A new method to estimate the amount of recycled material in the MORB source region.
The Icelandic mantle contains at least 5% recycled basalt.
Mantle potential temperature beneath Iceland is constrained to be >1460 °C.
Refractory domains are needed to match the volume and chemistry of Icelandic melts.
Refractory mantle heterogeneity may be critical for the buoyancy of mantle plumes.