山东蒙山冰川遗迹的类型、特征和年代——答王乃昂教授、李吉均院士质疑
|
摘要
鉴于王乃昂教授、李吉均院士等否定了蒙山拦马墙等冰川遗迹的冰川成因,本着学术的辩论是接近科学真相的有效途径,故撰写本文。重点就王乃昂教授在其论文中采用人工采样坑作为地震撞击坑的证据问题、冰川擦痕认知的局限性问题进行了阐述。详细描述了蒙山存在的擦痕、颤痕、新月形裂纹、新月形裂口、新月形凿口、钉头鼠尾擦痕等类型丰富的冰川遗迹,并与四川海螺沟现代冰川槽谷各类擦痕、美国缅因州的颤痕等进行了对比。就争议较大的拦马墙巨石垄的组构特征、形成过程与形成时代进行了研究分析。在此基础上就冰川与洪水、泥石流之间的动力学差异进行了讨论。研究发现,脱离了"冰是固体"这一基本的认知范畴,必然导致泥石流论的泛滥。蒙山类型丰富、形迹清晰的冰川擦痕,为我国第四纪冰川遗迹的研究提供了实物样本。
In view of many articles issued by Professor WANG Nai'ang and Academician LI Jijun questioning the Mount Mengshan glacier relics, this paper is written in the light of that academic debate is an effective way to approach the scientific truth. This paper focuses on two queries in WANG Nai'ang(2017 b&): one is the use of artificial sampling pits as evidence for seismic impact pits; the other is the limitation of recognition of glacial striaes. This paper describes in detail the abundant types of glacial relics, such as glacial striaes, chatter marks, crescentic cracks, lunate fractures, crescentic gouges, nail-head and rat-tail shaped scratches in Mount Mengshan, and compares them with various scratches in the modern glacial trough of Hailuo Valley in Sichuan Province and chatter marks in Maine State, the United States. On this basis, the dynamic differences among glaciers, floods and debris flows are analyzed. It is found that if the basic cognitive category of "ice is solid" is broken away, it will inevitably lead to the flood of debris flow theory. The richness of the types of glacial striaes on Mount Mengshan glacier goes beyond the cognitive scope of some modern glacier researchers, which provides a reference for the study of Quaternary glacial relics in China.
In view of many articles issued by Professor WANG Nai'ang and Academician LI Jijun questioning the Mount Mengshan glacier relics, this paper is written in the light of that academic debate is an effective way to approach the scientific truth. This paper focuses on two queries in WANG Nai'ang(2017 b&): one is the use of artificial sampling pits as evidence for seismic impact pits; the other is the limitation of recognition of glacial striaes. This paper describes in detail the abundant types of glacial relics, such as glacial striaes, chatter marks, crescentic cracks, lunate fractures, crescentic gouges, nail-head and rat-tail shaped scratches in Mount Mengshan, and compares them with various scratches in the modern glacial trough of Hailuo Valley in Sichuan Province and chatter marks in Maine State, the United States. On this basis, the dynamic differences among glaciers, floods and debris flows are analyzed. It is found that if the basic cognitive category of "ice is solid" is broken away, it will inevitably lead to the flood of debris flow theory. The richness of the types of glacial striaes on Mount Mengshan glacier goes beyond the cognitive scope of some modern glacier researchers, which provides a reference for the study of Quaternary glacial relics in China.
引文
韩同林,劳雄,郭克毅.1998.河北省丰宁县喇嘛山冰臼群的发现及意义.中国区域地质,17(1):103.
韩同林,郭克毅.1999.河北、内蒙古中低山区发现罕见的冰臼群.地质论评,45(5):456～462.
韩同林.2004.发现冰臼.北京:华夏出版社:1～190.
兰州大学资源环境学院.2006.李吉均院士、王乃昂教授等设立“求真”奖学金[EB/OL].[2019-04-02]http://news.lzu.edu.cn/c/200605/lmc5655.html
李德文,崔之久,李洪江,南凌.2003.华北北部花岗岩风化穴形成机制与环境意义.南京大学学报(自然科学版),39(01):120～128.
李吉均.1982.论冰川擦痕 .冰川冻土,(1):29～34.
李吉均,周尚哲.2017.极海洋型冰川是什么冰川——与景才瑞先生商榷.冰川冻土,39(5):1～5.
李四光.1947.冰期之庐山.中央研究院地质研究所专刊乙种2号.南京:1～27.
李四光.1975.中国第四纪冰川.北京:科学出版社:1～82.
吕洪波,杨超.2005.山东新泰青云低山区发现第四纪冰川遗迹.地质论评,51(5):608～612.
吕洪波,任晓辉,杨超.2006.赤峰等地第四纪大陆冰川的地貌证据.地质论评,52(3):379～385.
吕洪波,徐兴永,易亮,李萍.2012.山东鲁山混合岩表面发现第四纪冰川剥蚀的直接证据——颤痕 .地质学报,86(3):514～521.
施雅风.1981.庐山真的有第四纪冰川吗?自然辩证法通讯,(2):41～45.
施雅风.1982.庐山真的有第四纪冰川吗?冰川冻土,(1):64～103.
施雅风,崔之久,李吉均.1989.中国东部第四纪冰川与环境问题.北京:科学出版社:363～374.
施雅风,孔昭宸,王苏民,等.1992.中国全新世大暖期的气候波动与重要事件.中国科学(B辑),(12):1300～1308.
施雅风,崔之久,苏珍.2005.中国第四纪冰川与环境变化.石家庄:河北科学技术出版社:66～67.
施雅风.2010.论李四光教授的庐山第四纪冰川是对泥石流的误读.地质论评,56(5):684～688.
施雅风.2011.中国东部中低山地有无发育第四纪冰川的可能性?地质论评,57(1):44～49.
王乃昂,赵井东,余莺潇,于昕冉,张文佳.2017a.渐趋完善的第四纪冰川研究范式——记第四届中国第四纪冰川与环境变化研讨会.冰川冻土,39(5):1029～1038.
王乃昂,戴霜,张律吕,余莺潇,于昕冉,田璐,尹丽颖.2017b.第四纪冰川遗迹的判别标准与方法问题——兼论蒙山巨砾堆积堤之成因.冰川冻土,39(6):1289～1297.
王斯文.2015.浅析冰川擦痕与泥石流凹痕的区别.经济研究导刊,(4):303
王照波,卞青,李大鹏,王金玉,刘彩玲,郭启鹏.2017a.山东蒙山第四纪冰川组合遗迹的发现及初步研究.地质论评,63(1):134 ～140.
王照波,张剑,王江月,张盈松,卞青,郭启鹏.2017b.山东蒙山第四纪冰川遗迹光释光测年研究及冰期划分与对比.地质论评,63(3):694～697.
王照波,王江月.2017c.中国东部末次冰期雪线高程重建与成冰气候分析.山东国土资源,33(11):1～5.
王照波.2017.沂蒙山自然文化探秘.北京:地质出版社:177～184.
王照波,王江月.2018a.山东蒙山全新世冰川遗迹的发现及确认——来自宇生核素年龄的证据.山东国土资源,34(6):1～5.
王照波,王江月,王全义,徐宪立,李宝杰.2018b.豫西甘山第四纪冰斗系统的发现及其与MIS的耦合关系分析.山东国土资源,34(7):1～7.
王照波,王江月.2018c.渐新世“雪球事件”的发现及其意义——基于全球冰斗系统的解读与研究.山东国土资源,34(09):1～8.
王照波,王江月,张剑.2019.山东蒙山第四纪冰川、黄土、水系沉积物与MIS对比研究.华东地质,40(2):81～88.
熊黑刚.1983.冰碛物与泥石流堆积物的区别.新疆大学学报(自然科学版),(Z1):142～149.
郑本兴,马正海.1985.冰川沉积与非冰川沉积中砾石和碎屑矿物表面的形态特征.第四纪研究,1(1):69～72.
章雨旭.2005.“冰臼”成因争鸣——以克什克腾旗青山岩臼群为例.地质论评,51(6):680,712.
章雨旭,刘恋.2011.山脊壶穴不能作为中国东部第四纪冰川的证.科技导报,29 (33) 62～64
章雨旭.2017.山东蒙山国家地质公园存在中国东部第四纪冰川有力证据(?)[OL].[2019-04-02](2017-05-13)http://blog.sciencenet.cn/home.php?mod=space&uid=2719683&do=blog&id=1054647
张志刚,梅静,张梦媛,王立志.2018.蒙山国家地质公园拦马墙砾石堆积体暴露测年研究.地质论评,64(5):1217～1224.
朱银奎.2014.崂山花岗岩山脊壶穴的特征及成因探讨.地质论评,60(2):397～408
College of resources and environment of Lanzhou University.2006&.Academician Li Jijun and professor Wang Nai’ang established the “Qiuzheng”(Pursuing truth) scholarship[EB/OL].[2019-04-02](2006-05-22) http://news.lzu.edu.cn/c/200605/lmc5655.html
Han Tonglin,Lao Xiong,Guo Keyi.1998#.Discovery of Moulin in Mount Lama,Fenglin,Hebei,and its significance.Regional Geology of China,17(1):103.
Han Tonglin,Lao Xiong.1999&.Rare moulin swarms discovered in the medium-low mountains areas in Hebei and Inner Mongolia.Geological Review,45(5):456～462.
Han Tonglin.2004#.Moulin Discovered.Beijing:Huaxia Publishing House:1～190.
Li Dewen,Cui Zhijiu,Li Hongjiang,Nan Ling.2003&.Genesis of granitic tafoni of northern North China and its environmental significance.Journal of Nanjing University(Natural Science),39(1):120～128.
L Hongbo,Yang Chao.2005#.Glacial traces found on low hill in Xintai,Shandong.Geological Review,51(5):608～612.
L Hongbo,Ren Xiaohui,Yang Chao.2006&.Landform evidences of Quaternary continental glaciation in Chifeng and the vicinity areas,north of China.Geological Review,52(3):379～385.
L Hongbo,Xu Xingyong ,Yi Liang,Li Ping.2012&.A direct erosion evidence of Quaternary glaciation——chatter marks found in Mt.Lushan,Shandong Province,east of China.Acta Geologica Sinica,86(3):514～521.
Li Jijun.1982&.On glacial striation.Journal of Glaciology and Cryopedology,4 (1):30～35 .
Li Jijun,Zhou Shangzhe.2017&.What glacier is the polar oceanic glacier?——Discussion with Mr.Jing Cairui.Journal of Glaciology and Geocryology,39(5):1～5.
Lee J S.1922.Notes on Traces of Recent Ice-action in Northern China,Geol.Mag.LIX,London:14～21.
Lee J S.1933.Quaternary glaciations in the Yangtze Valley.Bull.Geol.Soc.China,13:15～62.
Rea B.2007.Glacial landforms,erosional features:micro to macro scale forms.In:Encyclopedia of Quaternary science.Amsterdam:Elsevier:853～864.
Shi Yafeng.1981&.Mount Lushan really has Quaternary glacer?Journal of Dialectics of Nature,(2):41～45
Shi Yafeng.1981&.Mount Lushan really has Quaternary glacer?Journal of Glaciology and Geocryology,(1) :64～69.
Shi Yafeng,Cui Zhijiu,Li Jijun.1989&.China's Eastern Quaternary Glacier and Environmental Problems.Beijing:Science Press:363～374.
Shi Yafeng,Cui Zhijiu,Su Zhen.2010&.The Quaternary Glaciations and Environmental Variations in China.Shijiazhuang:Hebei Science and Technology Press:66～67.
Shi Yafeng.2010&.On Prof.Lee’s having misread debris flow deposits as Quaternary glaciations in the Lushan area,Jiangxi Province.Geological Review,56(5):684～688.
Shi Yafeng.2011&.2011.Is it really possible for glacier to develop on the mountains which below 2500m asl in the eastern China?Geological Review,57(1):44～49.
Wang Nai’ang,Zhao Jingdong,Yu Yingxiao,Yu Xinran,Zhang Wenjie.2017a&.A more perfect Quaternary glacial research paradigm —— the fourth China’s Symposium on Quaternary glaciation and environmental change.Journal of Glaciology and Geocryology,39(5):1029～1038.
Wang Nai’ang,Dai Shuang,Zhang Ll,Yu Yingxiao,Yu Xinran,Tian Lu,Yin Liying.2017b&.Issues on criteria and methods for discriminating Quaternary glacial relics:also on the origin of the boulder-piled levees in Mount Mengshan.Journal of Glaciology and Geocryology,39(6):1289～1297.
Wang Siwen.2015&.Analyses the difference between the glacial scratches and mudslides dent.Journal of Tribune in Economic Research,(4):303.
Wang Zhaobo,Bian Qing,Li Dapeng,Wang Jinyu,Liu Chailing,Guo Qipeng.2017a&.Discovery of the Quaternary glacial relics in Mount Mengshan,Shandong Province.Geological Review,63(1):134～140.
Wang Zhaobo,Zhang Jian,Wang Jiangyue,Zhang Yingsong,Bian Qing,Guo Qipeng.2017b&.Study with Optically Stimulated Luminescence (OSL) and two credible glacial periods in Mount Mengshan,Shandong Province.Geological Review,63(3):694～697.
Wang Zhaobo.2017&.The Nature and Culture of Mount Yimengshan.Beijing:Geological Publishing House:177～184.
Wang Zhaobo,Wang Jiangyue.2017c&.The rehabilitation of snow line elevation in eastern China and the climatic characteristics preliminary discussion.Shandong Land and Resources Magazine,33(11):1～5.
Wang Zhaobo,Wang Jiangyue.2018a&.Early Holocene glacial relics existence confirmed in Mengshan,Shandong provience—— Chronological evidence from the cosmogenic nuclide.Shandong Land and Resources Magazine,34(6):1～5.
Wang Zhaobo,Wang Jiangyue,Wang Quanyi,Xu Xianli,Li Baojie.2018b&.The discovery of Quaternary cirques system in Ganshan,western Henan Province and analysis of coupling relation with MIS.Shandong Land and Resources Magazine,34(7):1～6.
Wang Zhaobo,Wang Jiangyue.2018c&.The Discovery and Significance of the Oligocene “Snowball Earth” events—— Based on the research of global cirques system.Shandong Land and Resources Magazine,34(9):1～7.
Wang Zhaobo,Wang Jiangyue,Zhang Jian.2019&.Comparative study on Shandong Mengshan’s Quaternary glaciers,loess,stream sediments and MIS.East China Geology,40(2):81～88.
Xiong Heigang.1983#.Difference between moraine and debris flow deposits.Journal of Xinjiang University,(Z1):142～149.
Zheng Benxing,Ma Zhenghai.1985&.Morphological characteristics of gravel and clastic mineral surfaces in glacial and non-glacial deposits.Quaternary Sciences,(1):69～72.
Zhang W,Yan H,Dodson J,et al.2017.The 9.2 ka event in Asian summer monsoon area:the strongest millennial scale collapse of the monsoon during the Holocene.Climate Dynamics.36(3):79～84.
Zhang Yuxu .2005#.An arguement on the origin of potholes:A case of the Qingshan area Hexigten Qi,Inner Mongolia.Geological Review,51(6):680,712.
Zhang Yuxu,Liu Lian.2011&.Potholes on hilltops is not the evidence for Quaternary Glaciaer in eastern China.Science and Technology Review,29 (33) 62～64.
Zhang Yuxu.2017#.There are strong evidences for Quaternary glaciers in eastern China in the Mount Mengshan National Geopark,Shandong (?) [OL].http://blog.sciencenet.cn/home.php?mod=space&uid=2719683&do=blog&id=1054647
Zhang Zhigang,Mei Jing,Zhang Mengyuan,Wang Lizhi.2018&.10Be exposure ages of the boulder in Lanmaqiang(Wall for Blocing Horses),Fota Valley,Mengshan National Geopark.Geological Review,64(5):1217～1224.
Zhu Yinkui.2014.Characteristics and origin of granite hilltop potholes in Mount Laoshan.Geological Review,60(2):397～408.
韩同林,郭克毅.1999.河北、内蒙古中低山区发现罕见的冰臼群.地质论评,45(5):456～462.
韩同林.2004.发现冰臼.北京:华夏出版社:1～190.
兰州大学资源环境学院.2006.李吉均院士、王乃昂教授等设立“求真”奖学金[EB/OL].[2019-04-02]http://news.lzu.edu.cn/c/200605/lmc5655.html
李德文,崔之久,李洪江,南凌.2003.华北北部花岗岩风化穴形成机制与环境意义.南京大学学报(自然科学版),39(01):120～128.
李吉均.1982.论冰川擦痕 .冰川冻土,(1):29～34.
李吉均,周尚哲.2017.极海洋型冰川是什么冰川——与景才瑞先生商榷.冰川冻土,39(5):1～5.
李四光.1947.冰期之庐山.中央研究院地质研究所专刊乙种2号.南京:1～27.
李四光.1975.中国第四纪冰川.北京:科学出版社:1～82.
吕洪波,杨超.2005.山东新泰青云低山区发现第四纪冰川遗迹.地质论评,51(5):608～612.
吕洪波,任晓辉,杨超.2006.赤峰等地第四纪大陆冰川的地貌证据.地质论评,52(3):379～385.
吕洪波,徐兴永,易亮,李萍.2012.山东鲁山混合岩表面发现第四纪冰川剥蚀的直接证据——颤痕 .地质学报,86(3):514～521.
施雅风.1981.庐山真的有第四纪冰川吗?自然辩证法通讯,(2):41～45.
施雅风.1982.庐山真的有第四纪冰川吗?冰川冻土,(1):64～103.
施雅风,崔之久,李吉均.1989.中国东部第四纪冰川与环境问题.北京:科学出版社:363～374.
施雅风,孔昭宸,王苏民,等.1992.中国全新世大暖期的气候波动与重要事件.中国科学(B辑),(12):1300～1308.
施雅风,崔之久,苏珍.2005.中国第四纪冰川与环境变化.石家庄:河北科学技术出版社:66～67.
施雅风.2010.论李四光教授的庐山第四纪冰川是对泥石流的误读.地质论评,56(5):684～688.
施雅风.2011.中国东部中低山地有无发育第四纪冰川的可能性?地质论评,57(1):44～49.
王乃昂,赵井东,余莺潇,于昕冉,张文佳.2017a.渐趋完善的第四纪冰川研究范式——记第四届中国第四纪冰川与环境变化研讨会.冰川冻土,39(5):1029～1038.
王乃昂,戴霜,张律吕,余莺潇,于昕冉,田璐,尹丽颖.2017b.第四纪冰川遗迹的判别标准与方法问题——兼论蒙山巨砾堆积堤之成因.冰川冻土,39(6):1289～1297.
王斯文.2015.浅析冰川擦痕与泥石流凹痕的区别.经济研究导刊,(4):303
王照波,卞青,李大鹏,王金玉,刘彩玲,郭启鹏.2017a.山东蒙山第四纪冰川组合遗迹的发现及初步研究.地质论评,63(1):134 ～140.
王照波,张剑,王江月,张盈松,卞青,郭启鹏.2017b.山东蒙山第四纪冰川遗迹光释光测年研究及冰期划分与对比.地质论评,63(3):694～697.
王照波,王江月.2017c.中国东部末次冰期雪线高程重建与成冰气候分析.山东国土资源,33(11):1～5.
王照波.2017.沂蒙山自然文化探秘.北京:地质出版社:177～184.
王照波,王江月.2018a.山东蒙山全新世冰川遗迹的发现及确认——来自宇生核素年龄的证据.山东国土资源,34(6):1～5.
王照波,王江月,王全义,徐宪立,李宝杰.2018b.豫西甘山第四纪冰斗系统的发现及其与MIS的耦合关系分析.山东国土资源,34(7):1～7.
王照波,王江月.2018c.渐新世“雪球事件”的发现及其意义——基于全球冰斗系统的解读与研究.山东国土资源,34(09):1～8.
王照波,王江月,张剑.2019.山东蒙山第四纪冰川、黄土、水系沉积物与MIS对比研究.华东地质,40(2):81～88.
熊黑刚.1983.冰碛物与泥石流堆积物的区别.新疆大学学报(自然科学版),(Z1):142～149.
郑本兴,马正海.1985.冰川沉积与非冰川沉积中砾石和碎屑矿物表面的形态特征.第四纪研究,1(1):69～72.
章雨旭.2005.“冰臼”成因争鸣——以克什克腾旗青山岩臼群为例.地质论评,51(6):680,712.
章雨旭,刘恋.2011.山脊壶穴不能作为中国东部第四纪冰川的证.科技导报,29 (33) 62～64
章雨旭.2017.山东蒙山国家地质公园存在中国东部第四纪冰川有力证据(?)[OL].[2019-04-02](2017-05-13)http://blog.sciencenet.cn/home.php?mod=space&uid=2719683&do=blog&id=1054647
张志刚,梅静,张梦媛,王立志.2018.蒙山国家地质公园拦马墙砾石堆积体暴露测年研究.地质论评,64(5):1217～1224.
朱银奎.2014.崂山花岗岩山脊壶穴的特征及成因探讨.地质论评,60(2):397～408
College of resources and environment of Lanzhou University.2006&.Academician Li Jijun and professor Wang Nai’ang established the “Qiuzheng”(Pursuing truth) scholarship[EB/OL].[2019-04-02](2006-05-22) http://news.lzu.edu.cn/c/200605/lmc5655.html
Han Tonglin,Lao Xiong,Guo Keyi.1998#.Discovery of Moulin in Mount Lama,Fenglin,Hebei,and its significance.Regional Geology of China,17(1):103.
Han Tonglin,Lao Xiong.1999&.Rare moulin swarms discovered in the medium-low mountains areas in Hebei and Inner Mongolia.Geological Review,45(5):456～462.
Han Tonglin.2004#.Moulin Discovered.Beijing:Huaxia Publishing House:1～190.
Li Dewen,Cui Zhijiu,Li Hongjiang,Nan Ling.2003&.Genesis of granitic tafoni of northern North China and its environmental significance.Journal of Nanjing University(Natural Science),39(1):120～128.
L Hongbo,Yang Chao.2005#.Glacial traces found on low hill in Xintai,Shandong.Geological Review,51(5):608～612.
L Hongbo,Ren Xiaohui,Yang Chao.2006&.Landform evidences of Quaternary continental glaciation in Chifeng and the vicinity areas,north of China.Geological Review,52(3):379～385.
L Hongbo,Xu Xingyong ,Yi Liang,Li Ping.2012&.A direct erosion evidence of Quaternary glaciation——chatter marks found in Mt.Lushan,Shandong Province,east of China.Acta Geologica Sinica,86(3):514～521.
Li Jijun.1982&.On glacial striation.Journal of Glaciology and Cryopedology,4 (1):30～35 .
Li Jijun,Zhou Shangzhe.2017&.What glacier is the polar oceanic glacier?——Discussion with Mr.Jing Cairui.Journal of Glaciology and Geocryology,39(5):1～5.
Lee J S.1922.Notes on Traces of Recent Ice-action in Northern China,Geol.Mag.LIX,London:14～21.
Lee J S.1933.Quaternary glaciations in the Yangtze Valley.Bull.Geol.Soc.China,13:15～62.
Rea B.2007.Glacial landforms,erosional features:micro to macro scale forms.In:Encyclopedia of Quaternary science.Amsterdam:Elsevier:853～864.
Shi Yafeng.1981&.Mount Lushan really has Quaternary glacer?Journal of Dialectics of Nature,(2):41～45
Shi Yafeng.1981&.Mount Lushan really has Quaternary glacer?Journal of Glaciology and Geocryology,(1) :64～69.
Shi Yafeng,Cui Zhijiu,Li Jijun.1989&.China's Eastern Quaternary Glacier and Environmental Problems.Beijing:Science Press:363～374.
Shi Yafeng,Cui Zhijiu,Su Zhen.2010&.The Quaternary Glaciations and Environmental Variations in China.Shijiazhuang:Hebei Science and Technology Press:66～67.
Shi Yafeng.2010&.On Prof.Lee’s having misread debris flow deposits as Quaternary glaciations in the Lushan area,Jiangxi Province.Geological Review,56(5):684～688.
Shi Yafeng.2011&.2011.Is it really possible for glacier to develop on the mountains which below 2500m asl in the eastern China?Geological Review,57(1):44～49.
Wang Nai’ang,Zhao Jingdong,Yu Yingxiao,Yu Xinran,Zhang Wenjie.2017a&.A more perfect Quaternary glacial research paradigm —— the fourth China’s Symposium on Quaternary glaciation and environmental change.Journal of Glaciology and Geocryology,39(5):1029～1038.
Wang Nai’ang,Dai Shuang,Zhang Ll,Yu Yingxiao,Yu Xinran,Tian Lu,Yin Liying.2017b&.Issues on criteria and methods for discriminating Quaternary glacial relics:also on the origin of the boulder-piled levees in Mount Mengshan.Journal of Glaciology and Geocryology,39(6):1289～1297.
Wang Siwen.2015&.Analyses the difference between the glacial scratches and mudslides dent.Journal of Tribune in Economic Research,(4):303.
Wang Zhaobo,Bian Qing,Li Dapeng,Wang Jinyu,Liu Chailing,Guo Qipeng.2017a&.Discovery of the Quaternary glacial relics in Mount Mengshan,Shandong Province.Geological Review,63(1):134～140.
Wang Zhaobo,Zhang Jian,Wang Jiangyue,Zhang Yingsong,Bian Qing,Guo Qipeng.2017b&.Study with Optically Stimulated Luminescence (OSL) and two credible glacial periods in Mount Mengshan,Shandong Province.Geological Review,63(3):694～697.
Wang Zhaobo.2017&.The Nature and Culture of Mount Yimengshan.Beijing:Geological Publishing House:177～184.
Wang Zhaobo,Wang Jiangyue.2017c&.The rehabilitation of snow line elevation in eastern China and the climatic characteristics preliminary discussion.Shandong Land and Resources Magazine,33(11):1～5.
Wang Zhaobo,Wang Jiangyue.2018a&.Early Holocene glacial relics existence confirmed in Mengshan,Shandong provience—— Chronological evidence from the cosmogenic nuclide.Shandong Land and Resources Magazine,34(6):1～5.
Wang Zhaobo,Wang Jiangyue,Wang Quanyi,Xu Xianli,Li Baojie.2018b&.The discovery of Quaternary cirques system in Ganshan,western Henan Province and analysis of coupling relation with MIS.Shandong Land and Resources Magazine,34(7):1～6.
Wang Zhaobo,Wang Jiangyue.2018c&.The Discovery and Significance of the Oligocene “Snowball Earth” events—— Based on the research of global cirques system.Shandong Land and Resources Magazine,34(9):1～7.
Wang Zhaobo,Wang Jiangyue,Zhang Jian.2019&.Comparative study on Shandong Mengshan’s Quaternary glaciers,loess,stream sediments and MIS.East China Geology,40(2):81～88.
Xiong Heigang.1983#.Difference between moraine and debris flow deposits.Journal of Xinjiang University,(Z1):142～149.
Zheng Benxing,Ma Zhenghai.1985&.Morphological characteristics of gravel and clastic mineral surfaces in glacial and non-glacial deposits.Quaternary Sciences,(1):69～72.
Zhang W,Yan H,Dodson J,et al.2017.The 9.2 ka event in Asian summer monsoon area:the strongest millennial scale collapse of the monsoon during the Holocene.Climate Dynamics.36(3):79～84.
Zhang Yuxu .2005#.An arguement on the origin of potholes:A case of the Qingshan area Hexigten Qi,Inner Mongolia.Geological Review,51(6):680,712.
Zhang Yuxu,Liu Lian.2011&.Potholes on hilltops is not the evidence for Quaternary Glaciaer in eastern China.Science and Technology Review,29 (33) 62～64.
Zhang Yuxu.2017#.There are strong evidences for Quaternary glaciers in eastern China in the Mount Mengshan National Geopark,Shandong (?) [OL].http://blog.sciencenet.cn/home.php?mod=space&uid=2719683&do=blog&id=1054647
Zhang Zhigang,Mei Jing,Zhang Mengyuan,Wang Lizhi.2018&.10Be exposure ages of the boulder in Lanmaqiang(Wall for Blocing Horses),Fota Valley,Mengshan National Geopark.Geological Review,64(5):1217～1224.
Zhu Yinkui.2014.Characteristics and origin of granite hilltop potholes in Mount Laoshan.Geological Review,60(2):397～408.
© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号 地址：北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编：100083 电话：办公室：(+86 10)66554848；文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新：66554700 |