用户名: 密码: 验证码:
企业债券与公司债券定价差异研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
本文从信息有效性、定价影响因素、定价模型评估三个方面,研究和比较了我国证券交易所市场上最重要、交易最活跃的两类信用债券——企业债券与公司债券——的定价机制和定价差异。
     对信息有效性的研究发现,企业债券和公司债券的信息有效性都很低,但后者好于前者,意味着企业债券和公司债券的未来价格在一定程度上可以通过各方面信息的历史数据进行预测。具体而言:1)历史价格信息最具预测力,两类债券的价格具有均值反转特性;2)历史的无风险利率数据也具有显著预测性,其反映到两类债券上会有延迟;3)股指回报率虽不能代表宏观经济信息,但也具有一定预测力,其与债券价格的关系是此消彼长,形成“跷跷板效应”;4)发债公司的股价回报率对债券价格有微弱的预测力,有可能是这方面的信息有效性高,也有可能是其与债券价格之间的关系本身就很微弱。5)作为新出现的公司债券,其在各方面的信息有效性都比企业债券高。
     对定价影响因素的研究发现,无风险利率、信用风险、流动性风险、定价复杂性风险等因素,都会对债券收益率产生影响。除无风险利率外,信用风险是最主要的影响因素,其次是流动性风险,而定价复杂性风险对收益率的影响则可忽略不计。流动性风险的各种考量指标中,债券年龄对收益率的影响最大。新债券的流动性往往很高,债券收益率较低,老债券的流动性往往降低很多,债券收益率较高。除上述影响因素之外,还有一个重要的影响因素是债券类型。即若控制住上述因素保证可比,公司债券的收益率仍然会比企业债券高50~100个基点。这个数值是非常显著不可忽视的,尤其值得投资者注意。
     对定价模型评估的研究发现,使用Merton模型来为企业债券和公司债券进行定价,效果很不理想。企业债券定价的平均绝对误差为3.33元,公司债券定价的平均绝对误差为10.65元,理论价格普遍高于实际市场价格。进一步分析定价残差的来源可以发现:1)Merton模型对无风险利率的调整是矫枉过正的;2)对信用风险的调整是失败的——有的调整方向错误,有的没能调整,有的矫枉过正;3)对流动性风险几乎完全没有调整;4)对定价复杂性风险有比较适宜的调整,但所产生的积极影响总的来说微不足道;5)对本文所发现的债券类型因素同样完全没有调整。
This paper researched and studied the pricing mechanism and pricing difference between China's enterprise bonds and corporate bonds, the two most important and actively trading credit bonds in China's Security Exchange Markets, from three different aspects of informational efficiency, pricing determinants, and pricing model evaluation, respectively.
     The research on informational efficiency found that, the informational efficiency on both enterprise bonds and corporate bonds is rather low, but it's better for the latter than that for the former, which implies that, to some extant, the future price of enterprise bonds and corporate bonds can be predicted by the historical data of various informational sources. Specifically,1) bond price historical data have the most significant predictive power:there are mean-reversion effects in both kinds of bonds.2) Historical risk-free interest rates also have significant predictive power, because there is some lag effect in its pricing into both kinds of bonds.3) Stock index return, although which cannot represent macroeconomic information, have some predictive power on bond prices:there is a trade-off between stock index return and bond return, a kind of so-called "seesaw effect".4) The stock return of the bond issuing company can have a little predictive power on bond return:maybe it's due to a higher informational efficiency, or maybe it's because the relation is weak between stock and bond prices.5) As the recently emerged kind of corporate bond, its informational efficiency is higher than enterprise bonds in all aspects.
     The research on pricing determinants found that, factors, including risk-free interest rate, credit risk, liquidity risk, and complication in pricing, will affect bond yield. Except risk-free interest rate, the most important determinant is credit risk, the second important is liquidity risk, and the effect of complication in pricing can be almostly ignored. In the various variables related to liquidity risk, bond age is the most important one. Newly issued bonds usually possess high liquidity, and the yield is low; seasoned bonds, on the other hand, usually have much lower liquidity, and the yield is higher. Besides all the factors above, there is another factor determining yield:the bond type. That is, if all the factors above were held the same and comparable, the yield of corporate bond will still be50-100basis points higher than that of enterprise bonds. This is a figure that is so significant that cannot be ignored, and deserves more attention from investors.
     The research on pricing model evaluation found that, the pricing result of enterprise bonds and corporate bonds using Merton model is rather unsatisfactory. The average absolute pricing error on enterprise bonds is3.33yuan, while the average absolute pricing error on corporate bonds is10.65yuan. The theoretical price is generally higher than market price. Further analysis on the source and determinant of pricing residual show that:1) the adjustment on risk-free interest rate by the Merton model is over-corrected.2) The adjustment on credit risk is generally failed:some are corrected in the wrong direction, some are failed to be corrected, and some are over-corrected.3) There is nearly no adjustment on liquidity risk.4) Although the Merton model reasonably adjusted the risk of complication in pricing, the overall positive effect is negligible.5) The important bond type factor is also not a bit adjusted.
引文
[1]陈灯塔,洪永淼.中国股市是弱式有效的吗——基于一种新方法的实证研究[J].经济学(季刊),2003,(4):97-124.
    [2]陈军泽,杨柳勇.国债市场的降息效应分析[J].浙江大学学报(人文社会科学版),2000,(3):77-81.
    [3]陈盛业,宋逢明.卖空约束下的公司债券定价[J].运筹与管理,2007,16(2):94-97.
    [4]陈小悦,陈晓,顾斌.中国股市弱型效率的实证研究[J].会计研究,1997,(9):13-17.
    [5]戴国强,孙新宝.我国企业债券信用利差宏观决定因素研究[J].财经研究,2012,37(12): 61-71.
    [6]冯宗宪,郭建伟,孙克.企业债的信用价差及其动态过程研究[J].金融研究,2009,(3):54-71.
    [7]高强,邹恒甫.企业债券与公司债券的信息有效性实证研究[J].金融研究,2010,2010(7):99-117.
    [8]韩立岩,郑承利.基于模糊随机方法的公司违约风险预测研究[J].金融研究,2002,(8):48-53.
    [9]邝梅,赵柯.中国公司债券市场与宏观经济关系实证分析[J].南开经济研究,2009,(4):56-67.
    [10]李合怡,贝政新.公司债信用利差影响因素的动态研究[J].学海,2013(1):113-117.
    [11]李杰群,齐新宇,赵庆,胡延坡.我国公司债券信用溢价的实证研究[J].上海财经大学学报:哲学社会科学版,2010,12(5):57-64.
    [12]李丽.公司债券市场的强制担保要求和投资者定位[J].金融研究,2006,(3):67-75.
    [13]李贤平,江明波,刘七生.国债市场有效性的初步探讨[J].统计研究,2000,(7):32-38.
    [14]李晓庆,方大春,郑垂勇.基于结构化模型的企业短期融资券信用溢价研究[J].证券市场导报,2006,12:62-67.
    [15]李晓庆,雷丰善.信用风险结构化模型及其实证研究[J].经济问题,2010,(9):58-61.
    [16]梁琪.企业信用风险的量化度量研究[J].南开经济研究,2000,(6):54-59.
    [17]林建伟,任学敏.双方互相担保公司债券的定价与风险分析[J].系统工程理论与实践,2009,(2):87-99.
    [18]鲁臻,邹恒甫.中国股市的惯性与反转效应研究[J].经济研究,2007,(9):145-155.
    [19]闵晓平.公司债券流动性衡量和决定研究述评[J].证券市场导报,2008,(10):65-71.
    [20]沈艺峰,吴世农.我国证券市场过度反应了吗?[J].经济研究,1999,(2):21-26.
    [21]宋颂兴,金伟根.上海股市市场有效实证研究[J].经济学家,1995,(4):107-128.
    [22]谭地军,田益祥,黄文光.中国企业债券特征与风险补偿[J].数量经济技术经济研究,2008(2):74-87.
    [23]汤亮.公开信息与国债市场价格的发现过程——基于中国的经验实证分析[J].南开经济研究,2005,(5):]00-105.
    [24]王安兴,解文增,余文龙.中国公司债利差的构成及影响因素实证分析[J].管理科学学报,2012,15(5):32-41.
    [25]王国刚.论“公司债券”与“企业债券”的分立[J].中国工业经济,2007,(2):5-11.
    [26]王璐,庞皓.中国股市和债市波动的溢出效应——基于交易所和银行间市场的实证研究[J].金融论坛,2008,(4):9-13.
    [27]王永宏,赵学军.中国股市“惯性策略”和“反转策略”的实证分析[J].经济研究,2001,(6):56-61.
    [28]吴谦.可转债价格与股票价格动态传导关系实证研究——基于多变量协整方法和非对称误差修正模型的检验分析[J].财经研究,2007,(5):134-143.
    [29]吴世农.我国证券市场效率的分析[J].经济研究1996,(4):13-19.
    [30]吴世农,吴超鹏.我国股票市场“价格惯性策略”和“盈余惯性策略”的实证研究[J].经济科学,2003,(4):41-50.
    [31]闫海峰,华雯君.基于KMV模型的中国上市公司信用风险研究[J].产业经济研究,2009,(3):14-22.
    [32]杨晔.企业债券品种创新驱动因素实证分析[J].金融研究,2006,(12):39-50.
    [33]余文龙,王安兴.基于动态Nelson-Siegel模型的国债管理策略分析[J].经济学(季刊),2010(4):1403-1426.
    [34]俞乔.市场有效、周期异常与股价波动——对上海、深圳股票市场的实证分析[J].经济研究,1994,(9):43-50.
    [35]袁超,张兵,汪慧建.债券市场与股票市场的动态相关性研究[J].金融研究,2008,(1):63-75.
    [36]曾志坚,江洲.关于我国股票市场与债券市场收益率联动性的实证研究[J].当代财经,2007,(9):58-64.
    [37]张兵,李晓明.中国股票市场的渐进有效性研究[J].经济研究,2003,(1):54-61.
    [38]张亦春,周颖刚.中国股市弱式有效吗?[J].金融研究,2001,(3):34-40.
    [39]赵静,方兆本.中国公司债信用利差决定因素——基于结构化理论的实证研究[J].经济管理,2011,33(11):138-148.
    [40]郑佳铭,范龙振.短期融资券收益率影响因素研究[J].管理学报,2011,(1):143-150.
    [41]周琳杰.中国股票市场动量策略赢利性研究[J].世界经济,2002,(8):60-64.
    [42]周孝坤.公司债券定价结构化模型实证分析[J].社会科学家,2006,(4):65-68.
    [43]朱如飞.公司债的非流动性与风险溢价——基于中国的实证研究[J].投资研究,2013,32(1):43-55.
    [44]朱世武,陈建恒.交易所国债利率期限结构实证研究[J].金融研究,2003,(10):63-73.
    [45]Alexander G.J., Edwards A. K., Ferri M. G.What Does Nasdaq's High-Yield Bond Market Reveal About Bondholder-Stockholder Conflicts?[J]. Financial Management, 2000,29(1):23-39.
    [46]Amihud Y. Illiquidity and Stock Returns:Cross-Section and Time-Series Effects[J]. Journal of Financial Markets,2002,5(1):31-56.
    [47]Arora N., Bohn J., Zhu F. Reduced Form Vs. Structural Models of Credit Risk:A Case Study of Three Models[J]. Journal of Investment Management,2005,3(4):33-73.
    [48]Ball R., Brown P. An Empirical Evaluation of Accounting Income Numbers[J]. Journal of Accounting Research,1968,6(2):159-178.
    [49]Bao J., Pan J. U. N., Wang J. The Illiquidity of Corporate Bonds[J]. The Journal of Finance,2011,66(3):911-946.
    [50]Black F., Cox J. C. Valuing Corporate Securities:Some Effects of Bond Indenture Provisions[J]. The Journal of Finance,1976,31(2):351-367.
    [51]Black F., Scholes M. The Pricing of Options and Corporate Liabilities[J]. The Journal of Political Economy,1973,81(3):637-654.
    [52]Blanco R., Simon B., Marsh I. W. An Empirical Analysis of the Dynamic Relation between Investment-Grade Bonds and Credit Default Swaps[J]. The Journal of Finance, 2005,60(5):2255-2281.
    [53]Blume M. E., Keim D. B., Patel S. A. Returns and Volatility of Low-Grade Bonds 1977-1989[J]. The Journal of Finance,1991,46(1):49-74.
    [54]Breusch T. S., Pagan A. R. The Lagrange Multiplier Test and Its Applications to Model Specification in Econometrics[J]. The Review of Economic Studies,1980,47(1): 239-253.
    [55]Briys E., de Varenne F. Valuing Risky Fixed Rate Debt:An Extension[J]. The Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,1997,32(2):239-248.
    [56]Campbell J. Y., Taksler G. B. Equity Volatility and Corporate Bond Yields[J]. The Journal of Finance,2003,58(6):2321-2349.
    [57]Chang E. C., Pinegar J. M. Return Seasonality and Tax-Loss Selling in the Market for Long-Term Government and Corporate Bonds[J]. Journal of Financial Economics, 1986,17(2):391-415.
    [58]Chen L., Lesmond D. A., Wei J. Corporate Yield Spreads and Bond Liquidity[J]. The Journal of Finance,2007,62(1):119-149.
    [59]Collin-Dufresne P., Goldstein R. S. Do Credit Spreads Reflect Stationary Leverage Ratios?[J]. The Journal of Finance,2001,56(5):1929-1957.
    [60]Collin-Dufresne P., Goldstein R. S., Martin J. S. The Determinants of Credit Spread Changes[J]. Journal of Finance,2001,56(6):2177-2207.
    [61]Cornell B., Green K. The Investment Performance of Low-Grade Bond Funds[J]. The Journal of Finance,1991,46(1):29-48.
    [62]Cox J. C, Ingersoll J. E., Jr., Ross S. A. A Theory of the Term Structure of Interest Rates[J]. Econometrica,1985,53(2):385-407.
    [63]Cremers M., Driessen J., Maenhout P., Weinbaum D. Individual Stock-Option Prices and Credit Spreads[J]. Journal of Banking & Finance,2008,32(12):2706-2715.
    [64]Crosbie P., Bohn J. Modeling Default Risk[R].2003. Moody's K·M·V.
    [65]Downing C., Underwood S., Xing Y. H. The Relative Informational Efficiency of Stocks and Bonds:An Intraday Analysis[J]. Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,2009,44(5):1081-1102.
    [66]Driessen J. Is Default Event Risk Priced in Corporate Bonds?[J]. The Review of Financial Studies,2005,18(1):165-195.
    [67]Duan J.-C. Maximum Likelihood Estimation Using Price Data of the Derivative Contract[J]. Mathematical Finance,1994,4(2):155-167.
    [68]Duffee G. R. Estimating the Price of Default Risk[J]. The Review of Financial Studies, 1999,12(1):197-226.
    [69]Duffie D., Singleton K. J. Modeling Term Structures of Defaultable Bonds[J]. The Review of Financial Studies,1999,12(4):687-720.
    [70]Eom Y. H., Helwege J., Huang J.-Z. Structural Models of Corporate Bond Pricing:An Empirical Analysis[J]. Review of Financial Studies,2004,17(2):499-544.
    [71]Ericsson J., Jacobs K., Oviedo R. The Determinants of Credit Default Swap Premia[J]. Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,2009,44(1):109-132.
    [72]Ericsson J., Reneby J. Estimating Structural Bond Pricing Models[J]. The Journal of Business,2005,78(2):707-735.
    [73]Ericsson J., Reneby J., Wang H. Can Structural Models Price Default Risk? New Evidence from Bond and Credit Derivative Markets[J]. SSRN Working Paper.2007. No.637042.
    [74]Fama E., Fisher L., Jensen M., Roll R. The Adjustment of Stock Prices to New Information[J]. International Economic Review,1969,10(1):1-21.
    [75]Fama E. F. Efficient Capital Markets:A Review of Theory and Empirical Work[J]. The Journal of Finance,1970,25(2):383-417.
    [76]Fan H., Sundaresan S. Debt Valuation, Renegotiation, and Optimal Dividend Policy[J]. Review of Financial Studies,2000,13(4):1057-1099.
    [77]Geske R. The Valuation of Corporate Liabilities as Compound Options[J]. The Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,1977,12(4):541-552.
    [78]Goyenko R. Y., Holden C. W., Trzcinka C. A. Do Liquidity Measures Measure Liquidity?[J]. Journal of Financial Economics,2009,92(2):153-181.
    [79]Gunduz Y., Uhrig-Homburg M. Does Modeling Framework Matter? A Comparative Study of Structural and Reduced-Form Models[J]. SSRN Working Paper,2011. No. 1342485.
    [80]Ho T. S. Y., Lee S.-B. Term Structure Movements and Pricing Interest Rate Contingent Claims[J]. The Journal of Finance,1986,41(5):1011-1029.
    [81]Hotchkiss E. S., Ronen T. The Informational Efficiency of the Corporate Bond Market: An Intraday Analysis[J]. Review of Financial Studies,2002,15(5):1325-1354.
    [82]Huang J.-z., Huang M. How Much of the Corporate-Treasury Yield Spread Is Due to Credit Risk?[J]. SSRN Working Paper,2002. No.1294412.
    [83]Hull J., White A. Valuing Credit Default Swaps I:No Counterparty Default Risk[J]. SSRN Working Paper.2000. No.1295226.
    [84]Jarrow R. A., Lando D., Turnbull S. M. A Markov Model for the Term Structure of Credit Risk Spreads[J]. The Review of Financial Studies,1997,10(2):481-523.
    [85]Jarrow R. A., Turnbull S. M. Pricing Derivatives on Financial Securities Subject to Credit Risk[J]. The Journal of Finance,1995,50(1):53-85.
    [86]Jones E. P., Mason S. P., Rosenfeld E. Contingent Claims Analysis of Corporate Capital Structures:An Empirical Investigation[J]. The Journal of Finance,1984,39(3): 611-625.
    [87]Jordan S. D., Jordan B. D. Seasonality in Daily Bond Returns[J]. The Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,1991,26(2):269-285.
    [88]Katz S. The Price and Adjustment Process of Bonds to Rating Reclassifications:A Test of Bond Market Efficiency[J]. The Journal of Finance,1974,29(2):551-559.
    [89]Kwan S. H. Firm-Specific Information and the Correlation between Individual Stocks and Bonds[J]. Journal of Financial Economics,1996,40(1):63-80.
    [90]Kyle A. S. Continuous Auctions and Insider Trading[J]. Econometrica,1985,53(6): 1315-1335.
    [91]Lando D. On Cox Processes and Credit Risky Securities[J]. Review of Derivatives Research,1998,2(2):99-120.
    [92]Leland H. E. Corporate Debt Value, Bond Covenants, and Optimal Capital Structure[J]. The Journal of Finance,1994,49(4):1213-1252.
    [93]Leland H. E., Toft K. B. Optimal Capital Structure, Endogenous Bankruptcy, and the Term Structure of Credit Spreads[J]. The Journal of Finance,1996,51(3):987-1019.
    [94]Li K. L., Wong H. Y. Structural Models of Corporate Bond Pricing with Maximum Likelihood Estimation[J]. Journal of Empirical Finance,2008,15(4):751-777.
    [95]Lindvall J. R. New Issue Corporate Bonds, Seasoned Market Efficiency and Yield Spreads[J]. The Journal of Finance,1977,32(4):1057-1067.
    [96]Longstaff F. A., Mithal S., Neis E. Corporate Yield Spreads:Default Risk or Liquidity? New Evidence from the Credit Default Swap Market[J]. The Journal of Finance,2005, 60(5):2213-2253.
    [97]Longstaff F. A., Schwartz E. S. A Simple Approach to Valuing Risky Fixed and Floating Rate Debt[J]. The Journal of Finance,1995,50(3):789-819.
    [98]Lucas R. E. Econometric Policy Evaluation:A Critique[R]. Carnegie-Rochester Conference Series on Public Policy.1976:19-46.
    [99]Lyden S., Saraniti D. An Empirical Examination of the Classical Theory of Corporate Security Valuation[J]. SSRN Working Paper.2001. No.271719.
    [100]Madan D., Unal H. Pricing the Risks of Default[J]. Review of Derivatives Research, 1998,2(2-3):121-160.
    [101]Mandelbrot B. Forecasts of Future Prices, Unbiased Markets, and "Martingale" Models[J]. The Journal of Business,1966,39(1):242-255.
    [102]Martin J. D. An Analysis of the Efficiency of the Market for New Corporate Bonds in Reflecting Two Sources of Essentially Free Information,1960-1971 [J]. The Journal of Finance,1974,29(4):1333-1334.
    [103]McCulloch J. H. Measuring the Term Structure of Interest Rates[J]. The Journal of Business,1971,44(1):19-31.
    [104]Merton R. C. On the Pricing of Corporate Debt:The Risk Structure of Interest Rates[J]. The Journal of Finance,1974,29(2):449-470.
    [105]Nelson C. R., Siegel A. F. Parsimonious Modeling of Yield Curves[J]. The Journal of Business,1987,60(4):473-489.
    [106]Norden L., Weber M. The Co-Movement of Credit Default Swap, Bond and Stock Markets:An Empirical Analysis[J]. European Financial Management,2009,15(3): 529-562.
    [107]O'Hara M. Presidential Address:Liquidity and Price Discovery[J]. The Journal of Finance,2003,58(4):1335-1354.
    [108]Pastor L., Stambaugh R. F. Liquidity Risk and Expected Stock Returns[J]. Journal of Political Economy,2003,111(3):642-685.
    [109]Samuelson P. A. Proof That Properly Anticipated Prices Fluctuate Randomly[J]. Industrial management review,1965,6(2):41-49.
    [110]Schneeweis T., Woolridge J. R. Capital Market Seasonality:The Case of Bond Returns[J]. The Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,1979,14(5):939-958.
    [111]Smirlock M. Seasonality and Bond Market Returns[J]. The Journal of Portfolio Management,1985,11(3):42-44.
    [112]Swamy P. A. V. B., Arora S. S. The Exact Finite Sample Properties of the Estimators of Coefficients in the Error Components Regression Models[J]. Econometrica,1972, 40(2):261-275.
    [113]Vasicek O. An Equilibrium Characterization of the Term Structure[J]. Journal of Financial Economics,1977,5(2):177-188.
    [114]Vasicek O. A., Fong H. G.Term Structure Modeling Using Exponential Splines[J]. The Journal of Finance,1982,37(2):339-348.
    [115]Waud R. N. Public Interpretation of Federal Reserve Discount Rate Changes:Evidence on the "Announcement Effect"[J]. Econometrica,1970,38(2):231-250.
    [116]Zhang B. Y., Zhou H., Zhu H. Explaining Credit Default Swap Spreads with the Equity Volatility and Jump Risks of Individual Firms[J]. Review of Financial Studies,2009, 22(12):5099-5131.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700