Like abyssal peridotites and xenoliths from oceanic hotspots that sample the convecting mantle, Os isotopes from the Savai’i and Tubuai xenolith suites are relatively unradiogenic, but do not preserve a record of depleted early-formed (Hadean and Archean) mantle domains expected from earlier cycles of ridge-related depletion, continent extraction, or subcontinental lithospheric mantle erosion. The lack of preservation of early-formed, geochemically-depleted Os-isotopic and 142Nd/144Nd domains in the modern convecting mantle contrasts with the preservation of early-formed (early-Hadean) 129Xe/130Xe isotopic heterogeneities in the convecting mantle. This can be explained if the initial isotopic signatures in Re–Os and Sm–Nd systems are erased by recycling because the parent and daughter elements are retained in subducting slabs and more efficiently returned to the mantle during subduction than Xe. In this way, early-formed Os and Nd-isotopic heterogeneities could have been overprinted with, and diluted by, younger isotopic signatures. In contrast, preservation of early-formed heterogeneities in the modern convecting mantle is possible for other elements, such as Xe, that are not as efficiently recycled back into the mantle, owing to greater fluid mobility that concentrates such elements in the near-surface. Differing recycling efficiencies for Os, Nd and Xe lead to wide differences in the preservation of Hadean isotopic signatures of these elements in the modern convecting mantle. In general, incompatible elements that are fluid mobile (e.g., Xe) concentrate in surface reservoirs and are more likely to preserve Hadean geochemical signatures in the convecting mantle than compatible elements (e.g., Os) and fluid immobile incompatible elements (e.g., Nd).