- 作者：Claudio S ; roni ; Fabio Cavallaro ; Clifton W. Callaway ; Sonia D¡¯Arrigo ; Tommaso Sanna ; Michael A. Kuiper ; Matteo Biancone ; Giacomo Della Marca ; Alessio Farcomeni ; Jerry P. Nolan
- 关键词：Heart arrest ; Coma ; Prognostication ; Therapeutic hypothermia
- 刊名：Resuscitation
- 出版年：2013
- 出版时间：October, 2013
- 年：2013
- 卷：84
- 期：10
- 页码：1324-1338
- 全文大小：1109 K
Aims and methods
To systematically review the accuracy of early (¡Ü7 days) predictors of poor outcome, defined as death or vegetative state (Cerebral Performance Categories [CPC] 4-5) or death, vegetative state or severe disability (CPC 3-5), in comatose adult survivors from cardiac arrest (CA) treated using therapeutic hypothermia (TH). Electronic databases were searched for eligible studies. Sensitivity, specificity, and false positive rates (FPR) for each predictor were calculated. Quality of evidence (QOE) was evaluated according to the GRADE guidelines.Results
37 studies (2403 patients) were included. A bilaterally absent N20 SSEP wave during TH (4 studies; QOE: Moderate) or after rewarming (5 studies; QOE: Low), a nonreactive EEG background (3 studies; QOE: Low) after rewarming, a combination of absent pupillary light and corneal reflexes plus a motor response no better than extension (M ¡Ü 2) (1 study; QOE: Very low) after rewarming predicted CPC 3-5 with 0 % FPR and narrow (<10 % ) 95 % confidence intervals. No consistent threshold for 0 % FPR could be identified for blood levels of biomarkers. In 6/8 studies on SSEP, in 1/3 studies on EEG reactivity and in the single study on clinical examination the investigated predictor was used for decisions to withdraw treatment, causing the risk of a self-fulfilling prophecy.
Conclusions
in the first 7 days after CA, a bilaterally absent N20 SSEP wave anytime, a nonreactive EEG after rewarming or a combination of absent ocular reflexes and M ¡Ü 2 after rewarming predicted CPC 3-5 with 0 % FPR and narrow 95 % CIs, but with a high risk of bias.