The geochemistry of the seamount varies from more differentiated to more primitive with time (6.2–8.6 wt.% MgO), suggesting that the sub-caldera reservoir is open and undergoes periodic collapse, replenishment, crystallization, and eruption. The youngest and least differentiated lavas entrained a crystal cargo of plagioclase (An80–90) with melt inclusion volatile saturation pressures indicating entrapment in the lower oceanic crust and upper mantle (6–12 km, with 45% between 8 and 10 km below the sea floor). Melt inclusions exhibit high Al2O3, low SiO2, positive Sr and Eu anomalies and negative Zr and Nb anomalies when normalized to typical Pacific mid-ocean ridge basalt (MORB). In comparison, the host lavas exhibit positive Sr anomalies, but no concurrent Zr, and Nb anomalies. Based on thermodynamic modeling using alphaMELTS, we develop a melt-rock interaction model defined by melting and assimilation of plagioclase-rich cumulates by hot, primitive mantle-derived melts. Significantly, the variability of the negative Zr and Nb anomalies cannot be explained by either cumulate melting or AFC alone. We propose that the melt inclusions record the interaction between cumulate partial melts and the assimilating melt, demonstrating the importance of cumulate melting during the assimilation process. Later percolating melts underwent diffusive interaction with, and entrained, recrystallized plagioclase cumulates resulting in the positive Sr signal without the concurrent Eu, Zr, or Nb anomalies observed in the host lavas. These results demonstrate that melt-rock interaction at the lower crust or upper mantle is an important process at Taney Seamount-A, and potentially other magmatic systems associated with seamount chains and ridge axes.