用户名: 密码: 验证码:
舰空导弹指挥决策模型及应用研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
协同作战是舰艇编队为应对日益严重的空中目标威胁而提出的一种以信息完全共享为构架的新型作战模式,它克服了传统基于烟囱式武器系统构架的综合调度困难、信息共享程度低等缺陷,体现了防空作战“体系”与“体系”对抗的特征,显著提升了舰载武器的防空作战效能。本文在概括分析协同作战研究现状,分析协同作战模式下武器、控制设备、传感器和目标的柔性连接构架特点的基础上,对舰空导弹在小型舰艇编队协同作战模式下的来袭空中目标的威胁程度和编队舰空导弹火力分配、射击指挥决策方案优选进行了较为系统的研究。研究的主要内容如下:
     (1)提出一种将模糊集理论、神经网路、遗传算法综合的模糊优选神经网络目标攻击企图判别模型。利用协同作战模式下目标观察范围广,航迹跟踪时间长等特点,针对获取融合后的空中目标实施攻击过程的特征信息,建立神经网络判别模型,利用遗传算法良好的全局搜索能力,实现目标攻击企图的自动学习、实时判断,便于及时积累目标实施攻击的特征,更新攻击方式和方法的信息,全面判别目标攻击企图。
     (2)根据协同作战条件下大大增强了战场态势的感知能力,减少了因为缺乏目标信息而难于决策的困难,同时大量模糊信息、残缺信息的涌入增加了作出精确判断的难度的特点。应用模糊集理论,建立目标函数为全体样本属性对于全体级别加权广义欧氏权距离平方和最小的非线性规划模型。通过积累的样本库对模型进行迭代辨识,确认空中目标威胁等级模式识别的分类标准和属性权重。该模型可以实时用于空中目标的威胁等级识别,拓展后可以用于空中目标部分属性值残缺条件下的模糊识别。提出了部分距离替代法、直接等效法和最近原型法三种属性值残缺情况下的模糊识别方法算法。实现了对空中目标属性数据完整或残缺情况下使用相同模型进行威胁等级模糊识别,从而提高了舰艇编队对空防御作战自动化程度。
     (3)鉴于协同作战模式改变了传统固定链路“烟囱式”武器系统构架,实现目标、武器、控制单元、传感器的火力通道柔性连接,达到控制单元对传感器、火力单元实时灵活切换。在共享统一的战场态势基础上,拓展传统武器目标分配的概念,建立了空中目标突防期望值最小和组织抗击占用防空资源最少,适用于火力单元、打击目标、控制单元实时调度的火力分配模型,优化调度舰艇编队舰空导弹资源,提高舰空导弹资源的利用效率,有效提高了编队的防空作战效能。
     (4)编队火力分配中确定火力通道后,将提出舰空导弹多次射击方案序列概念,将模糊优选理论与动态规划原理结合起来,舰空导弹射击方案序列中的每一次射击作为一个阶段,建立以尽可能少占用防空资源、消耗舰空导弹最少、达到可靠毁伤来袭空中目标的模糊优选动态规划模型。根据不同战场态势条件下对防空资源的占用程度,灵活选取不同射击阶段各决策指标权重;根据可抗击的舰空导弹资源条件和来袭目标的威胁程度,实时求取对来袭空中目标多次抗击的优化射击指挥方案序列。减少对空中目标抗击时对舰空导弹资源的占用程度,从而有效提高舰艇编队对空中目标的作战效能,满足未来舰艇编队有效抗击多方向、多批次饱和攻击的要求,提高舰艇编队整体的防空作战能力,较好地解决编队协同作战预研中指挥决策的关键问题。
     最后对全文作了总结,并对有待进一步研究的问题作了分析和展望。
Cooperative engagement, based on the framework of fully sharing of information, is a new operational mode aiming at increasingly serious air targets threats. The cooperative engagement overcomes the drawbacks of the difficulty of comprehensive dispatching and low level of information sharing embodied in the traditional "chimney-type" weapon system framework, reflects the countermeasure feature of one system against another system in anti-air operation, and remarkably improves the anti-air operation efficiency of ship-borne weapons. Based on the analysis of the current situation of cooperative engagement as well as the characteristics of the soft connection framework between weapons, control units, sensors and targets in the mode of cooperative engagement, a relatively systematic study has been done in this dissertation on the degree of threat of incoming air target, fire distribution of ship-to-air missile of ship formation and the priority of firing command decision making plan in the cooperative engagement mode. The main contents of the study are as follows.
     (1) A fuzzy-priority-neural-network-target-attack-intention orienting model is put forward, which integrates fuzzy set theory, neural network, and genetic algorithm. A neural network orienting model is established in accordance with the features of the air target attack procedure acquired after fusion. The comprehensive searching capability of the genetic algorithm is utilized to achieve the auto-learning, real-time judgment so as to timely accumulate the attack signatures of targets, to update the information of attack modes and methods of the target and to comprehensively judge the attack intention of the target.
     (2) A non-linear programming model is established which sets a goal function by minimizing the sum of the squares of the weighted generalized Euclidean distances of the total sample attributes to the all grades, in accordance with the greatly increased sensing capability of the battlefield situation, the decreased difficulties of decision making for lack of target information and of precision decision making owing to the entering of large amount of fuzzy and fragmentary information under the condition of cooperative engagement. Iterative discriminating is done by using the accumulated sample bank to determine the classification standard and attribute weighting of mode discriminating of the degree of threat of air targets. This model can be used in real time to discriminate the degree of threat of air targets. After extended, it can be used for fuzzy discriminating of air targets when the attribute information is incomplete. Under the circumstances of incomplete attribute values, three fuzzy discriminating method algorithms, partial range substituting method, direct equivalent method and closest prototype method are proposed, which achieve the fuzzy discriminating of the degree of threat by using the same model when the attribute data of air target are complete or fragmentary so as to improve the level of automation of the anti-air operation of ship formation.
     (3) The soft connection between weapon, control and sensors is advanced to realize the flexible switch-over of sensors and fire power units through control units according to the characteristics of the cooperative engagement mode which completely changes the traditional fixed link "chimney type" weapon system framework. Based on the sharing of unified battle field situation, by breaking the limit of the concept of traditional weapon target fire power distribution, a non-linear programming model of fire power distribution is set up for the real time dispatching of fire power units, target to be attacked and control unit, which can optimize the dispatching of anti-air resources within the ship formation to greatly increase the anti-air capability of the ship formation.
     (4) Based on the determining of the sequence of the multiple firing plan of the ship-to-air missile firing decision making after firing power channel is selected in the fire power distribution of ship formation, a fuzzy priority dynamic programming model is established which combines fuzzy priority theory and dynamic programming principle with the aim of taking less anti-air resources, consuming minimum ship-to-air missiles but achieving reliable destruction of air targets. Each decision making index weighting of various firing stage is flexible selected according to the degree of utilization of anti-air resources in different battle field situation. The optimized firing command decision making plan is obtained in real time to repeatedly counter the incoming air targets according to the countermeasure conditions. ship-to-air missile firing command and decision making automation is proposed to minimize the utilization of anti-air resources against air targets, to improve the operation efficiency of anti-air weapons for the promoting of operational efficiency of ship formation against air targets, to satisfy the requirement of effective countering of ship formation against multi-direction and multi-batch saturation attack, to upgrade the comprehensive anti-air operational capability of ship formation and to better solve the key issue of command and decision making in the early planning and research of cooperative engagement of ship formation.
     At the end of this dissertation, a sum-up on the above research is done and the analysis of some further study and future development trend are also predicted.
引文
[1]姚宗信,李明,陈宗基.多空中作战平台协同对抗多目标态势分析方法.系统工程与电子技术,2008,30(2):292-296
    [2]陈鸿猷.现代防空论.北京:解放军出版社,1991:76-84,164-166
    [3]常卫伟,张剑钊,陈拯民.未来的海上防空系统.舰载武器,1998,(4):13-16.
    [4]徐怡锋,洪亮,赵国祥.网络化舰艇编队协同防空目标分配模型.海军航空工程学院学报,2009,24(3):333-225
    [5]王红军,迟中先.舰载软硬武器综合反导决策优化.火力与指挥控制,2007,32(12):34-37
    [6]文仲辉.战术导弹技术,北京:国防工业出版社,2000,167-197
    [7]韩雁飞.舰艇编队对空防御问题研究.舰载武器,1998,(1):1-9.
    [8]卜广志,毛昭军.海上防空作战能力结构研究.舰船科学技术,2008,30(4):76-79
    [9]周玉珍,陈东光.舰载防御系统将面临超高速反舰导弹的挑战.飞航导弹,1998.5:27-30
    [10]Susan G.Hutchins.Principles for Intelligent Decision Aiding.ADA318053.August 1996
    [11]张年春.区域防空导弹反导火力分配研究.指挥控制与仿真,2007,29(6):41-43
    [12]刘占荣.宙斯盾作战系统结构分析.情报指挥控制系统与仿真技术,2004,26(1):22-31
    [13]The Cooperative Engagement Capability.Johns Hopkins Apl Technical Digest,1995,16(4)377-396.
    [14]顾云涛.海军网络战及CEC系统的发展研究.舰船科学技术,2003,25(5):34-36.
    [15]史越东,陈立编译.协同作战能力将改变战争的面貌.情报指挥控制系统与仿真技术,2001(4):13-15,53
    [16]王航宇,王辉华,王士杰.TCN—美军协同作战能力的新发展.舰船电子工程2003,(2):14-17,26
    [17]Norman Friedman.Some new trends of naval air-defense.Maritime Defense,1997,22(6):125-128.
    [18]陈康,罗雪山,罗爱民.CEC条件下的舰艇编队防空问题.火力与指挥控制.2006.(4):32-35
    [19]齐强,王瑞麒.北约舰队防空体系分析,现代防御技术,2001,29(2):12-15
    [20]刘占荣,防御反舰导弹武器系统的发展.情报指挥控制系统与仿真技术,2003(8):8-12
    [21]熊正祥,王峰,孙永侃等.舰空导弹对群目标射击效能模型与仿真分析.系统仿真学报,2006,16(9):2385-2388
    [22]肖增博,雷虎民,夏训辉.多导弹协同作战关键技术研究与展望,飞航导弹,2008(6):24-26
    [23]由大德等.水面舰艇防空火力兼容问题.火力与指挥控制,2004,29(4):49-50
    [24]Dale E.Blodgett,Brahim Chaib-draa,Pierrick Plamondon.A Method to Optimize Ship Maneuvers for the Coordination of Hardldll and Softkill Weapons within a Frigate,Systems.ADA424683.May 2004
    [25]D.Blodgett,S.Paquet,P.Plamondon,et al.Coordinating Plans for Agents Performing AAW Hardkill and Softldll for Frigates.In Proceedings of AAAI Fall Symposium on Intent Inference for Collaborative Tasks,North Falmouth,Massachusetts,2001.11,2-4,.
    [26]D.Blodgett,M.Gendreau,F.Guertin,et al.A Tabu Search Heuristic for Resource Management in Naval Warfare.Publication of Centre de Recherche du Transport,CRT-98-63,Montreal,1998.
    [27]莫志华,刘占荣.单、多平台综合武器系统从纵向到横向集成.指挥控制与仿真,2006,28(3):6-11.
    [28]秦登桥,王海川,李敏.综合火控系统的现状与发展.舰船科学技术,1997.(2):5-10.
    [29]董志荣.21世纪火控系统的发展.火力与指挥控制,2000,25(1):1-3.
    [30]王继石.舰载作战指挥与火控系统发展研究.情报指挥控制系统与仿真技术,1999,(4):1-6.
    [31]王继石.舰载作战指挥与火控系统发展研究(续).情报指挥控制系统与仿真技术,1999,(5):17-24.
    [32]王兴军.美国海军自防试验舰.现代舰船,2003,11:26-27
    [33]苏长云编译.舰艇自防御的发展与新威胁的增加同步.情报指挥控制系统与仿真技术,2002,22(12):1-7
    [34]常卫伟,张剑钊.用于沿海防御的新型舰艇自防系统.舰载武器,1999,(2):24-27.
    [35]王继石.水面舰艇新一代作战指挥与火控系统发展趋势.情报指挥控制系统与仿真技术,1999,(5):7-12.
    [36]郑安云.协同作战系统与数据融合技术.战术导弹技术,2001(5):21-30
    [37]郭光,王峰,李晓.舰空导弹协同使用样式探讨,飞航导弹,2008(9):25-28
    [38]王海川.舰艇火控系统的现状与发展设想.指挥控制与仿真,2007,29(1):1-6
    [39]刘全,刘占荣.海军协同作战武器协调.情报指挥控制系统与仿真技术,2002,(11):1-6.
    [40]李敏.21世纪初我国海军海上编队“协同作战系统”的构想.舰船电子工程,2000,(1):13-17.
    [41]Douglas E.Mason.Identifying Measures of Effectiveness for Marine Corps C~4I Systems.ADA305269.September 1995
    [42]冯杰,邓俊杰.美国海军综合作战系统发展与预测研究.舰船电子工程,2001(2):6-13
    [43]Hall D L,Llinas J.An Introduction to Multisensor Data Fusion.Proceedings of IEEE,1997,85(1):6-23
    [44]Steinberg A,Bowman C,White F.Revisions to the.1DL Data Fusion Model.SPIE,1999,3719:430-441.
    [45]Hall D L,Llinas J.Handbook of Multisensor Data Fusion.Washington DC,NY:CRC Press 2001
    [46]Urban C D.Design and Evaluation of a Tactical Decision Aid.Proceedings of IEEE International Conference on Systems Man and Cybernetics,1990,812-814.
    [47]李伟生,王宝树.基于贝叶斯网络的态势评估.系统工程与电子技术,2003,25(4):480-483.
    [48]苏羽,赵海,苏威积等.基于贝叶斯网络的态势评估诊断模型.东北大学学报(自然科学版),2005,26(8):739-742.
    [49]宋元,章新华.战场态势估计的理论体系研究.情报指挥控制系统与仿真技术,2004,26(1):43-48.
    [50]王三民.模糊推理及态势估计研究[博士学位论文].西安电子科技大学,2004.
    [51]孔祥忠.战场态势估计和威胁估计.火力与指挥控制,2003,28(6):91-93.
    [52]赵红艳,周茂林编译.美国海军用基于知识的实时系统进行态势评估.情报指挥控制系统与仿真技术,2000,(7)17-32.
    [53]吴强,曹义华,金长江.威胁级别判断技术的研究.飞行力学,2002,12:56-60.
    [54]邱浪波.一种应用神经网络技术的威胁估计算法.空军工程大学学报(自然科学版),2002,12:25-28.
    [55].岳韶华,李松,刘进忙.基于专家系统的目标威胁判断模型.计算机工程与应用,2003,11:71-73.
    [56].曲长文,何友,马强.应用多属性决策的威胁评估方法.系统工程与电子技术,2000,5:26-29.
    [57]高尚.基于神经网络威胁判断模型.系统工程理论与实践,2000(7):49-51
    [58]胡绍勇,郑应平.用模糊运算确定目标的威胁程度.兵工学报,1999,20(1):43-46
    [59]吴智辉,张多林.基于模糊理论的空袭目标威胁判断模型.火力与指挥控制,2005,30(4):92-94
    [60]范春彦,韩晓明,王献峰.基于最大隶属度的目标威胁评估与排序法.系统工程与电子技术,2003,25(1):47-48.
    [61]张由余,罗丽莉.多因子动态加权威胁估计方法.火力与指挥控制,1997,22(4):44-48
    [62]余舟毅,陈宗基,周锐.基于贝叶斯网络的威胁等级评估算法研究.系统仿真学报,2005,17(3):555-558
    [63]李加祥,王延章.面向防御的舰载威胁判断模型.舰船科学技术,2004,26(3):43-46
    [64]王猛,章新华,夏志军.基于属性分析的威胁评估技术研究.系统工程与电子技术,2005,27(5):848-851
    [65]黄宪成,陈守煜.定量和定性指标相混合的威胁排序模型.兵工学报,2003,24(1):78-81
    [66]岳韶华,李松,刘进忙.基于专家系统的目标威胁判断模型.计算机工程与应用.2003(11):71-72+79.
    [67]吴金平,陆铭华,黄文斌等.水面舰艇编队对反舰导弹的威胁判断研究.系统仿真学报;2004,16(5):879-882.
    [68]A.S.Manne.A target-assignment problem.Opns.Res.,1958(6):346-351
    [69]G.G.DenBroeder,Jr.R.E.Ellision,L.Emerling.On optimum target assignments.Opns.Res.,1959(7):323-326
    [70]W.Saceo,R.Shear.The optimum allocation of weapons to targets:a dymamic programming approach.BRL Report No.1175,September 1962
    [71]F.Lemus,K.H.David.An optimum allocation of different weapons to a target complex.Opns.Res.,1963(11):787-794
    [72]H.Everett.Generalized Lagrange multiplies method for solving problems of optimum allocation of resources.Opns.Res.,1963(11):399-417
    [73]R.H.Day.Allocation weapons to target complexes by means of nonlinear programming.Opns.Res.,1966(14):265-273
    [74]S.Maltin.A review of the literature on the missile-allocation problem.Opns.Res.,1970(17):334-373
    [75]F.A.Miercort.Optimal allocation of missiles against area and point defenses.Opns.Res.,1971(19):605-617
    [76]G.G.Furman,H.J.Greenberg.Optimal weapon allocation with overlapping area defenses.Opns.Res.,1973(21):1291-1308
    [77]Marlin S.A review of the literature on the missile allocation problem.Operations Research,1970,18:334-373
    [78]Rosenberger Jay M,Hee Su,H wang A Y,etal.The generalized weapon target assignment problem.The 10th International Command and Control Research and Technology Symposium on the Future of C2,McLean,VA.2005:2-11
    [79]Hosein Patrick A,Walton James T.Michael athans.Dynamic weapon-target assignment problems with vulnerable C2 nodes.LIDS of MIT 1988:1-10
    [80]Hosein Patrick A,Michael Athans.Preferential defense strategies.LIDS-P,2002,1990:1-25.
    [81]Hosein Patrick A,Michael Athans.Some analytical results for the dynamic weapon-target allocation problem.LIDS-P-1944,1990:1-28
    [82]Hosein Patrick A,Michael Athans.An asymptotic result for the mufti-stage weapon-target allocation problem.Decision and Control,1990,Proceedings of the 29th IEEE Conference on 5~7Dec.1990:240-245
    [83]Hosein Patrick A.A class of dynamic nonlinear resource allocation problems.Thesis(Ph.D.).Massachusetts Institute of Technology,1990
    [84]Khosla D.Method for automatic weapon allocation and scheduling against attacking threats.USPatent Issued on December 24,2002,http://www.patentstorm.us/patents/6497169.html
    [85]Khosla D.Hybrid genetic approach for the dynamic weapon-target allocation problem.Proceedings of SPIE.2001,4396:248-263
    [86]潘书山,吴晓云.基于粗集理论的武器目标分配.弹箭与制导学报,2005,25(1):56-59
    [87]曹奇英,何张兵.WTA问题的遗传算法研究.控制理论与应用.2001,18(1):76-79
    [88]吴平,梁青.武器—目标分配问题的模拟退火算法.计算机工程与应用,2006(4):87-90
    [89]王磊,盛文平,陈钰宁等.复杂电磁环境下舰空导弹抗击能力分析,舰船电子工程,2009(8):42-44
    [90]王明明,曾家有,黄晅.单舰武器系统组合抗击反舰导弹的方案选优,海军航空工程学院学报,2008,23(5):547-550
    [91]沈浩.海军装备作战效能评估研究.北京:海潮出版社,2004:111-165
    [92]徐怡锋,洪亮,赵国祥.网络化舰艇编队协同防空目标分配模型研究,海军航空工程学院学报,2009,24(3)333-336
    [93]孙增圻等.智能控制理论与技术.北京:清华大学出版社,1997
    [94]焦李成.神经网络系统理论.西安:西安电子科技大学出版社,1990.
    [95]陈守煜.工程模糊集理论与应用.北京:国防工业出版社,1998.
    [96]权太范.信息融合:神经网络—模糊推理理论与应用.北京:国防工业出版社,2002.
    [97]王小平,曹立明.遗传算法—理论、应用与软件实现.西安:西安交通大学出版社,2002.
    [98]汪民乐,高晓光.导弹攻击目标选择的Fuzzy方法.西北工业大学学报,2000,18(3):387-391
    [99]周立军,王昌金,王晶横.反舰导弹攻击方向的选择策略分析.指挥控制与仿真.2008,30(4):44-47
    [100]Chen Shouyu.Fuzzy Recognition Theoretical Model.The Journal of Fuzzy Mathematics.1993,1(2):261-269.
    [101]W.Zangwill.Nonlinear programming:A Unified Approach.Englewood Cliffs,New Jerseg:Prentice-Hall,1969,Ch.4.
    [102]李登峰,陈守煜.多目标优化问题的模糊交叉算法与收敛性.应用数学,1997,10(3):107-109.
    [103]陈守煜.模糊模式识别交叉迭代模型与收敛性.大连理工大学学报,2001,3:264-267.
    [104].J.K.Dixon,Pattern recognition with partly missing data.IEEE Transactions on Systems,Man,and Cybernetics,1979(9):617-621.
    [105].C.Z.Janikow.Fuzzy decision trees:Issues and methods.I IEEE Transactions on Systems,Man,and Cybernetics,1998,28(1):1-14.
    [106]Dengfeng Li.Fuzzy multiattfibute decision-making models and methods with incomplete preference information.Fuzzy Sets and Systems 1999,106:113-119
    [107]李登峰,程春田,陈守煜.部分信息不完全的多目标决策方法.控制与决策,1998,13(1):83-86
    [108].廖貅武,唐焕文.基于不完全信息的一种群决策方法.大连理工大学学报.2002,42(1):122-126.
    [109]Alejandro E.Scalise A Fuzzy ART neural network approach to missing data[Doctoral Dissertation].University of Pittsburgh,2001
    [110]Little R.,Rubin,D.Statistical analysis with missing data,John Wiley ans Sons.New Tork,1987
    [111]郦能敬.对空情报雷达探测威力的设计论证.雷达科学与技术,2005,(3):129-135
    [112]施莱赫D C.电子战导论.谢学初,袁分地,陈小林译.北京:解放军出版社,1988.
    [113]lames B.,Y.Tsui.电子战接收机灵敏度的一种近似计算方程式.电子对抗技术,1987,(2):35-39
    [114]黎敏.多径效应一下相控阵雷达低空目标角度估计与跟踪技术研究.电子科技大学,2006.5
    [115]徐品高.防空导弹武器系统总体设计与试验.北京:宇航出版社,1996:405-420
    [116]娄寿春.地空导弹射击指挥控制模型.北京:国防工业出版社,2009:118-141
    [117]李廷杰.防空导弹武器系统射击效率.北京:北京航空学院出版社,1987
    [118]乔良,王航宇.舰空导弹协同制导流程研究,舰船电子工程,2008(4):54-56.
    [119]韩雁飞.舰空导弹作战使用及指挥控制.现代防御技术,2002,30(2):40-43
    [120]李廷杰.防空导弹武器系统射击效率.北京:北京航空学院出版社,1987
    [121]马雷挺,金钊,郭磊等.中远程舰空导弹对蛇行机动飞机目标作战研究.射击学报,2008,(2)
    [122]李健,李相民.电子战对地空导弹拦截行动的影响.指挥控制与仿真,2007,29(3):9-12
    [123]王贤彪.编队电子战防空反导技术研究.舰船电子对抗,2001,(5):1-5
    [124]姜宁,胡维礼,王基组等.雷达干扰资源分配的模糊多属性动态规划模型,南京理工大学学报.2003,27(3):314-317
    [125]牛海.基于人工.神经网络的辐射源威胁评估方法.航天电子对抗.2001(5):16-19.
    [126]张军.军事气象学.北京:气象出版社,2005:64-66
    [127]张喻,李玲玲.低角雷达跟踪时的多路径散射模型.电波科学技术,2004(1):83-91
    [128]Kohtaro Hosoda etc.Difference characteristics of sea surface temperature observed by GLI and AMSR aboard ADEOS-Ⅱ.Journal Of Oceanography,2006,62:339-350
    [129]Avner Gal.Passive range estimation using oversea multi-path.Naval Postgraduate School,Monierey,CA.A.GAL,Jun.1988.AD-A199963
    [130]周建强,王为颂.单舰反导作战舰空导弹与电子战武器使用电磁兼容分析.舰船电子工程,2009.4,29(4):162-164
    [131]刘占荣.海军联合网络体系结构.情报指挥控制系统与仿真技术,2003(5):1-6
    [132]李云,王航宇,吴铃.航空导弹对任意方向目标的发射区计算.舰船电子对抗,2008(7):47-50
    [133]Joseph Sternberg,Ross Thackeray,Frederick Johnson.A New Methodology for Assessing the Military Value of Tactical Surveillance and Intelligence Systems.ADA294513.1995
    [134]Anthony E.Spezio.Electronic Warfare Systems.IEEE Transaction on Microwave Theory and Techniques,2002,50(3):633-644
    [135]Lloyd S P,H S W.Weapons allocation is NP-complete.Proceedings of the IEEE Summer Simulation Conference,Reno,Nevada.1986
    [136]BURR SA,FALK JE,KARR AF.Integer prim-read solutions to a class of target defense problems.Operations Research,1985,33(4):726-745.
    [137]KARASAKAL O.Aliterature review of operational research methods for modeling the air defence problem.DOR(MLA)Research Note RN-2001/02.
    [138]ORHAN KARASAKAL.Air defence missle-target allocation models for a naval task group.Computer &Operations Research,2008,35:1759-1770.
    [139]MARTIN PFM,DONGEN V,KOS J.The analysis of ship air defence:the simulation model SEAROADS.Naval Research Logistics,1995,42(2):291-309.
    [140]BLOEMEN AF,WITBERG RR.Anti-air warfare research for naval forces.Naval Forces,2000,21(5):20.
    [141]ECKLER AR,BURR SA.Mathematical models of target coverage and missile allocation.Alexandria,VA:Military Operations Research Society,1972.
    [142]谢春燕,李为民.整数规划与动态规划在防空导弹火力分配中的应用研究.弹箭与制导学报,2003,23(4):72-74
    [143]赵晨光,李为民.利用排队论探讨多层拦截巡航导弹的问题.系统工程与电子技术,第25卷,2003.2:177-178
    [144]Urban C D.Design and Evaluation of a Tactical Decision Aid.Proceedings of IEEE International Conference on Systems Man and Cybernetics,1990,812-814.
    [145]Martin L,Flin R.Building Fire Commander Situational Awareness from Team Shared Mental Models.IEE Colloquium on Computer Mediated Complex Supervisory and Decision Making in Teams,1997,2:1-7
    [146]徐品高.关于地空导弹的连续射击能力问题.战术导弹技术,1996,(3):1-9.
    [147]李明,赵夏丽.舰空导弹拦截反舰导弹仿真模型研究.2006,23(5):14-17
    [148]韩松臣,韩品尧,黄建军等.防空武器系统射击方案研究.哈尔滨工业大学学报,1995,27(3):80-83
    [149]钟志通,王峰,徐德民.抗反辐射导弹武器时的指挥决策.火力与指挥控制,2004,29(3):34-37
    [150]陈守煜.复杂水资源系统优化模糊识别理论与应用.长春:吉林大学出版社,2002.
    [151]孙卫东,马其东,王富宾.舰艇末端软硬协同防空辅助决策方法研究.舰船电子工程,2009(5):49-52
    [152]郭锐,赵晓哲.水面舰艇编队防空反导作战效能.火力与指挥控制.2004(S):57-58
    [153]徐奕航,金钊,张有志.编队舰空导弹武器系统战斗使用可靠性分析.战术导弹技术,2008(3)1-5
    [154]马其东,方立恭,王富宾.舰空导弹武器系统战斗使用可靠性分析.现代防御技术,2004,32(4):14-17
    [155]J.Kacprzyk,A.O.Esogbue,Fuzzy dynamic programming:Main developments and applications,Fuzzy Sets and Systems.1996,(81):31-45.
    [156]M.L.Hussein,M.A.Abo-Sinna,A fuzzy dynamic approach to the multicriteria resource allocation problem,Fuzzy Sets and Systems.1995,(69) 115-124.
    [157]樊治平,李洪燕.基于fuzzy,偏好关系的一种方案排序方法.东北大学学报(自然科学版),1999,20(6):651-653
    [158]徐泽水.互反和互补判断矩阵的转换关系及其集成排序.系统工程与电子技术,2002,22(10):60-63
    [159]樊治平,胡国奋.模糊判断矩阵一致性逼近及排序方法.运筹与管理,2000,9(3):21-25.
    [160]王应明,傅国伟.关于层次分析法中权的最小平方法的理论证明.系统工程理论与实践,1995,15(1):3-8.
    [161]阮智,李庆民,于志良等.基于多阶段多指标的编队干扰方案协同决策研究.系统工程与电子技术.2009,3(6):1404-1408

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700