The isotope values of sulfide minerals, x3b4;34S[min], from four bedrock cores vary over short distances and range from − 5.1 to + 7.5‰. The x3b4;34S[SO4] values are controlled by the x3b4;34S[min] values with minor input of atmospheric SO4. The much narrower range in x3b4;34S[SO4] values than x3b4;34S[min] values is probably due to sufficient ground-water mixing at a scale greater than the x3b4;34S[min] variability. The x3b4;34S[SO4] values are about 2‰ higher than the average x3b4;34S[min] value and fall within the range of x3b4;34S[min] values, indicating only minor fractionation due to bacterial reduction of SO4.
The highest x3b4;18O[SO4] values were measured in the downgradient, confined, arsenic-rich ground water. High x3b4;18O[SO4] values there cannot be due to aeration by atmospheric oxygen, but may arise from reoxidation of reduced SO4 products. The enrichment factors of x3b4;18O in SO4 compared to H2O, + 7.2 to + 15.5‰, in the Kelly's Cove ground water and the negligible 34S enrichment is very similar to those derived from experimental data of anaerobic sulfide oxidation in the presence of Mn and Fe oxides.
Sea level at the Kelly's Cove watershed was approximately 80 m above present sea level about 13 000 years before present, imposing reducing conditions on that area of the watershed. Sea level dropped approximately 60 m below present sea level about 11 000 years before present, allowing for possible oxidation of sulfide minerals and precipitation of arsenic in ferric oxyhydroxides during aeration of the ground-water system. Under present redox conditions, there is evidence that bacteria reduction of ferric oxyhydroxides releases arsenic. The fractionation of 18O in the SO4 during anaerobic oxidation of sulfide in the presence of Mn and Fe oxides and subsequent release of arsenic during Mn and Fe oxide reduction may explain the relationship between high arsenic concentrations and elevated 18O[SO4] at Kelly's Cove.