We sought to examine the diagnostic accuracy of the BDR test by using 3 large pediatric cohorts.
Cases include 1041 children with mild-to-moderate asthma from the Childhood Asthma Management Program. Control subjects (nonasthmatic and nonwheezing) were chosen from Project Viva and Home Allergens, 2 population-based pediatric cohorts. Receiver operating characteristic curves were constructed, and areas under the curve were calculated for different BDR cutoffs.
A total of 1041 cases (59.7 % male; mean age, 8.9?¡À?2.1?years) and 250 control subjects (46.8 % male; mean age, 8.7?¡À?1.7?years) were analyzed, with mean BDRs of 10.7 % ?¡À?10.2 % and 2.7 % ?¡À?8.4 % , respectively. The BDR test differentiated asthmatic patients from nonasthmatic patients with a moderate accuracy (area under the curve, 73.3 % ). Despite good specificity, a cutoff of 12 % was associated with poor sensitivity (35.6 % ). A?cutoff of less than 8 % performed significantly better than a cutoff of 12 % (P?=?.03, 8 % vs 12 % ).
Our findings highlight the poor sensitivity associated with the commonly used 12 % cutoff for BDR. Although our data show that a threshold of less than 8 % performs better than 12 % , given the variability of this test in children, we conclude that it might be not be appropriate to choose a specific BDR cutoff as a criterion for the diagnosis of asthma.