用户名: 密码: 验证码:
政府卫生支出效率及其改进研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
基本医疗卫生服务关系到人们的健康,是重大民生问题。面对卫生事业发展严重滞后于经济发展的局面,我国规划在2020年实现“人人享有基本医疗卫生服务”的目标。政府希望通过新一轮医疗卫生改革的推进尽快达到这个目标。新医改方针定位于“政府主导”,并将政府卫生支出作为“政府主导”的重要渠道,明确提出要建立政府主导的多元卫生投入机制。新医改推行至今3年,政府卫生支出增长很快,但其迅速增长的规模是否适度?其结构配置和资金的具体使用是否有效率?整个政府卫生支出是否带来了显著的健康改善?这已成为各界关注的焦点。研究政府卫生支出的效率及其改进对于基本医疗卫生服务共享目标顺利实施和社会经济包容性增长的实现有重要的理论和现实意义。
     在新医改方案推进初期,本文结合公共经济学与卫生经济学的相关理论,选择健康改善的视角,在构建政府卫生支出效率体系的基础上,建立本文的理论分析框架,从经济增长、财政分权、人口特征等方面分析政府卫生支出效率的影响机制并对此进行全面的实证检验。通过系统研究我国政府卫生支出的规模效率、城乡结构效率、供需结构效率和健康生产效率,本文力图为政府部门提供有针对性的政策建议,为建立覆盖城乡居民的基本医疗卫生服务体系、改善人们健康,达到人人享有基本医疗卫生服务的目标提供理论和政策支撑。
     首先,本文在系统梳理国内外相关研究成果的基础上,从规模效率、结构效率、生产效率三个层次构建了政府卫生支出效率体系,并选择经济增长、财政分权、人口特征三个方面对政府卫生支出效率的影响机制进行研究,从而构建统一的分析框架与理论平台。其中,经济增长通过影响政府卫生支出供给、政府卫生支出需求和技术进步来影响政府卫生支出效率;财政分权通过政府竞争、地方政府的信息优势和财权事权分配来影响政府卫生支出效率;人口特征则主要通过人口规模、人口结构和人口素质影响政府卫生支出效率。
     其次,本文着重对政府卫生支出的规模效率、城乡结构效率、供需结构效率和健康生产效率的影响因素进行了全面的实证检验。论文使用面板数据建立政府卫生支出规模效率的影响因素模型,发现对政府卫生支出规模效率影响最大的是经济增长和财政分权。其中经济增长对政府卫生支出规模效率有显著促进作用,而财政分权对其具有显著负向影响。其他有较显著正向影响的因素有环境污染、城镇化率和住院分娩率。论文使用偏最小二乘回归法检验了政府卫生支出城乡结构效率和供需结构效率的影响因素,发现政策因素、经济增长、卫生因素(传染病死亡率、传染病发生率、每千农村人口卫生技术人员数及医疗机构床位数)有利于提高城乡结构效率,而财政分权和环境污染则不利于提高城乡结构效率;有利于提高政府卫生支出供需结构效率的因素有经济增长、卫生因素(每千人口医疗机构床位数及卫生技术人员数)和人口素质等,不利于提高供需结构效率的因素有城镇化水平和传染病发生率。政府卫生支出健康生产效率的影响因素研究则发现,财政分权不利于健康生产效率的提高,而经济增长、人口密度及城市化率则与其存在不显著的正相关关系。上述实证分析验证了前文的理论分析。
     此外,在政府卫生支出规模效率分析中,本文通过建立政府卫生支出最优规模的生产函数模型,指出中国政府卫生支出具有生产性,其增长可以促进经济增长;中国政府卫生支出的最优规模是占GDP的9.6%,由此判断目前中国政府卫生支出规模仍可以适度增长。在政府卫生支出结构效率分析中,本文采用区域城乡双维度泰尔指数对政府卫生支出城乡结构的均等性水平进行了测算,结果显示城乡政府卫生支出不均等是我国政府卫生支出不均等的主要原因;本部分还发现政府卫生支出城乡差异在高分位数上对城乡收入差距有显著影响。本文使用DEA方法对1990年、2000年和2010年政府卫生支出健康生产效率进行了测算,发现不同年度处于前沿面的省份基本一致,远离前沿面的省份存在较大差别,总体而言政府卫生支出的健康产出效率不断提高,且该效率在区域间的差异较为显著。
     基于上述理论分析与实证检验,本文从完善财政分权制度、保障政府卫生支出规模适度增长、优化政府卫生支出结构效率和提高政府卫生支出健康生产效率等四个方面提出了改进政府卫生支出效率的相关政策建议,希望能为政府拟定有效的卫生政策,建立覆盖城乡居民的基本医疗卫生服务体系提供政策支撑。
The basic health care service is an important livelihood issue in China, whichconcerns the population health. As health care is lagging behind economicdevelopment in China, the government plans to achieve the goal of “universal basichealth care coverage” by2020through implementing the new round health carereform. The proposal for this reform centers around the dominant role of government,which sets the government health spending as the key channel of this dominance andexplicitly put forward the objective to establish a multi-resource fund system. Withthe new health care reform being implementing for3years up until now, thegovernment health spending grows fast in real terms. However, there are still quite afew questions to be addressed, i.e. whether the scale of government health spending isappropriate; whether the structure distribution is effective; whether the fund is usedefficiently and whether the whole input of government spending on health brings theimprovement of population health. All these concerns people working in differentareas. The research of this topic “the efficiency of government health spending and itsimprovement” will have pivotal theoretic and policy implications for the achievementof the goal of the universal basic health care coverage and the inclusive growth ofsocial economic development in China.
     This background that the implementation of the reform is still at its initial stageprovides the author an ideal opportunity to explore the issues mentioned above.Integrating the theories of public economics and health economics and choosing theperspective of health improvement, this paper establishes a theoretical framework andanalyses the determinants of government health spending efficiency in terms ofeconomic growth, fiscal decentralization, demographical characteristics etc. byempirical approaches, which is based on the analysis of a system of governmenthealth spending efficiency. By systematically studying of the scale efficiency,structural efficiency (between rural and urban areas and between supply and demandside respectively) and productive efficiency of government health spending, theauthor attempts to draw some policy implications of providing a theoretical andpolicy foundation for the establishment of a basic health care system covering ruraland urban residents, improving the population health and achieving the goal ofuniversal coverage of health care.
     Firstly, this paper studies related literatures both home and abroad, andestablishes a system of government health spending efficiency from three aspects, i.e.scale efficiency, structural efficiency and productive efficiency. Under this basis, itinvestigates the theoretical mechanism for the determinants of scale efficiency,structural efficiency and productive efficiency of government health spending interms of economic growth, fiscal decentralization system and demographiccharacteristics and establishes a unitary analyzing framework and theoretic platform.Economic growth has an impact on the efficiency of government health spendingthrough the supply side effects, demand side effects and technology progress effects;The impacts of fiscal decentralization on government health spending can be achievedby the competition among governments, information symmetry and the distribution offinancial resources; The impacts of demographical characteristics, however, comefrom its influence on the scale, structure and quality of the population.
     Secondly, this paper does a comprehensive empirical study of the determinants ofthe scale efficiency, structural efficiency and productive efficiency of governmenthealth spending. Using panel data approach, this paper establishes a determinantsmodel of scale efficiency of government health spending. Economic growth and fiscaldecentralization are found to be the most important determinants of governmenthealth spending: Economic growth has a significant positive impact and fiscaldecentralization has a significant negative impact on government health spending.The other significant positive factors include environmental factor, urbanization rate,and hospital delivery rate. The determinants of structural efficiency of governmenthealth spending between rural area and urban area are investigated using biased OLSapproach. Policy measures, economic growth, mortality rate, medical technicalpersonnel in health care institutions per thousand persons in rural areas, the number ofbeds in health care institutions and incidence rate of infectious disease have asignificant negative impact on the structural efficiency of government health spendingbetween rural area and urban area. However, fiscal decentralization andenvironmental factor have positive impacts on the structure ratio, which is to thedisadvantage of improvement of structural efficiency between rural area and urbanarea. In analyzing the determinants of structural efficiency of government healthspending between supply and demand side, economic growth, the number of beds inhealth care institutions and environmental factor are found to have a positive impacton the improvement of structural efficiency between supply and demand sides.Urbanization rate and infectious disease mortality rate can lead to the reduction of this efficiency rate. The results of the determinants of health productive efficiency ofgovernment health spending turns out to be that fiscal decentralization has significantnegative impacts on health productive efficiency. Economic growth, urbanization rateand population density are found to have insignificant positive impact. All theseempirical analyses fit with the theoretical analysis in the previous part.
     Furthermore, in the analysis of scale efficiency of government health spending,the author establishes a production model in order to calculate the optimal scale ofgovernment health spending in China. The empirical results demonstrate thatgovernment health spending in China is productive, which has a positive impact oneconomic growth; the optimal scale of government health spending is9.6%of GDP,based on which a conclusion is drawn that there can still be a moderate growth ingovernment health spending. In the part of structural efficiency analysis, the authorgauges the inequality of government health spending between rural and urban areas byusing Theil index and finds out that the inequalities in rural and urban areas is themain reason of inequalities in China. The author also finds that government healthspending discrepancy between rural and urban areas have different impact on theincome gap between rural and urban areas in high quartiles. DEA approach is used tocalculate the health productive efficiency in1990,2000and2010respectively. Thesame provinces are found to be on the productive frontier, but the provinces off thefrontier are different. In general, health productive efficiency of government healthspending is increasing gradually, and the regional difference in efficiency issignificant.
     Lastly, based on the theoretical and empirical analysis above, this paper putsforward corresponding policy suggestions of improving the efficiency of governmenthealth spending from four perspectives, i.e. ensuring the moderate growth ofgovernment health spending, optimizing the structural efficiency of governmenthealth spending, improving the health productive efficiency and completing thesystem of fiscal decentralization, in hope of supporting the government policy indesigning effective health policies and establishing basic health care system coveringthe rural and urban areas.
引文
[1]保罗·萨缪尔森,威廉·诺得豪斯.宏观经济学.萧称译.北京:华夏出版社,2001,10
    [2]高鸿业.西方经济学.第三版.北京:中国人民大学出版社,2004,329-330
    [3] Farrell M J. The measurement of productive efficiency. Journal of RoyalStatistical Society,1957,120:253-281
    [4] Whitesell, Robert. Industrial Growth and Efficiency in the United States andthe Former Soviet Union.Comparative Economic Studies,1994,36(4):47-77
    [5]吴俊培.财政支出效益评价问题研究.财政研究,2003,(1):15-17
    [6]于维洋,王宏.提高财政支出效率的思路与途径.经济论坛.2007,(20):115-117
    [7]李森.论财政支出效率的三个层次及其实现.西安财经学院学报,2005,(6):63-67
    [8] Grossman M. On the concept of health capital and the demand for health.Journal of Political Economy,1972,80(2):223-255
    [9] Kim K, Moody P M. More resources better health? A cross-nationalperspective. Social Science and Medicine,1992,34(8):837-842
    [10] McGuire A, Parkin D, Hughes D, et al. Econometric analyses of nationalhealth expenditures: can positive economics help answer normative questions?.Health Economics,1993,(2):113-126
    [11] Filmer D, Hammer J, Pritchett L. Health policy in poor countries: weak linksin the chain. Policy research working paper. Washington, DC: World Bank,1998
    [12] Filmer D, Pritchett L. Child mortality and public spending on health: howmuch does money matter? Policy research working paper. Washington, DC:World Bank,1997
    [13] Wolfs. B.Health Status and Medical Expenditures: Is There a Link?. SocialScience and Medicine,1986,22(10):993-999
    [14] Tanzi V,Schuknecht L. Reconsidering the Fiscal Role of Government: TheInternational Perspective. American Economic Review,1997,87(2):164-168
    [15] Anand S,Ravallion M. Human Development in Poor Countries: On the Role ofPrivate Incomes and Public Services. The Journal of Economic Perspectives,1993,7(1):133-150
    [16] Bidani B, Ravallion M.Decomposing Social Indicators Using DistributionalData. Journul of Econometrics,1997,77:125-139
    [17] Gupta S, Verhoeven M, Tiongson E R.The Effectiveness of GovernmentSpending on Education and Health Care in Developing and TransitionEconomies.European Journal of Political Economy,2002,18(4):717-737
    [18] Gupta S, Verhoeven M.The Efficiency of Government Expenditure:Experiences from Africa. Journal of Policy Modeling,2001,23,433-467
    [19] Wang Limin. Health Outcomes in Low-Income Countries and PolicyImplications: Empirical Findings from Demographic and Health Surveys.World Bank Policy Research Working Paper No.2831,2002
    [20] Bokhari FAS, Y W Gai,Gottret. Government health expenditures and healthoutcomes,Health Economics,2007,16(3):257-273
    [21] Anand S, Kanbur,Ravi S M. Public Policy and Basic Needs Provision:Intervention and Achievement in Sri Lank.The Political Economy of Hunger,1991,(12):59-92
    [22] Bhalotra S. Spending to save? State health expenditure and infant mortality inIndia.Health Economics,2007,16(9):911-928
    [23] Farahani M, S V Subramanian,David Canning. Effects of State-Level PublicSpending on Health on The Mortality Probability In India.Health Economics,2010,19(11):1361-1376
    [24]黄君洁.公共支出与我国居民健康关系的实证研究生产力研究.2007,(18):76-78
    [25] Schultz T W. Investment in human capital. American Economic Review,1961,6(51):1-17
    [26] Arrow K J. The economic implications of learning by doing. The Review ofEconomic Studies,1962,(29):155-173
    [27] Mushkin S J. Health as an investment. Journal of Political Economy,1962,(70):129-157
    [28] Lucas R E. On the Mechanics of Economic Development. Jouranl of MonetaryEconomics,1988,(22):3-42
    [29] Barro Robert J. Determinants of Economic Growth:A Cross-country EmpiricalStudy. NNER Working Paper No.5698. London:The MIT Press,1997
    [30] Fogel R W.,New Sources and New Techniques for the Study of Secular Trendsin Nutritional Status, Health, Mortality, and the Process of Aging. NBERHistorical Working Paper.1991
    [31] Fogel R W. Economic Growth, Population Theory and Physiology: TheBearing of Long-Tetm Processes on the Making of Economic Policy.American Economic Review,1994a,84(3):369-395
    [32] Knowles S, Owen P D. Health capital and cross-country variation in incomeper capita in the Mankiw-Romer-Weil model. Economics Letters,1995,48(1):99-106
    [33] Knowles S, Owen D. Education and health in an effective labour empiricalgrowth model. Economic Record,1997,73(7):14-28
    [34] Bloom David E,Canning David, Sevilla Jaypee.The Effect of Health onEwnomic Growth:Theory and Evidence. NBER Working Paper8587,2001
    [35] Bloom David E,Canning David, Sevilla Jaypee.Health, Worker Productivity,and Economic Growth.In:13th annual Health EconomicsConference.Pittsburgh,2002,2-3
    [36] Jamison, Dean T.Lau, Lawrence J. Health's Contribution to Economic Growthin an Environment of Partially Endogenous Technical Progress.DCPP WorkingPaper10,2003
    [37] Mayer, David, Humberto, et al. Health, growth and income distribution inLatin America and the Caribbean: A study of determinants and regional localbehavior. Investment in health: Social and economic returns. Washington, DC:American Health Organization,2001,35-43
    [38] McDonald S, Roberts J. Growth and multiple forms of human capital in anaugmented Solow model: A panel data investigation. Economics Letters,2002,(74):271-276
    [39] Bhargava A, Jamison D T, Lau L J,Murray C J L. Modeling the Effects ofHealth on Economic Growth. Journal of Health Economics,2001,20,423-440
    [40] Jamison D T, L J Lau, J. Wang. Health’s Contribution to Economic Growth inan Environment of Partially Endogenous Technical Progress. Cambridge, MA:MIT Press,2005,67-91
    [41] Arrow K J, M. Kurz. Public Investment, the Rate of Return, and OptimalFiscal Policy. Baltimore: The Johan Hopking Press,1970,77-101
    [42] Barro R J. Government Spending in a Simple Model of Endogenous Growth.Journal of Political Economy,1990,(5):s103-s125
    [43] Kleiman E. The determinants of national outlay on health.The Economics ofHealth and Medical Care. New York: John Wiley&Sons,1974,85-104
    [44] Newhouse J P. Medical-Care Expenditure: A Cross-National Survey. TheJournal of Human Resources,1977,12(1):115-125
    [45] Devarajan S, Swaroop V, Zou H. The composition of public expenditure andeconomic growth. Journal of Monetary Economics,1996,37(2):313-344
    [46] Bleaney,Michael F, Norman Gemmell, et al. Testing the Endogenous GrowthModel: Public Expenditure, Taxation, and Growth over the Long-Run.Canadian Journal of Economics,2001,34(1):36-57
    [47] Rosa Aisa T, Fernando Pueyo. Government health spending and growth in amodel of endogenous longevity. Economics letters,2006,90:249–253
    [48]杜乐勋.注意卫生保健消费需求对投资乘数的影响.中国卫生资源,2000,(1):6-9
    [49]杜乐勋,赵郁馨,石光等.中国卫生总费用——计量经济学分析与预测.中国卫生经济,2000,(3):62-64
    [50]王远林,宋旭光.公共卫生投资与区域经济增长关系的实证研究.经济学家,2004,(2):51-56
    [51]苗俊峰.我国公共卫生支出经济效应分析:[山东大学硕士学位论文].山东:山东大学,2006,19-22
    [52]刘勇政,张坤.我国公共卫生支出的经济增长效应实证分析.北方经济,2007,(24):9-10
    [53]蒋萍,田成诗.区域卫生行业政府投入对经济增长的贡献分析.财经问题研究,2009,(2):82-88
    [54] Abel-Smith. B Paying for health services: a study of the costs and sources offinance in six countries. Public Health Papers,1963,(17):86
    [55]杜乐勋,郑先荣,方立.我国医疗收费价格政策的演变与发展趋势.中国卫生经济,1995,(3):5-6
    [56]中国卫生费用核算小组.中国卫生总费用历史回顾和发展预测.卫生软科学,2000,(5):202-213
    [57]代英姿.公共卫生支出:规模与配置.财政研究,2004,(6):30-32
    [58]孙健夫,要敬辉.公共财政视角下中国医疗卫生支出分析.河北大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2005,(3):67-71
    [59]毛晖,姬艳飞.中国公共卫生财政投入状况分析.山东经济,2008,(2):82-87
    [60]杜乐勋,张文鸣,黄泽民.中国医疗卫生发展报告.第一版.北京:社会科学文献出版社,2006,55-75
    [61]贾莉英.我国对公共卫生的投入状况.卫生经济研究,2003,(12):18-19
    [62]苗俊峰.我国公共卫生支出规模与效应的分析.山东工商学院学报,2005,(2):31-35
    [63]曹璐.我国政府卫生支出规模研究.[东北财经大学硕士论文].大连:东北财经大学,2007,16-32
    [64]高梦滔,王健.中国卫生总费用、 GDP与个人付费.卫生经济研究,2005,(2):8-12.
    [65]陈洪海,黄丞、陈忠:我国卫生费用与经济增长关系研究.预测,2005,(6):24-27
    [66]何平,孟庆跃.基于误差修正模型的卫生总费用与GDP关系研究.中国卫生经济,2005,(9):20-22
    [67]王俊.政府卫生支出有效机制的研究——系统模型与经验分析.第一版.北京:中国财政经济出版社,2007,193-210
    [68]顾昕.公共财政转型与政府卫生筹资责任的回归.中国社会科学,2010,(2):103-120
    [69] Hoffmeyer, U.K., McCarthy T.R.Financing Health Care.Kluwer AcademicPublishers Dordrecht,1994,(1):57-68
    [70] Newhouse J P. Cross national differences in health spending what do theymean?. Journal of Health Economics,1987,6(2):159-162
    [71] Leu R. The public-private mix and international health care costs.Oxford:Basil Blackwell:Culyer A.J, Jonsson B.Public and private healthservices,1986:98-108
    [72] Parkin D, McGuire A, Yule B. Aggregate health care expenditures and nationalincome:Is health care a luxury good?. Journal of Health Economics,1987,6(2):109-127
    [73] Milne, R., and H, Molana.On the effect of income and relative price ondemand for health care: EC evidence. Applied Economics,1991,(23):1221-1226
    [74] Gerdtham U, Jasson B. Conversion factor instability in internationalcomparisons of health care expenditure. Journal of Health Economics,1991,10(2):227-234
    [75] Gerdtham,Ulf-G,Jes Sogaard,Fredrik Andersson etal. An econometric analysisof health care expenditure:A cross-section study of the OECD countries.Journal of Health Economics,1992,11(1):63-84
    [76] Hitiris T, Posnett J. The determinants and effects of health expenditure indeveloped countries. Journal of Health Economics,1992,11(2):173-181
    [77] Dolores J, Peter C S. Decentralisation of health care and its impact on healthoutcomes.Discussion Papers from Department of Economics,2005,(10):1-51
    [78] Chou W.L. Explaining China's regional health expenditures using LM-typeunit root tests. Journal of Health Economics,2007,26(4):682-698
    [79] Yee E. The Effects of Fiscal Decentralisation on Health Care in China.University Avenue Undergraduate: Princeton University,2001,182-203
    [80] Di Matteo L, Di Matteo R. Evidence on the determinants of Canadianprovincial government health expenditures:1965-1991.Journal of HealthEconomics,1998,17(2):211-228
    [81] Hoch Lang. The determinants of public health care expenditure in China.Sacramento: California State University Department of Economics,2010,44-65
    [82]陈共,王俊.论财政与公共卫生.第一版.北京:中国人民大学出版社,2007,105-109
    [83]潘杰,李晨赵.影响我国地方政府卫生支出的主要因素研究:基于省级数据的实证分析.中国财经信息资料,2009,(33):19-23
    [84]宋志华.中国政府卫生支出的规模、结构与绩效研究:[东北大学博士论文].辽宁:东北大学工商管理学院,2009,99
    [85]傅勇,张晏.中国式分权与财政支出结构偏向:为增长而竞争的代价.管理世界,2007,(3):4-12
    [86]何长江.政府公共卫生支出行为影响因素的实证分析.财经科学,2011,(4):94-100
    [87] Armay, Richard. The Freedom Revolution. Washington DC: RegneryPublishing Coporation,1995,68-94
    [88] Karras G. The Optimal Government Size: Further International Evidence onthe Productivity of Government Services. Economic Inquiry,1996,34,(2):193-203
    [89]马拴友.政府规模与经济增长:兼论中国财政的最优规模.世界经济,2000,(11):59-64
    [90]马树才,孙长清.经济增长与最优财政支出规模研究.统计研究,2005,(1):15-20
    [91]张明喜,陈志勇.促进我国经济增长的最优财政支出规模研究.财贸经济,2005,(10):41-45
    [92]何振国.中国财政支农支出的最优规模及其实现.中国农村经济,2006,(8):4-9
    [93]马拴友.财政科研支出与经济增长──论我国科研支出的最优规模.新疆财经,2001,(5):28-30
    [94]马拴友.公共教育支出与经济增长——我国财政教育支出的最优规模规模估计.社会科学家,2002,17(2):16-20
    [95]李梦娜.我国政府卫生支出的最优规模.当代经济,2008,(8):24-25
    [96] Gupta S, Clements, Tiongson. Public Spending on Human Development.Finance and Development,1998,35(9):10-13
    [97] Muhammad A, Pakistan. Faheem J. Health Care Services and GovernmentSpending in Pakistan.PIDE Working Papers. Pakistan Institute of DevelopmentEconomics,2007.
    [98] Hamid R, Davoodi R, Erwin T, et a1. How Useful Are Benefit IncidenceAnalyses of Public Education and Health Spending? IMF Working Paper227.IMF,2003
    [99] Castro L, Dayton L, Demery L, et a1. Public spending on health care in Africa:do the poor benefit? Bulletin of the World Health Organization,2000,8(1):66-74
    [100] Filip M,Eddy V D.Achieving Better Measles Immunization in DevelopingCountries: Does Higher Coverage Imply Lower Inequality. Social Science&Medicine,2008,66(8):1709-1718
    [101]冯占春,侯泽蓉,郑舒文等.我国城乡卫生投入公平性的影响因素及其对策.中华医院管理杂志,2006,(10):657-660
    [102]俞卫.医疗卫生服务均等化与地区经济发展.中国卫生政策研究,2009,(6):1-7
    [103]周超,任苒.城乡卫生费用与医疗保障筹差资异分析.中国卫生经济,2011,(1):24-26
    [104]王小林.中国卫生服务筹资:公平与发展——基于儿童发展的视角.南京大学学报(哲学.人文科学.社会科学版),2007,(3):42-53
    [105]韩子荣.完善城市社区卫生服务体系的思考.中国城市经济,2008,(5):70-72
    [106]李晓燕,谢长青.农村卫生资源配置公平性研究——基于2003-2005年黑龙江省13个地区的数据分析.数理统计与管理,2009,(3):402-411
    [107]夏新斌.湖南城乡卫生资源配置的聚类分析.企业家天地(理论版),2010,(7):56-57
    [108]葛凌霄,张亚斌.城乡基本医疗卫生服务均等化的实证分析——基于泰尔指数的测算.生产力研究,2010,(7):113-115
    [109]冯海波,陈旭佳.公共医疗卫生支出财政均等化水平的实证考察——以广东省为样本的双变量泰尔指数分析.财贸经济,2009,(11):49-53
    [110]夏新斌,赵梅梅,莫晓海等.城乡卫生资源统筹发展实证研究——以湖南省为例.卫生经济研究,2010,(9):34-37
    [111]刘海英,张纯洪.中国城乡卫生经济系统投入产出动态效率的对比研究.农业经济问题,2010,(2):44-51,111
    [112]李新民,张绍军,陈立珠.对“供需兼补”有关问题的思考.中国卫生经济,2008,(8):21-22
    [113]林巧珠,张文昌.政府投入兼顾医疗服务供方和需方的可操作性研究.中国卫生事业管理,2009,(7):443-445
    [114]李玲.医改不仅是民生更是增长动力.中国经济,2011,(4):1-5
    [115]李玲.英国模式:国民卫生服务体制.瞭望,2007,(1):29
    [116]束雅春.政府卫生投入的方向.医院管理论坛,2009,(8):8-10
    [117]刘军民.关于政府购买卫生服务改革的评析.华中师范大学学报(人文社会科学版),2008,(1):35-42
    [118]石光,邹珺,田晓晓.政府购买卫生服务的国内外改革经验评析.中国卫生政策研究,2008,(2):35-38
    [119]赵云,立体式全方位推进政府购买卫生服务方式.中国卫生事业管理,2010,(8):574-575
    [120] Bordignon M,Turati G.Bailing out expectations and public health expenditure.Journal of Health Economics,2009,28(2):305-321
    [121]刘军民.重构政府与市场、政府层级间规范的卫生支出责任.中国经济时报,2005-09-09
    [122]王晓洁.中国公共卫生支出政府间财政责任问题研究.河北学刊,2007,(5):193-196
    [123]刘军民.卫生投入的政府责任及结构优化.卫生经济研究,2008,(6):3-7
    [124]周海沙,阮云洲.财政分权与公共卫生政府间责任分担的现实选择.卫生经济研究,2009,(3):5-7
    [125]陈春辉,周金玲.卫生分级财政制度的国际比较及我国存在的问题.卫生经济研究,2009,(4):18-20
    [126]阮云洲,黄二丹,李卫平.完善卫生转移支付制度分析.卫生经济研究,2009,(3):8-11
    [127]陈春辉,李顺平.我国中央财政卫生转移支付方式探讨.中国卫生经济,2010,(1):5-7
    [128]李齐云,刘小勇.财政分权、转移支付与地区公共卫生服务均等化实证研究.山东大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2010,(5):34-46
    [129] Sanjeev Gupta, Marijn Verhoeven. The Efficiency of Government ExpenditureExperiences from Africa. Journal of Policy Modeling,2001,(23):433–467
    [130] Retzlaff-Roberts D, Cyril F, Rose M. Technical efficiency in the use of healthcare resources:a comparison of OECD countries.Health Policy,2004,(1):55-72
    [131] Antóni Afonso, Miguel St. Aubyn. Non-parametric approaches toeducationand health expenditure efficiency in OECD Countries.ISEG-UTL EconomicsWorking Paper.2004
    [132] Santiago Herrera, Gaobo Pang. Efficiency of Public Spending in DevelopingCountries: an Efficiency Frontier Approach. World Bank Policy ResearchWorking Paper No3645.2005
    [133] Ke Tom Xu.State-level Variations in Income-Related Inequality in Health andHealth Achievement in the US.Social Science&Medicine,2006,63(2):457-464
    [134] Etibar Jafarov, Victoria Gunnarsson. Government Spending on Health Careand Education in Croatia: Efficiency and Reform Options. IMF Working Paper136. IMF,2008
    [135] Cyrille Schwellnus. Achieving Higher Performance: Enhancing SpendingEfficiency in Health and Education in Mexico. OECD Economics DepartmentWorking Paper.2009,732
    [136] R F Lavado,E C Cabanda. The efficiency of health and education expendituresin the Philippines. Central European Journal of Operations Research,2009:3:275-291
    [137] Evans D, Tandon A, Murray C,et al.The comparative efficiency of nationalhealth systems In producing health: an analysis of191countries.GPEdiscussion paper No29.2000
    [138] A. Afonso, L.Schuknecht, V. Tanzi. Public sector efficiency: an internationalcomparison. Public Choice,2005:321-347
    [139]张宁,胡鞍钢,郑京海.应用DEA方法评测中国各地区健康生产效率.经济研究,2006,41(7):92-105
    [140]张晖,许琳.我国各地医疗卫生投入效果分析.卫生经济研究,2009(4):14-15
    [141] F re, Rolf FilLic,Grosskopf.Productivity Growth in Health-Care Delivery.Medical Care,1997,35(4):354-366
    [142]刘海英,张纯洪.我国省际卫生经济投入产出的动态效率测度研究.中国卫生经济,2009,(10):5-8
    [143]韩华为,苗艳青.地方政府卫生支出效率核算及影响因素实证研究——以中国31个省份面板数据为依据的DEA-Tobit分析.财经研究,2010,(5):4-15,39
    [144] Santiago Herrera, Gaobo Pang. Efficiency of Public Spending in DevelopingCountries: an Efficiency Frontier Approach. The World Bank Policy ResearchWorking Paper,2005,36-45
    [145] Pablo Gottret, George Schieber. Health Financing Revisited. Washington: TheWorld Bank,2006,55-56
    [146] David Hauner, Annette Kyobe. Determinants of Government Efficiency. WorldDevelopment.2010,38(11):1527-1542
    [147]贾智莲,卢洪友.财政分权与教育及民生类公共品供给的有效性——基于中国省级面板数据的实证分析.数量经济技术经济研究,2010,(6):20-28
    [148] Tibout C M.A Pure Theory of Local Expenditures.Journal of PoliticalEconomy,1956,(64):416-424
    [149] Oates WE.Fiscal Federalism.New York:Harcourt brace Jovanovich,1972,72-122
    [150] Brennan G.,Buchannan J.The Power to Tax: Analytical Foundations of a FiscalConsitution.Cambridge: Cambridge U. Press,1980,181-203
    [151] Marlow M.Fiscal Decentralization and Government Size.Public Choice,1988,56(3):259-269
    [152] Grossman P.J. Fiscal Decentralization and Government Size: AnExtension.Public Choice,1989,62(1):63-69
    [153] Moesen W. and P. Van Cauwenberge.The Status of the Budget Constraint,Federalism and the Relative Size of Government: A BureaucracyApproach.Public Choice,2000,104:207-224
    [154] Rodden J. Reviving Leviathan: Fiscal Federalism and the Growth ofGovernment.International Organization,2003,57:695-729
    [155] Arikan. G..Fiscal Decentralization s A Remedy for Corruption.InternationalTax and Public Finance,2004,(11):76-89
    [156] Tanzi. On Fiscal Federalism: Issues on Worry about. Woking Paper.2000
    [157] Dincer O. D.,Ellis C. J.,Waddell G. R..Corruption, Decentralization andYardstick Competition.Discussion Paper. University of Oregon,2006
    [158] Wilson, J. D..A theory of interregional tax competition.Journal of UrbanEconomics,1986,19:296-315
    [159] Wilson, J. D..Theories of Tax Competition.National Tax Journal,1999,52:269-304
    [160] Wellisch D..Theory of Public Finance in a Federal State.New York:CambridgeUniversity Press,2000,236-254
    [161] Keen, M.,Marchand, M..Fiscal competition and the pattern of publicspending.Journal of Public Economics,1997,9601:33-53
    [162] Qian, Y.,Roland, G..Federalism and the Soft Budget Constraint.EconomicReview,1998,77:265-284
    [163] Li Hongbin,Zhou Li-an.Political turnover and economic performance: Theincentive role of personnel control in China.Journal of PublicEconomics,2005,89:1743-1762
    [164]周黎安.中国地方官员的晋升锦标赛模式研究.经济研究,2007,(7):36-50
    [165]严冀,陆铭.分权与区域发展:面向一个最优分权程度的理论.世界经济文汇,2003,(3):18-28
    [166]盘宇章.财政分权改革对公共医疗供给影响的经验研究——基于省级面板数据.卫生经济研究,2010,(12):15-18
    [167] Anderson,Hendrik.Fiscal Decentralization and Government Size: AnInternational Test for Leviathan Accounting for Unmeasured EconomicActivity.International Tax and PublicFinance,1998,(5):171-186
    [168] Oates W..Searching for Leviathan: An Empirical analysis.American EconomicReview,1985,(75):748-757
    [169] Stein.Fiscal Decentralization and Government Size in Latin America.Journalof Applied Economics,1999,(2):357-391
    [170] Prud Homme R..The Dangers of Decentralization.World Bank ResearchObserver,1995,10(2):201-220
    [171] Tanzi Vito.Fiscal Federalism and Decentralization: A Review of SomeEfficiency and Macroeconomic aspects.In:M.Bruno, B. Pleskovic (Eds.).Annual World Bank Conference on Development Economics.WashingtonDC:World Bank,1996,295-316
    [172] Bardhan P..Decentralization of Governance and Development.Journal ofEconomic Perspectives,2002,16(4):185-205
    [173] Stigler,George.The Tenable Range of Functions of Local Government.In:Federal Expenditure Policy for Economic Growth and Stability. WashingtonD.C.,1957,213-219
    [174] Cochrane AL,St Leger AS,Moore F..Health Service ‘Input’ and Mortality‘Output’ in Developed Countries.Journal of Epidemiology and CommunityHealth,1978,200-205
    [175]阮煜琳.社科院:2030年中国将成老龄化程度最高国家.http://www.chinanews.com/gn/2010/09-10/2526415.shtml,2010-09-10
    [176]黄成礼.人口老龄化对卫生费用增长的影响.中国人口科学,2004,(4):36-43
    [177]厉以宁.卫生支出是生产性投资——在卫生经济理论研讨会上的发言.卫生经济,1985,(2):8-9
    [178] Antonio Afonso,Miguel ST. Aubyn.Non-parametric Approaches to Educationand Health Expenditure Efficiency in OECD Countries.Journal of AppliedEconomics,2005,227-246
    [179] Kam Ki TANG, Dennis Petrie.Non-Hierarchical Bivariate Decomposition ofTheil Indexes.Working Paper.2007
    [180]王小鲁,樊纲.中国收入差距走势和影响因素分析.经济研究.2005,(10):24-36
    [181]张启良,刘晓红,程敏.我国城乡收入差距持续扩大的模型解释.统计研究.2010,(12):51-56
    [182] Sen,Amartya,K..以自由看待发展.北京:中国人民大学出版社,2002,55-76
    [183] Charnes, A.,Cooper, W.,Rhodes, E..Measuring the efficiency of decisionmaking units.European Journal of Operational Research,1978,2(6):429-444
    [184]李燕凌.基于DEA-Tobit模型的财政支农效率分析——以湖南省为例.中国农村经济,2008,(9):52-62
    [185]陈诗一,张军.中国地方政府财政支出效率研究:1978—2005.中国社会科学,2008,(4):65-78
    [186]简玉峰,刘华生.地方政府公共服务提供效率研究——以湖南省不同地方政府为例.华东经济管理,2009,(12):120-125
    [187] Gerdtam,Ulf-G.,Sogaard, Jes,Andersson, Fredrik,et al.An EconometricAnalysis of Health Care Expenditure: A Crosssection Study of the OECDCountries. Journal of Health Economics,1992,11:63-84

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700