- 作者：Abigail Ford Winkel ; MD ; abigail.winkel@nyumc.org ; Veronica Lerner ; MD ; Sondra R. Zabar ; MD ; Demian Szyld ; MD
- 关键词：assessment ; residency ; technical skills ; observed structured clinical examination ; episiotomy ; vaginal laceration repair
- 刊名：Journal of Surgical Education
- 出版年：2013
- 出版时间：January-February, 2013
- 年：2013
- 卷：70
- 期：1
- 页码：10-14
- 全文大小：425 K
Objectives
Educators of trainees in procedure-based specialties need focused assessment tools that are valid, objective, and assess technical skills in a realistic context. A framework for hybrid assessment using standardized patient scenarios and bench skills testing might facilitate evaluation of competency.Methods
Seven PGY-1 obstetrics and gynecology residents participated in a hybrid assessment that used observed structured clinical examination (OSCE) by a standardized patient who had sustained a vaginal laceration during vaginal delivery. The residents elicited a history and counseled the patient, and then completed a laceration repair on a pelvic model. The residents were rated on their performance in the scenario, which included issues of cultural competency, rapport-building, patient counseling. The technical skills were videotaped and rated using a modified global assessment form by 2 faculty members on a 3-point scale from ¡°not done¡± to ¡°partly done¡± to ¡°well-done.¡± Residents also completed a subjective assessment of the station.
Results
Mean technical performance of the residents on the technical skills was 55 % ¡°well-done,¡± with a range of 20 % -90 % . The assessment identified 3 residents as below the mean, and 1 resident with areas of deficiency. Subjective assessment by the residents was that juggling the technical, cognitive, and affective components of the examination was challenging.
Conclusions
Technical skills can be included in a case-based assessment using scenarios that address a range of cognitive and affective skills required of physicians. Results may help training programs assess individuals' abilities as well as identify program needs for curricular improvement. This framework might be useful in setting standards for competency and identifying poor performers.