,本文对资源型区域发展缺陷和第三产业的外部性进行了详细梳理,证明了第三产业的外部性特征与资源型区域的转型目标存在着对应关系,通过发展第三产业能够有效地缓和、解决资源型区域的各种既有问题,进而促进资源型区域经济转型和可持续发展。在实证层面,本文通过信息熵评价法在省、市两个层面对我国的区域发展状况进行了系统评价,并依据评价结果对资源型区域、第三产业发达地区两个组别进行了比较分析;本文还通过计量经济学的方法研究了不同地区经济、社会、环境发展状况与资源、第三产业之间的关系;实证结果显示发展第三产业能有效稳定资源型区域转型和产业结构调整带来的经济冲击,对资源型区域的社会、环境状况起到良好的弥补及修复作用,与理论研究的结论基本一致。
     本文在一般性研究的基础上,对山西省长治地区的具体案例进行了研究,发现长治地区转型效率相对低下是由于第三产业发展不足导致的。在研究区域经济社会特点、总结回顾转型经验、分析转型评价结果的基础上,本文对长治地区第三产业的发展路径提出了战略建议。
     在文章架构上,本文第一章为绪论;第二章介绍了与资源型区域转型相关的理论研究成果和实践经验;第三章从理论逻辑的角度阐述了第三产业发展对资源型区域经济转型促进机制;第四章是第三产业对资源型区域经济转型促进机制的实证探讨;第五章是长治地区的个案分析;第六章是结论和研究展望。
     本文的创新点主要体现在对“资源型区域经济转型”问题的研究视角和研究方法上。首先,论文对资源型区域经济转型的目标进行了更加全面、具体的界定,不仅仅关注资源型区域的经济增长问题,还对其社会、生态状况予以充分重视,系统地将就业、城镇发展、民生、生态环境等内容纳入到转型的目标体系中;其次,论文在转型研究中更关注第三产业发展,将第三产业和资源型区域经济转型结合起来,从理论和实证两个层面阐述了第三产业发展对资源型区域经济转型的促进机制;最后,从第三产业发展入手,探讨长治地区经济转型的战略路径,通过数据包络的分析方法论证了长治地区第三产业发展存在缺陷,并结合长治地区的实际情况就其第三产业发展提出了战略建议。
From the mid-20th century, many domestic and foreign resource-based regionsencounter the economic, social, environmental and other development difficulties,which makes the economic transition of the resource-based region gradually getextensive attention of scholars from various countries. For resource-based regionaleconomies in China, which are in a critical period of reform and development, thetransition is the objective requirements of the sustainable development strategy toimplement the “Scientific Concept of Development”, which also provides amicrocosm of the transition of economic growth mode. Therefore, the study on theway and the path of regional economic transition of China's resource-based areas hasgreat theoretical and practical significance.
     From the point of the “transition path”, this paper proposes that developingtertiary industry is an effective promotion of the economic transition inresource-based regions, using a combination of theoretical method and empiricalmethod. At the theoretical level, this article details combing resource-based regionaldevelopment defects and the tertiary industry external to prove the correspondencebetween the external characteristics of the tertiary industry and the transition target ofthe resource-based region and concudes that through the development of tertiaryindustries, problems in the resource-based area can be eased and even solved andthen resource-based regions can enjoy economic transition and sustainabledevelopment. At the empirical level, through the system information entropyevaluation method, this paper evaluates regional development of the provinces andmunicipalities, the two regional levels in China, and based on the results of theevaluation, the two groups, the resource-based regions and the tertiary industrydeveloped regions, are compared. In this paper, through econometric methods, it isalso studied that the relationship between the economic, social and environmentaldevelopment and the resources, the tertiary industry in different areas. Empiricalresults show that the development of tertiary industry has a stabilizing effect on theeconomic impact of resource-based regional transition and industrial restructuring,which plays a good part to improve the social and environment state of theresource-based areas, which is consistent with the conclusions of the theoreticalresearch.
     On the basis of general studies, this paper focuses on the specific case ofChangzhi area in Shanxi Province. The transition efficiency of Changzhi area isrelatively low, due to the insufficient development of the tertiary industry.Recommendations are made on the path of the tertiary industry development strategyof Changzhi area, based on the study of economic and social characteristics, a reviewof the experience of transition, and the analysis of the evaluation results of transitions.
     The first chapter is an introduction; second chapter describes the results oftheoretical studies and practical experience of the transition of resource-based regions;from the point of theory, chapter3explained promotion mechanisms of tertiaryindustry development to the resource-based regional economic transition and chapter4discusses the promotion mechanism empiricaly; chapter5provides a case study onChangzhi area; chapter6contains conclusions and research prospects.
     The innovation of this paper is mainly reflected in the "transition ofresource-based region" perspective and research methods. Firstly, the transition targetof the resource-based region is defined more comprehensively and specificly, not onlyconcerned about the region’s economic growth, but also its social, ecologicalconditions to give adequate priority to the employment, urban development, people'slivelihood and ecological environment into the the transition target system. Secondly,among the transition research, this paper is more concerned about the specific path ofthe transition, combines the study of the tertiary industry and the resource-basedregion transition, and studies the promotion mechanism of the development of tertiaryindustries to the transition of the resource-based regions. Finally, from the perspectiveof the development of the tertiary industry, this paper explores the strategic path oftransition of Changzhi area, using data envelopment analysis, and demonstrates thatthe development of the tertiary industry in Changzhi area defects and providesstrategic advice on the development of its tertiary industry based the actucal situationin Changzhi area.
引文
[1] Browning H. c, Singelmann J. The Emergence of a Service Society: Demographic andSociological Aspects of the Sectoral Transformation of the Labor Force in the USA[M].Springfield,VA: National Technical Information Service,1975.
    [2] Singelmann Joachim. From Agriculture to Services: The Transformation of IndustrialEmployment[M]. Beverly Hills: Sage Publications,1978.
    [3]尚慧丽.服务业发展与产业结构优化关系的实证研究[J].对外经贸.2010(12):60-61.
    [4]段杰、阎小培.粤港生产性服务业合作发展研究[J].地域研究与开发.2003(3):26-30.
    [5]林聚任、刘玉安.社会科学研究方法[M].山东:山东人民出版社.1998.
    [6] Kuznets. Simon. The State as a Unit in Study of Economic Growth[J]. The Journal ofEconomic History. Cambridge University Press.1951. vol.11(01):25-41.
    [7] Kuznets. Simon. Modern Economic Growth: Findings and Reflections[J]. American EconomicReview. American Economic Association. vol.1973.63(3):247-258.
    [8] Rostow, W. W. The Stages of Economic Growth: A Non-Communist Manifesto[M]. CambridgeUniv Press.1960.
    [9] Baumol. W. Macroeconomics of Unbalanced Growth: The Anatomy of Urban Crisis[J].American Economic Review.1967.53(3):415-26.
    [10] Hollis B. Chenery, S. Robinson and M. Syrquin. Industrialization and Growth: AComparative Study[M]. New York: Oxford University Press.1986. Chapter11.
    [11] Echevarria, C. Echevarria. Changes in sectoral composition associated with economicgrowth[J]. International Economic Review.1997,38(2):431–452.
    [12] Kongsamut, P. P., Rebelo, S. T., Xie, D. Beyond Balanced Growth[C]. CEPR DiscussionPaper1693: Centre for Economic Policy Research, London.2001.
    [13] Meckl, J. Structural Change and Generalized Balanced Growth[J], Journal of Economics,2002,77(3):241-266.
    [14] Syrquin, M. Patterns of Structural Changes[C]. Handbook of Development Economics.Northe-Holland, Amsterdam,1988.
    [15] Bonatti, L. Felice, G. Structural Change and Economic Dynamics[J]. Journal of CleanerProduction.2008,13:455-467.
    [16]刘伟、李绍荣.产业结构与经济增长.中国工业经济[J].2005(4):61-68.
    [17]朱慧明、韩玉启.产业结构与经济增长关系的实证分析[J].运筹与管理.2003(2).
    [18]胡晓鹏.产业结构变迁视角下经济增长的系统性分析[J].财经科学.2004(1):87-91.
    [19]刘伟、张辉.中国经济增长中的产业结构变迁和技术进步[J].经济研究.2008(11):4-15.
    [20]李懿洋.甘肃省产业结构与经济增长的灰色关联分析[J].企业经济.2011(5):20-23.
    [21] Clark, C. The Condistions of Economics Progress[R]. Macmillan, London,1940.
    [22]胡鞍钢.中国城镇失业状况分析[J].管理世界.1998(4).
    [23]吴敬琏.怎样实现经济增长方式的转变[J].中国创业投资与高科技.2005(10):8-9.
    [24]刘世锦.支付改革成本,推动企业转制[J].管理世界.2005(8):3-5+32.
    [25]简新华、余江.重新重工业化不等于粗放增长和走旧型工业化道路[J].学术月刊.2006(5):88-95.
    [26]蔡昉、张车伟.就业弹性的变化趋势研究[J].中国工业经济.2002(5).
    [27]魏作磊.对第三产业发展带动我国就业的实证分析[J].财贸经济.2004(3):80-85.
    [28]陈佳贵、刘树成、汪同三、沈利生、万东华.中国经济形势分析与预测2006年秋季报告[R].2007年中国社会经济形势分析与预测国际研讨会论文集.2006年12月。
    [29] Lewis, W. A. Economic Development with Unlimited Supplies of Labour[J]. MancbesterSchool of Economic and Social Studies.1954,22,139-191.
    [30] Swamy, D. S. Statistical Evidence of Balanced and Unbalanced Growth[J]. Review ofEconomics and Statistics.1967(49):288-303.
    [31]李成贵、赵帮宏.农民收入分配基尼系数分解模型——兼论江苏省农村产业结构变动对农民收入分配差距的影响[J].农业技术经济.1993(03):18-21+25.
    [32]邵宜航、刘雅南.二元经济的结构转变与增长分析[J].数量经济技术经济研究.2007(10):3-13.
    [33]刘渝琳、彭吉伟.服务业产业内贸易对城乡居民收入差距的影响[J].经济问题探索.2010(4):1-6.
    [34]许海平、宋树仁.对外贸易、FDI、产业结构、全要素生产率与城乡居民收入差距的动态关系研究——基于非参数Malmquist指数[J].河北科技大学学报(社会科学版).2011(1):1-6.
    [35] UNDP(United Nations Development Programme). Human Development Report1992[R].Oxford University Press, Oxford/New York.1992.
    [36] Barbier, E. B. The Concept of Sustainable Economic Development[J]. EnvironmentalConservation.1987, Vol.14No.2,101-110.
    [37] Frosch, R.A., N. Gallopoulos. Strategies for manufacturing[J]. Scientific American.1989,261(3):144-152.
    [38] Turner, R. K. Sustainability: Principles and Practice[C]. Sustainable EnvironmentalEconomics and Management: Principles and Practice. Belhaven Press, New York/London.1990.
    [39] Grossman, M., Krueger, B. Environmental Impacts of a North American Free TradeAgreement[J]. NBER Working Papers3914, National Bureau of Economic Research.1991.
    [40] Innis, H.A. Essays in Canadian Economic Historu[M]. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.1956.
    [41] Lucas, R.A. Mine town, Milltown, Rail town: Life in Canadian Communities of SingleIndustry [M]. Toronto: University of Toronto Press,1971:31-39.
    [42] Bradbury, J.H. The impact of industrial cycles in the mining sector[J]. International Journal ofUrban and Regional Research,1984,8(3):311-331.
    [43]0'Faireheallaigh, C. Economic base and employment structure in northern territory miningtowns [A]. Resource Communities: Settlement and Workforces Issues[C]. CSIRO, Australia,1988:221-236.
    [44] Bradbury, J.H. Living with Boom and Cycles: New Towns on the Resource Frontier inGanada. Resource Communities[C]. CSIRO, Australia,1988:3-19.
    [45] Houghton, D. S. Long Distance Communting: a New Approach to Mining in Australia[J].Geographical Journal.1993,159(3).
    [46] Hayter,R., Barnes, T.J. Labour Market Segmentation, Flexibility and Recession: A BritishColombian Case Study[J]. Environment and Planing.1992(10):333-353.
    [47] Ironside, R.G., Randall, J.E. Single-Industry Resource Communities: Barometers ofCommunity Change in Canada[J]. The Canadian Geographer40,1996:17-35.
    [48] Auty, R.M. Sustaining Development in Mineral Economies: the Resource Curse Thesis[M].London: Rout ledge,1993.
    [49] Auty, R.M. The Political Economy of Resource-driven Growth[J]. European EconomicReview.2001,839-846.
    [50] Corden, W.M., Neary, J.P., Booming Sector and de-industrialization in a Small OpenEconomy [J]. Economic Journal,1982(92):825-848.
    [51] Sachs, J., Warner, A., Natural Resource Abundance and Economic Growth[J]. NBERWorking Paper series5398.1995,12:1-47.
    [52] Sachs, J., Warner, A., Warner. Fundamental Sources of Long-run Growth[J]. AmericanEconomic Review.1997(87):184-188.
    [53] Sachs, J., Warner, A., Natural Resource and Economic Development: the Curse of NaturalResources[J]. European Economic Review.2001,(45):827-838.
    [54] Gylfason, T. Natural Resources, Education and Economic Development[J]. EuropeanEconomic Review.2001,(45):847-859.
    [55] Aiezki, R. Can the Natural Resource Be Turned Into Blessing? The Role of Trade Policiesand Institutions[C]. IMF working paper.2007, No55.
    [56] Isham, J.,Woodeoek, M., pritehett, L.,Busby, G. The Varieties of Resource Experience:Natural resource Export Structures and the Political Economic Growth[J] The World BankEconomic Review.2005,19(2):141-174.
    [57] Murshed, S.M. When Does Natural Resource Abundance Lead to A Resource Curse[Z]. EEPDiscussion Paper.2004,04-01.
    [58] Stijns, J.P. Natural Resource Abundance and Human Capital Aceumulation[J]. WorldDevelopment.2006,34(6):106-108.
    [59]陈林生、李刚.资源禀赋、比较优势与区域经济增长[J].财经问题研究.2004(4).
    [60]徐康宁、韩剑.中国区域经济的“资源诅咒”效应:地区差距的另一种解释[J].经济学家.2005(6):96-102.
    [61]胡援成、肖德勇.经济发展门槛与自然资源诅咒——基于我国省际层面的面板数据实证研究[J].管理世界.2007(4):15-23+171.
    [62]张菲菲、刘刚、沈镭.中国区域经济与资源丰度相关性研究[J].中国人口、资源与环境.2007(4):19-24.
    [63]陈仲常、章翔.双视角下地区能源状况与经济增长关系研究——基于省际面板数据的实证分析[J].经济经纬.2008(3):54-57.
    [64]邵帅、杨莉莉.自然资源丰裕、资源产业依赖与中国区域经济增长[J].管理世界.2010(9):26-4.
    [65]邵帅、杨莉莉.自然资源开发、内生技术进步与区域经济增长[J].经济研究.2011(S2):112-123.
    [66]傅利平、王中亚.资源诅咒与资源型城市[J].城市问题.2010(11):2-8.
    [67] Marsh, B. Continuity and decline in the anthracite towns of Pennsylvania[J]. Annals of theAssoeiation of Ameriean Geographers.1987,77(3):337-352.
    [68]“资源枯竭矿业城市就业问题研究”课题组,资源枯竭矿业城市就业问题研究[R],经济研究参考,2005(48)。
    [69] Atkinson, A.B., Increased Income Inequality in OECD Countries and the RedistributiveImpact of the Government Budget[C]. Research Paper202, World Institute for DevelopmentEconomics Research.2003.
    [70] Adekoya, A.E. Rural and Urban youth participation in community development in southwestNigeria[J]. Global Approaches to Extension Practices.2009,14(1&2):21-28.
    [71]杜凯、周勤、蔡银寅.自然资源丰裕、环境管制失效与生态“诅咒”[J].经济地理.2009(2):290-297.
    [72]鲁金萍.广义“资源诅咒”的理论内涵与实证检验[J].中国人口·资源与环境.2009(1):133-138.
    [73]柳博会、严金明.煤炭城市农村居民点整理的驱动力与问题研究——以淮北市为例[J].城市发展研究.2010(4).91-94.
    [74] Bradbury J.H., I. St. Martin.Winding Down a Quebec Mining Town: A case Study ofSchefferville[J]. Canadian Geographer.2002,2(2).
    [75] David, D.S. Economic Growth and Urbanization in Developing Areas[M]. London and NewYork.1990.
    [76] Stark, D. Limited genetic diversity among genotypes of Enterocytozoon bieneusi strainsisolated from HIV-infected patients from Sydney, Australia[J]. Journal of Medical Microbiology.2009, vol.58no.3,355-357.
    [77]岳娜.资源型城市转型过程中服务业发展及空间布局研究[D],首都师范大学.2007.
    [78]齐建珍、白翎.煤炭工业城市要综合发展——抚顺、阜新两市经济发展对比的启示[J].煤炭经济研究.1987(1):9-11.
    [79]沈镭.大庆市可持续发展的问题与对策[J].中国人口、资源与环境.1998(2).
    [80]刘云刚.大庆市资源型产业结构转型对策研究[J].经济地理.2000(5).
    [81]张米尔、武春友.资源型城市产业转型障碍与对策研究[J].经济理论与经济管理.2001(2):35-38.
    [82]王广凤、张军、刘家顺.资源型城市产业转型与可持续发展问题的探讨[C].中国企业管理研究会2004年年会论文集.2004年9月.
    [83]王诚.资源型城市快速发展与生态环境保护的思考[J].资源·产业.2005(6):32-34.
    [84]吴雨霏.浅谈我国资源型城市转型以及三种转型模式[J].中国矿业.2010(1):55-57.
    [85]张冬冬.我国资源型城市产业转型研究[D].中国地质大学(北京).2008.
    [86]李雨潼.我国资源型城市转型问题研究[D].吉林大学.2005.198-199.
    [87]陈厚义.中国区域经济发展的“资源陷阱”及对策研究[D].武汉理工大学.2009.55.
    [88] Krueger, A.O. The political economy of the rent-seeking society[J], American EconomicReview.1974(64):291-303.
    [89] Papyakis, E.,Gerlagh, R. The Resource Curse Hypothesis and Its Transmission Channels[J].Journal of Comparative Economics.2004(32)181-193.
    [90] Papyakis, E.,Gerlagh, R. Resource Abundance and Economic Growth in the United States[J].European Economic Review.2006(4):253-282.
    [91] Warren R L. The Community in America[M]. Chicago: Rand McNally College Publishing.1963:133-142.
    [92]刘晶、汪继福.我国资源枯竭型城市的就业问题研究[J].辽宁工学院学报.2006(8).
    [93]黄少军.服务业与经济增长[M].北京:经济科学出版社.2000.
    [94]顾乃华、毕斗斗、任旺兵.生产性服务业与制造业互动发展:文献综述[J].经济学家。2006(6):35-41.
    [95]李江帆.产业结构高级化与第三产业现代化[J].中山大学学报(社会科学版).2005(4):124-130.
    [96]王雅莉.城市化经济运行分析[M].上海:上海三联书店.2004.
    [97]黄维兵.现代服务业经济理论与中国服务业发展[M].成都:西南财经大学出版社,2003.
    [98]李江帆.中国第三产业的战略地位和发展方向[J].财贸经济.2004(1):65-73+97.
    [99]徐康宁、王剑.自然资源丰裕程度与经济发展水平关系的研究[J].经济研究.2006(1):78-89.
    [100]邱苑华.管理决策与应用嫡学[M].北京:机械工业出版社,2001.
    [101]徐君.基于熵理论的资源型城市转型与产业演替机理研究[D].西南交通大学.2004.
    [102]饶扬德.企业经营绩效的嫡权系数评价方法及其应用[J].工业技术经济.2004,23(4):100-102.
    [103]于艳萍、李智.区域生态文明建设协同发展评价方法研究[J].福建行政学院学报.2012(6):12-20+32.
    [104]周薇、李筱菁.基于信息熵理论的综合评价方法[J].科学技术与工程.2010(23):5839-5843.
    [105]程晓娟.资源、环境两维视角下区域生态效率DEA评价[J].当代经济管理.2013(2):63-68.
    [106]柯健、李超.基于DEA聚类分析的中国各地区资源、环境与经济协调发展研究[J].中国软科学.2005(2).
    [107]董锋、龙如银、李晓晖.考虑环境因素的资源型城市转型效率分析——基于DEA方法和面板数据[J].长江流域资源与环境.2012(5):519-524.
    [108]王敏.地区主导产业选择的AHP模型及其应用[J].重庆师范学院学报(自然科学版).2001,18(4):44-47.
    [109]魏丽君、孙虎.长治市旅游资源及功能分区研究[J].干旱区资源与环境.2012(3):194-199.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700