New method analysing O-isotopes in carbonatite apatite, with an igneous apatite field proposed between + 2.5 and + 6.0‰ δ18O
HREE-bearing apatite and carbonate δ18O values are compared from Songwe Hill
Apatite and carbonate crystallise at different stages of the carbonatite evolution and are in isotopic disequilibrium
Diverging apatite and carbonate δ18O values are suggested to reflect the fluid composition at differing crystallisation times
HREE mineralisation caused by early apatite crystallisation; carbonate forms later and has higher δ18O due to reprecipitation